Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010658552025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.Nos:- 5 & 6
[3584]
WRIT APPEAL NOs: 757 & 882 of 2026
Kunja Ramudu
...Appellant
Vs.
The State of A.P. and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM :THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 28th July 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellant:
K JYOTHI PRASAD
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s): SITA RAM CHAPARLA,
GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals are preferred under clause 15 of Letters
Patent assailing the common order dated 15.10.2025 in
W.P. Nos.4761 and 4764 of 2019 passed by learned Single Judge,
therefore, are heard together and disposed by common order.
2.
(a)
Appellant in both these appeals is the writ petitioner in
the writ petitions. He belongs to Scheduled Tribe (Koya) and claims
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
to be absolute owner of land in an extent of Acres 6.03 cents and
Acres
4.00
cents
in
R.S.No.1629/1
and
R.S.No.1629/2
respectively situated at Buttaigudem Village of West Godavari
District. He claims to have inherited the same. He filed complaint
before 4th respondent contending that the unofficial respondents in
both the writ petitions, who are non-tribal, were in possession and
enjoyment of the subject lands in contravention of Section 3(1) of
Andhra Pradesh Scheduled Areas Land Transfer Regulation
(Regulation No.I of 1959) as amended by Regulation No.I of 1970.
(b)
The complaints were entertained vide S.R.No.1/2010/F2
and S.R.No.2/2010/F2 respectively before 3rd respondent herein.
The appeals were allowed vide separate orders even dated
09.05.2006. Aggrieved by the same, the appellant/writ petitioner
preferred two sets of revisions before the 2nd respondent and the
same eventually came to be dismissed, confirming the orders of
Appellate Authority in G.O.Ms.No.45, Social Welfare (TW.LTR)
Department
and
G.O.Ms.No.51,
Social
Welfare
(TW.LTR)
Department, even dated 15.02.2019.
(c)
Challenging the same, appellant preferred W.P.Nos.4761
and 4764 of 2019 respectively. Learned Single Judge having
appreciated the submissions made by respective parties and after
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
going through the documents on record has found that the subject
property in question though initially was under enjoyment of tribals,
by name Kunja China Gangulu and his sons, and later transferred
to Kumara Dulappa, the children of transferee eventually alienated
the same to one Daggu Gangamma, a non-tribal after obtaining
permission from Assistant Agent, Kovvur, under proceedings vide
L.Dis.C.No.1/SR/47, dated 01.01.1947. Thereafter, the property
has changed hands to the successors, non-tribals and all these
aspects have indeed were decisively concluded by Special Deputy
Collector, Tribal Welfare, vide order dated 27.09.1978 in
S.R.No.39 of 1978, therefore, the successive enquiry at the
instance of writ petitioner was found fault with, accordingly,
confirmed the orders of both respondents 3 and 2.
(d)
Assailing the same present appeals are preferred.
3.
Heard Sri K.Jyothi Prasad, learned counsel, appearing for
appellant, learned Government Pleader for Social Welfare,
appearing for the official respondents and Sri Sita Ram Chaparla,
learned counsel, appearing for unofficial respondent.
4.
(a)
Learned counsel for appellant contends that the first
appellate authority, revisional authority and as well as learned
Single Judge failed to appreciate that the subject property in issue
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
is different from the one enquired into and decided by order dated
27.09.1978 in S.R.No.39 of 1978, therefore, the findings rendered
in the previous enquiry in no way have any bearing over the subject
proceedings. This aspect of the matter was clearly noticed by
4th respondent while passing the original order even dated
09.05.2006. Except for the original authority, all other appellate and
revisional authorities as well as learned Single Judge fell in error in
misconstruing that the subject properties are one and the same
and erroneously relied on the permission given by Special
Assistant Agent, Kovvur, vide L.Dis.C.No.1/SR of 1947 under
Ex.R3. Learned counsel has drawn our attention to the said
permission and referred to the schedule mentioned therein.
Likewise, he also drawn our attention to the schedule of land as
mentioned in the order dated 09.05.2006 in S.R.Nos.11 and 12 of
2006.
(b)
He also contended that the schedules mentioned in both the
proceedings are distinct and separate, the land for which the
permission was granted by Assistant Agent was falling in
Kollaigudem Hamlet of Buttaigudem and whereas, the land which
is subject matter of present proceedings, as could be seen from
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
proceedings in S.R.Nos.11 and 12 of 2006 was falling in
R.S.Nos.1629/1 and 1629/2 of Buttaigudem.
(c)
He thus contended that the enquiry initiated in the year 2006
is therefore very much entertainable as it was mounted on a distinct
factual background and the 4th respondent was well within its
jurisdiction in undertaking the enquiry. In support, reliance has
been placed on order of combined High Court in Gaddam
Raghavulu v. Agent to Government (Dist. Collector), E.G.Dist.,
Kakinada and others1 and also the order of High Court of
Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State
of Andhra Pradesh in Special Deputy Collector (Tribal Welfare),
Rampachodavaram, East Godavari District and others v.
Datela Venkatapathi Raju and others2.
5.
Per contra, both the learned Government Pleader as well as
learned counsel appearing for unofficial respondents, while
supporting the impugned order of learned Single Judge, would
contend that the subject matter in controversary being one and the
same, a second and successive enquiry by the very same authority
is impermissible. Both the first appellate authority, revisional
authority and learned Single Judge having noticed that the property
1 1994 (2) AnWR 216
2 2003 (1) ALD 386 (DB)
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
in issue being one and the same have rightly rejected the claim of
the appellant/writ petitioner, therefore, the issues otherwise
concluded cannot be reopened and agitated once again. Thus,
prayed for dismissal of the appeals.
6.
We have considered the rival submissions made by learned
counsels for the parties and perused the record.
7.
One Kunja Muneeswara Rao filed complaint before Special
Deputy Collector (Tribal Welfare), Eluru, against Gelam Appa Rao
and Kanumuri Vijaya Narasimharaju, alleging that the respondents
therein, being non-tribals, were in possession of land belonging to
the petitioner, a tribe, by purchasing the same from non-tribals,
therefore, prayer was made to restore the said land in favour of the
petitioner by ejecting the non-tribals. The respondents in the said
proceedings filed a counter stating that initially Kumari Kanayya,
Scheduled Tribe, had alienated the subject land in favour of Daggu
Gangamma, a non-tribe, under registered sale deed dated
10.12.1947, after securing special permission from Special
Assistant Agent, Kovvur, vide proceedings L.Dis.C.No.1/SR of 47,
dated 01.01.1947. Further, Daggu Gangamma in turn alienated
the same in favour of Kanumuri Ramakrishnam Raju and
Narasimham Raju, through registered sale deed dated 18.12.1950,
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
who later alienated the same in favour of Aluri Venkata Narasimha
Raju under registered sale deed dated 20.09.1966. Further, the
same was again alienated in favour of Gellam Apparao and others
through registered sale deed dated 27.06.1968, therefore, the
alienations affected accordingly did not violate or contravene the
provisions of Regulation No.I of 1959 as amended by Regulation
No.I of 1970.
In support of their case, besides examining
themselves as witnesses, they also got exhibited Exs.B1 to B7,
which are the prior permission and sale leads executed from time
to time, as mentioned above.
8.
On appreciation of the evidence on record, the Special
Deputy Collector finally held that all the transactions involved in the
case were valid and not hit by Section 3(2) of Regulation No.I of
1959 as amended by Regulation No.I of 1970 and accordingly
dismissed the complaint. In the said order, it was also specifically
noticed that the property as mentioned in Ex.B3, i.e., Special
Assistant Agent permission and the one mentioned under sale
deed dated 10.02.1947 through which Kumari Kanayya and others
and sons of Kummara Dulappa have alienated the property in
favour of Daggu Gangamma are one and the same and that the
same were the properties mentioned as “Burugu Koyya Pampu”.
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
Further, it was also held that Kollaigudem, Hamlet of Buttaigudem
and Butlavarigudem, Hamlet of Buttaigudem were one and the
same. The said order has attained finality as there was no further
appeal preferred.
9.
We also noticed that the extent of land referred to in the
aforesaid order dated 27.09.1978 was admeasuring Acres 9.61
cents called “Burugu Koyya Pampu” and whereas, the extent
referred to in the proceedings granting prior permission was Acres
9.65 cents, which are more or less same.
10.
Now proceeding to the orders passed in S.R.Nos.11 and 12
of 2006, which are at the instance of the appellant, in the process
of later enquiry, the land referred to is in R.S.Nos.1629/1 and
1629/2 admeasuring Acres 6.03 cents and Acres 4.00 cents of
Buttaigudem Village. At first blush, the schedule of land referred
appear to be different, but, however, the relief claimed was with
respect to the very same extent of land, except for minor deviation
with regard to the extent. In the enquiry though the contesting
respondents therein have specifically taken stand that the issue
was already enquired into and decided way back in the year 1978
itself and the order passed in S.R.No.39/1978, dated 27.09.1978
was relied on, the same came to be discarded by the Special
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
Officer by holding that the schedule land, subject matter of enquiry,
was different from the one enquired into earlier. Strangely, the said
finding came to be arrived at merely basing on the documents
exhibited by the respondents therein and conspicuously writ
petitioner/complainant neither given any oral evidence nor
exhibited any documents to support his claim.
11.
The appellate authority reversed aforesaid orders on
reappreciation of the evidence adduced. Further, even the
2nd respondent also confirmed the same in revision. Learned
Single Judge, after having gone into all aforesaid aspects in greater
detail, has rightly come to conclusion that the first enquiry itself
indeed decided the issue and the land, subject matter of present
enquiry, was covered by said enquiry. We are in complete
agreement with the view expressed by learned Single Judge.
12.
That apart, as mentioned above, we find that the Special
Deputy Collector in the earlier enquiry has categorically recorded
finding that the land as mentioned in the proceedings issued by
Special Assistant Agent granting prior permission and the one
mentioned in the sale deed executed in favour of Daggu
Gangamma are one and the same. In that view of the matter, in
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
the absence of any new material justifying the claim that the lands
in issue are not one and the same has no basis to stand.
13.
Learned counsel for petitioner relied on the judgments in
Gaddam Raghavulu1 and Datela Venkatapathi Raju2. In the first
judgment, the second enquiry was held to be permissible, as the
first inquiry came to be dropped earlier for the reason that sufficient
evidence was not produced. In the second judgment, the second
enquiry was held to be permissible qua the subject property therein
as it was found that after initial enquiry the subject land was once
again transferred in favour of non-tribes in breach of bar contained
in Section 3(1) of the Regulations unlike present case.
14.
In Writ Appeal No.1342 of 2025, Coordinate Bench of this
Court, to which one of us is a party, while referring to the earlier
precedents on the aspect as to whether second inquiry is
permissible under Regulation No.I of 1959 as amended by
Regulation No.I of 1970, it has been held that although principles
of res judicata would not apply, when the first enquiry did not suffer
from any lacuna and remains conclusive upon appreciation of
proper evidence, the second inquiry would be barred, inasmuch as
the regulations did not envisage review.
15.
HCJ & CGR, J
W.A.Nos.757 & 882 of 2026
Even in the present case, the first enquiry which culminated
into order dated 27.09.1978 in S.R. No.39 of 1978 was rendered
considering the extensive evidence placed before it and once the
same attained finality, in the absence of any allegation of fraud,
the second enquiry is clearly impermissible. We therefore do not
find any infirmity in the impugned common order and thus sustain
the same.
16.
Accordingly, these writ appeals are dismissed. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in these cases,
if any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review