The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Viewed thus, this petition is allowed with the following directions, to the respondents:I. The respondent No.6-District Development Commissioner, Jammu who is also a Disaster Management Authority for Jammu District is directed to release the funds to the tune of ₹ 25.20 lacs from SDRF at his disposal in favour of respondent No.5-Executive Engineer, PWD(R&B), Construction Division-II, Jammu within a period of four weeks from this date. The respondent No.5- Executive Engineer, PWD(R&B), Construction Division-II, Jammu is further directed that, in the event of release of funds by the respondent No.6 in his favour, the payment shall be made to the petitioner within a period of four weeks, on fulfilling the codal formalities. If the admitted claim of the petitioner is not made within the aforesaid period of eight weeks, he shall be entitled to recover the same along with simple interest @ 10 % per annum, from the date of completion of the work, till its realization.
13. The petition stands disposed of along with connected application(s) on the above terms. (M A Chowdhary) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.69/2022
CM No.198/2022
Reserved on: 02.04.2026
Pronounced on:08.04.2026
Uploaded on:-08.04.2026.
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Yes
Kirpal Singh (66 yrs)
S/O Sh. Chaggar Singh
R/O Village Kana Chargal (Mela),
Jammu
.....Petitioner
Through :- Mr. R.K Gupta, Sr. Adv., with
Mr. Udhay Bhaskar, Adv.
V/S
1. Govt. of Jammu and Kashmir,
Department of Disaster Management, Relief
Rehabilitation and Reconstruction,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. Union Territory of J&K
through Commissioner Secretary,
Public Works (R&B), Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
3. Chief Engineer,
Public Works (R&B) Department,
Jammu.
4. Superintendent Engineer, PWD(R&B)
Jammu-Kathua Circle, Jammu.
5. Executive Engineer,
Public Works Department (R&B),
Construction Division-II, Jammu.
6. District Development Commissioner,
Jammu.
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Ms. Jagmeet Kour, Adv., vice
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG for R-1.
Ms. Pallavi Sharma, Adv., vice
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG for R-2 to 5.
Ms. Nazia Fazal, Adv., vice
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG for R-6.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Petitioner claiming to be registered as ‘A’ Class contractor asserts that
he was allotted a contract for the restoration of damaged Sidhra-Surinsar-Mansar
WP(C) No.69/2022
Road from 6 km to 21 km with approach road to Surinsar Lake with an
estimated cost of an amount of ₹25.50 lakhs and for construction of the road 2
km from Kana Chargal to Mela at an estimated cost of ₹4.50 lakh by the
respondent-PW(R&B) Construction Division-II, Jammu in September 2014.
2.
Petitioner has further pleaded that after allotment of the contract, the
petitioner deployed his men and machinery at the site and commenced the work
on war footing and completed the same within a short span of less than two
months; that on completion of the allotted restoration work, the District
Development Commissioner, Jammu vide his communication dated 11.08.2015
submitted the information to Divisional Commissioner, Jammu, about the
restoration of the damaged roads by the agency to whom the said work had been
allotted; that the respondent No.5-Executive Engineer, Public Works
Department requested the respondent No.3-Chief Engineer to get the funds to
the tune of ₹25.20 lakh released and placed at the disposal of the concerned
office, so that the pending liability may be cleared, however, despite various
correspondences and recommendations made by different authorities for the
release of funds for meeting out the pending liability, including the amount due
and payable to the petitioner, for the aforesaid executed works, neither the funds
were released nor the payment was made to the petitioner; and that the petitioner
had been made to run from pillar to post for release of the payment of the works
executed by him; that the respondents have illegally withheld huge amount of
the petitioner for no fault on his part and it was finally prayed that the
respondents be directed to make the payment of admitted liability of ₹29.20 lakh
along with interest @ 15 % per annum in respect of the works of the
respondents-department, executed by the petitioner.
WP(C) No.69/2022
3.
The petitioner besides other communications, placed on record a
communication
of
Executive
Engineer,
PWD(R&B),
Construction
Division-II, Jammu to the Superintending Engineer, PWD(R&B) JammuKathua Circle, Jammu vide No.15240-44 dated 17.02.2020, wherein it has been
admitted that there was pending liability of an amount of ₹25.20 lakhs with
regard to restoration of Sidhra-Surinsar-Mansar road from km 6 to km 19 with
approach road to Surinsar Lake damaged due to heavy rains/flash floods during
September, 2014.
4.
Pursuant to notice, the Public Works Department has filed reply stating
therein that the petition suffers from the vice of delay and laches, however, the
claim of the petitioner with regard to pending liability of ₹25.20 lakhs was not
disputed.
5.
The respondent No.1-Department of Disaster Management, Relief
Rehabilitation and Reconstruction filed counter affidavit asserting therein that
SDRF funds are released to the office of the Divisional Commissioners and
Deputy Commissioners as per the approval of the State Executive Committee
(SEC) of SDRF headed by Chief Secretary, Government of J&K, to meet the
requirement under National Disasters as per SDRF guidelines, with norms of
assistance issued by MHA, Government of India; that the concerned Divisional
Commissioner and Deputy Commissioner are the authorities releasing the funds
allotted to them and can clear any liability projected to them under the same,
subject to fulfillment of guidelines of SDRF; and that the adequate funds under
SDRF have already been released and placed at the disposal of Disaster
Management Authorities.
WP(C) No.69/2022
6.
Since the District Development Commissioner, Jammu as District
Disaster Authority, had to release the funds, as such, vide order dated
31.07.20204 he was made party as respondent No.6 on the submission made by
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner and the petition was admitted
to hearing with a direction to the respondents to file counter affidavit. Despite
service of notice, the respondent–Deputy Commissioner, Jammu chose not to
file any counter affidavit.
7.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that this is a
case where the respondents have not released the admitted claims of the
petitioner after execution of the work of restoration of the road having been
damaged due to insistent rains in the year 2014; that the petitioner has been
made to suffer for the official wrangles as the funds allotted by the Department
of Disaster Management, Relief, Rehabilitation and Reconstruction of
Government of Jammu and Kashmir, having been released funds in favour of
the Divisional Commissioners and the Deputy Commissioners, the same amount
has not been released despite reminders by the Public Works Department to
release the claims of the petitioner; and that the petitioner had been suffering for
the last more than 11 years for non receipt of the amount that was due to him
and prayed that the respondents be directed to release the amount in favour of
the petitioner at the earliest along with interest @ 15 % per annum for
withholding the amount, for such a pretty long time.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondents, particularly, respondents No.2 to 5
who was executing agency under whose work orders the petitioner had carried
out the restoration work, argued that the petitioner had approached the Court
after a long time and as such, this petition suffers from delay and laches so as to
WP(C) No.69/2022
recover an amount within the period of limitation. It has been argued that the
Public Works Department could not release the funds as funds were not placed
at their disposal by the Disaster Management Authority, under whose direction,
the work had been carried out and that as and when the funds are released by the
Disaster Management Authority, the same shall be released to satisfy the claims
of the petitioner.
9.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after consideration of the
matter, it comes out that the petitioner as a contractor had carried out the allotted
restoration work; and that he was made some part payment by the Executing
Department, except an amount of ₹25.20 lakhs is pending liability towards the
works of restoration of Sidhra-Surinsar-Mansar road km 6 to km 19 with
approach road to Surinsar Lake, damaged due to heavy rains/flash floods during
September, 2014 as per the communication No. 15240-44 dated 17.02.2020
addressed by Executive Engineer PWD(R&B) Construction Division-II, Jammu
to the concerned Superintending Engineer, Jammu Kathua Circle. This
communication has given a liability statement showing that an amount of ₹25.20
lakhs is payable to the petitioner-contractor, Kirpal Singh under SDRF.
10.
The contention of learned counsel for the Public Works Department that
the petitioner cannot maintain this petition as the same suffers from delay and
laches is simply not sustainable for the reason that the claim of the petitioner is a
recurring cause of action, in view of the communication made by the Public
Works Department to the Disaster Management Authority for releasing of the
funds in favour of the PWD so as to meet the pending liability to the contractors
including the petitioner. This Court understands that sometimes the release of
payments can be delayed or deferred for lack of funds, however, it is a serious
WP(C) No.69/2022
matter that the admitted claim of the petitioner, even after the communication
dated 17.02.2020 has not been attended to and the petitioner has been suffering
for non-payment of his claim for more than a decade, having completed the
allotted work in the year 2015.
Since an amount of ₹ 25.20 lakhs is an admitted claim of the petitioner as
11.
per the correspondence of the respondents-PWD, thus, in the considered opinion
of the Court, the petitioner has made out a case for grant of this petition, for
release of his admitted claim.
12.
Viewed thus, this petition is allowed with the following directions, to the
respondents:I.
The respondent No.6-District Development Commissioner, Jammu
who is also a Disaster Management Authority for Jammu District is
directed to release the funds to the tune of ₹ 25.20 lacs from SDRF at
his disposal in favour of respondent No.5-Executive Engineer,
PWD(R&B), Construction Division-II, Jammu within a period of four
weeks from this date.
II.
The respondent No.5- Executive Engineer, PWD(R&B), Construction
Division-II, Jammu is further directed that, in the event of release of
funds by the respondent No.6 in his favour, the payment shall be made
to the petitioner within a period of four weeks, on fulfilling the codal
formalities.
III.
If the admitted claim of the petitioner is not made within the aforesaid
period of eight weeks, he shall be entitled to recover the same along
WP(C) No.69/2022
with simple interest @ 10 % per annum, from the date of completion
of the work, till its realization.
13.
The petition stands disposed of along with connected application(s) on
the above terms.
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
JAMMU
08.04.2026
Surinder
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
WP(C) No.69/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review