Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010596012022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 42/2023
Between:
1. KOTAKONDLA RATHNA, W/O SIVAIAH, AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS,
R/O AT D.NO.1-1, VEMURIVADDIPALLI VILLAGE, VEMURI POST,
TIRUPATI RURAL MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. RENGICHETTY MANOHAR, S/O R.BALAJI, AGED NOT KNOWN, R/O
AT D.NO.14-473, HAMEED NAGAR, TIRUPATI, CHITTOOR DIST.
2. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, IFFO TOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE
CO.LTD., HAVING OFFICE AT RAMANUJA CIRCLE, TIRUCHANOOR
ROAD, TIRUPATI, CHITTOOR DISTRICT
3. D VENKATANAGULU, S/O D.SUBBAIAH, AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/O AT D.NO.12-7, PANDURANGAVARIPALLI VILLAGE, KOTTALA,
CHANDRAGIRI MANDAL, CHITTOOR DIST.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtpleased to call
for the records relating to the MVOP NO.102 of 2018 on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal cum X Additional District Judge at Tirupati, Chittoor
District and set aside the order dt.16-05-2022 with the extent of against the
respondents 1 and 3 and passed the order only against the respondents 1 and
2 who are jointly and severally liable to be pay to the compensation to the
appellant/petitioner herein by allowing the appeal as prayed for and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 4 days in filing the MACMA against the order
and decree dt.16-05-2022 passed in MVOP No.102/2018 on the file of the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal cum X Additional District Judge at Tirupati
and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 92 days in resubmitting the above MACMA
SR 48678/2022 and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. V ESWARAIAH CHOWDARY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
2.
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
JUDGMENT:
The appellant/claimant filed the present appeal questioning the
dismissal of claim petition as against respondent No.2/insurance company
vide order and decree 16.05.2022 in M.V.O.P.No.102 of 2018 on the file of the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-X Additional District Judge, Tirupati,
wherein the Tribunal granted compensation of Rs.9,28,000/- (Rupees Nine
lakhs Twenty eight thousand only) to the appellant/claimant, though the claim
petition was originally filed for Rs.8,00,000/-,on account of the death of the
deceased B.Nagamma in a motor accident that occurred on 22.10.2015 and
fixed liability on respondent Nos.1 and 3 only, the owner and driver of the
offending vehicle respectively, and dismissed the claim against respondent
No.2/insurance company.
02.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
03.
The case of the petitioners, in brief, is as follows:
a) On 22.10.2015 at 10-00 a.m. when the deceased was proceeding
from Annarao Circle side to Bhavani Nagar circle side near Sun-shine
Hospital, K.T. Raod, Tirupati, the 3rd respondent who drove the auto bearing
No.AP-03-Y-2690 in a rash and negligent manner and dashed the deceased
due to which the deceased sustained severe injuries and died on the spot.
Basing on a report, the Station House Officer, Traffic Police Station, Tirupati
registered a case in Crime No.83 of 2015 against the 3rd respondent and after
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
investigation, a charge sheet was filed in C.C.No.510 of 2015 for the offence
under Section 304-A IPC, Section 3 read with 181 of the M.V. Act and Section
134(a) & (b) read with 187 of M.V. Act.
b) It is the contention of the claimant that the deceased was aged about
50 years and was working as a domestic servant in two houses, earning
Rs.4,000/- per month, contributing the same to the family. Therefore, the
claimant sought compensation of Rs.8,00,000/- from respondents No.1 to 3,
the owner, insurer and driver of the crime vehicle respectively.
04.
Before the Tribunal, the 1st respondent-owner of the vehicle remained
ex parte.
05.
The 2nd respondent filed a counter-affidavit denying the averments
made in the petition and contended that the petitioner is put to strict proof of
the manner, mode of the accident, as well as the income and occupation of
the deceased. It was further contended that the accident occurred due to
negligence of the deceased, who was allegedly walking in the middle of the
road without observing traffic rules and regulations. The 2 nd respondent also
contended that the petitioner is required to produce legal heir certificate, that
the claim made is highly excessive and that the auto bearing No.AP-03-Y2690 must have been driven with a valid driving licence and valid documents.
Accordingly, the 2nd respondent prayed for dismissal of the petition.
06.
trial:
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
“1. Whether B.Nagamma, died in a motor vehicle accident occurred on 2210-2015 at about 10-00 am due to negligent driving of the Auto bearing
No.AP-03-Y-2690 or not?
2. Whether the Petitioner is entitled to any compensation, if so, to what
amount and from whom?
3. To what relief?”
07.
On behalf of the petitioner, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined, and Exs.A1 to
A5 were marked. On behalf of the 2ndrespondent, R.W.s 1 and 2 were
examined and Exs.B1 and B2 were marked.
08.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal allowed the claim petition with
the following terms:
“In the result, the petition is allowed by awarding compensation amount
of Rs.9,28,000-00 (Rupees Nine Lakhs and Twenty-Eight Thousand
Only) with costs to the petitioner and with interest payable at 9% per
cent per annum. The respondents 1 and 3 are jointly and severally
liable to pay the said compensation with future interest at 9% p.a., and
costs as above within one month from the date of this award. On such
deposit, the petitioner is permitted to withdraw her share of
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs) along with
accrued interest thereon and costs and the remaining amount of
Rs.4,28,0000/- shall be kept in Fixed Deposit in any nationalized Bank
for a period of two years. The petitioner is directed to pay Court Fee for
the compensation amount of Rs.1,28,000-00. Advocate fee is fixed at
Rs.1,500-00. The petition against the respondent No.2 is dismissed.”
09.
Aggrieved by the said award, the petitioner filed the present appeal on
the sole ground that the Tribunal erred in exonerating the Insurance Company
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
from liability despite the fact that the insurance policy of the offending vehicle
was in force as on the date of the accident, merely on the ground that the
driver of the offending vehicle did not possess a valid driving licence.
Therefore, the impugned award warrants interference insofar as liability is
concerned.
10.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No.2/insurance
company herein has supported the impugned award and prayed to dismiss
the appeal.
11.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
12.
Heard Mr.V.Eswaraiah Chowdary, learned counsel for the appellant and
Mr.Gudi Srinivasu, learned counsel for respondent No.2.
POINT:
13.
The appellant/claimant has preferred the present appeal on the ground
that, though the vehicle was insured with respondent No.2, the Tribunal has
held that respondent No.2 is not liable to indemnify the loss incurred by
respondent No.1, the owner of the offending vehicle, on the ground that
respondent No.3, who was driving the said vehicle, did not possess a valid
driving license as on the date of the said incident.
14.
This Court, under similar circumstances, in its judgment dated
25.03.2025 in MACMA No.144 of 2015, held that the principle of “pay and
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
recovery” is to be applied. In the said case also, the offending vehicle was
validly insured under an insurance policy, which was in force as on the date of
accident. However, since the driver of the offending vehicle was not having
valid and effective driving license at the relevant point of time it amounted to
breach of insurance policy conditions and therefore absolved the insurance
company of any liability and allowed the claim petition only against the owner
of the offending vehicle. This Court having considered the issue held as
under:
“10. On the issue of liability to pay the compensation by the insurer, if there
was fundamental breach of insurance policy, the insurance company could
be absolved of the liability. However, in those cases where the third party
claimant suffered serious injuries and acquired permanent disability such
as the one available in the case at hand, the consistent view taken by the
Constitutional Courts is to apply the principle of pay and recover
(Shamanna v. The Divisional Manager, The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
(2018) 9 SCC 650 and Parminder Singh v. New India Assurance Company
Limited (2019) 7 SCC 217). In such view of the principles of law it is
difficult to approve the impugned award to the extent that it absolved the
insurance company totally. In the given facts and circumstances of this
case this Court records that respondent No.2-Insurance Company need
not shoulder the liability and indemnify the owner of the offending vehicle.
However, this is a fit case to apply the principle of pay and recover.
Therefore, the compensation awarded by the Claims Tribunal has to be
first paid by the insurance company and thereafter the insurance company
is entitled to file execution petition against the owner of the offending
vehicle/respondent No.1 for recovering the same.”
15.
In the instant case also, it is not in dispute that the offending vehicle
was insured with the insurance company under Ex. B1 policy and the said
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
policy was in force as on the date of incident. Admittedly, the deceased
sustained severe injures and died on the spot.
16.
It is to be noted that in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh
& Ors.,1the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held that if the insurer successfully
proves a breach of policy condition, the insurance company may still be
directed to pay compensation to the claimantsand then recover the amount
from the insured (owner of the vehicle). This ensures that the rights of the
third-party victim are protected and it was emphasized that insurance policies
are statutorily required to protect third parties, and even in cases of breach by
the insured, the insurer's liability towards third-party victims does not vanish
immediately.
17.
In view of the above, and following the settled principles of law as held
by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the decisions referred supra, this Court is of
the opinion that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal in the instant case
has to be first paid by the insurance company, and thereafter the insurance
company can recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle.
18.
Now coming to the quantum of compensation, the deceased was aged
about 50 years, as on the date of the accident. As per the evidence of P.W.1
who is the daughter of the deceased, the deceased was working as a
domestic servant in two houses and was earning Rs.4,000/- per month. In the
absence of any documentary evidence, the Tribunal having considered
(2004) 3 SCC 297
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
various judgments of the Hon‟ble Apex Court, has held that the income of the
deceased can be taken as Rs.5,000/- per month, which comes to Rs.60,000/per annum (Rs.5,000 X 12). By applying the appropriate multiplier of „13‟ for
the age group of 50 years, as laid down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation 2 , the loss of earnings would come to Rs.7,80,000/-. The
Tribunal, further added 10% towards future prospects, which comes to
Rs.78,000/-, thereby totalling Rs.8,58,000/- (Rs.7,80,000 + 78,000). However,
as rightly contended by the learned counsel for the insurance company, the
Tribunal failed to deduct 1/3rd towards personal expenses of the deceased, as
held in Sarla Verma case (referred supra). If 1/3rd is deducted towards
personal expenses, the loss of dependency comes to Rs.5,72,000/(Rs.8,58,000 – 2,86,000).
19.
Apart from the said amount, the Tribunal also awarded Rs.40,000/-
towards consortium, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses and Rs.15,000/towards loss of estate, which are just and reasonable and require no
interference by this Court. Thus, the total compensation payable to the
claimant is Rs.6,42,000/-.
20.
In view of the above discussion, the award passed by the Tribunal in
MVOP No.102 of 2018 is modified by reducing the compensation from
Rs.9,28,000/- to Rs.6,42,000/- with interest at 9% p.a from the date of filing of
the petition till the date of realization. The liability also fixed on respondent
2009 ACJ 1298
VS,J
MACMA No.42 of 2023
No.2/Insurance Company, directing it to first pay the compensation to the
claimant and thereafter recover the same from respondent Nos.1 and 3/owner
and driver of the offending vehicle.
21.
With the above directions, this appeal is allowed in part. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Date: 06.04.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review