Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:549
Serial No. 76
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 31 of 2025
Date of Decision: 01.06.2026
Smti Laxmi Joshi,
D/o (Late) Kedar Nath Joshi,
Of Village Karaibari, Milan More
near Little Angel Public School,
P.O. Champasari P.S. Pradhan Nagar,
District-Darjeeling, Siliguri-734003, West Bengal … Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Union of India represented by
The Secretary Ministry of Finance, New Delhi.
2. The Comptroller & Auditor General of India,
9, Deendayal Upadhaya Marg, New Delhi-110 124
3. The Accountant General (Audit),
Meghalaya, Shillong-793001.
4. The Establishment Officer,
O/o The Accountant General (Audit),
Meghalaya, Shillong-793001
… Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Pandit, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Kharmawphlang, Adv. with
Ms. E.B. Passah, Adv. (For R 2-4)
2026:MLHC:549
_______________________________________________________
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Yes/No
Law journals etc:
ii)
1.
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
The brief facts are that the petitioner’s father one (L) Kedar
Nath Joshi while serving in the office of the Accountant General,
Meghalaya, Shillong as Duftry, died in harness on 11.02.2014. The
petitioner then applied for appointment on compassionate ground in
terms of the Scheme for Compassionate appointment issued by the
Government of India. Thereafter, the petitioner as directed, appeared
before the Department Screening Committee, but her application was
rejected on 11.03.2016 without any reason being cited. The petitioner
then approached this Court by filing a writ petition being WP(C) No.
405 of 2016, which was disposed of by order dated 30.06.2017 with the
directions that the respondents examine the case and consider the same
sympathetically. However, after consideration her application was
again rejected by letter dated 28.03.2018, which compelled the
petitioner to again approach this Court by a second writ petition being
WP(C) No. 230 of 2022, which was disposed of by order dated
16.09.2024, by directing the respondents to revisit the matter and to take
2026:MLHC:549
into account the Screening Committee Report dated 09.11.2017, which
was favourable to the petitioner. However, vide letter dated 03.01.2025,
the case of the petitioner was again rejected. Hence the writ petition.
2.
Mr. S. Pandit, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the writ petitioner has been compelled to approach this
Court repeatedly, in view of the denial of the grant of compassionate
appointment in spite of being eligible for the same. It is further
submitted that in spite of the directions of this Court by order dated
16.09.2024 passed in WP(C) No. 230 of 2022, whereby this Court had
directed the respondents to revisit the matter specifically taking into
account the Departmental Screening Committee Report dated
09.11.2017, the respondents deliberately delayed the process and
rejected the case of the petitioner, ignoring the directions of this Court
and the recommendations of the Departmental Screening Committee.
The learned counsel has then contended that the Departmental
Screening Committee, is the only authority to examine the eligibility of
the claim, and the respondents by not taking its report into consideration
when it was found inconvenient is arbitrary. To illustrate this point, it
is submitted that in the affidavit filed by the respondents in WP(C)No.
230 of 2022, two letters dated 10.11.2015 and 22.11.2027 had been
annexed which recommended the case of the writ petitioner, and that a
2026:MLHC:549
perusal of the report of the Screening Committee dated 09.11.2017,
would show that the petitioner was found eligible. However, he submits
that in spite of these positive materials in in favour of the petitioner, the
respondents without adverting to the same, had on an earlier occasion
rejected her case by letter 08.01.2018.
3.
The learned counsel has then submitted that the denial for
appointment even after the order of this Court, violates the Scheme for
compassionate appointment issued under Office Memorandum dated
16.01.2013 by the Department of Post and Telegraph. Reference has
been made to Para-11 of the Memorandum, which allows for grant for
compassionate appointment even when there is an earning member
subject to such restrictions, as contained therein. He therefore prays that
appropriate directions be issued to afford compassionate employment
to the petitioner.
4.
On behalf of the respondents, Mr. K. Kharmawphlang,
learned counsel has submitted that, compassionate appointments are
governed by a Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) scheme
issued on 16.01.2013, with the primary objective being to provide
immediate relief to a family left in penury and without means of
livelihood, following the death of a government servant. Reference has
been made to paragraph 11 which highlights the earning member rule.
2026:MLHC:549
It is submitted that if a family member is already employed,
compassionate appointment, is only permitted with the prior approval
of the Secretary of the department, who must be satisfied that the family
is truly in financial destitution, after evaluating their assets, liabilities
and the income of the earning member.
5.
It is further submitted that though the petitioner’s
application was considered by the Departmental Screening Committee
in the year 2014 and 2015, the same were not processed further due to
the unavailability of vacancies and has also added that even the
availability of a vacancy in the compassionate appointment quota, is not
the sole basis for consideration as the candidate must also meet the
Scheme’s requirements. The learned counsel submits that in
compliance to the order of this Court passed in WP(C) No. 405 of 2016,
the petitioner’s case was taken up for consideration and on 09.11.2017,
the Departmental Screening Committee met and recommended the
petitioner for compassionate appointment, which was however rejected
by the competent authority on the ground that the family was not in a
state of financial destitution noting that they received an enhanced
family pension. Following this Court’s directive passed in 16.09.2024,
in WP(C) No. 230 of 2022, and taking the Scheme into consideration,
the learned counsel submits, a speaking order was passed and re-
2026:MLHC:549
conveyed to the writ petitioner, wherein appointment was not accorded
as the family was not deemed indigent. It has been contended that as
per the speaking order’s findings, it was found that the petitioner’s
claim was not supported by independent verification and that the
Welfare Officer’s report was based only on statements from the
petitioner and her mother.
6.
On the aspect of a recommendation by the Departmental
Screening Committee, it has been submitted that as per Para-13 of the
Scheme for compassionate appointment, the Departmental Screening
Committee is not the final authority and that the final decision in
‘earning member’ cases, rests with the Secretary of the Department. It
is lastly argued that because the petitioner’s family had an earning
member and a stable enhanced pension until 2024, the immediate
emergency required for compassionate appointment no longer existed.
Reference has been made to the case of Local Administration
Department vs. M. Selvanayagam @ Kumaravel (Civil Appeal No.
2206 of 2006, wherein the Supreme Court held that appointments made
many years after an employee’s death without considering the family’s
actual current financial status is quite bad and illegal. Reliance has also
been placed in the case of State of West Bengal vs. Debabrata Tiwari
2023 SCC OnLine SC 219, wherein it has been observed that
2026:MLHC:549
compassionate appointment is a narrow humanitarian exception and not
a vested right intended to rescue a family from sudden financial crisis
and that immediacy is essential and prolonged delays extinguishes
one’s claims.
7.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, and on the
arguments advanced, the issue which deserves some consideration is
Clause-11 of the Scheme for compassionate appointment dated
16.01.2013. The same for the sake of convenience is reproduced
hereinbelow: “11. WHERE THERE IS AN EARNING MEMBER
(a) In deserving cases even where there is already an
earning member in the family, a dependent family
member may be considered for compassionate
appointment with prior approval of the Secretary of the
Department/Ministry concerned who, before approving
such appointment, will satisfy himself that grant of
compassionate appointment is justified having regard to
number of dependents, assets and liabilities left by the
Government servant, income of the earning member as
also his liabilities including the fact that the earning
member is residing with the family of the Government
servant and whether he should not be a source of support
to other members of the family.
(b) In cases where any member of the family of the
deceased or medically retired Government servant is
already in employment and is not supporting the other
members of the family of the Government servant,
extreme caution has to be observed in ascertaining the
economic distress of the members of the family of the
Government servant so that the facility of appointment
on compassionate ground is not circumvented and
misused by putting forward the ground that the member
2026:MLHC:549
of the family already employed is not supporting the
family.”
8.
A perusal of the above noted clause, would show that the
Scheme makes a provision for granting compassionate appointment
even when there is an earning member in the family, but the same would
be only after due consideration and with the prior approval of the
Secretary of the Department. Clause 11(b) has however put in a caveat
that extreme caution has to be observed in ascertaining the economic
distress of the members of the family so that the facility of appointment
on compassionate grant is not misused.
9.
In the case of the petitioner as the matter revolves around
the determination of financial distress by the authority concerned which
involves relaxation of the norms where there is an earning member in
the family at the relevant point of time, the sequence of events that have
occurred since the application was made will also have to be looked
into, inasmuch as, there has been a considerable lapse of time since the
initial application was made by the writ petitioner.
10.
First the petitioner’s father had expired on 11.02.2014 and
pursuant to an application, the petitioner had appeared before the
Departmental Screening Committee on multiple occasions i.e. on
23.12.2014, 21.08.2015 and 25.08.2015, whereafter the same came to
2026:MLHC:549
be rejected on 11.03.2016 on not being acceded to by the competent
authority. A representation was then preferred on 30.03.2016, seeking
reconsideration to which there was no response. This led to WP(C) No.
405 of 2016, wherein this Court by order dated 30.06.2016, directed the
respondents
to
consider
the
representation
and
her
case,
sympathetically. As per the Court’s directions, the representation was
disposed of by rejecting the petitioner’s prayer vide letter dated
28.03.2018, on the ground that there was an earning member in the
family and also that the family was entitled to family pension at an
enhanced rate till 11.02.2024, and there being no liabilities on the
family, no approval was accorded for appointment on compassionate
ground by the competent authority.
11.
Thereafter, a fresh writ petition being WP(C) No. 230 of
2022, was filed by the petitioner against the rejection, wherein this
Court by order dated 16.09.2024, directed the respondents to revisit the
matter taking into account the Screening Committee Report dated
09.11.2017, where her case had been recommended. The findings of the
Departmental Screening Committee which recommended the case in
2017, had recorded that taking into account the Welfare Officer’s
Report, her case be considered against the existing vacancy for the
period from 01.04.2017 to 30.03.2018. The competent authority
2026:MLHC:549
thereafter, by order dated 03.01.2025, in compliance with the order of
this Court after revisiting the matter, did not grant approval on the
ground that the Departmental Screening Committee, had not justified
the recommendations to offer appointment to the petitioner on
compassionate ground by relaxing the norms where there is an earning
member of the family in terms of Para-11 of the Scheme for
compassionate appointment.
12.
In the backdrop of the sequence of events, it would be seen
that the recommendations had been rejected by the competent authority,
and lastly by a speaking order, which was conveyed to the petitioner on
03.01.2025, as the family was not deemed indigent and further it was
emphasized that the petitioner’s claim of being unsupported was not
supported by any independent verification and it was noted that the
Welfare Officer’s report was based only on verbal statements from the
petitioner and her mother. Though the instant case is to be viewed from
the perspective of Clause-11 of the Scheme for Compassionate
appointment, however what cannot be lost sight of is the essence and
the basics of the circumstances which would warrant the grant of
compassionate appointment. In this regard, the judgment of the
Supreme Court rendered in the case of State of West Bengal vs.
Debrabata Tiwari (supra) may be referred to which has laid down the
2026:MLHC:549
rationale behind the Scheme and considerations that guide
determination of claims for compassionate appointment. Paragraphs 31,
32, 33, 34 & 35 are reproduced hereinbelow: 31. It may be apposite to refer to the following decisions of
this Court, on the rationale behind a policy or scheme for
compassionate appointment and the considerations that
ought to guide determination of claims for compassionate
appointment.
i. In Sushma
Gosain v. Union
of
India [Sushma
Gosain v. Union of India, (1989) 4 SCC 468 : 1989 SCC
(L&S) 662] , this Court observed that in all claims for
appointment on compassionate grounds, there should not be
any delay in appointment. That the purpose of providing
appointment on compassionate grounds is to mitigate the
hardship caused due to the death of the bread earner in the
family. Such appointment should, therefore, be provided
immediately to redeem the family in distress.
ii. In Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana [Umesh
Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138 : 1994
SCC (L&S) 930] , this Court observed that the object of
granting compassionate employment is to enable the family
of a deceased government employee to tide over the sudden
crisis by providing gainful employment to one of the
dependants of the deceased who is eligible for such
employment. That mere death of an employee in harness
does not entitle his family to such source of livelihood; the
Government or the public authority concerned has to
examine the financial condition of the family of the
deceased and it is only if it is satisfied that, but for the
provision of employment, the family will not be able to meet
the crisis, that a job is to be offered to the eligible member
of the family, provided a scheme or rules provide for the
same. This Court further clarified in the said case that
compassionate appointment is not a vested right which can
be exercised at any time after the death of a government
servant. That the object being to enable the family to get over
the financial crisis which it faces at the time of the death of
2026:MLHC:549
the sole breadwinner, compassionate employment cannot be
claimed and offered after lapse of considerable amount of
time and after the crisis is overcome.
iii. In Haryana
SEB v. Hakim
Singh [Haryana
SEB v. Hakim Singh, (1997) 8 SCC 85 : 1998 SCC (L&S)
31] (“Hakim Singh”) this Court placed much emphasis on
the need for immediacy in the manner in which claims for
compassionate appointment are made by the dependants
and decided by the authority concerned. This Court
cautioned that it should not be forgotten that the object of
compassionate appointment is to give succour to the family
to tide over the sudden financial crisis that has befallen the
dependants on account of the untimely demise of its sole
earning member. Therefore, this Court held that it would
not be justified in directing appointment for the claimants
therein on compassionate grounds, fourteen years after the
death of the government employee. That such a direction
would amount to treating a claim for compassionate
appointment as though it were a matter of inheritance based
on a line of succession.
iv. This Court in State of Haryana v. Ankur Gupta [State of
Haryana v. Ankur Gupta, (2003) 7 SCC 704 : 2003 SCC
(L&S) 1165] held that in order for a claim for
compassionate appointment to be considered reasonable
and permissible, it must be shown that a sudden crisis
occurred in the family of the deceased as a result of death of
an employee who had served the State and died while in
service. It was further observed that appointment on
compassionate grounds cannot be claimed as a matter of
right and cannot be made available to all types of posts
irrespective of the nature of service rendered by the deceased
employee.
v. There is a consistent line of authority of this Court on the
principle that appointment on compassionate grounds is
given only for meeting the immediate unexpected hardship
which is faced by the family by reason of the death of the
bread earner vide Jagdish Prasad v. State of Bihar [Jagdish
Prasad v. State of Bihar, (1996) 1 SCC 301 : 1996 SCC
(L&S) 303] . When an appointment is made on
2026:MLHC:549
compassionate grounds, it should be kept confined only to
the purpose it seeks to achieve, the idea being not to provide
for endless compassion, vide I.G. (Karmik) v. Prahalad
Mani Tripathi [I.G. (Karmik) v. Prahalad Mani Tripathi,
(2007) 6 SCC 162 : (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 417] . In the same
vein is the decision of this Court in Mumtaz Yunus
Mulani v. State
of
Maharashtra [Mumtaz
Yunus
Mulani v. State of Maharashtra, (2008) 11 SCC 384 : (2008)
2 SCC (L&S) 1077] , wherein it was declared that
appointment on compassionate grounds is not a source of
recruitment, but a means to enable the family of the
deceased to get over a sudden financial crisis.
vi. In State of J&K v. Sajad Ahmed Mir [State of
J&K v. Sajad Ahmed Mir, (2006) 5 SCC 766 : 2006 SCC
(L&S) 1195] , the facts before this Court were that the
government employee (father of the applicant therein) died
in March 1987. The application was made by the applicant
after four-and-half years in September 1991 which was
rejected in March 1996. The writ petition was filed in June
1999 which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge in
July 2000. When the Division Bench decided the matter,
more than fifteen years had passed from the date of death of
the father of the applicant. This Court remarked that the
said facts were relevant and material as they would
demonstrate that the family survived in spite of death of the
employee. Therefore, this Court held that granting
compassionate appointment after a lapse of a considerable
amount of time after the death of the government employee,
would not be in furtherance of the object of a scheme for
compassionate appointment.
vii. In Shashi Kumar [State of H.P. v. Shashi Kumar,
(2019) 3 SCC 653 : (2019) 1 SCC (L&S) 542] , this Court
speaking through Dr D.Y. Chandrachud, J. (as his Lordship
then was) observed that compassionate appointment is an
exception to the general rule that appointment to any public
post in the service of the State has to be made on the basis
of principles which accord with Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. That the basis of the policy is that it recognises
that a family of a deceased employee may be placed in a
position of financial hardship upon the untimely death of
2026:MLHC:549
the employee while in service. That it is the immediacy of the
need which furnishes the basis for the State to allow the
benefit of compassionate appointment. The pertinent
observations of this Court have been extracted as under :
(SCC pp. 670-71, para 35)
“41. Insofar as the individual facts pertaining to the
respondent are concerned, it has emerged from the
record that the writ petition before the High Court was
instituted on 11-5-2015. The application for
compassionate appointment was submitted on 8-5-2007.
On 15-1-2008 the Additional Secretary had required that
the amount realised by way of pension be included in the
income statement of the family. The respondent waited
thereafter for a period in excess of seven years to move a
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. In Umesh
Kumar Nagpal [Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of
Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 930] , this
Court has emphasised that the basis of a scheme of
compassionate appointment lies in the need of providing
immediate assistance to the family of the deceased
employee. This sense of immediacy is evidently lost by the
delay on the part of the dependant in seeking
compassionate appointment.”
32. On consideration of the aforesaid decisions of this
Court, the following principles emerge:
i. That a provision for compassionate appointment makes a
departure from the general provisions providing for
appointment to a post by following a particular procedure of
recruitment. Since such a provision enables appointment
being made without following the said procedure, it is in the
nature of an exception to the general provisions and must
be resorted to only in order to achieve the stated objectives
i.e. to enable the family of the deceased to get over the
sudden financial crisis.
ii. Appointment on compassionate grounds is not a source
of recruitment. The reason for making such a benevolent
scheme by the State or the public sector undertaking is to see
that the dependants of the deceased are not deprived of the
2026:MLHC:549
means of livelihood. It only enables the family of the
deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.
iii. Compassionate appointment is not a vested right which
can be exercised at any time in future. Compassionate
employment cannot be claimed or offered after a lapse of
time and after the crisis is over.
vi. That compassionate appointment should be provided
immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is improper
to keep such a case pending for years.
v. In determining as to whether the family is in financial
crisis, all relevant aspects must be borne in mind including
the income of the family, its liabilities, the terminal benefits
if any, received by the family, the age, dependency and
marital status of its members, together with the income from
any other source.
33. The object underlying a provision for grant of
compassionate employment is to enable the family of the
deceased employee to tide over the sudden crisis due to the
death of the bread-earner which has left the family in
penury and without any means of livelihood. Out of pure
humanitarian consideration and having regard to the fact
that unless some source of livelihood is provided, the family
would not be in a position to make both ends meet, a
provision is made for giving gainful appointment to one of
the dependants of the deceased who may be eligible for such
appointment. Having regard to such an object, it would be
of no avail to grant compassionate appointment to the
dependants of the deceased employee, after the crisis which
arose on account of death of a breadwinner, has
been overcome. Thus, there is also a compelling need to act
with a sense of immediacy in matters concerning
compassionate appointment because on failure to do so, the
object of the scheme of compassionate appointment would
be frustrated. Where a long lapse of time has occurred since
the date of death of the deceased employee, the sense of
immediacy for seeking compassionate appointment would
cease to exist and thus lose its significance and this would
be a relevant circumstance which must weigh with the
2026:MLHC:549
authorities in determining as to whether a case for the grant
of compassionate appointment has been made out for
consideration.
34. As noted above, the sine qua non for entertaining a
claim for compassionate appointment is that the family of
the deceased employee would be unable to make two ends
meet without one of the dependants of the deceased
employee being employed on compassionate grounds. The
financial condition of the family of the deceased, at the time
of the death of the deceased, is the primary consideration
that ought to guide the authorities' decision in the matter.
35. Considering the second question referred to above, in
the first instance, regarding whether applications for
compassionate appointment could be considered after a
delay of several years, we are of the view that, in a case
where, for reasons of prolonged delay, either on the part of
the applicant in claiming compassionate appointment or the
authorities in deciding such claim, the sense of immediacy
is diluted and lost. Further, the financial circumstances of
the family of the deceased, may have changed, for the better,
since the time of the death of the government employee. In
such circumstances, courts or other relevant authorities are
to be guided by the fact that for such prolonged period of
delay, the family of the deceased was able to sustain
themselves, most probably by availing gainful employment
from some other source. Granting compassionate
appointment in such a case, as noted by this Court in Hakim
Singh [Haryana SEB v. Hakim Singh, (1997) 8 SCC 85 :
1998 SCC (L&S) 31] would amount to treating a claim for
compassionate appointment as though it were a matter of
inheritance based on a line of succession which is contrary
to the Constitution. Since compassionate appointment is not
a vested right and the same is relative to the financial
condition and hardship faced by the dependants of the
deceased government employee as a consequence of his
death, a claim for compassionate appointment may not be
entertained after lapse of a considerable period of time since
the death of the government employee.”
2026:MLHC:549
13.
What emerges from the judgment quoted above and the
numerous judgments referred to therein, is that the Policy recognizes
the financial hardships that the family of a deceased employee may be
put to on account of the demise of the breadwinner while in service, and
the immediacy of the need. The same is an important consideration to
allow the benefit of compassionate appointment and as such therefore,
when applications for compassionate appointment are still pending after
several years and though the delay may be due to various factors, the
immediacy in the situation would no longer exist, as no situation can
remain constant. In the instant case as observed above and on the
consideration that as per Para-13 (xv) of the Scheme that the
recommendations of the Departmental Screening Committee be placed
before the Competent Authority, which therefore would be the final
authority, the case of the petitioner was rejected primarily on the
question of the family having an earning member. Further, taking into
account the passage of time and also the fact that compassionate
appointment is a narrow exception and not a vested right intended to
rescue families from sudden financial crisis, this Court is of the view
that the rejection by the Competent Authority is sustainable. In the
considered view of this Court, Clasue-11 of the Scheme not having been
conclusively met and the Competent Authority being the final authority
2026:MLHC:549
in such matters, and the sense of immediacy having been lost, inasmuch
as, over a decade has elapsed since the employee’s death in 2014, the
rejection of the petitioner’s case by the Competent Authority is not
interfered with and the writ petition accordingly stands dismissed.
14.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
01.06.2026
“V. Lyndem-PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2026.06.08 18:41:26 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review