The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. Accordingly, the impugned Order dated 15.12.2025 and also the observations therein on merits of the case are set aside. The appeal is allowed, and the Appellant is granted permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit in accordance with law.
24. It is clarified that nothing contained in this judgment shall be construed as an expression on the merits of the case.
25. The appeal, along with all pending applications, stands disposed of in the above terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Reserved on: 16.02.2026
Pronounced on: 08.04.2026
RFA(COMM) 102/2026 AND CM APPL. 10528/2026
KRISHAN CHAWLA
Through:
versus
SANJEEV JAIN AND ORS.
Through:
....APPELLANT
Mr. Subhankar Sengupta and
Mr. Narender Yadav, Advocate.
.... RESPONDENTS
Mr. Vinod Kumar Mantoo, Mr.
Hem Kumar and Ms. Niharika
Mantoo, Advs. for R-1 to 2.
Mr. Anuj Agarwal, Advocate
for R-3.
Mr. Mohd. Afaque, Advocate
for R-4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal assails the Order dated 15.12.2025
(hereinafter referred to as the “impugned order”) passed by the learned
District Judge (Commercial) (Digital-07), South-East District, Saket
Courts, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Commercial
Court”) in C.S. (COMM) No. 993/2025. By the impugned order, the
suit filed by the Appellant seeking reliefs of declaration and injunction
was dismissed as withdrawn simplicitor without liberty to file a fresh
suit.
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
2.
Briefly stated, the Appellant instituted a commercial suit on
01.12.2025 seeking, inter alia, a declaration that certain cash receipts
relied upon by Defendant No. 1 were false and fabricated, along with
consequential injunctive reliefs restraining their use and enforcement
of alleged rights arising from an agreement dated 01.02.2022
(executed on 01.08.2022). Along with the plaint, the Appellant filed
an application seeking exemption from pre-institution mediation under
Section 12A of the Act and an application under Order XXXIX Rules
1 and 2 CPC for interim relief.
3.
The matter was first taken up on 03.12.2025, when arguments
were heard on the application for interim relief. The Commercial
Court rejected the said application, inter alia, on account of noncompliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015
(hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) and observing certain other
defects like non-payment of adequate court fees, failure of plaintiff to
show bona fide behind statement made in the plaint reflecting no
cause of action. The detailed order was uploaded on 10.12.2025.
4.
In view of the observations made by the Commercial Court
regarding compliance with Section 12A of the Act and other defects,
the Appellant sought withdrawal of the suit with liberty to file afresh
after curing the defects. On 15.12.2025, such a request was made.
5.
However, the Commercial Court declined to grant such liberty
and treated the withdrawal as simpliciter, while further observing that
the plea of withdrawal is reflection of conformity that the plaint
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
disclosed no genuine cause of action and directing that a decree of
dismissal be drawn.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been filed.
7.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties and perused
the material placed on record.
8.
Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the grievance of
the appellant is two-fold. Firstly, that the Commercial Court erred in
refusing to grant liberty to withdraw the suit with permission to
institute a fresh suit after complying with the mandatory requirement
of pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Act and curing
other procedural defects, thereby effectively foreclosing the
Appellant’s remedy at the threshold. Secondly, that the Commercial
Court exceeded its jurisdiction by recording observation which were
somewhat conclusive findings on the merits, at the pre-summoning
stage, contrary to the settled scope of Order VII Rule 11 CPC, which
mandates that only the averments in the plaint be considered, and
further rendered observations inconsistent with its own earlier order
dated 03.12.2025, wherein it had observed that the issues required
adjudication at trial.
9.
Per contra, learned counsel for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3
supported the impugned order, contending that the Commercial Court
rightly examined the maintainability of the suit at the threshold and
correctly observed that the plaint disclosed no genuine cause of action.
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
10.
It is submitted that non-compliance with Section 12A of the Act
and deficiency in court fees justified such observation having the
effect of rejection of the plaint, and that the request for withdrawal
was not bona fide but an attempt to avoid an impending rejection
under Order VII Rule 11 CPC. It was further submitted that the
observation recorded by the Commercial Court were not mechanical
but were also based the observations made in the earlier order dated
03.12.2025, wherein the Court had already indicated serious
deficiencies in the suit.
11.
Learned counsel for Respondent No. 4 stated that he has no
objection to the appeal being allowed and liberty being granted to the
appellant to file a fresh suit.
12.
The principal question that arises for consideration is, whether
in the facts of the present case, the Commercial Court was justified in
refusing to grant liberty to the Appellant to withdraw the suit with
permission to institute a fresh suit under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC,
and in proceeding to record observations touching upon the merits of
the dispute at the pre-summoning stage.
13.
Order XXIII Rule 1(3) of the CPC: “ORDER XXIII
Withdrawal and Adjustment of Suits
1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of
claim –
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
…
(3) Where the Court is satisfied—
(a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal
defect, or
(b) that there are sufficient grounds for allowing
the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subjectmatter of a suit or part of a claim,
it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the
plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or
such part of the claim with liberty to institute a
fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such
suit or such part of the claim.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
14.
Order XXIII of the CPC is circumscribed by the requirement
that the Court must be satisfied that the suit suffers from a “formal
defect” or that there exist “sufficient grounds” warranting such liberty.
The Supreme Court in V. Rajendran v. Annasamy Pandian, (2017) 5
SCC 63, has held that “formal defect” must be given a liberal
interpretation and includes defects of a procedural nature, such as
insufficient court fee, improper valuation, want of notice, misjoinder
of parties, or failure to disclose a cause of action. The relevant portion
is reproduced herein below“10. In K.S. Bhoopathy v. Kokila [K.S. Bhoopathy
v. Kokila, (2000) 5 SCC 458] , it has been held that
it is the duty of the Court to be satisfied about the
existence of “formal defect” or “sufficient
grounds” before granting permission to withdraw
the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit under the
same cause of action. Though, liberty may lie with
the plaintiff in a suit to withdraw the suit at any
time after the institution of suit on establishing the
“formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”, such
right cannot be considered to be so absolute as to
permit or encourage abuse of process of court. The
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
fact that the plaintiff is entitled to abandon or
withdraw the suit or part of the claim by itself, is
no licence to the plaintiff to claim or to do so to the
detriment of legitimate right of the defendant.
When an application is filed under Order 23 Rule
1(3) CPC, the Court must be satisfied about the
“formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”. “Formal
defect” is a defect of form prescribed by the rules
of procedure such as, want of notice under
Section 80 CPC, improper valuation of the suit,
insufficient court fee, confusion regarding
identification of the suit property, misjoinder of
parties, failure to disclose a cause of action, etc.
“Formal defect” must be given a liberal meaning
which connotes various kinds of defects not
affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of
the parties.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
15.
In the present case, the defects noted by the Commercial Court
in its order dated 03.12.2025, namely deficiency in court fees, noncompliance with procedural requirements, and absence of supporting
documents, are procedural in nature and fall within the ambit of
“formal defects” as contemplated under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC.
Such defects are inherently curable.
16.
The suit was at a pre-summoning stage, and no vested right had
accrued in favour of the defendants. In such circumstances, an
opportunity to cure procedural defects ought ordinarily to be granted.
17.
The Commercial Court, however, declined liberty while
observing that the plea of withdrawal is reflection of conformity that
the plaint disclosed no genuine cause of action. This reflects a
conflation of distinct jurisdictions, as the scope under Order VII Rule
11 CPC is limited to examining the plaint on a meaningful reading of
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
its averments, without entering into merits as held by the Supreme
Court in Popat and Kotecha Property v. State Bank of India Staff
Association, (2005) 7 SCC 510, and Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji
Bhanusali, (2020) 7 SCC 366. Further, in T. Arivandandam v. T.V.
Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC 467, it has been held that the power to reject
a plaint is a drastic power, which must be exercised only where the
plaint, on a meaningful reading, not a formal, does not disclose a clear
right to sue and is manifestly vexatious and meritless, in the sense that
it does not disclose a clear right to sue.
18.
The Court, at this stage, cannot adjudicate disputed questions of
fact, or record conclusive findings on the merits or even observations
of such nature.
19.
In the present case, the Commercial Court travelled beyond this
limited inquiry by recording observations regarding lack of bona fides
and absence of a genuine cause of action, which were not warranted at
the pre-summoning stage.
20.
In absence of an actual rejection of the plaint under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC, the Commercial Court could not have indirectly nonsuited the Appellant by denying liberty under Order XXIII Rule 1(3)
CPC.
21.
The refusal to grant liberty, in the facts of the present case, has
the effect of attracting the bar under Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC,
thereby foreclosing the Appellant’s remedy despite the defects being
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
curable, which is unduly harsh. Procedural law is intended to facilitate
adjudication on merits and not to foreclose remedies at the threshold
on curable defects.
22.
This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that the
Commercial Court failed to exercise its discretion in accordance with
settled principles of law. The refusal to grant liberty and the
observations on merits are unsustainable.
23.
Accordingly, the impugned Order dated 15.12.2025 and also the
observations therein on merits of the case are set aside. The appeal is
allowed, and the Appellant is granted permission to withdraw the suit
with liberty to institute a fresh suit in accordance with law.
24.
It is clarified that nothing contained in this judgment shall be
construed as an expression on the merits of the case.
25.
The appeal, along with all pending applications, stands disposed
of in the above terms.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
RENU BHATNAGAR
(JUDGE)
APRIL 08, 2026/p/kz/nc
Signed
By:PRIYADARSHANI JAIN
13:34:10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review