Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:674
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 496 of 2021 with
WP(C) No. 416 of 2023
WP(C) No. 150 of 2024
Date of Decision: 04.08.2025
WP(C) No. 496 of 2021
1.
Shri. Kmen Myrchiang
Aged About 46 years
S/o Shri. Fidalis Pohrmen
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2.
Smt. Ri Kynti Ryngksai
Aged About 59 years
D/o Mrs Shila Ryngksai
R/o. Dawki, West Jaintia Hills District
3.
Shri. Marcony Pohty
Aged About 47 years
S/o (L) K.Khonglah
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District
4.
Shri. Tan Khongsling
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) Lar Kongwang
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District
5.
Shri. Aity Syngkrem
Aged About 40 years
D/o(L) Dusimai Syngkrem
R/o. Dawki, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
6.
Smt. Empty Syngkrem
Aged About 47 years
D/o(L) Dusimai Syngkrem
R/o. Dawki, West Jaintia Hills District
7.
Shri. Konstarwell Lamin
Aged About 62 years
S/o (L) Loris Sumer
R/o. Umkrem, East Khasi Hills District
8.
Ms. Morgina Sungoh
Aged About 29years
D/o Tomi Gassah
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
9.
Ms. Joysanta Merry Suting
Aged About 23 years
D/o Mrs Esterly Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
10.
Shri. Bok Sungoh
Aged About 58 years
S/o (L) Ragon Suchiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
11.
Shri. Tngen Dhar
Aged About 52 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
12.
Shri. Chobi Shadap
Aged About 56 years
S/o (L) Mrs Arban Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
13.
Shri. Lumlang Pohti
Aged About 37 years
D/o (L) Siangmin Pohti
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
14.
Smt. Ripa N Pamdhai
Aged About 46 years
D/o (L) Don Lamin
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
15.
Shri. Har Suting
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) Onli Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
16.
Smt. Tngensiful Lamin
Aged About 58 years
D/o (L) Hatdu Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
17.
Smt. Jemnud Lamin
Aged About 55 years
D/o (L) Hatdu Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
18.
Shri. Albert Lakashiang
Aged About 50 years
S/o (L) Kwin Lakashiang
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
19.
Smt. Pyntngen Lyngdoh Kiri
Aged About 75 years
D/o (L) Iem L Kiri
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
20.
Smt. Embhahlang Pohti
Aged About 33 years
D/o Smt. Somorin Pohti
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District.
21.
Shri. Denis Shadap
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Elbina Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
22.
Smt. Sophie Suting
Aged About 48 years
W/o Bob Sungoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
23.
Smt. Bina Durong
Aged About 48 years
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
24.
Shri. Wanbor Myrchiang
Aged About 64 years
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District.
25.
Shri. Udisty Ryngksai
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Lo Ryngksai
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
26.
Smt. Timai Ryngksai
Aged About 75 years
D/o (L) Lo Ryngksai
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
27.
Smt. Philo Tynsong
Aged About 70 years
D/o (L) Sngai Tynsong
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
28.
Smt. Mediya Pohsnem
Aged About 80 years
D/o (L) Nui Pohsnem
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
29.
Smt. Poonam Tynsong
Aged About 40 years
D/o Morgina Tynsong
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
30.
Shri. Brik Tynsong
Aged About 44 years
S/o (L) Kindro Pohti
R/o. Darrang, West Jaintia Hills District.
31.
Shri. Comfort Lynthong
Aged About 52 years
S/o (L) Elibon Lynthong
R/o. Amjalong, West Jaintia Hills District.
32.
Shri. Marjan Lakashiang
Aged About 32 years
S/o Minchiang Lamin
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
33.
Smt. Quality Lakashiang
Aged About 40 years
D/o Airis Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
34.
Shri. Use Pamblang
Aged About 28 years
S/o Shri Kiat Khyriem
R/o. Pasadwar, West Jaintia Hills District.
35.
Smt. Iaid Khongiong
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) David Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
36.
Smt. Onika Suting
Aged About 30 years
D/o Mrs Kwe Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
37.
Smt. Dap Mylliem
Aged About 48 years
D/o (L) Nit Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
38.
Smt. Dhar Khongiong
Aged About 45 years
D/o Mrs Pleris Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
39.
Smt. Berali Khongiong
Aged About 36 years
D/o Mrs Iaid Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
40.
Smt. Moi Mylliem
Aged About 62 years
D/o Mrs Nit Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
41.
Smt. Bistilda Khongiong
Aged About 50 years
D/o (L) N.Starling Iangrai
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
42.
Shri. Kelmon Khongiong
Aged About 30 years
S/o Kynjli Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
43.
Shri. Long Lyngdoh
Aged About 45 years
S/o Shri Bijun Lamare
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
44.
Smt. Lostme Lyngdoh
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Mrs Deh Lyngdoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
45.
Shri. Dhone Lyngdoh
Aged About 52 years
D/o (L) Mrs Deh Lyngdoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
46.
Shri. Mimi Sungoh
Aged About 30 years
S/o Arbili Sungoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
47.
Shri. Lurshai Khonglah
Aged About 62 years
S/o (L) Bishra Pohshna
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
48.
Smt. Oldis Khongiong
Aged About 54 years
D/o (L) David Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
49.
Shri. Rum Manar
Aged About 49 years
S/o (L) Mrs Be Manar
R/o. Amtapoh, West Jaintia Hills District.
50.
Shri. Bolai Sumer
Aged About 46 years
S/o Small Kassar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
51.
Shri. Hedrik Dhar
Aged About 63 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
52.
Smt. Rida Khongiong
Aged About 42 years
D/o Sophir Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
53.
Smt. Irinda Khongiong
Aged About 40 years
D/o Morina Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
54.
Shri. Saimon Shadap
Aged About 35 years
S/o Sarmen Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
55.
Shri. Mone Shadap
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Delilal Joshi
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
56.
Smt. Theisolong Suting
Aged About 35 years
D/o Sophie Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
57.
Smt. Wiles Khongiong
Aged About 47 years
D/o Kmir Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
58.
Shri. Dar Suting
Aged About 55 years
S/o (L) Biang Mukhim
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
59.
Smt. Income Gashnga
Aged About 55 years
D/o (L) Blue Gashnga
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
60.
Shri. Biju Shadap
Aged About 40 years
S/o Nayyar Sanmurgam
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
61.
Smt. Rihun Khongjoh
Aged About 38 years
D/o Second Khongjoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
62.
Smt. Hel Suting
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Oli Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
63.
Shri. Amin Suting
Aged About 62 years
D/o (L) Oli Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
64.
Shri. Moni Khongiong
Aged About 60 years
S/o (L) Rom Pohleng
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
65.
Shri. Keni Khongiong
Aged About 50 years
S/o (L) Rom Pohleng
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
66.
Smt. Sweetme Khongiong
Aged About 25 years
D/o Samuel Sangma
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
67.
Shri. Long Dhar
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
68.
Smt. Erila Khongiong
Aged About 23 years
D/o Rusty Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
69.
Shri. Bren Najiar
Aged About 50 years
S/o (L) Bill Najiar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
70.
Smt. Eral Khongiong
Aged About 37 years
D/o Long Dhar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
71.
Smt. Baribha Khongiong
Aged About 30 years
D/o Pleasetila Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
72.
Shri. Phumen Shadap
Aged About 75 years
S/o Langtuk Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
73.
Smt. Siang Sumer
Aged About 47 years
D/o (L) Bareh Sumer
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
74.
Smt. Riew Bareh
Aged About 69 years
D/o (L) Long Bareh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
75.
Smt. Amvalina Buam
Aged About 41 years
D/o Molini Buam
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District.
76.
Smt. Nong Pohtam
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Ron Pohtam
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
77.
Shri. Jiten Buam
Aged About 50 years
S/o Phre Pohshna
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
78.
Shri. Rajesh Nonglamin
Aged About 39 years
S/o (L) Kulab Nonglamin
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
79.
Smt. Teng Manner
Aged About 69 years
D/o (L) Lakhi Manner
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
80.
Shri. Hap Dhar
Aged About 63 years
S/o Long Dhar
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District
81.
Shri. Firstborn Pohti
Aged About 25 years
S/o (L) Li Sungoh
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
82.
Shri. Sarteng Syrty
Aged About 60 years
S/o Sarmen Syrti
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District
83.
Shri. Star Timung
Aged About 33 years
S/o (L) Mon Timung
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District
84.
Shri. Kongnge Syrti
Aged About 38 years
S/o Sarmen Syrti
R/o. Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District
85.
Shri. Dictorson Pohplet
Aged About 47 years
S/o Melina Pohplet
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
86.
Shri. Rallendar Pohti
Aged About 56 years
S/o C. Lamin
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
87.
Smt. Darihun Sumer
Aged About 26 years
D/o Bilty Sumer
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
88.
Shri. Ravis Syndai
Aged About 47 years
S/o Mrs Suliang Syndai
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
89.
Shri. Benediction Buam
Aged About 40 years
S/o Raphael Khonglah
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
90.
Smt. Molini Buam
Aged About 65 years
D/o (L) Syntu Buam
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
91.
Smt. Maya Pohlong
Aged About 55 years
D/o (L) Pohbai Pohlong
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
92.
Smt. Jingshai Kynsai
Aged About 37 years
D/o Temi Kynsai
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
93.
Smt. Sylvinia Buam
Aged About 33 years
D/o (L) Chiang Buam
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
94.
Smt. Rmen Lakuna
Aged About 74 years
D/o (L) Smt Nong Lakuna
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
95.
Shri. Bin Suting
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) Phur Surong
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
96.
Smt. Merciful Pakyntein
Aged About 46 years
D/o Chiang Pakyntein
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
97.
Smt. Lucy Lakashiang
Aged About 47 years
D/o Mary Lakashiang
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
98.
Smt. Bailin Syndai
Aged About 63 years
D/o (L) Lakuna Pohbai
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
99.
Shri. Willy Pohplet
Aged About 70 years
S/o (L) D. Khyriem
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
100.
Smt. Plastic Pala
Aged About 65 years
D/o (L) Eltimai Pala
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
101.
Smt. Beautiful Pakyntein
Aged About 54 years
D/o Chiang Pakyntein
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
102.
Shri. Wesperson Pohbai
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Kilbis Dhar
R/o. Muktapur, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
103.
Shri. Burma Lyngdoh
Aged About 70 years
S/o(L) Hat Bareh Pohlynjar
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
104.
Ms. Sawandashisha Pohlynjar
Aged About 25 years
D/o Mr. Burma Lyngdoh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
105.
Ms. Shing Lama Myrchiang
Aged About 74 years
D/o Belgium Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
106.
Smt. Molida Pamthied
Aged About 67 years
D/o (L) Priss Pamthied
R/o. Amjalong, West Jaintia Hills District
107.
Smti. Cicilia Lynthong
Aged About 57 years
D/o Mrs. Sidia Lynthong
R/o. Amjalong, West Jaintia Hills District
108.
Ms. Priyanka Lyngthong
Aged About 30 years
D/o Longmin Lynthong
R/o. Amjalong, West Jaintia Hills District
109.
Shri. Command Rymbui
Aged About 47 years
S/o (L) Releaseborn Rymbui
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
110.
Smt. Rati Myrchiang
Aged About 37 years
D/o Solbi Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
111. Smt. Hynchar Pohchen
Aged About 82 years
D/o (L) Ron Pohchen
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
112. Smt. Sah Pohlynjar
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Long Pohlynjar
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
113. Smt. Moti Pohlynjar
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Deng Pohlynjar
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
114. Smt. Min Lyngdoh
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Kat Bareh Lyngdoh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
115. Smt. Kmen Pohti
Aged About 55 years
D/o (L) Mibel Pohti
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
116. Smt. Law Myrchiang
Aged About 46 years
D/o (L) Long Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
117. Smt. Sidora Lamin
Aged About 43 years
D/o (L) Mrs Dengdu Lamin
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
118. Smt. Rekha Tongper
Aged About 39 years
D/o Mrs Kat Tongper
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
119. Smt. Siang Nongpoh
Aged About 70 years
D/o (L) Mrs Shing Nongpoh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
120. Smt. Hynchar Padu
Aged About 61 years
D/o (L) Mrs Men Padu
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
121. Smt. Ewanpynhun Padu
Aged About 25 years
D/o (L) Lina Padu
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
122. Smt. Fatima Padu
Aged About 38 years
D/o Doh Padu
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
123. Smt. Nerit Padu
Aged About 49 years
D/o (L) Toi Padu
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
124. Smt. Ruby Pohshna
Aged About 56 years
D/o (L) Long Pohshna
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
125. Shri. Covermewell Pamdhai
Aged About 37 years
S/o Roma N Pamdhai
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
126. Smt. Nazareth Nonglamin
Aged About 32 years
D/o Kmenlang Nonglamin
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
127. Shri. Reagan Buam
Aged About 23 years
S/o Smt. Shing Buam
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
128. Smt. Soly Lyngdoh Giri
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Hat Lyngdoh Giri
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
129. Smt. Ron Gassar
Aged About 67 years
D/o (L) Chuimin Kassar
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
130. Smt. Hat Lyngdoh Giri
Aged About 75 years
D/o (L) Eldi Lyngdoh Giri
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
131. Smt. Delimai Pohti
Aged About 67 years
D/o (L) Kwill Pohti
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
132. Smt. Philisbon Rymbui
Aged About 62 years
D/o (L) Prince Rymbui
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
133. Smt. Haibahun Rymbui
Aged About 34 years
D/o Dohri Rymbui
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
134. Smt. Nemsimai Lyngdoh Giri
Aged About 65 years
D/o (L) Labon LyngdohGiri
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
135. Shri. Dapmon Tariang
Aged About 71 years
S/o Elphimai Tariang
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
136. Smt. Pretty Rymbui
Aged About 52 years
D/o (L) Shilak Rymbui
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
137. Smt. Kyrmensoi Rymbui
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Shilak Rymbui
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
138. Smt. Bima Myrchiang
Aged About 39 years
D/o Mrs. Kat Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
139. Shri. Pillarson Nongpoh
Aged About 54 years
S/o (L) Bilamai Nongpoh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
140. Smt. Sunita Pohsnem
Aged About 45 years
D/o Sahmin Pohsnem
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
141. Smt. Rusila Lyngdoh Talang
Aged About 47 years
D/o (L) Law L. Talang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
142. Shri. Min Lyngdoh Rad
Aged About 59 years
S/o Phri Lyngdoh Rad
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
143. Shri. Long Bareh
Aged About 63 years
S/o (L) Riang Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
144. Smt. Bon Lyngdoh Talang
Aged About 63 years
D/o (L) Chui L Talang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
145. Shri. K. Rymbui
Aged About 61 years
S/o (L) Sadar Lyngdoh Rad
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
146. Shri. J. Donbor Dkhar
Aged About 48 years
S/o Jophola Thohrem
R/o. Nongsohphan, East Khasi Hills District
147. Smt. Ailad Kharluni.
Aged About 50 years
D/o Jophola Thohrem
R/o. Nongsohphan, East Khasi Hills District
... Petitioner(s)
-Versus1.
Union of India represented by the Home
Secretary, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The Union of India, represented by the
Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry
of Home Affairs, New Delhi-110001
3.
The Union of India, represented by the
Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry
of External Affairs, New Delhi-110001
4.
Government of Meghalaya represented by
The Chief Secretary
5.
Commissioner
&
Secretary
Political
Department Government of Meghalaya
Shillong.
6.
Commissioner
&
Secretary
Disaster
Management, Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong
2025:MLHC:674
7.
Director Survey of Meghalaya, Shillong.
8.
Collector, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai.
9.
Collector, East Khasi Hills District, Shillong.
10.
Jaintia Hills Autonomous District Council,
Jowai
11.
Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council,
Shillong
12.
National Building Construction Corporation
Limited.
....Respondent(s)
WP(C) No. 416 of 2023
1.
Dorbar Elaka Satpator,
West Jaintia Hills District, Meghalaya
Represented by its Doloi,
Shri Daman Lakashiang
- Versus –
… Petitioner(s)
1.
State of Meghalaya represented by
The Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Revenue & Disaster Management Department, Shillong
2.
The Deputy Commissioner in-charge,
West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai
3.
Shri Erwin Sutnga,
R/o Umsohsun, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
4.
Shri Kmen Myrchiang,
S/o Shri Fidelis Pohrmen, aged about 49 years,
R/o H. No. 78, Nongtalang Village, Shnongpdeng Locality,
West Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya-793109
2025:MLHC:674
5.
Shri Denis Shadap, aged about 48 years
S/o (L) Elbina Shadap
R/o Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
6.
Shri Kelmon Khongiong, aged about 53 years
D/o (L) N. Starling Iangrai,
R/o Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
7.
Shri Chobi Shadap, aged about 59 years
S/o (L) Mrs. Arban Shadap,
R/o Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
8. Smti Estarly Suting, aged about 48 years
D/o (L) Owen Manar,
R/o Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
…. Respondent(s)
WP(C) No. 150 of 2024
1. Shri. Kmen Myrchiang
Aged About 49 years
S/o Shri. Fidalis Pohrmen
R/o. H.No. 78, Nongtalang Village,
West Jaintia Hills District
2. Ms. Morgina Sungoh
Aged About 29years
D/o Tomi Gassah
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
3. Ms. Joysanta Merry Suting
Aged About 23 years
D/o Mrs Esterly Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
4. Shri. Bok Sungoh
Aged About 58 years
S/o (L) Ragon Suchiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
5. Shri. Tngen Dhar
Aged About 52 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
6. Shri. Chobi Shadap
Aged About 56 years
S/o (L) Mrs Arban Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
7. Shri. Har Suting
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) OnliSuting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
8. Shri. Denis Shadap
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Elbina Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
9. Smt. Sophie Suting
Aged About 48 years
W/o Bob Sungoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
10. Smt. Bina Durong
Aged About 48 years
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
11. Shri.Wanbor Myrchiang
Aged About 64 years
R/o. Nongtalang Mission,
West Jaintia Hills District
12. Shri. Marjan Lakashiang
Aged About 32 years
S/o Minchiang Lamin
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
13. Smt. Quality Lakashiang
Aged About 40 years
D/o Airis Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
14. Shri. Use Pamblang
Aged About 28 years
S/o Shri Kiat Khyriem
R/o. Pasadwar, West Jaintia Hills District.
15. Smt. Iaid Khongiong
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) David Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
16. Smt. Onika Suting
Aged About 30 years
D/o Mrs KweSuting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
17. Smt. Dap Mylliem
Aged About 48 years
D/o (L) Nit Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
18. Smt. Dhar Khongiong
Aged About 45 years
D/o Mrs Pleris Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
19. Smt. Berali Khongiong
Aged About 36 years
D/o Mrs IaidKhongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
20. Smt. Moi Mylliem
Aged About 62 years
D/o Mrs Nit Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
21. Smt. Bistilda Khongiong
Aged About 50 years
D/o (L) N.Starling Iangrai
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
22. Shri. Kelmon Khongiong
Aged About 30 years
S/o Kynjli Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
23. Shri. Long Lyngdoh
Aged About 45 years
S/o Shri Bijun Lamare
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
24. Smt. Lostme Lyngdoh
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Mrs Deh Lyngdoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
25. Shri. Dhone Lyngdoh
Aged About 52 years
D/o (L) Mrs Deh Lyngdoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
26. Shri. Mimi Sungoh
Aged About 30 years
S/o Arbili Sungoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
27. Shri. Lurshai Khonglah
Aged About 62 years
S/o (L) Bishra Pohshna
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
28. Smt. Oldis Khongiong
Aged About 54 years
D/o (L) David Mylliem
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
29. Shri. Rum Manar
Aged About 49 years
S/o (L) Mrs Be Manar
R/o. Amtapoh, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
30. Shri. Bolai Sumer
Aged About 46 years
S/o Small Kassar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
31. Shri. Hedrik Dhar
Aged About 63 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
32. Smt. Rida Khongiong
Aged About 42 years
D/o Sophir Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
33. Smt. Irinda Khongiong
Aged About 40 years
D/o Morina Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
34. Shri. Saimon Shadap
Aged About 35 years
S/o Sarmen Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
35. Shri. Mone Shadap
Aged About 45 years
S/o (L) Delilal Joshi
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
36. Smt. Theisolong Suting
Aged About 35 years
D/o Sophie Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
37. Smt. Wiles Khongiong
Aged About 47 years
D/o Kmir Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
38. Shri. Dar Suting
Aged About 55 years
S/o (L) Biang Mukhim
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
39. Smt. Income Gashnga
Aged About 55 years
D/o (L) Blue Gashnga
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
40. Shri. Biju Shadap
Aged About 40 years
S/o Nayyar Sanmurgam
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
41. Smt. Rihun Khongjoh
Aged About 38 years
D/o Second Khongjoh
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
42.
Smt. Hel Suting
Aged About 60 years
D/o (L) Oli Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
43.
Shri. Amin Suting
Aged About 62 years
D/o (L) Oli Suting
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
44. Shri. Moni Khongiong
Aged About 60 years
S/o (L) Rom Pohleng
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
45. Shri. Keni Khongiong
Aged About 50 years
S/o (L) Rom Pohleng
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
46.
Smt. Sweetme Khongiong
Aged About 25 years
D/o Samuel Sangma
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
47.
Shri. Long Dhar
Aged About 75 years
S/o (L) We Lakashiang
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
48. Smt. Erila Khongiong
Aged About 23 years
D/o Rusty Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
49. Shri. Bren Najiar
Aged About 50 years
S/o (L) Bill Najiar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
50. Smt. Eral Khongiong
Aged About 37 years
D/o Long Dhar
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
51. Smt. Baribha Khongiong
Aged About 30 years
D/o Pleasetila Khongiong
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District.
52. Shri. Phumen Shadap
Aged About 75 years
S/o Langtuk Shadap
R/o. Sankhat, West Jaintia Hills District
53. Smt. Riew Bareh
Aged About 69 years
D/o (L) Long Bareh
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
2025:MLHC:674
54. Shri. Dapmon Tariang
Aged About 71 years
S/o Elphimai Tariang
R/o. Nongtalang Mission, West Jaintia Hills District
55. Shri. Long Bareh
Aged About 63 years
S/o (L) Riang Myrchiang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
56. Smt. Bon Lyngdoh Talang
Aged About 63 years
D/o (L) Chui L Talang
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
57. Shri. K. Rymbui
Aged About 61 years
S/o (L) Sadar Lyngdoh Rad
R/o. Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District
58. Smt. Mili Bareh
Aged About 55 years
C/o Jaliakhola, West Jaintia Hills District
59. Shri. Albert Lakashiang
Aged About-53 years
S/o (L) Kwin Lakashiang
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
60. Shri. Hap Dhar
Aged About 65 years
S/o Long Dhar
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
61.
Shri. Firstborn Pohti
Aged About- 27 years
S/o (L) Li Sungoh
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
2025:MLHC:674
62.
Sarteng Syrti
Aged About- 63 years
S/o Sarmen Syrti
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
63.
Star Timung
Aged About- 36 years
S/o (L) Mon Timung
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
64.
Kongnge Syrti
Aged About- 41 years
S/o Sarmen Syrti
R/o Hawai Bhoi, West Jaintia Hills District.
65.
Smt. Ron Gassar
Aged About- 67 years
D/o (L) Chuimin Kassar
R/o Nongtalang, West Jaintia Hills District.
66.
Smt. Delimai Pohti
Aged About- 70 years
D/o (L) Kwill Pohti
R/o Nongtalang Mission,
West Jaintia Hills District
...Petitioner(s)
-Versus –
1.
Government of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary
2.
Commissioner & Secretary Political Department
Government of Meghalaya Shillong.
3.
Commissioner & Secretary Disaster Management,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
2025:MLHC:674
4.
Director Survey of Meghalaya, Shillong.
5.
Collector, West Jaintia Hills District, Jowai.
6.
Dorbar Elaka Satpator, West Jaintia Hills District,
Meghalaya, represented by its Doloi,
Shri. Daman Lakashiang.
7.
Shri. Erwin K. Sutnga,
R/o Umsohsun, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District Meghalaya.
…. Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance: in WP(C) No. 496 of 2021
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr, Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
Ms. M. Hajong, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA (For R 1&2)
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv. (For R 3)
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr, Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
Ms. M. Hajong, Adv. (For R 4-8)
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC (For R 1-3)
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA (For R 4-9)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. M. Myrchiang, Adv. (For R 10)
Mr. T.T. Diengdoh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv. (For R 11)
Mr. P.R. Paske, Adv. (For R 12)
Appearance: in WP(C) No. 416 of 2023
2025:MLHC:674
Appearance: in WP(C) No. 150 of 2024
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr, Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
Ms. M. Hajong, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA (For R 1-5)
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv. (For R 6)
Mr. M. Prasad, Adv. with
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv. (For R 7)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
These three writ petitions which are concerned with and
relate to the construction of the Border Fencing-cum-Road in the IndoBangladesh border, involving two sectors one in East Khasi Hills and
one in West Jaintia Hills, questioning the process of land acquisition and
the physical demarcation, or location of the fencing along the acquired
land, are being disposed of by this common Judgment and Order.
2.
WP(C) No. 496 of 2021
In this writ petition, the writ petitioner and 147 others have
prayed for the setting aside and quashing of preliminary Notification
2025:MLHC:674
dated 14.12.2021, 22.06.2021, Declaration dated 24.08.2021 and Public
Notice dated 02.01.2017 pursuant to preliminary Notification
14.12.2016 and a letter dated 01.07.2021, issued by the JHADC. Further
prayers made in the writ petition are for directions to be heard before
finalization and demarcation of the boundary, to direct the Union
respondents and the State respondents to erect the fencing within 11
meters from the existing boundary pillars and not from 150 yards by
paying suitable compensation and for directions to the Union and State
respondents to acquire the remaining 150 yards 11 meters from the
existing boundary pillars by payment of adequate compensation.
3.
WP(C) No. 416 of 2023
The writ petitioner in this writ petition which is stated to be
the Traditional Dorbar of Satpator Elaka has prayed for the quashing and
setting aside of an impugned letter/proceedings dated 22.11.2023, issued
by the Deputy Commissioner, West Jaintia Hills, whereby though the
process of land acquisition for the concerned stretch was completed in
the name of Doloiship of Elaka Satpator and has reached the award stage
by the impugned letter, the same has been halted due to objections by the
respondent No. 3.
2025:MLHC:674
4.
WP(C) No. 150 of 2024
The petitioner No. 1, along with other writ petitioners in
WP(C) No. 496 of 2021, have filed the instant writ petition on the ground
that the notified land under the impugned Section 11 Notification dated
13.03.2023 as well as Section 19 Declaration dated 25.09.2023 belongs
to the writ petitioner and others and that the Doloi of Satpator (petitioner
in WP(C) No. 416 of 2023) is only the customary head for
administration, and that the ownership title and possession, vest either
with the individual or with the clans. They pray therefore, that the
impugned Section 11 and Section 19 Declaration, wherein the name of
the Doloi Satpator is shown as land owner, be set aside and quashed.
5.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
T. Dkhar, learned counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No. 496 of 2021
and WP(C) No. 150 of 2024 submits that what is questioned, is the
impugned Section 11 Notification dated 14.12.2016, on the ground that
no survey or measurement, for the purpose of demarcation of the
boundaries has ever been conducted, and as to how the Collector could
ascertain and measure the location of the fencing, without ascertaining
the permanent pillars settled by the respondent State and Union of India
with the affected land owners. The acquisition procedure he submits, is
2025:MLHC:674
bad in law also in view of the fact that the 2015 land boundary agreement
arrived at between the Union of India and the Government of
Bangladesh, which should have settled the boundaries as per the land
boundary agreement dated 16.05.1974, never finalized the boundaries,
when in fact the authorities were required to conduct proper survey,
which would have resulted in the correct measurement and demarcation
of boundaries. Moreover, he submits there was no public consultation for
demarcation and that the setting apart of 150 yards from the Zero line for
erection of the fencing is unsustainable, inasmuch as, the said
arrangement which was arrived at as window for negotiation between the
two countries in 1975, does not exist anymore in view of the new land
boundary agreement of 2015. The learned Senior counsel contends that
the continuance of this practice of 150 yards, in spite of the assurance of
the Border Security Force that appropriate gates will be installed every
500 meters, to enable the villagers to cultivate in their lands falling
outside the fencing but within the Zero line is absolutely unsustainable,
due to the fact that there is a record of villagers being harassed and
subjected to hardship once the gate is closed. He therefore submits that
the impugned Section 11 Notifications dated 14.12.2016 and 11.06.2021,
Public Notice dated 02.01.2017 and Declaration under Section 21 read
2025:MLHC:674
with Section 14 dated 04.10.2021, therefore being bad in law are liable
to be set aside and quashed.
6.
The learned Senior counsel has also raised an issue with
regard to the issuance of the NOC for land acquisition by the Jaintia Hills
Autonomous District Council and submits that in spite of the withdrawal
and cancellation of the earlier NOC, on the compliant of the land owners
vide letter dated 14.05.2018, the subsequent review of the decision and
the grant of NOC vide letter dated 01.07.2021 by the JHADC, has been
without addressing the grievances of the writ petitioners.
7.
In conclusion, the learned Senior counsel has submitted that
alternatively, directions can be issued to the Union and State respondents
to construct the fencing the fencing within 11 meters from the existing
boundary pillars, if the pillars have not yet been made permanent, and
not from 150 yards from the Zero line, and further to direct the
respondents to acquire the remaining 150 yards from the existing
boundary pillars, by paying adequate compensation to the writ
petitioners in accordance with law.
8.
In WP(C) No. 150 2024, the learned Senior counsel has
submitted that notwithstanding the dispute whether the writ petitioners
or the private respondent No. 6, (Dorbar Elaka Satpator) is entitled to the
2025:MLHC:674
compensation, the main issue in this writ petition is the action of issuing
fresh Notifications under Section 11 and 19 of the Act during the
subsistence of the earlier Section 11 and Section 19 Notifications. The
learned Senior counsel has submitted that during the pendency of WP(C)
No. 496 of 2021, it came to the notice of the writ petitioner No. 1, that
the private respondent No. 6, had filed a writ petition being WP(C) No.
416 of 2023, claiming compensation by relying on a new Section 11
Notification dated 13.03.2023, as well as a Section 19 Declaration dated
25.09.2023, wherein it is shown as the owner of the notified land
measuring about 360845 Square meters situated at Muktapur, Lakroh
and other adjoining areas. These areas he submits, mentioned in the said
fresh notifications were already notified in the earlier Section 11
Notification dated 07.06.2021, and as such the same were untenable
without the earlier notifications under Section 11 and Section 19 being
cancelled. This action of the respondents he submits, have been made
with a view to frustrate and circumvent the pending WP(C) No. 496 of
2021, wherein the present writ petitioners had raised issues of great
public importance with regard to the boundary settlement, apart from
assailing the process of land acquisition. He therefore prays that the
impugned preliminary notification under Section 11 dated 13.03.2023
2025:MLHC:674
and the Section 19 Declaration dated 25.09.2023, be set aside and
quashed. He lastly submits that there is adequate remedy contained in the
Act itself, that allows any interested person to take recourse to Section
64 for reference or Section 76 of the Act of 2013, in the event of disputed
claim of ownership, and such the issuance of fresh Section 11 and
Section 19 Notifications showing the Dolloi of Dorbar Elaka Satpator as
the land owners is required to be set aside and quashed, as this action is
a clear attempt on the part of the respondents, to disable the writ
petitioners from asserting their rights in accordance with law.
9.
The learned AG on behalf of the State respondents, has
submitted that the very basis on which the writ petition rests, is on the
mistaken notion that the boundary demarcation between India and
Bangladesh is yet to be concluded finally and that the acquisition
proceedings will adversely affect their rights. It is submitted by the
learned AG, that the Nehru-Noon Agreement of 1958, was executed to
establish the temporary borders but however, the Land Boundary
Agreement signed on 07.05.2015 and ratified by the Parliament on
06.06.2015, has conclusively demarcated the International Boundary and
the boundary pillars as they exist today, are the result of the Agreement
of 2015. With regard to the convention of constructing the border fencing
2025:MLHC:674
at 150 yards from the Zero line, the same he submits emanates from the
joint India-Bangladesh guidelines for Border authorities of the two
countries in 1975, that no permanent structures will be raised within 150
yards of the International Boundary. The petitioners therefore, he
submits, cannot maintain their grievance without actually challenging the
Land Boundary Agreement of 2015, even though there might be some
lands belonging to the residents of the State in the past, are situated today
within the territorial jurisdiction of Bangladesh.
10.
The learned AG submits that for the purpose of land
acquisition, the provisions of Act of 2013, have been diligently followed
in detail and the spot survey was conducted by the District
Administration, Border Security Force and the National Building
Construction Corporation Limited in the presence of land owners to
ascertain the extent of land, of each land owner. As the matter is of great
importance to ensure security of the borders, the District Administration
has proceeded with great caution by taken all steps in accordance with
law. The learned AG has taken this Court through the various steps which
have been detailed in the affidavit to show that due process has been
followed. In this context, the attention of the Court has been drawn to a
Table showing the status of land acquisition for Indo-Bangladesh Border
2025:MLHC:674
Fencing (IBBF) from Hatimara (BP. No. 1251/MP) to Pyrdiwah (BP.
No. 1272/8-S) in East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya and also the List
of name of land owners in these areas some of whom have already
received compensation and some who are still to receive the same due to
claims and counter-claims of ownership over the lands. In East Khasi
Hills therefore, he submits it is only in respect of BP No. 1271/6S to
1272/MP measuring about .060 Km that compensation could not be paid
as the land owners insisted that the construction of the Border Fencing
must be from the Zero line.
11.
With regard to West Jaintia Hills, the learned AG submits
that the District Administration had proceeded with the great caution and
that the first meeting with Headmen to explain the components relating
to the construction of Border Fencing was initiated as far back as on
16.08.2005. The learned AG has also referred to the list of dates which
is contained in the affidavit filed by the Collector/Deputy Commissioner,
West Jaintia Hills, which reflects that public hearings had been held as
also grievances which were raised attended to and that notice for Joint
Inspection or fresh survey had been intimated to the Coordination
Committee on International Boundary (CCIB), an organization claiming
to represent land owners as also to the Headmen and Dollois, as far back
2025:MLHC:674
as on 09.04.2015. The same could not fructify into any conclusion, he
submits, inasmuch as, the CCIB had instigated the land owners to object
to the inspection and this situation continued till September, 2021. The
writ petitioner No. 1, (Shri K. Myrchiang), it is submitted is the Secretary
of the said CCIB and during a survey at Amdoh Village on 22.09.2021,
instigated the land owners to oppose the survey and to prevent the survey
party from conducting the survey, so much so, that the matter was
reported to the Superintendent of Police for necessary action. Thereafter,
he submits notices were given for re-measurement and demarcation and
all land owners cooperated readily. The learned AG has raised a serious
concern, that self-styled Committees such as the CCIB of which the
petitioner No. 1, is the Secretary have actively been trying to ensure that
the Border Fencing does not come up, by instigating people to oppose
the same. The action of such private persons, he submits is solely
responsible in the delay of construction leaving the general population in
border villages at risk from miscreants, smugglers and other elements
from within and across the border.
12.
The total length of land acquisition for the Border Fencing,
he submits from Dawki BP No. 1273/M to Jaliakhola BP No. 1301/4S,
in West Jaintia Hills District is 37.25 Km. In this regard, the learned AG
2025:MLHC:674
has referred to Para-14 & 15 of the affidavit, which shows the status of
land acquisition from Dawki BP No. 1273/M to Jaliakhola BP No.
1301/4S. Further, a list of names of land owners in the said Sector, which
have been enumerated in a Table has also been referred to. In conclusion,
it is submitted, that there is no question of any boundary dispute between
India and Bangladesh as the Land Boundary Agreement of 2015, has
demarcated the boundary permanently and that Boundary Pillars as they
exist today are the result of the said Land Boundary Agreement. He also
submits that the grievance of the petitioners pertaining to the present
boundary arrangement is not open for challenge without the Land
Boundary Agreement of 2015 being assailed. The only important issue
that remains which is hindering the construction of the Boundary
Fencing which is essential for the security and safety the borders is with
the claims and counter-claims of the land owners, for which the same can
be addressed at a different alternate forum.
13.
On the contention raised in WP(C) No. 150 of 2024 by the
writ petitioner, the learned AG submits that the fresh notification dated
13.03.2023, over the land from Muktapur to Pasadwar, was issued in
view of the fact that the respondent No. 6 (Dolloi Satpator) had claimed
the said lands by submitting agreements pertaining to cultivation rights,
2025:MLHC:674
whereas the petitioners had merely made bald averments without
enclosing any land documents. He further submits that only 5(five) of
the 66(Sixty-six) petitioners’ names also find mention in the preliminary
notification dated 11.06.2021. The learned AG submits that in these
matters, disputed facts have been raised by the writ petitioners which
cannot be addressed in a writ proceeding, and as such he prays that
notwithstanding the pendency of resolution of other disputes, for the sake
of national security the fencing works be allowed to be completed
expeditiously.
14.
On behalf of the other respondents, Mr. R. Debnath, learned
CGC for the respondents Nos. 1 & 2 has supported the submissions made
by the learned AG and further submitted that at present there is no
boundary dispute between India and Bangladesh in the State of
Meghalaya and that the International Border is well demarcated. He
further submits that all the Border Pillars have been erected and that the
total area required for construction of the Indo-Bangladesh Border Fence
(IBBF) is 70250 Sq. meters. He also submitted that no loss of land has
occurred beyond the Boundary Pillars, as the boundary is well
demarcated and that the land upto 150 yards beyond the fencing can be
utilized without any hindrance.
2025:MLHC:674
15.
On behalf of the respondent No. 10, Dr. N. Mozika, learned
DSGI assisted by Ms. M. Myrchiang, learned counsel has submitted that
the decision to withdraw the earlier order for cancellation of the NOC
was made pursuant to a letter dated 24.06.2021 from the Deputy
Commissioner, West Jaintia Hills for the consideration of the matter,
keeping in view the fact that the fencing is for safety and security of the
citizens and to prevent infiltration. As such, he submits on receipt of such
request and considering the importance of the matter, after several
meetings, discussions and deliberations of the issue, it was decided to
withdraw the cancellation of the NOC.
16.
On behalf of the respondent No. 12 (NBCC), Mr. P.R. Paske,
learned counsel has submitted that the NBCC is only the executing
agency entrusted with the job of construction of the fencing and has no
role to play in the process of acquiring land under the Act, 2013. He
further submits that the NBCC has acted as per instructions and that as
there were issues as to payment of land compensation, on the directive
of the State Government the NBCC has not commenced with the
construction works of the IBBF in the Khasi and Jaintia Hills sector.
17.
On behalf of the respondent No. 11, it is only given in the
affidavit that Section 41 of the Right to Fair Compensation and
2025:MLHC:674
Transparent in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
mandates that prior consent should be taken for acquisition.
18.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, learned counsel for the petitioner in
WP(C) No. 416 of 2024 and respondent No. 6, in WP(C) No. 150 of
2024, i.e. the Dolloi of Satpator, has submitted that the land proposed to
be acquired is Raid land, which exclusively belongs to the Dorbar Elaka
of Satpator, who is the sole custodian of the said land, and being Raid
land, the Dorbar Elaka had permitted persons to use and occupy a portion
of the acquired land for the sole purpose of cultivation. In this context,
he submits that it is to be noted that the petitioners in WP(C) No. 496 of
2021 and WP(C) No. 150 of 2024, have not enclosed any Land Holding
certificate, nor any recommendation issued the Dorbar Elaka Satpator
certifying the said petitioners as land owners. The Dorbor Elaka Satpator
he submits, vide Agreements allots and leases land to inhabitants of the
Elaka for the purpose of cultivation, and that one of the terms and
conditions of an Agreement, is that a Lessee shall not claim ownership
of the lease land except for the plantations. The learned counsel has
referred to the copies of Agreements, which are annexed to the affidavit
to substantiate his submissions. It is further submitted that the Dolloi of
Satpator, is not claiming any land compensation on the basis of being an
2025:MLHC:674
owner, but however being the custodian of the Raid land, the office of
the Dolloi and his Dorbar are entitled to land compensation, as the same
will be utilized for running the affairs and administration of the entire
Elaka. The learned counsel reiterates his submissions that the petitioners
are not land owners of the acquired land, but are mere cultivators and
their participation in the survey conducted, cannot be construed as to
make them land owners, inasmuch as, the survey had been done only to
assess the acquired land and the damage caused to the plantations. The
Notification he submits, which has been assailed by the petitioners has
been issued as per law after due verification, as the Dorbar of Elaka
Satpator, has always been recognized by the competent authority as the
custodian of all lands falling under the administrative control of
Muktapur, Lakroh, Hawaitilla, S.P. Tilla, Sankhat, Jaliakhola and
Pasadwar Villages.
With regard to the issue in WP(C) 416 of 2023, specifically
on the claim of the Respondent No.3, it has been submitted that the same
has been lodged without any basis or documentary evidence vide an
objection dated 27.09.2022, for the first time after the lapse of 20 years.
The Respondent No.2 (Deputy Commissioner) it has been contended, has
placed heavy reliance on the said objection dated 27.09.2022, while
2025:MLHC:674
issuing the impugned letter dated 22.11.2023, despite the fact the
Preliminary notification had already been issued on 11.03.2023 and
Declaration issued on 25.09.2023, and the acquisition proceedings being
at the final stage. In considering this objection, it is submitted, that the
Respondent No. 2, neither prepared any report as mandated by Section
15 of the RFCTLAR Act, 2013, but arbitrarily issued the impugned letter
dated 22.11.2023. in violation of the Act and as such, the same is liable
to be set aside and quashed.
19.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties in this batch of
writ petitions, the fundamental issue or question it is seen, is over the
manner, extent and method of acquisition of the lands required for the
IBBF (Fencing) and the claims and counter-claims over ownership that
have emerged therefrom, interspersed with grievances as to the proposed
location of the said fencing from the International Border.
20.
The IBBF as can be seen from the records and notifications,
covers areas in West Jaintia Hills and East Khasi Hills and as per the first
preliminary notification dated 11.06.2021, was to run from Boundary
Pillar No. 1293 to Boundary Pillar No. 1297 in Sankhat Village covering
an area of 70250 Sq. meters and as per the second preliminary
notification dated 13.03.2023 to run from Boundary Pillar No. 1273 to
2025:MLHC:674
1302 covering an area of 360845 Sq. meters. The total length in West
Jaintia Hills from BP No. 1273 to 1301 is 37.25 Km. (37250 meters) and
the total length land acquisition in the East Khasi Hills is from BP No.
1251 to BP No. 1272 is 33.30 Km (33300 meters). The status report as
given in the affidavit for the West Jaintia Hills section shows that in some
parts i.e. BP1273 to BP1275, the award has been approved by the
Government and notice under Section 37(2) for the Fair Compensation
and Transparent in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act, 2013, issued with 3 land owners accepting land compensation while
2 have refused. For other sectors namely between BP No. 1281 to BP
No. 1282, land has been handed over to BSF and NBCC, for BP. No.
1293 to BP No. 1297, the draft award is being prepared and for 2 stages
from BP. No. 1275/9s to BP No. 1277/12s, the land owners are yet to
collect the land compensation. For the substantial length of 15.124 Km
in Muktapur, Lakroh, Hawaitilla, S.P. Tila, Jaliakhola, Pasadwar and
Naljuri, encompassing BP No. 1283 to BP No. 1285, BP No. 1287 to BP
No. 1293, BP. No. 1297 to BP No. 1301, BP No. 1286 to BP No. 1287,
BP No. 1285 to BP No. 1286, BP No. 1301 MP to BP No. 1301/45, the
said lands have been notified under Section 11 (1) read with Section 40
of the Act of 2013, by the subsequent notification dated 13.03.2023. In
2025:MLHC:674
this sector, the Dolloi of Satpator who has been shown as the land owner,
has emerged as a bone of contention with the claimants who are
petitioners in WP(C) No. 150 of 2024 and the Dolloi of Satpator, the
petitioner in WP(C) No. 416 of 2023.
21.
In the East Khasi Hills sector, however advance handing
over taking over position of land had been effected, and it is noted that
the names of the land owners have also been indicated in the affidavit of
the State respondents. As such, it appears that the acquisition
proceedings is pending in various stages and has not been concluded,
due to the persistent claims and counter-claims, coupled with other
grievances such as, the extent of land to be acquired as demanded by the
petitioners in WP(C) No. 496 of 2021, and also the proposed location of
the fencing, which is opposed by some petitioners, who are insistent that
the same be erected at a closer distance from the International Border or
Zero Line, and not 150 yards as is the practice and convention. However,
it is also noted that some petitioners have accepted the awarded
compensation and have removed themselves from these cases.
22.
Due to this imbroglio, the urgent requirement of fencing the
International Border, has suffered considerable delay and the same being
a matter of National security to check influx, smuggling and other illegal
2025:MLHC:674
cross border activities, should necessarily be prioritized over the disputes
that are present. From the discussion made hereinabove, there is no room
for doubt that the issues involved, require a thorough and balanced
examination, as most of the questions are based on disputed facts, which
can only be resolved on the ground. In this context, to resolve these kinds
of issues, Section 64 of The Act of 2013, has provided as follows:
“64. Reference to Authority. – (1) Any person interested
who has not accepted the award may, by written
application to the Collector, require that the matter be
referred by the Collector for the determination of the
Authority, as the case may be, whether his objection be to
the measurement of the land, the amount of the
compensation, the person to whom it is payable, the rights
of Rehabilitation and Resettlement under Chapters V and
VI or the apportionment of the compensation among the
persons interested:
Provided that the Collector shall, within a period of
thirty days from the date of receipt of application, make a
reference to the appropriate Authority:
Provided further that where the Collector fails to
make such reference within the period so specified, the
applicant may apply to the Authority, as the case may be,
requesting it to direct the Collector to make the reference
to it within a period of thirty days.
(2) The application shall state the grounds on
which objection to the award is taken:
Provided that every such application shall be made
(a) if the person making it was present or
represented before the Collector at the time when he made
his award, within six weeks from the date of the
Collector’s award;
2025:MLHC:674
(b) in other cases, within six weeks of the receipt of
the notice from the Collector under section 21, or within
six months from the date of the Collector’s award,
whichever period shall first expire:
Provided further that the Collector may entertain an
application after the expiry of the said period, within a
further period of one year, if he is satisfied that there was
sufficient cause for not filing it within the period specified
in the first proviso.”
23.
The Act therefore, under Section 64, with regard to claims
and counter-claims, objections as to the measurement of the land, the
amount of compensation, the persons to whom it is payable, right of
rehabilitation, or the apportionment of compensation, has provided a
dispute resolution mechanism which can be resorted to . For this reason,
this Court though objections have been raised in WP(C) No. 496 of 2021
and WP(C) No. 150 of 2024, as to the locus of the petitioners and claims
of ownership being made without supporting material being filed, will
not venture to render any finding, leaving it to be decided as per the
provisions of the Act of 2013.
24.
However, in WP(C) No. 416 of 2023, the respondent No. 3
therein, it appears had on 27.09.2022, made an objection before the
respondent Collector, West Jaintia Hills claiming himself to be the
landlord of 8(eight) Villages and forest land in an area known as
Khloothangrangaw, when the matter had been fixed 30.09.2022, for
2025:MLHC:674
finalization of the land acquisition. The Collector it appears by an order
dated 22.11.2023, which has been impugned in this writ petition,
however, directed the parties to reach an agreement which the petitioner
has contended is against the scheme of the Act of 2013 and in violation
of Section 15 thereof. Section 15, it is noted, prescribes the procedure
with regard to the ‘Hearing of Objections’ and it reads as follows:“15. Hearing of objections. – (1) Any person interested in
any land which has been notified under sub-section (1) of
section 11, as being required or likely to be required for a
public purpose, may within sixty days from the date of the
publication of the preliminary notification, object to—
(a) the area and suitability of land proposed to be
acquired;
(b) justification offered for public purpose;
(c) the findings of the Social Impact Assessment
report.
(2) Every objection under sub-section (1) shall be
made to the Collector in writing, and the Collector shall
give the objector an opportunity of being heard in person
or by any person authorised by him in this behalf or by an
Advocate and shall, after hearing all such objections and
after making such further inquiry, if any, as he thinks
necessary, either make a report in respect of the land
which has been notified under sub-section (1) of section
11, or make different reports in respect of different parcels
of such land, to the appropriate Government, containing
his recommendations on the objections, together with the
record of the proceedings held by him along with a
separate report giving therein the approximate cost of land
acquisition, particulars as to the number of affected
2025:MLHC:674
families likely to be resettled, for the decision of that
Government.
(3) The decision of the appropriate Government on
the objections made under sub-section (2) shall be final.”
The objection of the respondent No. 3 dated 27.09.2022 it is
seen, was filed before the Section 11 notification was issued, but the
same was entertained and instead of adopting the procedure as laid down
by law, the Collector had instead recorded that both parties requested a
period of one month to reach an agreement. This to the mind of the Court
is unsustainable and accordingly, the impugned proceeding, as far as it
relates to the direction for an agreement to be arrived at, appearing at
paragraph 5 thereof, is set aside and quashed. The Collector is therefore
required to examine the maintainability of the objection and locus of the
objector as made, and pass necessary orders thereon in terms and as per
Section 15 of the Act of 2013.
25.
On the question that has been raised i.e. the issuance of the
second notification under Section 11 dated 13.03.2023, as has been
illustrated in the foregoing paragraphs, the first preliminary notification
dated 11.06.2021, is for an area measuring 70250 Sq. meters whereas in
the second notification the same is for an area of 360845 Sq. meters.
Though, there might be an overlap with respect to BP No. 1293 to BP
2025:MLHC:674
No. 1297/6s given in the first notification with BP No. 1273 to BP No.
1302, of the second notification, the section where there might be a
dispute is not extensive when compared to the total length of the land
which is sought to be acquired for the purposes of the fencing. The
second notification therefore, cannot be held to be illegal or
unsustainable in law, as it encompasses the areas which were not notified
in the first notification dated 11.06.2021, and the dispute at the most is
confined to areas around Sankhat Village.
25.
In view of the circumstances of the case, in public interest
and in the interest of national security, it is deemed necessary that
directions and orders be issued that notwithstanding any disputes on the
other issues that are involved, the construction of the International
Border Fencing is required to be re-started in the locations and areas
which have been identified, through survey or otherwise. It is ordered
accordingly.
26.
On the other aspect, the respondents Nos. 8 & 9 are also
directed to proceed in accordance with law and as per the Act of 2013,
to release compensation to persons named in the notification, over whom
there is no dispute or counter-claim, if the awarded amount has been
2025:MLHC:674
already determined, and for other issues to take necessary action for
reference of the dispute under the Act, or otherwise as per law.
27.
With the above discussions and directions, these writ petitions
are accordingly closed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
04.08.2025
“V. Lyndem PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2025.08.04 17:10:38 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review