Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/26
GAHC040014722024
2026:GAU-AP:140-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/28/2024
Marto Kamgo
Son of Late Kimar Kamgo, Permanent Resident of Kamki Village, PO/PS Kamba,
West Siang District Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 23 Ors
Represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, PIN
791111
2:The Commissioiner/ Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
Departmental Promotion Committee dated 10.06.2022
4:The Chief Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
5:Nima Tsering
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 2/26
Son of Late Towla Monpa
presently posted Assistant Engineer(E) Miao Electrical Division
Miao
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
6:Hage Nengka
Age: 34
Occupation :
Son of Hage Obin
presently posted Assistant Electrical Inspector
Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
7:Purik Buchi
Age: 34
Occupation :
Son of Jumpu Buchi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) SLDC Sub Division
Itanagar
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
8:Moli Kamki
Age: 36
Occupation :
Son of Remo Kamki
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Itanagar
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
9:Deken Boje
Age: 42
Occupation :
Son of Lukde Boje
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Khonsa Electrical Sub Division
Khonsa
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
10:Yumnya Yongam
Age: 35
Occupation :
Son of Late Minyum Yomgam
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Deomali
Page No.# 3/26
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
11:Nabum Gamin
Age: 45
Occupation :
Son of Nabum Saha
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Doimukh Electrical Sub Division
Doimukh
Papumpare District
Arunachal
12:Gyati Nobin
Age: 33
Occupation :
Son of Gyati Tada
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Kanubari Electrical Sub Division
Kanubari
Longding District
Arunachal Pradesh
13:Miss Jumyir Lollen
Age: 0
Occupation :
Daughter of Tojum Lollen
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Mechuka Electrical Sub Division
Shi Yomi District
Arunachal Pradesh
14:Miss Minpi Tasar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Pemin Gadi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Roing Electrical Sub Division
Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh
15:Neelam Raba
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Neelam Takhi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Yazali Electrical Sub Division
Yazali
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
16:Moter Basar
Page No.# 4/26
Age: 38
Occupation :
Son of Late Emo Basar
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Deomali Electrical Sub Division
Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
17:Kajen Tamin
Age: 40
Occupation :
Son of Late Pakko Debom
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Daporijo Electrical Sub Division
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
18:Todar Basar
Age: 37
Occupation :
Son of Late Dakto Basar
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Jairampur Electrical Sub Division
Jairampur
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
19:Duyu Richo
Age: 36
Occupation :
Son of Duyu Gyute
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
20:Oyi Nasi
Age: 33
Occupation :
Son of Maglom Nasi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Dumprijo Electrical Sub Division
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
21:Hage Habung
Age: 34
Occupation :
Son of Hage Hailyang
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Page No.# 5/26
Khuppi
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh
22:Nyanu Doji
Age: 34
Occupation :
Son of Karnya Doji
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Changlang Electrical Sub Division
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
23:Kipa Kame
Age: 41
Occupation :
Son of Kipa Nikio
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
24:Doge Ete
Age: 38
Occupation :
Son of Nyado Ete
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Nacho Electrical Sub Division
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Prades
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Rintu Saikia, Bomchi Taipodia,Idak Bam,Limi Bam,Ligam Nochi
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Dicky Panging,SC(Power),Lissing Perme
Linked Case : WA/35/2024
Kiyang Mize and 5 Ors
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Permanent Resident of Bolung
PO an PS Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Ruchu Niji
Page No.# 6/26
Age: 54
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Taru Niji
residing at Lekhi Village
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Bengia Kagung
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Bengia Tajak
permanent resident of Pingang Village
PO and PS Koloriang
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Mindu Phuntso
Age: 50
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Domchung Phuntso
permanent resident of Village Bongleng
PO Mukto
PS Jang
Tawang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Gungli (Loa) Tagang
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Loa (Gungli) Tache
permanent resident of Pathuk Village
PO Parsi Parlo
PS Koloriang
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Puluk Gadi
Age: 51
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Ikpu Gadi
permanent resident of Degom Village
PO and PS Tirin
Leparada District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 23 Ors
Page No.# 7/26
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Chief Secretary
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
791111
2:The Commissioiner/ Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Departmental Promotion Committee dated 10.06.2022
4:The Chief Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
5:Nima Tsering
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Towla Monpa
presently posted Assistant Engineer(E) Miao Electrical Division
Miao
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
6:Hage Nengka
Age: 34
Occupation :
Address:Son of Hage Obin
presently posted Assistant Electrical Inspector
Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
7:Purik Buchi
Age: 34
Occupation :
Address:Son of Jumpu Buchi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) SLDC Sub Division
Page No.# 8/26
Itanagar
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
8:Moli Kamki
Age: 36
Occupation :
Address:Son of Remo Kamki
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Itanagar
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
9:Deken Boje
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:Son of Lukde Boje
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Khonsa Electrical Sub Division
Khonsa
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
10:Yumnya Yongam
Age: 35
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Minyum Yomgam
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
11:Nabum Gamin
Age: 45
Occupation :
Address:Son of Nabum Saha
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Doimukh Electrical Sub Division
Doimukh
Papumpare District
Arunachal
12:Gyati Nobin
Age: 33
Occupation :
Address:Son of Gyati Tada
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Kanubari Electrical Sub Division
Kanubari
Longding District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 9/26
13:Miss Jumyir Lollen
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Tojum Lollen
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Mechuka Electrical Sub Division
Shi Yomi District
Arunachal Pradesh
14:Miss Minpi Tasar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Late Pemin Gadi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Roing Electrical Sub Division
Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh
15:Neelam Raba
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Son of Neelam Takhi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Yazali Electrical Sub Division
Yazali
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
16:Moter Basar
Age: 38
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Emo Basar
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Deomali Electrical Sub Division
Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh
17:Kajen Tamin
Age: 40
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Pakko Debom
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Daporijo Electrical Sub Division
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
18:Todar Basar
Age: 37
Occupation :
Page No.# 10/26
Address:Son of Late Dakto Basar
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Jairampur Electrical Sub Division
Jairampur
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
19:Duyu Richo
Age: 36
Occupation :
Address:Son of Duyu Gyute
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Daporijo
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
20:Oyi Nasi
Age: 33
Occupation :
Address:Son of Maglom Nasi
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Dumprijo Electrical Sub Division
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
21:Hage Habung
Age: 34
Occupation :
Address:Son of Hage Hailyang
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Khuppi
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh
22:Nyanu Doji
Age: 34
Occupation :
Address:Son of Karnya Doji
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Changlang Electrical Sub Division
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh
23:Kipa Kame
Age: 41
Occupation :
Address:Son of Kipa Nikio
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Grid Station Sub Division
Pasighat
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 11/26
24:Doge Ete
Age: 38
Occupation :
Address:Son of Nyado Ete
presently posted Assistant Engineer (E) Nacho Electrical Sub Division
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
-----------Advocate for : D Mazumdar
Sr. Advocate
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 23 Ors: Advocate ,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
Page No.# 12/26
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
Page No.# 13/26
23,
24, respectively.
Linked Case : WA/1/2025
Nani Pussang
Age: 25
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Nani Nipa
Village Reru
PO and PS Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 3 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Chief Secretary
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
2:The Commissioner (Power)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Chief Engineer (CEZ)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Power
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:The Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Departmental Promotion committee
C/o the Chief Secretary
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Page No.# 14/26
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Hage Lampu
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 3 Ors: Advocate ,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4, respectively.
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Dated: 13.02.2026
(S. K. Medhi, J.)
The challenge in all these three writ appeals being identical, the same are
taken up together for analogous hearing and are disposed of by this common
judgment and order. Suffice it to mention that Writ Appeal No. 28 (AP) of 2024
and Writ Appeal No. 35 (AP) of 2024 arises out of a judgment dated
31.08.2024. It may further be mentioned that though two appeals have been
preferred, they arise from the same batch of petitioners who had filed WP(C)
149 (AP) of 2023. In WA No.35 (AP) of 2024, 6 (six) of the petitioners have
joined together, while the remaining petitioner has preferred WA No. 28 (AP) of
2024. Insofar as WA No.01 (AP) of 2025 is concerned, the same has been
preferred against a judgment dated 19.12.2024 which, however, was delivered
by following the earlier judgment dated 31.08.2024. The appellants are the writ
petitioners.
Page No.# 15/26
2.
Before going into the issues which have arisen for adjudication, the facts
in brief, as projected in the writ petitions are given hereinbelow. For the sake of
convenience, the facts are stated as per the writ appeals.
WA No.35 (AP) of 2024
3.
In this appeal, there are 6 (six) appellants who were part of the writ
petitioners in WP(C) 149 (AP) of 2023. It is contended that the appellants were
appointed as Junior Engineers (Electrical) in the Department of Power during
the period 1994-1997 and had become eligible for promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineer on completion of the qualifying length of service. However,
the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meetings were not held, for
which the petitioners were deprived of their regular promotion. Be that as it
may, the petitioners were promoted on an officiating basis to the post of
Assistant Engineer during the years 2008–2011 and were given regular
promotion in the year 2022. However, the prayer for granting retrospective
effect to their promotion was declined and, accordingly, the writ petition was
filed which, however, was dismissed.
4.
It is contended that as on 24.07.2012, 11 (eleven) nos. of Assistant
Engineers in the Department who were senior to the appellants and had been
promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer on an officiating basis during the
year 2007–2008, were recommended by the DPC for regularisation with
retrospective effect from the date of their officiating promotion. For the purpose
of regularisation, 8 (eight) posts of Assistant Engineer under the direct
recruitment quota were converted to the promotion quota as a one-time
relaxation vide order dated 17.03.2008. On 23.11.2011, an advertisement was
issued for filling up 20 (twenty) nos. of posts of Assistant Engineer by direct
recruitment and, accordingly, to accommodate such direct recruits, the
Page No.# 16/26
appellants were reverted to the post of Junior Engineer. Consequently, vide
order dated 18.07.2013, 20 (twenty) nos. of Assistant Engineers, including
respondent Nos. 5 to 24 were appointed as direct recruits pursuant to the
advertisement dated 23.11.2011. The appellants were, however, reinstated to
the post of Assistant Engineer on an officiating basis vide order dated
29.07.2013, which was made effective from the date of reversion, i.e.,
17.07.2013. It is contended that, in that view of the matter, there was no break
in their service as Assistant Engineers on an officiating basis.
5.
The writ petitioners/appellants had been representing from time to time
for regularisation, which, however, was not considered. In the meantime, three
of the appellants, namely appellant nos. 4, 5 and 6 had instituted WP(C) 379
(AP) of 2013, wherein this Court vide judgment and order dated 24.11.2015
directed holding of a DPC within four months and consideration of their cases
along with other similarly situated persons. Subsequently, on 23.06.2022, the
appellants were promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer on a regular basis
on the recommendation of the DPC, but with effect from 10.06.2022. The claim
of the petitioners to grant retrospective effect to their promotion from the date
of their officiating appointment was, however, negated by the learned Single
Judge on the ground that there were no vacancies available at the relevant
point of time.
6.
Shri D. Mazumdar, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Shri P. Borah,
learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the vacancy position was
clear and that the total number of vacancies in the cadre of Assistant Engineers
during the period 2008–2012 was 36 (thirty six), out of which 8 (eight)
vacancies of the direct recruitment quota were earlier converted to the
promotional quota. Therefore, 28 (twenty eight) vacancies were existing and, by
Page No.# 17/26
the ratio of 50:50, out of those 28 (twenty eight), 14 (fourteen) posts were left
for the promotional quota. In that view of the matter, he contends that the
finding of the learned Single Judge that regularisation from the date of
officiating appointments could not have been made is factually incorrect. The
learned Senior Counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court to the aspect
of continuous service, which is a relevant criterion for directing regularisation. In
this regard, he has placed reliance on the case of Direct Recruit Class-II
Engineering Officers’ Association v. State of Maharashtra, reported in
(1990) 2 SCC 715, and the relevant principles are extracted hereinbelow:
“44. To sum up, we hold that:
(A) Once an incumbent is appointed to a post according to rule, his seniority has
to be counted from the date of his appointment and not according to the date of
his confirmation.
The corollary of the above rule is that where the initial appointment is only ad
hoc and not according to rules and made as a stop-gap arrangement, the
officiation in such post cannot be taken into account for considering the seniority.
(B) If the initial appointment is not made by following the procedure laid down
by the rules but the appointee continues in the post uninterruptedly till the
regularisation of his service in accordance with the rules, the period of officiating
service will be counted.
(C) …”
7.
He has also submitted that in the instant appeal, the IA(C)43(AP)2026 had
to be filed inasmuch as a notification dated 16.01.2026 has been issued
whereby it has been notified that the DPC would be held soon for further
promotion from the post of Assistant Engineer to Executive Engineer, for which
Page No.# 18/26
APARs have been called for. He has also submitted that on 29.01.2026, an inter
se seniority list was published, which, however, contains a clause that the same
would be subject to the outcome of the writ petition. He has submitted that if
such seniority list is acted upon in the meantime, grave prejudice would be
caused to the appellants. The learned Senior Counsel has further submitted that
the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the Department would show that vacancies
had existed for which a direction for granting retrospective effect could have
been issued. However, the learned Single Judge had drawn a presumption
without any factual basis that there were no vacancies simply on the strength of
certain office notes obtained by the private respondents by means of an RTI
application. He has submitted that office notes cannot take the form of an order
and in view of the categorical stand of the Department regarding existence of
vacancies, such a course could not have been adopted by the learned Single
Judge.
WA No.28 (AP) of 2024
8.
Shri R. Saikia, learned counsel for the appellant in the instant case has
clarified that the present appellant was one of the writ petitioners in WP(C) 149
of 2023, who, however, has preferred this appeal separately. He has submitted
that the appellant was appointed as a Junior Engineer on 07.10.1994 and on
27.02.2009, he was promoted as Assistant Engineer on an officiating basis
against a deputation vacancy. Subsequently, the writ petitioner was given the
pay scale of Assistant Engineer. The deputationist in whose vacancy the
petitioner was appointed was permanently absorbed in the Hydropower
Department by an order dated 16.05.2012 with effect from 27.02.2009. He has
further submitted that on an earlier instance, the petitioner was reverted to the
post of Junior Engineer, which was the subject matter of challenge in WP(C) 428
Page No.# 19/26
(AP) of 2008. In accordance with the direction of this Court, the petitioner was,
however, reinstated as Assistant Engineer on 24.06.2009.
9.
He has submitted that a DPC was conducted on 24.07.2012 to regularise 8
(eight) promotees who were given officiating promotion against the direct
recruitment quota. Among those eight persons, one Shri Tajong Messar at serial
No. 4 had expired and, in effect, seven persons were regularised. It is submitted
that no DPC was convened thereafter despite representations being filed. He
has submitted that as on 17.07.2013, 18 (eighteen) officiating promotees were
reverted back, which did not include the petitioner, and in any case those
candidates were reinstated again on 02.09.2013. On 04.04.2013, 20 (twenty)
direct recruits were appointed, but there are 7 (seven) other Departments and
only 13 (thirteen) belong to the Electrical Division. He has submitted that the
petitioner was never reverted to the post of Junior Engineer and has been in
continuous service on an officiating basis as Assistant Engineer and, in view of
the existence of vacancies, the claim to be granted benefits of promotion from
the date of his officiating appointment is justified. He has also relied upon the
case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. N. R. Banerjee & Ors., reported in
(1997) 9 SCC 287.
WA No.01 (AP) of 2025
10.
Shri H. Lampu, learned counsel has appeared for the appellant in this
case, whose writ petition was dismissed vide judgment and order dated
19.12.2024 based on the earlier judgment and order dated 31.08.2024 passed
in WP(C) 149 (AP) of 2023. It is submitted that the petitioner is the senior-most
amongst the Junior Engineers in the Department and in his writ petition, there
were no private respondents. He has submitted that on 27.05.2022, there was a
meeting
of
the
DPC
which
recommended
for
regularisation
of
the
Page No.# 20/26
appellant/petitioner and for further promotion to the post of Executive Engineer.
He has submitted that on 21.01.1994 the appellant was appointed as Junior
Engineer. After completion of the required length of service, the petitioner
became eligible for promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer and, accordingly,
on 27.02.2008, he was granted officiating promotion as Assistant Engineer
against the direct recruitment quota. The said promotion was, however,
withdrawn, for which the appellant had earlier filed a writ petition challenging
such withdrawal. Vide an order dated 24.06.2009, the petitioner was, however,
reinstated as per the direction of the High Court. He has also submitted that the
deputation vacancy in which the petitioner was promoted was absorbed with
effect from 2009 and in that line, he has submitted that the vacancy of Assistant
Engineer in which he was promoted was an existing vacancy from 2009 itself.
He has further submitted that as on 2012, a DPC was conducted and two
persons junior to the petitioner were regularised with retrospective effect. The
petitioner had accordingly filed WP(C) 11 of 2013 which was, however,
dismissed on 24.09.2013 as the private respondents in that case were held to
be differently placed namely, they being degree holders. However, from 2012 to
27.05.2022, no further DPC was held. On 11.11.2021, an order was passed to
reckon the seniority of the petitioner which, however, was not put to challenge
by anybody. In the provisional seniority list, the petitioner is shown at serial No.
2. The grievance of the petitioner is that the failure to hold the DPC in time has
delayed his substantial promotion and has adversely affected his seniority.
11.
It is submitted that the writ petitioner was eligible in all respects and
vacancies were existing and, for the negligence of the Department in not
holding the DPC, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer. He has submitted
that, if not from 2009 when the petitioner was given officiating promotion, at
Page No.# 21/26
least from 2012 when the deputationist was absorbed in the vacancy in which
the petitioner was appointed, his seniority should be reckoned. He has also
gone to the extent that even notional promotion may be granted from such
date.
12.
Shri Perme, learned Standing Counsel for the Power Department has,
however, submitted that the aspect of lack of vacancy which was taken into
consideration by the learned Single Judge may not be strictly in accordance with
the version of the Department given in the affidavit-in-opposition filed on
20.05.2024 in WP(C) 149 of 2023. By drawing the attention of this Court to the
said affidavit, he has submitted that till 2005, the ratio of 50:50 was maintained
between direct recruits and promotees and the next DPC was held in 2012
which was meant for regularising 8 (eight) promotees who were given
officiating promotion against direct recruitment quota in 2008. He has submitted
that the posts after 17.03.2008 were not the subject matter of consideration of
the said DPC. He has drawn the attention of this Court to the DPC proceedings
dated 24.07.2012 annexed to the records and also to the affidavit-in-opposition
wherein a table of vacancies and details as to how the vacancies had arisen
have been stated. He has submitted that 36 (thirty) vacancies existed and this
aspect was misconstrued by the learned Single Judge.
13. On the other hand, Shri Panging, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 5 to
24 in WA No. 28 (AP) of 2024 as well as WA No.35 (AP) of 2024 has strenuously
opposed the appeals and has submitted that the impugned judgment dated
31.08.2024 has been passed based on the materials on record and does not
require any interference.
14.
At the outset, he has submitted that the projection made that there are
different segments of Engineering in the cadre of Assistant Engineer in the
Page No.# 22/26
Power Department, as projected by the petitioners, is incorrect. He has
submitted that it is a common cadre and there is no difference between
Electrical Engineer, Mechanical Engineer, etc. He has drawn the attention of this
Court to the inter se seniority list dated 29.01.2026 which includes the names of
all incumbents irrespective of whether they are in the Electrical, Mechanical or
Computer Division of the Power Department. He has submitted that the vacancy
position as on 30.08.2011 was 23 (twenty three). However, taking into
consideration that earlier there was backlog in the direct recruitment quota, 20
(twenty) posts were advertised on 23.11.2011, which were accordingly, filled up
on direct recruitment basis. On 23.08.2009, the appellant nos. 2 and 3 were
given officiating promotion, which, however, was subject to the filling up of the
posts by direct recruitment. Similarly, on 16.06.2010, the appellant no. 1 was
given officiating promotion and on 07.07.2011 appellant nos. 4, 5 and 6 were
given officiating appointments.
15. Shri Panging, learned counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court to
the minutes of the DPC dated 24.07.2012 which recorded that as on 17.03.2008,
8 (eight) posts were converted from direct recruitment quota to promotion
quota. He has submitted that if vacancies in the promotion quota were
available, there was no requirement to convert posts from the direct recruitment
quota. He has also submitted that three promotions were made which were
unsuccessfully challenged. So far as WA No.28 of 2014 is concerned, he has
submitted that the writ petitioner was given promotion on 27.08.2008, whereas
in WA No. 35 of 2014, the appellants were given promotion on 23.08.2009,
16.06.2010, and 07.07.2011. He has submitted that the affidavit filed by the
department contains incorrect facts which are not in sync with the data obtained
by his clients under the Right to Information Act. He has also submitted that no
Page No.# 23/26
rejoinder affidavit was filed by the Department to his affidavit-in-opposition.
16.
In support of his submissions, Shri Panging has relied upon the case of
Union of India & Anr. v. Manpreet Singh Poonam & Ors. , reported in
(2022) 6 SCC 105, wherein it has been laid down that mere existence of
vacancies does not vest any right to promotion. He has also relied upon the
case of Bihar State Electricity Board & Ors. v. Dharamdeo Das , reported
in 2024 SCC Online SC 1768, wherein it has been laid down that no
retrospective promotion can be granted. Reliance has been placed on the case
of State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath & Ors. , reported in 1991
Supp (1) SCC 334, wherein it has been laid down that retrospective promotion
cannot be given which adversely affects the rights of others. He has submitted
that though the petitioners have relied upon the case of Union of India v. N.
R. Banerjee (supra), the same would not be applicable in the facts and
circumstances of the present case, as in those cases there was a stipulation
regarding availability of pre-existing vacancies. He has also drawn attention of
this Court to a judgment reported in (2014) 6 GLR 152 (Tanzin Gombu
Khrime & Ors. Vs. State of AP), wherein it has been laid down that in the
absence of any provision in the recruitment rules for granting retrospective
effect, the same is impermissible.
17.
Shri Panging, the learned counsel has referred to the findings of the
learned Single Judged recorded in paragraph 34 of the judgment as per which,
the stand of the State respondents in the affidavit was not supported by the
record made available and a contrary picture had emerged.
18.
Shri Perme, learned Standing Counsel in his rejoinder has however
clarified that the vacancy position was clearly explained in details in the affidavit
filed by the Department.
Page No.# 24/26
19. Shri Mazumdar, learned Senior Counsel in his rejoinder has submitted that
the file noting annexed in the affidavit by the private respondents were not for
the purpose of ascertaining the vacancy position and the connected pleadings in
this regard are wholly inadequate. On the other hand, in the Department
affidavit, the entire details of the vacancy position have been given and there is
no reason to disregard the same.
20. The rival contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the contesting
parties have been duly considered and the materials placed before this Court
have been carefully examined.
21. The proposition of law has been laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Direct Recruit II (supra), which have been extracted above.
The position have also been explained by the subsequent decision rendered in
the case of State of West Bengal & Ors. Vs. Aghore Nath Dey, reported in
(1993) 3 SCC 371. The settled position of law is that the seniority can be
reckoned from the date of officiating appointment if such appointment was done
by following the rules and in an existing vacancy.
22.
In the instant bunch of appeals, there is a dispute with regard to the
existence of vacancy in the promotional quota in the rank of Assistant Engineer
of the Department at the time of giving officiating promotion to the appellants.
As indicated above, the learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment dated
31.08.2024 had however, proceeded on the basis that though an affidavit was
filed by the Department acknowledging availability of vacancies at the relevant
time, the records made available did not support the same.
23. On that point, the materials on record have been carefully examined. The
records which the learned Single Judge has referred are the file noting which
Page No.# 25/26
the respondent nos. 5 to 24 had annexed to the affidavit-in-opposition. A
perusal of the same, would however, show that certain data were extracted in
terms a direction of the Secretary (Power) on 30.08.2011 which was mainly for
the purpose of initiating a recruitment drive for unemployed youths. We are also
of the opinion that file noting cannot take the form of any direction or order and
in this connection, one may gainfully refer to the case of Bachhittar Singh Vs.
the State of Punjab, reported in 1963 AIR 395, wherein a Constitutional
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down as follows:
“The question, therefore, is whether he did in fact make such an order. Merely
writing something on the file does not amount to an order. Before something
amounts to an order of the State Government two things are necessary. The
order has to be expressed in the name of the Governor as required by cl. (1)
of Art. 166 and then it has to be communicated. As already indicated, no formal
order modifying the decision of the Revenue Secretary was ever made. Until such
an order is drawn up the State Government cannot, in our opinion, be regarded
as bound by what was stated in the file. As along as the matter rested with him
the Revenue Minister could well score out his remarks or minutes on the file and
write fresh ones.”
24. We have also seen that the Department in its affidavit filed on 20.05.2024
has, in an elaborate and detail manner given the vacancy position in paragraph
4(III). The said details are with regard to the vacancy position from 31.08.2008
to 31.03.2012. In the remark column, the details of the orders of
promotion/deputation/retirement/deaths, etc. have been given. Under such
circumstances, perhaps there was no occasion on the part of the learned Single
Judge to come to a finding that the Department’s affidavit was not matching
with the file noting dated 14.09.2011.
Page No.# 26/26
25. Rejecting the claim of the appellants/writ petitioners only on the basis of
certain file noting may not be proper when the Department affidavit is clear on
the aspect of availability of vacancy. As noted above, the principle of law laid
down is that if vacancy was available, the seniority of an incumbent has to be
reckoned from the date of officiating appointment.
26.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we are of the view that
the matter is required to be reconsidered by the Department. The Department is
accordingly directed to re-do an exercise with regard to the availability of
vacancy from the date of officiating appointment of the appellants and if such
vacancies in the promotional quota in the cadre of Assistant Engineers were
found to be existing, the appellants be given the benefit of seniority from such
date. It is needless to say that the appellants, if found to be senior, they would
be entitled only to the notional benefits.
27.
The aforesaid exercise be undertaken and completed expeditiously and
preferably within an outer limit of 90 (ninety) days from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
28.
The impugned judgments dated 31.08.2024 and 19.12.2024 accordingly
stand interfered with.
29. The appeals are accordingly allowed to the extent indicated above.
30. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review