Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 103432 OF 2024
(482(CR.PC)/528(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench.
1.
LAKSHMANAN GANESHAN S/O. LATE M.R. LAKSHMANAN
AGE. MAJOR, OCC. ASST. MANAGER,
R/O. NO.368-A, RUKMINI SADANA,
2ND CROSS, (RIGHT) M.V. NAGAR,
KOPPAL ROAD, BALLARI-583101.
2.
T. BHEEMANNA S/O. LATE THIMMAPPA
AGE. 54 YEARS, OCC. ASST. MANAGER,
SHANKARGOUDA POLICE HOUSE,
3RD CROSS LEFT, KALIDAS NAGAR,
KOPPAL, KARNATAKA-583231.
3.
G.R. LAWHALE S/O. R.P. LAWHALE
AGE. MAJOR, OCC. THE THEN DY. GENERAL MANAGER,
NO.4, SOGONENT,
RAMAKRISHANAPPA ROAD,
NEAR DODEGUNTHA CIRCLE,
COX TOWN, BENGALURU-560008.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. S.V. YAJI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION,
BANK SECURITIES AND FRAUDS CELL,
NO.36, CBI COMPLES, 2ND FLOOR,
BALLARI ROAD, GANGANAGAR,
BENGALURU-560032.
R/BY CENTRAL GOVERNMENT,
STANDING COUNCIL, GROUND FLOOR,
HIGH COURT BUILDING, DHARWAD.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. NEELENDRA D. GUNDE, ADVOCATE)
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482 OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND ALLOW THIS
PETITION AND QUASH THE CHARGE SHEET FILED AGAINST THE
PETITIONERS AS ACCUSED NO.5, 6 AND 7 DATED 26.08.2011 WHICH
IS REGISTERED AT SPL.C.B.I. CC NO.24/2013 BEFORE THE III RD
ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS SPECIAL JUDGE DHARWAD, FOR THE
OFFENCE PUNISHABLE U/S 120B R/W 420, 467, 468, 471 AND 511 OF
IPC AND SECTION 7, 13(2), R/W 13(1) (D) OF PC ACT, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
Heard Sri.S.V.Yaji, learned counsel for the petitioners
and Sri.Neelendra D. Gunde, learned counsel for the
respondent/Central Bureau of Investigation (hereinafter
‘CBI’ for short).
2.
are
Present petitioners are accused Nos.5 to 7 who
Deputy
General
Manager,
Cashier
and
Assistant
Manager of Union Bank of India who have been charge
sheeted for the offences punishable under Section 120B
read with Section 420, 467, 468 and 471 of Indian Penal
Code.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
3.
They
have
approached
this
Court
with
the
following prayer by filing a petition under Section 482 of
Cr.P.C.:
“Wherefore, it is humbly prayed that this Hon’ble
Court may kindly be pleased to call for the records
and be pleased to allow this petition and quash the
charge
sheet filed against the
petitioners as
accused No.5, 6, and 7 dated 26.08.2011 which is
registered at Spl. CBI CC No.24/2013 before the
IIIrd Addl. District and Sessions Special Judge
Dharwad for the offence punishable under Section
120B read with 420, 467, 468, 471 and 511 of IPC
and Section 7, 13(2) R/w 13(1)(D) of PC Act in the
interest of justice and equity.”
4.
Facts in the nutshell which are utmost necessary
for disposal of the present petition are as under:
4.1.
Accused No.8 filed an application for sanction of
loan with the Union Bank of India, Ballary Branch.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
4.2.
Loan application was serviced and as against the
security of the immovable property, loans were being
sanctioned at different interval of time.
4.3.
Loan
account
was
serviced
without
proper
sanction from the Board, as the branch did not have the
power to sanction the loan amount beyond the branch limit.
Therefore, the loan request was recommended by the
branch to the higher authorities.
4.4.
It is alleged that the loan became irregular and
at that juncture, an internal enquiry was held in the bank by
the Vigilance Department of the Union Bank of India and
they found lot of irregularities in servicing the loan request
of accused No.8 and filed a report.
4.5.
Based on the report, the Board of Union Bank of
India decided to initiate criminal action against accused
No.8 and other employees of the Union Bank of India who
have all recommended the loan and present petitioners who
are not named as accused in the FIR were arraigned as
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
accused Nos.5 to 7 in the charge sheet after collecting
necessary materials that they are also responsible for the
illegal servicing of the loan request of accused No.8.
4.6.
In the meantime, the recovery proceedings were
also initiated for the amounts that were due to the Union
Bank of India and accused No.8 opted for the one time
settlement scheme and it is submitted that entire loan
amount is now settled and as such, there is no civil liability.
4.7.
After the charge sheet came to be filed, learned
Special Judge took cognizance of the offences alleged
against the accused persons and registered a criminal case
and proceeded with the same.
5.
An Application seeking discharge of the present
petitioners came to be filed under Section 239 of Cr.P.C.
Same was opposed by the CBI by filing written objections.
6.
Learned
Trial
Judge
after
considering
the
objections, filed by the CBI, dismissed the application filed
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
by the present petitioners by order dated 08.08.2024 inter
alia holding in paragraph Nos.29 to 34 as under:
“29.
It is allegation against the accused No.7
that,
he
was
working
as
Deputy
General
Manager, Union Bank of India, Regional Office,
Bangalore, but he did not ensure Technical
inspection of Unit to ascertain the technical
feasibility and economic viability, at the time of
sanctioning the term loan. Further he has not
ensured to obtain the cash budget at the time of
sanction, as applicable to seasonal industry. He
has sanctioned short term loan of Rs.225 lakh
without ensuring technical inspection of the unit,
in order to ascertain its commissioning as the
unit was not started its commercial activity at
the time of his sanction leading to diversion of
funds. It is further alleged that, the accused
no.7 had knowledge that, the plant was not in
operational by way of his personal visit, to the
plant and yet he sanctioned subsequent loan
i.e., SOD of Rs.75 lakhs, short term loan of
Rs.225 lakhs and direct loan of Rs.400 lakhs.
30.
By
considering
the
rival
contention
of
accused No.1, 5 to 7 and the prosecution side,
this Court has gone through statements of the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
witnesses,
documents
submitted
along
with
charge sheet.
31. On perusal of the statement of witness No.1
who
has
stated
that,
he
has
conducted
investigation on the various Irregularity in the
account of M/s. Rytu Depot Cold Storage Pvt.
Ltd., during the year 2009. Further stated that,
he
has
registers
verified
and
relevant
other
original
related
vouchers,
documents
and
prepared detailed investigation report, showing
irregularities made in the account of M/s. Rytu
Depot Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd. He has clearly
stated regarding the Irregularities committed by
the accused No.1 while submitting proposal and
did not ensure the technical feasibility and
economic viability. Further witness No.2 who is
Assistant
General
Manager,
Vigilance
Department, Central Office, Mumbai, has stated
regarding the processing of agricultural loan of
Rs.265
lakhs
without
carrying
out
detail
verification regarding technical feasibility and
economic viability of M/s. Rytu Depot Cold
Storage pvt. Ltd.
32. Further the witness No.11 has stated that,
lapses and Irregularities observed by him in the
credit facilities l.e., term loan of Rs. 261.60
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
lakhs SOD(TD) of Rs. 75 lakhs, SIT loan of
Rs.225 lakhs and direct loan of Rs.400 lakhs
disbursed to M/s. Rytu Depot Cold Storage Pvt.
Ltd, Bellary. Further clearly stated that, loan was
not disbursed as per progress work. Limits were
disbursed without conducting proper inspection
and use was never verified by the branch.
33. C.W-14 who is Sr. Branch Manager Union
Bank
of
India,
Bagalkot
Branch,
who
has
conducted internal audit of Bellary branch, he
has submitted in the report that he has observed
regarding
the
deviations
in
the
advances
amounts of M/s. Rytu Depot Cold Storage
private Pvt. Ltd., which were serious issues.
Further stated that, the total work done was
Rs.80 lakhs. Whereas, branch had released
Rs.108.70 lakhs already inclusive of margin.
34. Cw-20 has stated regarding accounts were
not properly monitored, all the three limits were
not
disbursed
without
conducting
proper
inspection even while releasing big amount
disbursement were not properly monitored. End
use was never verified by the branch.”
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
7.
Being aggrieved by the same, accused Nos.5 to 7
have filed the present petition on following grounds:
“The Trial court has failed to consider the facts
that the complaint and FIR is not filed nor
registered
against
the
petitioner.
The
complaint is not filed against the petitioner by
the Bank as there is no evidence in their
inspection and enquiry before lodging the
complaint. However, the charge sheet was
filed without any records and contradictory
statement of the witness.
The learned Sessions Judge has failed and
consider the fact that the prosecution has
failed to produce any oral and documentary
evidence to prove the ingredients of the
commission of offence U/S 7 of the P.C. Act.
It is submitted that the prosecution has
nowhere alleged or produced any document or
statement regarding the illegal gratification
what so ever in cash or kind. Further it is not
alleged or stated before the lower court by the
prosecution that the person who has given the
illegal gratification or received the same.
Absolutely there is no statement or document
to prove or connect the illegal gratification
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
received by the petitioner/Accused in cash or
kind. Therefore, the provisions of P.C. Act is
not attracted.
It is submitted that filing of charge sheet
without any materials for the commission of
offence
under
P.C.
Act
is
arbitrary
and
erroneous. On this count alone the charge
sheet against the petitioners alleging the
commission offence under P.C Act is not
sustainable.
The Prosecution has failed to consider the fact
that the loan pertains to the customer is a
NABARD Sponsored scheme and the unit is
monitored
and
supervised
by
NABARD.
Further the NABARD has release the subsidy
on 20-07-2009. Thus it is evident that the
customer of the Bank has implemented the
project.
Therefore,
the
statement
of
the
witnesses is not sustainable.
That there are no reasonable grounds to
believe that the petitioners have committed
an offence punishable under sections 120B
R/W 420, 467, 468, 471 and 511 of IPC and
Section 7, 13(2), R/W13(1) (D) of PC Act.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
That the petitioners are falsely implicated by
the investigation officer without knowing any
law
of
investigation
on
the
available
documents on record just to harass the
petitioners for the reasons best known to
them. Hence the entire criminal proceedings
are liable to be quashed.
That there was no motive or intention on the
part of the petitioners to commit the alleged
offence punishable under section 120B R/W
420, 467, 468, 471 and 511 of IPC and
Section 7, 13 (2), R/W 13 (1) (D) of PC Act.
That this Hon'ble High Court be please to
permit
the
petitioners
to
raise
any
new
grounds for arguments at the time of hearing.
The Investigation Authority and the Court
below has failed to consider the fact that the
prosecution/C.B.I. has not stated about the
forgery of the document and the manner in
which the documents are forged that of the
original
document.
It
is
submitted
that
whatever the documents submitted by the
customer of the Bank was sent to the Regional
Office for sanction of the loan. The Regional
Office has considered the proposal of the loan
and
sanctioned
the
same
without
any
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
alteration
of
the
documents
in
the
file.
Therefore, the charge leveled against the
petitioner for commission of the offence under
sanction 467 of IPC is not attracted.
Even
the
Investigation
Officer
has
not
considered the fact that the officials of the
Bank have not changed or altered any of the
documents pertains to the loan file and
thereby there is no forgery of the documents
for cheating. Hence the charge sheet U/S 468
of IPC is worthless. The lower court has erred
in considering the same.
The Investigation Officer has not considered
the records pertains to the charge U/S 471 of
IPC pertains to the using a forged document
as Genuine document. The Prosecution/CBI
has not stated in the charge sheet and also
documents
being
produced
to
prove
the
forging of the document which was the real or
original document or Genuine Document and
with that of the
forged documents. The
Genuine document or forged documents are
not before the court. The documents which
are produced by the investigation agency is
pertains to loan documents. Hence the charge
U/S 471 of IPC is not applicable.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
The Investigation Agency has filed the charge
sheet based on the statement made by the
officers of other bank and further without
appreciating
the
fact
that
the
bank
or
management has not doubted or suspected
the petitioners in commission of any offence.
Therefore, the charge sheet is deserves to be
quash.
The CBI has not collected the document nor
produced before the Trial Court as to the
function
and
duties
to
entrusted
to
the
petitioners in the bank and there is no
document as to the entrustment to the work.
The Prosecution has not appreciated and
considered the fact that the processing of the
loan
application,
recommendation,
disbursement of the Joan is at the branch end.
The Manager is the Head of the Branch and he
has to take the decision. Each and every
witness have stated about the duties and
function of the Manager who is the head of the
Branch and these petitioners are no-way
concerned about the same. Consequently, the
charge sheet against the petitioners is not
sustainable.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
The document produced by the Prosecution is
evident that whatever the objection raised by
the audit unit was rectified and the earlier
report was recalled as it is based on the false
information or report without any basis.
The Trial Court ought to have discharge the
petitioners
considering
the
development
during the pendency of the proceedings such
as settlement of account, closer of the loan
account and issue of no dues certificate. Thus,
it is evident that the matter was not consider
seriously by the management.
The
Prosecution
has
not
appreciated
or
considered the fact that the market value of
the properties assessed by the PWD Engineer
worth Rs.8.27 Lacks as against the liability of
Rs. 5.29 Lacks as on 14.06.2010. Therefore,
there is no diversion of funds and under
valuation of the property.
The CBI has not considered the fact that the
sanction of the loan by the accused no. 7 is
not unilateral and it is a decision by the
committee
consisting
of
3-4
officers
of
different departments and sanctioning of the
loan is by a common decision based on the
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
records. Therefore, the charges against these
petitioners is without any evidence.
The
Prosecution
has
not
considered
and
care
taken
by
the
the
loan
by
appreciated
the
fair
petitioners
while
sanctioning
imposing additional conditions which are in his
hand writing dated 30.04.2009.
The petitioners have acted in good faith
without any lapse and taken the decision
diligently to approve the loan based on the
recommendation by the branch head, duly
vetted credit department and recommendation
of the credit grid. Hence, the decision of the
petitioners is beyond suspicion.
The charge sheet filed by CBI against the
petitioners
is
contrary
to
the
decision,
guidelines and directions of the Apex Court
and this Hon'ble Court.
The Lower Court has failed to consider the fact
that the charge sheet filed later against this
petitioner alleging the commission of the
offence.
A. As
he
did
not
ensure
technical
inspection of the unit to ascertain the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
technical
feasibility
and
economic
viability at the time of sanction of the
loan.
B. He has sanctioned the loan when the
company
has
not
started
its
commercial operation.
C. He has not ensured to obtain the cash
budget at the time of sanction of the
loan applicable to seasonal industry.
D. Granting of additional loan when the
earlier
account
operation
was
not
satisfactory.
E. The
loan
was
sanctioned
without
ensuring the technical inspection and
diversion of funds. He has sanctioned
the loan when the plant was not in
operation.
The Lower Court has erred in considering the
fact that the subordinate officials of the Bank
have
processed
inspection
report
the
was
file
and
made
technical
and
the
petitioners have approved the same on the
bases of the note and report made by the
subordinate. It is very clearly from the records
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
that the commercial operation of the unit was
commenced and additional loan was made on
secured
asset.
The
budget
including
the
balance sheet was made available in the file.
It is further evident in the records that the
special report was later which drawn as in
correct. The industrial unit has commenced
the activities in the presence of the public.
The Lower Court has failed to consider the fact
that the NABARD has released the subsidy to
the industrial unit only it has commenced the
operation. Hence the Lower Court without
considering the documents and appreciating
the materials placed has wrongly rejected the
application
instead
of
discharging
the
petitioners which has resulted in miscarriage
of justice.
The Lower Court has not considered the fact
that in the enquiry made by the Bank the
petitioners were discharged.
The decisions of the Apex Court sighted during
the course of the arguments is not considered
and appreciated in proper perspective.
In alternative the petitioners prays that the
order
of
the
learned
Sessions
Judge
in
rejecting the application for discharge U/S 227
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
of Cr.P.C may kindly be set a- side and they
may be discharged by exercising the inherent
jurisdiction as the order is contrary to law and
true facts of the case.”
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioners reiterating
the grounds urged in the petition vehemently contended
that the present petitioners were not shown as accused
persons in the FIR and without there being any material
evidence
placed
on
record,
they
have
been
falsely
implicated in the charge sheet as accused Nos.5 to 7
resulting in not only abuse of process of law but also
miscarriage of justice.
9.
He would also contend that the role assigned to
the present petitioners is not specific and charge sheet
materials are highly insufficient to establish prima facie
nexus between the petitioner and the alleged crime.
10.
He would further contend that accused No.5
being the Deputy General Manager of Union Bank of India
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
was only a recommendatory authority and he has no role
whatsoever in the alleged fraud.
11.
Insofar as petitioner No.2 is concerned, he is
only a cashier and therefore, no overt act would be
attributed per se in the alleged fraud as he had no role to
play in sanctioning of loan or disbursement thereof.
12.
Insofar as petitioner No.3 is concerned, learned
counsel for the petitioner would submit that he is only
Assistant Manager of Union Bank of India and he had no
independent power either to recommend the loan or
disburse the loan and he was acting under the directions of
the official superiors. Therefore, per se he cannot be held
liable for any of the charges as is found in the charge sheet
and thus, sought for allowing the petition.
13.
He
would
also
contend
that
the
limit
was
sanctioned by the Board and thereafter, servicing of the
loan as and when accused No.8 made a request to the
branch was serviced by following the requisite established
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
procedure and therefore, no criminality could be attributed
to the present petitioners.
14.
He would also contend that since accused No.8
has now repaid the entire outstanding amount by availing
one time settlement scheme, civil liability is totally cleared
and under such circumstances, continuation of the criminal
case is nothing but futile exercise as is held by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of N.S.Gnaneshwaran Etc. v.
Inspector of Police and Another reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1257.
15.
He would invite the attention of this Court to
paragraph Nos.6 to 10 of the said judgment which is culled
out hereunder for ready reference:
“6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the
respondents contends that the settlement of
dues or compromise between the parties does
not automatically warrant quashing of criminal
proceedings when serious allegations involving
fraud and criminal conspiracy are made out. It is
submitted that the existence of a prima facie
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
case is sufficient to warrant trial and that private
settlements should not interfere with criminal
prosecution, especially at an advanced stage.
7. Having considered the submissions of both
sides and examined the record, we are of the
view that no useful purpose would be served by
continuing
the
criminal
proceedings
in
the
present matter. The dispute has, admittedly,
culminated
in
a
comprehensive
One
Time
Settlement under which the Bank has received
the entire outstanding amount. The recovery
proceedings
before
the
tribunal
have
been
dismissed as settled, and no residual claim
survives. The Bank has not raised any objection
to the closure of the matter and has issued
formal acknowledgments of satisfaction.
8. Further, in identical proceedings filed by the
CBI against the appellants in C.C. Nos. 13 of
2006 and 151 of 2010, the charge sheets were
quashed by the High Court after taking note of
the
settlement
proceedings.
reached
The
in
special
the
recovery
leave
petitions
preferred by the State being SLP (Crl) No. 711
of
and
SLP
(Crl)
No.
of
challenging the said quashing were dismissed by
this Court, rendering the orders final. Since the
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
facts and legal position are the same in the
present matter, we see no reason why the
appellants should not be given the same relief.
9. In our view, allowing the present criminal
proceedings
to
continue
meaningful
purpose,
would
serve
no
particularly
when
the
dispute between the parties has already been
resolved through a full and final settlement. The
settlement between the parties having taken
place
after
the
alleged
commission
of
the
offence, and there being no continuing public
interest we see no justification for allowing the
matter to proceed further.
10. In view of the above discussion, we find it
appropriate to quash the proceedings pending in
C.C. No. 16 of 2006 against the appellants
herein. Consequently, the appeals are allowed.”
16.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent/CBI
would support the impugned order of rejection of discharge
application by contending that the investigation agency has
collected all necessary materials to arraign the present
petitioners as accused Nos.5 to 7.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
17.
He would further contend that it is the Assistant
Manager of the Branch who has to process the application
and petitioner No.2 being the cashier who claims that he
had no role in the application, has counter signed the
application and petitioner No.1 being the Deputy General
Manager
without
even
considering
the
flaw
in
the
application, recommended to the higher authorities whereby
prima facie all of them are responsible for the alleged fraud
and therefore, sought for rejection of the petition.
18.
He would further contend that at the time of
considering the discharge application, material collected by
the prosecution alone to be considered as is held in the case
of State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi reported in
2005 (1) SCC 568.
Therefore, any other documents
cannot be considered by the Court and therefore, no
additional documents can be considered by the Trial Court
or by this Court while considering the request of the
petitioner and sought for dismissal of the petition.
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
19.
Having heard the arguments of both the sides,
this Court perused the material on record meticulously.
20.
On such perusal of the material on record, prima
facie materials collected in the form of charge sheet by the
investigation agency based on the internal enquiry report of
the very same officials of the Union Bank of India, it is
found that the loan request made by accused No.8, is
serviced by
the
bank
without
following the requisite
procedure and the guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of
India
which
would
govern the
day
to
day
activities
especially in the matter of sanctioning of loan.
21.
Further, there is no rule that the additional
accused persons cannot be arraigned while filing the charge
sheet whose names have not found in the FIR.
22.
If additional accused persons are involved in the
crime, it is always open for the Investigation Officer to
arraign them as additional accused persons. Therefore, the
contentions urged on behalf of the petitioners that the
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
present petitioners are not named in the FIR and therefore,
filing of the charge sheet against them is per se incorrect
cannot be countenanced in law.
23.
Further, this Court is not required to hold a mini
trial to find out respective individual overt acts committed
by the petitioners in the alleged crime.
24.
It is always open for the petitioners herein to
place such necessary material before the Trial Court in
accordance with law to prove their innocence.
25.
Prima
facie
materials
collected
by
the
investigation agency especially the loan application and
related papers wherein the signatures of the present
petitioners are found, would be sufficient enough to frame
the charge against the present petitioners.
26.
Now, adverting to the decision relied on by the
learned counsel for the petitioners is concerned, no doubt,
in a case where the civil liability is settled between the
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
parties and prima facie there is no criminality involved in a
given case and it is only a irregularity in sanctioning the
loan, the criminal matters can be put to end as continuation
of the same would only result in futile exercise.
27.
There is a clear and subtle difference between
irregularity and illegality though it is separated by a very
thin line. An irregularity can be condoned but an illegality
cannot be condoned.
28.
View of this Court, in this regard is supported by
the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Gian
Singh v. State of Punjab reported in (2012) 10 SCC
303.
29.
Further, the principles of law enunciated in the
case of Gian Singh supra is reiterated by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Anil Bhavarlal Jain and Another v.
State of Maharastra and Others reported in 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3823.
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
Relevant paragraph in this regard is culled out
30.
hereunder:
“14. This Court in Gian Singh (supra) has dealt
with
the
powers
of
the
High
Court
under
Section 482 r/w Section 320 of the CrPC and the
consequent authority of the High Court to quash
criminal proceedings, FIRs or complaints under its
inherent jurisdiction as in contradistinction to the
power
with
criminal
courts
for
compounding
offenses under Section 320 of the CrPC. The High
Court observed that quashing was dependent on
the unique circumstances of each case and though
no fixed category can be established, heinous and
severe offences should not be quashed even if the
parties have settled. However, this Court in Gian
Singh (supra) categorically made an observation
that:
“61. …….. The offences of mental depravity
under the Penal Code, 1860 or offences of moral
turpitude under special statutes like Prevention of
Corruption Act or the offences committed by the
public servants while working in that capacity, the
settlement between offender and victim can have
no legal sanction at all.”
16. Another reference can be made to the
judgment of this Court in Parbatbhai Aahir v. State
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
of Gujrat8 wherein it was observed that, economic
offenses involving financial and economic wellbeing of the state have implications which lie
beyond the domain of a mere dispute between the
private disputants. The High Court would be
justified in declining to quash where the offender is
involved in an activity akin to a financial or
economic
fraud
or
misdemeanour.
The
consequences of the act complained of upon the
financial or economic system will weigh in the
balance. Thus, it can be concluded that economic
offences by their very nature stand on a different
footing
than
other
offences
and
have
wider
ramifications.
They
constitute
a
class
apart.
Economic offences affect the economy of the
country as a whole and pose a serious threat to
the financial health of the country. If such offences
are viewed lightly, the confidence and trust of the
public will be shaken.
18. In the instant case, it is on record that
consent terms were submitted by the parties before
the DRT. It is admitted that the bank had suffered
losses to the tune of Rs. 6.13 Crores approximately.
Hence, a substantial injury was caused to the public
exchequer and consequently it can be said that public
interest has been hampered. Keeping in view the fact
that in the present case a special statute i.e. PC Act
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:668
CRL.P No. 103432 of 2024
HC-KAR
has been invoked, we are of the view that quashing
of offences under the said Act would have a grave
and substantial impact not just on the parties
involved, but also on the society at large. As such the
High Court committed no error in declining to
exercise its inherent powers in the present case,
thereby refusing to quash the criminal proceedings.”
31.
Thus, the decision relied on by the learned
counsel for the petitioner would not advance the case of the
petitioners in setting aside the order of rejection of the
discharge application.
32.
Hence, following:
ORDER
i.
Petition is meritless and hereby dismissed.
ii.
However, all the defences available to the
petitioners are kept open to be canvassed
before the Trial Court in accordance with
law.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
KAV, CT:CMU
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 0
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review