Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
FAO No.558 of 2025
….
Kusuma Chhatoi & Anr.
Union of India
-versus….
Appellant (s)
Mr. Suven Ku. Pani, Adv.
Respondent (s)
Ms. Pratima Nayak, CGC
Order No.
05.
CORAM:
DR. JUSTICE SANJEEB K PANIGRAHI
ORDER
17.02.2026
1.
This matter is taken up through hybrid arrangement
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
In this FAO, the Appellants challenge the order dated 18.11.2025
passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Bhubaneswar in OA
(IIU)/ 288 of 2015 wherein the Tribunal did not allow the petition
filed by them to summon the I.O. of the U.D. Case vide No.05 of 2015
of Sakhigopal GROP for the purpose of examination.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that the Appellants being the
dependents of the deceased Rati Kanta Chhatoi had filed a claim case
before the learned Tribunal for compensation on account of death of
the deceased in an untoward incident due to accidental fall down
from Barbil-Puri Express train.
5.
The I.O. of the UD case seized a valid train journey ticket vide No-E
72281462 from the possession of the deceased in presence of
witnesses. The I.O. himself mentioned the said fact in the Inquest
Report. But, surprisingly, the same I.O. has mentioned in the Final
Page 1
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
Report that the family members of the deceased arranged the train
journey ticket from Puri and pushed it in the pant pocket of the
deceased. Again, the same I.O. has mentioned in the Final Report that
due to negligence of the deceased his leg slipped, so, he fell from the
moving train.
6.
However, the Appellants had filed a petition to summon the I.O.,
GROP, Sakhigopal for cross examination on 11.05.2018. No objection
was filed from the side of the Respondent/ Railway. But, the learned
Tribunal without applying judicial mind arbitrarily and without
justifying any reason rejected the same vide order dated 11.05.2018 in
O.A. No.288 of 2015. Thereafter, the Appellants preferred W.P.(C)
No. 10730/2018 before this Court. This Court vide order dated
29.07.2025 dismissed the said Writ Petition on the ground that since
the I.O. of the case was never examined as a witness, the prayer made
by the Appellants to cross examine the I.O. is not at all entertainable.
7.
Thereafter, the Appellants filed a petition before the learned Tribunal
on 09.09.2025 to summon the I.O, GROP, Sakhigopal for examination.
No objection was filed by the Respondent/ Railway. But, the learned
Tribunal vide order dated 18.11.2025 did not allow the said petition
and listed the case for argument.
8.
Being aggrieved by the said order dated 18.11.2025, the Appellants
have filed this appeal.
9.
Learned counsel for the Appellants submits that the impugned order
dated 18.11.2025 passed by the learned Tribunal is illegal, arbitrary
Page 2
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
and not sustainable in law as the learned tribunal has not assigned
any reason while passing the impugned order.
10.
He further submits that the I.O. being the material witness, his
examination is very much required for just decision of the case.
Moreover, the Appellants have specifically mentioned in their
petition that the I.O. in the UD case has not conducted the
investigation properly and submitted the Final Report before the
SDM, Puri stating therein that the deceased died due to his own
negligence and the journey ticket was planted by the members of the
deceased's family. Therefore, examination of the I.O. in the UD case is
very much essential for the interest of justice. However, the aforesaid
aspect has not been taken into account by the learned Tribunal.
11.
It is also submitted that the deceased was travelling with a valid train
journey ticket vide No-E-72281462. Also, the deceased was having
monthly journey ticket (MST) vide No- E68228267. So also the ticket
was seized from his pocket as has been mentioned in the Inquest
Report. But, the I.O. has observed something else which is contrary to
the evidence laid by the applicants /Appellants. Hence, examination
of the I.O. is necessary for just decision of the claim case.
12.
In such view of the matter, it is contended that the order dated
18.11.2025 passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal,
Bhubaneswar in OA (IIU)/ 288 of 2015 may be set aside giving a
direction to the learned Tribunal to allow the petition filed by the
Appellants under Annexure-1 for summoning the I.O., GROP
Page 3
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
Sakhigopal for examination on the facts and circumstances as
mentioned above.
13.
Learned counsel for the Opposite Party/ Union of India submits that
filing of the present appeal is a clear attempt to reopen the case at the
stage of closing of the evidence. The Appellants had ample
opportunity to establish their case during the trial. As per the
principles under Order 18 Rule 17 of the C.P.C., the power to recall or
summon a witness is discretionary and should be used sparingly to
clarify ambiguities, not to allow a party to fill gaps in his/her
evidence after the closure of the case.
14.
It is contended that the Appellants had effectively sought the same
relief which was denied by this Court in W.P.(C) No.10730 of 2018.
Re-agitating the same issue in the guise of a fresh "examination"
petition is an abuse of the process of law. The dismissal order dated
29.07.2025 passed by this Court in W.P.(C) No.10730 of 2018 remains
binding.
15.
It is contended that the Appellants argue that the I.O. should be
examined because the Final Report contradicts the Inquest Report
regarding the recovery of the ticket. However, it is settled principle
that an Inquest Report is intended only to determine the apparent
cause of death, whereas the Final Report (DRM Report) is the result
of a detailed statutory investigation into the bona fides of the
passenger. Discrepancies between the above two reports do not grant
an automatic right to summon the I.O. for cross-examination.
Page 4
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
16.
It is also submitted that the Tribunal has not passed a “nil award”
yet; it has merely listed the case for arguments based on the existing
record. The Appellants can still argue their case based on the Inquest
Report and other evidence already on record. Summoning the I.O. at
this stage would only cause unnecessary delay in the matter that has
been pending since 2015.
17.
In such view of the matter, it is contended that the appeal filed by the
Appellants may be dismissed allowing the Railway Claims Tribunal
to proceed with final arguments in the interest of justice.
18.
Heard the Parties and perused the materials available on record.
19.
This appeal is directed against the order dated 18.11.2025 passed by
the learned Railway Claims Tribunal in O.A. (IIU)/288 of 2015,
whereby the petition filed by the Appellants for summoning the
Investigating Officer (I.O.) of U.D. Case No.05 of 2015 of Sakhigopal
G.R.O.P. for examination was rejected and the matter was posted for
final arguments.
20.
The Appellants, being the dependents of deceased Rati Kanta
Chhatoi, filed a claim petition seeking compensation on account of
death in an alleged untoward incident arising from accidental fall
from a running train. It is their consistent case that during inquest,
the I.O. seized a valid journey ticket from the person of the deceased
and recorded such fact in the Inquest Report. However, in the Final
Report, the same officer allegedly opined that the ticket was planted
by the family members and attributed the fall to the negligence of the
Page 5
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
deceased. The Appellants contend that such material contradiction
renders the I.O. a crucial witness.
21.
The short question that arises for consideration is whether refusal to
summon the I.O., in the backdrop of the above inconsistency,
amounts to failure of justice. The proceedings before the Tribunal,
though summary in nature, are nonetheless adjudicatory and must
conform to the foundational requirements of fairness. In A.K.
Kraipak v. Union of India 1wherein the Supreme Court has held that
the dividing line between administrative and quasi-judicial functions
has become thin, and the rules of natural justice apply wherever civil
consequences exists. Denial of opportunity to lead material evidence
strikes at the root of audi alteram partem principle.
22.
It is well settled that the power to summon or recall a witness is
discretionary and must not be exercised to fill lacunae. In Vadiraj
Naggappa Vernekar
v. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate2the
Supreme Court cautioned that recall cannot be permitted to patch up
weak parts of a case. Equally, in K.K. Velusamy v. N. Palanisamy3
it was clarified that the Court possesses inherent power to permit
additional evidence if the same is necessary for a just decision and
does not cause irreparable prejudice. The present case does not
concern recall of a witness already examined. Rather, it concerns
summoning of a material witness whose recorded statements form
(1969) 2 SCC 262
(2009) 4 SCC 410
(2011) 11 SCC 275
Page 6
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
part of the foundational documents relied upon by both sides. The
inconsistency between the Inquest Report and the Final Report
directly impacts the determination whether the deceased was a bona
fide passenger — a jurisdictional fact for grant of compensation
under Sections 123(c) and 124A of the Railways Act, 1989.
23.
In Union of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar4, the Supreme Court
emphasized that provisions relating to compensation for untoward
incidents must receive liberal interpretation to advance the object of
social justice. Conversely, any finding that a victim was not a bona
fide passenger must rest on cogent material. Where the Investigating
Officer himself has recorded divergent versions regarding recovery
of the ticket, his testimony assumes evidentiary significance.
24.
The learned Tribunal, while rejecting the petition, has not assigned
discernible reasons. The duty to record reasons is an integral
component of judicial accountability. In Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. v.
Masood Ahmed Khan5, it was held that reason is the soul of justice
and ensures transparency in decision-making. A cryptic rejection of a
prayer to examine a material witness does not satisfy this standard.
25.
The earlier dismissal of the writ petition cannot operate as a bar. In
fact, that order proceeded on the limited premise that crossexamination of a witness not examined was impermissible. The
present prayer is for summoning the I.O. as a witness in the first
instance. The cause and scope are thus distinct; the principle of res
(2008) 9 SCC 527
(2010) 9 SCC 496
Page 7
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 09-Mar-2026 17:45:07
judicata or constructive finality does not apply in its rigid form to
interlocutory procedural orders where justice so demands. The
objection that the matter is at the stage of arguments cannot eclipse
the right to lead material evidence, particularly when no objection
was raised by the respondent before the Tribunal. Procedural
discipline is meant to subserve justice, not to thwart it.
26.
In the considered view of this Court, the examination of the I.O. is
not a mere attempt to fill gaps but is germane to adjudication of a
core issue. Refusal to permit such examination, without reasons, has
resulted in material irregularity and failure of justice. Accordingly,
the appeal is allowed. The impugned order dated 18.11.2025 is set
aside. The learned Tribunal shall summon the Investigating Officer of
U.D. Case No.05 of 2015 of Sakhigopal G.R.O.P. for examination,
subject to the Appellants taking necessary steps within two weeks.
27.
The learned Tribunal shall ensure that the examination is completed
expeditiously and thereafter proceed to dispose of the claim petition
preferably within three months, without granting unnecessary
adjournments.
28.
Accordingly, the FAO is disposed of.
29. Interim order, if any, passed earlier stands vacated.
(Dr. Sanjeeb K Panigrahi)
Judge
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review