Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34431
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR TtIE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDE
FRIDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSANDAND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2796 OF 2019
Petition under Nticle 227 of th Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 171812019 passed OS No. 1312017 on the file of The Court of the Agent to
GovernmenUDistrict Collector, Khammam, Khammam District.
Between:
1. Kummanaboina Nagaiah S/o Gopaiah, Aged 67 years, Occ: Agriculture, Rl/o.
Thaltagudem (v) Kamepally(M) Khammam District.
2. Kummanaboina Kotamma Wo Nagaiah, Aged 57 years, Occ: House Wife,
R/o. Thallagudem (v) Kamepally(M) Khammam District.
3. Kummanaboina Venkateswarlu S/o Nagaiah, Aged 37 years, Occ: Agriculture,
R/o. Thallagudem (v) Kamepaily(\4) Khimmambistrlct.
Raju S/o Nagaiah, Aged 35 years, Occ: Agriculture, Fl/o.
fy11aryUoina.
I nalagudem (v) Kamepally (M) Khammam
Diskict.
+
1. Gottuparthi Upender
Kishan Rao,
Aged 76 years, Occ: Rtd..
Emptoyee, R/o. bank _Rao !{o
inl"m#"rn 0i.,.
2' Kelothu Bhasker s/o "orony,
Lily".l.fgg9 az v"r,.sl occ: Agricurture/sarpanch,
Pinjaramadugu 1vy ramefatii1tr,t"y (rl.r,i,ri.,bilti[i
FVo
ktrmi"i,
_
Res pondents/plaintiff..2
ffiaa$ffiA=lftr**#il'l,.*ik'#fir,,,,ffi ji
Counsel for the petitioners
Counsel for the Respo
: Sri. lUadiraiu
Sri. Kowturu Pavan Kumar o representing
Sri. N V Anantha Krishna
The Court made the foflowing:
---
ORDER
IN T}IE.HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TTLAI{GANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE IION'BLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NAT{DIKONDA
of
DATE: 13.0,3.2o126
Between:
Kummanaboina Nagorlo;h olnd 3 others
...Petitioners
AI{I)
@ttuparltht Upender Roo ornd
o:nother
.ResPondent-s
ORDER
ThisCivilRevisionPetitionisfiledunderArticle22Tofthe
ConstitutiorroflndiatosetasidethemarkeddocumentEx.A-l
O'S'No'13 of2Ol7 on
in
27'04'2017
dated
sale
agreement cf
Agent to Government/District
learned
the
by
17.O8.2O1g
Collector, Khammam'
Khammarn District'
i
.:
l
I
2of13
NNR, J
cPJ
Rao'
2. Heard Sri Madiraju Prabhakar
Pawan Kumar'
representing Sri Kowturu
learned counsel
learned counsel for
N'V' Anantha Krishna'
the petitioners and Srt
learned' counsel
fortherespondents.Perusedtheentirematerialonrecord.
3.I.earnedcounselofthepetitionercontendedthatthe
presentrevisionpetitionisfiledformarkingofadocrrmentasan
exhibit,eventhoughthesameisunregisteredandinsufficiently
for
the Agent to Government
by
record'ed'
reasons
stamped. The
as Ex'A- 1 is not
'2017
dated
'O4
admitting the document
sustainableinlaw,arrdthesaiddocumentisnotadmissiblein
evidence
4.
as Ex.A- 1, was
The document, marked
admitted ignoring
respond'ents' who are
the
by
raised
objections
the
the
The said
its marking'
defendants in the suit, regarding
sale' However' its
is d'escribed as ar' agreement of
d,ocument
recitalsclearlyrevealthatthenatureofthed'ocumentisthatof
asaledeed.Therefore,therespondentscontendedthatsucha
document,beingunregisteredandinsuffrcientlystamped.,
carrnot be received in*erddence.
d-4
3 of13
M\fR, J
cRP_2796 2ot9
D.
Dr-rring the course of
Agency court, the counsel
objectiorr to the marking
27'04'2077, which is said
No' 1 in favour of plaintiff
property. The objection
marking of documents
before the
for the defendants raised
a specific
of the agreement of sale dated
to have been executed by plaintiff
No.2 in respect of the
was raised on the ground
document is not a registered
I
,
,
a
I
i
l
:
j
6'
J
:
The Agency court, after
!
i
counser fc,r the defendant,
:
registratiorr, the executor
overn-r.red the objection
and
by the
and herd that
Agency area before going
wil go for agreement of sare and
will get the approval of poITDA
7'
of sale, though its contents
hearing the objection raised
due to the general practice in
document ra.s per Indian
to be
is a sale deed.
l
I
that the
one and that it is sought
marked rnerely as an agreement
recitals d.lsclose that it
suit schedule
for
they
and they wil registered their
Registration Act.
setting aside the objection raised,
on perusar of Ex'A-l, which
Ex.A-l was rnarked and
is written in the Telugu language,
reveals that the land in sy.No.T,2/AA
was said to have been
sold for a consideration of Rs.5,0o,ooo/-, and it is further
'!-
4of13
NNR, J
cRP 2796 20t9
recited that the entire sale consideration had been paid and
possession of the property was delivered to the purchaser.
8.
The recitals in the document clearly indicate that the
transaction was completed, inasmuch as the consideration was
fully paid and possession was delivered. These aspects
demonstrate that the so called Agreement of Sale is, in
substance and for all practical purposes, in the nature of a sale
deed. However, the said document was engrossed only on
Rs. 100/- non-judicial stamp paper.
9.
[n view of the specific recitals indicating payment of the
entire sale consideration and delivery of possession, the true
nature of the document amounts to a sale deed, attracting the
provisions of Section 33 of the Stamp Act, 1899, which is
extracted hereunder:
"Every person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive
evidence, and every person in charge of a public office, except an officer
of police, before whom any instrument, chargeable, in his opinion, with
duty, is produced or comes in the performance of his functions, shall, if it
appears to him that such instrument is not duly stamped, impound the
samg"
\
5of13
NN& J
cRP-2796-0t9
And als,t the Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, l9Og,
which is extracted below:
"Ser;tion [7 of The Registration Act, 190g, mandates the registration
of
specific documents relaled to immovable property, valued at Rs.l00/_
or
mon:, to ensure legal validity, prevent fraud, and record ownership
charges- Key requirements include gifts of immovable property, non_
testamentary instruments creating/extinguishing rights, and
leases
exceeding one year."
It also attracts the provisions of the Section 49 of the
Registration Act, 19O8, which is extracted hereunder:
"[t nundates that documents requiring compulsory registration (under
Secti,tn 17) cannot affecr immovable property, confer adoption power,
be received as evidence of transactions involving that property
or
if they
remain unregistered. However, such documents art admissible
for
collat:ral purposes."
Therefore. the provisions are thereby rendering the
document
compulso:rily registrable and to be proper stamped.
10. The Court, whenever any document is produced before an
authority empowered to receive evidence, and every person
charge of rr public office, except a police offlcer, is duty
bound to
examine the same with regard to its proper stamping. If
appears that the document is not duly stamped, such
in
it
authority
6of13
I.[NR, J
cRP 2796 2019
is required to take appropriate action in accordance with law for
sending the document for impounding.
11. In the present case, the Agency Court, before which the
suit is pending, is undoubtedly a public oflice and is also the
authority competent to receive evidence. Therefore, it squarely
falls within the scope of the authority contempleited under
Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, which mandates that
any such authority must examine the document and deal with it
in accorda.nce with the provisions of the Stamp Act if it is found
to be insuffrciently stamped.
L2. Further, having regard to the recitals in the document
indicating that the entire sale consideration was paid and
possession of the property rvas delivered, the document becomes
one that is amenable to compulsory registration. [n such
circumstances, the nature and contents of the document would
attract the relevant provisions of the Stamp Act and the
Registration Act, requiring proper stamping and registration
before it can be admitted in evidence.
\. \
7of13
NNR, J
cRP 2796 2019
13. Tt:e learned counsel for the respondent, while making his
submis:;ions, contended that the present suit is f,rled for the
relief of injunction, arrd that the question of title arises only
incidentally. Therefore, according to him, the parlies are not
relying upon the said document as the basis of their title. It was
further submitted that the document is sought to be looked into
only for a collateral purpose, which is permissible under Section
49 of tht: Registration Act.
L4. However, the learned counsel for the respondent also fairly
submitted that, as per the settled position of law, even for the
limited flurpose of looking into an unregistered document for a
collateral purpose, the document must be duly stamped. In the
absence of proper stamping, or in the event of a deficit stamp
duty, tht: document is liable to be impounded, and unless and
until thr: requisite stamp duty and penalty are paid, the
document can be looked into for any purpose whatsoever.
ir
\.,
8of13
NNN, r
cRPJTe6-0te
15. Further, in view of the judgment of this court in the case
of Yeluvolu Blessy Sheeba v/s. Amgoth Anitha Nayak r ,
wherein held that:
"The leamed counsel for the respondent- defendant placed reliance on
the judgment of the combined High coun of Andhra hadesh and
Telangana in syed yousuf Ari v. Mohd.yousuf and othersr, wherein
also it was contended that when a document is admitted and marked as
exhibit, it could not be questioned except under Section 6l in view of
interdict contained under Section 36 of Indian Stamp Act, it was held that:
No doubg Section 36 of the Act created an interdict to raise an
objection about admissibility of document, once admitted, except under
Section 61, it is the duty of the court to apply its mind about the
admissibility and determine judicially but the Presiding gfficer failed to
look into the admissibility of the document for want of stamp duty and
penalty. Putting signature on the stamp of marking on the document
cannot be considered as admission of a document in evidence. when
similar issue came up before Division B"n".h of this court in
w.P.No.29434 of 2or3, dated 12.02.2014, placing reliance on judgment
of Apex court in RV.E.venkatachala Gounder v. Arurmigu
viswesaraswami [AIR 2003 sc 454g] and v.p.Temple and another
and Ram Rattan (dead) by regat representatives v. Bajranrar and
others [AIR 1978 sc 1393] drawn distinction between admitting in
evidence and marking of document. Marking of a document is only for
convenient reference, whereas, admitting document is taking the
document as evidence after apprying judicial mind. tn view of principle
laid down in RV.E. venkatachara Gounders case
[AIR 2003 sc 454g]
and Ram Ratran (dead) by LRs case [AIR l97g sc 1393], the parties can
raise objection as to admissibility of document and mere marking of
t
c.R.P.No.l7o 9 of 2023
t- 4b
9of13
NNR, J
cRP i2796.0t9
do:ument for convenience of reference would not preclude the parties to
rai;e objection as ro the admissibility. In RV.E.Venkatachala
Goun6srs case [AIR 2003 SC 4548], the Apex Court is of the view that
merely because a document is marked as exhibit an objection as to its
adrnissibility is not excluded and is available to be raised even at a later
sta.ge or even in appeal or revision. Similarly in Ram Rattan's case
[AIR
1978 SC 1393], the Supreme Court is of the view that when the document
wa; tendered in evidence by the plaintiffwhile in witness box, objection
has been raised by the defendants that the document was inadmissible in
evi,lence as it was not only insufficiently stamped, but also for want of
registration, it was obligatory upon the leamed trial judge to apply his
mirrd to the objection raised and decide the objection in accordance with
law. Tendency sometimes is to postpone the decision to avoid
intemrption in the process of recording evidence and therefore, a very
convenient device is resorted to, of marking the document in evidence
subject to ob.iection. However, would not mean that the objection as to
adnissibility on the ground that the instrument is not duly stamped is
judi:ially decided; it is merely postponed. In such a situation at a rater
stago before the suit is finally disposed of it would none-the-less be
obli;3atory upon the court to decide the objection. The endorsement made
by the learned trial Judge that objected, altowed subject to objection,
clea{y indicates that when the objection was raised, it was not judicially
determined arrd the document was tentatively marked and in such a
situation, section 36 would not attract. Though facts are different, the law
laid down by the courts time and again is that to admit a document in
evidt:nce the court has to apply its mind and decide the admissibility of
document in evidence, judicially, mere marking for convenience of
refer,mce itself would not amount to admitting the document by applying
judicial mind and it is not a judicial determination as to the admissibility
of document in evidence. section 35 created clear embargo against acting
upon insuffrciently stamped document for any purpose. Any purpose
10 of 13
I.INR, J
cRP 2796 20t9
would include collateral purpose. Even if both parties gave consent for
marking insufficiently stamped document, it shall not be act upon, more
particularly to enforce the right of parties under contract of sale, unless it
falls under any clauses of proviso. The present document does not fall
within any of the clauses of proviso to Section 35of the Act, when
document shall not be acted upon admitting the same by consent would
mean that it is the duty of the Court to decide admissibility of document
in evidence judicially.
In such situation, the bar under Section 36 of the Act would not come
in the way of the parties to raise an objection as to the admissibility'of the
document. ln the present case except affixing stamp giving numerical
number to the possessory contract of sale as Ex.A.l, signing thereon by
officer, nothing discloses about the judicial determination of admissibility
of possessory contract of sale. The provisions of Stamp Act are fiscal in
nature and such provisions have tb be construed strictly, at the same time,
it is the duty of the office to decide or determine judicially about
admissibility of the document, irrespective of objection to avoid loss of
revenue to the State. In the absence of any judicial determination about
admissibility of the documen! the same can be questioned at a later stage
though stamp is affixed marking the document as exhibit.
The High Court of Andhra Pradesh (United) in Syed Yousuf Ali's
Case (cited supra) also held that:
When the documents were marked as exhibits in the absence of
defendant or his counsel and without considering the nature of the
document by the Court, assigning exhibit number cannot be said to be
admitted in evidence and interdict contained in Section 36 would not
come to the aid of the party in whose evidence the document was marked
as exhibit without any judicial determination, totally debaning the
adversary to challenge the admissibility of document in evidence. In
Vemireddy Kota Reddy's Case [2004(3)ALD 187], single Judge of this
Court relied on Javer Chand and others v. Pukhraj Surana to
11 of13
NN& J
cRP_27962019
conclude that marking of a document is assigning exhibit number rvithout
jucicial determination would not amount to admitting document in
evidence and such objection can be raised at later point oftime.
Whereas, leamed counsel for the respondents placed reliance in
T.I{agaratnam's case [2006 (3) ALD 838], so also lWNarasimhulu's
case [1996 Law Suit (AP) 4471and Isra Fatima's case [2002 Law Suit
83111. In all the three judgments, the single Judges of this Court decided
the bar contained under Section 36 of Indian Stamp Act holding that until
anc unless there is a judicial determination it cannot be said that it has
been admitted in evidence though it is marked. Mere marking of
document itself is not sufficient and there should be judicial
detr:rmination as to the nature of document and its admissibility. Further
the words admitted in evidence appearing under Section 36 of the Act
meirns admined after judicial consideration of objections relating to
adnrissibility. [n the absence of judicial determination marking of
document mechanically is an illegality. Even otherwise at any stage of
the suit the Court may reject any document which it considers irrelevant
or otherwise inadmissible in view of Order 13 Rule 3 CPC.
r\ccording to Orderl3 Rule 3 CPC the Court may at any stage of the
suit. reject any document which it considers irrilevant or otherwise
inadmissible, recording the grounds for such rejection. Order 13 Rule 4
CP() prescribes an endorsement to be made on the document when a
document is admitted in evidence. According to it, there shall be an
endrlrsement on every document which has been admitted in evidence
containing number and title of the suit, the name of the person producing
the rlocument, the date on which it was produced and a statement of its
having been so admitted and the endorsement shall be signed or initialled
by ttre Judge.
tr'lere there is an endorsement on the reverse of possessory contract of
sale consisting the details under Order 13 Rule 4(lXA) to (C), l(D) is
absetrt. Therefore, the document cannot be said to be admitted after
I
\
--
-\.
12 of 13
NNR, J
cRP 2796]019
judicial determination, in such a czrse, exercising power under Order 13
Rule 3 CPC, the Court can reject any document which it considers
irrelevant or in-admissible, recording reasons.
16. Having regard to the above submissions and the settled
legal position, this Court is of the view that the finding recorded
by the learned Agency Court is contrar5r to the settled principles
of law. The document in question ought not to have been
marked as €u1 exhibit unless and until the required stamp duty
and registration was paid. For the said reasons, the finding of
the Agency Court marking thq document as Ex.A-l is liable to be
set aside, so as to meet the ends ofjustice
L7. This Court is of the opinion that the present case is a fit
one wherein the document in question has to be sent for
impounding by the competent authority. Accordingly, the
Agency Court is directed to ensure tllat tJ'e said document is
forwarded to the District Registrar for the purpose of
determining and collecting the proper stamp duty and penalt5r,
in accordance with law. Until such time, Ex.A-l, though already
marked, need not be de-exhibited. However, the said document
shall not be looked into for any purpose, nor shall it be
13 of 13
NNR, J
cRP_2796_20 I 9
considereri while appreciating the facts of the case, unless and
until the requisite stamp duty and penalty is duly paid' Only
after paytnent of the required stamp duty and penalty' and
subject to compliance with the Stamp Act, the document may be
looked intc for only collateral purposes'
lE. With. these obsenrations and directions, the present Civil
Revision l'etition stands disposed of. There shall be no order as
to costs.
Miscellaneous applications, if any' \pending in this appeal
shall stanrl closed.
SD/-S MALLIKARJUNA RAO
ISTANT REGISTRAR
,,TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. TheAgent to GovernmenUDistrict Collector'
, Khammam District.
UC]
2. One CC 1.o Sri Kowturu Pavan Kumar, Advocate PUC]
3. One CC r.o Sri N V Anantha Krishna, Advocate [O
4. Two CD ,lopies
GNK/ABK
M
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 13/0312026
T t-t
Is
IE
o
CRP.No.12796 of 2019
U
1F, I:fr,q 1lf/E
*
:,-i..r.-i
i
'*.....".:.^
DISPOSING THE CRP
tef"l 2-c
rt,
t:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review