Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010615592018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3547]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2402/2018
Between:
1. KOMMIREDDINAGU @ GANESH, HINDU, R/O.28THWARD,
DOMMARACOLONY, TADEPALLIGUDEM, WEST GODAVARI
DIST
...APELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep., by the Public
Prosecutor, Andhra Pradesh, High Court of Telangana And A.P.,
Hyderabad
...RESPODENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the
High Court may be pleased to to present this Memorandum of grounds
of Criminal Appeal against the Judgment passed in S.C No. 226 of 2017
dated 19.06.2018 convicting the Accused And Appellant U/Sec., 302 IPC
to undergo R.I for Life and to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- and in default to
suffer imprisonment for 3 months, by the court of the II Additional District
and Sessions Judge, at Eluru, West Godavari, A.P
Counsel for the Apellant:
1. SUREPALLI MADHAVA RAO
2. LEGAL AID
Counsel for the Respodent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
APHC010800672017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3547]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY,THE EIGHT DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2402 of 2018
JUDGMENT: (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice Subba Reddy Satti)
The sole accused in Sessions Case No.226 of 2017 on the file of
the Court of II Additional District and Sessions Judge, West Godavari
District, Eluru, is the appellant. He was tried and convicted by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge under Section 302 I.P.C. and was sentenced
to suffer imprisonment for ‘LIFE’ and also to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-, in
default to suffer Simple Imprisonment for three months.
2.
Substance of the charge is that on the intervening night of
26/27.12.2016, the accused caught hold of the head of Muppina
Chiranjeevi (hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’) and struck him to a
brick wall and thereafter picked up a stone and hit on his face, causing
his instantaneous death, thereby committed offence punishable under
Section 302 I.P.C.
3.
The case of the prosecution, as per the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, is:
(i)
The deceased, a Mechanic by profession, was a resident of
Kadakatla, Tadepalligudem. The material witnesses as well as the
accused are also residents of Tadepalligudem. P.W.1 is the mother of
the deceased; P.W.2 is the sister of P.W.1, and P.W.3 is the daughter of
P.W.2 and cousin of the deceased. On 25.12.2016, P.W.1, the
deceased, and P.W.3 went to Chebrolu to visit the parents’ house of
P.W.1 and returned to Tadepalligudem on 26.12.2016 at about 7:00 p.m.
Thereafter, the deceased went out to fetch sambar. At around 10:00
p.m., since the deceased did not return, P.W.1 called him, who in turn
replied that he would be back within fifteen minutes. Thereafter, P.W.1
again called the deceased twice, who in turn, replied that he would come
back within ten minutes and thereafter within five minutes. However, the
deceased neither returned nor replied to the subsequent call made by
P.W.1.
(ii)
On the next day at about 6:30 a.m., while P.W.1 was
cleaning the front yard, she observed three persons looking below the
bridge. On her questioning, they informed her that somebody killed a
person and the dead body was at the bridge. P.W.1 rushed to the place
and identified the deceased as her son. She noticed that the face was
smashed. She also found kadiyam, a cell phone and cheppals at the
scene of offence. On 27.12.2016, P.W.1 went to the Police Station and
gave a report.
(iii)
P.W.13, Inspector of Police, Tadepalligudem Town Circle,
received Ex.P1-report and registered a case in crime No.328 of 2016
under Section 302 I.P.C. He submitted copies of the F.I.R. to all
concerned. Ex.P11 is the original F.I.R. He requested higher officials to
depute dog squad and clues team to the scene of offence. He secured
the presence of P.W.11 and others and visited the scene of offence. He
prepared scene observation report-Ex.P6 and rough sketch-Ex.P12. At
the scene of offence, he found a motorcycle bearing No.AP 04 AP 2404,
index company cell phone, belonged to the deceased and two green
colour beer bottles containing a label as Carlsberg, Elephant strong beer.
He seized the Index company cell phone-M.O.1, boulder stones-M.O.6,
Beer bottles (M.O.4), Blood-stained earth and controlled earth- M.O.5,
slippers-M.O.2, Steel Kadiyam-M.O.3 under mediators’ report Ex P.6.
P.W.13 examined P.Ws.1 to 4 and others at the scene of offence and
recorded their statements. He conducted inquest over the dead body in
the presence of P.W.11 and others. Ex.P7 is the inquest report. He sent
the body for postmortem examination.
(iv)
P.W.9,
Civil
Assistant
Surgeon,
Area
Hospital,
Tadepalligudem, conducted autopsy over the dead body of the deceased
and opined that the deceased died due to severe crush injury over the
face due to head injury and hanging. He issued postmortem certificate
and final opinion under Exs.P3. He also issued final opinion Ex P5, after
receipt of the RFSL report Ex.P.4.
(v)
On 28.12.2016, P.W.13 examined P.W.10 and recorded his
statement. He also examined P.Ws.5 to 7 and others and recorded their
statements. On 29.12.2016, he received fingerprint report-Ex.P10 from
the Fingerprint Office, Eluru. Based on the said report, he identified the
accused as he was a previous convict. On 31.12.2016, he examined
P.W.8 and another. On the same day, on receipt of credible information,
he, along with mediators, P.W.11 and another staff proceeded to the
house of the accused and arrested the accused. The accused confessed
commission of the offence. At the time of arrest, he seized the clothes of
the accused, M.O.7 and sent the accused to judicial remand. He sent the
material objects to FSL through SDPO, Kovvur. On 30.03.2017, P.W.13
received the final opinion from P.W.9 and filed the charge sheet on
13.04.2017.
(vi)
P.W.12, Inspector of Police, in the office of Fingerprint
expert, Eluru, on receiving a phone call from Inspector of Police,
Tadepalligudem, visited the scene of offence along with his team. During
the course of examination at the scene of offence, he found two empty
beer bottles-M.O.4. He developed chance prints by using technical
powders. He found two chance prints on one beer bottle, and they were
marked as ‘A’ and ‘B’ for the facility of photography. He got photographed
the chance prints and examined them. One chance print i.e. ‘B’ is unfit for
comparison. The other chance print ‘A’ was fit for comparison. Ex.P9 is
the scene of offence visiting report. The photocopy of the chance print ‘A’
has been compared with fingerprint record slips of Ex-convict criminals in
the fingerprint unit, Eluru. During the course of minute examination and
ridge comparison, the chance print marked as ‘A’, and it matched with
the left thumb impression on the fingerprint slip bearing Tin No.2160626
of ex-convict criminal, the accused. He sent the report to P.W.13 under a
covering letter. Ex.P10 is the fingerprint expert report of comparison.
4.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined PWs.1 to 13,
marked Exs.P1 to P12 and exhibited M.Os.1 to 7.
5.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he
denied the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
6.
Accepting the evidence of prosecution witnesses, the learned
Sessions Judge convicted the accused as foresaid.
7.
Heard Sri Surepalli Madhava Rao, learned legal aid counsel for the
appellant and Sri C. Panini Somayaji, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the respondent-State.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant would contend that the
prosecution rests its case on the circumstantial evidence, and no
circumstances connecting the accused were proved. The evidence of
P.Ws.5 to 7 and 10 is not trustworthy. P.W.10 had criminal antecedents,
and hence, his evidence cannot be relied upon. P.W.12 is not competent
to examine fingerprints on the bottles, and no separate panchanama was
conducted by P.W.12 regarding seizure of M.O.4. The Police seized
M.O.4 and later handed over the same to P.W.12. He would further
contend that the thumb impression of the accused was not taken in the
presence of the Magistrate and hence, the opinion of P.W.12 cannot be
relied upon.
9.
Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor would contend
that the prosecution established the chain of links and proved the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt. He would also submit that the
prosecution established the last seen theory, by examining P.Ws.6, 7
and 10 and further connected the chain of links by proving the thumb
impression of the accused on M.O.4 and thus connected the accused
with the crime. He would also contend that the accused failed to give any
explanation for the injuries appearing on the body of the deceased and
thus prayed to dismiss the appeal.
10.
We have given our anxious consideration and perused the entire
material on record.
11.
As seen from the material available on record, the incident took
place on the intervening night of 26/27.12.2016, and the prosecution
rests its case on circumstantial evidence. To establish the last seen
theory, the prosecution examined P.Ws.6, 7 and 10. Though P.W.10 had
criminal antecedents, his evidence cannot totally be brushed aside on
that ground. P.Ws.6 and 7, who are auto drivers, testified that the
accused and the deceased were last seen together at Brandy shop near
petrol bunk, where P.Ws.6 and 7 were also present. P.Ws.6 and 7 in
their evidence stated that when they were present at the brandy shop,
the accused offered an apple to P.Ws.6 and 7. When they refused the
offer, the accused broke an empty bottle. P.Ws.6 and 7 necked out the
accused. Later, the deceased, P.W.10 and the accused came back to the
brandy shop. When P.W.10 and the deceased asked the accused as to
who beat him, the accused, in turn, told them that nobody beat him. On
that, the deceased slapped the accused two times. Thereafter, the
accused and the deceased left on a motorcycle. Thus, the prosecution
established the last seen theory of the accused and the deceased. When
the accused was seen with the deceased, it is the duty of the accused to
explain the circumstances under which the death of the victim occurred.
However, the accused failed to explain the circumstances.
12.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Ravasaheb v. State of Karnataka1,
observed as under:
29. On its own, last seen theory is considered to be a weak basis
for conviction. However, when the same is coupled with other
factors such as when the deceased was last seen with the
accused, proximity of time to the recovery of the body of the
deceased, etc. The accused is bound to give an explanation
under Section 106 of the Evidence Act, 1872. If he does not do
so, or furnishes what may be termed as wrong explanation or if a
motive is established — pleading securely to the conviction of
the accused closing out the possibility of any other hypothesis,
then a conviction can be based thereon. [Satpal v. State of
Haryana [Satpal v. State of Haryana, (2018) 6 SCC 610]
(2023) 5 SCC 391
and Ram Gopal v. State of M.P. [Ram Gopal v. State of M.P.,
(2023) 5 SCC 534]
13.
Of course, it is a settled principle of law that the circumstance of
last seen together does not by itself infer that the accused committed the
crime. The prosecution must establish something more to connect the
accused to the crime.
14.
In the case at hand, apart from the last seen theory, the
prosecution also established fingerprints of the accused on M.O.4 and
recovery of M.O.7 at the behest of the accused. As per Ex.P4, RFSL
report, the clothes recovered at the behest of the accused, M.O.7 contain
human blood. Once the prosecution connected the accused to the crime
by placing substantial material, the accused should have given some
explanation for the presence of blood stains on his pant and shirt. A mere
plea of false implication during examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
given the incriminating circumstances against the accused, is not
sufficient.
15.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Ravirala Laxmaiah v. State of A.P.2,
observed as under at para No.20:
(2013) 9 SCC 283
“20. It is a settled legal proposition that in a case based on
circumstantial
evidence,
where
no
eyewitness
account
is
available, the principle is that:
“6. … when an incriminating circumstance is put to the
accused and the said accused either offers no explanation [for the
same,] or offers an explanation which is found to be untrue, then
the same becomes an additional link in the chain of circumstances
to make it complete.”
[Vide State of U.P. v. Ravindra Prakash Mittal [(1992) 3
SCC 300 : 1992 SCC (Cri) 642 : AIR 1992 SC 2045] , Gulab
Chand v. State of M.P. [(1995) 3 SCC 574 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 552 :
AIR 1995 SC 1598] , State of T.N. v. Rajendran [(1999) 8 SCC
679 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 40 : AIR 1999 SC 3535] (SCC pp. 685-86,
para 6), State of Maharashtra v. Suresh [(2000) 1 SCC 471 : 2000
SCC (Cri) 263] and Ganesh Lal v. State of Rajasthan [(2002) 1
SCC 731 : 2002 SCC (Cri) 247] .]
16.
The Hon’ble Apex Court, in Neel Kumar v. State of Haryana3,
held as under:
30. It is the duty of the accused to explain the
incriminating circumstance proved against him while making a
statement under Section 313 CrPC. Keeping silent and not
furnishing any explanation for such circumstance is an additional
link in the chain of circumstances to sustain the charges against
him. Recovery of incriminating material at his disclosure
statement duly proved is a very positive circumstance against
him. …”
(2012) 5 SCC 766
17.
In the case at hand, P.W.12, Inspector of Police working in the
office of fingerprint expert, Eluru, deposed that he rushed to the scene of
offence along with his team, where he found two empty beer bottlesM.O.4 and he developed the chance prints by using technical powder. He
further deposed that during the course of minute examination and ridge
comparison of the chance print marked as ‘A’, it was found to be
identified with the left thumb impression on the fingerprint slip bearing Tin
2160626 of the Ex-convict criminal. As seen from the material, the
accused was convicted earlier, and his fingerprints were available. The
contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the thumb
impression was not obtained in the presence of the learned Magistrate in
the facts and circumstances of the accused, falls to ground.
18.
It appears that the fingerprints of the accused on one of the bottles,
M.O.4, support the case of the prosecution and completes the chain of
links and connected the accused to the crime. The accused also did not
give any explanation for the injuries appearing on the body of the
deceased. P.W.9, medical officer, found ten external injuries on the body
of the deceased. The learned Additional Sessions Judge considered all
the aspects, concluded that the prosecution proved the guilt of the
accused, and eventually convicted the appellant.
19.
Given the discussion supra, we do not find any merit in the criminal
appeal.
20.
Accordingly, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby dismissed,
confirming the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned II
Additional District and Sessions Judge, West Godavari, Eluru in
S.C.No.226 of 2017 dated 19.06.2018. It is needless to state that the
period already undergone by the appellant shall be given set off, as per
the provisions of Section 428 Cr.P.C.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall
stand closed.
________________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
_______________________________
Dated : 08.01.2026
IKN
JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review