Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 23.03.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MOHAMMED SHAFFIQ
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
M/s.L.G.Balakrishnan & Bros. Limited
Represented by its Chief Financial Officer,
SF No.195, Kondayampalayam Village, Vaiyampalayam,
Coimbatore-642110.
: Petitioner
Vs.
1.Commisioner of GST & Central Excise,
Coimbatore Division,
No.6/7, A.T.D Street, Race Course Road,
Coimbatore -641 018.
2.Principal Commissioner (RA),
8th Floor, World Trade Centre, Cuffe Parade,
Mumbai-400 005.
: Respondents
PRAYER: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
praying to issue Writ of Certiorari, calling for records relating to impugned
Revision Order No.202/2018-CX(SZ)/ASRA/MUMBAI dated 24.07.2018 passed
by second respondent and quash the same and pass orders.
1/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Petitioner
:
Mr.R.Parthasarathy
For Respondents
:
Mr.K.S.Ramasamy
Central Government Standing Counsel
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
ORDER
The present writ petition has been filed challenging impugned Revision
Order No.202/2018-CX(SZ)/ASRA/MUMBAI dated 24.07.2018 passed by second
respondent.
2. The question that arises for consideration in this writ petition is as to
whether exemption granted vide Notification No.24 of 2003-CE dated 31.03.2003
is conditional or absolute for the purposes of Section 5A(1A) of the Central Excise
Act.
3. Brief facts:
3.1. Petitioner was 100% Export Oriented Unit, (hereinafter referred to as
EOU), manufacturing parts of motor vehicles classified under Tariff sub-heading
number 8708. Petitioner was granted Letter of Permission (LoP) to operate as an
EOU vide Development Commissioner’s letter dated 12.04.2006 subject to terms
and conditions, which inter alia includes:
a) The unit shall export its entire production for a period of 5
years from the date of commencement of production. The unit would
have the option to renew its EOU status or opt out of the scheme as
per the Industrial Policy in force (Clause i);
2/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
b) The unit shall achieve positive Net Foreign Exchange
Earning as prescribed in the EOU scheme for a period of 5 years
(Clause ii);
c) The LoP shall be valid for 3 years from its date of issue
within which the petitioner shall implement the project. The LoP shall
automatically lapse if application for extension of validity is not
made before the end of the said period (Clause vi).
3.2. At the end of 5 year period i.e. 11.04.2011, petitioner opted to withdraw
from EOU Scheme and submitted a letter dated 12.04.2011 to Development
Commissioner requesting de-bonding of EOU. An “in-principle” approval for debonding was granted by Development Commissioner vide letter dated 21.07.2011.
Petitioner paid an amount of Rs.33,27,725/- on 31.05.2011 towards excise duty
pertaining to goods lying in stock as on 31.05.2011 and received no due certificate
from Excise Department on 23.11.2011. A Final Exit Order dated 16.12.2011 came
to be issued by Assistant Development Commissioner of MEPZ.
3.3. It is submitted by petitioner that in the meanwhile on 03.06.2011,
petitioner intimated Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore that
excise duty on goods manufactured for export will henceforth be cleared on
payment of excise duty under claim for rebate.
3/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Exports were then made on
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
payment of duty under claim of rebate by utilizing Cenvat credit. After final exit
order, petitioner filed their claim for rebate sometime in April 2012. Show cause
notice came to be issued proposing to deny rebate claim filed by petitioner inter
alia on the following grounds.
a) Final exit order, effecting de-bonding was only issued on
16.12.2011, till which date petitioner would continue to be 100%
EOU, despite the fact that an in-principle approval was granted
sometime in July 2011.
b) Importantly, in terms of Notification No.24/2003-CE dated
31.03.2003, all excisable goods manufactured in a 100% EOU are
exempt from the whole of excise duty. The exemption in terms of
the above notification is absolute thus in terms of Section 5A(1A) of
the Central Excise Act, 1944, manufacturer of such excisable goods
shall not pay duty on such goods and option is not available to such
manufacturers to remit the duty and claim the benefit of
rebate/refund.
3.4. Petitioner submitted its reply on various dates including 31.08.2012,
18.01.2013 and 08.03.2013 inter alia submitting that 100% EOU license expired
on 11.04.2011 and petitioner ceased to be a 100% EOU since 11.04.2011, thus
exemption vide Notification No.24/2003-CE dated 31.03.2003 is inapplicable in
4/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
respect of goods cleared with effect from 12.04.2011. However, Order in Original
came to be passed confirming the proposal vide order dated 26.04.2013 denying
rebate claimed by petitioner. Aggrieved, petitioner preferred an appeal in Appeal
No.35 of 2013-CEX before the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), who, in
turn confirmed the order of the adjudicating authority denying rebate.
3.5. Petitioner, thereafter, preferred a revision application No.195/999/2013RA-CEX before second respondent. Revision also came to be rejected vide order
dated 24.07.2018 confirming the order in original inter alia on the premise that a
unit goes out of EOU scheme only when the Final Exit Order is given by the
Development Commissioner after obtaining a no-objection certificate from the
jurisdictional Customs and Central Excise authorities.
Resultantly, goods
manufactured and cleared by a 100% EOU till date of final exit order is
unconditionally exempt under Notification No.24/2003-CE dated 31.03.2003.
3.6. It is against the above order of revision, present writ petition has been
filed.
4. Learned counsel for the respondent would reiterate that orders of
authorities below are in accordance with law and does not warrant interference and
would also submit that the exemption granted vide Notification No.24/2003 is
5/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
absolute exemption as would be evident from the fact that there are no conditions
attached except that it must be produced or manufactured by an EOU.
5. Against the above background the primary question that arise for
consideration is whether exemption granted vide Notification No.24/2003 from
excise duty on goods manufactured in 100% EOU is conditional or absolute
exemption;
6. Thus if exemption granted vide Notification No.24/2003 is conditional
and not absolute, then Section 5A(1A) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, may not get
attracted. To understand the scope of the exemption granted vide Notification No.
24 of 2003, it may be necessary to understand the scope of Section 5A(1A) of the
Act and Notification No.24/2003-CE dated 31.03.2003, which read as under:
“5A. Power to grant exemption from duty of excise.—(1) If
the Central Government is satisfied that it is necessary in the
public interest so to do, it may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, exempt generally either absolutely or subject to such
conditions (to be fulfilled before or after removal) as may be
specified in the notification, excisable goods of any specified
description from the whole or any part of the duty of excise
leviable thereon:
Provided that, unless specifically provided in such
notification, no exemption therein shall apply to excisable goods
which are produced or manufactured—
6/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
(i) in a [free trade zone [or a special economic zone] and
brought to any other place in India; or
(ii) by a hundred per cent export-oriented undertaking
and 3 [brought to any other place in India].
Explanation.—In this proviso, [“free trade zone” [special
economic zone] and “hundred per cent export-oriented
undertaking” shall have the same meanings as in Explanation 2
to sub-section (1) of Section 3.
[(1A) For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared
that where an exemption under sub-section (1) in respect of any
excisable goods from the whole of the duty of excise leviable
thereon has been granted absolutely, the manufacturer of such
excisable goods shall not pay the duty of excise on such
goods.]”
7. On a reading of the above provision following position appears to emerge:
a) Central Government is conferred with power to issue
notification in public interest to exempt generally either absolutely or
subject to such conditions to be fulfilled before or after removal as
may be specified in the notification from the whole or any part of the
duty of excise leviable thereon.
b) Proviso to Section 5A of the Act provides that unless the
notification made thereunder, specifically provides, no exemption
shall apply to excisable goods manufactured or produced in 100%
EOU and brought to any other place in India.
c) Power to grant exemption under Section 5A of the Act,
7/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
includes the power to grant exemption either absolutely or subject to
conditions. This would be evident from the use of the expressions
either absolutely or subject to such conditions in Section 5A of the
Act.
d) Sub-section (1A) to Section 5A of the Act, provides that if
exemption granted under Sub Section (1) to Section 5A in respect of
any excisable goods is absolute, then the manufacturer shall not pay
duty of excise of such goods. This provision was inserted with effect
from 13.05.2005 vide Section 75 of the Finance Act, 2005 (18 of
2005) to get over judgments including that of the Supreme Court,
wherein it has been held that assessee can forgo the benefit under an
exemption notifications, some of them being:
i) Narayan Polyplast vs Commissioner of C.Ex. Ahmedabad
reported in 2003 (153) E.L.T.160 (Tri.-Mumbai)
ii) Commission of Cental Excise & Customs (Appeals),
Ahmedabad vs arayan Polyplast and others reported in (2005) 10 SCC
121.
8. While examining whether an exemption is absolute or conditional for the
purpose of Section 5A(1A) of the Act, the expression in respect of “any excisable
goods” employed therein assumes relevance. This would indicate that exemption
8/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
ought to be qua the “goods” and not with reference to a particular class of
manufacture or with reference to circumstance. The nature of exemption ought to
be with reference to “goods”, to qualify as being absolute for the purposes of
Section 5A(1A) of the Act. Secondly, the expression ‘in respect of’ employed in
Section 5A(1A) of the Act, would mean, “in connection with or related to with a
subject which follows”1, in the present case, the expression “in respect of” is
followed by the expression “excisable goods”, thereby making it clear that the
exemption ought to be with reference to “goods”. The other crucial expression is
“absolute” which would mean free from conditions, restrictions or qualifications,
not dependent or modified or affected by circumstances. 2 Therefore, to fall within
Section 5A(1A), it may be necessary for the revenue to demonstrate that exemption
is absolute in respect of a particular class of goods and not a class of
manufacturer/circumstance.
9. Keeping the above aspects in view, let us examine the subject notification,
which reads as under :
Notification No.24/2003-CE dated 31.03.2003:
“In exercise of the power conferred by sub-section (1)
of section 5A of Central Excise Act, 1944, (1 of 1944), read
with sub-section (3) of section 3 of the Additional Duties of
Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 ( 58 of 1957)
1. P Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, 5th Edition; Union of India and Another vs Vijay Chand Jain,
(1977) 2 SCC 405
2. Black Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition.
9/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
and sub-section (3) of section 3 of the Additional Duties of
Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles ) Act, 1978 (40 of 1978),
the Central Government, being satisfied that it is necessary in
the public interest so to do, hereby,(a) exempts all excisable goods produced or
manufactured in an export oriented undertaking from whole
of duty of excise leviable thereon under section 3 of Central
Excise Act, 1944 ( 1 of 1944) and additional duty of excise
leviable thereon under section 3 of Additional Duty of Excise
(Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 (58 of 1957) and
additional duty of excise leviable thereon under the section 3
of Additional duty of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles)Act,
1978 (40 of 1978): Provided that the exemption contained in
this notification in respect of duty of excise leviable under
section 3 of said Central Excise Act shall not apply to such
goods if brought to any other place in India;
(b) rescinds the notification Nos. 125/84- Central
Excise, dated the 26th May 1984 ( G.S.R. 403(E), dated the
26th May, 1984), 127/84 Central Excise dated the 26th May
1984 ( G.S.R. 405(E), dated the 26th May, 1984) and 55/91Central Excise, dated the 25th July, 91 (G.S.R. 389 (E),
dated the 25th July, 1991). 2. This notification shall come
into force on the 1st day of April, 2003. The principal
notification No. 55/91 Central Excise dated the 25th July
1991 was issued vide GSR 389, dated the 25th July, 1991.
2.This notification shall come into force on the 1 st day of
April, 2003.
[Notification No.24/2003-C.E., dated 31.03.2003]”
10. A reading of Notification No.24/2003, would show that exemption is
with reference to export oriented undertaking, it exempts all excisable goods,
manufactured therein. The exemption is qua the manufacturer by virtue of his
status as an EOU and not with reference to goods. This in my view, cannot but be a
10/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
conditional notification, the condition being that it must be manufactured or
produced by a particular class of manufacturers viz., EOU. Once it is conditional,
then sub-section (1A) to Section 5A of the Act, would not get attracted and it may
be open for petitioner to avail benefit of exemption or opt out of exemption and pay
duty and thereafter, claim rebate.
11. To understand different kinds of exemptions/concession that has been
granted/extended in exercise of the power under Section 5A of the Act, it may be
relevant to contrast the subject notification with a few other notifications, some
exemption being absolute and others conditional.
a) Notification No.03/2006-CE dated 01.03.2026:
S.N Chapter or
o.
heading or
subhearing or
tariff item
1.
0402 91 10
0402 99 20
2.
…..
36. [2403 19
21]
11/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Description
goods
of
excisable Rate
Condition No.
Condensed milk
Nil
-
Tea, including tea waste
Nil
-
Biris, other than paper Nil
rolled biris, manufactured
without the aid of machines,
by a manufacturer by whom
or on whose behalf no biris
are sold under a brand
name, in respect of first
clearances of such biris for
home consumption by or on
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
behalf of such manufacturer
from one or more factories
upto
a
quantity
not
exceeding 20 lakhs cleared
on or after the 1st day of
April in any financial year
…..
41. 1901
Food preparations put up in Nil
unit containers and intended
for free distribution to
economically
weaker
sections of the society under
a programme duly approved
by the Central Government
or any State Government.
Annexure
Condition
No.
1.
2.
12/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Conditions
If the manufacturer of the food preparations produces a
certificate from an officer not below the rank of the Deputy
Secretary to the Government of India or not below the rank of
the Deputy Secretary to the State Government concerned to the
effect that such food preparations have been distributed free to
the economically weaker sections of the society under a
programme duly approved by the Central Government or the
State Government concerned, within five months from the date of
clearance of such goods or within such further period as the
Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise or the Assistant
Commissioner of Central Excise, as the case may be, having
jurisdiction may allow in this regard.
The exemption contained in this notification shall apply subject
to the condition that the manufacturer of biris, files a declaration
in the format given below before the 30 th day of April in each
financial year with the jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner of
Central Excise or Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, as
the case may be.
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
Provided that the declaration for the financial year 2006-2007
shall be filed on or before the 31st day of March, 2007.
11.1. While the 1st two exemptions vide Notification No.3/2006-CE dated
01.03.2006 are absolute, the 3rd and 4th exemptions of the said notification are
subject to complying with the conditions set out in 5 th Column to the Table of the
above notification thus exemption is conditional. The above exemptions through
notifications issued in exercise of power under Section 5A of the Act is referred to
for the purpose of contrasting the same with the subject notification to find if the
subject notification granting exemption is conditional or absolute. Going back to
the subject Notification No.24/2003-CE dated 31.03.2003 it would be clear that it
grants exemption from excise duty on “all goods manufactured in a EOU”, thus
conditional inasmuch as exemption is with reference to a class of manufacturer
viz., EOU.
12. In the light of the above discussion, this Court is of the view that
exemption granted vide Notification No.24/2003 in question is not absolute but
conditional. The condition being that manufacture ought to enjoy the status of
EOU. In view thereof, the impugned order dated 24.07.2018 stands set aside.
13/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
13. Accordingly, writ petition stands disposed of. No costs.
23.03.2026
Speaking (or) Non Speaking Order
Mrn
To
1.Commisioner of GST & Central Excise,
Coimbatore Division,
No.6/7, A.T.D Street, Race Course Road,
Coimbatore -641 018.
2.Principal Commissioner (RA),
8th Floor, World Trade Centre, Cuffe Parade,
Mumbai-400 005.
14/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
MOHAMMED SHAFFIQ, J.
(mrn)
W.P.No.33773 of 2018
23.03.2026
15/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review