Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 3363/2022
Kum. Ishita Lalwani D/o Shri Mahendra Kumar Lalwani, Aged
About 25 Years, R/o 5/24, S.F.S. Agarwal Farm, Mansarovar,
Jaipur-302020 (P.S. Shipra Path, Mansarovar).
----Claimant/Appellant
Versus
1.
Ramesh Kumar Son Of Srilal, Aged 53 Years, Resident of
Imarlota, P.S. And Tehsil Charkhi Dadri, District Bhiwani
(Haryana) (Owner & Driver Truck No. HR-46-B-7492)
2.
Chola Mandalam M.S. General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Dara House, Second Floor No. 234, N.S.C. Bora Road,
Chennai
and
E-52,
Second
Floor,
A.R.G.
Building,
Chitranjan Marg, C-Scheme, Jaipur through Regional
Manager (Insurance Co. Truck No. HR-46-B-7492)
----Non-claimants/Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Sandeep Mathur, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Virendra Agrawal, Adv. (for
respondent No.2)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
Order
Date of Arguments Concluded
:
14/11/2025
Date of Judgment Reserved
:
14/11/2025
Full/Operative Part Uploaded
:
Full
Date of Judgment Pronounced
:
20/01/2026
1.
This appeal has been filed by the claimant-appellant against
the impugned judgment dated 19.09.2022 passed by learned
Special Court, Printing and Stationary Embezzlement Case and
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jaipur, District Jaipur (hereinafter
(2 of 7)
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
referred
to
as
learned
'Tribunal')
[CMA-3363/2022]
in
M.A.C.
No.
790/2017
(52/2016), whereby, the claim petition filed by the claimantappellant has been dismissed.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the claimant-appellant
along with her parents, was travelling by Car No. RJ-14-CN-5536
from Jaipur to Udaipur on 26.03.2013. Father of the claimantappellant was driving the aforesaid car. At about 6 pm, a truck No.
HR-46-B-7492, allegedly being driven rashly and negligently by its
driver-respondent No.1, hit the aforesaid car. As a result of the
collision, claimant-appellant sustained serious injuries. An F.I.R.
No. 89/2013 was lodged in Police Station Chanderiya, District
Chittorgarh on 26.03.2013. According to the site plan dated
28.03.2013, it has been mentioned that due to bursting of the
tyre of the aforesaid car; it crossed the divider and stopped in the
middle of the road and in the meantime, the offending vehicle i.e.
truck approached from opposite direction and hit the car.
Moreover, the same manner of the accident was stated in the
statement of the claimant and her mother recorded under section
161 Cr.P.C. In pursuance of the investigation in the said F.I.R., a
charge-sheet under Section 279, 337 and 338 of I.P.C. was filed
against the truck driver-respondent No.1 on 20.04.2013. It is
pertinent to mention here that after filing of the said chargesheet, respondent No.1 i.e. driver of the offending vehicle had also
confessed his guilt of causing the accident due to his rash and
negligent driving on 07.08.2021. The claimant-appellant claimed a
sum of Rs.32,20,00,000/- as compensation before the learned
tribunal, as she has sustained permanent disability of 100% due
to 'paraplegia'.
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
3.
(3 of 7)
[CMA-3363/2022]
At the very outset, learned counsel for the claimant-
appellant contends that learned Tribunal vide impugned award
dated 19.09.2022, held that since the claimant-appellant has
failed to prove negligence on the part of the truck driverrespondent No.1 in the said accident, therefore, the claimantappellant is not entitled to get any compensation and thereby,
dismissed the claim petition. While dismissing the said claim
petition, learned Tribunal relied upon the decision passed by the
Coordinate Bench at the Principal Seat, Jodhpur in the case of
Mukesh Vs. Pradeep Kumar & Ors. (S.B Civil Misc. Appeal
No. 580/2014) decided on 03.12.2015, wherein, it was observed
that mere filing of charge-sheet against the driver is not the
conclusive proof of rash and negligent driving qua the driver for
causing the accident. Hence, being aggrieved with the said
dismissal, the present appeal has been filed by the claimantappellant to quash and set aside the impugned award dated
19.09.2022 passed by learned Tribunal.
4.
Learned counsel further contends that the learned Tribunal
has decided the claim petition as if it was a criminal case. It is the
settled law that the strict proof of fact is required in a criminal
case, whereas the claim petitions are decided on the basis of
preponderance of probabilities.
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent No.2 opposes the prayer
made on behalf of the claimant-appellant and contends that there
is no infirmity or illegality in the impugned judgment. Hence, the
present appeal be dismissed.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
7.
(4 of 7)
[CMA-3363/2022]
Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the
present case; that the charge-sheet has been filed against the
driver of the offending vehicle; the fact that after the filing of the
charge-sheet and the fact that driver of the offending vehicle also
confessed guilt of causing accident due to his rash and negligent
driving, this Court is of the opinion that negligence on the part of
driver of the offending vehicle is not required to be proved
separately by the claimant-appellant, as filing of the charge-sheet
is itself sufficient to decide the claim case. The Hon'ble Apex Court
in the case of Ranjeet & Anr. Vs. Abdul Kayam Neb & Anr.
[SLP (C) No. 10351/2019] decided on 25.02.2025, has held as
below:-
" 4. It is settled in law that once a charge
sheet has been filed and the driver has
been held negligent, no further evidence
is required to prove that the bus was
being negligently driven by the bus driver.
Even if the eye-witnesses are not
examined, that will not be fatal to prove
the death of the deceased due to
negligence of the bus driver.
5. In view of the aforesaid facts, we are
of the opinion that the Tribunal and the
High Court both manifestly erred in law in
refusing to grant any compensation to the
claimants.
6. In the facts and circumstances of the
case, we would have remitted the matter
to the Tribunal for determination of the
compensation to be payable to the
claimants."
8.
Further, in the present case, not only the charge-sheet has
been filed but the cognizance against the driver of the offending
vehicle has also been taken by the concerned court along with his
confession of guilt of causing the accident due to rash and
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
(5 of 7)
[CMA-3363/2022]
negligent driving, which has also been placed on record. The
observation made by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Rajani Sahoo &
Ors. [SLP (C) No.29302/2019] decided on 02.01.2025, is
reproduced hereinbelow:“9. Thus, there can be no dispute with
respect to the position that the question
regarding negligence which is essential
for passing an award in a motor vehicle
accident claim should be considered
based on the evidence available before
the Tribunal. If the police records are
available before the Tribunal, taking note
of the purpose of the Act it cannot be
said that looking into such documents
for
the
aforesaid
purpose
is
impermissible or inadmissible.”
9.
On the point of negligence on the part of driver of the
offending vehicle, it is an admitted fact that the car of the
claimant-appellant was hit by the offending vehicle, while in use.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Kaushnuma Begum Vs.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd., reported in (2001) 2 SCC 9
decided on 03.01.2001, has held:"11. It must be noted that the jurisdiction of
the Tribunal is not restricted to decide claims
arising out of negligence in the use of motor
vehicles. Negligence is only one of the species of
the causes of action for making a claim for
compensation in respect of accidents arising out
of the use of motor vehicles. There are other
premises for such cause of action.
12. Even if there is no negligence on the part of
the driver or owner of the motor vehicle, but
accident happens while the vehicle was in use,
should not the owner be made liable for
damages to the person who suffered on account
of such accident? This question depends upon
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
(6 of 7)
[CMA-3363/2022]
how far the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher [(186173) All ER Rep 1 : (1868) 3 HL 330] can apply in
motor accident cases. The said rule is
summarised by Blackburn, J., thus:
“[T]he true rule of law is that the
person who, for his own purposes,
brings on his land, and collects and
keeps there anything likely to do
mischief if it escapes, must keep it in
at his peril, and, if he does not do so,
he is prima facie answerable for all the
damage
which
is
the
natural
consequence of its escape. He can
excuse himself by showing that the
escape was owing to the plaintiff's
default, or, perhaps, that the escape
was the consequence of vis major, or
the act of God; but, as nothing of this
sort exists here, it is unnecessary to
inquire
what
excuse
would
be
sufficient.”
10.
Therefore, in light of the decisions rendered by the Hon'ble
Apex Court in the cases of Ranjeet (supra) and Rajani Sahoo
(supra) and Kaushnuma Begum (supra), it is an admitted
position in the present case, since the police records are available
on record, the learned tribunal ought to have consider the
legislative intent behind the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as it is a
beneficial legislation and a self-contained act with an object to
give effective relief to the victims and families of the motor
accident claims, also the fact that, since the charge-sheet has
already been filed and thereafter, the driver of the offending
vehicle also confessed the guilt of causing the alleged accident due
to his rash and negligent driving, hence, negligence on the part of
driver of the offending vehicle is not required to be proved
separately by the claimant-appellant, as filing of the charge-sheet
is itself sufficient to decide the claim case, this Court is of the view
that the matter requires reconsideration by learned Tribunal.
[2025:RJ-JP:51992]
11.
(7 of 7)
[CMA-3363/2022]
Hence, the present appeal is allowed. Accordingly, the
impugned judgment dated 19.09.2022 passed by learned Special
Court, Printing and Stationary Embezzlement Case and Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Jaipur, District Jaipur in M.A.C. No.
790/2017 is set aside and quashed. The matter is remanded back
to learned Tribunal with the direction to the learned tribunal to
decide the claim petition afresh, after giving opportunity of
hearing to both the parties, in accordance with law and the
principles of law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases
of Ranjeet (supra), Rajani Sahoo (supra) and Kaushnuma
Begum (supra) and other judgments which may be cited by the
parties before the learned Tribunal.
12.
Registry is directed to send the copy of this order to the
learned Tribunal along with the record for compliance of the same.
13.
It is directed that both the parties shall appear before
learned Tribunal on 23.02.2026. Learned Tribunal is directed to
decide the claim petition expeditiously as early as possible; not
beyond the period of 6 months from the first date of appearance
i.e. 23.02.2026.
14.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(ASHUTOSH KUMAR),J
AARZOO ARORA /104-S.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review