The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. 11.2022. However, in the 2nd detention order, bail application No. 33 of 2022 was mentioned and hence the detention order is also vitiated due to total non-application of mind. [10] In the case of Gracy vs. State of Kerala & Ors. reported as (1991) 2 SCC 1 at para 9, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the competent authority has to consider the representation submitted by the detenu irrespective of the authority mentioned therein. Para 9 is reproduced as under: Page 6 “9. It being settled that the aforesaid dual obligation of consideration of the detenu’s representation by the Advisory Board and independently by the detaining authority flows from Article 22(5) when only one representation is made addressed to the detaining authority, there is no reason to hold that the detaining authority is relieved of this obligation merely because the representation is addressed to the Advisory Board instead of the detaining authority and submitted to the Advisory Board during pendency of the reference before it. It is difficult to spell out such an inference from the contents of Article 22(5) in support of the contention of the learned Solicitor General. The Contents of Article 22(5) as well as the nature of duty imposed thereby on the detaining authority support the view that so long as there is a representation made by the detenu against the order of detention, the aforesaid dual obligat…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Cril.) No. 40 of 2023
Lamneihat Haolen Thadou @ Hatpi (27 years), W/o
Jangminlen Haolen Thadou of Gamnomjang Village, P.O &
P.S. and District: Churachandpur.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1. The
State
of
Manipur,
through
the
Chief
Secretary,
Government of Manipur at Babupara, Imphal-795001;
2. The Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur at
Babupara, Imphal-795001;
3. The Union of India – through the Secretary, Ministry of
Finance, Department of Revenue, Near North Block, Room
No. 26, Church Road, RFA, Barrack, New Delhi-110001.
........Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
::
Mr. Th. Babloo, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. O. Ratankumar, Dy. G.A. for the
State and Mr. Boboy Potsangbam,
CGSC for the Union of India.
Date of Order
::
17.04.2023
Page 1
ORDER(ORAL)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, (J)
[1]
The detenu was arrested on 01.10.2022 by a team of NAB-PS
from Tuibong Bazar, Churachandpur in connection with FIR No.
33(10)2022 NAB-PS u/s 18(c) ND & PS Act. From her possession, 1 kg of
opium was recovered and she was produced before the Court and
remanded to judicial custody. When the detenu was in custody, the 1st
detention order dated 02.11.2022 under Section 3 (1) of the Prevention of
Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (PIT-ND &
PS Act), 1988 was issued by the Special Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur for effectively preventing her from further involvement in illicit
trafficking of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances for a period of
three months until further orders. It is also stated that the detenu filed a bail
application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 38 of 2022 before the Special
Judge (ND & PS), Churachandpur in connection with FIR No. 33(10)2022
NAB-PS u/s 18(c) ND & PS Act. Vide order dated 15.12.2022, the
Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur revoked the 1st detention
order dated 02.11.2022 under section 12(a) of the PIT-ND & PS Act with
immediate effect. The bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) No. 33 of 2022
was disposed of as not pressed vide order dated 28.11.2022 by the Ld.
Special Judge, ND & PS, Churachandpur. The 2nd detention order dated
16.12.2022 against the detenu was issued by the Commissioner (Home),
Page 2
Government of Manipur exactly the same grounds as the 1st detention
order dated 02.11.2022. Vide order dated 18.01.2023, the State
Government rejected the representation submitted by the detenu.
The detention was challenged mainly on the ground that the
[2]
2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 was issued on the same grounds as
the 1st detention order dated 02.11.2022 which was revoked vide order
dated 15.12.2022. It is also stated that after withdrawal of the bail
application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. 33 of 2022 vide order dated
28.11.2022, the detenu did not file any fresh bail application and the
Central Government has not disposed of the representation till the date of
filing.
The State Government filed counter affidavit where it is stated
[3]
that the detenu was taken into preventive detention as she was a habitual
offender. The 1st detention order dated 02.11.2022 was withdrawn on
technical ground on the advice of the AG, Mannipur and as a corrective
steps, the 2nd detention order was freshly issued. Hence, there is no defect
in the 2nd detention order. The 2nd detention order was duly communicated
to the Central Government. The representation dated 10.01.2023 was
received by the State government on 11.01.2023 and forwarded the same
to
the
Central
Government
vide
letter
dated
13.01.2023.
The
representation was rejected vide order dated 18.01.2023. It is prayed that
Page 3
there is no delay on the part of the State Government and as such the writ
petition be rejected.
[4]
The Central Government did not file any reply, however,
during the course of hearing, Mr. Boboy Potsangbam, learned CGSC for
the Union of India, submitted a copy of e-mail dated 10.03.2023 sent by
PITNDPS Division, Government of India to the Home Department,
Government of Manipur stating that the representation submitted by the
detenu was addressed to the Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur and
requested to forward a copy of the representation addressed to the Central
Government urgently.
[5]
Heard Mr. Th. Babloo, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr.
O. Ratankumar, learned Dy. G.A. for the State and Mr. Boboy
Potsangbam, learned CGSC for the Union of India.
[6]
Mr. Th. Babloo, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits
that the 2nd detention order is liable to be set aside as no fresh ground has
been disclosed, no bail application filed by the detenu is pending on the
date of the detention and mentioning of a bail application is total nonapplication of mind and as such, the detention order is liable to be set aside
on this ground alone. He further submits that the Central Government
ought to consider the representation submitted by the detenu irrespective
of whether it was addressed to the Central Government or not. Non-
Page 4
disposal of the representation dated 10.01.2023 for more than 3 months
vitiates the detention order. He prays that the detention order be set aside
and the detenu be set at liberty.
[7]
Mr. O. Ratankumar, learned Dy. A.G. for the State
respondent, submits that there is no defect in the 2nd detention order which
was reissued to rectify the technical defect in the 1st detention order. The
State Government duly intimated the Central Government about the
detention
and the representation
submitted
by the
detenu.
The
representation submitted by the detenu was disposed of within a short
period of 5 days and hence, there is no delay on the part of the State
Government. He prays that the writ petition be rejected.
[8]
Mr. Boboy Potsangbam, learned CGSC for the Union of India,
submits that as the detenu has not preferred any representation addressed
to the Central Government, a request has been made to the State
Government to forward a representation addressed to the Central
Government. In the circumstances, the Central Government could not take
any effective step.
[9]
On comparing the 1st detention order dated 02.11.2022 and
2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022, it is clearly seen that both have the
same contents and in other words, there is no new material in the 2nd
detention order. It may be noted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in
Page 5
the Case of Chhagan Bhagwan Kahar vs. N.L. Kalna reported as (1989)
2 SCC 318 at para 12 that fresh order of detention can be passed against
the same person only if some additional or fresh materials are in
possession after the 1st detention order was revoked or lapsed or set aside
by the Court. But in the present case, after revocation of the 1 st detention
order dated 02.11.2022, there are no fresh additional facts for issuing the
2nd detention order. The revocation order dated 16.12.2022 did not mention
that the same was done due to technical ground, rather it was revoked with
immediate effect without any condition. The 2nd detention order dated
16.12.2022 is in clear violation of the dictum of the decision of Chhagan
Bhagwan Kahar (Supra). Moreover, there is total non-application of mind
while issuing the 2nd detention order where no bail application was pending
on the date of issue of the 2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 after
withdrawal of bail application
being Cril.Misc.(B) No. 33 of 2022 on
28.11.2022. However, in the 2nd detention order, bail application No. 33 of
2022 was mentioned and hence the detention order is also vitiated due to
total non-application of mind.
[10]
In the case of Gracy vs. State of Kerala & Ors. reported as
(1991) 2 SCC 1 at para 9, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the
competent authority has to consider the representation submitted by the
detenu irrespective of the authority mentioned therein. Para 9 is
reproduced as under:
Page 6
“9. It being settled that the aforesaid dual obligation of
consideration of the detenu’s representation by the Advisory
Board and independently by the detaining authority flows from
Article 22(5) when only one representation is made addressed
to the detaining authority, there is no reason to hold that the
detaining authority is relieved of this obligation merely
because the representation is addressed to the Advisory
Board instead of the detaining authority and submitted to the
Advisory Board during pendency of the reference before it. It
is difficult to spell out such an inference from the contents of
Article 22(5) in support of the contention of the learned
Solicitor General. The Contents of Article 22(5) as well as the
nature of duty imposed thereby on the detaining authority
support the view that so long as there is a representation
made by the detenu against the order of detention, the
aforesaid
dual
obligation
under
Article
22(5)
arises
irrespective of the fact whether the representation is
addressed to the detaining authority or to the Advisory Board
or to both. The mode of address in only a matter of form which
cannot whittle down the requirement of the Constitutional
mandate in Article 22(5) enacted as one of the safeguards
provided to the detenu in case of preventive detention.”
[11]
In case, the Central Government did not take any action on
the representation submitted by the detenu on the ground that it was not
addressed to it to the Advisory Board and not to the Central Government
and hence there is no obligation on the Central Government to consider the
representation addressed to the Advisory Board. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court held in the case of Gracy (supra) that the Central Government has
Page 7
mandate to consider an obligation under Article 22(5) of the constitution to
consider the representation submitted by the detenu irrespective of the fact
whether it is addressed to the Central Government or not.
In view of the above discussion and decision of the Superior
[12]
Court, we are of the view that the detention order cannot be sustained on
the ground that (i) non-application of mind; (ii) non-disclosure of additional
facts while issuing the 2nd detention order dated 16.12.2022 and (iii) nonconsideration of the representation submitted by the detenu by the Central
Government on the ground that the same was addressed to the Chief
Secretary, Government of Manipur and not to it. Accordingly, the detention
order dated 16.12.2022 is set aside and all consequential proceedings with
respect to the detention order dated 16.12.2022 are also set aside. The
detenu, namely Lamneihat Haolen Thadou @ Hatpi be released from
detention forthwith, if not required in any other case.
Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. No cost.
[13]
JUDGE
FR/NFR
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
KH. JOSHUA KH. JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2023.05.03
MARING
10:57:27 +05'30'
joshua
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review