Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010862202018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3397]
MONDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA
KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL NO: 1621/2018
Between:
Kothapalli Jagapathiramyya and Others
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
Vytla Srinivas
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. T V S PRABHAKARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. G V GANGADHAR
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT
Reserved on 31.01.2026
Pronounced on 09.02.2026
Uploaded on 09.02.2026
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL No.1621 of 2018
JUDGMENT:
This second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is
filed aggrieved against the judgment and decree, dated 13.07.2018, in
A.S.No.01 of 2015, on the file of the Senior Civil Judge Court,
Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari District, reversing the judgment and
decree, dated 21.08.2014, in O.S.No.125 of 2010, on the file of the Principal
Junior Civil Judge Court, Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari District.
2.
The plaintiff initiated action in O.S.No.125 of 2010, on the file of the
Principal Junior Civil Judge Court, Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari
District, with a prayer for declaration of right and title over the plaint schedule
property and for
consequential
permanent injunction restraining the
defendants with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the plaintiffs over
the plaint schedule property and for costs.
3.
The learned Principal Junior Civil Judge Court, Ramachandrapuram,
East Godavari District, dismissed the suit without costs. Felt aggrieved of the
same, the unsuccessful plaintiff in the above said suit filed the aforesaid
appeal before the first appellate Court. The learned Senior Civil Judge Court,
Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari District, allowed the appeal without costs
by setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Judge.
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Aggrieved thereby, the defendants approached this Court by way of second
appeal.
4.
The appellants herein are the defendants, the respondent herein is the
plaintiff in O.S.No.125 of 2010.
5. For the sake of convenience, both parties in the second appeal will be
referred to as they are arrayed in the suit O.S.No.125 of 2010.
6. The case of the plaintiff, in brief, as set out in the plaint averments in
O.S.No.125 of 2010, is as follows:
The plaintiff is the absolute owner of Ac.0.73 cents out of the total
extent of Ac.0.88 cents in S. No. 106/6, and the father of the plaintiff acquired
the property under a gift deed dated 24.04.1967. The plaintiff pleaded that his
father died intestate on 12.08.1989, and all the properties devolved upon his
legal heirs. On 31.10.1989, the grandmother of the plaintiff and the sister of
the plaintiff executed a relinquishment deed in favour of the plaintiff,
relinquishing their joint right in all the properties that devolved on them upon
the death of Vytla Veerraghava Rao, i.e., the father of the plaintiff. The plaintiff
further pleaded that he became the absolute owner of the properties covered
under the gift deed dated 24.04.1967 and that he is in possession of the
same. He also obtained pattadar passbooks and paid land revenue to the
Revenue Department.
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
The plaintiff further pleaded that the land belonging to defendant Nos. 1
and 2 is situated on the northern side of the plaint schedule property, covered
under Sy.Nos.106/5 and 105/4, and that, as the plaintiff is a landlord in their
village, defendant No. 1 and his son, who is defendant No. 3 herein, are
making hectic efforts to encroach upon the plaintiff‟s land situated on the
northern side of the plaint schedule property. The northern side of the land is
upland, admeasuring approximately Ac.0.10 cents, and the remaining
southern side of the plaint schedule property is cultivable land.
The plaintiff further pleaded that defendant Nos. 1 and 3 tried to
encroach upon the dimma land of the plaintiff, and the men of the plaintiff
obstructed them from committing such illegal acts. He further pleaded that the
defendants are making claims over the plaint schedule property and are
attempting to encroach upon the cultivable land of the plaintiff by proclaiming
in the village that they intend to purchase the same. The plaintiff apprehends
that the defendants are creating such litigation, i.e., making false claims over
the dimma land, so that the plaintiff would sell the land to the defendants at
the cheapest rate. As such, the plaintiff is constrained to file the present suit.
7. The case of the defendant No.3 as per the written statement filed by the
defendant No.3, which was adopted by the defendant Nos.1 and 2 is as
follows:
The defendants got their land measured in R.S.No.106/5 and surveyed
the same by the Mandal Surveyor, who fixed the boundaries and planted
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
stones. Defendant No.3 pleaded that the plaintiff high-handedly removed the
stones fixed by the Mandal Surveyor, and that when the defendants made a
complaint to the concerned authorities, the plaintiff, in order to stall the action
taken by the authorities and with a view to encroach upon the land of the
defendants, filed the present suit. Defendant No. 3 further pleaded that the
land in R.S.No.106/6 has no direct access to Puntha Road situated in
R.S.No.104, wherein the land in R.S. No. 104 was subdivided as R.S.
No.104/4 and given to the ryots. The defendants further pleaded that the
plaintiff never enjoyed any part of the dimma covered by R.S.No.106/5, in
which palmyra, coconut, and other trees are grown, and that the same
belonged to defendant No.2. The plaintiff, with an intention to grab the said
property of defendant No. 2, is harassing them.
Defendant No.3 pleaded that the full extent of land in R.S.No.106/6 is
Ac. 0.88 cents, out of which the western side measuring Ac.0.20 cents fell to
the share of Vytla Krishnavenamma. Under a registered partition deed dated
17.11.1963, by reducing the terms of the partition into writing, the said Vytla
Krishnavenamma gifted the said property, along with other properties, to her
daughter, Koduri Seetha Rama Lakshmi, under a registered gift deed dated
20.05.1970. Pursuant thereto, the Government issued pattadar passbooks in
the year 1980. He further pleaded that Koduri Seetha Rama Lakshmi became
the owner of Ac.2.44 cents of land in R.S.No.106/5 and the western land
measuring Ac.0.20 cents in R.S.No.106/6, which were later sold through three
different sale deeds dated 17.08.1981 in favour of the defendants.
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Consequently, the western land measuring Ac.0.20 cents in R.S.No.106/6 fell
to the share of defendant No.3.
He further pleaded that the excess extent of land shown in the plaintiff‟s
documents, i.e., Ac.0.73 cents, actually pertains to Ac.0.68 cents. On
verification of the revenue records and documents of both parties, the
Tahsildar, K. Gangavaram, issued a certificate dated 24.01.2010, certifying
that the plaintiff is entitled to Ac. 0.68 cents of land and that defendant No. 3 is
entitled to Ac.0.20 cents of land out of the total extent of Ac.0.88 cents in
R.S.No.106/6 situated at Panangipalli Village. Thus, the entire extent of land
in R.S.No.106/5 belongs to the defendants, and as such, he prayed for
dismissal of the suit with costs.
8. On the basis of above pleadings, the learned trial Judge framed the
following issues for trial:
1) Whether the plaint plan is true and correct?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for declaration as prayed for?
3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for consequential permanent injunction
as prayed for? and
4) To what relief ?
9.
During the course of trial in the trial Court, on behalf of the plaintiff,
P.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.A-1 to A-10 were marked. On behalf of
the defendants, D.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-15 were
marked. Exs.X-1 to X-4 were also marked.
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
10.
The learned trial Judge after conclusion of trial, on hearing the
arguments of both sides and on consideration of oral and documentary
evidence on record, dismissed the suit without costs. Felt aggrieved thereby,
the unsuccessful plaintiff filed the appeal suit in A.S.No.01 of 2015, wherein
the following points came up for consideration:
1) Whether the plaintiff is having right, title over plaint schedule property
which is equivalent to „P‟ marked property of the plaint plan including
the red marked portion of Dimma altogether comes to an extent of
Ac.0.73 cents covering under S.No.106/6?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled consequential relief of Permanent
Injunction as prayed for? and
3) To what relief?
11.
The learned first appellate Judge after hearing the arguments,
answered the points, as above, against the defendants and allowed the
appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial
Judge. Felt aggrieved of the same, the unsuccessful defendants in
O.S.No.125 of 2010 filed the present second appeal before this Court.
12. On hearing both sides‟ counsel at the time of admission of the second
appeal on 12.04.2019, a learned Judge of this Court admitted the second
appeal and framed the following substantial questions of law:
1) Whether the Lower Appellate Court is legally right in reversing the
judgment and decree of the trial court wherein the suit for declaration of
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Easementary right, title and injunction in respect of the plaint schedule
property is dismissed?
2) Whether the Lower Appellate Court is right in declaring the suit for
declaration of Easementary right without there being any pleading of
enjoyment for continuation period as required under law? and
3) Whether the Lower Appellate Court is right in decreeing the suit by
reversing the judgment of the trial court without confirming that the
plaintiff established his right without depending on the weakness of
defendants case?
On 31.01.2026, during the course of hearing, this Court framed the
following additional substantial question law:
1) Whether the finding recorded by the First Appellate Judge that the
plaintiff has been in possession of the plaint schedule property for a
period of 15 years is legally sustainable in the absence of any pleadings?
13.
Heard Sri Vedula Venkata Narayana Rao, learned counsel representing
Sri T.V.S.Prabhakara Rao, learned counsel for the appellants/defendants and
Sri T.N.M.Ranga Rao, learned counsel representing Sri G.V.Gangadhar,
learned counsel for the respondent /plaintiff.
14.
The law is well settled that under Section 100 of CPC, High Court
cannot interfere with findings of fact arrived at by first appellate Court, which is
final Court of facts, except in such cases where such findings were erroneous
being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law, or its settled position on the
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
basis of the pronouncement made by the Apex Court or based upon
inadmissible evidence or without evidence.
In the case of Bhagwan Sharma v. Bani Ghosh1, the Apex Court held
as follows:
“The High Court was certainly entitled to go into the question as to whether the
findings of fact recorded by the First Appellate Court which was the final Court of fact
were vitiated in the eye of law on account of non-consideration of admissible evidence
of vital nature.”
In the case of Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar 2,
the Apex Court held as follows:
“The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the opinion of the First Appellate
Court unless it is found that the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate Court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law applicable or its settled
position on the basis of pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based upon
inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence.”
15.
The appellants herein are the defendants; the defendant No.3 is none
other than the son of the defendant Nos.1 and 2. The respondent herein is the
plaintiff in O.S.No.125 of 2010. The respondent/plaintiff approached the trial
Court seeking the relief of declaration of title in respect of the plaint schedule
property for an extent of Ac.0.73 cents situated in R.S.No.106/6 at
Panangipalli Village, and also for the consequential relief of permanent
injunction to restrain the defendants and their men from ever interfering with
the possession and enjoyment of the plaintiff over the plaint schedule
property. In a suit for declaration of title, the entire burden lies on the plaintiff
AIR 1993 SC 398
AIR 1999 SC 471
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
to prove that he has valid right and title in respect of the total extent of
property of Ac.0.73 cents in the plaint schedule.
16.
The legal position in this regard is no more res integra and the same is
well settled in the catena of judgments by the Hon‟ble Apex Court. In a case of
Union of India and others vs. Vasavi Cooperative Housing Society
Limited and others3, wherein the Apex Court held as follows:
“In a suit for declaration of title, burden always lies on the plaintiff to make out and
establish a clear case for granting such a declaration and the weakness, if any, of the
case set up by the defendants would not be a ground to grant relief to the plaintiff. The
legal position, therefore, is clear that the plaintiff in a suit for declaration of title and
possession could succeed only on the strength of its own title and that could be done
only by adducing sufficient evidence to discharge the onus on it, irrespective of the
question whether the defendants have proved their case or not. We are of the view
that even if the title set up by the defendants is found against, in the absence of
establishment of plaintiff‟s own title, plaintiff must be non-suited.”
17.
It is the specific case of the plaintiff that the plaint schedule property is
situated in Sy.No.106/6 in an extent of Ac.0.73 cents at Panangipalli Village
and his father Vytla Veeraraghava Rao, got the same under a registered gift
deed said to have been executed by his paternal grandmother Buchamma
vide registered gift deed dated 24.06.1967, and the said registered gift
settlement deed is filed and got exhibited as Ex.A-1 before the trial Court. As
seen from Ex.A-1, the paternal grandmother of the plaintiff, Buchamma, who
is the wife of Vytla Venkata Krishnaiah, executed a registered gift deed for
Ac.0.73 cents out of Ac.0.88 cents of land in Sy.No.106/6 at Panangipalli
(2014) 2 Supreme Court Cases 269
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Village. It is undisputed by both sides that the full extent of land in
Sy.No.106/6 is Ac.0.88 cents.
18.
It is specifically pleaded by the defendant No.3 in the written statement,
which was adopted by the defendant Nos.1 and 2, that in Ex.A-1 document,
the excess extent of Ac.0.05 cents of land is mentioned in the document of the
father of the plaintiff, i.e., in Ex.A-1 gift deed, instead of Ac.0.68 cents, an
extent of Ac.0.73 cents is mentioned in Ex.A-1. As stated supra, the defendant
No.3 is none other than the son of the defendant Nos.1 and 2. It is the specific
case of the defendants that the paternal grandfather of the plaintiff is Vytla
Pattabhi Ramanna, and the said Vytla Pattabhi Ramanna has got two sons,
Veera Raghava Rao and Viswa Sundara Rao. The said Veera Raghava Rao
is none other than the father of the plaintiff. The defendants further pleaded in
the written statement itself that the said Pattabhi Ramanna has got a brother
by name Brahmaiah, and after the death of the said Brahmaiah, there was a
partition of the properties in the year 1963 in the family of Vytla Pattabhi
Ramanna. The defendants further pleaded that in the said partition, Vytla
Pattabhi Ramanna and his sons took one share, and the widow of Brahmaiah
took the remaining share, and in that partition an extent of Ac.0.20 cents in
R.S.No.106/6 out of the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents fell to the share of Vytla
Krishnavenamma, who is the widow of Brahmaiah, and the remaining 0.68
cents fell to the share of the paternal grandfather of the plaintiff, and so, any
documents obtained by the plaintiff in excess of Ac.0.68 cents of land in
Sy.No.106/6 are not valid documents. In order to prove the defence, they
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
relied on the registration extract of the registered partition deed and got it
exhibited as Ex.B-1, and Ex.B-1 is undisputed by the plaintiff. The defence put
forth by the defendants, as stated supra, is well supported by Ex.B-1.
19.
The recitals of Ex.B-1 partition deed dated 20.11.1963 clearly go to
show that from out of the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents in R.S.No.106/6 at
Panangipalli Village, Ac.0.20 cents fell to the share of Vytla Krishnavenamma,
and the remaining extent of Ac.0.68 cents fell to the share of the paternal
grandfather of the plaintiff, Vytla Venkata Krishnaiah. Ex.B-1 clearly goes to
show that the son of Vytla Venkata Krishnaiah by name Pattabhi Ramanna
and his sons Veeraraghava Rao (father of the plaintiff), and Viswa Sundara
Rao, and the widow of Vytla Brahamaiah, by name Vytla Krishnavenamma,
partitioned the properties, and in the said partition Ac.0.20 cents in
R.S.No.106/6 out of Ac.0.88 cents fell to the share of Krishnavenamma, and
the branch of Vytla Krishnaiah remained with Ac.0.68 cents only in
R.S.No.106/6 in the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents. But the wife of Vytla Venkata
Krishnaiah executed a gift deed for Ac.0.73 cents instead of Ac.0.68 cents in
R.S.No.106/6 along with other properties in other survey numbers under Ex.A1 gift settlement deed. The dispute is with regard to the suit schedule property
only, namely, situated in R.S.No.106/6, but not other properties.
20.
It is the specific case of the defendants that the original owner of
Ac.0.20 cents in R.S.No.106/6, by name Vytla Krishnavenamma, executed a
registered gift deed in favour of her daughter Seetha Rama Lakshmi on
30.05.1970 under Ex.B-9 along with other properties. Ex.B-5 is the registration
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
extract of the sale deed said to have been executed by Seetha Rama
Lakshmi, which goes to show that Seetha Rama Lakshmi sold an extent of
Ac.0.20 cents in R.S.No.106/6 along with other properties to Kothapalli
Venkata Rao, who is the junior paternal uncle of the defendant No.3, i.e., the
brother of the defendant No.1. The evidence of the D.W.1 clearly goes to
show that subsequent to the execution of registered sale deed in favour of
Venkata Rao, an oral partition of their ancestral properties between his father
and his junior paternal uncle took place, and in the said partition an extent of
Ac.0.20 cents fell to the share of his father and later fell to his share. The
same is well supported by the documentary evidence produced by the
defendants. The plaintiff failed to prove that the donor under Ex.A-1 has right
and title in an extent of Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6, but not Ac.0.68 cents.
In Ex.A-1, the source of title is not at all mentioned by the donor, i.e., the
paternal grandmother of the plaintiff, in favour of the father of the plaintiff.
21.
As stated supra, the plaintiff approached the Court for seeking the relief
of declaration of title; therefore, it is for the plaintiff to prove that he has a valid
right and title in the total extent of Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6. It is relevant
to refer to the own admissions of the plaintiff in his evidence in crossexamination, which are as follows:–
The plaintiff admitted in his evidence in cross-examination that the survey
line is the boundary line between his property and the properties of the
defendants in respect of the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents of land in
Sy.No.106/6, and the property devolved upon him through Buchamma,
who is his paternal grandmother, and there is no mention about the
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
document number in Ex.A-1 about the source of acquisition of property
by Buchamma, and to his knowledge, Buchamma purchased the
property, and the same is a self-acquired property. He further admits that
there was a partition in the property on 17.11.1963 by way of a registered
document between the paternal grandfather of the plaintiff and his sons
and Krishnavenamma, and Ex.B-1 is the registration extract of the
partition deed. He further admits that he is not having any documentary
evidence to show that Buchamma has Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6,
and he has not verified the revenue records to ascertain whether
Buchamma has right over Ac.0.73 cents or not, even after the filing of the
written statement by the defendants.
22.
The plaintiff himself admitted about the source of the title of the
defendant for Ac.0.20 cents of land in Sy.No.106/6. P.W.1 admitted in his
evidence in cross-examination that Seetha Rama Lakshmi is none other than
the daughter of Krishnavenamma, and she executed a gift deed in favour of
her daughter on 30.05.1970 by giving her entire property, including Ac.0.20
cents of land in R.S.No.106/6, by way of gift. He further admits that Ex.B-2 is
the pattadar passbook issued by the Tahsildar, Ramachandrapuram, in the
name of Seetha Rama Lakshmi. He pleaded ignorance about the pattadar
passbook obtained by Seetha Rama Lakshmi. Therefore, it is evident that the
plaintiff is not having a valid title for the extent of Ac.0.73 cents of land, at
best, the plaintiff is having a valid title for Ac.0.68 cents of land in Sy.No.106/6,
and the same is undisputed by the defendants. It is the admitted case of the
defendants that the plaintiff is having a valid title only in Ac.0.68 cents of land
in R.S.No.106/6, but not in Ac.0.73 cents of land as pleaded by the plaintiff in
the plaint. The material on record reveals that instead of obtaining the gift
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
deed for Ac.0.68 cents of land in R.S.No.106/6, the father of the plaintiff
obtained the gift deed for Ac.0.73 cents of land from his mother. Therefore,
without having a valid title in the remaining Ac.0.05 cents of land in
R.S.No.106/6, the donor executed a registered gift deed for Ac.0.73 cents
instead of Ac.0.68 cents of land in R.S.No.106/6 in favour of the father of the
plaintiff.
23.
P.W.2 stated that he knows the landed properties of the plaintiff and the
defendants, and the plaintiff is having Ac.0.73 cents of land at Panangipalli
Village. But, in his evidence in cross-examination, he admits that he has not
visited the plaint schedule property during twenty (20) years, and he cannot
say for which part of Ac.0.73 cents of land is the disputed property. As per his
own evidence, he has not visited the suit schedule property since twenty
years. The specific case of the defendants is that the paternal grandfather of
the plaintiff, Vytla Pattabhi Ramanna, has got two sons, Veeraraghava Rao
and Viswa Sundar Rao, and the said Pattabhi Ramanna has got one brother
by name Brahmaiah, and after the death of the said Brahmaiah, there was a
partition of the properties in the year 1963 under Ex.B-1 between the family of
Veeraraghava Rao and the widow of Brahmaiah, and a registered partition
deed was executed by Vytla Veeraraghava Rao and his sons and
Krishnavenamma, and in the said partition an extent of Ac.0.20 cents of land
in R.S.No.106/6 fell to the share of Vytla Krishnavenamma out of the total
extent of Ac.0.88 cents of land, and the remaining extent of Ac.0.68 cents fell
to the share of the branch of Vytla Veeraraghava Rao, i.e., the branch of the
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
plaintiff, and the same is well supported by the documentary evidence
produced by the defendants. Learned counsel for the plaintiff would contend
that the plaintiff got revenue documents, viz., pattadar passbook and land
revenue receipts for Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6, therefore, he is having a
valid right and possession in the total extent of Ac.0.73 cents, but not in
Ac.0.68 cents of land. It is the admitted case of both the parties that the full
extent in R.S.No.106/6 of Panangipalli Village is Ac.0.88 cents, and it is
evident that an extent of Ac.0.20 cents was given by the paternal grandfather
of the plaintiff, the father of the plaintiff and his brothers in R.S.No.106/6 to
Vytla Venkata Krishnavenamma. Therefore, at best, the plaintiff‟s grandfather
retained only Ac.0.68 cents in R.S.No.106/6 in the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents,
but not Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6. But the plaintiff has approached the
trial Court for seeking the relief of declaration of title in respect of Ac.0.73
cents instead of Ac.0.68 cents in R.S.No.106/6, though he is having a valid
right and title in Ac.0.68 cents in R.S.No.106/6.
24.
D.W.3 is the Tahsildar, K.Gangavaram; he deposed in his evidence that
as per the revenue record, an extent of land in R.S.No.106/6 is Ac.0.88 cents,
and as per the revenue register, Ac.0.68 cents of land in the said survey
number is in the name of the plaintiff, and an extent of Ac.0.20 cents of land is
in the name of the defendant No.3, and he also filed Form 1-B Adangal and
registered copies of the B-Register, and Exs.X-1 to X-4 are marked through
the Tahsildar/D.W.3. Therefore, it is evident that the plaintiff is having the title
of Ac.0.68 cents only in R.S.No.106/6, but not to Ac.0.73 cents. The defendant
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
No.3 is having a valid title on the remaining extent of Ac.0.20 cents in the full
extent of Ac.0.88 cents in R.S.No.106/6. Therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled
to the relief of declaration of title for Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6, the plaintiff
is having title in Ac.0.68 cents in R.S.No.106/6 at Panangipalli Village.
25.
Learned counsel for the plaintiff would contend that the possession of
the plaintiff in Ac.0.73 cents in Sy.No.106/6 is admitted by the defendants.
Unless and until the entries in revenue records are set aside by the appellate
authority in the Revenue Department, the plaintiff is having a valid title for an
extent of Ac.0.73 cents in R.S.No.106/6 at Panangipalli Village. Here, both the
parties to the suit are relying on the pattadar passbooks issued by the
Revenue authorities, and both the parties are relying on the documents issued
by the Revenue Department. The defendant No.3 also got the pattadar
passbook for Ac.0.20 cents in R.S.No.106/6; the plaintiff got the pattadar
passbook for Ac.0.73 cents in the same survey number, though the full extent
of the said survey number is Ac.0.88 cents. Learned counsel for the plaintiff
would contend that D.W.1 himself admitted that the plaintiff is in the
possession of Ac.0.73 cents; therefore, he is entitled to the relief of declaration
of title for Ac.0.73 cents. I am unable to accept the said contention of the
learned counsel for the plaintiff. In the written statement itself, the defendant
pleaded that the father of the plaintiff got a gift deed for an extent of Ac.0.73
cents in R.S.No.106/6 at Panangipalli Village instead of Ac.0.68 cents, and an
excess extent of Ac.0.05 cents was mentioned in the document of the plaintiff,
but the donor under Ex.A-1 is having title only to an extent of Ac.0.68 cents in
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Sy.No.106/6, at best, the donor could execute a gift deed for Ac.0.68 cents
only. No doubt, D.W.1 admitted in his evidence in cross-examination that he is
in the possession of an extent of Ac.0.15 cents, and the remaining extent of
Ac.0.05 cents of land is in the possession of the plaintiff. The defendant
specifically pleaded and deposed in his evidence that he is having valid title in
Ac.0.20 cents of land. Taking into consideration of stray sentences in the
deposition of the witness, the entire evidence of a witness cannot be thrown
out.
26.
It was contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the First
Appellate Judge came to a wrong conclusion in its judgment that the plaintiff
has been in possession of the plaint schedule property for a period of fifteen
(15) years by way of adverse possession, i.e., more than twelve (12) years, in
an extent of Ac.0.05 cents of land, therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to a relief
of declaration of title for Ac.0.73 cents of land in R.S.No.106/6. As seen from
the judgment of the First Appellate Judge, the First Appellate Judge held in its
judgment that since the date of Ex.A-1, i.e., from 24.04.1961 onwards, the
plaintiff has been enjoying Ac.0.73 cents of land for more than fifty (50) years,
and even assuming that Ex.A-3 pattadar passbook is taken into consideration,
the plaintiff has paid taxes for Ac.0.73 cents of land, and the plaintiff has been
in possession for more than twelve (12) years, and that the plaintiff
establishes that he is having right and title over the said Ac.0.05 cents of land
in addition to the Ac.0.68 cents of land in Sy.No.106/6. It is not the case of the
defendants that the plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment of the said
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
Ac.0.05 cents of land by way of adverse possession; there is no pleading in
the plaint that the plaintiff acquired title for Ac.0.68 cents of land in
R.S.No.106/6 and he has been in possession of another Ac.0.05 cents of land
in the same survey number since more than twelve (12) years and that his title
is perfected by way of adverse possession. It is the specific case of the
plaintiff that by virtue of gift deed said to have been executed in favour of his
father, he is having right and title for Ac.0.73 cents of land, but not for Ac.0.68
cents of land. As stated supra, the full extent of property in Sy.No.106/6 is
Ac.0.88 cents, out of which the defendant No.3 is having title in Ac.0.20 cents
in the said survey number, and the plaintiff is having title in Ac.0.68 cents of
land in R.S.No.106/6, and the plaintiff is not having any title for other Ac.0.05
cents of land in addition to Ac.0.68 cents of land in the same survey number.
27.
The law is well settled that “The execution of or registration of a
document by itself will not create any new title, and the execution of or
registration of such document covering an immovable property is governed by
the principle Nemo Dat Quad Non Habet, which means 'no person can
transfer/pass a better title than what he possesses in the property so
transferred‟. Given the fact that transfer of an immovable property is governed
by this principle, the registering authority when receives a document and
registers it, does not decide title of the persons executing the document.
Therefore, mere registration of a document will not confer any new title, and in
the case of any title disputes arising out of such registrations, they are subject
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
to and decided under the provisions of various other laws, governing the
transfer of immovable property”.
28.
In the case at hand, by virtue of the registration partition deed dated
20.11.1963, the paternal grandfather of the plaintiff had right and title in an
extent of Ac.0.68 cents of land out of the full extent of Ac.0.88 cents of land in
R.S.No.106/6 at Panangipalli Village, and Krishnavenamma had right and title
in the remaining Ac.0.20 cents of land out of Ac.0.88 cents of land in
R.S.No.106/6. Therefore, the paternal grandmother did not have any right to
execute a registered gift deed on 24.04.1967 in favour of the father of the
plaintiff for an extent of Ac.0.73 cents, since the paternal grandmother of the
plaintiff had right in Ac.0.68 cents of land in R.S.No.106/6, situated at
Panangipalli Village. Therefore, at best, the paternal grandmother of the
plaintiff can execute a registered gift deed in favour of the father of the plaintiff
for an extent of Ac.0.68 cents, but not for an extent of Ac.0.73 cents, since she
had right and title for an extent of Ac.0.68 cents only.
29.
The law is well settled that “mere possession of land would not ripen
into possessory title” for the said purpose possessor must have „Animus
Possidendi‟ and hold that the land adverse to the title of the true owner. It is
also well settled that a party claiming adverse possession must prove that his
possession is “nec vi, nec clam, nec precario,” i.e., peaceful, open and
continuous possession. The person who set up the plea of adverse
possession must establish the physical fact of exclusive possession and the
Animus Possidendi to hold as an owner in exclusion of the actual owner. As
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
the person who set up a plea of adverse possession tries to defeat the rights
of the true owner, the burden lies on him to plead and establish all facts
necessary to establish his adverse possession. In the case at hand, it is not
the specific case of the plaintiff in the plaint itself that by virtue of adverse
possession he is in possession of Ac.0.05 cents of land and by virtue of
documentary evidence, he is having title in Ac.0.68 cents of land. Therefore,
the said finding given by the learned First Appellate Judge that the plaintiff is
having title by way of adverse possession for an extent of Ac.0.05 cents in
R.S.No.106/6 is nothing but a perverse finding.
30.
For the aforesaid reasons, this Court holds that the plaintiff failed to
establish that he is having title in Ac.0.73 cents of land in R.S.No.106/6 at
Panangipalli Village. The plaintiff is having title in an extent of Ac.0.68 cents of
land in R.S.No.106/6 at Panangipalli Village. The plaintiff suppressed the truth
and approached the Court with unclean hands and got filed the suit with a
specific plea that he is having title to Ac.0.73 cents of land. But, the fact
remains that he is having title in Ac.0.68 cents of land only. Therefore, the
plaintiff is not entitled to the relief of declaration of title in respect of the plaint
schedule property for an extent of Ac.0.73 cents as sought by the plaintiff.
Since the plaintiff is not entitled to the relief of declaration, he is also not
entitled to the consequential relief of permanent injunction. The trial Court on
appreciation of the entire evidence on record came to right conclusion and
dismissed the suit. The First Appellate Court, without appreciating the
evidence on record in a proper manner, came to a wrong conclusion and
VGKR, J.
SA_1621_2018
allowed the first appeal filed by the plaintiff. Therefore, the decree and
judgment passed by the First Appellate Court are liable to be set aside.
31.
In the result, the second appeal is allowed and the judgment and
decree dated 13.07.2018, in A.S.No.01 of 2015, passed by the learned Senior
Civil Judge Court, Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari District, is hereby set
aside.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, each party do
bear their own costs in the second appeal.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the appeal shall
stand closed.
__________________________
V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO, J.
Date: 09.02.2026
SRT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review