Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case: WP(C) No. 1196/2022
CM No. 4025/2025
CM No. 3508/2022
CM No. 5629/2022
CM No. 4906/2024
CM No. 6149/2023 c/w
CCP(S) No.260/2023
Reserved on:08.07.2026
Pronounced on:21.07.2026
Uploaded on:22.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Ms. Kunzang Dolma D/O Sonam Dorjay,R/O
Teri- Zimskhang, TashlGatsal, Choglamsar, Leh
Union Territory Of Ladakh. UID No.
2. Sh. Atul Kumar S/O Sh. Jagat Singh,H No.93,
Phase -II, Prem Nagar, Najafgarh, New Delhi110043 UID No.
3. Sh. Jagat Singh S/O Lt Inder Singh, H No.93,
Phase -II, Prem Nagar,Najafgarh, New Delhi110043UID No.
All Former Director/s of the struck off company
Through:-
Petitioner No. 2 is present in person.
Vs.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
…. Petitioner(s)
Union of Indiathrough its Secretary Housing
and Urban Affairs.Email: secyurban@nic.in
Union Territory of LadakhThrough its
Principal Secretary
Email: comsecyutladakh@gmail.com
Advisor to Lieutenant Governor,
Civil Secretariat, Leh-Ladakh
Union Territory of Ladakh.
The Deputy Commissioner,LEH,
Union Territory of Ladakh.
EMAIL: dcleh-jk@nic.in
Power Development Department
through its Executive Engineer, Leh
Union Territory of Ladakh.
EMAIL: xenstdleh@gmail.com.
Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Leh, Union Territory of Ladakh.
Assistant Commissioner Revenue, Leh
Union Territory of Ladakh.
Tehsildar,Tehsil office, Leh,
Union Territory of Ladakh.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
9.
Assistant Director Tourism,
Leh, Union Territory of Ladakh.
10. Executive Engineer, Electric Distribution
Division, Leh, Union Territory of Ladakh.
11. Patwari, Palam village Spituk,
Leh, Union Territory of Ladakh.
12. Executive Officer. Municipal Committee,
Leh, Union Territory of Ladakh.
13. District Magistrate, Chairman DDMA, Leh.
UT of Ladkah.
14. Tsering Angchok, S/o Sh. Tsering Nurboo,
Zangsti Pa, Palam Village, Leh
Union Territory of Ladakh.
15. The Managing Committee of the Spituk
Gompa Through its President/ Ven Gonbo
Lama, Palam Village, Leh
Union Territory of Ladakh
Through:-
…..Respondent(s)
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC
Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Anirudh Sharma, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. Through the medium of the present writ petition filed under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, the petitioners have sought the following
reliefs:
“(i) A Writ of Certiorari or any appropriate writ or direction
quashing
the
impugned
demolition
order
vide
SQ-
18(L)Rev/2022(805) dated 17.05.2022 passed by the Additional
D.C. Leh.
(ii) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 4 and Respondent no. 6 to
allow the Petitioners, and/or their attorney, assignee, agents etc.,
to run the business and to water the plants and trees.
(iii) Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 5 to provide a temporary
electric connection to the petitioners on the land in question in
accordance to rules.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
(iv) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 2 and Respondent no. 4 to
adequately compensate the Petitioners and/or their attorney,
assignee, agents etc. for usage of premises as covid center and for
the loss of business and time by the act/s of omission and
commission by Respondent no. 6, Respondent no. 7, respondent
no. 8 and respondent no. 11.
(v) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 2 to Grant lease for a parallel
land for a period not less than 2 years, to reinstate the Petitioners
and/or their attorney, assignee, agents etc. by shifting the
infrastructure of the resort.
(vi) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 2, Respondent no. 4 &
Respondent no. 7 to clearly earmark the land belonging to Mr.
Tsering Angchok, Spituk gompa and Government of the Union
Territory of Ladakh before taking any steps for demolition of the
premises in question.
(vii) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby directing the Respondent no. 2, Respondent no. 4 and
respondent no. 6 grant the petitioners access to the seized articles
and the documents of seizure etc.
(viii) Any other writ, order or direction as the Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper so as to protect the rights and interests of the
Petitioners.
(ix) A Writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ or direction
thereby awarding the costs of the writ petition to the petitioners.”
2.
Before adverting to the merits of the controversy, it also deserves
notice that petitioner No. 2 appeared in person not only on his own
behalf but also sought to represent petitioner Nos. 1 and 3 as well. In
this regard, this Court, vide order dated 20.07.2024, directed petitioner
No. 2 to place on record the requisite Power of Attorney authorizing
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
him to represent the other petitioners. The relevant part of the said
order reads as under:
“The petitioner no. 2 present in person submits that he will argue the
matter not only on his behalf but also on behalf of other petitioners as
such, he requests that the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
be discharged of this professional obligation. Accordingly the
petitioner no. 2 is permitted to argue the matter provided he places on
record the requisite Power of Attorney on behalf of other petitioners
to argue the matter. Same be done within a period of two weeks.”
3.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order, petitioner No. 2 has placed on record
the requisite Powers of Attorney executed by petitioner Nos. 1 and 3
authorizing him to represent them in the present proceedings.
Accordingly, petitioner No. 2 has been heard not only on his own
behalf but also on behalf of petitioner Nos. 1 and 3 as well.
4.
During the course of arguments, however, petitioner No. 2, who
appeared in person not only on his own behalf but also on behalf of
the petitioners’ No. 1 and 3, made a categorical statement before this
Court that the petitioners do not wish to press the reliefs claimed at
Serial Nos. (ii) to (vii) of the prayer clause and intend to confine the
present writ petition only to the relief claimed at Serial No. (i), which
pertains
to
the
communication
quashment
bearing
No.
of
the
impugned
demolition
SQ-18(L)Rev/2022(805)
dated
17.05.2022. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed as not
pressed insofar as the reliefs claimed at Serial Nos. (ii) to (vii) are
concerned and survives only to the limited extent of examining the
legality and validity of the aforesaid communication.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
5.
Briefly stated, the case projected by the petitioners is that petitioner
No. 2, while pursuing his business in the field of travel and tourism in
the Union Territory of Ladakh, entered into arrangements with
respondent Nos. 14 and 15 in respect of certain land situated at
village Palam, Spituk, Leh, whereupon a tourist resort under the
name and style ‘The Last Resort’ came to be established. According to
the petitioners, substantial investments were made in developing the
said resort by raising temporary structures and creating various
facilities for tourists. It is further their case that during the COVID-19
pandemic, the premises in question were requisitioned and utilised by
the District Administration as a COVID Isolation Centre.
6.
The petitioners further assert that despite having invested
considerable amounts in developing the resort and despite the
premises having been utilised by the Government authorities during
the
pandemic,
respondent
No.
issued
the
impugned
communication dated 17.05.2022 directing removal of the alleged
encroachment from the State land. The principal grievance projected
by the petitioners is that the impugned communication was issued
without serving any notice upon them or affording them an
opportunity of being heard and is, therefore, liable to be quashed on
the ground of violation of the principles of natural justice.
7.
Upon notice, the official respondents No. 2 to 4, 6 to 8 and 11, have
filed their objections controverting the averments made in the writ
petition. It is their specific stand that the land in question is State
land and that the camping site/resort under the name ‘The Last
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
Resort’had been established by way of illegal encroachment thereon.
It has further been pleaded that before initiating the process for
removal of the encroachment, the District Administration verified
the official records maintained by the concerned departments,
including the records of the Tourism Department as well as the
Power Development Department, and found that the resort stood
registered in the name of respondent No. 14, namely, Mr. Tsering
Angchok, who was reflected as the proprietor of ‘The Last Resort’and
in whose name the electricity connection also existed.
8.
The official respondents have further pleaded that, in view of the
aforesaid official record, notices preceding the demolition action
were issued to respondent No. 14, who, according to the official
record, was the registered proprietor of the resort. It is their stand
that after the expiry of the notice period and in the absence of any
response thereto, action for removal of the illegal encroachment was
initiated strictly in accordance with law. The respondents have,
therefore, denied the allegation that the impugned action was taken
arbitrarily or in violation of the principles of natural justice.
9.
Separate set of objections have also been filed on behalf of
respondent Nos. 14 and 15. A preliminary objection has been raised
regarding the maintainability of the present writ petition. It has been
specifically pleaded that the petition has been filed by the Directors
of M/s Travel Gear Private Limited without impleading the
Company itself as a party and that, in any event, the said Company
already stands struck off from the Register of Companies. It has,
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
therefore, been contended that the petitioners lack the requisite locus
standi to maintain the present challenge to the impugned
communication.
10.
It has further been contended on behalf of respondent Nos. 14 and
15 that the resort in question stood registered in the name of
respondent No. 14 and that the petitioners cannot claim any
enforceable legal right on the basis of disputed and unregistered
arrangements alleged to have been entered into between the parties.
According to the private respondents, the entire controversy sought
to be projected by the petitioners involves disputed questions
relating to title, possession and the nature of the arrangements
allegedly entered into between the parties, which cannot be
adjudicated in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
11.
Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI appearing on behalf of the
official respondents, while adopting the stand taken in the
objections, submitted that the impugned communication was issued
only after verification of the official records, which disclosed
respondent No. 14 to be the registered proprietor of the resort. It
was, accordingly, argued that the petitioners, whose names did not
figure either in the official tourism records or in the electricity
records in relation to the resort, cannot legitimately contend that any
notice was required to be served upon them before issuance of the
impugned communication.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
12.
In view of the statement made by petitioner No. 2 confining the writ
petition only to prayer No. (i), and having regard to the rival pleadings
of the parties, the only question that falls for consideration is whether
the petitioners have made out any case warranting interference with
the communication dated 17.05.2022 directing removal of the alleged
encroachment from the State land, particularly when the impugned
action was taken against the person reflected in the official records as
the registered proprietor of the resort.
13.
At the outset, it is required to be noticed that the petitioners have
consciously confined the present writ petition only to the challenge
laid against communication dated 17.05.2022 issued by the
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Leh. Accordingly, this Court is
not required to examine the other grievances projected in the writ
petition or the supplementary affidavits regarding compensation,
allotment of alternate land, release of seized articles, utilization of
the resort as a COVID Isolation Centre or the inter se disputes
between the petitioners and respondent Nos. 14 and 15.
14.
The principal submission advanced by petitioner No. 2 is that the
impugned communication directing removal of the alleged
encroachment was issued without serving any notice upon the
petitioners and, therefore, the same is violative of the principles of
natural justice. According to the petitioners, despite the fact that the
petitioners had established the infrastructure at the site and were
running the business under the name and style "The Last Resort", no
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
opportunity of hearing was afforded to them before directing
demolition of the structures.
15.
Per contra, Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI, appearing for the
official respondents submitted that the aforesaid contention is
wholly misconceived. It is argued that before initiating action for
removal of the encroachment, the District Administration verified
the records maintained by the Tourism Department as well as the
Power Development Department. Upon such verification, it was
found that the resort in question stood registered in the name of
respondent No. 14, namely, Mr. Tsering Angchok, and that even
the electricity connection in respect of the resort existed in his name.
It is, therefore, contended that the competent authority rightly
proceeded against the person who was reflected in the official
records as the proprietor of the resort.
16.
Mr. Rahul Pant, learned Senior Advocate appearing for respondent
Nos. 14 and 15, while raising a preliminary objection regarding the
maintainability of the writ petition, submitted that the petitioners have
no locus standi to assail the impugned communication. According to
the learned Senior Counsel, the petitioners themselves admit that the
Company through which the business was allegedly being carried on
has already been struck off from the Register of Companies. It is,
therefore, contended that neither the petitioners nor the struck off
Company possess any enforceable legal right so as to challenge the
impugned communication issued by the competent authority.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
17.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the petitioners seek
to assert rights flowing from alleged lease arrangements, licence,
possession and investment over the property, all of which are
seriously disputed by the private respondents. It is contended that
the alleged agreements relied upon by the petitioners neither confer
any legal title nor create any enforceable right capable of being
adjudicated in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. It is, therefore, argued that the present writ
petition is not maintainable.
18.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
19.
Having regard to the statement made by petitioner No. 2, appearing in
person on behalf of all the petitioners, restricting the relief only to
prayer No. (i), this Court, therefore, is proceeding to decide the instant
writ petition with respect to relief as claimed by the petitioners in
prayer No.(i) only. The only question which falls for consideration is
whether the communication dated 17.05.2022 is liable to be interfered
with on the ground that the petitioners were not served with notice
before the impugned action came to be initiated.
20.
The principal contention advanced on behalf of the petitioners is that
the impugned communication is vitiated on account of violation of the
principles of natural justice as no notice was served upon them before
directing removal of the alleged encroachment. The aforesaid
contention has to be examined in the light of the factual position
existing on the date the impugned communication came to be issued
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
and the material which was available before the competent authority at
the relevant point of time.
21.
A perusal of the reply affidavit filed by the official respondents and
after examining the record meticulously, it has come to fore that the
resort in question, namely "The Last Resort", was found to be
registered with the Tourism Department in the name of respondent
No. 14, Mr. Tsering Angchok. It has further been specifically
averred by the official respondents that the electricity connection
pertaining to the said establishment also stood in the name of
respondent No. 14, Mr. Tsering Angchok. Acting upon the
aforesaid contemporaneous official records, the competent authority
proceeded against respondent No. 14 and issued the notice
contemplated under law before initiating the impugned action.
22.
The aforesaid factual assertions made by the official respondents
have not been effectively controverted by the petitioners by placing
on record any official document to demonstrate that, on the date the
impugned communication came to be issued, the petitioners were
recognized by any statutory authority as owners, proprietors, lessees
or occupiers of the establishment in question. Admittedly, neither
the registration before the Tourism Department nor the electricity
connection stood in the names of the petitioners. In the absence of
any such material, this Court finds no infirmity in the action of the
respondents in proceeding against the person who stood reflected in
the official records as the proprietor of the resort.
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
23.
Once the respondents had acted on the basis of the official records
maintained by the competent authorities, it cannot be held that they
were under any further obligation to issue notice to persons whose
names did not find place in such records. The administrative
authorities are expected to proceed on the basis of the official
records available before them and the action so taken cannot be
faulted merely because third parties subsequently assert independent
private claims in respect of the property.
24.
It is well settled that the principles of natural justice are not to be
applied in the abstract. The requirement of notice has to be
examined in the context of the person against whom the authority
was legally required to proceed. Once the competent authority
proceeded against the person who stood reflected in the official
records as the registered proprietor of the establishment, the
petitioners cannot successfully complain of violation of the
principles of natural justice merely because no independent notice
was issued to them.
25.
The petitioners have sought to justify their claim for issuance of
notice by placing reliance upon the alleged arrangements entered
into with respondent Nos. 14 and 15, the investments stated to have
been made by them in establishing the resort and their alleged
possession
over
the
property.
However,
none
of
these
circumstances, by themselves, establish that the petitioners were
recognised by the official respondents as persons against whom the
impugned action was required to be initiated. The question before
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
this Court is not whether the petitioners have any civil or
contractual claim against the private respondents, but whether the
official
respondents
acted
arbitrarily
in
proceeding
against
respondent No. 14 on the basis of the official records. The answer,
in the opinion of this Court, has to be in the negative.
26.
Respondent Nos. 14 and 15 have also raised a preliminary objection
that the Company through which the petitioners claim to have been
operating the resort already stands struck off from the register
maintained by the Registrar of Companies. However, having regard
to the conclusion arrived at hereinabove, this Court does not consider
it necessary to examine the said objection any further, as the present
writ petition can be effectively decided on the basis of the admitted
position emerging from the official records.
27.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is unable to accept the
contention that the impugned communication is vitiated for
violation of the principles of natural justice. Since the respondents
proceeded against the person who stood reflected in the official
records as the proprietor of the establishment, the action of the
respondents cannot be said to suffer from any procedural infirmity
merely because a separate notice was not issued to the petitioners.
28.
Apart from the above, the impugned communication relates to
removal of structures alleged to have been raised over State land by
way of encroachment. The petitioners have not produced any material
in the present proceedings to demonstrate that the structures sought to
be removed had been raised pursuant to any permission, sanction or
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
lawful authority granted by the competent Government authority. In
these circumstances, once the official respondents proceeded in
accordance with law against the respondent No. 14 (Mr. Tsering
Angchuk) reflected in the official records as the proprietor of the
establishment, no ground is made out to interfere with the
consequential action for removal of the encroachment.
29.
Another aspect of the matter which is required to be dealt in the instant
petition is that the claim projected by the petitioners is founded upon
alleged agreements and private arrangements entered into with
respondent Nos. 14 and 15 and their possession over the property and
the investments claimed to have been made by them in developing the
resort. These assertions are seriously disputed by the private respondents
and fall within the realm of disputed questions of fact, which cannot be
gone into while exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
30.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in ‘Roshina T. v. Abdul Azeez’,
(2019) 2 SCC 329, while dealing with disputes involving rival claims
relating to property, observed that:
“13. The question as to who is the owner of the flat in question,
whether respondent No. 1 was/is in possession of the flat
and, if so, from which date, how and in what circumstances, he
claimed to be in its possession, whether his possession could
be regarded as legal or not qua its real owner etc. were some of
the material questions which arose for consideration in the
writ petition.
14. These questions, in our view, were pure questions of
fact and could be answered one way or the other only by the
Civil Court in a properly constituted civil suit and on
the basis of the evidence adduced by the parties but not in a
writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution by the
High Court.”
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
The aforesaid principle squarely applies to the facts of the
present case, where the rival claims regarding the alleged
arrangements, possession and rights asserted by the petitioners are
seriously disputed and cannot be adjudicated in the exercise of writ
jurisdiction. This Court is, therefore, not required to adjudicate upon
the inter se rights of the petitioners and respondent Nos. 14 and 15
arising out of the alleged agreements, lease arrangements or any other
contractual understanding relied upon by them. Equally, this Court is
not required to determine whether the petitioners have acquired any
independent civil rights in respect of the property or the establishment.
All such questions are left open to be determined in appropriate
proceedings before the competent forum, if so advised.
31.
The scope of the present proceedings is confined to examining the
legality of the communication dated 17.05.2022. For the reasons
recorded hereinabove, this Court is satisfied that the respondents
acted on the basis of the official records available before them and
the petitioners have failed to establish that the respondents were
under any legal obligation to issue an independent notice to them
before issuance of the impugned communication.
32.
Before parting with this matter, it is necessary to clarify that this
Court has not undertaken any adjudication upon the rival civil
claims/rights of the petitioners and respondent Nos. 14 and 15 in
respect of the property or the resort. The present conclusion is
founded solely upon the admitted position emerging from the official
records available before the competent authority at the relevant point
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
of time and no material has been placed on record to show that the
petitioners were recognised by any statutory authority as proprietors or
persons entitled to notice. It is only in that limited context that this
Court has held that the official respondents were justified in proceeding
in the manner they did.
33.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, no ground is made out for exercise
of the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution for quashing the communication dated 17.05.2022. The
challenge laid by the petitioners is, accordingly, devoid of merit and
the same is liable to be rejected.
34.
Accordingly, the writ petition, insofar as it relates to Prayer No. (i), is
dismissed.
35.
It is, however, made clear that this judgment shall not be construed as
an expression of opinion on the merits of the rival claims of the
petitioners and respondent Nos. 14 and 15 arising out of the alleged
agreements, title, possession, lease or any other civil or contractual
rights, all of which are left open to be agitated before the competent
forum in accordance with law. Pending applications, if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
36.
In view of the disposal of the main writ petition, nothing further
survives for adjudication in the contempt petition. Accordingly, the
proceedings in the contempt petition i.e CCP(S) No. 260/2023 shall
also stand closed.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Jammu
21.07.2026
Vijay
Whether the judgment is speaking
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
WP(C) No. 1196/2022
Vijay Kumar
2026.07.23 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review