Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:8617
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 86 of 2026
1 - Laxmi Prasad Chouhan S/o Chhedu Lal Chouhan Aged About 63 Years Retired
Head Master (Primary School) At Govt. Primary School, Mudpar (Bade), Block
Sarangarh, Distt. Sarangarh Bilaigarh, Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of School Education,
Mantralaya,
Mahanadi
Bhawan, Atal
Nagar
Nawa
Raipur,
Distt.
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Director Directorate Of Public Instructions, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Accountant General Chhattisgarh, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
4 - Divisional Joint Director Fund, Account And Pension, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur,
Distt. Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
5 - District Education Officer Sarangarh Bilaigarh, Distt. Sarangarh-Bilaigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
6 - Block Education Officer Sarangarh, Distt. Sarangarh Bilaigarh, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Govind Prasad Dewangan, Advocate
For Respondents
:
Mr. Khulesh Sahu, Panel Lawyer
SB: Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
ORDER ON BOARD
17/02/2026
1. Petitioner has filed this writ petition against the recovery of excess
amount paid to petitioner during his service period vide impugned order
dated 31.05.2024 (Annexure P/1) seeking following reliefs:“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to .call for the entire records in relates to the
case of the petitioner from the possession of
respondents for its kind perusal
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to set aside the impugned recovery order
dated 31.05.2024 (Annexure P/1) issued by the
Respondent No. 4 i.e. Divisional Joint Director, Fund,
Account and Pension, Bilaspur Division, District –
Bilaspur (C.G.) ordering to recovery of excess
payment from the petitioner to the sum of Rs.
3,68,198/- and further be pleased to direct the
respondents to return back the entire amount which
has already been recovered from the Gratuity of the
petitioner in pursuance of the impugned recovery
order dated 31.05.2024 with interest @ 18% per
annum within the period of 15 days, in the interest of
justice.
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to grant any other relief/relief’s in favour of
the petitioners, which this Hon’ble Court deemed fit &
just in the facts and circumstances of the case,
including awarding of the costs to the petitioner.”
2. Learned counsel for petitioner submit that petitioner stood retired from
service on 30.06.2023 while working on the post of Head Master in
Government Primary School, Department of School Education. He
contended that after one year of his retirement, Respondent No. 4 issued
impugned order of recovery dated 31.05.2024 (Annexure P/1) for an
amount of Rs. 3,68,198/-. Petitioner was compelled to give consent for
deduction of the aforesaid amount from his Gratuity along with an affidavit
for deducting the amount form the petitioner. He was threatened that if the
consent is not given, his retiral dues will be withheld and accordingly,
petitioner submitted consent. He also contended that from perusal of the
reply submitted by the Respondents/State, it would be apparent that the
petitioner was paid the amount accrued to him towards Group Insurance
Scheme (GIS), Leave Encashment and General Provident Fund (GPF)
and after deducting the amount of Rs. 3,68,198/-, petitioner was paid
amount of Gratuity.
3. He submits that recovery which is said to be made from petitioner is
against the excess payment made to him towards salary due to wrong
fixation of pay as pleaded in reply. Excess payment is not on account of
any suppression of facts, frauds or misrepresentation on the part of
petitioner with the respondent authorities. Petitioner stood retired from the
post of Head Master which is a Class – III post under the Chhattisgarh
School Education Services (Educational and Administrative Cadre)
Recruitment and Promotion, Rules, 2019 and therefore, recovery of
excess amount made to the petitioner after his retirement is not
permissible. In support of his contention he places reliance upon the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab & Ors
Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & Ors, reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334
and and also the orders passed by Division Bench of this High Court in
Writ
Appeal No.264/2020 (State of Chhattisgarh v. Labha Ram
Dhruv) and Writ Appeal No.265/2020 (State of Chhattisgarh and
Others v. Roshan Lal Baghel) as also, the decision dated 29.01.2025
passed by this Court in WP (S) No. 9793/2025 (Divya Kumar Sahu &
Ors. Vs. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors).
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the Respondents/State opposes
the submission of learned counsel for the petitioner and would submit that
it is not in dispute that the petitioner stood retired from service holding the
post of Head Master, Government Primary School which is a Class – III
post. However, deduction is made pursuant to the consent and affidavit
given by the petitioner to the department in this regard. He submits that
the consent letter along with affidavit is filed as ANNEXURE R/1 and
ANNEXURE R/2.
5. He submits that recovery is against the excess payment made to the
petitioner due to wrong fixation of pay as the petitioner remained
unauthorized absent from 09.05.1989 to 10.05.1989 and petitioner was
given punishment of withholding of 01 increment with cumulative effect by
order dated 16.01.1990, however, petitioner was getting the regular
increment. Petitioner was paid retiral benefits after his retirement of Group
Insurance Scheme (GIS), Leave Encashment and General Provident
Fund (GPF) and after deducting the amount of Rs. 3,68,198/-, gratuity is
also paid to him. There is no arbitrariness or illegality on the part of the
respondents in deducting the amount which was paid to the petitioner in
excess. In support of his contention he relied upon the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of ‘Chandi Prasad Uniyal & Ors. Vs. State
of Uttrakhand & Ors.’ reported in (2012) 8 SCC 417 the High Court of
Madhya Pradesh in case of ‘Badri Prasad Sharma Vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh’ reported in (2006) 3 MPLJ 583. It is also contended that the
petitioner gave consent for deduction of the said amount.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused documents filed along
with writ petition.
7. From the arguments which is advanced by learned counsel for respective
parties, it is not in dispute that petitioner stood retired from the post of
Head Master, Government Primary School which is a Class – III post.
8. Recovery which is made from petitioner is towards excess payment made
to him due to wrong fixation of pay. It is not the case of respondent that
excess payment is made to petitioner due to misrepresentation or
suppression of fact or any fraud committed by the petitioner with
respondent department. From the pleadings made in reply, it is not
appearing that the petitioner was served with any notice during his service
period mentioning that the petitioner is required to refund the amount of
excess payment, wrongly paid to him towards the salary, but the
deduction is made vide letter dated 31.05.2024 (Annexure P/1) that is,
after about 01 year from his retirement.
9. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Rafiq Masih (Supra) has clearly
observed that recovery from the employees, when the excess payment
for a period in case of 05 years before the order of recovery is issued and
recovery from the retired employee or employees who are due to retire
within 01 year of the order of recovery is impermissible. The relevant
paragraph of the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court is extracted below
for reference:“18
It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the issue of
recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by
the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it
may, based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we
may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would be
impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III
and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of the
order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully
been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and
has been paid accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent,
as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the
employer's right to recover.”
10. In the recent decision in case of Thomas Daniel Thomas Daniel Vs.
State of Kerala & Ors. (2022 SCC OnLine SC 536), Hon’ble
Supreme Court considering the decision in case of Rafiq Masih (supra)
has allowed the petition filed by the employee therein and observed thus:
“(9) This Court in a catena of decisions has consistently
held that if the excess amount was not paid on account of
any misrepresentation or fraud of the employee or if such
excess payment was made by the employer by applying a
wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the
basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order which is
subsequently found to be erroneous, such excess
payment of emoluments or allowances are not
recoverable. This relief against the recovery is granted not
because of any right of the employees but in equity,
exercising judicial discretion to provide relief to the
employees from the hardship that will be caused if the
recovery is ordered. This Court has further held that if in a
given case, it is proved that an employee had knowledge
that the payment received was in excess of what was due
or wrongly paid, or in cases where error is detected or
corrected within a short time of wrong payment, the matter
being in the realm of judicial discretion, the courts may on
the facts and circumstances of any particular case order
for recovery of amount paid in excess.
(11). In Col. B.J. Akkara (Retd.) v. Government of India
and others, (2006) 11 SCC 709 this Court considered an
identical question as under:
‘27. x x x x x
28. x x x x x
29. On the same principle, pensioners can also seek a
direction that wrong payments should not be recovered,
as pensioners are in a more disadvantageous position
when compared to in-service employees. Any attempt to
recover excess wrong payment would cause undue
hardship to them. The petitioners are not guilty of any
misrepresentation or fraud in regard to the excess
payment. NPA was added to minimum pay, for purposes
of stepping up, due to a wrong understanding by the
implementing departments. We are therefore of the view
that the respondents shall not recover any excess
payments made towards pension in pursuance of the
circular dated 7-6-1999 till the issue of the clarificatory
circular dated 11-9-2001. Insofar as any excess payment
made after the circular dated 11-9-2001, obviously the
Union of India will be entitled to recover the excess as the
validity of the said circular has been upheld and as
pensioners have been put on notice in regard to the
wrong calculations earlier made.’
(12). In Syed Abdul Qadir and Others v. State of Bihar
and Others, (2009) 3 SCC 475 excess payment was
sought to be recovered which was made to the
appellants-teachers on account of mistake and wrong
interpretation of prevailing Bihar Nationalised Secondary
School (Service Conditions) Rules, 1983. The appellants
therein contended that even if it were to be held that the
appellants were not entitled to the benefit of additional
increment on promotion, the excess amount should not be
recovered from them, it having been paid without any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part. The Court held
that the appellants cannot be held responsible in such a
situation and recovery of the excess payment should not
be ordered, especially when the employee has
subsequently retired. The court observed that in general
parlance, recovery is prohibited by courts where there
exists no misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the
employee and when the excess payment has been made
by applying a wrong interpretation/ understanding of a
Rule or Order. It was held thus:
“59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount that has been paid
to the appellant teachers was not because of any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part and the appellants
also had no knowledge that the amount that was being
paid to them was more than what they were entitled to. It
would not be out of place to mention here that the Finance
Department had, in its counter-affidavit, admitted that it
was a bona fide mistake on their part. The excess
payment made was the result of wrong interpretation of
the Rule that was applicable to them, for which the
appellants cannot be held responsible. Rather, the whole
confusion was because of inaction, negligence and
carelessness of the officials concerned of the Government
of Bihar. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant teachers submitted that majority of the
beneficiaries have either retired or are on the verge of it.
Keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of
the case at hand and to avoid any hardship to the
appellant teachers, we are of the view that no recovery of
the amount that has been paid in excess to the appellant
teachers should be made.”
(13). In State of Punjab and others v. Rafiq Masih
(White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334 wherein this court
examined the validity of an order passed by the State to
recover the monetary gains wrongly extended to the
beneficiaries employees in excess of their entitlements
without any fault or misrepresentation at the behest of the
recipient. This Court considered situations of hardship
caused to an employee, if recovery is directed to
reimburse the employer and disallowed the same,
exempting the beneficiary employees from such recovery.
(14).
xxxxx
(15). Having regard to the above, we are of the view that
an attempt to recover the said increments after passage
of ten years of his retirement is unjustified.”
11. So far as the plea taken by State that the petitioner submitted undertaking
for recovery of the amount paid in excess is concerned. In undertaking,
no date is mentioned as to when, the said undertaking was executed.
However, in the Affidavit (Annexure R/2), the date is mentioned as
08.04.2024 i.e. after the retirement of the petitioner from service. It
appears that the Affidavit as also, the Undertaking are of subsequent to
the retirement of the petitioner. Division Bench of this Court in the case of
State of Chhattisgarh & Ors Vs. Labha Ram Dhruv (supra) has
considered the recovery of the amount which has been paid long ago,
undertaking was stated to be submitted by employee and observed thus:
“6. In Rafiq Masih (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
would observe that when the excess unauthorised
payment is detected within a short period of time, it would
be open for the employer to recover the same.
Conversely, if the payment had been made a for a long
duration of time, it would be iniquitous to make any
recovery. Interference because an action is iniquitous,
must really be perceived as, interference because the
action is arbitrary. All arbitrary actions are truly, actions in
violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The logic
of the action in the instant situation, is iniquitous, or
arbitrary, or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India, because it would be almost impossible for an
employee to bear the financial burden, of a refund of
payment received wrongfully for a long span of time. It is
apparent, that a government employee is primarily
dependent on his wages, and if a deduction is to be made
from his/her wages, it should not be a deduction which
would make it difficult for the employee to provide for the
needs of his family. Besides food, clothing and shelter, an
employee has to cater, not only to the education needs of
those dependent upon him, but also their medical
requirements, and a variety of sundry expenses. Based
on the above consideration, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
was of the view that if the mistake of making a wrongful
payment is detected within five years, it would be open to
the employer to recover the same. However, if the
payment is made for a period in excess of five years, even
though it would be open to the employer to correct the
mistake, it would be extremely iniquitous and arbitrary to
seek a refund of the payments mistakenly made to the
employee.
7. With the above reasoning, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
carved out a class of employees and the situations in
which recoveries would be impermissible in law. The
same has already been reproduced while quoting para-10
of the judgment in the matter of Jagdev Singh, Supra, in
the preceding paragraph.
8. While applying the ratio in the matter of Jagdev Singh,
Supra, paragraph-11 is not to be read in isolation, but the
same has to be read conjointly with the facts of the matter
in para-2 and the class of employees against whom
recovery would be impermissible, as reproduced in para10. The requirement of submission of undertaking by the
employee has to be provided under the Rules which was
exactly the position in the matter before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jagdev Singh, (Supra).
9. In the case at hand, the Revision of Pay Rules, 2009
and 2017 do not make any enabling provision reserving
option for the employer to seek refund of the amount paid
in excess, by making the employee to furnish an
undertaking. Even if we conclude, for the sake of
arguments, that even in the absence of enabling provision
under the Rules, undertaking given by the employee
would operate, the fact remains that against the classes of
employees against whom recovery would be
impermissible in law, as held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the matter of Rafiq Masih (Supra), recovery from
the employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service
(or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service) would still be
impermissible in law. Meaning thereby that even when
undertaking is submitted by the employee, but he
otherwise belongs to Class-III and Class-IV service, and
the amount has been paid more than 5 years back, the
law declared by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter
of Rafiq Masih (Supra) would still hold the field in favour of
such employees, because the judgment in the matter of
Rafiq Masih (Supra) has not been overruled, but only
clarified, by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its later
judgment in the matter of Jagdev Singh, Supra.
11. In view of the above and on finding that in the cases at
hand, the recovery of the excess payment has been made
more than 12 years ago; the writ petitioners belong to
Class-III cadre in the services of the State Government,
and small amount has been paid to them in a long span of
time, which has now accumulated and the recovery of
substantial amount is to be made against them, we are
inclined to hold that the Writ Appeals have no substance.
They deserve to be and are hereby dismissed.”
12.In above facts of the case and decisions as referred above, it is clear that
the recovery from the employees belonging to Class-II and Class-IV
category (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service) is held to be impermissible
in law. Meaning thereby that even if undertaking is submitted by the
employee, but he otherwise belongs to Class-III or Class-IV service,
recovery of excess amount paid from him/her is impermissible. In the
case at hand, admittedly, petitioner was working on the Class-III post in
the School Education Department and stood retired on 30th June 2025. It
is also not the case of respondents that petitioner had received excess
payment by practicing fraud or by making misrepresentation. Thus,
petitioner cannot be compelled to return the amount which has been paid
by the respondents on their own without any misrepresentation or fraud
on the part of petitioner.
13.If the case at hand is to be considered in light of the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Division Bench of this Court, recovery
from the petitioner is impermissible because, the recovery is sought to be
made from the petitioner after his retirement and that too, after about 01
year of his retirement, undertaking and affidavit is said to be executed is
also after retirement.
14.For the foregoing discussion, I am of the considered view that the
respondents have arbitrarily and illegally acted in deducting an amount of
Rs. 3,68,198/-, from the retiral benefits (Gratuity) of the petitioner, which is
not sustainable in the eyes of law. Accordingly, the letter/communication
dated 31.05.2024 (Annexure P/1) is set-aside. Respondents are directed
to refund the amount of Rs. 3,68,198/- deducted from the retiral benefits
of the petitioner within a period of 03 months from date of receipt of copy
of order, failing which, the amount shall carry interest at the rate of 8% per
annum till its realization.
15. With the aforesaid observation and direction, this writ petition stands
allowed.
16. Certified copy as per rules.
Digitally
SHUBHAM signed by
DEY
SHUBHAM
DEY
Dey
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review