Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:13672
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 11502 of 2025
1 - Laxmi Narayan Thakur S/o Krishna Dev Thakur Aged About 36 Years R/o
Koriya, District- Koriya (C.G.) At Present Posted As Sub-Divisional Officer
(Forest), Janakpur, Division Manendragarh, District - Manendragarh-ChirmiriBharatpur (C.G.)
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Forest And Climate Change
Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Capital Complex, Atal Nagar,
Nawa Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Principal Chief Conservator Of Forest Aranya Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa
Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Divisional Forest Officer Manendragarh, Division Manendragarh, Jkd
Road, Manendragarh, District - Manendragarh-Chirmiri-Bharatpur (C.G.)
4 - Senior Secretaries Committee (Varishdh Sachivo Ki Committee)
Constituted Under Clause No. 8 Of The Transfer Policy Dated 05-06-2025,
General Administration Department, Through Its Secretary, General
BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
Administration Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Capital
Complex, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Uttam Prasad Paikra S/o Arjun Singh Aged About 61 Years Sub-Divisional
Officer Janakpur, Division Manendragarh, District - Manendragarh-ChirmiriBharatpur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause title is taken from CIS system)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Apporva Ghore, Advocate
For Respondents/State No.1 to 4
: Mr. Ajay Kumrani, P.L.
For Respondent No.5
: Mr. Jai Prakash Shukla, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Order On Board
19/03/2026
1.
Petitioner has filed this petition challenging the order dated
22.09.2025, passed by respondent No.1 cancelling the order of
transfer dated 30.06.2025 of the respondent No.5 enter-alia on the
ground that reasons assigned in cancelling the order of transfer of
respondent No.5 is factually not correct. It is also pleaded that
Committee constituted under transfer policy as also the State
Government has failed to take note that in the facts of the case Clause
1.6 of transfer policy would not apply. It is also a ground that petitioner
was transferred in place of posting of respondent No.5. Pursuant to
the order of transfer petitioner joined his service, however, the order of
cancellation has been passed without affording any opportunity of
hearing to petitioner and had prayed for following relief (s) :“10.1] That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to issue a writ/writs, direction/directions, order/orders
quashing the impugned order dated 22.09.2025,
passed by the State Government as well as the
recommendation of the committee dated 19.08.2025
and petitioner may kindly be allowed to continue at the
present place as Sub-Divisional Officer (Forest)
Janakpur, Division Manendragarh.
2] That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
grant any other relief(s), which is deemed fit and
proper in the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the
case.”
2.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that vide order dated
30.06.2025, treating petitioner to be in surplus in Forest Division
Office, Manendragarh was transferred to office of Sub-Divisional
Forest Officer, Janakpur, Forest Division, Manendragarh. On the same
date, vide another order of transfer, respondent No.5 has been
transferred from the office of Sub-Divisional Forest Officer, Janakpur,
Forest Division – Manendragarh to the office of Deputy Managing
Director, District Union, Manendragarh. Both the orders i.e. order of
transfer of petitioner and order of transfer of respondent No.5 was on
administrative ground. The order of transfer was put to challenge by
respondent No.5 in writ petition bearing WPS No. 8040 of 2025, which
was disposed of on 21.07.2025 in that writ petition also petitioner was
arrayed as respondent. Finding some typographical error in the order,
private
respondent
No.5
has
filed
an
application
for
modification/correction of order dated 21.07.2025 and the Court has
modified the order and in that order Court has taken note of the fact of
submission made by counsel engaged by petitioner herein/respondent
No.5 (in WPS No.8040 of 2025) on caveat that respondent No.5
therein had joined his transferred place and ordered for maintaining
status-quo. Respondent No.5 (petitioner in WPS No.8040 of 2025)
pursuant to the order passed in writ petition, submitted representation
before the Committee constituted under transfer policy mentioning that
petitioner is posted in his home district. It is also pleaded that
petitioner is due to retire in the year 2026. The Committee constituted
under transfer policy had made recommendation for allowing the
application/representation considering that order of transfer of
petitioner (in WPS No.8040 of 2025) is in violation of Clause 1.6 of the
transfer policy 2025. The said observation made by the Committee
constituted under transfer policy was not correct as on the date of
issuance of order of transfer, respondent No.5 he was having about
one year and four months of service remaining and therefore, the said
clause would not apply. He next contended that pursuant to the order
of transfer, petitioner acted upon, gave his joining and assumed
charge on 04.07.2025 and since then he is working on the said post.
Divisional Forest Officer, Forest Division, Manendragarh has informed
joining of petitioner and assuming charge to Chief Conservator of
Forest. This aspect was also considered by Court while disposing the
MCC on 25.07.2025, therefore, the direction was issued to maintain
status-quo.
The
State
Government
while
considering
the
recommendation made by the Committee constituted under transfer
policy had canceled the order of transfer only taking note that the
order of transfer of respondent No.5 was passed in violation of Clause
1.6 of the transfer policy, which in the facts of the case is not
sustainable. Before cancelling the order of transfer, petitioner was not
given opportunity of hearing, even though it is specifically mentioned in
the order that petitioner herein/respondent No.5 therein had objected
the proceedings filed by respondent No.5, before the High Court. In
support of his contention, he placed reliance upon the order passed by
this Court in case of Miss. Harsha Kashyap Vs. State of C.G. in WPS
No.3544 of 2019 dated 10.05.2019, order passed in WPS No.9176 of
2019 in case of Rajesh Kumar Suman Vs. State of Chhattisgarh
decided on 11.11.2019 and in case of Tarun Kanungo Vs. State of
C.G., in W.A. No.248 of 2015 decided on 15.05.2015.
3.
Learned counsel for respondent No.5 vehemently opposes the
submission of learned counsel for petitioner and would submit that
claim of petitioner herein that he took charge of office of Sub-Divisional
Forest Officer, Janakpur, Forest Division Manendragarh is not correct.
After passing of order of transfer in favour of petitioner, petitioner was
on leave from 04.07.2025 to 22.09.2025, therefore, taking charge on
04.07.2025 is not correct. It is also contended that posting of
employee is in exclusive domain of employer/State Government. State
Government has issued an order of transfer and upon representation
submitted as provided under the transfer policy, before the Committee,
the State Government considering the recommendation made by the
Committee constituted under transfer policy had canceled the order of
transfer, therefore, in such case, no grievance can be raised by
another employee that before canceling the order of transfer of one
employee, other employee was not given an opportunity of hearing.
Petitioner was not relieved from the present place of posting i.e. office
of Sub-Divisional Forest Officer, Janakpur, therefore, the submission of
learned counsel for petitioner that petitioner has assumed the charge
is not correct. He also contended that during pendency of this writ
petition, petitioner is posted in the office of Sub-Divisional Forest
Officer, Pendra, Forest Division Marwahi, therefore, petitioner is having
no right to seek relief as prayed for in this writ petition after passing of
subsequent order dated 16.02.2026.
4.
Learned State counsel submits that in the order of transfer of petitioner
dated 30.06.2025 (Annexure P-2), certain directives have been
specifically mentioned and one of the direction to the employees, who
were transferred is that they have to join at transferred place of posting
within a period of 10 days and further mentioned that if any employee
is not relieved within said period, they will be deemed to be relieved
automatically and against those employee, disciplinary action would
also be initiated. He submits that petitioner assumed charge which is
also reflecting from Annexure P-5, letter written by Divisional Forest
Officer,
Manendragarh
Forest
Division,
Manendragarh
dated
04.07.2025. It is next contended that in the affidavit submitted by Chief
Conservator of Forest, Sarguja Circle Ambikapur on 27.10.2025 there
is specific averment that respondent No.5 was reluctant to handover
the charge to petitioner and did not perform his duty as per rules laid
down in forest Manual. He remained continuously absent after transfer
order is passed without any intimation. Therefore, petitioner took
charge in compliance of transfer order and thus petitioner has
assumed charge on 04.07.2025. He also contended that respondent
No.5 was on leave from 04.07.2025 till 22.09.2025. He lastly
contended
that
transfer
Committee
while
considering
the
representation submitted by respondent No.5 (petitioner in WPS
No.8040 of 2025) has called for the comments from the department,
however, the comment called for and forwarded by department was
not considered and have passed the order. In support of his
contention, he referred to the comment forwarded by the Principal
Chief Conservator of Forest on 12.08.2025, in which it is mentioned
that on the date of transfer of respondent No.5, he was having more
than one year remaining to attain the age of superannuation and
further that after creation of new District Manendragarh, Chirmiri,
Bharatpur, posting of petitioner in Manendragarh is not in his home
district and petitioner is a resident of Korea district.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for parties and perused the documents
placed on record.
6.
Main grievance of petitioner is that the order passed by State
Government on the recommendation made by the Committee
constituted under transfer policy is erroneous and considering, wrong
facts.
7.
To appreciate the grounds raised in the writ petition as also the
submission made by learned counsel for respective parties, it is to be
considered whether on the date of order of transfer i.e. 30.06.2025,
respondent No.5 was having less than one year of service remaining
to retire from service.
8.
The comments submitted by Principal Chief Conservator of Forest on
12.08.2025 clearly mentions that date of birth of respondent No.5 as
19.10.1964 and order of transfer is dated 30.06.2025. Age of
superannuation of respondent No.5 is also mentioned as 31.10.2026.
From the aforesaid dates, it is apparent that on the date of passing of
order of transfer, petitioner was having about one year and four
months of service remaining for his retirement.
9.
Clause 1.6 of the transfer policy, which is relied upon by the
Committee
constituted
under
transfer
policy
for
recommending/acceptance of representation as also by the State
Government for cancelling the order of transfer provides that if a
government servant is remaining less than one year of service, then
his posting is to be done on his option or he should not be transferred.
In the case at hand, learned counsel for respondent No.5 has not
controverted and disputed the dates as mentioned in the comments
forwarded by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forest about the date
of birth and date of superannuation, therefore, undisputedly on the
date of issuance of order of transfer, petitioner was having about one
year and four months to retire. The Committee constituted under
transfer policy has not taken note of the specific date of birth of the
petitioner as mentioned in the comments forwarded by Principal Chief
Conservator of Forest and has erroneously recommended to accept
the representation of respondent No.5 only considering Clause 1.6 of
transfer policy, which is based on pleading in representation, therefore,
the
order
passed
by
respondent
No.1/State
based
on
the
recommendation of the Committee, in the opinion of this Court is not
sustainable.
10.
So far as the submission of learned counsel for respective parties on
taking charge of the office of Sub-Divisional Forest Officer, Janakpur
Forest Division Manendragarh is concerned, it is a case of respondent
No.5 himself that from 04.07.2025, he went on leave till 22.09.2025.
The affidavit filed by official of the State Government in para-4 it is
clearly stated that respondent No.5 was continuously absent after
transfer order without any intimation and petitioner assumed charge on
04.07.2025. This affidavit is filed by one Mr. Dilraj Prabhakar, who is
working as Chief Conservator of Forest, Sarguja Circle, Ambikapur. In
another affidavit, filed by official of the State Government i.e. Divisional
Forest Officer, Manendragarh also there is mention that petitioner
joined at Sub-Divisional Office, Janakpur i.e.
transferred place on
04.07.2025 and respondent No.5 was on leave from 04.07.2025 to
27.07.2025 and further remained on leave until on 22.09.2025. Order
granting leave is dated 18.07.2025. From the aforementioned facts it is
apparent that official of the State Government has clearly made
averment that petitioner has joined at his transferred place of posting
i.e. office of Sub-Divisional Forest Officer, Janakpur.
11.
The other submission made by learned counsel for respondent No.5
that during the pendency of this writ petition, petitioner was again
transferred on 22.09.2025, in-fact is not an order of transfer but i.e. is
made only a time gape arrangement by attaching the petitioner with
additional charge.
12.
In the aforementioned facts of the case, consideration of the
Committee
constituted
under
transfer
policy
to
accept
the
representation and recommending to cancel the transfer relying upon
the Clause 1.6 of the transfer policy and further order of State
Government based on the recommendation made by the Committee
relying upon Clause 1.6 of the transfer policy is not sustainable.
13.
It is also to be noted that in the earlier round of litigation, petitioner
herein was party respondent in writ petition filed by respondent No.5
as also in the MCC and from the order passed in MCC No.751 of 2025
dated 25.07.2025 it is appearing that there was categorical statement
made that petitioner herein has assumed the charge.
14.
The period of service remaining of an employee in the facts of the
case where challenge to the order of transfer is period remaining on
the date of passing of an order of transfer, is to be considered. In the
facts of the case on the date of passing of order of transfer,
respondent No.5 was having one year and four months of service
remaining, therefore, cancelling the order of transfer of respondent
No.5 taking note of Clause 1.6 of policy, as also the petitioner and reposting them is not sustainable.
15.
For the foregoing discussions, this writ petition is allowed. The
impugned order dated 22.09.2025 (Annexure P-1) is hereby quashed.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Balram
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review