Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
Digitally
signed by
SISTA
SOMAYAJULU
SISTA
SOMAYAJULU Date:
2026.02.18
18:05:24
+0530
2026:CGHC:8680-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1943 of 2019
{Arising out of judgment dated 28-6-2014 in Sessions Trial No.343/2012
of the 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Ambikapur, District Surguja}
Judgment reserved on: 15-1-2026
Judgment delivered on: 18-2-2026
Judgment (Full) uploaded on: 18-2-2026
Lakhan Ram, S/o Motiram Gond, Aged about 27 years, R/o Village
Jhirmitti, P.S. Udaipur, District Sarguja, Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant
versus
State of Chhattisgarh, through the Police Station Udaipur, District Sarguja,
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent
For Appellant
: Mr. Saurabh Dangi, Advocate.
For Respondent
: Mr. Vivek Mishra, Panel Lawyer.
Division Bench: Hon'ble Shri Sanjay K. Agrawal and
Hon'ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, JJ.
C.A.V. Judgment
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.
1. The appellant herein has preferred this criminal appeal under
Section 374(2) of the CrPC against the impugned judgment of
conviction & order of sentence dated 28-6-2014 passed by the 3 rd
Additional Sessions Judge, Ambikapur, District Surguja in Sessions
Trial No.343/2012, by which he has been convicted for offence under
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
Section 302 of the IPC and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for
life and further sentenced to pay a fine of ₹ 500/-, in default of
payment of fine to further undergo additional rigorous imprisonment
for three months.
2. The appeal filed by the appellant came up for hearing before this
Court on 16-12-2019 and this Court directed to call for the records of
the trial Court and list the matter after six weeks. However, when the
matter again came up for hearing on 29-6-2021, the Assistant Record
Keeper of the concerned District & Sessions Judge, Ambikapur has
informed that record has been misplaced and this Court by order
dated 29-6-2021 directed to reconstruct the record. This Court again
on 15-11-2021, directed the Sessions Judge, Ambikapur to hold
enquiry and submit report as to whether responsibility has been fixed
for misplacing the record and what efforts have been taken to trace
out the record. Further, this Court on 15-11-2021, also directed the
Director (Prosecution) to file a detailed affidavit regarding what steps
can be taken for reconstructing the record.
The Director
(Prosecution) on 24-11-2021, submitted its report that relevant
documents have been forwarded to the Office of the Advocate
General on 31-12-2014 and 1-1-2015, however, on 16-8-2021, they
sought documents from the office of the Advocate General upon
which they were informed that since no appeal was filed, therefore,
now, the records have become untraceable.
Thereafter, on 11-5-
2022, this Court directed the respective counsel for the parties to
suggest ways and means to be adopted regarding reconstruction of
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
the records of the original criminal case so that the criminal appeal
can be heard. Ultimately, on 27-7-2022, the State has filed certified
true copy of the final report bearing No.70/2012 in which following
documents have been made available: 1. Final Report
2. Memorandum Statement of the Accused (Ex.P-8)
3. Property Seizure Memo (Ex.P-10 – soil & Ex.P-11 – appellant's
cloth)
4. Crime Details Form
5. Medical Examination of the Accused
6. FIR under Crime No.83/2012 (Ex.P-18)
7. Arrest Memo
8. Section 161 CrPC Statements of Witnesses
9. Merg diary (Ex.P-13A – merg intimation & Ex.P-17 – merg
report)
10. Intimation by Hospital to Police Station
11. Notice for Naksha Panchayatnama
12. Naksha Panchayatnama (Ex.P-2)
13. Application for Postmortem and Postmortem Report (opinion)
(Ex.P-14 – application & Ex.P-15 report)
14. MLC of the deceased
3. Though the aforesaid documents have been made available by the
prosecution and as such, most of the records are available except
statements of the prosecution and defence witnesses and exhibited
documents, but appeal cannot be heard, as statements of witnesses
and some documents are not available.
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
4. The question for consideration is, what would be the proper
procedure to be followed in this appeal?
5. Section 386 of the CrPC provides for powers of the Appellate Court.
Clause (b) of Section 386 states as under: “386. Powers of the Appellate Court.—After perusing such
record and hearing the appellant or his pleader, if he appears,
and the Public Prosector, if he appears, and in case of an appeal
under section 377 or section 387, the accused, if he appears, the
Appellate Court may, if it considers that there is no sufficient
ground for interfering, dismiss the appeal, or may—
(a) xxx
xxx
xxx
(b) in an appeal from a conviction—
(i) reverse the finding and sentence and acquit or
discharge the accused, or order him to be re-tried by a
Court of competent jurisdiction subordinate to such
Appellate Court or committed for trial, or
(ii) alter the finding, maintaining the sentence, or
(iii) with or without altering the finding, alter the nature
or the extent, or the nature and extent, of the sentence,
but not so as to enhance the same;
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx
xxx”
6. Under sub-section (2) of Section 385 of the CrPC, it is obligatory on
the part of the appellate Court to peruse the record before deciding
the appeal against an order of conviction.
The conviction of an
accused cannot be confirmed unless the appellate Court peruses the
entire record.
7. The Supreme Court in the matter of State of U.P. v. Abhai Raj
Singh and another1 has held that where that is not possible
1 (2004) 4 SCC 6
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
because of circumstances like destruction of the records, the proper
course for the appellate court would be to direct retrial after
reconstruction of the records, and observed as under: “6. The powers of the appellate court when dealing with an
appeal from a conviction are delineated in sub-clauses (i), (ii)
and (iii) of clause (b) of Section 386 of the Code. The appellate
court is empowered by Section 386 to reverse the finding and
sentence and acquit. Therefore, the acquittal is possible when
there is reversal of the finding and sentence. The appellate
court is also empowered to discharge the accused. The third
category which seems to be applicable to the present case is a
direction for retrial by a court of competent jurisdiction
subordinate to the appellate court or committed for trial. For
exercise of the powers in cases of first two categories, obviously
a finding on merits after consideration of the materials on
record is imperative. Where that is not possible because of
circumstances like the case at hand i.e. destruction of the
records, the proper course for the appellate court would be to
direct retrial after reconstruction of the records if in spite of
positive and constructive efforts to reconstruct the records the
same was impossible. If on the other hand, from the copies
available with the prosecuting agency or the defence and/or
their respective counsel, reconstruction is possible to be made,
the said course should be adopted and the appeal can be
disposed of as it deserved under the course indicated in subclauses (i) and (ii). After perusal of the records and hearing the
appellant's pleader and Public Prosecutor under Section 377 or
378, the exercise of power as indicated above can be resorted
to. As was observed in Bani Singh v. State of U.P.2 the plain
language of Section 385 makes it clear that if the appellate
court does not consider the appeal fit for summary dismissal, it
must call for the records and Section 386 mandates that after
record is received, the appellate court may dispose of the
appeal after hearing as indicated.”
8. Similarly, in the matter of Jitendra Kumar Rode v. Union of
India3, the Supreme Court has held that the “procedure established
by law” in a criminal prosecution is a sacrosanct requirement, and
observed as under: 2 (1996) 4 SCC 720 : 1996 SCC (Cri) 848
3 (2024) 11 SCC 559
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
“24. One of the earlier cases on this issue is the judgment of
the Allahabad High Court in Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh4,
wherein the District Judge failed to trace or discover the lost
records. The Court observed that this loss of records has lost
the appellant, a right he is entitled to, that of hearing by a
higher court. In such situations, no other recourse remains
than to order trial de novo. The judgment in Khimat Singh4
has been followed by this Court in Abhai Raj Singh1.”
9. In the matter of Bani Singh and others v. State of U.P. 5, the
Supreme Court has considered the meaning and scope of Section
385(2) of the CrPC and held as under: “8. Section 385(2) clearly states that if the appellate court
does not dismiss the appeal summarily, it ‘shall’, after issuing
notice as required by sub-section (1), send for the record of the
case and hear the parties. The proviso, however, posits that if
the appeal is restricted to the extent or legality of the sentence,
the court need not call for the record. On a plain reading of the
said provision, it seems clear to us that once the appellate
court, on an examination of the grounds of appeal and the
impugned judgment, decides to admit the appeal for hearing, it
must send for the record and then decide the appeal finally,
unless the appeal is restricted to the extent and legality of the
sentence. Obviously, the requirement to send for the record is
provided for to enable the appellate court to peruse the record
before finally deciding the appeal. It is not an idle formality but
casts an obligation on the court to decide the appeal only after
it has perused the record. This is not to say that it cannot be
waived even where the parties consent to its waiver. This
becomes clear from the opening words of Section 386 which
say that “after perusing such record” the court may dispose of
the appeal.
However, this section imposes a further
requirement of hearing the appellant or his pleader, if he
appears, and the public prosecutor, if he appears. This is an
extension of the requirement of Section 385(1) which requires
the court to cause notice to issue as to the time and place of
hearing of the appeal. Once such a notice is issued the accused
or his pleader, if he appears, must be heard.”
10. Coming to the facts of the case, it is quite vivid that in view of the
finding recorded by this Court on 29-6-2021, the original records
4 Queen Empress v. Khimat Singh, 1889 All WN 55
5 AIR 1996 SC 2439
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
have already been lost and it has been directed for reconstruction of
the records. As such, though the records have been reconstructed
except statements of witnesses, prosecution and defence and some
other documents as well, it would not be possible to hear the appeal
arrive at a conclusion that the impugned judgment passed and
sentence awarded against the appellant is legally justified and in
conformity with law. Therefore, it is not legally permissible for this
Court to affirm the conviction of the appellant since perusal of the
complete record of the case is one of essential elements of hearing of
the appeal. The appellant has a right to satisfy the appellate Court
that the material or evidence available on record did not justify his
conviction and this right cannot be denied to the appellant. Since the
State has submitted documents containing all the material
documents, except statements (prosecution and defence) in light of
the decision of the Supreme Court in Abhai Raj Singh’s case
(supra) followed in Jitendra Kumar Rode (supra), it would be
expedient to set aside the impugned judgment of conviction and
order of sentence and direct for retrial of the appellant. It is ordered
accordingly and the appeal is allowed. Records as filed on 27-7-2022
shall be sent to the trial Court in a closed envelope keeping the
photocopy of the same. The trial Court would do well to conclude the
retrial within six months as the incident is said to have occurred on
10-8-2012.
11. In that view of the matter, since the appellant is on bail, the bail
bonds of the appellant shall remain in operation for a period of six
(Cr.A.No.1943/2019)
months in view of the provisions contained in Section 437A of the
CrPC.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
Soma
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review