Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 52 of 2022
Date of Order :14.08.2023
Ms. Larisha Shabong
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. H.L.Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T.Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R.Gurung, Addl. Sr. GA with
Ms. S.Shyam, GA for R 1-3.
Mr. K.Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.Chanda, Adv. for R 4.
Dr. N.Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. S.Rumthao, Adv. for R 5.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner being aggrieved with the Notification dated 22-12-
2021 which recommended the name of the private respondent No.5 to the
post of Social Officer at the Meghalaya Institute of Mental Health and
Neurological Sciences (MIMHANS) is before this Court by way of the
instant writ petition. The grounds set forth for the challenge is that
respondent No. 5, lacked the eligibility criteria mentioned in the
advertisement and further also lacked experience to be considered for the
said post, whereas, the writ petitioner was eminently qualified as she
possessed
a
degree
of
Master
in
Social
Work
with
specialization/concentrated courses, coupled with experience, in the field
of Mental Health.
2.
Mr. H.L.Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. T.
Dkhar, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the advertisement
for the post of Social Officer had provided that a candidate was to possess
a Master Degree in Social Work preferably with 5 years’ experience in
the field of Mental Health from recognised Institutions. The learned
Senior counsel has then taken this Court to the Certificates of the
petitioner, to show that she, in the course of her study for Masters in
Social Work, taken papers dealing with Mental Health, apart from
possessing experience in the said field, and on 03-11-2021 was appointed
to officiate against the advertised post for a period of 59 days. The
respondent No. 5 on the other hand, he submits, as per information
received from RTI replies, does not possess any experience in the field of
Mental Health and that further the University where the Degree was
obtained from, did not offer any specialized course on Mental Health.
3.
On another limb of submission, the learned Senior counsel has
raised another issue by contending that the draft advertisement as
provided by the requiring department in this case, the Director of Health
Services (MI) vide letter dated 22-03-2016, had specifically indicated that
applicants should have more than 5 years’ experience in the field of
Mental Health from recognised Institutions, whereas the respondent No. 4
(Meghalaya Public Service Commission) had altered this criteria in the
advertisement, by inserting the word preferably. The respondent No. 4, he
asserts, had no authority to change, or alter the criteria that had been
prescribed by the requiring department in the advertisement, and as such,
the selection of the respondent No. 5, based on the altered advertisement
was irregular. It is further submitted that, had the advertisement been
published as given in the draft advertisement, the petitioner having more
experience would have been selected and not the respondent No. 5.
4.
Learned Senior counsel submits that there has been no reply in the
affidavits with regard to the alteration of the criteria, with regard to the
mandatory experience of 5 years that was required as per the draft
advertisement. He submits that though challenge has been put to the
selection process after the same had been concluded wherein the
petitioner had also taken part, there can be no estoppel, since the
deviation in the criteria came to the knowledge of the petitioner
subsequent to the selection process. He further submits that though there
are no service rules or executive orders governing the eligibility of
candidates to the said post, the same cannot take away the right of the
appointing authority to formulate the necessary criteria as has been done
by way of the draft advertisement. The criteria he contends, having been
diluted, such dilution would not confer any right on the selected candidate
that is respondent No. 5. In support of his arguments, the learned Senior
counsel has cited the following decisions:
(i)
(2006) 9 SCC 507 Malik Mazhar Sultan & Anr. vs.
U.P.Public Service Commission & Ors.
(ii)
(2007) 8 SCC 100 Union of India & Ors. vs. Vinodh
Kumar & Ors.
(iii)
(2008) 4 SCC 619 Sadananda Halo & Ors. vs. Momtaz Ali
Sheikh & Ors.
(iv)
5.
(1997) 9 SCC 527 Raj Kumar & Ors. vs. Shakti Raj & Ors.
Mr. K.Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.Chanda,
learned counsel on behalf of the respondent No.4, has at the outset
submitted that the petitioner was aware about the criteria given in the
advertisement, took her chances and has now sought to challenge the
same on being unsuccessful, in a selection process that has been
concluded. He also submits that there has been no dilution in the criteria,
inasmuch as, the draft advertisement provided by the requiring
department, was not final and will not and cannot confer any right on any
party. The advertisement, he submits, was based on the materials before
the Public Service Commission and in this regard, clarification had also
been sought from the requiring department which had replied that there
was no service rules or office memorandum, regarding the post of Social
Officer at MIMHANS, Shillong. He however, has made a reference to an
office memorandum annexed to the affidavit, wherein it has been
mentioned that the qualification was that an applicant, must have passed
Masters in Social Work (MSW)/Ph.D. in the field of Mental Health
preferably with 5 years’ experience in the field of Mental Health from
recognised institutions. However, he submits, the same is inconsequential
in the present case, inasmuch as, the writ petitioner in the prayer has
sought quashment of the recommendations issued by the respondent No.
4, for a mandamus to make a fresh recommendation in favour of the writ
petitioner, and also for directions to offer the appointment to the writ
petitioner against the post of Social Officer. This he contends, is
untenable and there was no question of the recommendation being
vitiated, as the respondent No. 5 was found to be eligible as per the
advertisement and was found to be more meritious than the writ petitioner
in the selection, as he had scored higher marks. He submits therefore, the
petitioner cannot at this stage challenge the concluded process of
selection especially in the light of the prayer so made.
6.
Dr. N.Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. S.Rumthao,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 5, submits that the case put up by
the writ petitioner that she having undertaken specialized courses on
Mental Health should have been the natural choice is illusory, as
specialisation in Mental Health has not been mentioned anywhere. The
baseline required qualification he submits, was that of Masters in Social
Work which the respondent No. 5 possessed, and in the selection had
scored more than the petitioner. On the point of the preference clause, the
learned Senior counsel submits that it is only when all things are equal
such as two candidates securing equal marks, that this clause will come
into play to decide who should be the selected candidate, which is not the
case in the present matter, as respondent No. 5 has scored more marks.
The rule of estoppel he further submits, will surely come into play as the
advertisement was already published before the selection, and it is not a
case that the same was altered subsequently in the course of the selection
process. There being a clear distinction between challenging an
advertisement and a challenge to the recruitment process, the writ
petitioner he contends, cannot seek to club these two aspects and seek the
relief of annulling the recommendations made by respondent No. 4. On
the point of preferential qualification, the learned Senior counsel has
placed the following decisions:
(i)
(1996) 6 SCC 282 Secy. (Health) Deptt. Of Health & F.W.
& Anr. vs. Dr. Anita Puri & Ors.
(ii)
(2003) 5 SCC 341 Secretary, A.P. Public Service
Commission vs. Y.V.V.R.Srinivasulu & Ors.
(iii)
(2019) 6 SCC 362 Maharashtra Public Service Commission
vs. Sandeep Shriram Warade & Ors.
7.
Mr. R.Gurung, learned Addl. Sr. GA for the respondent Nos. 1-3,
has in his submissions supported the arguments made on behalf of the
respondent Nos. 4 & 5, and reiterated the point that once having taken
part in the selection, one cannot turn around and challenge the same on
being unsuccessful.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, it is noted that the
issues raised before this Court is the question of eligibility of the
respondent No. 5 and whether the advertisement as published, had
deviated from the qualifications necessary to the post of Social Officer,
MIMHANS. It has been argued at length, apart from materials being
placed, to demonstrate that the writ petitioner apart from possessing the
basic qualification of Master of Social Work had also undertaken specific
courses dealing with Mental Health and was also experienced having
worked in this field. At this juncture therefore, it is necessary to examine
the advertisement which for the sake of convenience is extracted and
reproduced hereinbelow:
Sl.
No.
Name of Posts, Pay Scale and No.
of Age & Relaxation as on
Required Qualification
vacancies 1.1.2018
9.
Social
Officer
at
MIMHANS,
Meghalaya,
Shillong.
Rs.14,700-370-17290-EB480 - 21,610 - 650-28,760/pm. (Pre-revised)
Master Degree in Social
Work (MSW)/PHD in the
field of Mental Health
preferably with 5 years
experience in the field of
Mental
Health
from
recognized Institutions.
Additional Qualification:
Knowledge of either Khasi,
Jaintia or Garo as one of
the language is necessary.
9.
Candidates
should
not be less than 18
years and not more
than 27 years. Upper
age limit is relaxable
by 5 years for
candidates belonging
to SC / ST. No upper
age
limit
for
candidates already in
Meghalaya
Government Service
provided they entered
Service within the
prescribed age limit.
An examination of the advertisement clearly reflects that the
requirement is a Master Degree in Social Work (MSW) or a Ph.D. in the
field of Mental Health, preferably with 5 years’ experience in the field of
Mental Health from recognised institutions. Both the writ petitioner and
the respondent No. 5 therefore, being holders of Degrees of Master of
Social Work as required, possessed the requisite educational qualification
to apply for the post of Social Officer, MIMHANS. It is to be noticed that
the advertisement, has nowhere prescribed that the holder of a MSW
Degree is to have specialized in Mental Health, as has been asserted by
the writ petitioner to make out a case of her being more suitable. Further,
the clause of preference to those having experience, as has been rightly
argued by the counsel for the respondent No. 5, will come into
consideration if some additional weightage be given to a candidate with
higher qualification, and it cannot mean that a person who possesses
higher or specialized qualification, is automatically to be selected and
appointed. As held in the case of the Secy. (Health) Deptt. of Health &
F.W. & Anr. (supra), an expert body like the respondent No. 4, in the
absence of statutory criteria, has the discretion of evolving its mode of
evaluation of merit and selection of the candidate. Further, the preference
clause, when a selection is made on the basis of merit, will come into play
only if all other things are equal, and as such, a candidate possessing
additional qualification would be preferred. The respondent No. 5 having
undisputedly scored more marks than the writ petitioner, the preference
clause would therefore have no application.
10.
On the question of whether there was any deviation in the
advertisement published from the draft advertisement supplied by the
requiring department i.e., respondent No. 2, in the considered view of this
Court, in the absence of any statutory rule or guidelines as noted above in
the earlier paragraph, and the clarification provided by the respondent No.
2 to this effect, the advertisement cannot be held to be faulty or that the
criteria had been altered in the course of selection. Moreover, the fact that
the petitioner did not choose to question the same at the time of its
publication, but only after the selection process was over, clearly creates
an estoppel in law.
11.
The stand of the petitioner taken in the course of arguments,
however, is belied by the prayer in the writ petition itself, inasmuch as,
the same is directed only against the selection and nowhere is the
advertisement impugned. Infact, directions have been sought for quashing
the recommendation and for a direction that a fresh recommendation be
made in favour of the writ petitioner. Further, a mandamus is also sought
to direct the State respondents to consider and offer the appointment to
the writ petitioner against the post of Social Officer. The petitioner
therefore, while on one breath impugning the selection process, cannot by
the same breath, seek any relief from the same selection process.
12.
This being a clear case of challenging a selection process after
willingly taking part in the same, therefore, cannot be sustained. Courts’
interference with the decision of the selection by an expert body, will
only be called for, on very limited circumstances or grounds, such as
illegality or patent material irregularity which has vitiated the selection
process. In the instant case, the challenge being only on criteria therefore,
no cause for any interference has been made out and as such the writ
petition is liable to be dismissed.
13.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition being devoid of any merit
stands dismissed, however, with no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
14.08.2023
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review