Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:8
Serial No. 02-11
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Date of Hearing: 04.12.2025
Date of Decision: 28.01.2026
WP(C) No.174 of 2024
Smti. Baiantimon Blah
Daughter of Late Shri. B. Swer
Resident of Wahingdoh Block 3,
Shillong-793001, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Dr. Twinkle Suhasini R. Marak, MCS
Deputy Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department &
Joint Director, Meghalaya Administrative Training Institute
(MATI), mawdiangdiang, Meghalaya-793018
4. Dr. Wilford Challang R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South Garo Hills District, Baghmara
5. Smti. Ripamchi N. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
7. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
8. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
2026:MLHC:8
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
9. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
11.Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
12.Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
13.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
14.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
15.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.175 of 2024
Shri Shanborlang Warjri
Son of Shri. G. Speaker Swer,
Resident of Umpling, Dongsharum
Shillong-793006, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
2026:MLHC:8
3. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
4. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
5. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
7. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
8. Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
9. Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
11.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
12.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.176 of 2024
2026:MLHC:8
Shri Ronnieson Wahlang,
Son of Shri. P. Warjri
Resident of Mawlai Mawroh,
Shillong-793008, Meghalaya.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Dr. Twinkle Suhasini R. Marak, MCS
Deputy Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department &
Joint Director, Meghalaya Administrative Training Institute
(MATI), mawdiangdiang, Meghalaya-793018
4. Dr. Wilford Challang R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South Garo Hills District, Baghmara
5. Smti. Ripamchi N. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
7. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
8. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
9. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
2026:MLHC:8
11.Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
12.Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
13.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
14.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
15.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.177 of 2024
Shri. Peter Tremi Passah
Son of (L) F. Laloo
Resident of mooralong Moomon, near K. Rymbai
Petrol Pump, Ladthlaboh, Jowai-793150, Meghalaya.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
4. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
2026:MLHC:8
5. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
6. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
7. Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
8. Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
9. Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
10.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
11.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.178 of 2024
Shri. Ferdinand Banteilang Basan,
Son of Shri. Silverius Syiemlieh
Resident of Mawlai Umshing, Umjapung,
Shillong-793022, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
2026:MLHC:8
3. Dr. Wilford Challang R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South Garo Hills District, Baghmara
4. Smti. Ripamchi N. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
5. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
6. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
7. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
8. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
9. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
10.Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
11.Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
12.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
13.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
14.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
2026:MLHC:8
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.179 of 2024
Smti. Dahunlang Veronica Lyngdoh,
Daughter of Shri Henry Dominic Lakadong,
Resident of Laitkor Rngi, Sohiong A,
House No.8, Shillong Meghalaya.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Dr. Wilford Challang R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South Garo Hills District, Baghmara
4. Smti. Ripamchi N. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
5. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
6. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
7. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
8. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
9. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
2026:MLHC:8
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
10.Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
11.Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
12.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
13.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
14.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.180 of 2024
Shri. Mark Andrew Challam,
Lympyngad, Near MSPCB Office,
Nongthymmai, Shillong-793014, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
4. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
2026:MLHC:8
5. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
7. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
8. Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
9. Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
11.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
12.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.181 of 2024
Smti. Yvette Risa Mawlong, Daughter of
(L) Dr. Lurshai Roi Lyngksor, Resident of
Nongrim Road, Laithumkhrah Shillong-793003
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
2026:MLHC:8
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
4. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
5. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
7. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
8. Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
9. Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
11.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
12.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
2026:MLHC:8
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.182 of 2024
Shri Gautam Warjri
Son of (L) Pankach Mandal
Resident of Majai, Shella-Bholaganj C&RD block
East Khasi Hills District,
Shillong-793107, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
4. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
5. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
7. Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
8. Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
9. Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
2026:MLHC:8
10.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
11.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
12.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
WP(C) No.183 of 2024
Shri Labiangbha Trevor Tariang
Son of Late Dr. M.T. Khyriem
Resident of Mawlai Nonglum, TSS Road, Block-4
Shillong-793008, Meghalaya
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1. State of Meghalaya represented by Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Secretary, Personnel & A.R.(A) Department,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
3. Dr. Twinkle Suhasini R. Marak, MCS
Deputy Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department &
Joint Director, Meghalaya Administrative Training Institute
(MATI), mawdiangdiang, Meghalaya-793018
4. Dr. Wilford Challang R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South Garo Hills District, Baghmara
5. Smti. Ripamchi N. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
6. Shri. Tennystar R. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
2026:MLHC:8
7. Smti. Mary Lisa K. Marak, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
8. Shri. Raymond Zachary D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
South West Garo Hills District, Ampati
9. Shri. Nipon Hajong, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
10.Shri. Jude Rangkhu T. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
North Garo Hills District, Resubelpara
11.Smti. Winje Rosalie G. Momin, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura & ADC I/C Jengjal
Sub-Divison, Jengjal
12.Smti. Prettylisa K. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills District, Tura
13.Smti. Dimseritha A. Sangma, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
East Garo Hills District, Williamnagar
14.Smti. Rojalinda D. Shira, MCS
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Raksamgre (Civil) Sub-Division
15.Smti. Florina Boro, MCS
Additional Resident Commissioner,
Meghalaya House, 9 APJ Abdul Kalam Road,
New Delhi-110011.
…..Respondents
2026:MLHC:8
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Jindal, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, GA
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. A.G. Momin, Adv with
Ms. L.D. Sangma, Adv
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This set of ten writ petitions involving common issue and praying for
same relief is taken up together for disposal on being consented by the
learned counsels appearing for the parties.
2.
The challenge made by the petitioners in all the writ petitions is
against the gradation list dated 22.08.2022, published by the State
respondent wherein the names of the private respondents are placed above
the petitioners. The principal ground raised by the petitioners is that since
they were placed above the private respondents in the select list dated
07.09.2010 prepared in order of merits, their name should have been placed
above the private respondents in the gradation list dated 22.08.2022, in
terms of Rule 16 (4) of the Meghalaya Civil Service Rules, 1975 (herein
after referred to as the MCS Rules).
3.
The relevant facts, as can be derived from the materials on record, is
that pursuant to the advertisement dated 22.11.2006 and holding of
selection process thereof by Meghalaya Public Service Commission
(MPSC) for recruitment to the Meghalaya Civil Services (MCS), a select
list in the descending order of merit was published on 07.09.2010 indicating
2026:MLHC:8
a total of 74 successful candidates. Thereafter, initial appointments of 40
candidates were made to the Junior Grade of MCS on 01.12.2010 in
accordance with the prevailing reservation criteria and merit. A further 11
candidates were appointed as Junior Grade MPS on 08.12.2010 basing also
on the reservation criteria and merits. The validity of the select list dated
07.09.2010 was extended from time to time till 09.05.2012. While the
private respondents in the present case were appointed in the year 2010 to
the Junior Grade of MCS, all the petitioners came to be appointed to the
same post much later in the year 2012 vide notification No.
PER.56/1010/293 dated 08.05.2012.
4.
It is contented on behalf of the petitioners that the gradation list dated
22.08.2022 setting out the seniority of the members of the MCS was
required to have maintained the seniority that was established through the
original merit list dated 07.09.2010. Merely because the private respondents
have received appointment earlier in the year 2010 than the petitioners who
were appointed in the year 2012, cannot be a valid ground for placing the
private respondents above the petitioners in the gradation list. The attempt
of the State-respondent to determine seniority on the basis of appointment
as opposed to determining seniority on the basis of the original merit list, as
required under Rule 16 (4) of the MCS Rules, is against the established
norms of law. The decision dated 26.09.2023 passed in WA No.30 of 2023,
Smt. Krishpilla T. Sangma v. State of Meghalaya has been placed in support
of the above contention.
5.
Per contra, as pointed out on behalf the respondents, it transpires that
the question of inter-se seniority between the petitioners and the private
respondents stood finally adjudicated by this High Court in the common
Judgment dated 10.02.2022 in WP(C) No. 301 of 2018, WP(C) No.302 of
2018 and WP(C) No.306 of 2018 wherein it was specifically held that the
2010 recruits to the entry-level post have to be regarded as senior to the
2026:MLHC:8
2012 recruits to the same entry-level post, irrespective of whatever future
considerations may arise in determining their cases for promotion to the
next level. While coming to the aforesaid conclusion, it was observed in the
said Judgement that the examination was one, but appointments were made
in several tranches; not as a part of the same recruitment process but under
discrete process. The Judgement further held that in 2012 a seniority list
was prepared and, in such list, the persons recruited in the year 2010 and
the persons recruited in the year 2012 were clubbed together for
determination of inter-se seniority among them which was patently absurd
and completely without any element of rationality and logic. It was also
said in the Judgement that when two sets of appointments are so distinct
and different in points of time as in 2010 and 2012, there is no question of
apples and oranges being put in the same basket for the inter-se seniority of
two distinct classes of persons to be attempted to be ascertained.
6.
There is no dispute to the fact that the petitioner and the private
respondents herein were parties to the WP(C) No. 301/302/306 of 2018
and that no challenge was made to the said Judgement dated 10.02.2022
before any higher forum by any of the parties.
7.
The material on record reveals that in terms of the Judgement dated
10.02.2022, a gradation list of the members of the MCS was published and
circulated vide notification No. PER.31/2018/151 dated 04.03.2022 by the
State respondent by placing the private respondents above the petitioners.
Thereafter, the State respondent issued two notifications being Notification
No.
PER.99/90/Pt.I/181
dated
07.03.2022
and
Notification
No.
PER/99/90/Pt.I/223 dated 28.07.2022 promoting some of the members of
the MCS who had been serving in the Junior Grade, including the
petitioners and the private respondents herein, to the Senior Grade Time
Scale of the MCS by placing the private respondents above the petitioners.
The petitioners have not made any challenge to the gradation list dated
2026:MLHC:8
04.03.2022 and the above notifications dated 07.03.2022 and 28.07.2022 in
the present set of writ petitions.
8.
Rule 23 of the MCS Rules, 1975 requires that the seniority of
members of the Service promoted to the Senior Grade Time Scale should be
in the order in which their names are arranged by the Selection Board under
sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 for the purpose of promotion to that grade. In the
present case, there is no grievance raised by the petitioners that the order of
names in the notifications of promotion has not been indicated in
accordance with sub-rule (2) of Rule 22 or that the gradation list dated
22.08.2022 was not prepared in terms of Rule 23 of the MCS Rules. It is,
therefore, clear that the issue raised by the petitioners in the present writ
petitions is essentially with regard to the fixation of seniority in terms of
Rule 16(4) stemming from the select list dated 07.09.2010, which already
stood finally settled by this High Court in the Judgement dated 10.02.2022
rendered in WP(C) No.301/302/306 of 2018. As the decision of a
coordinate bench is binding on the subsequent bench, the issue raised by the
petitioners cannot be re-agitated before this bench. Any order passed at the
instance of the petitioners in the instant matter will have the effect of
interfering with the Judgement dated 10.02.2022. The case laws cited on
behalf of the petitioners, thus, are of no help to the petitioners.
9.
In view of the above, the writ petitions filed by the petitioners cannot
be entertained by this court and the same are hereby dismissed as not
maintainable. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
28.01.2026
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2026.01.28 15:00:27 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review