Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16495/2022
Komal Vaishnav, D/o Shri Gopichand Vaishnav, Aged About 23
Years, Permanent R/o Village Gaonri Kalan, Post Ahmadpur,
Tehsil Gangapur City, District Sawai Madhopur - Presently
Residing At Nasiya Colony,
Gangapur
City, District Sawai
Madhopur (Rajasthan)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Punjab National Bank, Through Its Chief Manager, Human
Resource Department, Circle Office, Plot No. 9-A, Near Dic
Industrial Area, Dcm Road, Kota-324007 (Rajasthan)
2.
Chief Manager, Punjab National Bank, Human Resource
Department,
Circle
Office,
Plot
No.
9-A,
Near
Dic
Industrial Area, Dcm Road, Kota-324007 (Rajasthan)
3.
Disciplinary
Authority
And
Divisional
Chief,
Punjab
National Bank, Human Resource Department, Divisional
Office, Plot No. 9-A, Near Dic Industrial Area, Dcm Road,
Kota-324007 (Rajasthan)
----Respondents
Connected With
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 10598/2023
Komal Vaishnav, Daughter Of Shri Gopi Chand Vaishnav, Aged
About 24 Years, Permanent Resident Of Village Gaonri Kalan,
Post
Ahmadpur,
Tehsil
Gangapur
City,
Sawai
Madhopur
(Rajasthan)-322201 - Presently Residing At Nasiya Colony,
Gangapur City, Sawai Madhopur (Rajasthan)-322201
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
Punjab National Bank, Through Its Chief Manager, Human
Resource Department, Circle Office, Plot No. 9A, Near Dic
Industrial Area, Dcm Road, Kota (Rajasthan)-324007
2.
Disciplinary
Authority
And
Divisional
Chief,
Punjab
National Bank, Human Resource Department, Divisional
Office, Plot No. 9A, Near Dic Industrial Area, Dcm Road,
Kota (Rajasthan)-324007
----Respondents
(2 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
[CW-16495/2022]
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Saransh Saini
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Shruti Pareek
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Judgment
24/03/2026
1.
These two writ petitions were filed by the same petitioner,
hence they are tagged together and are being decided by
this common order.
2.
The writ petitions are filed with the following prayers:
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16495/2022:
(i) By an appropriate writ, order or direction, the
impugned
order/notice
(Annexure-23)
dated
passed
28.09.2022
by
the
Disciplinary
No.3
may
kindly
Authority
respondent
quashed
and
set
aside
and
the
arbitrary
to
the
effect
of
possession
be
condition
of
graduation and higher qualifications not to be
eligible
under
qualification
the
head
the
advertisement
in
of
educational
dated
12.02.2021 (Annexure-1) and only to the said
extent may kindly be declared nullity in the eyes
of law and/or it be quashed and set aside.
(ii) It is also prayed that by an appropriate writ,
order
or
specifically
direction,
be
the
respondents
commanded
to
may
allow
the
petitioner to work as it is on the post of Peon
under
the
order
of
appointment
dated
18.03.2021 further directing them to pay her
salary and other admissible allowances and
relief
with
consequential
benefits
flowing
therefrom.
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 10598/2023:
(i) the action on the part of the respondents
proceeding
further
CasteCertificate
consequent
upon
of
regarding
the
the
OBC
petitioner
and
charge-sheet
dated
(3 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
[CW-16495/2022]
09.06.2023 may kindly be declared as illegal,
arbitrary,
mala
fide
and
violative
to
the
provisions
of
Articles
and
of
the
Constitution of India, besides the provisions of
the Bipartite Settlement and consequently, the
impugned
charge-sheet
dated
09.06.2023
(Annexure-21) may kindly be quashed and set
aside;
(ii)
the
respondents
may
specifically
be
commanded not to proceed further in pursuance
of the charge-sheet dated 09.06.2023 in the
matter.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, while placing reliance
upon the grounds of the writ petition in Writ Petition No.
16495/2022, submitted that after notice of dismissal dated
28.09.2022, the instant writ petition has been filed. He
further
submitted
that
the
respondents
have
invited
applications for the post of Peon (Class IV) with the condition
that any person who has passed 12th Secondary Education
is eligible for appointment, but a graduate or higher qualified
person is not eligible for the post. He also submitted that
possessing a higher qualification is not bad and the condition
prescribing a lower qualification is bad in the eye of law. He
also
submitted
that
the
condition
prescribed
in
the
advertisements dated 12.02.2021 (Annexure-1) is not only
bad but is a nullity in the eye of law.
4.
He also submitted that pursuant to the application form
submitted by the petitioner, the petitioner was appointed on
the post of Peon and she has submitted an affidavit with
entire
information,
and
herein
it
is
not
a
case
of
concealment. He further submitted that without any reason,
a charge-sheet has been issued to the petitioner and without
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
(4 of 13)
[CW-16495/2022]
giving her sufficient opportunity, following proper procedure,
and defend herself, an enquiry report has been prepared
against the petitioner.
5.
He also submitted that now notice dated 28.09.2022,
(Annexure-23), has been served upon the petitioner for
show cause with a predetermined decision of dismissal from
service. He also submitted that the respondents are bent
upon to dismiss the petitioner from service, and the
petitioner has no other alternative except to seek indulgence
of this Hon’ble Court.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon
the judgment in the case of Parvaiz Ahmad Parry vs.
State of Jammu and Kashmir and others, (2015) 7 SCC
709=MANU/SC/1290/2015, and submitted that when a
candidate has acquired higher qualification, the same cannot
be treated as a disadvantage to employer. He also submitted
that if the petitioner is more qualified, then it is an added
advantage for the employer, but on this ground alone,
disciplinary proceedings cannot be initiated against the
petitioner, on being higher qualified than twelfth and alleging
concealment of higher qualification.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner in Writ Petition No.
10598/2023 has submitted that by filing the current writ
petition, the petitioner has challenged the unreasonable,
arbitrary, and illegal action of the respondents in proceedings
relating to initiation of enquiry regarding the caste certificate
issued to the petitioner.
(5 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
8.
[CW-16495/2022]
He further submitted that Manisha Vaishnav has filed a Writ
Petition No. 5077/2021 to challenge the appointment order
of the present petitioner on the ground that petitioner Komal
Vaishnav does not belong to OBC category as per the Union
List. He further submitted that this writ petition was
dismissed by the Hon'ble Single Judge Bench on 03.05.2021
and thereafter Manisha Vaishnav has filed D.B. Special
Appeal No. 583/2021 and the same was dismissed on
23.08.2022. He further submitted that a review petition was
also filed and the same was dismissed on 22.08.2025.
9.
He further submitted that after dismissal of the challenge to
the appointment of the petitioner, the respondents have no
ground to initiate an enquiry against the petitioner. He
further
referred
Annexure-3
(caste
certificate)
dated
07.03.2021, and submitted that the petitioner belongs to the
"Bairagi" community and as per the list of castes included in
the Union List (Annexure-5), the entry is at Serial No. 66. He
also submitted that on the basis of the declaration and
further enquiry by the concerned authority, notice was
issued to the petitioner.
10.
He further submitted that "Swami" and "Bairagi" both are in
the same category and are considered as OBC. Learned
counsel has further placed reliance upon the additional
affidavit of the petitioner filed on 30.01.2025 and submitted
that while disposing of Review Petition (Writ) No. 186/2022
filed by Manisha Vaishnav, a Coordinate Bench of this Court
has observed that the caste certificate is cancelled by the
competent authority.
(6 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
11.
[CW-16495/2022]
He further referred to the order dated 16.04.2024 passed by
the State Level Committee and submitted that the decision
dated
17.05.2022,
whereby
the
caste
certificate
was
cancelled, has been set aside and the matter was remanded
back for re-enquiry by the District Committee. He also
submitted that since then, the enquiry is pending before the
District Level Committee. He also submitted that when the
matter is pending before the District Level Committee, and it
will take time to conclude. He cannot be said that the
petitioner has procured a false or fake certificate under OBC
category to secure appointment in the respondent bank. At
last, he submitted that the respondents have issued a
charge-sheet without any reasonable basis and the same is
liable to be set aside till the issue is finally resolved by the
District Level Committee.
12.
Aforesaid contentions were opposed by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents, and she submitted
that the respondent is a nationalised bank governed by
statute and rules as framed from time to time. She further
submitted that the respondent bank has followed the
procedure and also the guidelines as issued from time to
time, and before proceeding against the petitioner, it has
observed the procedure as prescribed under the Rules and
also the principles of natural justice.
13.
Learned counsel for the respondents in Writ Petition No.
16495/2022 has submitted that the respondent bank has
issued
an
advertisement
dated
12.02.2021
inviting
applications from eligible candidates who are only 12th pass,
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
(7 of 13)
[CW-16495/2022]
and in the advertisement, it was also made clear that
graduate or higher qualified persons are not eligible. She
further submitted that the petitioner has submitted an
affidavit on 05.03.2021 wherein she has made a statement
on oath that her minimum and maximum qualification is
12th pass. She further submitted that the petitioner has
specifically stated that she has not passed graduation or any
higher qualification from any place.
14.
She also submitted that the affidavit was submitted pursuant
to the advertisement and the petitioner is bound by the
same. She further referred the material placed on record and
submitted that the petitioner has passed graduation in year
2019 from University of Kota, Kota and further B.Ed. from
Bhagwati Teachers Training College, Gangapur City, District
Sawai Madhpur in the years 2019–2021. She further
submitted that upon notice of higher qualification, a notice
was served to the petitioner and a charge-sheet was issued
to her.
15.
She also submitted that the petitioner was given full
opportunity to participate and defend herself in the enquiry,
and after receipt of the enquiry report the petitioner was
served notice with proposed punishment. She also submitted
that as per bipartite settlement, the petitioner was served
notice dated 28.09.2022 with proposed punishment.
16.
Learned counsel for the respondents, while placing reliance
upon the judgment in Union of India and Ors. vs. M.
Bhaskaran, AIR 1996 SC 686, submitted that if anyone
obtains an appointment order by misrepresentation and
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
(8 of 13)
[CW-16495/2022]
fraud, then the appointment order is tainted and cannot be
protected by a court of law. She further referred to the
judgment in Chief Manager, PNB & Another vs. Anit
Kumar Das MANU/SC/0823/2020, and submitted that a
candidate suppressing material information or giving false
information cannot claim a right to continue in service.
17.
Learned counsel for the respondents in Writ Petition No.
10598/2023 has submitted that the respondent bank has
issued a show cause notice on the basis of complaint and
further facts brought to the notice of the bank. She also
submitted that after reply of the petitioner to the show cause
notice, disciplinary proceedings were initiated and a chargesheet was issued, to which the petitioner has submitted a
detailed reply. She further submitted that the respondent
bank, after considering the reply, has appointed an enquiry
officer to conduct an enquiry.
18.
She also submitted that the original caste certificate issued
to the petitioner has already been cancelled by the issuing
authority and the material submitted by the petitioner is not
sufficient to quash the charge-sheet. At last, she submitted
that the bank is a Government of India undertaking and is
governed by the Union List to implement reservation policy.
19.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record.
Writ Petition No. 16495/2022:
20.
The respondent bank has issued an advertisement dated
12.02.2021 (Annexure-1) inviting applications for the post of
Peon in its various branches. The qualification as on
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
(9 of 13)
[CW-16495/2022]
01.01.2021 (prescribed as per the advertisement) was
minimum and maximum 12th pass, and it was specifically
mentioned that a graduate or higher qualified candidate is
not eligible. The petitioner has filed an application and was
appointed by the respondent bank at Branch Gangapur City.
On request of the petitioner, permission for further study
was granted, but an anonymous complaint was made against
the petitioner to the respondent bank. Thereafter, on
enquiry, it came to the notice of the bank that the petitioner
has passed graduation from Agarwal Girls College, Sawai
Madhopur as private candidate, and B.Ed. from Bhagwati
Teachers Training College, Gangapur City,.
21.
The petitioner was served a show cause notice and, after
receipt of reply, a charge-sheet was issued for enquiry. After
conducting the enquiry, an enquiry report was submitted to
the disciplinary authority, and notice dated 28.09.2022 was
issued to the petitioner with proposed punishment. The
petitioner has challenged the same.
22.
In the case of Parvaiz Ahmad Parry vs. State of Jammu
and Kashmir and others (supra), the issue was whether
a candidate was qualified as per the prescribed qualification
in the J&K Service Gazetteed Recruitment Rules, 1970.
Hon’ble Supreme Court allowed the appeal and held that the
candidate possessing higher qualification than the required
qualification, is suitable for the post and same is not
disadvantageous.
23.
In the present case, the advertisement clearly indicated that
a person qualified as graduate or more is not eligible.
(10 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
[CW-16495/2022]
Admittedly, the petitioner was qualified as a graduate on the
date of submission of the application form for the post of
Peon. The condition mentioned in the advertisement makes
it clear that a person who is higher qualified is not eligible
for consideration on the post of Peon.
24.
The
petitioner
has
challenged
the
condition
of
the
advertisement only after she has been appointed on the post
and found guilty of misconduct by the enquiry officer in
departmental proceedings. The purpose of challenge is
evident from the conduct and intention of the petitioner,
which appears to be only to protect the job secured by her
on assertion that her minimum and maximum qualification is
12th pass.
25.
The petitioner has filed an affidavit dated 05.03.2021, which
is reproduced as under:
'kiFk&i=
eSa dksey oS".ko mez 22 lky iq= Jh xksihpan oS".ko fuoklh
ufl;k dkWyksuh] xaxkiqj flVh ftyk lokbZ ek/kksiqj jkt0
cgYQ c;ku djrh gw¡ fd%&
1- eSa iatkc us'kuy cSad e.My dk;kZy; dksVk }kjk vf/kuLFk
lEoxZ esa pijklh in ij HkrhZ gsrq jkstxkj foKfIr@lwpuk dks
HkyhHkkafr i<+ o le>dj ds mDr in ds fy, vkosnu fd;k
gSA
2- mDr foKfIr@lwpuk esa of.kZr 'kS{kf.kd ;ksX;rk tks fd
U;wure ,oa vf/kdre d{kk 12 oh mRrh.kZ gksuk vfuok;Z gSA eSa
;g ?kksf"kr djrh gw¡ fd esjh U;wure ,oa vf/kdre
'kS{kf.kd ;ksX;rk 12oh mRrh.kZ gSA ,oa eSaus dgha ls Hkh
Lukrd ;k led{k ijh{kk mRrh.kZ ugha dh gSA
(11 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
[CW-16495/2022]
3- mDr foKfIr@lwpuk esa of.kZr lHkh ik=rk@ekin.Mksa dks eSa
iw.kZ djrh gw¡A vkSj ;fn esjs }kjk nh xbZ dksbZ Hkh tkudkjh
xyr ik;h tkrh gS rks esjh fu;qfDr fujLr dh tk ldrh gSA
fnukad%& 05-03-2021
gLrk{kj
LFkku& xaxkiqj flVh
26.
'kiFkdrkZ
In the case of Chief Manager, PNB vs. Anit Kumar Das
(supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a candidate who
has
suppressed
material
information
or
given
false
information cannot claim a right to continue in service. The
petitioner was found ineligible as per the eligibility criteria
prescribed in the advertisement.
27.
The issue relating to specific qualification for the post of Peon
has been considered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in said
judgment. In the present case also, the petitioner has
participated in the selection process as per the eligibility
criteria and secured appointment. It is only upon an
anonymous complaint that the enquiry was conducted and
the facts came to the notice of the bank. The judgment in
case of Parvaiz Ahmad Parry vs. State of Jammu and
Kashmir and others (supra) is in respect of different
context and not application upon the facts of the case.
28.
In view of the law laid down in Chief Manager, PNB vs.
Anit Kumar Das (supra), the petitioner is not entitled to
any relief with regard to notice dated 28.09.2022. The
petitioner has no right to challenge the condition of the
advertisement dated 12.02.2021 after having participated in
(12 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
[CW-16495/2022]
the selection process without raising any objection and the
writ petition sans merits and same is liable to be dismissed.
Writ Petition No. 10598/2023:
29.
The issue pertains to issuance of OBC caste certificate in
favour of the petitioner. The material on record indicates that
the certificate issued in favour of the petitioner was
challenged by Manisha Vaishnav by filing SBCWP No.
5077/2021, which was dismissed on 03.05.2021. Thereafter,
D.B. Special Appeal No. 583/2021 was filed by her and was
dismissed on 23.08.2022. A review petition No. 186/2022
was also filed, which was dismissed on 22.08.2025, but by
the time the caste certificate was cancelled after enquiry by
the District Committee.
30.
The material on record further indicates that the certificate
issued in favour of the petitioner was cancelled by the
District Level Committee, but thereafter, on an appeal
preferred by the petitioner, an order dated 16.04.2024 was
passed and after setting aside the decision of District Level
Committee, the matter was remanded back to the District
Level Authority for fresh consideration. The District Level
Authority is seized with the matter and is at liberty to decide
the issue.
31.
As regards the complaint and charge-sheet, it is an admitted
position
that
the
Court
ordinarily
cannot
interfere
in
disciplinary proceedings, as the petitioner has yet to face
enquiry before the Enquiry Officer. In case of State of
Rajasthan and Ors. Vs. Bhupendra Singh reported as
2024 INSC 592, Hon'ble Supreme Court has examined the
[2026:RJ-JP:12485]
(13 of 13)
[CW-16495/2022]
scope of Article 226 of Constitution of India in dealing with
departmental enquiries.
32.
Considering the settled position of law, this Court cannot
interfere by holding that the disciplinary proceeding initiated
against the petitioner is contrary to law. It is well settled that
the Court cannot interfere or substitute its own decision in
place of the disciplinary authority.
33.
As regard to petitioner is concerned, if the petitioner belongs
to a caste which has been listed as one of the caste in OBC
Category in Union List then obviously petitioner is entitled
for protection but same is required to be considered only
when the proceedings are decided by the District Level
Authority. As on today, the matter is in the Court of District
Level Authority. The petitioner has no right to claim
protection only on ground that there was delay in fact finding
enquiry by the District Level Authority.
34.
Having considered the totality of facts and circumstances of
the case, no ground is made out for interference to stale the
charge-sheet issued to the petitioner, therefore the petitioner
has no right to challenge the charge-sheet issued to her.
35.
In view of discussion made hereinabove, the writ petitions
Nos. 16495/2022 and 10598/2023 are hereby dismissed.
Misc. application, if any, stands disposed of.
36.
No order as to cost.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J
PREETI VALECHA /220-221
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review