The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In the instant case, the petitioners have specifically pleaded that they have purchased the plots carved out of Sy. No. 532 and 533. The suit is filed in respect of the land situated in Sy. No. 533/A2. For the mere fact that the petitioners did not specify as to in which of the two survey numbers their plots have fallen, they cannot be non-suited. This aspect needs to be necessarily adjudicated in the suit itself. Having regard to the averments on which the petitioners filed the application for theft; impleadment, it cannot be denied that they have direct interest in the subject matter of the suit. As to what extent they have interest and whether respondent No. 1 / plaintiff is entitled to the grant of injunction or not, need to be examined in the suit. Even if the petitioners are not necessary parties, surely, they are proper parties. Besides respondent No. 1 / plaintiff not suffering any distinct disadvantage due to the impleadment of the petitioners, the latter's impleadment in the suit would, indeed, avoid multiplicity of proceedings, in that, if the plaintiff succeeds in convincing the Court for granting a BSB, J C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025 decree of injunction in the presence of the petitioners, such decree would bind the petitioners as well, obviating the necessity for the plaintiff to face separate civil proceedings that may be initiated by the petitioners if their applicatio…
11. On the other hand, the learned counsel for respondents Nos.1 and 2 / plaintiffs submitted that the petitioners can file a separate suit, if at all, they have any grievance and that in a suit for perpetual injunction, they are not necessary or proper parties and therefore, the trial Court dismissed the petition. He placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in Mumbai International Airport Private Limited Vs. Regency Convention Centre and Hotels Private Limited and others 3 . In paragraph No.15 of the said decision, the phrases, ‘necessary party’ and ‘proper party’ are explained as follows: “A 'necessary party' is a person who ought to have been joined as a party and in whose absence no effective decree could be passed at all by the Court. If a 'necessary party' is not impleaded, the suit itself is liable to be dismissed. A 'proper party' is a party who, though not a necessary party, is a person whose presence would enable the court to completely, effectively and adequately adjudicate upon all matters in disputes in the suit, though he need not be a person in favour of or (2010) 7 Supreme Court Cases 417 BSB, J C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025 against whom the decree is to be made. If a person is not found to be a proper or necessary party, the court has no jurisdiction to implead him, against the wishes of the plaintiff. The fact that a person is likely to secure a right / intere…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010576632025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Tuesday, the twentieth day of January two thousand and twenty six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B. S. Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petition No.2883 of 2025
Between:
Kolkar Sikindar and others
...Petitioners
and
Dasari Venkatesh Chandrasekhar and others
Counsel for the petitioners:
1. S. Krishna Reddy
Counsel for the respondents:
1. Kanakala Devi Prasanna Kumar
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
ORDER:
This revision is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
against the order, dated 29.12.2023, dismissing I.A.No.891 of 2018 in
O.S.No.341 of 2018 on the file of the Court of the Principal Junior Civil
Judge, Kadiri, filed by third parties / petitioners Nos.1 to 6 under Order I,
Rule 10 C.P.C. to implead them as defendants Nos.5 to 10 in the suit.
2.
The respondents Nos.1 & 2 filed the suit against the respondents
Nos.3 to 6 for perpetual injunction. The case of the plaintiffs is that the
suit schedule property of Ac.3.04 cents in Sy.No.70-3 of Kadiri village
and mandal of Anantapur district was originally owned by Vutla Venkata
Subbaiah and he sold the same to Smt. G.Sowbhagyavathi,
M. Nagarathnamma, T.Aravinda Babu and N. Sreenivasulu Reddy for
consideration under a registered sale deed, dated 07.04.2011, and put
them in possession of the property; that the purchasers enjoyed the
property with absolute rights and subsequently, Smt. Sowbhagyavathi
and the three others sold the entire plaint schedule property to the
plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2 for consideration under a registered sale deed,
dated 04.07.2011 and put them in possession. Shortly thereafter, on
18.07.2011, Smt. G.Sowbhagyavathi and the three others executed a
registered rectification deed, rectifying the mistake in the name of the
plaintiff No.2, i.e., instead of mentioning her name as D.C. Nagamani, it
was mentioned as D.V.Nagamani in the registered sale deed, dated
04.07.2011; that mutations were made in the revenue records in the
names of the plaintiffs and pattadar passbooks and title deeds were
issued to the plaintiffs showing half of the plaint schedule property with
demarcated sub-division survey numbers 70-3A and 70-3B; that the
plaintiffs got the plaint schedule property converted for non-agricultural
use vide proceedings of the Revenue Divisional Officer, Kadiri in
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
R.Dis.No.2519/2014E, dated 22.08.2014; and that the defendants,
having no manner of right and possession, started interfering with the
plaint schedule property and made efforts to exert pressure on the
plaintiffs to alienate the same to them, but as the plaintiffs declined to do
so, the defendants who are realtors, are making all efforts to grab the
plaint schedule property in one way or the other including fabrication of
revenue records.
3.
The defendants filed a written statement denying the case of the
plaintiffs and further stating that the plaint schedule property originally
belonged to D.Mangamma; that she executed an agreement of sale in
favour of Vutla Venkata Subbaiah and Y. Krishna Reddy who filed a suit
in O.S.No.370 of 1988 before the Court of the District Munsif, Kadiri, for
its specific performance; that the suit was decreed; that decree holders
transferred the decree in favour of M.Askar; that the transferee obtained
a registered sale deed through Court in execution proceedings in
E.P.No.44 of 1992 in O.S.No.370 of 1988; that M. Askar sold the
property to the defendants under a registered sale deed, dated
19.07.2007, for a valid consideration and put the purchasers in
possession of the property; that D.Mangamma filed an application in
E.A.No.66 of 1989 for grant of cheque and received the amount
deposited for balance of consideration by accepting the decree; that
D.Mangamma could not execute a Will in favour of Vutla Venkata
Subbaiah; that when there were rumors in the town that Venkata
Subbaiah is going to alienate the property in favour of third parties, the
defendants raised an objection setting out the facts to the SubRegistrar, Kadiri and requesting him not to entertain any deed of
alienation in respect of the plaint schedule property and further, the
defendants got a notice published in Eenadu daily newspaper on
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
22.04.2011; that Vutla Venkata Subbaiah brought into existence the
sale deed in favour of M.Nagarathnamma and others, dated 07.04.2011
without having any right over the property and therefore, the said
document is not valid and binding on the defendants; that on coming to
know of the sale deed, dated 07.04.2011, the defendants filed a suit in
O.S.No.40 of 2011 on the file of the Court of III Additional District Judge,
Anantapuramu, for cancellation of the said sale deed; that Venkata
Subbaiah filed a written statement, whereas the other defendants did
not contest the case and the suit was decreed cancelling the sale deed,
dated 07.04.2011, and therefore, the sale deed of the plaintiffs is hit by
the principle of lis pendense and the plaintiffs cannot lay any claim and;
that the plaintiffs are not in possession of the suit schedule property and
therefore, there is no cause of action to file the suit.
4.
The petitioners in I.A.No.891 of 2018 contended that the plaint
schedule property of Ac.3.04 cents in Sy.No.70-3 of Kadiri village
originally belongs to Devalam Mangamma and she sold the property to
Pulamithi Anand Kumar under a registered sale deed, dated
08.01.1985, for valid consideration and put the purchaser in possession;
that the said Anand Kumar sold the entire property to Patan
Khajamohiddin Khan for valid consideration under a registered sale
deed, dated 28.07.1989 and inducted the purchaser in possession of
the property; that Patan Khajamohiddin Khan, gifted Ac.1.52 cents with
specific boundaries out of the said property to his daughter, Kolkar
Khamarunnisa, under registered gift deed, dated 28.02.1991, and
delivered possession of the same; that he remained in possession of
the rest of Ac.1.52 cents; that the revenue authorities, after conducting
enquiry, granted
pattadar
passbook
and title deed to
Kolkar
Khamarunnisa; that Khamarunnisa, in turn, gifted a single plot of
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
Ac.0-47 ½ cents out of her property of Ac.1.52 cents under a registered
gift deed, dated 20.03.2006 to the petitioner No.2 and inducted her in
possession of the same; that since then, they have been in possession
of their respective properties; while the things stood thus, as (1) Vutla
Venkata Subbaiah, (2) Y.Krishna Reddy, (3) M.Askar, (4) M.Arshad
Basha @ Munna / respondent No.5, (5) K.Abubakar / respondent No.3,
(6) G.Nayazuddin / respondent No.4, (7) S.Aslam Khan / respondent
No.6; (8) Guduru Soubhagyavathi, (9) Mannem Nagarathnamma, (10)
Thatanagari Aravinda Babu and (11) Naguru Sreenivasulu Reddy tried
to interfere with the possession and enjoyment of the property by
creating false documents, the petitioner No.2 filed suit in O.S.No.386 of
2011 and Kolkar Khamarunnisa filed O.S.No.375 of 2011 before the
Court of Principal Junior Civil Judge, Kadiri, against all the said eleven
persons seeking perpetual injunction with regard to their respective
properties; that the defendants remained ex parte and decrees have
been passed on 21.03.2013 in both the suits; that Kolkar Khamarunnisa
died in the year 2016 leaving behind her the petitioners Nos.1 to 6 to
succeed her property of Ac.1.04 ½ cents and that apart, the petitioner
No.2 is the owner of Ac.0.47 ½ cents and; that therefore, the petitioners
have right, title and possession over Ac.1.52 cents out of the plaint
schedule property of Ac.3.04 cents and are proper and necessary
parties to the suit.
5.
The petition was opposed by filing counters.
6.
The respondents Nos.1 and 2 filed a separate counter stating that
the petitioners have suppressed the material facts and approached the
Court with all false and distorted versions, and reiterated the case
pleaded in the plaint and further stated as follows:
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
The respondents Nos.3 to 6, the defendants, have no manner of
right and possession over the plaint schedule property at any point of
time. In view of the threats of the defendants, the plaintiffs filed the suit
in O.S.No.341 of 2018 against the respondents Nos.3 to 6, i.e.,
defendants Nos.1 to 4 seeking permanent injunction along with a
petition in I.A.No.784 of 2018 for temporary injunction. The trial Court
passed ad-interim injunction order on 25.07.2018 restraining the
respondents Nos.3 to 6 from interfering with the possession and
enjoyment of the respondents Nos.1 and 2 over the plaint schedule
property. The plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2 also filed a writ petition in
W.P.No.27685 of 2018 before this Court against the State and the local
police officials and this Court directed the local police not to interfere in
the civil dispute between the respondents Nos.1 and 2 / plaintiffs Nos.1
and 2 and the respondents Nos. 3 to 6 / defendants Nos.1 to 4 till
disposal of the writ petition. The respondents Nos.3 to 6, having kept
quiet for considerable period and when the respondents Nos.1 and 2 /
plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2 purchased the suit property, started to interfere
with their possession and enjoyment over the plaint schedule property.
The respondents Nos.1 and 2 / plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2 are not parties to
the alleged documents and the ex parte decrees referred to above. The
petitioners have nothing to do with the plaint schedule property. The
suit filed by the respondents Nos.1 and 2 / plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2 against
the respondents Nos.3 to 6 / defendants Nos.1 to 4 is one for
permanent injunction simplicitor. It is not a declaratory suit to adjudicate
upon the so called right, title, possession and enjoyment of the
petitioners over part of the suit property. The remedy of the petitioners
is to seek appropriate reliefs in a properly framed suit with regard to
their alleged rights in part of the suit property. The present petition to
bring them on record as parties to the suit to adjudicate their right and
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
title to part of the suit property is not at all maintainable. Further, the
petitioners are third parties and are not entitled to seek amendment of
the plaint filed by the respondents Nos.1 and 2 / plaintiffs Nos.1 and 2.
The petition is mala fide and liable to be dismissed.
7.
The respondents Nos.3 to 6 filed a separate counter with the
following averments:
These respondents alone are the owners of the plaint schedule
property and their right was also confirmed by the District Judge,
Ananthapuramu. Further, the Sub-Registrar, Kadiri also cancelled the
deed as per the directions of the District Judge, Ananthapuramu, in
O.S.No.372 of 1988. The possession of the property has been delivered
through the agreement of sale.
The petitioners colluded with the
respondents Nos.1 and 2, i.e., the plaintiffs and filed the petition only to
drag on the proceedings. Further, the petitioners have remedy also to
file a separate suit. Hence, the petition is liable to be dismissed.
8.
After hearing all the parties, the trial Court dismissed the petition
holding that the petitioners are not necessary parties and without their
presence, the suit can be completely decided. It is further observed that
in a suit for perpetual injunction, threat by the defendant to dispossess
the plaintiff or with such apprehension, the cause of action for the suit
would arise, but in the present suit, there is no such threat from the
petitioners and thus, there is no cause of action in the suit against them
as defendants.
9.
Aggrieved by the order, this revision petition was filed by the
proposed parties mainly contending that pending the suit, I.A.No.891 of
2018 was filed on 21.08.2018 whereas the written statement was filed
on 07.08.2018 and therefore, there is no much delay in the approach of
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
the petitioners to file the petition in I.A.No.891 of 2018. However, the
trial Court erroneously dismissed the petition in spite of the best cause
shown by the petitioners and the presence of the petitioners in the suit
would facilitate the Court to examine whether there is any negligence or
collusion between the plaintiffs and the defendants Nos.1 to 4 and that
unless the petitioners are impleaded, immense prejudice would be
caused to them and that it is necessary to implead them to avoid future
litigation in relation to the plaint schedule proeprty.
10.
The learned counsel for the revision petitioners submitted that
even in a suit for perpetual injunction, third parties can be impleded as
defendants at their instance as there is no hard and fast rule that a third
party cannot be added though such a party is a necessary or proper
party for complete / better adjudication of the lis. In this regard, he
placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Racharla Thirupathi
and
others
Vs.
Gundala
Shobha
Rani
and
others 1 and
S.M.M.Jahangir Ali Khan Vs. Markazi Qutub Khana (Library), rep.
by its President, Mr. Mohammed Abdul Khader and another2.
a.
In Racharla Thirupathi and others (1 supra), it was held at
paragraphs Nos.5, 10 and 11 as follows:
“5. Order I Rule 10(2) CPC confers discretion on the
Court, either to strike out or add parties, at any stage of
the proceedings either upon or without the application of
any party. The main criterion for addition of parties is to
enable the Court to effectively and completely adjudicate
2013 (5) ALT 209 (S.B)
2016 (3) ALT 754 (S.B)
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit.
Whether a person is a necessary or a proper party
depends upon the nature of the dispute raised and the
relief claimed by the plaintiff.
10. In the ultimate analysis, the Court is required to see
whether the persons who claim to be impleaded have
direct interest in the subject matter of the dispute and
whether their presence would help the Court to finally
and completely adjudicate the dispute.
11. In the instant case, the petitioners have specifically
pleaded that they have purchased the plots carved out of
Sy. No. 532 and 533. The suit is filed in respect of the
land situated in Sy. No. 533/A2. For the mere fact that
the petitioners did not specify as to in which of the two
survey numbers their plots have fallen, they cannot be
non-suited. This
aspect needs
to
be
necessarily
adjudicated in the suit itself. Having regard to the
averments on which the petitioners filed the application
for theft; impleadment, it cannot be denied that they have
direct interest in the subject matter of the suit. As to what
extent they have interest and whether respondent No. 1 /
plaintiff is entitled to the grant of injunction or not, need to
be examined in the suit. Even if the petitioners are not
necessary parties, surely, they are proper parties.
Besides respondent No. 1 / plaintiff not suffering any
distinct disadvantage due to the impleadment of the
petitioners, the latter's impleadment in the suit would,
indeed, avoid multiplicity of proceedings, in that, if the
plaintiff succeeds in convincing the Court for granting a
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
decree of injunction in the presence of the petitioners,
such decree would bind the petitioners as well, obviating
the necessity for the plaintiff to face separate civil
proceedings that may be initiated by the petitioners if
their application for impleadment is dismissed. On a
careful analysis of the facts and circumstances of the
case, I am of the opinion that the petitioners deserved to
be impleaded as defendants in the suit.”
b.
In S.M.M. Jahangir Ali Khan (2nd supra), the plaintiff filed suit
against the G.H.M.C. for perpetual injunction to restrain it and its
employees from either interfering in any manner with the suit schedule
property or demolishing it, either in part or whole and for other reliefs. In
the suit, a third party wanted to be impleaded as a defendant being
aggrieved by the constructions made by the plaintiff, inter alia
contending that
such constructions are being made unauthorizedly
without obtaining approved plan and without leaving setbacks and
without proper foundation endangering the lives of the neighbours. The
third
party,
who
filed
the
impleadment
petition
submitted
a
representation to G.H.M.C. and complained to the police authorities.
When the authorities failed to act upon, the third party filed writ petition
in W.P.No.15703 of 2015 before the High Court.
The High Court
directed G.H.M.C. to take further action. The plaintiff who is a party to
the writ petition, filed the suit immediately after the order in the writ
petition, without impleading the writ petitioner as a party to the suit and
obtained status quo order in the interlocutory application filed along with
the suit. The petition for impleading third party was resisted by the
plaintiff. The third party / petitioner contended that though the plaintiff is
a dominant litigant, a Court can direct impleadment of such party and
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in Ramesh
Hirachand Kundanmal Vs. Municipal Corporation of Greater
Bombay [(1992) 2 SCC 524], wherein the Supreme Court held that a
Court in its discretion can direct a plaintiff, though dominant litigant, to
implead a person as a necessary party if the facts and circumstances of
the case so warrant.
In that backdrop, the High Court allowed
impleadment of third party as a defendant for effective adjudication of
the suit.
11.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for respondents Nos.1
and 2 / plaintiffs submitted that the petitioners can file a separate suit, if
at all, they have any grievance and that in a suit for perpetual injunction,
they are not necessary or proper parties and therefore, the trial Court
dismissed the petition.
He placed reliance on the decision of the
Supreme Court in Mumbai International Airport Private Limited Vs.
Regency Convention Centre and Hotels Private Limited and
others 3 . In paragraph No.15 of the said decision, the phrases,
‘necessary party’ and ‘proper party’ are explained as follows:
“A 'necessary party' is a person who ought to have been
joined as a party and in whose absence no effective
decree could be passed at all by the Court. If a
'necessary party' is not impleaded, the suit itself is liable
to be dismissed. A 'proper party' is a party who, though
not a necessary party, is a person whose presence
would enable the court to completely, effectively and
adequately adjudicate upon all matters in disputes in the
suit, though he need not be a person in favour of or
(2010) 7 Supreme Court Cases 417
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
against whom the decree is to be made. If a person is not
found to be a proper or necessary party, the court has no
jurisdiction to implead him, against the wishes of the
plaintiff. The fact that a person is likely to secure a right /
interest in a suit property, after the suit is decided against
the plaintiff, will not make such person a necessary party
or a proper party to the suit for specific performance.”
After thorough examination of the decisions in the previous
decided cases and the facts of the case before the Supreme Court, it
was held that appellant was neither a necessary party nor a proper
party as he is neither a purchaser nor the lessee of the suit property and
has no right, title or interest therein and relief was sought by the plaintiff
against the appellant. It was also observed that an effective decree can
be passed even in the absence of the appellant.
12.
In reply, the learned counsel for the petitioners distinguished the
application of the decision in Mumbai International Airport Private
Limited (supra), on the ground that it was rendered in a suit for specific
performance, whereas the present case is a suit for perpetual injunction
and that each case is to be examined in the light of the facts and
circumstances.
13.
As can be seen from the above discussion and the decisions
referred by the revision petitioners, there is no absolute bar against the
impleadment of a third party in a suit for perpetual injunction in spite of
resistance by the plaintiffs. What is to be examined is the necessity to
implead a party to the suit.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
14.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
The case pleaded by both the parties to the suit and the
petitioners, as indicated above, clearly make out that the contention of
the petitioners is not frivolous, but needs a detailed trial. The relief of
perpetual injunction being a discretionary relief, a party can show that a
plaintiff is not entitled to the relief claimed. As such, though the plaintiff
does not choose to seek any relief against the defendant alleging threat
of dispossession, a third party who has a good case to resist the relief of
the plaintiff can be added as a proper party. In a suit for perpetual
injunction, though the question of possession is primary and essential,
question of title is incidental and assumes significance in many aspects.
It is often argued that the proposed party can lay a separate suit, if at all
has a good case in a suit for perpetual injunction. However, to avoid
multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting approaches and meanwhile,
creating chaos in the rights over the property further leading to
multiplicity of proceedings, in a given case, if necessary, a third party
can be allowed to be impleaded even in a suit for perpetual injunction.
16.
The case on hand is one such case where the impleadment of
third party can be allowed for better and complete adjudication of the lis.
Without appreciating the subject in a proper perspective, the trial Court
erroneously dismissed the petition and therefore, the order impugned in
the revision is liable to be set aside.
17.
In the result, the civil revision petition is allowed.
The order,
dated 29.12.2023, in I.A.No.891 of 2018 in O.S.No.341 of 2018 on the
file of the Court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Kadiri, is set aside.
As a sequel, I.A.No.891 of 2018 is allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.2883 of 2025
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________
B.S. BHANUMATHI, J
Date: 20.01.2026
RAR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review