Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:24531
NAFR
Digitally
signed by
YOGESH
YOGESH TIWARI
TIWARI Date:
2026.06.18
18:26:08
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Order Reserved on : 24.04.2026
Order Delivered on : 18.06.2026
WPC No. 6422 of 2024
Kiran Meshram W/o Avindra Meshram, Aged About 52 Years, Caste
Mahar, R/o Ward No. 09 Sanjay Nagar Dongargarh, Tahsil- Dongargarh
District- Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, Department Of Tribal
Welfare, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nawa Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
- The
Sub
Divisional
Officer
(Revenue)
Dongargarh, Tah,
Dongargarh, District- Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Love Kumar Ramteke, Advocate
For Respondents/State :
Mr. Abhishek Gupta, Panel Lawyer
Hon'ble Shri Amitendra Kishore Prasad, Judge
CAV Order
1.
The petitioner has filed the present petition challenging the
inaction of the competent authority in not issuing a permanent
social
status
certificate,
as
well
as
assailing
the
communication/order dated 16.08.2024 (Annexure-P/1), whereby
the petitioner’s claim has not been duly considered and granted.
The petitioner has payed for following relief(s):“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call the entire records from the
respondents.
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly issue
a writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondent authority to issue Permanent Social
Status Certificate (Caste Certificate).
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may issue a writ
in the nature of mandamus to the respondent
no.2, who has not issuing Permanent Social
Status Certificate till date only to harass the
petitioner. Therefore, order to take action
against respondent no.2 should be passed.”
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner belongs to the
Scheduled Caste “Mahar” and seeks issuance of a permanent
social status/caste certificate in order to avail the benefits
admissible under the law in the State of Chhattisgarh. In this
regard, the petitioner submitted an online application bearing No.
0704011912013679 on 14.11.2019 before the competent authority
i.e., the S.D.O. (Revenue), Dongargarh, District Rajnandgaon,
along with relevant documents, affidavit, and Inability Memo.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that despite submission of complete
documents, the competent authority repeatedly directed the
petitioner to appear with original records and ultimately refused to
issue the caste certificate. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner
approached this Court in W.P.(C) No. 168/2020, wherein
directions were issued for consideration of the application in
accordance with law. However, the application was rejected vide
order dated 10.08.2020.
4.
Thereafter, in W.P.(C) No. 2102/2020, this Court again issued
necessary directions. The petitioner further preferred an appeal
under Section 5 of the Chhattisgarh Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes (Regulation of
Social Status Certification) Act, 2013 (for short, ‘Act, 2013’), which
was partly allowed on 26.07.2021. However, the competent
authority failed to comply with the appellate order and reiterated
its earlier stand vide order dated 12.08.2022.
5.
Subsequently, in W.P.(C) No. 1812/2023, this Court directed the
petitioner to avail statutory remedy, pursuant to which the
petitioner again preferred appeal dated 19.05.2023, which was
rejected on 09.02.2024. In W.P.(C) No. 2006/2024, this Court
quashed the orders dated 09.02.2024 and 12.08.2022 and
remanded the matter for fresh consideration.
6.
Despite remand, the S.D.O. (Revenue), Dongargarh again sought
documents stating non-availability of online records, issued a
temporary social status certificate, and thereafter ultimately
refused to issue the caste certificate on the ground of lack of
jurisdiction vide impugned communication/order dated 16.08.2024
(Annexure-P/1), which is under challenge in the present petition.
7.
Mr. Love Kumar Ramteke, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, submits that the petitioner has been compelled to run
from pillar to post since the year 2019 for issuance of a
Permanent Social Status Certificate recognizing her Scheduled
Caste “Mahar” status, despite being fully eligible and having
submitted all requisite documents along with the online application
bearing No. 0704011912013679 dated 14.11.2019 before the
competent authority i.e., S.D.O. (Revenue), Dongargarh, District
Rajnandgaon. It is submitted that along with the application, the
petitioner furnished all relevant supporting documents, including
affidavit and Inability Memo in terms of Rule 6 of the Chhattisgarh
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward
Classes (Regulation of Social Status Certification) Rules, 2013
(for short, ‘Rules, 2013’). However, instead of deciding the
application in accordance with law, the authorities repeatedly
issued directions requiring production of original records, which
the petitioner duly complied with.
8.
It is further submitted that despite clear directions issued by this \\
Court in W.P.(C) No. 168/2020 vide order dated 16.01.2020, the
petitioner’s application was arbitrarily rejected on 10.08.2020 on
the vague ground that caste certificate cannot be issued.
Thereafter, in W.P.(C) No. 2102/2020, this Court again intervened
in the matter. Subsequently, even the appellate proceedings
under Section 5 of the Act, 2013 culminated in partial relief in
favour of the petitioner on 26.07.2021. However, it is contended
that the competent authority failed to comply with the appellate
order and instead reiterated its earlier rejected view vide order
dated 12.08.2022. When the matter was again carried before this
Court in W.P.(C) No. 1812/2023, the petitioner was relegated to
statutory remedy, and accordingly, fresh appeal was preferred,
which was rejected on 09.02.2024. Thereafter, in W.P.(C) No.
2006/2024, this Court quashed the orders dated 09.02.2024 and
12.08.2022 and remanded the matter for fresh consideration in
accordance with law.
9.
Learned counsel submits that even after remand, the S.D.O.
(Revenue), Dongargarh again sought production of documents on
the ground that online records were not available, and though a
provisional certificate was issued on 24.07.2024 by the Nayab
Tehsildar, the final decision was once again adverse to the
petitioner. Ultimately, by the impugned communication dated
16.08.2024 (Annexure-P/1), the application has been rejected on
the purported ground of lack of jurisdiction and inability of the
petitioner to produce documents prior to 1950 showing ancestral
residence within the territorial jurisdiction of Dongargarh. It is
strongly contended that the rejection on such ground is ex facie
illegal, arbitrary and contrary to the statutory scheme. Learned
counsel submits that there is no legal requirement mandating
production of pre-1950 documents for issuance of caste
certificate,
particularly
when
sufficient
contemporaneous
documents, including school records, transfer certificates, family
tree, and earlier caste certificate dated 01.09.1993, clearly
establish the petitioner’s caste status. It is further submitted that
the petitioner’s father has been shown to be a resident of the
region and has educational records indicating admission and
study in institutions during 1952–1953, which further corroborate
the family’s social status. Therefore, the insistence on pre-1950
records is wholly misconceived and dehors the Rules, 2013.
10. Attention is also drawn to Rule 5 of the Rules, 2013, which
mandates that deficiencies, if any, must be pointed out within
seven days of receipt of application. However, in the present
case, the issue of jurisdiction has been raised after nearly five
years, which renders the entire process arbitrary, unjust and
violative of statutory mandate. It is further submitted that the
S.D.O. (Revenue) is the competent authority as per the relevant
circular dated 24.09.2013, and therefore, the plea of lack of
jurisdiction is wholly unsustainable in law. The belated objection
regarding territorial jurisdiction is only an afterthought to defeat
the petitioner’s rightful claim. He also submits that it is well settled
that once a competent authority issues or processes a caste
certificate, the same cannot be invalidated merely on technical or
territorial objections, and the scope of inquiry under the Act is
limited only to verification of genuineness and prevention of fraud,
not repeated harassment of genuine applicants.
11.
In view of the above, it is submitted that the petitioner is fully
eligible for issuance of a Permanent Social Status Certificate
(Caste Certificate) and has been unnecessarily subjected to
prolonged litigation and administrative harassment since 2019.
Accordingly, it is prayed that this Court may be pleased to issue
an appropriate writ, particularly in the nature of mandamus,
directing the respondent authorities to issue the Permanent Social
Status Certificate to the petitioner forthwith in accordance with
law.
12. On the other hand, Mr. Abhishek Gupta, learned Panel Lawyer
appearing for the State/respondents, at the outset opposes the
submissions advanced by learned counsel for the petitioner and
submits that the present writ petition is wholly misconceived,
devoid of merit, and is liable to be dismissed at the threshold
itself. It is submitted that the petitioner has approached this Court
without disclosing complete and correct facts and is seeking
issuance of a writ of mandamus in disregard of the statutory
scheme governing issuance of social status certificates under the
Act, 2013 and the Rules framed thereunder.
13. It is further submitted that the issuance of social status certificate
is strictly governed by the statutory framework, wherein Section 4
of the Act, 2013 provides the procedure for issuance of caste
certificate, while Section 14 casts the burden upon the applicant
to establish and prove his entitlement to claim such certificate.
The Rules, 2013, particularly Rule 3, clearly prescribe the
mandatory documents required to be submitted by the applicant,
which include proof of caste status, affidavit, family tree, and
crucially, documentary evidence establishing ancestral residence
within the territorial jurisdiction of the State prior to the prescribed
cut-off date. It is submitted that compliance with these statutory
requirements is sine qua non, and in their absence, no
enforceable right accrues in favour of the petitioner.
14. Reliance has also been placed by the learned Panel Lawyer for
the State/respondents on the statutory scheme governing
issuance of social status certificates under the Rules, 2013,
particularly Rule 3, which mandates submission of complete and
verifiable documents, and is exhaustive in nature. It is further
submitted that Rule 6 relating to Inability Memo does not dilute the
burden of proof cast upon the applicant, but only provides a
limited procedural relaxation in cases where documents are not
available despite due diligence. Even in such cases, the
competent authority is required to conduct a proper inquiry under
Rule 8, and the ultimate burden of establishing the claim of social
status continues to remain squarely upon the applicant.
15. Reliance is further placed on the settled principle of law laid down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Director of Tribal Welfare,
Government of Andhra Pradesh v. Laveti Giri (1995) 4 SCC
32, wherein it has been categorically held that the burden of proof
as to social status always lies upon the person claiming such
status for availing constitutional benefits, and such claim must be
strictly established through cogent and reliable documentary
evidence. It is submitted that in absence of the mandatory
documents prescribed under Rule 3, particularly those relating to
ancestral caste and residence prior to the relevant cut-off date, no
caste certificate can be issued as a matter of right, as any
relaxation would defeat the very object of the legislation. It is
further submitted that the impugned action of the competent
authority is strictly in accordance with law and based on proper
appreciation of statutory requirements. The petitioner has failed to
demonstrate any violation of statutory provisions, arbitrariness, or
illegality warranting interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. Accordingly, it is submitted that the present
writ petition, being devoid of merit and substance, deserves to be
dismissed.
16. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused
the documents annexed with the writ petition.
17. From perusal of the impugned order dated 16.08.2024, it appears
that the application of the petitioner seeking issuance of
permanent social status certificate (Mahar caste, Scheduled
Caste category) has been rejected by the Office of the SubDivisional
Officer
(R.),
Dongargarh,
District
Rajnandgaon
(Chhattisgarh), on the ground of non-compliance of the
requirements under the Rules, 2013.
18. It is reflected from the order that though the petitioner submitted
certain documents including school records of her father showing
his study at Shaheed Smarak Primary School, Raipur during the
period 20.06.1952 to 03.02.1953 along with Transfer Certificate
dated 04.02.1953, however, no documentary evidence was
produced to establish that the petitioner’s ancestors were residing
within the territorial jurisdiction of Dongargarh Tehsil prior to the
cut-off date of 1950, as mandated under the Rules, 2013.
19. It is further recorded that the competent authority, upon scrutiny of
the documents submitted, found that the records rather indicated
residence and schooling of the petitioner’s father outside
Dongargarh Tehsil prior to 1950. It has also been observed that
issuance of caste certificate under the Scheduled Caste category
can be made only by the competent authority having jurisdiction
over the ancestral residence prior to the Presidential notification
dated 10.08.1950, and in absence of such foundational proof, the
claim of the petitioner cannot be entertained.
20. Accordingly, it has been concluded that since the petitioner failed
to establish ancestral residence within the jurisdiction of
Dongargarh Tehsil prior to the relevant cut-off date, issuance of
permanent social status certificate would be contrary to the
statutory provisions of the Rules, 2013. On this basis, the
application of the petitioner has been rejected vide order dated
16.08.2024.
21. At this stage, it is apposite to refer to the statutory scheme
governing issuance of social status certificates under the
Chhattisgarh Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other
Backward Classes (Regulation of Social Status Certification) Act,
2013, and the Rules framed thereunder, namely the Chhattisgarh
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward
Classes (Regulation of Social Status Certification) Rules, 2013.
22. In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 9 of the Act,
2013, the Rules, 2013 have been enacted. Chapter II thereof
specifically deals with issuance of social status certificates. Rule 3
of the Rules, 2013 lays down the procedure for submission and
consideration of application for issuance of certificate on
permanent basis. The said Rule 3 of Rules, 2013 reads as follows
for easy reference :“3. Application for issuance of Certificate.(1) The applicant in order to obtain Certificate
on permanent basis, shall submit an application
to the Competent Authority in FORM-1A.
(2) Applicant shall submit his application to the
Competent Authority in person or through post
or Choice Centre or a Common Service Centre.
(3) Applicant shall submit along with application
following documents, namely :-
“(a) An Affidavit in FORM-2A, in original;
(b) Family tree of the applicant starting from
last three generations, duly issued by the
Halka Patwari;
(c) Document or self-attested copy of the
document verifying that his ancestors were
residing in the geographical limits of the
State of Chhattisgarh on or before the date of
Presidential Notification or the relevant cutoff date;(d) In cases where applicant is an
officer/employee allocated to Chhattisgarh
State Cadre or their children, in com
compliance,
of
Section
of
Madhya
Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2000 (No. 28 of
2000), principles laid down in Para (1) and
(2) of the Notification dated 23-9-2007 of
State Reorganization Cell. Such document or
duly attested copies of documents, verifying
that(i) ancestors of the applicant were residing
in the geographical limits of the then State
of Madhya Pradesh before or on the Date
of Presidential Notification or Notification
Date relating to Other Backward Classes,
as the case may be;
(ii) they have been allotted to Chhattisgarh
State Cadre under Section 67 of the
Madhya Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2000
(No. 28 of 2000).
(e). Any of the following document or self
attested
copy
showing
caste
of
the
applicant's father or ancestor, namely :(I) Revenue document of ancestors (case,
file);
(II) Jama-Bandi (Survey) or Girdawari;
(III) State Settlement;
(IV) Document of Rights (1954);
(V) Census (1931);
(VI) Survey of Forest Department;
(VII) National Register of Citizens (1949);
(VIII) Register of Birth or Death;
(IX) Admission Register (Dakhil/Kharij), in
case father or ancestors were literate;
(X) Caste Certificate, issued earlier to
Father, Ancestor or a relative;
(XI) Resolution passed by the GramSabha regarding caste of the applicant
where no documentary evidence in proof
of caste is available;
(f) Income certificate of preceding year of
applicant's father in case of Other Backward
Class Applicant;
(g) Envelope having appropriate postage
stamp and legible address.
(4)
The
applicant
shall
submit
original
certificates and documents, at the time of
verification or whenever required, before the
Competent Authority. District level Certificate
Verification Committee or Scrutiny Committee,
as the case may be.”
23. From perusal of the aforesaid Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013, it is quite
clear that issuance of a Permanent Social Status Certificate is not
an automatic or routine exercise, but is a strictly regulated
statutory process, contingent upon the applicant satisfying the
mandatory requirements prescribed therein. The Rule, in clear
and unambiguous terms, casts an obligation upon the applicant to
submit a complete application in FORM-1A along with specific
foundational documents, which include, inter alia, an affidavit in
FORM-2A, family tree verified by the competent revenue
authority, and crucially, documentary proof establishing that the
ancestors of the applicant were residing within the geographical
limits of the State of Chhattisgarh on or before the relevant cut-off
date prescribed under the Presidential Notification.
24. A conjoint reading of Rule 3(3)(c) and Rule 3(3)(e) makes it further
evident that the legislature has consciously insisted upon
production of historical and contemporaneous records such as
revenue records, settlement records, census of 1931, birth or
death registers, admission registers, earlier caste certificates, and
other public documents of unimpeachable authenticity, so as to
ensure that the claim of social status is not founded on mere
assertion but is duly substantiated by credible documentary
evidence tracing the origin of caste status and ancestral
residence. The scheme of the Rule thus clearly demonstrates that
the requirement of proving ancestral linkage prior to the cut-off
date is not merely procedural but goes to the root of eligibility for
issuance of such certificate.
25. Rule 3(4) further reinforces this position by mandating production
of original documents at the stage of verification before the
competent
authority
or
the
Scrutiny
Committee,
thereby
emphasizing the seriousness and evidentiary rigor attached to the
process. The statutory framework, therefore, leaves no manner of
doubt that the burden squarely lies upon the applicant to
establish, through cogent and verifiable material, the foundational
facts necessary for recognition of social status under the Act of
2013.
26. Viewed in this light, it becomes manifest that compliance with
Rule 3 is a condition precedent for consideration and grant of a
permanent social status certificate, and in absence of satisfaction
of these statutory requirements, no indefeasible right accrues in
favour of the applicant.
27. Rule 6 of the Rules, 2013 provides for submission of an “Inability
Memo” in cases where, despite due diligence, the applicant is
unable to procure the documents prescribed under Rule 3(3). In
such circumstances, the applicant may furnish an affidavit in the
prescribed Form-3C, explaining the reasons for non-availability of
documents, upon which the competent authority is required to
proceed with the inquiry under Rule 8. However, the said
provision does not dilute or absolve the applicant from the
substantive burden of establishing his claim of social status in
accordance with law. Rule 6 of the Rules, 2013 reads as under:“6. Inability Memo.—(1) An applicant belonging
to Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes, who
has applied for obtaining certificate, in spite of
adequate efforts could not get the required
document under sub-rule (3) of Rule 3, may
give an affidavit about his inability to submit
such document in prescribed Form-3C, printed
on the back of Return Memo.
(2) On receipt of Inability Memo, the competent
authority shall not demand for the required
document or documents under sub-rule (3) of
Rule 3 and shall proceed to inquire the claim of
the applicant under Rule 8:
Provided that the applicant shall present
himself
during
such
inquiry
before
the
competent authority or before the inquiry officer
and shall extend full cooperation to prove his
claim of social status.”
28. A careful reading of Rule 6 makes it manifest that the provision
does not dispense with the burden of proof cast upon the
applicant. It only provides a limited procedural relaxation in cases
where, despite due diligence, certain documents under Rule 3
cannot be procured. Even in such cases, the statutory mandate
requires the competent authority to conduct a detailed inquiry
under Rule 8, during which the applicant is required to
substantiate his claim by participating in the inquiry and extending
full cooperation. Thus, Rule 6 read with Section 14 of the Act,
2013 makes it abundantly clear that the burden of establishing
social status is squarely upon the applicant seeking such
certificate, and the filing of an Inability Memo does not, in any
manner, absolve the applicant from discharging the said burden.
The statutory framework, therefore, maintains a clear distinction
between procedural relaxation and substantive proof, and the
latter continues to remain an essential precondition for issuance
of a permanent social status certificate.
29. From perusal of the statutory scheme, it is evident that issuance
of social status certificate is strictly governed by the Act, 2013 and
the Rules framed thereunder. Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013 mandates
the applicant to furnish specific and foundational documents, inter
alia, affidavit in Form-2A, family tree issued by the Halka Patwari,
and crucially, documentary proof establishing that the ancestors of
the applicant were residing within the territorial limits of the State
of Chhattisgarh prior to the relevant cut-off date. The requirement
of such documents is not directory but mandatory in nature,
forming the very basis for determination of social status.
30. It further appears that Rule 6 of the Rules, 2013 provides for an
“Inability Memo”, which enables an applicant, who despite due
diligence is unable to procure certain documents prescribed under
Rule 3, to submit an affidavit explaining such inability. However,
the said provision does not, in any manner, dilute the substantive
burden cast upon the applicant to prove his social status. Even in
such cases, the competent authority is required to conduct an
inquiry under Rule 8, during which the applicant must fully
cooperate and establish his claim by cogent material. Thus, Rule
6 only provides a procedural relaxation and not a substantive
exemption from proof.
31. It is further relevant to note that Section 14 of the Act, 2013 places
the burden of proof squarely upon the person claiming the benefit
of social status certificate, thereby reinforcing the settled legal
principle that such constitutional benefit must be strictly
established by the claimant through reliable and verifiable
documentary evidence. In the absence of such foundational proof,
particularly with regard to ancestral residence prior to the cut-off
date, the competent authority is under no obligation to issue the
certificate.
32. From perusal of the record in the present case, it appears that the
principal and sole ground on which the petitioner’s claim has been
rejected is the failure to produce any documentary evidence
establishing that the petitioner’s ancestors were residing within
the territorial jurisdiction of the State of Chhattisgarh, particularly
Dongargarh Tehsil, prior to the year 1950, which is the relevant
cut-off period prescribed under the statutory framework. The
impugned order records that the documents produced, including
school records pertaining to the petitioner’s father for the period
1952–1953, only establish subsequent residence outside the
concerned jurisdiction and do not satisfy the foundational
requirement under Rule 3 of Rules, 2013.
33. It is also the case of the respondents that in absence of any pre1950 documentary proof indicating ancestral residence within the
territorial limits of the State, the claim of the petitioner cannot be
verified in accordance with the statutory mandate. The competent
authority, therefore, has proceeded to reject the application on the
ground of non-fulfilment of mandatory requirements under the
Rules, 2013.
34. However, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that certain
additional documents, including a document issued by the Union
of India dated 10.06.1924 and other supporting records, were
placed before the authority, which have not been properly
appreciated. It is further contended that reliance placed by the
authority on the absence of pre-1950 documents is hypertechnical, particularly when contemporaneous and secondary
evidence sufficiently establishes the caste status of the
petitioner’s family lineage.
35. Having considered the rival submissions advanced at the Bar and
upon careful perusal of the entire material available on record,
including the pleadings of the parties, the documents annexed
with the writ petition, and the impugned order dated 16.08.2024
(Annexure-P/1), this Court finds that the core issue arising for
consideration is whether the petitioner is entitled, in law, to
issuance of a Permanent Social Status Certificate (Scheduled
Caste – “Mahar”) in the facts and circumstances of the present
case, and whether the rejection of the petitioner’s claim suffers
from
any
perversity,
illegality
or
arbitrariness
warranting
interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
36. It is not in dispute that the petitioner has been prosecuting her
claim since the year 2019 for issuance of caste certificate and has
approached this Court on multiple occasions. It is also evident
that despite repeated rounds of litigation, including earlier writ
petitions wherein directions were issued for reconsideration of her
claim, the competent authority has consistently examined the
matter within the framework of the Act, 2013 and the Rules
framed thereunder. The record further reveals that even after
remand by this Court in W.P.(C) No. 2006/2024, the authority has
reconsidered the matter and passed the impugned order dated
16.08.2024, rejecting the claim principally on the ground of noncompliance of Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013 and failure to establish
ancestral residence prior to the relevant cut-off date within the
jurisdictional limits.
37. The statutory scheme under the Act, 2013, particularly Section 4
read with Section 14, clearly places the burden upon the applicant
to establish his/her claim of social status by producing cogent
documentary evidence. Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013 is exhaustive in
nature and mandates submission of specific foundational
documents, including proof of caste, family genealogy, affidavit,
and
most
importantly,
documentary
evidence
establishing
ancestral residence within the State prior to the relevant cut-off
date prescribed under law. The requirement is not procedural in
nature but goes to the root of entitlement itself.
38. Rule 6 of the Rules, 2013, which provides for submission of
“Inability Memo”, only relaxes the requirement of producing
certain documents where the applicant, despite due diligence, is
unable to procure them. However, even in such cases, the
statutory obligation of the competent authority to conduct an
inquiry under Rule 8 remains intact, and the ultimate burden of
establishing the claim does not shift from the applicant.
39. This legal position has been consistently recognized by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Laveti Giri (supra), wherein it has
been held that the burden of proof of social status is entirely upon
the claimant and must be discharged through reliable and
unimpeachable evidence. Further, in Kumari Madhuri Patil v.
Additional Commissioner, Tribal Development, (1994) 6 SCC
241, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the
process of issuance of caste certificates is a sensitive exercise
requiring strict scrutiny, and the authorities are duty-bound to
ensure that the constitutional benefits meant for reserved
categories
are
not
misused
on
the
basis
of
false
or
unsubstantiated claims.
40. In the present case, the consistent finding recorded by the
competent authority is that the petitioner has failed to produce any
contemporaneous or historical document establishing that her
ancestors were residing within the territorial jurisdiction of
Dongargarh or within the State of Chhattisgarh prior to the cut-off
date of 1950. On the contrary, the material placed on record
indicates that the petitioner’s father’s educational records reflect
his residence and schooling outside the claimed jurisdiction during
the relevant period. In absence of foundational evidence satisfying
Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013, the authority has concluded that the
claim of the petitioner cannot be accepted.
41. The argument advanced on behalf of the petitioner that insistence
upon pre-1950 documents is arbitrary cannot be accepted in view
of the clear statutory mandate under Section 14 of the Act, 2013
and Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013. The requirement of establishing
ancestral linkage prior to the cut-off date is intrinsic to the
determination of social status and cannot be diluted by invoking
equity or hardship. It is trite law that where the statute prescribes
a particular manner of doing an act, the same must be done in
that manner alone and not otherwise.
42. It is further significant to note that the impugned order dated
16.08.2024 has been passed after due consideration of earlier
judicial directions as well as the documents submitted by the
petitioner. The authority has not acted mechanically but has
recorded categorical findings regarding non-satisfaction of
statutory requirements. No material has been placed before this
Court to demonstrate that such findings are perverse, based on
no evidence, or contrary to the statutory provisions.
43. The scope of interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India in matters relating to caste certification is extremely limited.
Unless the decision-making process is shown to be vitiated by
arbitrariness, mala fides or violation of statutory provisions, this
Court would not sit in appeal over the factual findings recorded by
the competent authority.
44. Applying the aforesaid settled principles to the facts of the present
case, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner has
failed to demonstrate any illegality or procedural irregularity in the
impugned order dated 16.08.2024. The competent authority has
acted strictly in accordance with the Act, 2013 and the Rules
framed thereunder. The repeated failure of the petitioner to
produce the mandatory foundational documents as required under
Rule 3 of the Rules, 2013 disentitles her from the relief sought.
45. In view of the foregoing analysis, and considering the statutory
scheme, the consistent findings of the competent authority, and
the settled position of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, this Court does not find any ground to interfere with the
impugned order dated 16.08.2024 (Annexure-P/1). The writ
petition, being devoid of merit, is accordingly dismissed.
46. There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Yogesh
The date when the
The date when the
The date when the judgment is
judgment is
judgment is
uploaded on the website
reserved
pronounced
24.04.2026
18.06.2026
Operative
Full
------
18.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review