Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/17
GAHC010162642022
2026:GAU-AS:606
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5335/2022
KISHORE SAIKIA
S/O- SRI HEMANTA SAIKIA,
DHEMAJI TOWN, WARD NO. 3, RAILWAY STATION ROAD,
P.O.- DHEMAJI,
PINCODE- 787057,
DISTRICT- DHEMAJI,
ASSAM.
VERSUS
ASSAM PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION AND 7 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN, JAWAHAR NAGAR, GUWAHATI781022.
2:SECRETARY
ASSAM PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
JAWAHAR NAGAR
KHANAPARA- 781022.
3:THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATION
ASSAM PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
JAWAHAR NAGAR
KHANAPARA
GUWAHATI- 781022.
4:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL-A
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
5:LABOUR COMMISSIONER
Page No.# 2/17
OFFICE OF THE LABOUR COMMISSIONER
ASSAM
GOPINATH NAGAR
GUWAHATI-16.
6:COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
DISPUR- 781006.
7:UTTAM PEGU
LABOUR INSPECTOR
THROUGH THE LABOUR COMMISSIONER
ASSAM
GOPINATH NAGAR
GUWAHATI- 16.
8:NIRAB KUMAR DEURI
LABOUR INSPECTOR
THROUGH THE LABOUR COMMISSIONER
ASSAM
GOPINATH NAGAR
GUWAHATI- 16
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. A. Phukan, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. T.J. Mahanta, Sr. Advocate
Ms. M. Bhattacharjee, Govt. Advocate
Ms. P. Sarma, Advocate
Mr. S.K. Deori, Advocate
Date on which judgment was reserved : NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 20.01.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 3/17
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. A. Phukan, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioner. Mr. T.J. Mahanta, the learned Senior Counsel assisted
by Ms. P. Sarma, the learned counsel appears on behalf of the Assam
Public Service Commission; Ms. M. Bhattacharjee, the learned
Government Advocate appears on behalf of the State of Assam and
Mr. S.K. Deori, the learned counsel appears on behalf of the
respondent Nos. 7 and 8.
2.
The petitioner herein is aggrieved by the selection and
appointment of the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 to the post of Labour
Inspector
pursuant
to
the
Combined
Competitive
Services
Examinations held in the year 2015. It is under such circumstances,
the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition on 12.08.2022 seeking
the following reliefs:
“i.
A declaration that the evaluation undertaken and done by the respondent
authorities is bad in law and is liable to be re-evaluated, re- checked and to
award to the petitioner correct marks to the question under scrutiny.
ii.
a writ in the nature of Certiorari shall not be issued to set aside/quash the
impugned evaluation and under marking meted out towards the petitioner.
iii.
To issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari and /or other appropriate writ, order
or direction of like nature to set aside and quash the selection and
appointments of the respondents no. 7 and 8 as Labour Inspectors.
iv.
A writ in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued directing the Respondents
Page No.# 4/17
to allow appropriate appointment to the petitioner in the cadre of Labour
Inspector in the Scheduled Tribes (Plains) Category (Male) or any other
appropriate category in accordance with law and /or
v.
Alternatively, a writ in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued directing the
Respondents to create a supernumerary post for appointment to the petitioner
in the cadre of Labour Inspector in the Schedule Tribes (Plains) (Male) category
or any other appropriate category in accordance with law
vi.
A writ in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued directing the Respondents
to forthwith cancel/recall/ rescind and/or otherwise forbear from giving effect to
the impugned evaluation.”
3.
Let this Court at the outset deal with the facts which led to the
filing of the instant writ petition.
4.
The Assam Public Service Commission (for short, “the APSC”)
issued an advertisement bearing No. 13/2015 dated 03.07.2015
inviting candidates for recruitment to various posts in accordance with
the Assam Public Services (Combined Competitive Examination) Rules,
1989. It is pertinent to take note of the various posts which were
advertised. It included the posts of Assam Civil Service (Jr. Grade),
Assam Land & Revenue Service (Jr. Grade), Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Labour Inspector, Inspector of Taxes and
Inspector of Excise.
5.
From a perusal of the said advertisement, it is apparent that the
candidates applying were required to give their preference in respect
Page No.# 5/17
to the posts advertised. The petitioner herein who is a Schedule Tribe
(Plain) applied and gave preference to various posts including the post
of Labour Inspector which was his fourth preference. In the year
2017, more particularly, on 28.08.2017, the petitioner was informed
upon filing an application under the Right to Information Act, 2005
that he had secured 901 marks in the Combined Competitive (Main)
Examination. In the said communication issued by the State Public
Information Officer of the APSC, the detailed marks so obtained by
the petitioner in each subject were duly mentioned. The materials on
records clearly show that for the post of Labour Inspector for a ST(P)
candidate the cut off mark was 901. The petitioner knew that he had
secured 901 marks but for reasons best known did not take any steps
till filing of the writ petition on 12.08.2022.
6.
At this stage it is very pertinent to take note of an interesting
development during this period. A candidate namely Shri Hrishikesh
Das being aggrieved in not granting marks in respect to certain
questions in the Main Examination approached this Court by filing a
writ petition which was registered and numbered as WP(C) No.
5576/2017. The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide the
judgment and order dated 20.08.2018 allowed the said writ petition
thereby directing re-evaluation of the competitive examination paper
of the said Shri Hrishikesh Das and award additional marks in respect
of certain indisputably correct answers given by the said Shri
Page No.# 6/17
Hrishikesh Das, for which, no marks were awarded by the examiner.
7.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 20.08.2018
passed in WP(C) No. 5576/2017, the APSC preferred a Writ Appeal
before the learned Division Bench of this Court which was registered
and numbered as Writ Appeal No. 61/2019. The learned Division
Bench of this Court vide an elaborate judgment dated 07.10.2021
dismissed the said Writ Appeal thereby confirming the judgment of
the learned Coordinate Bench. An Appeal thereagainst was filed
before the Supreme Court which was registered and numbered as
Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 2946/2022. The Supreme Court vide
an order dated 28.02.2022 dismissed the said Special Leave Petition
by keeping the question of law open.
8.
It appears that the dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the
Supreme Court might have encouraged the petitioner herein to file the
present writ petition on 12.08.2022, in spite of the fact that the
petitioner had due knowledge that the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 were
selected, recommended and appointed as far back as in the year
2017.
9.
The petitioner herein has filed the instant writ petition primarily
on 2 (two) grounds.
First, the petitioner was not awarded marks in respect to
Page No.# 7/17
question No. 6(d)(v) in the General English Paper. The petitioner
submitted a representation on 27.09.2019 which was not considered.
The second ground is that there was an illegality committed by
the examiner while awarding marks to the petitioner in terms with
Rule 56 of the Assam Public Service Commission (Procedure and
Conduct of Business) Rules, 2010 (for short, “the Rules of 2010”). It
was the specific case of the petitioner that this particular Rule
mandated that no marks should be overwritten and marks should be
given clearly and legibly and if necessary it may be cut by a line
across it and the new mark allotted may be written over it by putting
signature of the Invigilator. It is the case of the petitioner on the basis
of the answer scripts which the petitioner received as far back as in
the year 2017 that while awarding the marks there was overwriting
and also there were no signatures.
10.
The respondent APSC filed an affidavit-in-opposition on
25.08.2023. The filing of the affidavit-in-opposition and, more
particularly, the contents of paragraph No. 8 of the said affidavit-inopposition led to the third ground on which the petitioner has
attacked the selection, recommendation and appointment of the
respondent No. 8. It was submitted that there was a violation of Rule
68 of the Rules of 2010 inasmuch as both the petitioner and the
respondent No. 8 secured 901 marks, but as the petitioner secured
Page No.# 8/17
more marks in the main subjects which the petitioner came to learn
subsequent to another affidavit being filed by the APSC on
07.01.2026,
the
petitioner
ought
to
have
been
selected,
recommended and appointed in place of the respondent No. 8. It is
noteworthy to reiterate that the petitioner knew that he secured 901
marks and the cut off for the ST(P) candidate for the post of Labour
Inspector was 901 marks as far back as on 28.08.2017.
SUBMISSIONS BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS
11.
Mr. A. Phukan, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submitted that non-granting of marks in respect to the
question No. 6(d)(v) of the General English Paper was a mistake/error
committed by the examiner of the APSC which is apparent and as
such if the 2 (two) marks are given then the petitioner would secure
903 marks and thereby the petitioner’s marks would be higher than
that of the respondent No. 8 who secured 901 marks.
12.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that
Rule 56 of the Rules of 2010 was violated and in that regard referred
to the tabulation of the marks given to the petitioner which is at page
No. 50 of the writ petition. The learned counsel submitted that the
petitioner initially was awarded 200 marks which were struck off and
made 198 and thereafter again struck off and reduced to 196, but
there were no signatures against such striking off thereby violating
Page No.# 9/17
Rule 56 of the Rules of 2010.
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that a
perusal of Rule 68 of the Rules of 2010 would make it apparently
clear that in case of a tie, the candidate who has secured more marks
in the main subjects would be given preference. The learned counsel
drew the attention of this Court to the affidavit filed by the APSC on
07.01.2026 and, more particularly, to paragraph No. 2 wherein it
would be seen that the petitioner secured more marks in the General
Studies and General English (combined together) to that of the
respondent No. 8. The learned counsel further referring to the Assam
Public Services (Combined Competitive Examination) Rules, 1989
referred to Clause 2 of Appendix-I and submitted that which would be
the main subjects. He therefore submitted that if Rule 68 of the Rules
of 2010 would have been applied then in that case the petitioner
ought to have been selected, recommended and appointed to the
post of Labour Inspector.
14. Mr. T.J. Mahanta, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf
of the APSC submitted that the writ petition is completely baseless
and it should be dismissed on the ground of delay and laches. The
learned Senior Counsel submitted that the instant writ petition has
been filed seeking a fishing and roving enquiry. Referring to the
judgment of the learned Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Page No.# 10/17
Assam Public Service Commission & Others Vs. Hrishikesh Das &
Another reported in 2021 (4) GLT 788, the learned Senior Counsel
submitted that the said candidate Shri Hrishikesh Das immediately
approached the Court in the year 2017 itself and certain interim
directions were passed therein. However, in the instant case the
petitioner is a classic example of a fence sitter who awaited the
outcome of the judgment in the case of Hrishikesh Das (supra) which
was confirmed by the Supreme Court on 28.02.2022 and approached
this Court on 12.08.2022. The explanation provided for the delay in
approaching this Court as regards COVID pandemic and all have no
legs to stand taking into account that these appointments were made
much prior to the COVID pandemic. The learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that the petitioner had all the materials available as
far back as on 10.12.2017 itself and the petitioner approached this
Court almost after 5 (five) years. In the meantime, the learned Senior
Counsel submitted that the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 were duly
appointed in the year 2017 and subsequent to certain departmental
examination held in the year 2021 they have also been confirmed as
far back as in the year 2023. He therefore submitted that the instant
writ petition ought to be dismissed purely on the ground of delay and
laches.
15. It must be noted herein that the learned Senior Counsel with all
fairness submitted that there appears to be a mistake in applying Rule
Page No.# 11/17
68 of the Rules of 2010, but in the present facts and circumstances,
this Court may not exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction for the reason
that the petitioner had approached this Court so late.
16.
The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the question
of re-evaluation is not permitted as per Rule 70 of the Rules of 2010
and further there is no infraction to Rule 56 of the Rules of 2010
inasmuch the signature duly appears. The learned Senior Counsel
further referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
Mrinmoy Maity Vs. Chhanda Koley & Others reported in (2024) 15 SCC
215 as well as another judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
Sankar Mondal Vs. State of West Bengal & Others reported in (2022)
SCC OnLine SC 1800.
17.
Mr. S.K. Deori, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos. 7 and 8 submitted that as regards the respondent
No. 7, the petitioner has no case at all taking into account that the
respondent No. 7 had secured 907 marks and even if there is a reevaluation ordered, then also it would not affect the selection,
recommendation and appointment of the respondent No. 7. As
regards the respondent No. 8, the learned counsel submitted that the
question of re-evaluation is not permitted as per Rule 70 of the Rules
of 2010. The learned counsel further submitted that the principle of
law laid down by the learned Division Bench of this Court in the case
Page No.# 12/17
of Hrishikesh Das (supra) cannot also be applied to the facts of the
instant case, taking into account that the petitioner has approached
this Court after 5 (five) years seeking re-evaluation in respect to
question No. 6(d)(v) of the General English Paper. The learned
counsel further referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of State of M.P. & Others Vs. Nandlal Jaiswal & Others reported in
(1986) 4 SCC 566 and submitted that as third party rights have
already been created by the appointment of the respondent Nos. 7
and 8 as far back as in the year 2017 and the services of the
respondent Nos. 7 and 8 in the meantime have also been confirmed,
any exercise of the writ jurisdiction in the present case may have the
effect of inflicting not only hardship and inconvenience, but also
injustice to the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 inasmuch as on today they
have put in 8 (eight) years of service.
18.
Mr. A. Phukan, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner, however, replying to the submission of delay and laches
submitted that if the illegality is apparent, the petitioner cannot be
ousted on the ground of delay and laches and in that regard had
referred to a judgment dated 04.12.2024 of the Supreme Court in the
case of Ram Autar Singh Yadav Vs. The State of Uttar Pradesh &
Others and referred to paragraph Nos. 20 and 22 of the said
judgment. He further referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court
in the case of Inder Singh Vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh reported in
Page No.# 13/17
(2025) INSC 382 and referred to paragraph No. 14.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
19.
In the foregoing paragraphs of the instant judgment, this Court
has referred to the fact that the case of the petitioner hinges upon the
3 (three) grounds. The question however arises, taking into account
the submissions so made by the learned counsels appearing on behalf
of the parties is, as to whether, this Court at this stage should
entertain the instant writ petition taking into account that the
petitioner has approached this Court after a delay of almost 5 (five)
years.
20.
The materials on record, more particularly, Annexure-4 series
would show that on 28.08.2017 the petitioner was informed about the
marks which he has obtained in the Combined Competitive (Main)
Examination, 2015 against each subject. Thereupon, the petitioner
submitted the challans and was provided with all other documents
which forms a part of Annexure-4 series in the year 2017 itself. The
petitioner
thereupon
remained
silent
till
submission
of
a
representation on 27.09.2019 requesting a re-evaluation of the
question No. 6(d)(v) so that 2 (two) marks can be awarded to him.
The petitioner thereupon did not take any steps till filing of the writ
petition on 12.08.2022. It is very pertinent to take note of that in the
meantime both the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 were appointed in the
Page No.# 14/17
year 2017 and subsequently their services have also been confirmed
after passing the departmental examination held in the year 2021.
The respondent Nos. 7 and 8 in the meantime as on date have been
confirmed and they have put in 8 (eight) years of service.
21. This Court now finds it pertinent to take note of the observations
made by the Supreme Court in the case of Nandlal Jaiswal (supra)
and in that regard reproduces paragraph No. 24 herein under:
“24. Now, it is well settled that the power of the High Court to issue an appropriate
writ under Article 226 of the Constitution is discretionary and the High Court in the
exercise of its discretion does not ordinarily assist the tardy and the indolent or the
acquiescent and the lethargic. If there is inordinate delay on the part of the petitioner
in filing a writ petition and such delay is not satisfactorily explained, the High Court
may decline to intervene and grant relief in the exercise of its writ jurisdiction. The
evolution of this rule of laches or delay is premised upon a number of factors. The
High Court does not ordinarily permit a belated resort to the extraordinary remedy
under the writ jurisdiction because it is likely to cause confusion and public
inconvenience and bring in its train new injustices. The rights of third parties may
intervene and if the writ jurisdiction is exercised on a writ petition filed after
unreasonable delay, it may have the effect of inflicting not only hardship and
inconvenience but also injustice on third parties. When the writ jurisdiction of the High
Court is invoked, unexplained delay coupled with the creation of third party rights in
the meanwhile is an important factor which always weighs with the High Court in
deciding whether or not to exercise such jurisdiction. We do not think it necessary to
burden this judgment with reference to various decisions of this Court where it has
been emphasised time and again that where there is inordinate and unexplained delay
and third party rights are created in the intervening period, the High Court would
decline to interfere, even if the State action complained of is unconstitutional or illegal.
Page No.# 15/17
We may only mention in the passing two decisions of this Court one in Ramana
Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India and the other in Ashok
Kumar Mishra v. Collector. We may point out that in R.D. Shetty case, even though the
State action was held to be unconstitutional as being violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution, this Court refused to grant relief to the petitioner on the ground that the
writ petition had been filed by the petitioner more than five months after the
acceptance of the tender of the fourth respondent and during that period, the fourth
respondent had incurred considerable expenditure, aggregating to about Rs 1.25
lakhs, in making arrangements for putting up the restaurant and the snack bar. Of
course, this rule of laches or delay is not a rigid rule which can be cast in a strait
jacket formula, for there may be cases where despite delay and creation of third party
rights the High Court may still in the exercise of its discretion interfere and grant relief
to the petitioner. But, such cases where the demand of justice is so compelling that
the High Court would be inclined to interfere in spite of delay or creation of third party
rights would by their very nature be few and far between. Ultimately it would be a
matter within the discretion of the court; ex hypothesi every discretion must be
exercised fairly and justly so as to promote justice and not to defeat it.”
22. A perusal of the above quoted paragraph would show that when
there is an unexplained delay coupled with the creation of third party
rights in the meanwhile, it acts as an important factor in deciding
whether the Court should exercise its jurisdiction or not. In the instant
case, it would be seen that not only rights were created in favour of
the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 as far back as in the year 2017 but also
the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 upon participation in the departmental
examinations have also been confirmed. The explanation so provided
by the petitioner does not appear to be bona fide and reasonable.
23.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
Page No.# 16/17
though had relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of Ram Autar Singh Yadav (supra) but the said judgment in the
opinion of this Court would not aid the case of the petitioner
inasmuch as in that case neither there was any accrual of any parallel
right of third party nor grant of relief would cause confusion and
public inconvenience. In this regard, this Court finds it pertinent to
take note of paragraph No. 21 of the said judgment, which in the
opinion of this Court squarely applies to the facts of the instant case
and the same being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“21.
Taking a cue from the above, we can safely conclude that the foremost factor
based whereon relief could be declined in a case of unexplained delay and laches is
the accrual of a parallel right in favour of a third party. The other vital factor to be
borne in mind is whether grant of relief in a belated claim is likely to cause confusion
and public inconvenience like unsettling matters which have long settled. Relief could
also be denied if by reason of the delay, the official respondents are hopelessly
inconvenienced in defending their action for lack of the relevant records and to
establish their defence to the full satisfaction of the court.”
24.
This Court has also taken note of that the Rules of 2010 do not
permit re-evaluation. The judgment in the case of Hrishikesh Das
(supra) and the observations made therein in the opinion of this Court
cannot be applied to the facts of the instant case, taking into account
that the said candidate, namely Shri Hrishikesh Das, had approached
this Court promptly in the year 2017 itself unlike the petitioner who
approached after 5 (five) years.
Page No.# 17/17
25.
Considering the above, this Court therefore is not inclined to
exercise the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
even though there is an apparent irregularity in the application of Rule
68 of the Rules of 2010.
26. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed. No costs.
JUDGE
Date: 2026.01.22 17:47:43 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review