Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e2 I
INTHEHIGHGoURTFoRTHESTATEoFTELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND NruENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
AND
THEHoNoURABLEJUSTIGEB.R.MADHUSUDHANRAo
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 1370 OF 2017
Dated
Appeal under section 374(2) of cr.P.c against the Judgment
Additional sessions Judge at
28-07-2006 in S.c.No. 396 0f 2004 0n the file of the I
Mahabubnagar.
Between:
KommuRamulu@ChittoduS/o.Papaiah,Ag9d46years,Gl!,:Coolie,R/o.
pothi red p rirrvirr"-g" of Thi m m aiipet Ma ndal, Mahabubnaga r District'
i
...APPELLANT/ACCUSED
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High court
JUdicature at HYderabad.
of
...RESPONDE NT'COM PLAINANT
CounselfortheAppellant:SriRapoluBhaskar(LegalAid)
counsel for the Respondent: sri Syed Yasar Mamoon, Public
Prosecutor
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
.;r,;;:l:.t
'a':):-;;t
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OT TELITNGANA
AT HYDERABAD
I
MAN
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
NO.1370
20.L7
DATED: )I81- APRIL. 2025
Between :
Kommu Ram.ulu @ Chittodu,
S/o.Papaiah. aged 46 years,
Golla, Coolie,
R/ o.Pothiredipally Village of
Thimmajipet Mandal,
Mahabubnag,ar District.
i
i
I
i
... Appellant/Accused
/
rl
i
AND
li
The State of llelangana,
Rep. By its Frblic prosecutor,
High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad
. ..
Respondent/ Complainant
This Cc,urt delivered the following:
i
JUDGMEIIT: (per Justice B.R.Madhusudhan Rao)
1.
This Mt:morandum of criminal Appeal is filed under Section
374(21 of criminal procedure code, Lgrg (for short cr.p.c.l
assailing the conviction and sentence passed by the learned
I Additional Sessions Judge, at Mahabubnagar District in
SC No.396 of 2OO4, dared 28.0T.2006.
\
\
2.
KL,J and BRMR,J
Crininal Appeal- 137O-2O 17
Appellant-acclrsed was sentenced to undergo Rigorous
Imprisonment for Life and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-, in default
Simple Imprisonment for one year for the charge under Section 3O2
of Indian Penal Code (for short 'IPCJ. He is further sentenced to
undergo Rigorous tmprisonment for three yeais for the charge
under Section 379 of IPC. The period of imprisonment for the
offence under Section 379 of IPC should be set off against the
period of remand under Section 428 of Cr.P.C.
3.
The case of the prosecution is that the appellant-accu.sed
started enjoying the roadside ladies by indulging in committing
property offences, in that course he was arrested in Crime No.83 of
L997 under Section 379 of IPC of PS Annasagar and in Crime
No.98 of 2OOO under Sections 457 and 380 of IPC of PS Jadcherla.
Appellant-accused has developed illicit intimary with Pullakurala
Mallamma and enjoyed her for about a year. On 11.05.20O3 at
about 10.OO A.M., appellant-accused visited Bhoothpur and offered
toddy to Mallamma, took her to Jadcherla. Later, they both
proceeded to Ranipet Village and had toddy in the shop of PW.4-
B.Yadaiah Goud at about 3.O0 P.M. and purchased five more
bottles of toddy, parcelled the same into two polythene covers,
proceeded to Minambaram Vagu in the limits of Buddisamudram
Village. They consumed toddy and enjoyed. Subsequently,
:
*
I
KL,J and BRMR,J
Crfunind Appeal- 137O_20 I 7
appellant-accused smashed the head of P.Mallamma with a
boulder arld tied her saree tightly around her neck, strangulated
and comm.itted murder. Appellant-accused committed theft of gold
and silver ornaments of Mallamma worth Rs.5,58O /- and pledged
the same with PW.6-Anjaiah Chary and .charge sheet is filed
against him under Sections 302 and 379 of IPC.
4.
The learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nagar Kurnool
took the case on file and registered as PRC No.29 of 2OO4. Since
the offencr: is exclusively triable by Court of Sessions, the learned
Magistrate uide order dated 2O.O8.2OO4 committed the case to the
Court of Sessions, Mahabubnagar. The Sessions Judge,
Mahabubnagar took cognizance of the case assigned SC.No.396 of
2OO4 and made over the same to the learned I Additional Sessions
Judge, at lVlahabubnagar.
5.
The learned trial Court has framed charges under Sections
3O2 and 3'79 of IPC against the accused on 26.10.2004.
6.
Prosecution has examined PWs.l to 19, got marked Exs.Pl
to P17 and MOs.L to 12.
7.
The learned trial court after analysing the evidence adduced
by the prosecution has sentenced the appellant-accused for Life
.*
\dt
Imprisonrnent as stated in Para No.2.
8.
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal ApPeal- I 37O-2O I 7
Learned counsel for the appellant-accused submits that the
learned trial Court failed to see that there are no direct
eye-witnesses to the incident and the entire case of the prosecution
is resting on circumstantial evidence. The learned Judge should
have seen that there was absolutely no motive for the appellant to
kitl the deceased and the confession made before the Police Officer
is inadmissible evidence, mere recovery of certain incriminating
articles at the instance of the accused cannot form the basis of
conviction and the Test Identification Parade of the accused by
PW.4 is not proper and the evidence of PW.16 is inconsistent and
PW.1 has not supported the case of the prosecution. Learned
counsel for the appeltant-accused in alternate submits that Section
379 oflPC is not made out and the case falls under Section 382 of
IPC. Counsel to substantiate his contention has relied on the
decision in the case of Battigari Shaker Vs. State of Telanganat.
g.
karned Public Prosecutor submits that the learned trial
Court has properly appreciated the evidence of the witnesses and
rightly convicted the appellant-accused for the offences he is
charged with, prayed to dismiss the appeal'
10. Heard both sides, perused the material on record.
' uemufruoLo4lzoz4
sl27
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal- I 370-2O f 7
11. Now the point for consideration is : Whether the conviction
and sentenc.l imposed by the learned trial Court against the
appeltant-accused suffers from any perversity or illegality? If so,
does it require interference of this Court?
12. PW.1 has lodged Ex.Pl- complaint on 15.o5.2oo3 before the
police statirrg that on 1 1.05.2003 his mother Pullakoorala
Mallamma w()ke up in the early hours on 11.05.2003 at about 5.OO
hours, went out without informing anybody, he was under the
belief that his mother went to sell fruits. On 15.05.2003, at about
11.OO hours he received a phone ca[[ from Budha Samudram that
a female dead body was found and she has telephone No.23618,
animals ate the meat completely, bones are visible, corpse is in a
decomposed state. On seeing the saree, house key, bag and the
details found thereon, arrived at a conclusion that it is his
mother's de,ad body. Basing on Ex.Pl, PW.13 has registered
Ex.P12-FIR rrn 15.05.2003 at 18.00 hours under Section 174 of
Cr.P.C.
t3. The t:vidence of PW-l-Pullakurala Naga Rdu is in
consonance with Ex.Pl-complaint and he further deposed that his
mother left the house along with the jewellery. After one month
after the death of his mother, the accused came to the village
searching for his house and he asked him to wear on his a shirt
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal ApPcal- I 37O-2O I 7
and follow him as Government is paylng amount of Rs.2 La-khs in
view of the death of his mother. He had suspicion and took the
help of a reporter in the Village who questioned the accused, found
him to be a fraudster and handed him over to Annasagar police on
the same day. The police has let him off on the ground that the
accused merely came to his house to threaten and collect some
money. On one occasion, when his mother was vending fruits in
the stand at Bhootpur, he saw the accused speaking to his rnother'
MO.l-Green blouse, Mo.2-Yetlow saree, MO.3-Red petty coat,
MO.4-slip having telephone number and MO.S-Amulet, MO.7-Pair
of silver anklets, MO.8-Gold ear tops, MO.9-four silver bangles,
MO.lO-silver chain, MO.1l-Nose screw betongs to his mother and
he is seeing them today in the Court.
tn his cross-
examination, he stated that he did not inform the police that he
saw the accused speaking with his motl:er in a stand at Bhootpur'
Police has not shown him MOs.7 to' 11 earlier and once he has
ptedged MO.7-silver anklets as he fell due two installments of loan
with one Babu Rao of Jadcherla. He denied the suggestion that
MOs.7 to 11 do not belong to his mother and they were concocted
by the police.
14. PW.2-La<man Goud deposed that he did not observe the
clothes on the dead body. A small betel leaves bag (MO.6)
t.
7lz7
KL.J and BRMR'J
Criminal APPeal- 1370-2O
containedarlamountofRs.T2l-atthattime(noalnountisshown
inthebag).Exs.P2toP6arephotoswithnegativeswhichwere
is declared hostite by the
taken &t th'e scene of
offence' Witness
prosecution.Duringhiscross-examination,hestatedthathedid
notStatetothepoliceasinEx.PT,tothateffectthedeadbodyhad
Mos.lto5'Inthecross-examinationdonebytheaccusedcounsel,
with
MO'6-betel leaves bag
over
handed
has
he
he stated that
of the village
Rs.72l-to Upa Sarpanch
as a witness) and the
15.
by name Shekar (not cited
police did not examine him'
that he received
PW'3-Shiva Raj deposed
informed that a d'ead
Thimmajipet police who
a phone call from
body was lying in
containing a chit with
bag
a
has
which
Buddasarnudram stream'
or
missing for about two
found
was
!W'1
of
phone number' Mother
to the
PW'1 who in turn spoke
called
he
three da5's, immed'iately
police on Phone
accused and one
deposed that the
16. Pv/.4-B'Yad'aiah Goud
at about 4'OO P'M' at
shop
his
to
carne
years
lady aged about 3O
consumed near the
bottles'
toddy
three
purchased
Raypet and they
the lady had purchased
shop. The accused and
three more toddy
bottlesandpouredthetoddyintoaplasticbagandwenttowards
days' Jadcherla police
five
or
four
After
A5ryawa-ripally Village'
with
the accused and enQuyed
with
along
shop
came tc the toddy
I
KLJ and BRMR,J
Criminal Appal-l 37 O -2O | 7
him. He informed the police that the accused has purchased
toddy, consumed it along with another lady. After 1O days he
received surnlrlons to attend District Jail, Mahabubnagar for
identification of the accused. He was shown the photograph of the
decomposed dead body and he could not make out and identiff tLre
dead body. In his cross-examination, he stated that daily about 1O
toddy crates will be sold and he cannot say how many customers
visit their toddy shop. The accused when c€une along with the
police, pointed out towards their shop saying that he consumed
toddy along with the female companion and he cannot identify all
the couples who consume toddy in their shop. He denied the
suggestion that accused did not visit his shop, consumed toddy
along with the female.
l7'. Pw.s-Salauddin Khan deposed that he has taken
photographs at the scene of offence which are Exs.P2 to P6 with
negatives.
18. Pw.6-Anjaiah Chary deposed that G.Krishna Reddy-PW.7
has introduced the accused to him saying that he belongs to his
village. Accused has pledged a pair of silver anklets-MO.7, silver
amulets-MO.9 and he paid Rs.6OOl- or 80O/- to the accusedAbout two or three months later, accused also pledged two pairs of
silver anklets, pair of ear tops-Mo.8, silver chain-MO.l0, nose
'9127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_ 137O_20 I 7
screw-Mo.ll and he paid Rs.2,5oo/- to the accused. After six
months pc,lice Jadcherla came along with the accused to his shop
on which he has returned Mos.7 to 11 to the police. In his crossexaminatic,n he stated that he maintains a small book and do not
maintain emy register and he do not have an]r reeeipt book. The
notebook rvhich is handed over to the police contains about 50
transactions details and each of which has a carbon copy
transactiorr. He has not taken the signature or acknowledgement
from the a<:cused. Mos.7 to l l are available in the market. only
by virtual identification he can say tllat Mos.7 to l l vrere ptedged
with him blr the accused. Mos.7 to 11 do not bear any tags to show
that he has ftrrther pledged the iterns with others and his business
is making jewellery and he make articles of jewellery on collecting
labour cha::ges. He denied the suggestion that accused did not
pledge any :Ltems and he is giving false evidence.
19. Pw.7-.G.Krishna Reddy deposed that at the request of the
accused he has introduced him to pw.6 which happened
about one
and half yeer back
20- PW.8-Rathnaiah deposed that inquest was conducted in his
presence urrder Ex.p8 and t-t.e dead body
was in a skeleton form
which had clothes like red petticoat and yellow
saree. In his cross_
KL,J and BRMRJ
Criminal APPeal-l37 O -2O 1 7
rol27
examination he stated that he do not know the
inquest report and he signed on written white
contents of Ex'P8-
paper'
2L.Pw.g.S.Nagammadeposedthatshewenttoatod.dyshop,
purchased one toddy bottte and consuneed it- Thereafter
came and sat at a little distance. He enquired
accused
about her village and
she informed that she is a native of Marikal and
has been living at
Jadcherla. Accused informed her that he works in
railway and he
has no one in the village and asked her to accompany
ternple at Jadcherla,
Accused took her to another toddy shop near
him'
he brought two to three toddy bottles and insisted
her to consume
it. Accused has inforrned her that he is rnarried, his wife
that she is also
deserted him. she also informed the accused
has
marriedandleftherhusband.Accusedhasenquiredwithher
that except ear
whether she has any jewellery, in turn she stated
tops she has no other jewellery' Accused has engaged
an auto and
took her to Gollapally and she inforrned the accused
that she has
nomoneyexcepttheeartops.Accusedhasdemandedhertogive
the ear tops. Meanw.hile police calne tleere and took
the accused' In
calne alone to
her cross-examination she stated that the accused
purchased by
the toddy shop and she has consumed half bottle
her. prior to the incident she had no acquaintance
with the
accusedandthedistancebetweentwotoddy^shoPsisone
i
tu27
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_1370_20 I 7
kilometre. They reached Gollapally Railway station in an auto and
they sat irr the railway station and had a discussion for half an
hour, then she became scared and she came to Gollapally bus stop
from the railway station after leaving the accused. By that time
it was about 7.0o or 7.30 P.M. when she was at Gollapally bus
stage the golice came and enquired about the accused and asked
her about his whereabouts. She informed the police that the
accused was at railway station. Police went to the railway station
and took him into custody, came back and took her in a Jeep to
the police rstation. Accused has not abused her nor beat her and
they were <:ordial during their meeting. she denied the suggestion
that she is giving false evidence at the instance of the police.
22. Pw.10-K.Jangamma deposed trrat the police has drafted
Ex-P8-inqur3St report which bears her thumb impression and she
has not seon any material objects. The photos i.e., Exs.p2 to p6
show the dt:ad body at the scene. witness is declared hostile by the
prosecution. In her cross-examination she denied the suggestion
that police has discovered betel leaves bag containing Rs.70o/-.
witness is cross-examined by the accused counsel wherein she
stated that she do not know the contents of Ex.pg-inquest report
and at the' request of the police she has alfixed her thumb
impressiorr,)rl the papers.
:
\
L2lzt
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_I37o_2o I 7
23. Pw.11-Mohd.Fareed deposed that the police has took him
and K.Mohan Reddy-LW.l4 to the police station at Jadcherla
where accused was present in the police custody. Accused has
confessed the crime and he disclosed that the gold and silver
jewetlery stolen from the deceased were pledged with one
Goldsmith. on 17.07.2oo3 accused has led them to a Hillock near
Bandameedipally (Sangam gutta). Accused informed that he
removed the gold and silver items from the dead body, from there
they went to Nalla Cheruvu area of Jadcherla there the accused
disclosed his participation in another crime near the bushes.
Accused informed them that he removed the gold and silver
jewellery from another dead body of another woman. Ex.P9 is the
confession panchanama. on 18.07.2003 the accused led them to
the shop of PW.6-Anjaiah Chary where the police has recovered
gold and silver jewellery. Ex.PlO is the seizure panchanama. MOs.7
to 11 are the items of jewellery and the panch chits bear his
signatures. [n his cross-examination he stated that on 17.O7.2OO3
he went to Jadcherla PS through a constable at about 7.OO or 8.OO
P.M. On 17.O7.2OO3 at about 11.30 A.M. all of them including the
accused went to Hillock at Bandameedipally. Mohan Reddy-LW.14
did not accornpany them to the Hillock and they remained
at the Hillock from 11.00 A.M. to 2.oo p.M. panchanama was
da
drafted at the Hillock on 17 .07.2oo3 and another panchanama was
L3lZ7
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal AppeaI_I37O_2O l7
drafted at llalla cheruvu area at about 2.30 p.M. on the same day.
On 18.07.2rO03, he along with the police went to Krishna.Reddy
compound to recover material objects-Mos.l to 6. About 5 to 6
persons went to the shop of PW.6. The policemen had Mos.7 to 1l
with them when they reached the shop of prv,6, in his presence
police has :thown MOs.7 to 1l to pW.6 and asked him whether he
has acceptr:d the pledge from the accused. pw.6 stated that Mos.7
to 11 were pledged and he paid money to the accused and he gave
evidence irr different courts. The panch chits were pasted on
Mos.7 to 1 1. He denied the suggestion that no panchanama took
place and ro material objects were seized at the instance of the
accused.
24. Pw.12-A.Prakash Mudiraj deposed that on receipt of a memo
from the h::spector of Police (pw.l6) he has altered the section of
law to 302 ef IPC and Ex.Pl l is the section alteration memo. In his
cross-examination he stated that on tg.oz.2o19 at about 1o.oo
A.M., he re<:eived the memo from the Inspector of police.
25- Pw.l 3-Md. Suleman has registered Ex.pl2-FIR. In his
cross-examination he stated that he has not noted the reference
number of G.D. in the FIR. In the printed FIR he has not
mentioned the date, time and the name of the person who d;livered
the FIR to the Court.
14127
KLJ and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal-l 37 O -2O I 7
26. PW.l4-R.Narsimhaiah deposed that on L7.o7.2oo3 himself,
Inspector of Police (PW.16) and other constables were on patrolling
duty. At about 7.00 P.M. they reached Gollapally bus stage on
NH-7 in the Jeep and has observed the accused taking to a woman,
proceeding to the bus stage in a suspicious manner. They stopped
them and on enquiry they discovered that the accused and the lady
were not husband and wife and they also discovered the name of
the accused as Kommu Ramulu and the lady is Chakali Nagamma
(PW.9). The Inspector of Police suspected that the accused have
been involved in crimes. He went to Jadcherla in a Jeep secured
PW.l1 and Mohan Reddy-LW.l4 and produced them before the
Inspector of Police at 8.00 P.M. The lnspector of Police thereafter
interrogated the accused. In his cross-examination he stated that
he do not know whether PW.1 was shown MOs.7.to 11 in the police
station and he secured PW.l 1 and another person from the MRO
ofhce at about 8.00 P.M. and he has directly taken the panch
witnesses to Gollapally bus stage and not to the police station. He
has not gone to Gollapally Railway Station and has not seen the
accused there at. The arrest of the accused in the present case and
in other cases was at Gollapally bus stage. PW.lS-Abdul Rahman
has not participated in the arrest of the accused in this case. He
denied the suggestion that they have taken the accused in a Jeep
Lsl27
KL,J and BRMR'J
Criminal APPeal- 1370-20 1 7
andpickedupPw.g,notdraftedanypanchanamaatGollapally
bus stop an(l a false case is registered
against the accused'
27.Pw.l5-Mohd.AbdulRahamandeposed'thaton15.05.2003
atabout8.ooA.M.hereceived'informationabouttheunknown
deadbody.Immediatelyherushedtothesceneofoffenceatabout
partly eaten away by wild
9.3O A.M. and the dead body was
bearing telephone
hr: found one small bag and in it a chit
animals,
No.36l32ofMallamma.Hecalledtheabovesaidnrrmberand
ShivarajhasreceivedthecallandaskedhimtocallMallamma.
Pw.3-ShivarajinformedtoPW.l.Pw.lcametothespotalongwith
his relatives and identified that it is Mallamma,
thereafter P\M' 1
haslodgedEx.Plcomplaint.Pw.l3hasregisteredthecaseand
issued FII?. He has examined PW.1 and recorded
his statement' He
a]soexanrinedPWs.2to5andrecordedtheirstatementsandhe
hasconductedinquestoverthedeadbodyofthedeceasedinthe
presenceofPW.loandanotherandtheinquestreportisEx.P8.He
gaverequisitiontotheMedicalofficertoconductautopsyonthe
of offence' PW'2 has
spot. Au.topsy was conducted' at the scene
statedbeforehimasinEx.PT.Inhiscross-examinationhestated
thathehasnotexaminedandrecordedthestatementofPW.lon
thedateofcomplaintandhedonotknowwhoscribedEx.Pl.He
has exa.mined PW.1 lirst and thereafter conducted inquest: 49-!er
*\
KL,J and BRMRJ
Criminal APPeal- I 37O-20 I 7
16127
Ex.P8-inquest report in column No'8'
there were seven 1OO/- rupee
notes, one 50/- rupee note and four
1O/- rupee notes apart from
other items found in the betel bag'
PW' 1 has given him the
physicaldescriptionoftheaccusedinhisstatement.PW.2was
his grocery
inquest and he has examined Pw.1 at
present at the
shop at Bhootpur' He has not enquired
vendors were present at the shop.
with PW'4 as to how many
He denied the suggestion that
he
has conducted table investigation'
28.Pw.16-Ch.RajaiahdeposedthatontT.oT.2oo3ataboutT'0o
p.M. himself, pw.14 and I.D.party policemen while
patrolling in the
areaofJadcherlaonNationalHighwayNo.TatGollapallybus
in the company of one ladystage, they have noticed the accused
Pw.g.Theystoppedandquestionedtheaccusedandtheaccused
wasreadytoconfessthecommissionoftheoffences.Hisstaffhas
broughtPw.llandMohanReddy-LW.|4atabout8.3oP.M.and
bus stage in the
he has interrogated the accused at Goltapally
presenceofpanchwitnesses.Theaccusedduringthecourseof
interrogationconfessedofcommitting^theoffenceinthepresent
crimeandalsoinCrimeNos'1/03'5O/O3'54103'll4lO3ofPS
Jadcherla.Accusedhasconfessedthathehaspledgedtheitems
withPW.6andconfessionpanchanama'isEx.Pgandalsoinformed
themthathewouldshowthestoneusedintheoffence.on
tTlzt
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_ I 370_2O 1 7
l8-o7.2oo3, the accused has led them to scene of offence at about
10.3o A.M. at chiliveru Village, they have seized the stone (Mo.l2)
under Ex.l)13-recovery of stone panchanama. Accused has led
them to thr: shop of PW.6 and pw.6 admitted to have accepted the
pledge of jewellery from the accused and produced them on
demand i.e., MOs.7 to 11 and he has also seized pledge book from
Pw.6 which contains the thumb prints of the accused on various
dates. He has sent a memo to SHo, Thimmajipet to alter the
section of law to sections 302 and 379 of Ipc and he has taken the
fingerprintr; of the accused in the office and sent the pledge book
along with the admitted thumb prints to the fingerprint expert for
comparison. on 18.07.2003 he produced the accused before the
court. on :2 l.o7 .2oo3 he has secured the accused on p.T. warrant.
Thereafter he submitted a requisition before the chief Judicial
Magistrate. Mahabubnagar to nominate a Magistrate to conduct
T.l. Parade. The learned Magistrate has conducted T.l. parade on
o2.o8.2o0ii and gave report under Ex.p16. pw.l has identified
Mos.7 to 1.1. PWs.l to 4 have participated in the T.l. parade and
identified the accused. Mos.7 to r 1 are the valuables seized from
the shop of PW.6 at the instance of the accused. In his crossexamination he stated that he took up the investigation on
18.o7-2ooli from pw.15. Exs.p9 and p13 are drafted by pc
zs4
who has attested the panchanamas and they prepared
1-
18127
L7
Criminal
signatures of panchas
identification slips with the
on Mos'7 to 11'
Pw.6istheowneroftheshop.Hedidnotfindanyidentification
PW'6 has produced them'
when
lt
to
MOs'7
to
tags
PW'4 and has also not
of
employer
the
examined
He has not
examined the
the accused along with a
know
to
Badepally
at
toddy shop owner
no recoveries
denied the suggestion that
He
shop'
his
visiting
lady
voluntarily stated that
Witness
18.07'2003'
were made on
confessionwasrecordedon|T.oT.2oo3tiltlatenightandalso
custody and
that MOs '7 to 11 were in their
denied. the suggestion
compelledPw.6toidentifythem.Healsodeniedthesuggestion
not Gold' merchant or Pawn
but
Goldsmith
a
only
is
that PW.6
brokerandalsodeniedthesuggestionthatpriortoT.I.Parade,he
tooktheaccusedinaJeepandshownhimtoPWs.lto4inthe
shop.Healsodeniedthesuggestionthataccusedisfalsely
imPlicated in the case'
29. PW'17-Selvaraj-Finger Print
Expert deposed that he received
aletteron13.L2.2oo3fromlnspectorofPolice,Jadcherlaincrime
No.SOof2OO3underSections302arrd'37gofIPCalongwith
of Kommu
pledge book' fingerprint slip
are
They
documents'
Ramulu@Chittoduforcomparisonandexamination.Fourthumb
as
book' They are marked
were found on the pledge
impressions
.:
D,DL,D2,andD3'ThespecimenimpressionofKommuRamuluis
--1
19127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_ I 370_20 I 7
marked as 's,'and after cornparison, he opined the disputed finger
impression nrarked as D, D1 - D3 are identical with the fingerprint
marked as s of Kommu Ramulu @ chittodu. Ex.p14 is the Xerox
copy of his report. In his cross-exarnination he stated that t]le book
is titled as pledge book. Page number is not found in the photos
which contains thumb impressions. The thumb impressions were
found in the original receipts. He denied the suggestion that his
report is incorrect.
30. Pw.18-P.Lakshmi sarada deposed that on 3o.or.2oo3 she
received a rt:quisition from CI of police, Jadcherla for conducting
T.l. Parade of the culprit in crime No.2z of 2003 of ps
Thimmajipet. The requisition is Ex.p15 and she fixed the date as
02.08.2003 and directed the police to serve the summons on the
witnesses. T.l. Parade is held on o2.08.2oo3 from 3.1s to 4.15 p.M.
by following; the formalities and procedure. pw.l and pw.4
identified the suspect as culprit and she drafted Ex.p16
proceedings. suspect did not raise any objection for the T.I.
Parade but rstated that he was detained in the police station and
his photos u/ere taken by the police and he is falsely implicated in
the case. In her cross-exarnination she stated that she recorded the
statement oi PW.l and pw.4 prior to the commencement of the
parade and Ln the statements they stated that culprit
is tall, b[ack
I
ll
KL,J and
Criminal APPeal- 1 370-20 I 7
20127
place No'4
in complexion, stout and had a beard. suspect stood at
at the time of identification by PW'l and PW'4' PW'l and PW'4
have correctly identified the suspect as culprit'
31.1. PW.lg-B.Vijaya Laxmi deposed that Dr.S-Chakradar Goud
dead
has conducted PME on 16.05.200 3 at 12.20 P.M- over the
bodyofP.MallammaontherequisitionofASlofPolice,
Thimmajipet and found the following external antimortem
injuries:
ol/igaturemarkaroundtheneck.Transverselyand
and
completely encircling the neck' 35 to 40 cms' in length
4to5cms.widthwithirregularinshape.Haemmorrhagic
pacheswerenoted.Belowtheskinonfrontalsideofthe
neck. Body was completely putrified' No mass was found
onface,upperandlowerlimbs.Greenishyellowcolourwas
foundontheskinoftheabdomenwithmissingorgans".
3L.2. Haemorrhaghic patches found in the ligature
indicates
antemortem in nature. The cause of death of the deceased
is due to
asphyxia,duetostrangulation.Ex.PlTisthePMEreport.tnternal
reveal fracture of thyroid, cartlege and the time of
examination
death is 5 to 7 days prior to PME. In her cross-examination
stated that she has not brought the hand-writings
Goud for comparison with Ex.p17.
she
of Dr'chakradar
pieces of liver, kidney and
stomachandsmallintestinesweresenttotheFsL.Shedeniedthe
suggestion that
she cannot identify the signature of
"t
2t127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appett _l 37 O _2O 17
32. It is the case of the prosecution and the evidence of pw.14
and Pw.l(; that the accused was apprehended at Gollapally bus
stage on ItlH-7 along with PW.9 and confessional panchanama is
drafted under Ex.P9. The evidence of pw.g is material wherein she
has admit:ed in her cross-examination that she and the accused
boarded Auto rickshaw at the auto stand near the temple and
reached Gcllapally Railway station and got down. They sat in the
railway stzrtion and had a chat, walked for an half an hour in the
railway station itself and she was scared, came back to the bus
stage of tiollapally from the railway station after leaving the
appellant-accused. By that time it was 7.o0 or 7.3o p.M. and when
she was ett Gollapally bus stage, the police came and enquired
about the appellant-accused and asked for his whereabouts, then
she inforrned the police that the accused was at the railway
station. Police went to the railway station took him into custody
and came back to Gollapally bus stage, took her in the Jeep to the
police steLtion. The admissions made by pw.9 falsifies the
contentior of the prosecution witnesses i.e., pws.l4 and 16 that
they have apprehended the appellant-accused at Gollapally bus
stage.
33. Insofar as securing the panch witnesses at the time of
recording confessional panchanama under Ex.p9, it is the evidence
22127
KLJ and BRMRJ
Criminal Appeal-l 37 O 20 17
of Pw.14-R.Narsimhaiah that he went to Jadcherla in a Jeep to
fetch PW.11 and Mohan Reddy-LW.14 and produced them before
Inspector of Police at about 8.0O P.M. and thereafter, the Inspector
of Police interrogated the accused. The evidence of PW.16 is that he
has sent for two panch witnesses and his staff has brought PW.ll
and Mohan Reddy-Lw.l4 to him at about 8.30 P.M. and he has
interrogated the accused at Gollapally bus stage in the presence of
the above said panch witnesses. It is apt to refer to the evidence of
PW.ll who deposed that the police has taken him and LW.14K.Mohan Reddy to the police station of Jadcherla where the
accused were present in the police custody. The evidence of PW.11
does not support the case of the prosecution with that of the
evidence of PWs.14 and 16 about interrogating the appellant-
accused at Gollapally bus stage. PW.ll stated in his crossexamination that on 17.07.2003 at about 11.30 A.M. the accused
along with the police officers and himself went to the Hillock at
Bandameedipally. The admission made by PW.l1 goes to show that
the appellant- accused was in the police custody when they were
taken to the police station, no credence can be placed on the
evidence of PWs.14 and 16 with regard to apprehending the
accused at Gollapally bus stage
23127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_ l37O_20 17
34. Insofar as the recovery panchanama under Ex.p9 by pw.I l,
it is the evidence of pw.l l that the accused has led them to the
Hillock r.ear Bandameedipalry by name Sangam Gutta on
17.07.2003 and he confessed that he has removed gold and silver
items frorn the dead body and the confessional panchanama is
drafted at the Hillock near Bandameedipally in the present crime.
The evidertce of Pw.16 is that they along with the panch witnesses,
accused went to the scene of offence on 1g.07.2oo3 at about 1o.3o
A.M. at chiliveeru Village and he has seized the stone _ Mo.l2
under cov(:r of panchanama-Ex.pl3 and later the accused led them
to the shop of PW.6 that he has pledged Mos.7 to 1t with him and
has seized the same under Ex.plO-seizure panchanama. pw.11
stated in his cross-examination that Mos.l to 6 were recovered on
18.o7.2ooit and the porice had Mos.T to 11 with them, when they
reached the shop of pw.6 and in his presence, the police has
showed Mos.7 to l1 to pw.6 and asked him whether he accepted
the pledge of MOs.Z to 11 for money from the accused. In turn,
Pw.6 stated that on recommendation of pw.7 he has accepted
Mos.7 to 11 on pledge. The evidence of pw.6 is that in two spells
the appelftrnt-accused has predged the material objects. The
admissions made by pw.ll is that Mos.7 to 11 were in
the
custody of rhe police and they were shown to PW.6 which itself
is
sufficient tr> come to a conclusion that Mos. 7 to 11 were not
24127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal- l37O-20 I 7
pledged by the appellant-accused with PW.6 but they were in the
police custody.
35. Insofar as the TI Parade is concerned, PW.18 has fixed the
date of TI Parade on 02.C,8.2003 and her evidence goes to show
that PW.1 and PW.4 have identified the suSp.it. fh" evidence of
PW.l is material at this stagb, he stated in his chief-examination
that accused came to his house, during that time he was cooking
meals, he had suspicion on him. Thereby, he has handed over the
accused to Annasagar police station on the same day and the
police has let him go. PW.1 has already seen the accused before TI
Parade itself. The evidence of PW.4 is also important wherein he
stated that the accused has purchased toddy in his shop and he
has received summons to attend the TI Parade. PW.l and PW.4
have not given any identification marks or disclosed special
features in their evidence. In
our considered view such
identilication simplicitor cannot form the basis or be taken as the
fulcrum for the entire case of the prosecution. Hence, benefit of
doubt should be given to the appellant-accused. PW.2 evidence is
that he has not observed any clothes on the dead body but a small
betel leaves bag which contained an amount of Rs.72l- is noticed
(MO.6). He handed over Mo.6-betel leaves bag with Rs.72/- to
Upasarpanch, PW.10 also did not support the case of the
prosecution with regard to inquest report under Ex'PF'
2s127
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminaf Appeel- 1370_2O I 7
36. Pw.16 stated in his chief-examination that on tr.or.2oo3 he
has apprehended the appellant-accused at Gollapally bus stage
and recorded the confession panchanama. on the next date i.e.,
18.07.2oo3 they recovered Mo.12 under recovery panchanama. [n
the cross-,:xamination he stated that he took:up the investigation
in the case from Pw.15 on 18.07.2003 itsetf. when he has taken
i
up the investigation on 18.o7.2oo3, the question of him
i
apprehending the appellant-accused at Gollapally bus stage
i
creates a <loubt in the mind of the court and as per his evid.ence
Mos.7 to I 1 were seized from the shop of pw.6 but whereas pw.l l
stated in his cross-exarnination that Mos .T to 11 were with the
I
i
police. The learned trial court has failed to look into the
discrepancies in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses,
:
erroneously arrived at a conclusion that the prosecution has
i
proved 1tr6' guilt of the appellant-accused for the offences he is
j
charged with.
I
i
i
I
37. when two views are possible, following the one in favour of
innocence of the accused is the safest course of action : See
Mallappa and Others Vs. State of Karnataka2.
21zoz+13
scc 5z+4
26127
KL,J and BRMR'J
Criminal Appeal- r 37O-2O I 7
38. We are of the view that the prosecution has miserably failed
to prove the charges framed against the appellant-accused'
Appellant-accused has filed depositions of S.Nagamrna-Pw.9,
Anjaiah chary-PW.6, K.Mohan Reddy and Md.Fareed-Pw.11
during the course of his Section 313 Cr."p.C. examination
pertaining to sc No. 41 of 2005. The learned trial court has not
considered the same as they were not confronted to PWs'6 and 9 to
contradict or ad.mit their previous statements. Even otherwise
prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt'
The observations of the learned trial Court in Para Nos'45-49 are
perverse, requires interference of this Court'
39. We are not discussing the alternate arguments advanced by
the appellant-accused counsel that Section 382 of IPC is
applicable, since prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond
reasonable doubt. The decision cited by the appellant counsel in
Battigari Shaker Vs. State of Telanganar is not applicable to the
case on hand.
40. In view of the reasons above, the conviction and sentence
imposed by the learned trial Court in SC No.396 of 2004, dated
28.07.2006 is not sustainable in law and the same is liable to be
bk
set aside and is-accordingly set aside'
27lz7
KL,J and BRMR,J
Criminal Appeal_ I 37O_20 I 7
41. Criminal Appeal No.137O of 2OI7 is allowed and the
conviction and sentence passed by the learned I Additional
Sessions Judge, at Mahabubnagar in SC.No.396 of 2OO4, dated
28.07.2006, is set aside and the appellant-accused is acquitted of
the charger;, he shall be released forthwith, if not required in any
other offenr:e.
Misct:llaneous applications, if any, stands closed.
SD/.T. KRISHNA KUMAR
JOINT REGISTRAR
G
//TRUE COPY//
/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The I Additional sessions Judge at Mahabubnagar (with records
2. The Judicierl First Class Magistrate, Nagarkurnoot
3. The Superintendent, Central prison, Warangal.
4. The statior House officer, Thimmajipet porice station
in any)
5' Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana
Hyderabad [OUT]
6. One CC to Sri Rapotu Bhaska(LEGAL AtD) IOUTI
7. Two CD Copies
VH/BA
Ny
at
r'
HIGH COURT
DATED i 21104t2026
( HE STA
JUDGMENT
,c
,J
2t rPfl
CRLA.No.13'70 of 2017
*
ALLOWINGTHE CRLA
Ig
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review