Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 02.02.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. SURESH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SHAMIM AHMED
W.P.Nos.48845, 48849, 48870, 48874, 48880,
48893, 48906, 48907 and 48911 of 2025
KMC College of Law,
Represented by Correspondent,
Aruna Sreedevi G.
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48845/2025
Anandam Law College,
Represented by its Chairman,
Mr.Sathasivam.P.
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48849/2025
GTN Law College,
Represented by its Chairman,
Ln.Dr.K.Retinam
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48870/2025
Erode College of Law,
Represented by its Chairman,
Mr.Sindhu Ravichandran
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48874/2025
Mother Teresa Law College,
Represented by its Chairman,
R.C.Uthayakumar
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48880/2025
Thulasi College of Law for Women,
Represented by its Chairman,
Dr.A.Kanagaraj
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48893/2025
S Thangapazham Law College,
Represented by its Chairman,
Mr.T.Murugesan
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48906/2025
Mugil College of Law,
Represented by its Chairman,
Arulananthan.C.
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48907/2025
SKP Law College,
Represented by its Chairman,
K.Karunanithi
.. Petitioner in W.P.No.48911/2025
Page No.1 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
Vs.
1. The State of Tamil Nadu
Represented by its Secretary
Law Department, Secretariat, Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Bar Council of India
Represented by its Secretary
21, Rouse Avenue, Industrial Area
New Delhi.
3. The Tamil Nadu Dr. Ambedkar Law University
Represented by its Registrar
Dr.D.G.S.Dinakaran Salai
R.A.Puram, Chennai – 28.
.. Respondents in all W.Ps.
For the Petitioners
in all W.Ps except
W.P.No.48874 of 2025
: Mr.M.Ravi
For the Petitioner in
W.P.No.48874 of 2025
: Ms.Dakshayani Reddy
Senior Counsel
for Mr.M.Ravi
For the Respondents
in all W.Ps.
: Mr.A.Selvendran,
Special Government Pleader
for R1
: Mr.S.R.Raghunathan
Standing Counsel
for R2
: Mr.S.Siva Shanmugam,
Standing Counsel
for R3
Prayer in W.P.No.48845 of 2025: Petition filed under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, seeking a writ of mandamus, directing the
second respondent to pass appropriate orders of regular approval
for additional sections for the 3-year LL.B. and 5 year B.A., LL.B. in
the petitioner Institute for the Academic Year 2025-26 and to direct
the third respondent to forthwith allot students under Government
quota for the aforementioned additional sections.
Page No.2 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
COMMON ORDER
(Order of the Court was made by R. SURESH KUMAR, J.)
In all these writ petitions, the respective writ petitioners are
Centers for Legal Education1, commonly known as Law Colleges.
2.1. As per the procedure in vogue, in order to establish a CLE
by a private Management, first, they must have applied to the State
Government and to the concerned Affiliating University to get No
Objection Certificate from the State Government and the affiliation
and consent of affiliation from the Affiliating University. After getting
these certifications, they have to make further application, as a final
process, to the Bar Council of India2.
2.2. The BCI will independently process the application, to be
submitted by the Educational Agency for starting the CLE and, on
the basis of the input send by the University through affiliation or
consent for affiliation, as well as the No Objection Certificate by the
State Government and after having conducted an inspection by the
team of experts to be sent by the BCI, the approval process would
be completed and wherever there are deserved cases, such
approval would be granted by the BCI. In order to complete this
process, separate fee would be collected by the BCI.
In short, hereinafter referred as “CLE”.
In short, hereinafter referred as “BCI”.
Page No.3 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
2.3. Almost the same procedure is adopted in respect of the
existing CLEs, seeking such approval for additional Centres or
additional Sections or additional intake in both the three year Law
Degree Course or LL.B. Course or five year integrated Law Degree
Course.
3.1. Here, as far as the present cases are concerned, all the
present petitioners are existing Law Colleges, that is CLEs. They
want to get approval for additional intake in the existing Institutions
from the Academic Year 2025-26, for which, they have already
applied to the Affiliating University, that is the Tamil Nadu
Dr. Ambedkar Law University, Chennai, as well as the State
Government and from the University as
well as
the
State
Government, they received the consent of affiliation or affiliation as
well as the No Objection Certificate for starting of the additional
intake or additional classes in the existing Institutions.
3.2.
After
getting
these
affiliations
and
No
Objection
Certificates from the respective Authorities, they applied to the BCI
by making payment of Rs.6,50,000/- as processing fee to the BCI.
The said applications, insofar as these CLEs are concerned, had
been kept pending without processing the same.
Page No.4 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
3.3. At one point of time, except two Institutions, in respect of
the remaining Institutions/writ petitioners, the fee paid by the
Institutions to the BCI have been returned. In respect of the said
two Institutions alone, the fee had not been returned. Therefore,
the fee-returning order has been questioned in seven writ petitions
and in respect of the two writ petitions, as the fee had not been
returned, they seek a writ of mandamus to process those
applications.
3.4. That is how these batch of writ petitions came to be filed
before this Court, seeking relief as sought in the respective writ
petitions.
4. It is the argument advanced by Mr.M.Ravi, learned counsel
appearing for the writ petitioners that, apart from these nine
Institutions, already two Institutions, by name, Sir Issac Newton
Law
College,
Nagapattinam
and
Saraswathi
Law
College,
Tindivanam, both at Tamil Nadu, have also applied for additional
intake, as these two Institutions also are existing CLEs. Insofar as
these applications are concerned, these applications have been
processed and necessary approval has been conveyed by the BCI
through their order dated 14.10.2025, whereas, seven out of the
Page No.5 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
nine Institutions'/writ petitioners' applications have been returned
with the fee paid by them and in respect of two applications, no
progress had been made in processing these applications and they
have been kept pending.
5.1.
Mr.S.R.Raghunathan,
learned
Standing
Counsel
appearing for the BCI, on instructions, would submit that, these
applications have been processed or returned only on the basis of
the resolution passed in this regard by the BCI, whereby, a press
release had been issued on 13.08.2025. In the said press release,
the BCI had stated that, the BCI has taken some decision that, as
per the policy decision having been declared, whereby, it affirms
that the moratorium is aimed at elevating and protecting standards
of legal education, preserving the dignity of the legal profession and
reinforcing public trust in the justice system, while ensuring
inclusivity in keeping with Constitutional mandates.
5.2. Insofar as the said policy decision is concerned, the BCI
wants to place the moratorium of three years period, by which, no
new CLEs shall be established or granted approval anywhere in
India. Universities, State Governments, Central Government Entities
and other Institutions shall not submit or forward proposals or
applications to the BCI for the establishment of new CLEs.
Page No.6 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
5.3. This notification dated 13.08.2025, though had been
issued, under Rule 9 of the Rules of Legal Education – Moratorium
(Three-Year Moratorium) with respect to Centers of Legal Education,
2025, certain exemptions have been given.
5.4. As per Rule 9, the CLEs which have made proposals for
new Sections or Courses exclusively meant for students belonging
to socially and educationally Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and Economically Weaker Sections, as recognized
under Articles 15(4) and 15(5) of the Constitution, provided they
have
an
explicit
and
demonstrated
purpose
to
serve
these
categories, possess adequate infrastructure and qualified faculty,
these Institutions' applications would be processed and on the basis
of merit of each of the individual applications of that category, these
applications would be processed and wherever there are desired
cases, approval would be granted.
5.5. Therefore, even though the Moratorium Notification dated
13.08.2025 had been issued, there was certain exemptions, under
which, individual applications on the basis of exclusivity, where it is
meant for Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes or
Marginalized people, if it is established or if it is already established
Page No.7 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
and seeking additional intake, these applications shall be processed
and a decision shall be taken by the BCI.
5.6. Citing the said notification dated 13.08.2025, the learned
Standing Counsel appearing for the BCI would submit that, only
within the said parameters, under the exemption or exclusive
category, these applications though could be processed, as these
applications have not been subsequently made only for the
development and upliftment of the marginalized category, that is
Other Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes
category, etc., these applications have not been processed and have
been returned at the threshold, including fee, he contended.
6. After hearing the respective learned counsel on earlier
occasions, we passed an interim order on 05.01.2026 to the
following effect:“Mr.S,R.Raghunathan, learned Standing Counsel
appearing for the Bar Council of India wants
further two weeks time to file counter affidavit
touching upon the policy decision taken by the
Bar Council of India for bringing the Rules or
amendments, by which three years moratorium
since has been provided for, within which no new
Centres of Legal Education [in short, ‘CLEs’]
would be permitted to be established like that no
existing CLE would be permitted to establish a
new course, additional course or additional intake.
Page No.8 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
2. In this context, the three years total ban is
provided in Regulation 3, whereas regulation 4
speaks about that, in exceptional cases, the
application can be strictly processed on need
basis. That apart, certain exceptions have been
provided under Regulation 9, which includes
regulation 9(b), under which, if application is filed
to establish a law college or a new course
exclusively for Backward classes, Scheduled
caste, Scheduled tribes and persons with disability
with an undertaking that 100% seats would be
reserved for these category of people, that kind of
applications can be considered and processed. In
order to strike out the balance between
Regulation 3, Regulation 4 and Regulation 9, how
an application made in this regard during
moratorium period especially for wanting of
additional course, additional intake or a new
course in the existing CLE can be considered and
decided has to be spelled out in the said counter
affidavit to be filed in this regard by the Bar
Council of India.
3. To make such compliance, learned Standing
Counsel since seeks two weeks time, post this
case on 20.01.2026.”
Thereafter, these cases were taken up for further hearing on
27.01.2025, where also, we passed orders to the following effect:“After hearing the learned counsel for both sides
on 05.01.2026, we have passed the following
order.
“Mr.S,R.Raghunathan,
learned
Standing
Counsel appearing for the Bar Council of
India wants further two weeks time to file
counter affidavit touching upon the policy
decision taken by the Bar Council of India
for bringing the Rules or amendments, by
which three years moratorium since has
been provided for, within which no new
Centres of Legal Education [in short, ‘CLEs’]
Page No.9 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
would be permitted to be established like
that no existing CLE would be permitted to
establish a new course, additional course or
additional intake.
2. In this context, the three years total ban
is provided in Regulation 3, whereas
regulation 4 speaks about that, in
exceptional cases, the application can be
strictly processed on need basis. That apart,
certain exceptions have been provided
under
Regulation
9,
which
includes
regulation 9(b), under which, if application
is filed to establish a law college or a new
course exclusively for Backward classes,
Scheduled caste, Scheduled tribes and
persons with disability with an undertaking
that 100% seats would be reserved for
these category of people, that kind of
applications
can
be
considered
and
processed. In order to strike out the balance
between Regulation 3, Regulation 4 and
Regulation 9, how an application made in
this regard during moratorium period
especially for wanting of additional course,
additional intake or a new course in the
existing CLE can be considered and decided
has to be spelled out in the said counter
affidavit to be filed in this regard by the Bar
Council of India.
3. To make such compliance, learned
Standing Counsel since seeks two weeks
time, post this case on 20.01.2026.”
2. Though time was given upto 20.01.2026, today
when the case is listed after a week’s time beyond
the time limit given by our earlier order dated
05.01.2026, the Standing Counsel for the
respondent Bar Council of India would submit
that, he has got some oral instructions that the
Bar Council of India is going to have a meeting
today to take some decision and pass a resolution
to decide each of the application pending before
Page No.10 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
them and also each of the application which were
rejected out-rightly by citing the three year
moratorium notification. He submits that each of
the application would be considered and decided
on merits based on Rule 9 ie., exception clause
and also on the basis of the infrastructural and
instructional facilities possessed by each of the
institution as has been certified by the University
concerned after conducting necessary inspection.
3. This position in fact should have been filed
before this Court by way of an affidavit or
compliance affidavit as directed by our order
dated 05.01.2026. However, the learned Standing
Counsel for the Bar Council of India would submit
that, such a compliance certainly would be made,
for which a very short accommodation of less than
a week is required to consolidate all these
developments and put forth before this Court by
filing a compliance affidavit on behalf of the Bar
Council of India.
4. Recording the said submission by the learned
Standing Counsel for the Bar Council of India,
post the matter on 02.02.2026 for filing
compliance affidavit. It is made clear that on the
next date of hearing if no such compliance
affidavit is filed in writing by the Bar Council of
India, adverse inference would be drawn and the
matter would be decided and final orders would be
passed based on the available records.”
7. Only pursuant to these orders, today, when the cases are
taken up for further hearing, on behalf of the second respondent,
that is the BCI, a common counter affidavit has been filed, wherein,
it has been mainly underscored that, the BCI subsequently had a
meeting on 11.01.2026, where, a resolution has been passed, by
Page No.11 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
which, the notification dated 13.08.2025 had been decided to be
done-away and replacing the same, a new policy decision has been
taken and the main substance of the policy decision, according to
the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the BCI, is that,
wherever such kind of applications are filed and are pending before
the BCI, those applications, whether could be processed or not, by
conducting an inspection, could be decided by an Inspection
Permission Team consisting of a Former Judge of the High Court and
a Law Professor in each State and thereafter, after conducting
inspection, on the basis of infrastructure and institutional facilities
available and also on need-basis, the process of such kind of
applications would be conferred and a final decision would be
communicated to the Institutions concerned.
8. We have gone through the said policy decision taken as
reflected in Resolution dated 11.01.2026 passed by the BCI.
9. Though there is no definite or a clear unambiguous decision
has been taken by the BCI, the only factum that could be culled out
from the said policy decision is that, the earlier decision of three
year moratorium taken through notification dated 13.08.2025 has
now been replaced, therefore, the three year moratorium period is
Page No.12 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
gone. The next step according to the policy decision is that, now,
they propose to constitute an Inspection Permission Committee for
each of the State, headed by a Former Judge of the High Court.
That Committee will give permission to inspect each of the
Institutions and thereupon, the Institution concerned would be
inspected and after completing inspection on need-basis as well as
merit-basis, that is fulfillment of infrastructural and institutional
facilities, those individual applications would be finalized and orders
would be passed. Therefore, it is now the process to be taken up by
the BCI, that they have to inspect the Institutions which have made
such applications seeking approval for the new College or additional
intake.
10. Insofar as the new Colleges to be established is
concerned, in this lis, we are not concerned with the said issue, as
none
of
the
writ
petitioners
are
seeking
any
approval
for
establishing new Institutions, that is CLEs.
11. As we have said earlier, since all these writ petitioners are
existing CLEs and they made applications only seeking approval for
starting additional intake in the existing Courses alone, the
moratorium or need-basis decision would not apply to these cases.
Page No.13 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
When that being the position, there could be no impediment for the
BCI to process these applications and to take a decision on meritbasis.
12. It is pertinent to point out here that, merit-basis means, if
an application is submitted by any existing CLE seeking approval for
such additional intake, for having such additional intake, whether
necessary infrastructural and institutional facilities have been
established and on verification of the same by conducting an
inspection, the BCI could come to a conclusion if such Institution
could be granted such approval for additional intake. Such a
decision could be taken by the BCI only on individual application on
the merits of each of such applications, therefore, there could not
be any uniform decision to be taken in this regard.
13.
Insofar as the need-basis theory is concerned, the fact
remains that, while taking the policy decision, as reflected in the
Resolution dated 11.01.2026 of the BCI, whether it is taken on the
basis of any available data or not is not reflected.
Page No.14 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
14. In this context, the learned Standing Counsel appearing
for the BCI, on oral instructions, would submit that, there are
records to show or data to establish that no new CLEs are required
in some of the areas. Insofar as this data is concerned, the same is
not available as part of the policy decision reflected in the
Resolution dated 11.01.2026. Horeover, if such a decision is taken
by the BCI to put a ban on CLEs to be established hereinafter on
the basis of such data, where, on need-basis, there is no further
need to establish any new Institution, additional intake or additional
course, such a drastic decision could be taken by the BCI supported
by data and in the absence of any such data being filed before this
Court for judicial scrutiny, we do not wish to comment on the
decision taken by the BCI on the arena of need-basis.
15. When that being the position, now, since the applications
have been filed, which are pending for all these months, except a
formal return of the applications and fees for conducting inspection
because
of
the
earlier
moratorium
notification
issue
dated
13.08.2025, those applications could very well be revived now and
in this process, each of the writ petitioners, whose applications have
been returned in limine without processing the same, can resubmit
their applications at the earliest and on such resubmission, those
Page No.15 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
applications can be processed on its own merits, for which, if
inspection is needed, such inspection also can be conducted within
a time frame.
16. In this context, though we feel that two weeks' time could
be granted to the BCI for completing the process and passing of
final orders, the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the BCI
sought four weeks' time, however, since already these writ
petitioners/Institutions are running out of time and the Academic
Year 2025-26 has already commenced, making further delay in
processing these applications and completing the same would no
way be helpful either to the Institutions or to the Students to be
admitted in these Institutions, provided if they are able to establish
before the BCI that they have additional infrastructural and
institutional facilities to take additional intake and the purpose itself
would be defeated and the infrastructural facilities created in these
Institutions would be a waste not only to the Institutions, but also
be a National waste.
17. Considering the totality of the situation and taking into
account of the two decisions taken by the BCI, one on 13.08.2025
as well as the Resolution taken on 11.01.2026, as the latter
Page No.16 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
decision has replaced the earlier one dated 13.08.2025, and as per
the present Resolution dated 11.01.2026, there could be no
complete ban in processing the applications filed by the existing
CLEs, we are inclined to pass the following orders in these writ
petitions:(i) That there shall be a direction to the second
respondent
BCI
to
process
the
applications
submitted by all these writ petitioners within a
period of three weeks either from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order or from the date of
receipt of resubmission of the applications to be
made by seven out of the nine writ petitioners, as
whose applications have already been returned in
limine, which ever is later.
(ii) Enabling the BCI to start processing, the seven
out of the nine writ petitioners, whose applications
have been returned already by the BCI, shall
resubmit the applications within a period of three
days from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(iii) It is made clear that, during the process of
considering these applications, it is open to the
BCI
to
conduct
inspections
and
once
such
inspection is completed, without further delay,
keep the matter in the next meeting of the BCI for
Page No.17 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
consideration for grant of approval to these
Institutions
only
fulfillment
of
on
merit-basis,
infrastructural
and
that
is
on
institutional
facilities and not on the basis of the alleged needbasis, as the policy reflected in 11.01.2026
Resolution of the BCI does not reflect with any
empirical data.
(iv) Unmindful of such policy decision, such
applications could be processed and final orders
could be passed on or before the completion of
the three weeks' period as indicated above.
18. With these directions, all these writ petitions are disposed
of. However, there shall be no order as to costs. Consequently,
W.M.P.Nos.54543, 54545, 54548, 54549, 54578, 54579, 54584,
54587, 54592, 54593, 54607, 54608, 54621, 54622, 54623,
54624, 54628 and 54629 of 2025 are closed.
(R.S.K., J.)
(S.S.A., J.)
02.02.2026
Speaking Order
Internet:Yes
Index:Yes
Note: Issue Order Copy on 04.02.2026.
(drm)
Page No.18 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
To:
1. The Secretary,
Law Department, Secretariat, Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Bar Council of India,
Represented by its Secretary, 21, Rouse Avenue,
Industrial Area,
New Delhi.
3. The Registrar,
Tamil Nadu Dr.Ambedkar Law University,
R.A.Puram, Chennai – 28.
Page No.19 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.48845 of 2025 & batch
R. SURESH KUMAR, J.
AND
SHAMIM AHMED, J.
(drm)
W.P.Nos.48845, 48849, 48870, 48874, 48880,
48893, 48906, 48907 and 48911 of 2025
02.02.2026
Page No.20 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review