Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC040008552024
2026:GAU-AP:126
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/271/2024
Lama Tenzin and 2 Ors
Son of Late Namgey, permanent resident of Shocktsen Village, PO Zemithang, PS
Lungla, Tawang District, Arunachal Pradesh
2: Jampal Tashi
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Gentsen Chibber
permanent resident of Shocktsen village
PO Zemithang
PS Lungla
Tawang District
Arunachal Pradesh
3: Tenzin Sonam
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Tenzin Chhombey
permanent resident of Shocktsen village
PO Zemithang
PS Lungla
Tawang District
Arunachal Prades
VERSUS
The Union of India and 8 Ors
represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Sena Bhavan, Govt of India, New
Delhi 110011
2:The Director General Border Roads
Age: 0
Occupation :
Seema Sadak Bhawan
Page No.# 2/13
Ring Road
Naraina Delhi Cantt
New Delhi 110010
3:The Chief Engineer (VARTAK)
Age: 0
Occupation :
C/o 99 APO
Tezpur
PO Tezpur
Sonitpur District
Assam 784001
4:The Commander
Age: 0
Occupation :
763 BRTF
Khirmu
Kitpi Circle
C/o 99 APO
Tawang Dsitrict
Arunachal Pradesh 790104
5:The Officer Commanding
Age: 0
Occupation :
Road Construction Coy (GREF)
Zimithang Circle
PO Zimithang
Tawang District
Arunachal Pradesh 790106
6:The State of Arunachal Pradesh
Age: 0
Occupation :
represented by the Commissioner/ Secretary
Land Management
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
7:The Dreictor
Age: 0
Occupation :
Land Management
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
Page No.# 3/13
8:The Deputy Commisioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Tawang
Tawang District
PO and PS Tawang
Arunachal Pradesh 790104
9:The Additional Deputy Commisisoner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Lungla (Lumla) District Tawang
Arunachal Pradesh 79010
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Binter Picha, Tao Tarin,Jumgam Jini
Advocate for the Respondent : Marto Kato, GA (AP),DSGI
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Dated: 11.02.2026
Three nos. of petitioners have joined together in this petition filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, with the following prayer:
“I. A Writ of Certiorari shall not be issued quashing and setting aside the
impugned revised estimate cost of compensation prepared for Shungatser
to Sulula of Tawang District for the area measuring 3,38,400/- (three
lakhs thirty-eight thousand four hundred) Square Meters, amounting to
Rs.11,11,98,240/- (Rupees eleven crore eleven lacs ninety-eight thousand
two hundred forty).
II. A Writ of Certiorari shall not be of issued quashing and setting aside
the impugned letter communication dated 21.03.2022, whereby the
Page No.# 4/13
Deputy Commissioner, Tawang District, upon preparation of impugned
revised estimate, had sent the same to the Director, LM, Government of
Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, for necessary action.
III. A Writ of Certiorari shall not be issued quashing and setting aside the
impugned minute of meeting dated 14.12.2022 drawn by the respondent
authority, wherein the respondent authority had conveyed that the
villagers have accepted compensation amount of Rs.11,11,98,240/(Rupees eleven crore eleven lacs ninety-eight thousand two hundred
forty).
IV. A Writ of Certiorari shall not be issued quashing and setting aside the
impugned Award dated 14.02.2023, where the respondent authority had
awarded land compensation amount of Rs.11,11,98,240 /- (Rupees eleven
crore eleven lacs ninety-eight thousand two hundred forty) for the area of
land from Shungatser to Sulula of Tawang District, measuring 3,38,400/(three lakhs thirty-eight thousand four hundred) Square Meters.
V. A Writ of Certiorari shall not be issued quashing and setting aside the
impugned reply dated 03.11.2023.
VI. A Writ of Mandamus shall not be issued directing the respondent
authorities to pass fresh Award in respect of construction of road from
Sungetsar to Sulula of Tawang District, by taking 1.2 as multiplication
factor.
VII. A Writ of Mandamus shall not be issued directing the respondent
authorities to pay compensation to the villagers for construction of road
from Sungetsar to Sulula as per the first estimated cost of land, i.e., by
taking 1.2 as multiplication factor, with interest thereof and/or pass any
Page No.# 5/13
other consequential relief and/or pass any other order(s) as your lordship
may deem fit and proper.”
2.
As per the facts projected, there was a land acquisition proceeding for
construction of a road from Shungatser to Sulula under the Zemithang Circle of
Tawang District. For the said purpose, the respondent authorities had issued a
preliminary notification dated 03.11.2021 for acquisition of land measuring
3,38,400 Sq. Mtrs. under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 , (hereinafter
referred to as the Act of 2013). In furtherance of the said objective, a Board of
four members was constituted, which took a decision to adopt the multiplication
factor for the acquisition as 1.2. Such factor was taken in accordance with the
notification dated 05.07.2016 issued by the Government. The estimate was
accordingly prepared for compensation of Rs.13,21,79,040/- (Rupee Thirteen
Crore Twenty-One Lakh Seventy-Nine Thousand and Forty) only, by taking 1.2
as the multiplication factor. There were other charges also included in the
estimate. However, without the knowledge of the petitioners, the new
incumbent who had joined as the Deputy Commissioner of the District revised
the compensation to Rs.11,11,98,240/- (Rupees Eleven Crore Eleven Lakh
Ninety-Eight Thousand Two Hundred and Forty) only. The impugned revised
compensation was prepared by taking into account the multiplication factor as 1
instead of 1.2, which according to the petitioners is in complete violation of the
earlier decision of the Board taken as per the notification dated 05.07.2016. It
also transpires that such action was taken as per the verbal direction of the
Secretary (Land Management) Department, Arunachal Pradesh. The petitioners
claim that because of the impugned decision, rightful compensation has been
denied to them, and accordingly, the instant writ petition has been filed.
Page No.# 6/13
3.
I have heard Shri B. Picha, learned counsel for the petitioners. I have also
heard Shri M. Kato, learned Dy.S.G.I. for the Union of India and Shri R. H.
Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General for the State of Arunachal Pradesh.
4.
Shri Picha, learned counsel for the petitioner, has referred to the
notification dated 05.07.2016, which was issued by the appropriate authority in
the State Government. By referring to the Act of 2013, more specifically Section
26(2) thereof, which deals with determination of market value, he has submitted
that the said provision of law refers to a Schedule referred as the First Schedule.
Under Serial No. 2 of the Schedule, the aspect of multiplication has been laid
down depending on the radial distance of the area in question. He has
submitted that in terms of the Act and the provisions of law, the notification
dated 05.07.2016 was issued by the State Government, as per which the
applicable multiplier was 1.2. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to
the proceeding of the Board wherein such a multiplier was applied and,
accordingly, the estimate was prepared. However, from certain responses to
applications made under the RTI in the year 2023, the petitioners could learn
that the estimate was illegally revised whereby the multiplication factor was
applied as 1 instead of 1.2. Specific attention has been drawn to the
communication dated 03.11.2023, as per which such reduction was done as per
the verbal order of the Secretary (Land Management) Department. He has also
submitted that though there is a reference to a subsequent notification dated
21.03.2022 regarding the reduction in the multiplication factor, such notification
would not be applicable inasmuch as the preliminary notification for the land
acquisition was issued in the year 2021 itself. The learned counsel submits that
the impugned action, apart from being grossly illegal and arbitrary, is also
Page No.# 7/13
vitiated by fraud. He has submitted that the estimate forwarded by the Deputy
Commissioner to the Director of Land Management dated 21.03.2022 is prior to
the second notification dated 06.09.2022 and, therefore, the second notification
would not have any application in the assessment of fair compensation.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioners in support of his submission has
relied upon the following case laws:
(i) M/s Neyveli Lignite Corporation Limited v. Special Tahsildar
(Land Acquisition) & Ors., reported in (1995) 1 SCC 221;
(ii) Vitthal Rama Pawar (Katkari) & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra &
Ors., reported in (2017) 11 SCC 417;
(iii) Young Lal Association (YLA), Lawngtlai-III v. State of
Mizoram & Ors., reported in 2017 Supreme (Gau) 1083; and
(iv) Jashiben Lallubhai Patel v. Competent Authority, National
Highways Authority of India, reported in 2023 0 Supreme (Guj)
669.
6.
In the case of M/s Neyveli Lignite Corporation Limited (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down that when an award is vitiated by fraud,
there is violation of the rights of the land affected person and therefore, such an
affected person can approach the Writ Court.
7.
The case of Vitthal Rama Pawar (supra) has been cited to bring home
the contention that the multiplication factor is mandatory in nature. In the
aforesaid case, a Division Bench of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court has made
the following observations:
“12. As can be seen from this schedule, the same is divided into four columns.
Page No.# 8/13
Column 2 deals with the component of compensation package in respect of land
acquired under the Act and column 3 deals with the manner of determination of
value. Entry 1 of the 1st Schedule talks about the market value of the land and
stipulates that the same is to be determined as provided under Section 26. Entry
2 of the 1st Schedule, and which is relevant for our purpose, stipulates the factor
by which the market value is to be multiplied in the case of rural areas. The
manner of determination of value is that the multiplier factor has to be between
1.00 to 2.00, based on the distance of the project from the urban area, as notified
by the Appropriate Government. In other words, whilst determining the
compensation in case of the rural areas, the appropriate government has to
notify the multiplier factor as contemplated under Entry 2 of the 1st Schedule of
the 2013 Act. On a plain reading of Section 26 with Section 30 and the 1st
Schedule, it is clear that before any Award is passed in relation to any land in
rural areas, the aforesaid multiplier factor has to be applied. Passing an Award
without applying the multiplier factor would be contrary to the provisions of
Sections 26 to 30 of the 2013 Act.”
8.
The case of Young Lal Association (supra) has been cited to bring on
the contention that the availability of a remedy in the form of a reference could
not be a bar for a Writ Court to entertain a petition. It has been held that when
there is failure on the part of the authorities to discharge statutory duties, a Writ
Court can be approached.
9.
In the case of Jashiben Lallubhai Patel (supra), a Division Bench of the
Hon’ble Gujarat High Court has laid down that an Award can be interfered with
on the aspect of use of a wrong multiplication factor.
Page No.# 9/13
10.
Per contra, Shri Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, Arunachal
Pradesh, has opposed the writ petition and has submitted that the impugned
action is based on the subsequent notification dated 06.09.2022. He has
submitted that the Award is dated 14.02.2022, on which date the said
notification was in existence, and therefore, there was no illegality in applying
the said notification dated 06.09.2022, as per which the multiplication factor is
1. He has also raised a preliminary objection regarding the maintainability of the
writ petition by submitting that Section 64 of the Act of 2013 prescribes an
avenue to raise the grievance if an affected party is aggrieved by a land
acquisition proceeding or the quantum. He has further submitted that the
subsequent notification dated 06.09.2022 has not been challenged and,
therefore, no relief can be granted to the petitioners.
11.
Shri M. Kato, learned Dy. S.G.I., has endorsed the submissions made on
behalf of the State and has reiterated that the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed.
12.
The rival submissions advanced by the contesting parties have been duly
considered, and the materials placed before this Court have been carefully
examined.
13. The grievance, as narrated above, is with regard to the reduction of the
compensation amount by applying a multiplication factor of 1 instead of 1.2.
14.
The requirement of the application of a multiplication factor emanates
from the statute itself, namely Section 26(2) of the Act of 2013, read with the
First Schedule. As per the said provision, which is in connection with the
determination of market value, the First Schedule contains, amongst others, a
multiplication factor which has to be between 1 and 2. The appropriate
Page No.# 10/13
Government was accordingly required to issue a notification for such
multiplication factor. It is not in dispute that, so far as the State of Arunachal
Pradesh is concerned, a notification was issued on 05.07.2016 determining the
multiplication factor for various areas as per the distance, strictly in accordance
with the First Schedule. It also appears that in the Board proceeding for
determining and assessing the compensation, the multiplication factor applied
was 1.2 and, accordingly, the estimate was made, which was also forwarded to
the Director of Land Management on 21.03.2022.
15.
It is not in dispute with regard to the area vis-à-vis the use of the
multiplication factor. What is, however, disputed is the multiplication factor itself,
which was reduced by the impugned action. The defence taken by the State
Government is that a subsequent notification was issued on 06.09.2022,
whereby the multiplication factor was made 1. The learned State Counsel has
submitted that, taking into consideration that the Award is dated 14.02.2023,
there was no illegality in adopting the subsequent notification dated 06.09.2022.
This Court is, however, of the view that the process of acquisition started with
the issuance of the preliminary notification on 03.11.2021, whereafter there was
a Board proceeding which had taken into consideration the existing notification
dated 05.07.2016 issued in terms of the First Schedule to Section 26(2) of the
Act of 2013. The legality or correctness of the earlier notification has not been
questioned by the State, and therefore, no fault can be attributed to the Board
proceeding which had made an assessment of the compensation. As mentioned
above, there is no dispute with regard to the aspect of distance, and the only
defence for the impugned action is the new prescription of the multiplication
factor as 1.
16. It appears from the materials on record that the impugned decision was
Page No.# 11/13
based on the subsequent notification dated 06.09.2022 and also on the verbal
order of the Secretary, Land Management Department. Such a course of action,
in the opinion of this Court, is not in accordance with law. Any action taken by
the State has to be justified by law and the existing notifications. It is a settled
principle of law that the notification which existed at the time of initiation of the
process is to be applied, which was rightly done by the Board while making the
estimate. The response received by the petitioners to their applications under
the Right to Information Act also reveals that the assessment was done in terms
of the earlier notification dated 05.07.2016, which was later reduced.
17.
On the aspect of the maintainability of the writ petition, this Court finds
force in the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that Section 64
of the Act of 2013 would not be an absolute bar when the challenge is based on
an error apparent on the face of the record. In this regard, it would be
beneficial to refer to certain observations made by the Division Bench of this
Court in the case of Young Lal Association (supra). For ready reference, the
relevant observations made by the Division Bench of this Court are extracted
hereinbelow:
“19. Now coming to the next question as to whether such a claim can also be
maintained in a writ petition, as already discussed above, claim of interest and
solatium is a statutory right of the person interested and non-payment of such
interest and solatium would be a failure on the part of the Collector to discharge
statutory duty vested on him. If there is such failure on the part of the public
authority in the discharge of statutory duty, certainly a writ Court would be well
within its jurisdiction to issue a writ of mandamus to compel the public authority
to discharge his statutory duty. The fact that alternative remedy is available
under Sections 13(A) and 18 of the LA Act, 1894 would not debar the writ Court
Page No.# 12/13
from exercising such jurisdiction in an appropriate case.”
18.
The learned counsel for the petitioners by relying upon the case of M/s
Neyveli Lignite Corporation Limited (supra) has also raised an allegation of
cheating and has contended that such allegation not being controverted in the
affidavit-in-opposition amounts to an admission. This Court is, however, not
inclined to go deep into the allegation that the impugned action is vitiated by
fraud. However, it cannot be overlooked that the impugned action is also based
on the verbal order of the Secretary (Land Management) Department, which
would raise a serious doubt regarding the bona fide of such action. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in the case of Vitthal Rama Pawar (supra) has laid down, in
no uncertain terms that the multiplication factor is mandatory in nature. The
Court has already noted that such factor is a prescription of the statute, namely,
the Act of 2013.
19. At this stage, it would be necessary to keep in mind that the objective of
the Act of 2013 is to provide a better avenue and compensation for the land
affected person as acquisition of land is compulsory in nature and the only
remedy is to afford an adequate, fair and just compensation. It is in that context
that section 26(2) of the Act has been enacted, along with the First Schedule,
requiring the application of a multiplication factor. As noted above, the
corresponding notification by the State was issued on 50.07.2016 which without
any dispute, was in operation when the present process was initiated vide
publication of the preliminary notification on 03.11.2021.
20.
This Court is unable to accept the contention advanced on behalf of the
State that since the Award was of a later date, i.e., 14.02.2023, the subsequent
notification dated 06.09.2022 could have been taken into consideration. This
Court is of the opinion that prior to the subsequent notification dated
Page No.# 13/13
06.09.2022, the Deputy Commissioner, Tawang, vide communication dated
21.03.2022, had forwarded the revised estimate, including the compensation of
the land to the Director of Land Management. It is also not in dispute that the
estimate was prepared by the Board in accordance with the existing notification
dated 05.07.2016.
21. In the conspectus of the above discussion, this Court is of the opinion that
the impugned action is unsustainable in law and not in consonance with the
objective of the Act of 2013.
22. Accordingly, the writ petition succeeds and the impugned revised estimate
as contained in the Award dated 14.02.2023 stands interfered with and is set
aside. The Award is accordingly directed to be prepared in accordance with law
by taking the multiplication factor as 1.2, whereafter, expeditious steps be taken
for release of the amount. The aforesaid exercise be undertaken and completed
expeditiously and preferably, within an outer limit of 90 (ninety) days from the
date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
23. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review