Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2241-DB
The date when
The date when
the judgment
the judgment is judgment is uploaded on
is reserved
17.10.2025
The date when the
pronounced
the website
Operative
Full
--
14.01.2026
14.01.2026
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Judgment reserved on: 17.10.2025
Judgment delivered on: 14.01.2026
FA(MAT) No. 25 of 2019
1 - Ku. Durgesh Nandani, D/o Brajmohan Duwa, Aged About 44 Years,
R/o Link Road Infront of Bukhari Petrol Pump Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.
2 – Smt. Santoshi Jangde, D/o Brajmohan Duwa, Aged About 38 Years,
W/o Venkat Ramn, R/o Village Chhatandanapur, Post And Tahsil
Mungeli, District Mungeli Chhattisgarh.
3 - (Deleted) Smt. Chandrakali As Per The Hon'ble Court Order Dated
20-06-2022.
... Appellants
versus
1 - Neelam Sharma, Daughter of Late Brijmohan Dua and Wife of Shri
Rajendra Sharma, Aged About 42 Years, Resident of Gondpara, Beside
Agrawal Saw Mill, Bilaspur, District - Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. (As Per
Hon'ble
Court
Order
Dated
06/05/2023
And
14/08/2023).
2 - Smt. Krishna Duwa, D/o Late Sitaram Duwa, W/o Late Govind
Mahendra, Aged About 68 Years, R/o Infront of Bukhari Petrol Pump,
Link Road, Bilaspur, Tahsil And District Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Appellants
:
Mr. B.P. Sharma along with Mr. K.N.
Singh, Advocate
For Respondent No.1 :
Mr. H. V. Sharma, Advocate
For Respondent No.2 :
Mr. Sandeep Jha along with Ms. Gunjan
Tiwari, Advocate
Hon'ble Smt. Justice Rajani Dubey
Hon’ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
CAV Judgment
Per Rajani Dubey, Judge
1. The present appeal has been preferred by the appellants against
the judgment and decree dated 29.07.2019 passed by the learned
Family Court, Bilaspur in Civil Suit No. 331-A/2019 whereby the
suit instituted by the appellants/plaintiffs seeking a declaration of
paternity against the defendant Brajmohan Duwa, was dismissed.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall hereinafter be
referred to in accordance with their respective status before the
learned Family Court.
2. As pleaded in the plaint, it was averred that plaintiff No. 3,
Chandrakali was married at the age of about 12–13 years to
Atmaprakash who was approximately 16 years old at the time of
marriage. From the inception of the marriage, Atmaprakash
adopted a neglectful and indifferent attitude towards plaintiff No. 3,
Chandrakali, and her family and led a detached life akin to that of
a sanyasi, being inclined towards spiritual pursuits. In the year
1984, Atmaprakash deserted plaintiff No. 3 and the family,
renounced worldly life by embracing asceticism and departed to
an unknown place; since then, his whereabouts have remained
untraced till date. It is further pleaded that during the period when
Atmaprakash was residing in the matrimonial home, the defendant
used to visit the house of plaintiff No. 3, and during such visits an
intimate relationship developed between the defendant and
plaintiff No. 3. As a result of the said relationship, plaintiff Nos. 1
and 2 were born to plaintiff No. 3 and the defendant. However,
despite the aforesaid facts, from that time onwards, the name of
Atmaprakash continued to be recorded as the husband of plaintiff
No. 3 and the father of plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 in the relevant
records.
The plaintiffs further averred that the defendant was
considered unmarried in the eyes of society. In the year 1971, the
defendant came into close association with plaintiff No. 3,
Chandrakali, and thereafter they started cohabiting in the nature
of husband and wife. Since 1971, the defendant has been residing
on Link Road. It was pleaded that the defendant, being a wealthy
and respected person of the city, did not publicly acknowledge
plaintiff No. 3 as his wife in order to safeguard his social
reputation. At the relevant time, inter-caste relationships were
socially frowned upon and not accepted; therefore, out of fear of
social stigma, the defendant refrained from conferring the status
of wife upon plaintiff No. 3. Nevertheless, it was asserted that
plaintiff No. 3 and the defendant have been living together
continuously since 1971 and were treated as husband and wife by
all concerned.
It was further pleaded that from the relationship between the
defendant and plaintiff No. 3, plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 were born,
whose upbringing, maintenance and welfare were continuously
taken care of by the defendant. Plaintiff No. 1 is unmarried and
plaintiff No. 2 contracted a love marriage, in which the defendant
extended full support and cooperation. It was alleged that the
plaintiffs repeatedly requested the defendant to acknowledge
plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 as his daughters and plaintiff No. 3 as his
wife and to confer legal status upon them; however, the defendant
merely
kept
assuring
them
without
formal
recognition.
Consequently, the plaintiffs prayed that plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 be
declared the daughters of the defendant and plaintiff No. 3 be
declared his legally wedded wife.
3. In the written statement, the defendant stated that considering his
advanced age, he does not desire any dispute and wishes to live
the remainder of his life peacefully. The defendant expressed his
willingness to accept all the claims made by the plaintiffs and
stated that he has no objection to the grant of the reliefs sought.
Accordingly, the defendant prayed that the suit be decided by
allowing the plaintiffs’ claims.
4. On the basis of pleadings made by both the parties, learned
Family Court framed the issues and after appreciating oral and
documentary evidence, by its judgment and decree dated
29.07.2019 dismissed the application filed by the plaintiffs. Hence,
this appeal.
5. Learned counsel for the appellants submit that the impugned
judgment and decree dated 29.07.2019 are bad in law, being
illegal, perverse, arbitrary, unreasonable, unwarranted, unjust and
mala fide and are therefore liable to be set aside. It is further
submitted that the learned Family Court failed to appreciate that
the defendant had categorically admitted the entire claim of the
appellants and in view of such admission, nothing further
remained to be proved by the appellants. The learned Family
Court also erred in ignoring the mandate of Section 58 of the
Indian Evidence Act, which provides that facts admitted need not
be proved. In the present case, since the defendant admitted the
entire claim of the appellants, the insistence on further proof was
wholly unwarranted.
It is further submitted that even assuming for the sake of
argument that the marriage between appellant No.3 and the
respondent was not valid, the learned Family Court could not have
curtailed or denied the legal entitlement and maintenance rights of
appellant Nos.1 and 2.
Lastly, the learned Family Court failed to consider that there
has been no trace or information regarding Atmaprakash for
several years. In such circumstances, a presumption of death
ought to have been drawn in accordance with the provisions of the
Indian Evidence Act.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the
appellants humbly submit that the impugned judgment and decree
deserve to be quashed and set aside and the appeal be allowed
in the interest of justice.
6. Learned counsel for respondent No.1 submits that respondent
No.1 is the legal heir of late Brajmohan Duwa and that she has
filed Civil Suit No. 80A/2019, which is pending adjudication before
the learned District Court.
7. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 supports the impugned
judgment and submits that the learned Trial Court has minutely
appreciated the oral as well as documentary evidence available
on record and has rightly dismissed the suit filed by the
appellants. It is contended that plaintiff No.3, Chandrakali, was
married to another person in the year 1960 and plaintiffs No.1 and
2 were born during the subsistence of the said marriage;
therefore, they are not entitled to any declaration of paternity as
they cannot be treated as the daughters of late Brajmohan Duwa
in view of Section 112 of the Evidence Act. It is further submitted
that the present suit was filed by the appellants/plaintiffs against
late Brajmohan Duwa with an intention to claim his property. The
present litigation is not a simplicitor suit for declaration of
paternity, rather it involves several disputes and questions relating
to property. The learned Trial Court has passed the impugned
judgment after due consideration of the facts and circumstances
of the case and in accordance with settled principles of law;
hence, the judgment is well-reasoned and does not call for any
interference by this Court.
Reliance
has
been
placed
on
the
judgment
dated
28.01.2025 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ivan
Rathinam Vs. Milan Joseph in Criminal Appeal No. 413 of
2025, the order dated 19.04.2024 passed in Transfer Petition (C)
No. 2043 of 2023 (Dolly Rani Vs. Manish Kumar Chanchal),
and the order dated 07.02.2022 passed by this Court in WP No.
245 of 2021 (Smt. Neelam Sharma Vs. Brijmohan Dua and
others).
8. Heard counsel for the parties and perused the material placed on
record.
9. It is evident from the record of the learned Trial Court that plaintiffs
Durgesh Nandani and Smt. Santoshi Jangde along with late Smt.
Chandrakali, filed a civil suit against Brajmohan Duwa, which was
registered as Civil Suit No. 331-A/2019, seeking a declaration of
paternity on the ground that plaintiffs No.1 and 2 are the
daughters
of
Brajmohan
Duwa
and
that
plaintiff
No.3,
Chandrakali, be declared the legally wedded wife of Brajmohan
Duwa.
10. Late Brajmohan Duwa also filed his written statement on the
same day, i.e., on 16.05.2019, when the suit was registered,
wherein he admitted the allegations made by the plaintiffs and
prayed that the suit be decreed in their favour.
11. On the basis of the pleadings of both the parties, the learned
Trial Court framed the following issues, which read as under:द
क
न
क
क 03
01.
क
ज हन
बर
र
?
अ
03.
" र
गण
02.
थ
र न र
ह ध
न ।
* क आ,
अ
ए 1
न ।
?
?
अ
र
12. After appreciating the oral as well as documentary evidence on
record, the learned Trial Court dismissed the suit filed by the
र्ष
नि
हीं
ली
मां
नी
चं
सा
के
दी
वा
मो
त
में
पु
ला
मा
व
प
सं
में
दि
मं
हीं
है
प्ति
के
का
कं
डि
सा
नु
णा
ष
घो
म
री
का
धि
ने
पा
के
य
य
वं
है
दि
वा
ति
सं
या
मा
हा
म
वा
वि
वै
दी
वा
या
तो
नु
ता
य
हा
स
ष
दि
का
या
मां
वा
plaintiffs on the ground that Chandrakali was the legally wedded
wife of Atmaprakash, that he was not impleaded as a party to the
suit, and that in all legal documents Atmaprakash was shown as
the father of plaintiffs No.1 and 2.
13. Learned counsel for the appellants vehemently submits that
since late Brajmohan Duwa himself admitted before the learned
Trial Court that he was in a relationship with Chandrakali and that
appellant Nos.1 and 2 are his daughters, and further admitted all
the allegations in his written statement, the learned Trial Court
erred in dismissing the suit filed by the plaintiffs.
14. The plaintiffs/appellants pleaded before the learned Trial Court
that Chandrakali was married to Atmaprakash, who left the
matrimonial home in the year 1984 and whose whereabouts
thereafter are not known, nor is it known whether he is alive or
dead. It was further pleaded that Chandrakali and Brajmohan
Duwa thereafter lived together as husband and wife and from their
relationship, Durgesh Nandani and Smt. Santoshi Jangde were
born.
15. In the matter of Ivan Rathinam (supra), Hon’ble Apex Court held
in paras 27, 28, 29 and 32 as under:“27. Before delving into the analysis, it is pertinent to
elucidate Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872:
"112. Birth during marriage, conclusive proof of legitimacy.
The fact that any person was born during the continuance
of a valid marriage between his mother and any man, or
within two hundred and eighty days after its dissolution,
the mother remaining unmarried, shall be conclusive proof
that he is the legitimate son of that man, unless it can be
shown that the parties to the marriage had no access to
each other at any time when he could have been
begotten."
28. The language of the provision makes it abundantly clear
that there exists a strong presumption that the husband is
the father of the child borne by his wife during the
subsistence of their marriage. This section provides that
conclusive proof of legitimacy is equivalent to paternity
{Aparna Ajinkya Firodia, supra note 3}. The object of this
principle is to prevent any unwarranted enquiry into the
parentage of a child. Since the presumption is in favour of
legitimacy. the burden is cast upon the person who asserts
illegitimacy to prove it only through 'non-access.'
29. It is well-established that access and non-access under
Section 112 do not require a party to prove beyond
reasonable doubt that they had or did not have sexual
intercourse at the time the child could have been begotten.
'Access' merely refers to the possibility of an opportunity for
marital relations {Mir Muzafaruddin Khan v. Syed Arifuddin
Khan, (1971) 3 SCC 810, para 6; Chilukuri Venkateswarlu
v. Chilukuri Venkatanarayana, ( 1953) 2 SCC 627, para 4}.
To put it more simply, in such a scenario, while parties may
be on non-speaking terms, engaging in extra-marital affairs,
or residing in different houses in the same village, it does
not necessarily preclude the possibility of the spouses
having an opportunity to engage in marital relations
{Banarsi Dass v. Teeku Dutta, (2005) 4 SCC 449; Kamti
Devi, supra note 2}. Non-access means the impossibility,
not merely inability, of the spouses to have marital relations
with each other {Aparna Ajinkya Firodia, supra note 3;
Sham Lal v. Sanjeev Kumar, (2009) 12 SCC 454}. For a
person to rebut the presumption of legitimacy, they must
first
assert
non-access
which,
in
turn,
must
be
substantiated by evidence.
32. In the case at hand, it is an admitted fact that when the
Respondent was begotten in 2001, his mother and Mr. Raju
Kurian were married. In fact, they had been married since
1989 and neither had ever questioned the validity of the
marriage. They were, admittedly, living under the same roof
from 1989 till 2003, when they decided to separate. It is, but
obvious, that the Respondent's mother and Mr. Raju Kurian
had access to each other throughout their marriage. This
conclusion has been arrived at through concurrent findings
of all the courts involved, at multiple stages of litigation.
Even if it is assumed that the Respondent's mother had
relations with the Appellant during her marriage and
especially when the Respondent was begotten, such a fact
per se, would not be sufficient to displace the presumption
of legitimacy. The only thing that such an allegation sheds
light on is the fact that there seems to have been
simultaneous access with the Respondent's mother, by the
Appellant and Mr. Raju Kurian. What, however, needs to be
clarified is that an 'additional' access or 'multiple' access
does not automatically negate the access between the
spouses and prove non-access thereof. Consequently,
there is a statutory mandate that the Respondent must be
presumed to be the son of Mr. Raju Kurian.”
16. Further in the matter of Dolly Rani (supra), Hon’ble Apex Court
held as under:“Section 7 of the Act reads an under:
"7. Ceremonies for a Hindu marriage.-(1) A Hindu marriage
may be solemnized in accordance with the customary rites
and ceremonies of either party thereto (2) Where such rites
and ceremonies include the Saptapadi (that is, the taking of
seven steps by the bridegroom and the bride jointly before
the sacred fire), the marriage becomes complete and
binding when the seventh step is taken."
Section 7 of the Act speaks about ceremonies of a Hindu
marriage. Sub-section (1) uses the word "solemnised". The
word "solemnised" means to perform the marriage with
ceremonies in proper form. Unless and until the marriage is
performed with appropriate ceremonies and in due form, it
cannot be said to be "solemnised". Further, sub-section (2) of
Section 7 states that where such rites and ceremonies include
the saptapadi, i the taking of seven steps by the bridegroom
and the bride jointly before the sacred fire, the marriage
becomes complete and binding when the seventh step is
taken. Therefore, requisite ceremonies for the solemnisation
of the Hindu marriage must be in accordance with the
applicable customs or usage and where saptapadi has been
adopted, the marriage becomes complete and binding when
the seventh step is taken. Where a Hindu marriage is not
performed in accordance with the applicable rites or
ceremonies such as saptapadi when included, the marriage
will not be construed as a Hindu marriage. In other words, for
a valid marriage under the Act, the requisite ceremonies have
to be performed and there must be proof of performance of
the said ceremony when an issue/controversy arise. Unless
the parties have undergone such ceremony, there would be no
Hindu marriage according to Section 7 of the Act and a mere
issuance of a certificate by an entity in the absence of the
requisite ceremonies having been performed, would neither
confirm any marital status to the parties nor establish a
marriage under Hindu law.”
17. Further it is held as under:“The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 solemnly acknowledges
both the material and spiritual aspects of this event in the
married couple's lives Besides providing a mechanism for
registration of marriages in order to confer the status of a
married couple and acknowledge rights in personam and
rights in rem, a special place is given to rites and ceremonies
in the Act. It follows that the critical conditions for the
solemnizing of a Hindu marriage should be assiduously,
strictly and followed. This is for the reason that the genesis of
a sacred religiously process cannot be a trivial affair. The
sincere conduct of and participation in the customary rites
and ceremonies under Section 7 of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 ought to be ensured by all married couples and priests
who preside over the ceremony.
The promises made to each by the parties to a Hindu
marriage and the oath taken by them to remain friends
forever lay the foundation for a life-long commitment between
the spouses which should be realized by them. If such
commitment to each other is adhered to by the couple, then
there would be far fewer cases of breakdown of marriages
leading to divorce or separation.
But in the instant case, the above parameters have not
been followed by the parties herein. In the circumstances, we
declare that the 'marriage dated 07.07.2021 between the
parties is not a 'Hindu marriage' having regard to the
provisions of Section 7 of the Act. Consequently, the
certificate issued by the Vadik Jankalyan Samiti (Regd) dated
07.07.2021 is declared null and void. In view of the above the
Certificate issued under the Uttar Pradesh Registration
Rules, 2017 dated 07.07.2021 is also declared null and void.
In view of the aforesaid declaration, it is further declared
that the petitioner and the respondent were not married in
accordance with the provisions of the Act and therefore, they
have never acquired the status of husband and wife.”
18. Plaintiff No.1- Durgesh Nandani and Plaintiff No.3- Chandrakali
filed their affidavits under Order 18 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil
Procedure before the learned Trial Court in support of the plaint.
Brajmohan Duwa also filed his affidavit under Order 18 Rule 4 of
the Code of Civil Procedure.
19. In his written statement as well as in his affidavit, Brajmohan
Duwa admitted that he had been in a relationship with
Chandrakali since the year 1971 and that Plaintiffs No. 1 and 2
are his daughters; however, due to fear of social stigma, he
refrained from conferring the status of wife upon Plaintiff No. 3.
20. Learned trial Court vide its judgment dated 29.07.2019 held in
paras from 11 to 14 as under:“11. उ
र
आ*
श
क 03
क1
उ;
द <
क
ज5
रह
ह
12-13
गअ 9
क
थ
5 क
कह
अ
र 72
उ
.
ह
द
क
ग
र
आ*
श
अ
र
क
ह
क
अ
और आ*
श
। इ
र आ*
श और
क
थ रह
।
क
ज हन
थ र
।
न
अ
उ;
12-13
क
, जब
।
,
।
कह
उ
आ*
ब
श
क ए
ह
थ
ह
ह
5 न
थ
क ।
12. जब
ध
य
र्षी
र्ष
व
ने
ली
व
में
जा
या
च
र्व
सा
व
र्ष
त
धि
व
र्ष
व
वा
वि
र्ष
व
कि
हीं
य
मां
नी
दि
वा
सा
नु
क्ता
रो
पू
सा
के
का
नु
मा
में
र्त
व
हा
है
के
स
जि
म
र्ष
वा
वि
व
ना
हो
है
का
र्ष
व
से
ने
ला
मा
वा
वि
मा
वा
सा
व
की
ली
की
में
यी
वा
में
वि
यी
र्शा
व
चं
नी
सा
सा
के
का
रा
स
भी
त
वा
वि
सा
नु
के
रा
धा
की
म
य
नि
ता
धि
वा
हि
वि
हो
ति
प
पू
र्व
नी
त
प
का
ली
वि
को
जी
चं
धु
व
व
की
में
तो
में
से
क्त
तु
नों
दो
प
कि
हो
य
म
के
वा
वि
कि
गा
हो
स
ति
प
त
वि
जी
को
का
धु
व
वै
दू
कि
स
दू
वि
के
के
व
ली
म
ला
हु
ति
मो
चं
का
र्ष
दि
ने
वा
सा
नु
स
र्ष
व
र्ष
था
व
लि
बा
से
क्ति
य
म
ना
का
म
ना
सा
के
प
वा
की
ली
चं
नु
है
ती
के
स
दी
वा
प
र्व
पू
त
के
ति
के
ति
का
म
जि
हो
र्ष
म
की
ली
चं
व
है
ती
ना
वा
वि
सा
हो
ली
नी
दि
वा
है
ता
हो
चं
म
स
हैं
ते
का
ने
ली
नी
दि
वा
है
ती
हो
चं
कि
है
ती
ना
हो
में
स
प
र्व
ना
बि
त
है
का
चु
हो
पू
प
न
हअ
ह
ई
C
,
5 उ
अ
5 (1)
न
र
करण
ई
र
ह
*
क
और
है
ता
जा
या
दि
में
हीं
र्ष
नि
मां
वा
स
तः
है
हीं
री
का
धि
के
ने
पा
ष
तो
नु
प्ति
म
णा
ष
घो
दी
वा
का
स
है
यी
पा
हीं
त
णि
मा
ना
हो
नी
प
वै
की
मो
दी
वा
ति
मां
दी
वा
सा
नु
क्ता
रो
प
है
ता
स
प
से
र्ग
सं
स
के
मो
दी
वा
ति
व
मां
दी
वा
कि
ती
स
जा
की
हीं
णा
धा
प
य
में
से
है
ता
हो
म
का
व
मां
दी
वा
रा
दौ
सी
है
ते
हो
र्ष
व
भ
ल
त
से
र्ष
व
वा
वि
का
ली
चं
मां
नी
दि
वा
त
र्था
है
ते
ना
सा
त
र्ष
व
सा
के
का
म
दी
वा
तु
प
है
या
कि
का
वी
ना
हो
नी
प
को
मां
दी
वा
था
त
त्री
पु
को
व
मां
दी
वा
में
य
त्री
प
प
ने
प
ने
मो
दी
वा
ति
मां
वा
है
ता
जा
या
दि
में
है
हीं
वै
वा
वि
ला
मा
व
र्ष
नि
का
य
ष
वि
बा
स
तः
है
य
शू
वं
वै
य
भी
ये
लि
स
है
की
ते
त
वि
जी
के
का
म
ति
प
र्व
पू
व
भी
तो
हो
भी
हु
वा
वि
ला
मा
व
में
र्ष
व
से
मो
दी
वा
ति
का
ली
चं
दी
वा
कि
ये
जा
या
लि
भी
मा
दि
य
है
त
खि
ल्ले
म
ना
का
का
म
ति
प
र्व
पू
में
पी
र्श
वं
पी
र्श
र्ड
का
धा
त
तु
रा
द्वा
दी
वा
है
या
या
ना
का
प
में
स
से
ही
ना
है
हीं
ष्टी
प
को
त
मृ
या
है
त
वि
जी
में
मा
र्त
व
व
है
की
हीं
को
बं
सं
के
स
प
है
यी
ता
ना
जा
ले
च
य
हीं
ने
का
दि
वे
में
बं
सं
के
ति
प
र्व
पू
ट्टी
छु
छो
जि
मा
सा
ना
है
हु
ला
त
से
ली
चं
तो
का
का
म
ति
प
र्व
पू
के
ली
चं
में
क्त
दू
है
य
शू
सा
नु
के
रा
धा
की
म
य
नि
धि
वा
वि
हि
व
तो
है
भी
या
कि
वा
वि
ला
मा
व
से
मो
ने
ली
च
दि
य
में
शा
सी
है
त
वि
जी
का
म
आ*
न
अ
श
13. उ
आ*
आ*
आ*
उ
कर
न
ऐ
ह
ब
गण
द
द
14.
थ
1984 क
क
ह
न
क 01
ज5
श
करण
क
आ
क
ई9
श
ज हन
श
क
क
र
। इ
।अ
इ
आ*
क 01
द
क
ज हन
हअ
अ
न
क
ड़
, रउ
ई कथन न
। ह
करण न
उ
C रब
आ र
द
ध और
उ
।
रह
,इ
र
ह धन
क 03
र
द
श
।
ध
इ
करण
01 ए
र
ह आ
न
क 02
ज हन
अ
श थ
कथन
क 03
*
थ रह
कह
क
ऐ
ज हन
गण
न क क 02
* क आ,
क न
र
आ
क
द
हअ धए
र
,
हउ
र
ज हन
ह
र 5
न
,
क 01
र5
अ
ग ग 24
उ* "
।
क
अ5 <
न
ग
।
क
ह
।अ
इ
।
गण
क 03
और उ
न
5 न
।
ध *
अ
।"
21. It is undisputed from the record that plaintiff No.3, late Smt.
Chandrakali, admittedly entered into a valid marriage with
Atmaprakash in the year 1960 and continued to reside with him till
the year 1984. There is no evidence on record to establish
dissolution of the said marriage either by decree of divorce or by
any recognized customary practice. In the absence of proof
regarding the death of Atmaprakash or severance of matrimonial
ties, the alleged varmaala marriage between Chandrakali and
Brajmohan Duwa in the year 1971, even if assumed to have taken
place, is hit by the mandatory provisions of Section 5(i) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and is rendered void under Section 11
thereof.
22. The learned Trial Court has rightly taken note of the fact that
Atmaprakash was neither impleaded as a party nor was his civil
status clarified, despite his name being reflected as the
husband/father in official documents, including Aadhaar Cards
(Ex.A/1 and Ex.A/2). The statutory presumption under Section 112
of the Indian Evidence Act was correctly applied, particularly in
view
of
the
admitted
cohabitation
of
Chandrakali
with
Atmaprakash during the relevant period when plaintiffs No.1 and 2
were born.
23. Merely because Brajmohan Duwa admitted his relationship with
Chandrakali and acknowledged plaintiffs No.1 and 2 as his
daughters, such admission, by itself, cannot override statutory
provisions nor confer legitimacy upon an otherwise void marriage
or displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy under law. An
admission, even if made voluntarily, cannot override the mandate
of statutory provisions.
24. This Court also finds substance in the conclusion of the learned
Trial Court that the circumstances surrounding the filing of the
written statement and affidavit by Brajmohan Duwa on the very
day of institution of the suit, without issuance of notice, further
weakens the plaintiffs’ case and does not inspire judicial
confidence.
25. Upon a careful and comprehensive consideration of the
pleadings, evidence both oral and documentary and the impugned
judgment passed by the learned Trial Court, this Court finds no
merit in the present appeal.
26. The learned Trial Court has meticulously analyzed the evidence,
correctly applied the relevant statutory provisions and arrived at
findings which are neither perverse nor illegal. The judgment
impugned is well-reasoned, based on proper appreciation of facts
and law and does not warrant interference by this Court in
appellate jurisdiction.
27. Accordingly, the appeal is devoid of merit and is hereby
dismissed.
28. Let a decree be drawn up accordingly.
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Rajani Dubey)
(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Judge
Ruchi
signed
RUCHI YADAV Digitally
by RUCHI YADAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review