Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 28th November, 2022
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Petitioners
:
Kiran Chettri and Others
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Rachhitta Rai,
Advocate for the Petitioners.
Dr. (Mrs.) Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General with Mr.
S. K. Chettri, Government Advocate and Mr. Shakil Raj Karki,
Assistant Government Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Advocate and Mr. Dewen Sharma Luitel
Advocate for the Respondent Nos.4, 5, 11, 12, 14, 16, 18, 19, 21,
26, 28, 29, 36, 37, 40, 43, 46, 51, 54, 57, 59, 61, 66, 72, 73, 77,
78, 79 and 80.
None present for Respondent Nos. R-6, R-7, R-8, R-9, R-10, R-13,
R-15, R-17, R-20, R-22, R-23, R-24, R-25, R-27, R-30, R-31, R32, R-33, R-34, R-35, R-38, R-39, R-41, R-42, R-44, R-45, R-47,
R-48, R-49, R-50, R-52, R-53, R-55, R-56, R-58, R-60, R-62, R63, R-64, R-65, R-67, R-68, R-69, R-70, R-71, R-74, R-75 and R76.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners were appointed in the Indian Reserve
Battalion (hereinafter, the “IRB”) as Constables, on 01-03-1996
and promoted variously, to the ranks of Lance Naik, Naik and Head
Constables as per seniority and available vacancies in IRB Units.
That, in the year 2019, they were in service for approximately
twenty-three years.
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
2(i).
Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner submits that,
the only prayer in the Petition that is being pressed today is a part
of prayer (iv) i.e., preparation and publication of an amalgamated
Seniority list of the four forces, the second part of the prayer
pertaining to the protection of the seniority of the Petitioners at the
level of Head Constables is not being urged presently.
The prayer is as follows;
“Under the above facts and circumstance, it is,
therefore prayed that this Hon’ble Court may be
pleased to admit this petition, call for the records and
issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why a writ of mandamus/Certiorai and
appropriate writ/order or direction may not be issued
commanding and directing the Respondent authorities
to; show cause as to why:─
i)
.................................................................
ii)
.................................................................
iii) .................................................................
iv) An amalgamated seniority list of the Four Forces
by duly protecting the seniority of the petitioners
at the level of Head Constables shall not be
prepared and published.”
[emphasis supplied]
(ii)
That, in terms of the prayer, the State Respondent
Nos.1 to 3 be directed to prepare an amalgamated Seniority List of
the four Police Forces of the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment,
Promotion and Seniority) Rules, 2000.
That, the Petitioners be
granted liberty to approach the Court, if so advised, should they be
aggrieved by the Seniority List prepared by the State-Respondents
No.1 to 3.
Attention of this Court was invited to the Order of this
Court dated 27-06-2022, wherein the State-Respondent Nos. 1 to
3 had submitted that no amalgamated Seniority List was prepared
by the State-Respondent Nos.1 to 3 and therefore they have no
such List to file.
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(iii)
Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners urged that a
common Seniority List is essential for the Petitioners, to gauge
their position in the overall seniority ranking of the amalgamated
four
services,
for
which
strength
was
garnered
from
the
observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Sikkim and
Others vs. Adup Tshering Bhutia and Others1, wherein it was inter alia
observed as follows;
“2. The State is bound to ensure a fair and
equitable
treatment
to
officers
in
various
categories/cadres of services while preparing the
common seniority list. ...............”
That, this observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court be
adhered to by the State-Respondent Nos.1 to 3.
3.
Learned Additional Advocate General for the State-
Respondent Nos.1 to 3 while walking this Court through the
circumstances which led to the instant Writ Petition, advanced the
submission that the inter se Seniority List in terms of the
Notification bearing No.73/GEN/DOP, dated 09-08-2018, issued by
the Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms, Training and
Public Grievances, Gangtok, Government of Sikkim, shall be
prepared, for which three months time may be afforded.
4.
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Learned Counsel for the Private
Respondents endorsed the submissions put forth by the Learned
Additional Advocate General and had no independent submissions
to advance.
5(i).
To appreciate the matter in its correct perspective the
crux of the dispute is being narrated.
Prior to the constitution of
the integrated Sikkim Police Force with effect from 11-09-2000 as
per the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and Seniority)
(2014) 12 SCC 507
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Rules, 2000, there were three different Police Services (1) Sikkim
Police Force, (2) Sikkim Armed Police and (3) Sikkim Vigilance
Police governed by separate Service Rules.
A short history to the
constitution of the integrated Police Force with effect from 11-092000 as per the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and
Seniority) Rules, 2000, has been detailed in State of Sikkim and
Others vs. Adup Tshering Bhutia and Others (supra) which to prevent
prolixity are not being reiterated herein.
(ii)
The Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and
Seniority) Rules, 2000, was amended vide Notification of the
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms, Training, Public
Grievances, Career Options and Employment Skill Development
and Chief Minister’s Self Employment Scheme, Government of
Sikkim bearing No.222/GEN/DOP, dated 20-01-2010, wherein the
amendment inserted was as follows;
“SIKKIM
GOVERNMENT
GAZETTE
EXTRAORDINARY
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
Gangtok
Friday 12th February, 2010
No. 35
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
DEPTT. OF PERSONNEL, ADM. REFORMS, TRAINING,
PULIC
GRIEVANCES,
CAREER
OPTIONS
&
EMPLOYMENT
SKILL DEVELOPMENT AND CHIEF
MINISTER’S SELF EMPLOYMENT SCHEME
GANGTOK
No.222/GEN/DOP
Date: 20.1.2010
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by the
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the
Governor of Sikkim hereby makes the following rules
to amend the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment,
Promotion and Seniority) Rules, 2000, namely:
1.
(1)
These rules may be called the Sikkim
Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and
Seniority) Amendment Rules, 2009.
(2)
They shall be deemed to have come into
force on the 11th day of September,
2000.
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
2.
In the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment,
Promotion and Seniority) Rules, 2000;
(hereinafter referred to as the said
rules), after sub-rule (iii) of rule 9, the
following shall be inserted, namely:“(iv)
(a) The inter-se-seniority of police
personnel up to the rank of Assistant
Sub-Inspector in the Sikkim Police and
Sikkim Vigilance Police on date of
amalgamation of the cadres for the
purpose of their promotion to the next
rank shall be determined on the basis of
their date of appointment to the entry
level post of Constable.
(b)
The inter-se-seniority of Police
Inspectors of Sikkim Police, Sikkim
Vigilance Police, Sikkim Armed Police and
Indian Reserve Battalion on the date of
amalgamation of the cadres for the
purpose of their promotion to the rank of
Deputy Superintendent of Police shall be
determined on the basis of their date of
appointment to the entry level of SubInspector.”
3.
In the said rules, in Schedule l, the existing
paragraph (b) under the Column 8, against the
post of Assistant Sub-Inspector and in Schedule
ll, the existing paragraph (b) under the column
the column 8, against the post of SubInspector and Inspector, shall be omitted.
4.
In the said rules, after rule 16, the following
shall be inserted, namely:“17. Power to relax: Where the Government of
Sikkim is of the opinion that it is necessary or
expedient to do so, it may, by order, for
reasons to be recorded in writing, relax any of
the provisions of these rules with respect to
any class or category of persons or post.”
BY ORDER.
JOINT SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT
DEPTT. OF PERSONNEL, ADM. REFORMS, TRAINING,
PULIC
GRIEVANCES, CAREER OPTIONS &
EMPLOYMENT SKILL DEVELOPMENT AND CHIEF
MINISTER’S SELF EMPLOYMENT SCHEME”
(ii)
Notification
Another amendment took place in the said Rules vide
of
the
Department
of
Personnel,
Administrative
Reforms, Training and Public Grievances, Government of Sikkim,
bearing No.73/GEN/DOP, dated 09-08-2018, wherein the following
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
amendment in Rule 9 of Sub-Rule (iv), after Clause (b), the
Clauses, i.e., (c) and (d) inserted;
“....................................................................
NOTIFICATION
......................................................................
Amendment
of
Schedule
2.
In the Sikkim Police Force
(Recruitment,
Promotion
and Seniority) Rules, 2000, in
rule 9, in sub-rule (iv), after
clause (b) the following clauses
shall be inserted, namely;“(c) The inter-se-seniority of all
the Head Constables of Sikkim
Police, Sikkim Vigilance Police,
Sikkim Armed Police and Indian
Reserve
Battalions
shall be
common for the purpose of their
promotion
to
the
rank
of
Assistant Sub-Inspector which
shall be determined on the basis
of their date of appointment to
the entry level post of Constable.
(d) Head Constables eligible for
promotion
to
the
rank
of
Assistant
Sub-Inspector,
on
promotion, shall be liable to be
posted to any branch of Sikkim
Police
where
the
vacancies
arise.”
......................................................................”
6(i).
It
is
the
Petitioners
case
that
pursuant
to
the
amalgamation of the four forces, a common inter se Seniority List
of the Police Personnel in the amalgamated service has not been
prepared till date.
Consequently, although the Petitioners have
been in service for more than twenty-three years, in the absence of
an inter se seniority list they are unable to gauge their seniority in
terms of the amalgamated service.
The State-Respondent Nos.1
to 3 have admitted, as reflected in the Order of this Court dated
27-06-2022, that amalgamated Seniority List has not been
prepared.
(ii)
Rule 9 of the Sikkim Police Force provides that
Seniority would be determined by order of merit in which they
WP(C) No.18 of 2019
Kiran Chettri and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
were selected for recruitment.
By the Notification dated 09-08-
2018 referred to supra in Rule 9 of Sub-Rule (iv), after Clause (b),
the Clauses, i.e., (c) and (d), were also inserted as already
extracted supra making provision for inter se seniority of ranks
detailed in the insertions.
7.
In light of the foregoing submissions and the limited
dispute supra projected today, the State-Respondent Nos.1 to 3
are hereby directed to prepare an amalgamated Seniority List of
the four Forces, i.e., (1) Sikkim Police, (2) Sikkim Vigilance Police,
(3) Sikkim Armed Police and (4) Indian Reserve Battalion, in terms
of the Notification bearing No.73/GEN/DOP, dated 09-08-2018.
It
is expected that the process will be completed within three months
from today.
8.
The Petitioners are at liberty to approach the Court if
aggrieved, and so advised.
9.
WP(C) No.18 of 2019 stands disposed of in terms of
the above directions.
10.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
28-11-2022
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review