Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.20887 of 2025
======================================================
Kumari Sneha W/o Shri Akshay Mohan, Resident of Village- Husainpur, P.S.Rahui, District- Nalanda
1.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Food and
Civil Supplies, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.
The Bihar State Food and Civil Supplies Corporation, through its Managing
Director, Patna.
3.
The District Magistrate -cum- Chairman, District Transport Committee,
Nalanda.
4.
The District Transport Committee, through its Secretary, Nalanda.
5.
The District Manager -Cum- Secretary, District Transport Committee,
Nalanda.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the State
For the BSFC
:
:
:
Mr. Hansraj, Advocate
Mr. Sajid Salim Khan, SC 25
Mr. Shailendra Kumar Singh, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR VERMA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE)
Date : 21-07-2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The present writ application has been filed for the
following reliefs :“1. i. For issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari
or any other appropriate writ, order or direction for
quashing / setting aside the Letter bearing Memo No.
1129 dated 02.12.2024 (Annexure- P/4) issued under
the signature of the District Manager, State Food
Corporation, Nalanda whereby and whereunder the
amount of Rs. three lakhs deposited by the petitioner
along with the tender has been forfeited and the
petitioner has been black-listed for five years for not
entering into an agreement with the Corporation,
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
2/9
despite having been selected.
ii. For issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari or
any other appropriate writ, order or direction for
setting aside the decision of the District Transport
Committee, Nalanda, in so far as it relates to the
petitioner, contained in Memo no. 1128 dated
02.12.2024 (Annexure-P/4), whereby it has been
decided that the amount of Rs. three lakhs deposited by
the petitioner along with the tender has been forfeited
and the petitioner has been black-listed for five years
for not entering into an agreement with the
Corporation, despite having been selected.
iii. For issuance of consequential writ in the nature of
writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order
or direction, commanding the respondents to release the
amount of Rs. three lakhs submitted at the time of
submission of tender
iv. For any other relief/reliefs for which petitioner is
entitled under law as well as on facts.”
3.
The present writ petition arises out of Notice
Inviting Tender (NIT) No. 573 dated 26.06.2024 issued by the
Bihar State Food and Civil Supplies Corporation Limited
through the District Manager, Nalanda, for selection and
empanelment of contractors for doorstep delivery transportation
of food grains in the district of Nalanda. The petitioner
participated in the tender process and was declared technically
qualified along with eight other bidders. Upon opening of the
financial bids, Mukesh Kumar was declared the L-1 bidder,
while the petitioner and seven others were placed in the L-2
category. After negotiations with the L-1 bidder, the negotiated
rate of SOR + 6.25% (Rs. 38.25 per quintal) was approved by
the District Transport Committee, Nalanda. The petitioner, along
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
3/9
with the other successful bidders, submitted her consent to
execute the work at the approved L-1 rate and was declared
selected, with directions to execute the agreement.
4. Before execution of the agreement, however, the
petitioner submitted a representation requesting permission to
execute the work at SOR + 20% (Rs. 43 per quintal), stating that
the approved rate was commercially unviable in view of the
loading and unloading charges payable to labourers and other
transportation expenses. In the alternative, the petitioner sought
refund of the earnest money deposit of Rs. 3,00,000/-. The
District Transport Committee, in its meeting held on
02.12.2024, rejected the petitioner’s representation on the
ground that she had failed to execute the agreement despite her
selection at the approved rate and resolved to forfeit her earnest
money deposit and blacklist her for a period of five years. The
said decision was communicated to the petitioner vide Memo
Nos. 1128 and 1129, both dated 02.12.2024. Aggrieved thereby,
the petitioner has preferred the present writ petition challenging
the forfeiture of the earnest money deposit and the order of
blacklisting.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
although the petitioner had initially consented to execute the
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
4/9
work at the negotiated L-1 rate, she subsequently found the rate
to be commercially unviable and, therefore, requested the
District Transport Committee to permit execution of the work at
SOR + 20% or, in the alternative, to refund the earnest money
deposit. It is contended that the said representation was rejected
without proper consideration and the petitioner was blacklisted
for five years and her earnest money deposit was forfeited
without issuance of any show-cause notice or affording her an
opportunity of hearing, in violation of the principles of natural
justice.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents submits that
the impugned action has been taken strictly in accordance with
Clause 12(c) of the NIT, which provides that where a selected
bidder fails to furnish the requisite security deposit or execute
the agreement, the contract shall stand terminated, the security
deposit shall be forfeited, and the bidder shall be debarred from
participating in BSFCSCL tenders for a period of five years. It is
further submitted that the petitioner has selectively relied upon
the tender conditions while suppressing the complete text of
Clause 12(c), under which the impugned forfeiture and
debarment have been effected.
7. The limited issue which arises for consideration
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
5/9
before this Court is as to whether, when Clause 12(c) of the
Notice Inviting Tender provides only for debarring a selected
bidder from participating in BSFCSCL tenders for five years
upon failure to execute the agreement, the respondents were
justified in passing an order blacklisting the petitioner.
8. Clause 12(c) of the Notice Inviting Tender
prescribes the consequence of a selected bidder failing to
furnish the requisite security deposit or execute the agreement.
The clause reads as under:
“12 (c) In the event of Tenderer's failure, after the
communication of acceptance of the tender by the
Corporation, to furnish the requisite Security Deposit
under clause 12 (a) by the due date, his Contract shall
be summarily terminated besides for feature of the
Security and the Corporation shall proceed for
appointment of another contractor. Any losses or
damages arising out of and incurred by the Corporation
by such conduct of the contractor will be recovered
from the contractor, without prejudice to any other
rights and remedies of the Corporation under the
Contract and Law. The contractor will also be debarred
from participating in any future tenders of the
Corporation for a period of five years. After the
completion of prescribed period of five years, the party
may be allowed to participate in the future tenders of
BSFCSCL provided all the recoveries/dues have been
affected by the Corporation and there is no dispute
pending with the contractor/party."
9. A plain reading of the aforesaid clause shows that
the
tender
conditions
specifically
provide
for
three
consequences, namely, (i) termination of the contract, (ii)
forfeiture of the security deposit, and (iii) debarment from
participating in BSFCSCL tenders for a period of five years.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
6/9
Notably, the clause does not provide for blacklisting of the
selected bidder.
10. The terms “debarment” and “blacklisting” are not
synonymous. While debarment under a tender condition is a
contractual consequence restricting participation in future
tenders of the concerned procuring entity for the specified
period, blacklisting is a stigmatic administrative action having
wider civil and commercial consequences. The Supreme Court
in Kulja Industries Ltd. v. Chief General Manager, Western
Telecom Project, BSNL, reported in (2014) 14 SCC 731,
observed that blacklisting is an inherent executive power of the
State, but its exercise has serious civil consequences and must
be traceable to law and exercised fairly. The relevant para of the
said order reads as follows:
“17. That apart, the power to blacklist a contractor
whether the contract be for supply of material or
equipment or for the execution of any other work
whatsoever is in our opinion inherent in the party
allotting the contract. There is no need for any such
power being specifically conferred by statute or
reserved by contractor. That is because “blacklisting”
simply signifies a business decision by which the party
affected by the breach decides not to enter into any
contractual relationship with the party committing the
breach. Between two private parties the right to take
any such decision is absolute and untrammelled by any
constraints whatsoever. The freedom to contract or not
to contract is unqualified in the case of private parties.
But any such decision is subject to judicial review when
the same is taken by the State or any of its
instrumentalities. This implies that any such decision
will be open to scrutiny not only on the touchstone of
the principles of natural justice but also on the doctrine
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
7/9
of proportionality. A fair hearing to the party being
blacklisted thus becomes an essential precondition for a
proper exercise of the power and a valid order of
blacklisting made pursuant thereto. The order itself
being reasonable, fair and proportionate to the gravity
of the offence is similarly examinable by a writ court.”
11. Likewise, in UMC Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Food
Corporation of India, reported in (2021) 2 SCC 551, the Court
recognized that blacklisting is a distinct penal measure affecting
future business relations with the State and cannot be treated as
an ordinary contractual consequence. The relevant para of the
said order reads as follows:
“13. At the outset, it must be noted that it is the first
principle of civilised jurisprudence that a person
against whom any action is sought to be taken or whose
right or interests are being affected should be given a
reasonable opportunity to defend himself. The basic
principle of natural justice is that before adjudication
starts, the authority concerned should give to the
affected party a notice of the case against him so that
he can defend himself. Such notice should be adequate
and the grounds necessitating action and the
penalty/action proposed should be mentioned
specifically and unambiguously. An order travelling
beyond the bounds of notice is impermissible and
without jurisdiction to that extent. This Court in Nasir
Ahmad v. Custodian General, Evacuee Property has
held that it is essential for the notice to specify the
particular grounds on the basis of which an action is
proposed to be taken so as to enable the noticee to
answer the case against him. If these conditions are not
satisfied, the person cannot be said to have been
granted any reasonable opportunity of being heard.
14. Specifically, in the context of blacklisting of a
person or an entity by the State or a State Corporation,
the requirement of a valid, particularised and
unambiguous show-cause notice is particularly crucial
due to the severe consequences of blacklisting and the
stigmatisation that accrues to the person/entity being
blacklisted. Here, it may be gainful to describe the
concept of blacklisting and the graveness of the
consequences occasioned by it. Blacklisting has the
effect of denying a person or an entity the privileged
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
8/9
opportunity of entering into government contracts. This
privilege arises because it is the State who is the
counterparty in government contracts and as such,
every eligible person is to be afforded an equal
opportunity to participate in such contracts, without
arbitrariness and discrimination. Not only does
blacklisting take away this privilege, it also tarnishes
the blacklisted person's reputation and brings the
person's character into question. Blacklisting also has
long-lasting civil consequences for the future business
prospects of the blacklisted person.”
12. In the present case, the respondents have
purported to blacklist the petitioner, whereas Clause 12(c)
authorizes only debarment from participating in BSFCSCL
tenders for five years. It is well settled that the rights and
liabilities of the parties in a tender are governed by the terms of
the tender itself, and the authority cannot travel beyond the
conditions incorporated therein. Once the NIT consciously
provides for debarment as the prescribed consequence, the
respondents could not substitute it with the more onerous
consequence of blacklisting.
13. Accordingly, this Court holds that while the
respondents might be entitled to impose the consequences
expressly stipulated under Clause 12(c), including forfeiture of
the security deposit and debarment from participation in
BSFCSCL tenders for five years, they were not justified in
passing an order blacklisting the petitioner, as such a
consequence is not envisaged under the tender conditions.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20887 of 2025 dt.21-07-2026
9/9
Therefore, the issue framed is answered in favour of the
petitioner.
14. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
the impugned order dated 02.12.2024 (Annexure-P/4) is hereby
set aside to the extent it deals with the present Writ Petitioner,
i.e., Kumari Sneha.
15. The matter is remitted to the respondent
authorities to pass a fresh order as may be permissible strictly in
accordance with the terms of the Notice Inviting Tender and
applicable law.
16. Accordingly, the present writ petition stands
allowed.
17. The forfeited security deposit, if any, shall be
refunded to the petitioner within a period of four weeks from the
date of receipt or production of a copy of this order.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Sudhir Singh, ACJ)
(Rajesh Kumar Verma, J)
Vanisha/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
AFR
NA
27.07.2026
NA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review