Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 24
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on : 31.01.2026
Uploaded on : 03.02.2026
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
Lalit Kumar
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Dhruv Pant, Advocate
Vs
Jammu Development Authority & Ors.
.….Respondents
Through: Mr. Atul Verma, Advocate vice
Mr. Adarsh Sharma, Advocate for R-1
to 3
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA for R-4
CORAM:
01.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Through the medium of the present petition, the
petitioner has challenged order No. Secy/JDA/PS/79596 dated 04.03.2024 passed by the respondent No. 2Vice Chairman, Jammu Development Authority, Jammu,
whereby the claim of the petitioner for restoration of his
promotion
to
the
post
of
Assistant
Programmer
(Computer) has been declined. A further direction asking
the respondents to withdraw order No. 230-JDA of 2010
dated 04.10.2010 whereby promotion of the petitioner
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
was kept in abeyance with a direction that consequential
benefits of seniority, pay increments etc., be released in
favour of the petitioner has also been sought by the
petitioner.
02.
Briefly stated, the facts emanating from the pleadings of
the parties are that in terms of an order No. 71-83 dated
25.07.2001 the petitioner along with one Smt. Sunita
Ambardar and three more Computer Assistants was
promoted to the higher scale of Rs. 4000-6000 after
accord of approval by the Departmental Promotion
Committee.
03.
In terms of the order No. 68-72/JDA of 2005 dated
19.11.2005,
order
dated
25.07.2001
(supra)
was
modified and effect of promotion of the petitioner and one
Smt. Jyoti Sharma was given from 13.11.1998. It is
pertinent to mention here that Smt. Sunita Ambardar
who was figuring senior to the petitioner in order dated
25.07.2001 was not given the benefit of retrospective
promotion. On 06.01.2007, in 66th meeting of the Board
of Directors of Jammu Development Authority, a decision
was taken to upgrade one post of Computer Operator
held by the petitioner in the pay scale of Rs. 4000-6000
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
to the post of Assistant Programmer (Computers) in the
pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500 and the petitioner was
adjusted against the said upgraded post in terms of order
dated 28.04.2007 pursuant to the decision of the Board
of Directors.
04.
It seems that order dated 28.04.2007 whereby the
petitioner was adjusted against the upgraded post of the
Assistant
Programmer
(Computers),
came
to
be
challenged by Smt. Sunita Ambardar by way of writ
petition bearing SWP No. 2194/2009 before this Court.
Vide interim order dated 30.11.2009 passed in the said
writ petition, the order dated 28.04.2007 (supra) was
stayed. Pursuant to said interim order, the respondents
issued order No. 230 JDA of 2010 dated 04.10.2010
whereby order dated 28.04.2007 regarding adjustment
of petitioner as Assistant Computer Programmer was
kept in abeyance till further orders.
05.
The writ petition was contested by the respondents by
filing their reply. It seems that Smt. Sunita Ambardar-the
writ
petitioner
in
writ
petition
bearing
SWP
No.
2194/2009 did not pursue the writ petition as a result
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
whereof, the writ petition came to be dismissed for nonprosecution on 24.10.2017.
06.
After the dismissal of the writ petition filed by Smt.
Sunita Ambardar, the petitioner made a representation
before the respondents for restoration of his position as
Assistant Computer Programmer with all consequential
benefits. When the respondents did not take any action
in the matter, the petitioner filed writ petition bearing
WP(C) No. 507/2022 for redressal of his grievance. The
said writ petition came to be disposed of by this Court in
terms
of
order
dated
14.03.2022
whereby
the
respondents were directed to consider the case/claim of
the petitioner as per law and rules applicable within a
period of two months.
07.
Pursuant to the aforesaid direction/order of this Court,
the respondents considered the case of the petitioner and
issued
the
impugned
Secy/JDA/PS/795-96
consideration
dated
order
04.03.2024
No.
thereby
rejecting the claim of the petitioner on the grounds that
the petitioner does not hold eligibility for being promoted
as
Assistant
Computer
Programmer
as
he
is
not
possessing the requisite qualification as laid down in the
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
Jammu
and
Kashmir
Information
Technology
(Subordinate) Service Recruitment Rules, 2016. The
second ground on which the claim of the petitioner has
been rejected is that Smt. Sunita Ambardar figures senior
to the petitioner in the list of Computer Operators under
Information Technology Wing, as such, he cannot be
accorded
promotion
over
and
above
Smt.
Sunita
Ambardar.
08.
The
petitioner
has
challenged
the
impugned
consideration order on the ground that the same is
contrary to the stand taken by them in the objections
filed to the writ petition of Smt. Sunita Ambardar. It has
been further contended that the order of promotion dated
28.04.2007 passed in favour of the petitioner was issued
on the basis of approval accorded by the Board of
Directors and once the writ petition filed by Smt. Sunita
Ambardar
was
dismissed,
the
order
whereby
the
promotion of the petitioner was kept in abeyance was
required to be withdrawn by the respondents. It has
further been contended that the Jammu and Kashmir
Information
Technology
(Subordinate)
Service
Recruitment Rules, 2016 are not applicable to the
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
employees of the respondent-authority and in any case,
the said rules came into operation after the petitioner had
been promoted to the post of Assistant Computer
Programmer in the year 2007. It has been also contended
that once the effect to the promotion of the petitioner to
the higher grade in terms of an order dated 25.07.2001
was given retrospective effect without according the
similar benefit to Smt. Sunita Ambardar, the petitioner
ranked senior to her, as such, the stand taken by the
respondents is not tenable.
09.
The writ petition has been contested by the respondents
by filing their reply. In their reply, it has been submitted
that recruitment rules relating to the post of Assistant
Computer Programmer have not been finalized as yet but
as per the recruitment rules of Information Technology
Department, a person holding the post of Assistant
Computer Programmer, which has been re-designated as
Junior System Engineer, must possess the bachelor
degree of Engineering/B.Tech with two years experience
from AICTE recognized institute and the mode of
recruitment is 100% by direct recruitment. It has been
further submitted that in draft of the recruitment rules of
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
the respondent-authority, the same qualification has
been proposed and the mode of recruitment has been
prescribed as deputation from the Jammu and Kashmir
Information Technology Department. The other factual
aspects of the case have not been disputed by the
respondents.
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
11.
As already stated above, so far as the factual aspects of
the case are concerned, the same are not in dispute. The
first ground on which the respondents have rejected the
claim of the petitioner is that he does not hold the
requisite qualification to man the post of Assistant
Computer Programmer which has been re-designated as
Junior System Engineer in terms of Jammu and Kashmir
Information
Technology
(Subordinate)
Service
Recruitment Rules, 2016 inasmuch as that eligibility
condition for holding said post is possession of bachelor’s
degree in Engineering/B.Tech, Information Technology or
Electronics
and
Communication
or
Computer
Engineering or Computer Science Engineering or MCA
from recognized University or Diploma in Engineering
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
with
two
years
experience
from
AICTE
recognized
institute and that mode of recruitment is 100% by direct
recruitment. It is case of the respondents that they have
framed draft rules on the same lines and because the
petitioner does not possess the requisite qualification he
cannot
claim
promotion
to
the
post
of
Assistant
Computer Programmer.
12.
In the above context, it is to be noted that the petitioner
was promoted to the post of Assistant Computer
Programmer in the year 2007. The Jammu and Kashmir
Information
Technology
(Subordinate)
Service
Recruitment Rules came to be framed in the year 2016
and were notified vide SRO No. 341 dated 24.10.2016.
It is only thereafter that the respondent-authority framed
its draft of rules. Thus, at the time when the petitioner
was considered for promotion to the post of Assistant
Programmer
(Computers)
neither
the
Jammu
and
Kashmir Information Technology (Subordinate) Service
Recruitment Rules, 2016, were in existence nor the draft
rules
framed
by
the
respondent-authority
were
in
operation. The eligibility of the petitioner for promotion to
the post of Assistant Programmer (Computers) has to be
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
determined
on
the
basis
of
the
rules/guidelines/instructions that were in vogue in the
year 2007 and not those which came into being later on.
13.
It is not a case where the petitioner is to be considered
afresh for grant of promotion to the post of Assistant
Programmer (Computers) but it is a case where he had
already been granted promotion to the said post by virtue
of order dated 28.04.2007 (supra) that was kept in
abeyance pursuant to interim directions passed by this
Court in SWP No. 2194/2011 filed by Smt. Sunita
Ambardar. Once the said writ petition came to be
dismissed, the interim order dated 30.11.2009 passed in
the said writ petition stood vacated and the cloud over
the promotion order of the petitioner vanished. The
necessary logical consequence, upon dismissal of writ
petition filed by Smt. Sunita Ambardar, was that
promotion order dated 28.04.2007 issued in favour of the
petitioner would get revived. The respondents instead of
reviving the said order continued to deny the rightful
claim of the petitioner for years together and compelled
the petitioner to resort to two further rounds of litigation.
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
The conduct of the respondents in this regard is contrary
to the legal position and it defies the logic.
14.
The second ground on which the respondents have
rejected the claim of the petitioner is that he was figuring
inferior in rank in the seniority list of Computer
Operators to the rank of Smt. Sunita Ambardar therefore,
even if, promotion is to be accorded to the post of
Assistant Programmer (Computers), the claim of Smt.
Sunita Ambardar is superior to the claim of the
petitioner.
15.
In the above context, it is to be noted that though, Smt.
Sunita Ambardar ranks superior in the seniority list to
the petitioner in order dated 25.07.2001 (supra) whereby
they were accorded higher grade, yet the said order has
been given retrospective effect by the
respondent-
authority in terms of its subsequent order dated
19.11.2005 in the case of petitioner but not in the case of
Smt. Sunita Ambardar. Thus, the petitioner is deemed to
have been promoted in the higher grade w.e.f 13.11.1998
whereas no such retrospective effect was given to Smt.
Sunita Ambardar. This action of respondent-authority
has made the petitioner senior to Smt. Sunita Ambardar.
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
Thus, the contention of the respondents that Smt. Sunita
Ambardar is senior to the petitioner is contrary to their
own record.
16.
Apart from the above, in the writ petition filed by Smt.
Sunita Ambardar, the respondents in their reply have
justified accord of promotion to the post of Assistant
Programmer. They cannot now take a U-turn and take a
stand contrary to what they had stated in the previous
round of litigation. In law, the official respondents are
estopped from doing so.
17.
For what has been discussed herein before, the impugned
order No. Secy/JDA/PS/795-96 dated 04.03.2024
passed by the respondent No. 2-Vice Chairman, Jammu
Development Authority, Jammu whereby the claim of the
petitioner has been rejected is not sustainable in law and
the same deserves to be quashed.
18.
Accordingly, the writ petition is
impugned
order
No.
allowed and the
Secy/JDA/PS/795-96
dated
04.03.2024 issued by the respondent No. 2 is quashed
and a direction is issued to the respondents to revive the
promotion
order
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
No.
Secy/JDA/P/293-95
dated
28.04.2007 issued by respondent No. 2 whereby the
petitioner has been adjusted against the upgraded post of
Assistant Programmer (Computers). The respondents are
also directed to release all consequential benefits to the
petitioner. The entire exercise shall be completed by the
respondents within a period of two months from today.
19.
Disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
31.01.2026
SUNIL
Whether the order is speaking ?
Whether the order is reportable ?
WP(C) No. 1243/2024
:
:
Yes
No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review