Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!!"
#$ %
&
)#
#$ %
&
)*
#$ %
&
!!)
#$ %
&
'(
+
!!"'
#
(
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
! " #$
%
"
& '
%
(%) $
%
* +#
,
- $
%
!
/
%
$
%
%
%
(
%
(
!
*
(
.
/
/
/
/ /
) &
% !
%
*
*
#
-2-
!
%
%
$
%
* +#
#
"
(%) $
% $
( %
%
%
#
*
!
!
! "
$
#.
%
"
% %
%
*
%
&
%
/
-
*
*
!
% % %!
"! (
! /
% $
( %
%
%
$
(%) $
#
+
%
!
" #
*
*
,
- $
%
%
%
%
%
)
(
%
(
%
#
.
%
%
(
)
/
$$
%
(
$
! %
(
%
%
%
$% !
(%) $
)
%
*(%) $
$
- .
%
$
% $% !
%
!
%
(
%
%
*
!
-3-
%
$
%
% %
$ !
%1
%!
$
%
(
$
)#'
#
(
!
%
%
%
%
(%) $
$
- $
%
%
/
.
!
! " #$
%
"
(%) $
/
%
%
%
$
/
/
/ )
!
*
%
!
! "
%
%
* +#
/
&
/
!
$
/
"
% % &
* #
%
%
%
%
!
% % %!
! (
! /
%
$
(%) $
%
* +#
!
% !
-4-
- $
%
(
%
!
(
%
%
)
(
(
#
!%
.
%
%
( %
$
%
%
% !
$% !
%
%
(
%
%
*
$
%
)*'
- .
(
!
)
%
(% ) $
#
(
!
%
%
%
%
(%) $
$
%1
%!
- $
$
%
%
)/
! " +$
)
!
/
%
%
%
/
%
* +#
"
% (%) $
%
%
$
!
*
%
/
/ )
/
&
!
$
(
.
/
!
! "
/
"
/
%
%
%
!
-5-
%
% % &
* #
/
%
!
% % %!
! (
! /
- $
%
%
!
%
%
%
$
(%) $
%
* +#
(
%
)
(
(
)
(
!
$$
$
#
(
! %
.
%
%
(
%
%
- .
$% !
$
)
%
% !
%
(
%
!
!
%
$
%
%
(%) $
!!)'
#
(
)/
! " +$
)
!
- $
%
"
% (%) $
/
%
* +#
(
%
!
/
%
$
%
%
%
(
!
(
.
/
/
/
/ /
) &
%
(
%
-6-
%
*
% !
*
*
#
!
%
%
$
%
* +#
#
"
(%) $
% $
( %
%
%
#
*
!
! "
%
!
"
%
% % &
$
#
%
%
/
-
*
*
!
% % %!
"! (
! /
% $
( %
%
- $
%
(
(
%
$
(%) $
#
+
*
%
#
#
+
(
!
%
%
(
/
*
%
$$
%
(
$
%
(
%
%
! %
%
%
%
)
!
%
!
" #
%
)
%
%
%
.
%
%
$% !
$
(%) $
*
- .
%
%
*(%) $
$
% $% !
%
% %
%
$
-7-
!
% !
%
$
$
% !
)
!
%(
"
%
%
)
%
%
;<
< 356
:;C><79
(;D7E78>:
;96
- :
%
>3
356 )>?=@6<3
(
25 :3
$
%
5626 7886792 7:6 7:;2;<=
7<? 7A7:? ?736?
%
"
F356
7<?
3 :
BB;?6<3
:;C><79G.
(
97;@2
7A7:?;<=
B @86<273; < 3 356 B97;@7<32
: 356 27H6
B <I6<;6<B6 356 87:3;62 A;99 C6
:6 6::6? 3 72 86: 356;: :7<H;<= C6 :6 356 :;C><79
56 :696I7<3
7B32
: 7?D>?;B73; <
7886792 7:6 3573 356 B97;@7<32 A6:6 3:7I699;<= ;< 7
6@8
C67:;<=
+
8@
:6=;23:73; <
3 A7:?2
356 ?:;I6:
*
@;??96
*
*
35626
;B56:
<
7<?57:78>: 2;?6 7<? 73 7: ><?
>@86: I65;B96 C67:;<= :6=;23:73; <
# 572 A: <=9E 87:H6? 356 27;? I65;B96
< 356
356 : 7? A;35 >3 356:6 C6;<= 7<E 87:H;<= 9;=532 7<?
-8-
< 7BB ><3
356 27@6
?7256? 3 356
>@86: I65;B96 A5;B5 A72 C6;<= 2373; <6? 7<?
< 7BB ><3
356 27@6 356 B97;@7<32 2>237;<6? =:;6I >2
;<D>:;62
6<B6
356 ?:;I6:
B97;@7<32
7<?
57I6
;B56:
6@8
8:6 6::6?
(
(
266H;<=
B @86<273; <
36: 26:I;B6
< 3;B6 356 :628 <?6<32 6<36:6?
78867:7<B6 7<? ;96? ?637;96? A:;336< 23736@6<3 ?6<E;<= 356
7I6:@6<32 @7?6 ;< 356 B97;@ 863;3; <
%<
:?6: 3
8: I6 356;: B726 356 B97;@7<32 57I6
6J7@;<6? 35:66 A;3<62262 72
? B>@6<32 72
J
J
7<? @7:H6?
< 356
356: 57<? 3A
A;3<62262 A6:6 6J7@;<6? CE 356 :628 <?6<3 2;?6 72
7<?
7<? 8: ?>B6? 3A
J
? B>@6<32 72
J
7<?
:;C><79 7 36: B <2;?6:;<= 356 @736:;79
< :6B :?
CE ;32 )>?=@6<3 7<? 7A7:? ?736?
B @86<273; <
##
* ;<
#
* ;<
(
K 86: 7<<>@ : @ 356 ?736
7A7:?6?
(
7<?
A;35 ;<36:623 73 356 :736
863;3; < 3;99 :679;L73; <
-9-
#
%3 ;2 792
:;C><79 572 569? 3573 356 ?:;I6:2
:35B @;<= : @ 356 ;@8>=<6? 7A7:?
I65;B962 ;< M>623; < 7:6 9;7C96
<6=9;=6<B6
:
"
C 35 356
;<2 7: 72 356
< 356;: 87:3 7<? 7BB :?;<=9E ?;28 26?
B97;@ 863;3; <
669;<=
7==:;6I6?
B @86<273; < 7A7:?6? CE 356
CE
M>7<3>@
:;C><79 7<?
< 356 9;7C;9;3E
356 %<2>:7<B6 B @87<E 572 8:6 6::6?
7<?
56 B97;@7<32 57I6 8:6 6::6?
7<?
6<57<B6@6<3
+
@3
356 %<2>:7<B6
I6:9
266H;<=
B @86<273; <
:663;
73;9 967:<6? B ><269 78867:;<=
@87<E 7:=>6? 3573
H6? 356 B57:=6*25663 8: ?>B6? 73
:
:;C><79 572
J
A56:6;<
356 B57:=6*25663 572 C66< ;96? 7=7;<23 356 ?:;I6:
;B56:
6@8
7<? 356:6 :6
;3 ;2 B <36<?6? 3573
>@86: I65;B96 A72 87:H6? CE 356 2;?6
356 27@6 356 B <3:;C>3 :E <6=9;=6<B6 3
356 : 7? ?628;36
7< 6J36<3
K ;2
- 10 -
@7?6 7=7;<23 356
>@86: I65;B96 A5;B5 :6M>;:62 3
C6
;<36: 6:6? A;35 ;< 35;2 788679
%3 ;2 792
7:=>6? CE 356 967:<6? B ><269
7886997<3 3573 356 7A7:?
7<<>@ ;2
;<36:623 73 356 :736
< 356 5;=56: 2;?6 A5;B5 :6M>;:62 3
: 356
K 86:
C6 :6?>B6? 3
#K
%3
;2
3:7I699;<=
2>C@;336?
7:=>6?
><7>35 :;L6?
B97;@7<32
87226<=6:2
;@8>=<6?
7<?
7A7:?
A6:6
356:6 :6
:6M>;:62
C6
;<36: 6:6<B6 A;35 ;< 35626 7886792
6: B <3:7
B ><269 78867:;<=
:;
72 356
73;9 967:<6?
: 356 7886997<3*B97;@7<32 7:=>6? 3573
356 B <3:;C>3 :E <6=9;=6<B6
;B56: I65;B96 CE 356
7<=7<7C727I7
7236<6?
< 356 ?:;I6:
:;C><79 :6M>;:62 3
C6 ;<36: 6:6? A;35
>@86: I65;B96 A72 87:H6? ;< 356 @;??96
A5;B5 ;2 7 2;<=96 : 7? 7<? 356:6 :6 2 >=53
6<3;:6 9;7C;9;3E
< 356 ?:;I6:
356 : 7?
: 7236<;<= 356
>@86: I65;B96 %3 ;2 792
7:=>6? CE 356 967:<6? B ><269 78867:;<=
: 356 7886997<3*
- 11 -
B97;@7<32 3573 356 7A7:?
B @86<273; < :6M>;:62 3
C6
6<57<B6? ;< 35626 7886792
%< 356 9;=53
967:<6?
B ><269
356 2>C@;22; < @7?6 CE 356
78867:;<=
<
B7:6 >9
B <2;?6:73; <
356 ;<?;<= :6B :?6? CE 356 967:<6?
:;C><79
< %22>6
A56:6;< ;3 ;2
356 37: : 7? A72
6;356: 2;?6
:
87:3;62
:35B @;<= 3573 356 A;?35
663 57I;<= H7B5B57 : 7?
%3 ;2 792
23736? 3573
2;3>736? 73 7 ?;237<B6 : @
663 : @ 356 A6236:< 6?=6
>@86: ;2 2;3>736?
- J
.
:35B @;<=
7H;<= ;<3
< 356 A6236:< 6?=6 8733; 7<? /7B5B57
N 663 : @ 356 A6236:< 6?=6
27;? 7286B3 ;2
>@86:
56 : <3 96 3 2;?6 A5669
2;?6 8733; 7<? ;32 C7BH A5669 ;2 2;3>736?
?;237<B6
7<? N 663
< 3 ;< ?;28>36 3573 356 27;?
I65;B96 ;2 57I;<= 36< A56692
<
;B56: I65;B96 A72
7<? ;32 C7BH A5669 ;2 2;3>736? ;< 7 ?;237<B6
< 37: : 7? %3 ;2 792
< 356 : 7? ;< 7
356 : 7?
: @ 356 28 3 87<B57<7@7
B <2;?6:73; < 356 27;? 7286B3
@7336: 72 356 7BB;?6<3 ;< M>623; < A72 3
H 897B6 73 7C >3
8 @ 7<? 356:6 :6 72 356 37: : 7? ;2 2;<=96 : 7? < 3
57I;<= 3A
: 7?2 A;35 C; >:B73;<= 9;<6
< 6;356: 2;?6
- 12 -
: 7? 7<? 2>B5 C6;<= 356 B726 356 ?:;I6:
87:H6? 356 I65;B96 A;35 >3 967I;<= 287B6
>@86: 572
: 356: I65;B962 3
89E : @ 356 I6:E 27@6 2;?6
%<
?6B97:73; <
I;6A
97A @7?6 CE 356
@7336:
<GC96
99 A;<=
>8:6@6
>:3 ;< 356
B726
:68 :36? ;<
><?6: 2;@;97: B;:B>@237<B62
!
2 + 7<?
572 569? 72
$
$
99 A2"
!
& %
%#
'
A56:6;< 73 87:7=:785
"
" '
(
"
*
+
%
'
#
"
" %
%
"
(
)
%#
%#
"
"#
&
' ""
(
)
' #
*
' ""
'
$
%#
%#
"
"
"
%
% #
)
& %
"
#
(
)
" ' &
%#
*
,
'
"#
#
%"
%
""#
& %
"
& %
"
%"
'
#
& %
" '
,
, "
'
&
& %
"#
"
- 13 -
"
"#
%
-
%"#
(
)
%
%
" %"
.
"
"
$
/
&
$
"
& %
"
"
"
/
$
"
"
&
(
$
$
!
)
"
/
$
%
# '
*
"
$
'
%"#
" '
"
&
%
$
/
'
'
&
"
"
$
!
"
'
"
&
"
$
#
$
"
&
! '
)
&
"
%#
$
(
"
(
)
$
"
/
'
#
'
'
%
"
/
&
&
$
%
#
#
$
$
.
"
"
/
"
*
*
%
#
"
%
"
$
+3
'
/
&
"
$
"#
"
'
(
)
'
- 14 -
"
""
)
'
"
%
# '
%
#
"
%#
#
"
*
& %
'
"#
$
/
"
$
"
*
&
'
$
>8:6@6
< 57<? 7<? CE 9
% 7@
H;<= ;<3
356 28 3 87<B57<7@7 73
356 ?:;I6:
C67:;<= :6=;23:73; <
*
C6 7236<6?
>@86: I65;B96
A<6:
I65;B96 C67:;<= :6=;23:73; <
*
#
%<2 7:
7A7:?
(
:
356 @7336: 356 6<3;:6
< 356
J
# ;2 2 969E :628 <2;C96
356 7996=6? 7BB;?6<3 %< 3573 I;6A
<6=9;=6<B6 572 3
97A @7?6 CE 356
>:3 7<? 7889E;<= 356 8:;<B;896 3 356 B726
356 I;6A 3573
B <B6:<6? ;<
+
+
"
#
99 A;<= 356 ?6B97:73; <
<GC96
'
"
"
"
(
'
>@86:
B @86<273; <
57I;<= 37H6< < 36
;2
;<D>:E 2>237;<6? CE 356 B97;@7<3 7<? 356 6I;?6<B6
7<? 72 356 7BB;?6<3 ;2
=>;?69;<62
356 E67:
356 /7:<737H7
@ <359E ;<B @6
6=79
7<? 72 86: 356
6:I;B62
356 B97;@7<3 572 3
>35 :;3E
C6 37H6< 73
- 15 -
* 86: @ <35 7<? CE 7889E;<= 356 788: 8:;736
@>93;89;6:
F
6J36<3
K % 7@
:
9 22
#
G CE 37H;<= ;<3
7BB ><3 356 ?;27C;9;3E 3
356 I;6A 3573 356 B97;@7<3 ;2 6<3;396?
* - 2
*
K. 3 A7:?2
67:<;<= B787B;3E
#
7H;<= ;<3
;<D>:E
2>237;<6?
B <2;?6:73; < 356
CE
356: 7286B32 72 3
B97;@7<3
7<?
7A7:?
B @86<273; < ;2 :6*7226226? 72 ><?6:"
,
+
#
86:>279
-./0 +1 2+34-50.67+5
67:<;<= B787B;3E
7;< 7<? 2> 6:;<=2
;63
;<B @6 ?>:;<= 97;? >8
86:; ? - 2
*
@ <352.
7@6<;3;62
6?;B79 6J86<262
+6.,
%<2 7: 72
;2 B <B6:<6?
(
356 6I;?6<B6
3+856
#
*
*
)* '
<
@7H62 ;3 B967: 3573 356
B97;@7<3 572 2> 6:6? 86:@7<6<3 ?;27C;9;3E 3
K3
*
*
*
*
K 72 3 356 9;@C %< 3573 I;6A
7< 6J36<3
356 @7336: 72 356
B97;@7<3 572 2>237;<6? ><;36? :;=53 7<? 96 3 6@>: 257 3 A;35
;<36:9 BH;<= <7;92 A;35 ><;36? :;=53 3;C;7 :7B3>:6 A;35 C 35
H<66 D ;<32 287B6 <7:: A 7<? 57;LE 7<? :;=53 B97I;B96 7:67
- 16 -
2A699;<= A;35 87;< 7<? 36<?6:<622 A;35 ><;36?
:;=53 B97I;B96
56 7BB;?6<3 ;2
356 E67:
=>;?69;<62
356 /7:<737H7
6=79
@ <359E ;<B @6
:7B3>:6
7<? 72 86: 356
6:I;B62
356 B97;@7<3 572 3
>35 :;3E
C6 37H6< 73
* 86: @ <35 7<? CE 7889E;<= 356 788: 8:;736
@>93;89;6:
F
6J36<3
K % 7@
:
9 22
+
G CE 37H;<= ;<3
7BB ><3 356 ?;27C;9;3E 3
356 I;6A 3573 356 B97;@7<3 ;2 6<3;396?
* - 2
*
K. 3 A7:?2
67:<;<= B787B;3E
+
7H;<= ;<3
;<D>:E
2>237;<6?
B <2;?6:73; < 356
CE
356: 7286B32 72 3
B97;@7<3
7<?
7A7:?
B @86<273; < ;2 :6*7226226? 72 ><?6:"
,
#
+
-./0 +1 2+34-50.67+5
67:<;<= B787B;3E
7;< 7<? 2> 6:;<=2
<I6E7<B6
;<B @6 ?>:;<= 97;? >8
86:; ? - 2
*
@ <352.
7@6<;3;62
6?;B79 6J86<262
+6.,
BB :?;<=9E 356
3+856
+
*
# *
0 # !) # '
99 A;<= :?6:"
*
*
*
*
- 17 -
-;.
7<?
7:6 56:6CE ?;2@;226?0
-;;.
7<?
7:6 87:39E 799 A6? 5 9?;<= 3573
A<6:
356 I65;B96 C67:;<=
:628 <?6<3
C6 :6 356
*
:;C><79 ;2 9;7C96 7<?
356:6CE 356 :628 <?6<3
%<2>:7<B6 B @87<E*
:;6<379 %<2>:7<B6 B @87<E ;2 9;7C96 3
356 :628 <?6<3
#O
;<?6@<; E
273;2 E 356 6<3;:6 B97;@
356 B97;@7<32
-;;;.
6<3;396?
56 B97;@7<3 ;<
(
;2
: 7 3 379 B @86<273; <
79 <= A;35 ;<36:623 73 356 :736
863;3; < 3;99 356 ?736
7<? B97;@7<3 ;<
(
#
:7
* 79 <= A;35
#K 86: 7<<>@ : @ 356 ?736
863;3; < 3;99 356 ?736
356 B97;@ 863;3; <2
:679;L73; <
;2 6<3;396?
3 379 B @86<273; <
*
#K 86: 7<<>@
: @ 356 ?736
;<36:623 73 356 :736
#
:679;L73; <
BB :?;<=9E
;96? CE 356 B97;@7<32 7:6
799 A6? ;<*87:3
-;I.
7@ ><3
3:7<2@;336? 3 356 :;C><79
;<
?68 2;3
:35A;35
25799
C6
- 18 -
-I.
%< I;6A
B97;@7<3
6<3;396?
:?6: ?736?
#
+
;<
: 356 ;<36:623
;2
: 356 ?697E6? 86:; ?
# ?7E2 ;< ;9;<= 356 788679
/'
$
(
;23
"
" /
"
< 3
&
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review