Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 2 of 2019
Shri. Leequa Mukhim
Date of Decision: 05.05.2023
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. L. Nghaka, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. A.Kharwanlang, GA (For R 1-4)
Mr. V.G.K. Kynta, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. C. Nongkhlaw, Adv. (For R 5-7)
Mr. K.S. Kynjing, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A.D. Syiem, Adv. (For R 8)
Mr. D.R. Chen, Adv. (For R 9)
Mr. L. Khyriem, Adv. (For R 10)
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv. (For R 11).
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The facts of this case in a narrow compass is that the
petitioner’s Patta, indicating his right over a plot of land situated at
Laitkor Nongdaneng, Shillong-10, was cancelled by the Respondent
No.8, ostensibly without he being heard or being allowed to participate
in the inquiry proceedings, instituted by the District Council
respondents, in connection with rival claims over the said land.
2.
It has been contended by Mr. L. Nghaka, learned counsel for
the petitioner that, the petitioner had acquired ownership rights over a
plot of land measuring 156 acres more or less, situated at Laitkor
Nongdaneng, Shillong-10, on the same being bought from the
respondent No. 11 by Deed of Sale dated 05.07.2016, who in turn had
possessed the land by virtue of a Gift Deed dated 10.10.1988, executed
by his mother. Thereafter he submits, a Patta being No. 165 of 2017,
had been issued by the respondent No. 8 (Syiem of Mylliem), in
recognition of this right, but subsequently on September 2018, the
petitioner was served with a summons dated 21.09.2018, issued by the
respondent No. 7, asking him to appear before the Inquiry Officer in
connection with the said plot of land. The learned counsel submits
thereafter, pursuant to the purported inquiry, the respondent No. 8,
cancelled the Patta and confirmed the ownership of the respondent No.
10, over the plot of land, without the petitioner being afforded any
opportunity of hearing. It has been urged that, this is the main grievance
of the petitioner in writ petition, notwithstanding other attendant facts
and circumstances.
3.
The State respondents who have been arrayed as respondents
No. 1-4, have filed an affidavit and also challenged the maintainability
of the writ petition, on the ground that, apart from the writ petitioner
approaching this Court, with unclean hands, he is seeking to achieve
wrongful gains by resorting to the instant proceeding under Article 226
of the Constitution, to try to establish non-existent rights, inasmuch as,
the entire case and issues raised are hit by the Principles of Res judicata.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Mr. A. Kharwanlang,
learned GA for the State respondents submits that the land in question
forms part of the Laitkor Protected Forest Compartment No. 6, which
had been leased out in perpetuity, to the then British Government vide
lease document dated 02.12.1874, and that with the lapse of British
paramountcy, the land vests with the State of Meghalaya, a position that
has been affirmed even by a Full Bench Decision of the Gauhati High
Court in the case of Nongkhlaw Clan & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
reported in 1997 (II) GLT 652 (FB). Learned AAG has also drawn the
attention of this Court to the lease document which is annexed to the
affidavit.
4.
It is further submitted that, the respondent No. 8, does not
possess any right or authority to issue any Patta, as the said land is under
the possession and control of the respondent No. 1. It has also been
submitted that, the respondent No. 4 (The Divisional Forest Officer,
Government of Meghalaya), on coming to learn about these illegalities,
had issued a letter dated 22.03.2017, which is annexed to the affidavit,
informing the respondent No. 8, that the said land is part of the Laitkor
Protected Forest Compartment No. 6, and directed cancellation of the
said Pattas. The learned AAG submits that, the entire transaction and
transfer of the said land as narrated by the writ petitioner is
unsustainable, inasmuch as, firstly, the respondent No. 11 was never in
possession of the said land and further, the purported documents such as
Sale Deeds and Deed of Declaration enclosed to demonstrate title,
cannot be relied upon, or withstand any legal scrutiny as the same are
unregistered, and are void.
5.
Learned AAG submits that, the matter received the attention of
the State respondents, when the respondent No. 4, was informed by the
Air Force Authorities, that the respondent No. 11 had approached them
with a copy of a Patta, and offered the said land for sale. Thereafter he
submits, to ascertain and verify as to the exact location of the land, a
joint inspection was fixed and the petitioner was informed to be present,
as also the respondent No. 11. However, he submits on the date fixed,
the petitioner and the respondent No. 11 did not choose to attend, but
the respondent No. 10 along with relatives were present, and the finding
which was communicated vide letter dated 07.12.2017 (Annexure – 8 to
the affidavit), showed that, the land in question claimed by the petitioner
was part of the Compartment No. 6 of Laitkor Protected Forest. He
lastly submits that, the entire transaction between the petitioner and the
respondent No. 11 being illegal and made with a view to achieve
wrongful gain, the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
6.
From the submissions of the counsels of the other respondents
and the affidavits filed on their behalf, namely, the respondent No. 8
(The Acting Syiem of Mylliem Syiemship), respondent No. 9 (Headman
Laitkor Nongdaneng), respondent No. 10 (Smti. Akrisha Mylliempdah),
another claimant to the said land, respondents No. 11 and 12 (Shri.
Hirobanistar
Mylliempdah
and
Shri.
Depend
Mohon
Roy
Mylleimpdah), it appears that claims and counter claims including a
Title Suit before the District Council Court, apart from the inquiry
proceedings before the District Council Authorities, and Syiem of
Mylliem, there has been a keen tussle to claim ownership rights over the
land in question. The respondent No. 8, has however made a pertinent
averment in his affidavit that, the petitioner had been issued notice vide
letter dated 10.08.2018, to appear on 16.08.2018, to show cause along
with relevant documents, to substantiate his claim, which was refused
by the writ petitioner, a fact which has been substantiated by a report of
the Peon, who went to serve the petitioner on 14.08.2018 (Annexure – 2
to the additional affidavit of the respondent No. 8).
7.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties, from the
submissions and materials placed before this Court, the controversy in
the matter, appears to be confusing and complicated with proceedings
being conducted at different levels and before multiple authorities,
which surely would lie outside the realm of a proceeding under Article
226 of the Constitution. However, shorn of all the other details, the
grievance of the writ petitioner is centered around the impugned
cancellation of his Patta, which he has alleged was done without
affording him an opportunity of hearing. The other prayers made in the
writ petition, such as, to quash certain land documents made in favour of
the respondent No. 10, and for directions to the respondents not to
interfere with the possession and ownership of the petitioner over the
land in question, are unsustainable before a writ Court.
8.
On another aspect, the case put up by the State respondents
cannot be ignored, as the stand taken by them is supported by credible
documentation and evidence. This observation is made in view of the
fact that, the lease document made in favour of the then British
Government in 1874 of lands, which include land in question has not
been rebutted or any material produced to the contrary. In fact, the
respondent No. 10, who also claims the same land in question has also
annexed the lease documents in her affidavit. Another aspect which is
equally important is that, the entire episode with regard to the purported
transaction and sale of the land between the respondent No. 11 and the
writ petitioner, and the subsequent offer to sell to the Air Force
Authorities, as also the other collateral proceedings before the Syiem of
Mylliem and the District Council Courts, was not to the knowledge of
the State respondents, who appear to have been kept in the dark. As
narrated on affidavit by the State respondents, it is only after the offer
was made to the Air Force Authorities, that the matter came to light and
steps were then initiated to redeem the situation.
9.
Coming back to the grievance of the writ petitioner that, he
was not heard or afforded adequate opportunity, the materials produced
by the parties and his own admission speak otherwise. It is noted that,
he was served with notice to appear before the respondent No. 7, and
declined to do so, refused notice to appear before the respondent No. 8,
and inspite of service of notice, failed to appear in the inquiry conducted
by the State respondents to ascertain and verify the location of the land
in question. Though, the proceedings before the respondents No. 7 and
8, now seem inconsequential, in view of the larger picture with the
entrance of the State respondents into the arena, the case of the
petitioner that he was not heard, apart from losing any importance, is
also incorrect as he was issued notice, and his non-participation can
squarely be attributed to his own laches.
10.
For the aforementioned reasons, this writ petition being devoid
of any merit is accordingly dismissed.
11.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
05.05.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review