Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
APHC010609402018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3566]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY,THE TWELFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA
SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2403/2018
Between:
1. KOTHAPALLI PRASAD, R/O. BOMMAIAHPALLI (V) SC
COLONY,
VEDURUKUPAAM
MANDAL,
CHITTOOR,
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
...APELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep. by its Public
Prosecutor, (AP) High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad.
...RESPODENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that
the High Court may be pleased to to present this Memorandum of
Grounds of Appeal questioning his Conviction and sentence in the
Judgement dated 24th November, 2018 in SC.no.166 of 2017 on the
file of the Court of III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Chittoor
at Tirupathi for the following and among other.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to condone the delay of 202 days in
perferring the appeal against the Judgement dated 24th November,
2018 in SC.no.166 of 2017 on the file of the Court of III Additional
District and Sessions Judge, Chittoor at Tirupathi
IA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to suspend the Sentence of Life
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
Imprisonment as per the Judgment dated 24.11.2017 in
S.C.No.166/2017 on the file of the III Additional District and Sessions
Judge at Tirupathi and release the petitioner on Interim Bail for a
period of three (03) months and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased pleased to suspend the sentence of
Life Imprisonment as per the Judgment dt. 24.11.2017 in S.C.
No.166/2017 on the file of the III Additional District and Sessions
Judge at Tirupathi and release the Petitioner on Interim Bail for a
period of three (03) months and pass such other
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased pleased to suspend the execution of
sentence of petitioners in SC No. 166 of 2017 dt. 24-11-2017 on the
file of the III Addl. District and Sessions Judge, Tirupathi and release
the Petitioner on bail on any conditions pending disposal of the
Appeal and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SUREPALLI MADHAVA RAO
2. LEGAL AID
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH ::
AMARAVATI
THURSDAY, THE TWELTH DAY OF MARCH, TWO
THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SURESH REDDY
AND
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2403 OF 2018
JUDGMENT
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.166 of 2017 on the file of
the Court of the learned III Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Tirupati, is the appellant in the present Criminal Appeal. He was tried
and convicted by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under
Section 302 IPC and was sentenced to suffer imprisonment for ‘Life’
and also to pay a fine of Rs.500/- (Rupees Five Hundred only), in
default to suffer Simple Imprisonment for a period of three (3)
months.
2.
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
Substance of the charge is that on the intervening night
of 26/27.11.2016 at about 1.00 a.m., while the accused was in sound
sleep, his wife K. Sumathi (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”)
tied his legs with a towel and attempted to kill him by pressing a
pillow on his face, but the accused woke up from sleep and pushed
the deceased aside, firmly pressed her neck and fisted on her chest,
as a result of which she fell unconscious on the TV stand, and in the
same process he picked up a pillow and pressed it on her face and
mouth and killed her, thereby committed an offence punishable
under Section 302 IPC.
3.
Case of the prosecution, briefly, is as follows:-
The accused is a resident of Bommaiahpalli Village,
Vedurukuppam Mandal. P.Ws. 3 and 4 are neighbours of the
accused. Marriage between the accused and the deceased was
solemnized on 12.12.2012 at the residence of the accused. They led
happy marital life for some time and were blessed with a son. Except
the household disputes, the couple lived happily.
(ii) While so, on the intervening night of 26/27.11.2016 at
about 1.00 a.m., the accused knocked the door of his neighbour,
P.W.3, and informed him that his wife was suffering from chest pain
and that he intended to take her to the hospital in an auto rickshaw.
P.W.4-the wife of P.W.3, also witnessed the same. P.W.3 then went
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
to the house of the accused and found the deceased lying
unconscious on a cot. Thereafter, the accused, along with the
deceased, their son and his father, boarded the auto to proceed to
Devalampet to consult a doctor. While proceeding to Devalampet,
P.W.3 drove the auto, and the accused telephoned to P.W.1 and
informed him that his wife was suffering from chest pain and asked
him to come.
(iii) Accused took the deceased to P.W.5-RMP Doctor at
Devalampeta. P.W.5, on examining the deceased, advised the
accused to take her immediately to the Government Hospital,
Chittoor. Thereafter, they started to Chittoor via Lakshmireddypalle,
the village of in-laws of the accused. The accused informed P.W.1
that they were proceeding via Lakshmireddypalle and requested
P.W.1
and
his
in-laws
to
come
Lakshmireddypalle.
By
the
time
to
the
the
main
road
at
auto
reached
Lakshmireddypalle, P.W.1 and the mother-in-law of the accused
were present on the main road. When P.W.1 enquired about the
condition of his sister, the accused stated that she was suffering
from chest pain. The mother-in-law of the accused and another
person boarded the auto, while P.W.1 followed them on his
motorcycle. The accused thereafter took the deceased to P.W.6another RMP Doctor at Kothapallimitta. P.W.6 examined her and
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
declared her dead. Thereafter, the accused brought the dead body
back to his residence.
(iv) P.W.2- relative of P.W.1, went to the house of accused
and found the dead body of the deceased lying in the verandah.
P.W.2 noticed certain injuries on the dead body, particularly on the
neck, lips and knee. He immediately informed P.W.1 and others.
Thereafter P.W.1 went to the police station and lodged a report.
(v) On the same day, i.e., on 27.11.2016, P.W.13-the then
Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police, Vedurukuppam Police Station,
received a report-Ex.P1 from P.W.1 and registered a case in Crime
No.72 of 2016 under Section 174 Cr.P.C. He issued copies of FIR to
all the concerned.
FIR is marked as Ex.P7. He also issued a
requisition to the Tahsildar for conducting inquest over the dead
body.
(v) P.W.12, the Tahsildar, Vedurukuppam Mandal, conducted
inquest over the dead body in the presence of mediators-P.W.9 and
another. Inquest report is marked as Ex.P2. In the inquest report, the
Panchayatdars opined that the deceased died due to the injuries
found on the neck, nose, right hand, upper lip and knees.
(vi) After registering the crime, the Investigating Officer,P.W.13, proceeded to the scene of offence at about 8.30 p.m. As it
was late in the night, he posted guards at the scene. On the next
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
day, at about 8.00 a.m., P.W.13 visited the scene of offence and
prepared an observation report-Ex.P8, in the presence of P.W.8 and
another. During the course of the observation proceedings, P.W.13
found broken glass pieces of a TV stand and seized the same, which
were marked as M.O.7. He also prepared a rough sketch-Ex.P9, at
the scene of offence. Thereafter, P.W.13 recorded statements of
P.Ws.1, 2 and others, and sent the dead body for post-mortem
examination.
(vii) P.W.11-Civil Assistant Surgeon, Community Health
Centre, Puttur, conducted autopsy over the dead body. He found
contusions on the inner side of the lower lip as well as the inner side
of the upper lip with bluish discoloration. On the basis of RFSL report
and the external injuries, he opined the cause of death was due to
pressure over the nose and mouth leading to airway obstruction,
resulting in asphyxia and cardio-respiratory arrest, culminating in
death. He issued his final opinion marked as Ex.P6. He further
stated that he did not find any symptoms of heart attack.
(viii) P.W.13 recorded statements of P.Ws. 3 and 4. He also
seized wearing apparel-MOs. 1 to 4 of the deceased under police
proceedings-Ex.P10.
(ix) Further investigation was taken over by P.W.14-Inspector
of Police, Karvetinagaram circle. On 07.12.2016, P.W.14-the
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
Inspector of Police, took up further investigation. On the same day,
P.W.8-Village Revenue Officer of Bommaiahpalli, brought the
accused and produced him before P.W.14, stating that the accused
confessed his guilt in the presence of panchayatdars- P.W.10 and
another. Ex.P3 is confessional statement of the accused. Pursuant
to the confession made by the accused, P.W.14 recovered a towel
and a pillow, marked as M.Os. 5 and 6, and seized them under a
panchanama marked as Ex.P4. He arrested the accused and
remanded him to judicial custody. He forwarded the material objects
to the Forensic Science Laboratory and received the RFSL reportEx.P12, which indicated that no poisonous substance was found in
the viscera of the deceased.
(x) On 16.3.2017, P.W.14 received final opinion-Ex.P6 from
P.W.11. After receiving all documents and after completion of
investigation, P.W.14 filed charge sheet.
4.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined PWs.1
to 14, got marked Exs.P.1 to P.12, apart from exhibiting MOs.1 to 7.
5.
When the accused was examined under Section 313
Cr.P.C., he denied the incriminating evidence found against him from
the prosecution witnesses. However, he did not choose to examine
any witness on his behalf but got marked Ex.D-1.
6.
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
Accepting the evidence of prosecution witnesses, the
learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted the appellant as
aforesaid.
7. Heard Sri Surepalli Madhava Rao, learned counsel for the
appellant as well as Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional
Public Prosecutor for the respondent-State.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant strenuously contends
that the prosecution has not adduced any evidence to establish
motive for the appellant to kill the deceased. He further submits that
neighbours-P.Ws. 3 and 4, did not speak about any harassment by
the appellant towards the deceased. He also contends that the
so-called extra-judicial confession cannot be relied upon, as P.W.8,
before whom the appellant is said to have made such confession,
did not support the prosecution. He further submits that there was
abnormal delay in lodging the report-Ex.P1 with the police by P.W.1.
He contends that the deceased fell down and suffered with heart
attack, and that it was the appellant who took the deceased to
doctors-P.Ws. 5 and 6. He further contends that, apart from the
appellant, other inmates were also present in the house. As such, he
contends that the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge are illegal and liable to be set aside.
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
9. On the other hand, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
contends that the deceased met with a homicidal death in the house
of the appellant. It is also admitted by the appellant that he was
present in the house at the time of the incident. He further submits
that P.W.11, the Medical Officer, in his post-mortem report-Ex.P6,
has categorically stated that the cause of death was due to pressure
exerted over the nose and mouth, leading to airway obstruction,
resulting in asphyxia and cardio-respiratory arrest, culminating in
death. He further submits that P.W.11, in his evidence, specifically
stated that there were no symptoms of heart attack.
10. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor further contends
that, in view of the provisions of Section 106 of Indian Evidence Act,
it is incumbent on the part of the appellant to explain as to how the
deceased met with a homicidal death in his house. Instead of
offering any plausible explanation, the appellant came up with a false
story of the deceased having fallen accidentally, which has been
negatived by the medical evidence adduced through P.W.11. As
such, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor requested this Court
to dismiss the appeal by confirming the conviction and sentence
recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
11. We have carefully scrutinised the entire evidence on
record.
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
12. According to the prosecution, the appellant used to quarrel
with the deceased suspecting her fidelity. However, the prosecution
failed to adduce any evidence to establish the alleged motive for the
appellant to kill the deceased. Neighbours-P.Ws. 3 and 4 also did
not whisper anything about any quarrels between the appellant and
the deceased. P.Ws. 3 and 4, in their evidence, stated that on the
intervening night of 26/27.11.2016 at about 1.00 a.m., the appellant
knocked their door and informed them that the deceased was
suffering from chest pain and that he intended to take her to the
hospital. They further stated that P.W.3 drove the appellant’s auto, in
which the deceased was first taken to P.W.5, an RMP Doctor, and
thereafter to another doctor, P.W.6, who confirmed the death of the
deceased.
13. The evidence of P.Ws. 1 and 2 disclose that injuries were
found on the neck, lips and knees of the deceased. On noticing
these injuries on the body of the deceased, P.W.1 lodged a reportEx.P1, with the police. Thus, it was only after observing the injuries
the criminal law was set in motion. Till then, the appellant had been
stating to P.W.1 and his relatives that the deceased was suffering
from chest pain. Subsequently, the appellant is said to have made
an extra-judicial confession before the Village Revenue Officer,
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
Bommaiahpalem, on 07.12.2016. However, P.W.8 did not support
the prosecution and was declared hostile.
14.
P.W.14-the
Investigating
Officer,
stated
that
on
07.12.2016, P.W.8 produced the appellant before him along with the
confessional statement-Ex.P3. Another witness, P.W.10, who was
working as Village Revenue Officer of Mambedu Panchayat, stated
that in his presence, P.W.8 produced the appellant before P.W.14,
before whom the appellant made confessional statement, Ex.P3.
However, as the so-called confessional statement-Ex.P3, was made
in the presence of the Investigating Officer- P.W.14, no credence
can be given to the said confession.
14. Further, if M.Os. 5 and 6 were used to kill the deceased,
the pillow ought to have contained saliva. Curiously, M.Os. 5 and 6
were not sent to the RFSL to ascertain whether any saliva was
present on the pillow cover or not. As such, the prosecution has
failed to establish the motive as well as the so-called extra-judicial
confession in the circumstances of the case.
15. Coming to the next evidence available on record, namely
the medical evidence through P.W.11, he stated in his evidence that
he found contusions on the inner side of the lower lip as well as on
the inner side of the upper lip with bluish discoloration. The evidence
of P.Ws.1 and 2 lends support to the medical evidence adduced
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
through P.W.11 to the effect that injuries were found on the body of
the deceased. It was only after noticing these injuries P.W.1 lodged
report-Ex.P1.
16. P.W.11, in his final opinion, stated that the cause of death
was due to pressure exerted over the nose and mouth, leading to
airway obstruction, resulting in asphyxia and cardio-respiratory
arrest, culminating in death. P.W.11 also categorically deposed that
he did not find any symptoms of heart attack. Thus, the evidence of
P.Ws. 1 and 2 stands corroborated by the medical evidence
adduced through P.W.11 coupled with Ex.P6. Consequently, the
prosecution was able to establish that the deceased met with
homicidal death in the house of the appellant.
17. In this connection, it is trite that the Hon’ble Apex Court in
a catena of judgments including the decision in Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda v. State of Maharashtra1, has laid down five (5) golden
principles, which govern a case based only on circumstantial
evidence:
“(1)
The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt
is to be drawn should be fully established.
(2)
The facts so established should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is
(1981) 4 SCC 116
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
to say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty.
(3)
The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature
and tendency.
(4)
They should exclude every possible hypothesis
except the one to be followed, AND
(5)
There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not
to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and
must show that in all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused.”
18. In the case on hand, the prosecution has established that
the deceased met with homicidal death in the house of the appellant.
The prosecution has also established that the appellant was present
in the house at the time of the incident. Apart from these
circumstances, no explanation has been forthcoming from the
appellant in terms of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act. Instead
of offering any explanation, the appellant came up with a false story
of chest pain. As such all the circumstances relied on by the
prosecution pointing guilt towards the appellant alone, but to none
others.
19. Having analysed the evidence carefully, we have no
hesitation to come to the conclusion that the appellant caused the
death of the deceased. As such, there are no grounds to interfere
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
with the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge.
20.
In the result, the present Criminal Appeal is dismissed,
confirming the conviction and sentence passed by the learned
III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirupati, in Sessions Case
No.166 of 2017, dated 24.11.2017. As the appellant/Accused was
released on bail, he is directed to surrender before the trial Court
forthwith. Failing which, the learned trial Judge is directed to take
steps to secure the presence of appellant by issuing warrants for
serving the remaining sentence of imprisonment. Needless to state
that the period already undergone by the appellant/Accused shall be
given set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Criminal Appeal,
shall stand closed.
________________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
_________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Date:12.03.2026
GR
KSR, J & AHHS,J
Crl.A.No.2403 of 2018
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SURESH REDDY
AND
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2403 OF 2018
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Date:12.03.2026
GR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review