Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.07.07 13:49:38 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022
Ref:- (i) El. Pet. No. 34 of 2022
Kimneo Haokip Hangshing, aged about 34 years, wife of David
Hangshing, resident of Saikul Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Saikul, District
Kangpokpi, Manipur, Pin-795118.
...Applicant/Respondent no. 1
-Versus1.
Kenn Raikhan, aged about 46 years, S/o Surrender
Raikhan, resident of
Mapao Khullen Village, P.O. & P.S.
Sekmai, Sub-Division Saikul, District Kangpokpi, Manipur,
PIN-795118.
... Respondent/ Election Petitioner
2.
Seikholal Haokip, aged about 46 years, S/o (Late)
Nengkholun Haokip,
resident of Ankhumbhung Village,
P.O. & P.S. Saikul, Saikul Sub-Division, Kangpokpi District,
Manipur, PIN-795118.
3.
Yamthong Haokip, aged about 59 years, S/o (Late)
Holkhothang Haokip, resident of Ekou Mulam, P.O. & P.S.
Saikul, District Kangpokpi, Manipur, PIN-795118.
4.
Lhingkim Haokip, aged about 50 years, resident of
Koirengei, P.S. Heingang P.O. Mantripukri, Imphal East
District Manipur, PIN-795002.
5.
Ch.
Ajang
Khongsai,
aged
about
years,
S/o
Lhunkhothang Khongsai, resident of Lhungjang Village,
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |2
P.O. & P.S. Saikul, Kangpokpi District, Manipur, PIN795118.
6.
Chungkhokai Doungel, aged about 81 years, S/o (Late)
Thangpao Doungel, resident of C. Aisan Village, B.P.O.
Moikon, P.O. & P.S. Saikul, District Kangpokpi, Manipur,
PIN-795118.
7.
Jamchinlen Lunkim, aged about 62 years, S/o Tongkhojang
Lunkim, resident of L. Molnom Village, Saikul Sub-Division,
P.O. Yairipok, P.S. Yairipok, Manipur-795148.
.... Proforma respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Applicant
::
Mr. A. Mohendro, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
Date of Judgment & Order
::
05.07.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This miscellaneous case has been filed by the
petitioner under Order 7, Rule 11(a) CPC read with Section 86(1)
of the Representation of People Act, 1951 to reject the election
petition.
2.
The election petition has been filed to declare that
the election of the petitioner from 46-Saikul Assembly
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |3
Constituency of 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly, 2022 as null
and void under Section 100(1)(d)(i)&(v) as well as under Section
100(1)(b) of the Representation of People Act and to declare that
the first respondent herein is the duly elected member in the 12th
Manipur Legislative Assembly, 2022 from 46-Saikul Assembly
Constituency.
3.
Resisting the election petition, the petitioner has
filed the written statement raising various grounds.
4.
Pending election petition, the petitioner has filed the
present miscellaneous case to dismiss the election petition on
the ground of non-disclosure of cause action and non-conformity
with the provisions of the Representation of People Act. The
petitioner also alleged that the election petition is ill-conceived
one and the same has been filed with unclean hands and,
therefore, the same is liable to be dismissed at the threshold.
5.
Resisting
the
miscellaneous
case,
the
first
respondent/election petitioner filed affidavit-in-opposition, inter
alia, stating that the issue of sufficiency of the pleadings and
evidences is to be determined only at the final hearing of the
election petition and no single pleading of the election petitioner
has been denied by the petitioner till date.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |4
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the first respondent failed to mention material facts which
would constitute the cause of action for filing the election petition
and, in fact, the first respondent has failed to mention the material
facts which if proved would amount to corrupt practice under
Section 123 of the Representation of People Act alleged to be
committed by the returned candidate.
In other words, the
allegations do not constitute ingredients of any corrupt practice
within the meaning of Section 123 of the Representation of
People Act and also do not amount to concealing of material
facts.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that the petitioner has not undertaken any development work in
the piece of land and had only undertaken construction after
completion of the election process which is evident from the
photographs produced thereby showing bamboos being erected
in order to support the new construction.
8.
The learned counsel further submitted that as per
the income tax return statement made available to the petitioner
by the Income tax Department for the financial year 2021-2022,
the total income of the petitioner is Rs.0/- and since the petitioner
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |5
is a member of Scheduled Tribe community, she is exempted
from income tax.
9.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner adopted the surname ‘Hangshing’ from her husband’s
name i.e. David Hangshing after the marriage and necessary
affidavit in this regard has also been sworn.
As such, the
allegation does not constitute the ingredients of any corrupt
practice within the meaning of Section 123 of the Representation
of People Act.
10.
The learned counsel next submitted that the
petitioner has already applied for deletion of her name from the
electoral roll of 51-Saitu (ST) Assembly Constituency long back
before election. Her name was still included in the electoral roll
of 51-Saitu (ST) Assembly Constituency, which is purely
dereliction of duty on the part of the concerned authority, for
which the petitioner cannot be blamed.
11.
The learned counsel then submitted that neither the
petitioner nor her husband has indulged in any form of
intimidation of voters as alleged by the first respondent. The
entire allegations in the election petition have been based upon
the unverified documents and had the first respondent/election
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |6
petitioner taken deep measures for ascertaining the actual facts,
there would be no ground for the election petition.
12.
The
learned
counsel
urged
that
the
first
respondent/election petitioner has not complied with the
provisions of Section 83(1)(a)&(b) of the Representation of
People Act and, as such, the election petition deserves to be
dismissed by application of Order 7, Rule 11 CPC for nondisclosure of cause of action, apart from approaching the Court
with unclean hands.
13.
In support of the submissions, the learned counsel
for the petitioner placed reliance upon the following decisions:
(i)
Ram Sukh v. Dinesh Aggarwal, (2009)
10 SCC 541;
(ii)
Mangani Lal Mandal v. Bishnu Deo
Bhandari, (2012) 3 SCC 314;
(iii)
Jaipal Singh v. Sumitra Mahajan and
another, (2004) 4 SCC 522;
(iv)
Ananga Uday Singh Deo v. Ranga Nath
Mishra and others, (2002) 1 SCC 499;
(v)
Ishwardas Rohani v. Alok Mishra and
others, (2012) 7 SCC 309;
(vi)
Punjab and Haryana High Court order
dated 26.9.2019 in Civil Miscellaneous
No.8 of 2018;
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |7
(vii)
Allahabad
High
Court
order
dated
12.9.2022 in Election Petition No.10 of
2017;
(viii)
Allahabad
High
Court
order
dated
29.7.1981 in Election Petition No.11 of
1980;
(ix)
Madras
High
Court
order
dated
17.3.2022 in O.A.No.764 of 2021 in
Election Petition No.8 of 2021.
14.
Refuting the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the learned counsel for the first
respondent/election petitioner argued that the election petition
has been filed in the context of gross misrepresentation and
concealment of facts, documents, assets and holdings by the
petitioner in filing her Form 26 affidavit for the election in
question. The actions and omissions of the petitioner as detailed
in the election petition are sufficient to constitute a case for
setting aside the election of the petitioner in terms of Section 100
of the Representation of People Act and being violative of
Section 33 and 33A of the Act read with Rule 4A of the Conduct
of Election Rules, 1961 as well as the instructions/notifications
issued by the Election Commission of India.
15.
The learned counsel for the first respondent further
submitted that the first respondent has taken various grounds in
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |8
the election petition and all the allegations are triable points and
without taking evidence, the election petition is not liable to be
dismissed and, as such, this Court may give an opportunity to
both parties for adducing evidence and the election petition
should be heard on merits.
16.
Adding further, the learned counsel for the first
respondent submitted that the main allegation made in the
election petition is dealing with improper acceptance of the
nomination of the petitioner and also non-compliance of the
statutory provisions.
The allegation qua the corrupt practice
under Section 123 of the Representation of People Act is related
with the concealment of material information in Form 26 affidavit
amounting to undue influence as defined in Section 123(2) of the
Act.
17.
The learned counsel for the first respondent urged
that the petitioner has failed to disclose her assets and her
correct name.
Further, the non-disclosure of movable and
immovable assets would constitute a corrupt practice falling
under the heading undue influence.
18.
The learned counsel submits that each and every
averment made in the election petition constitute the material
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
Page |9
facts and material particulars and these are the cause of action
for granting the reliefs to the election petitioner. All the pleadings
or averments should be read as a whole so as to examine
whether such pleadings/averments furnish the cause of action of
the election petition. In the present case, the cause of action has
been correctly spelt out in the election petition. Thus, a prayer
has been made to dismiss the miscellaneous case.
19.
To fortify his submissions, the learned counsel for
the first respondent/election petitioner placed reliance upon the
following decisions:
(i)
D.Ramachandran v. R.V. Janakiraman
and others, (1999) 3 SCC 267.
(ii)
Ashraf Kokkur v. Abdul Khader, (2015) 1
SCC 129.
(iii)
Madras
High
16.10.2020
in
Court
Original
order
dated
Application
Nos.140 and 141 of 2020.
20.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
21.
The first respondent/election petitioner filed the
election petition on the following grounds:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 10
(i)
False Form 26 affidavit has been filed by
the petitioner whereby concealing the
facts of the ongoing construction of
building
inside
the
agricultural
land
mentioned in her affidavit Form 26.
(ii)
The petitioner was serving as Committee
Officer, Assembly Secretariat, Manipur
Legislative Assembly and was retired on
31.12.2021 from her office. However, in
paragraph 4 of the affidavit Form 26 – the
total income for the financial year 20212022, the petitioner provided her total
income as Rs.0/-.
(iii)
The name of the petitioner given in the
affidavit Form 26 is quite different from the
electoral roll of 46-Saikul (ST) Assembly
Constituency.
(iv)
Para No.8 at Serial No.341 under EPIC
No.CRP0588178 as provided by the
petitioner in Form 26 affidavit, the said roll
number is listed in the name of the person
named as Kimneo Haokip and on the
other hand, the same person Kumneo
Haokip is also listed in another electoral
roll
of
51-Saitu
(ST)
Assembly
Constituency of part 11 at Sl.No.643
under EPIC No.KSW0104935.
As the
petitioner claimed herself as the person
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 11
listed at Sl. No.341 in the electoral roll of
part No.8 of 46-Saikul (ST) Assembly
Constituency, it is offense under the
provisions of the law enacted in the State
of Manipur and the Union of India for
having enrolled two voter IDs on different
EPIC Nos.
(v)
The husband of the petitioner is a leader
of an underground organization had used
arms and intimidated the innocent voters.
This constitutes to be a corrupt practice
and undue influence for obtaining more
votes in the election.
22.
The petitioner is the candidate sponsored by the
Kuki’s People Alliance and the first respondent is an independent
candidate.
23.
The petitioner has filed the present miscellaneous
case by raising the following plea:
(i)
The election petitioner failed to mention
material facts which would constitute the
cause of action for filing the election
petition.
(ii)
The allegations set out in the election
petition do not constitute the ingredients
of any corrupt practice within the meaning
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 12
of Section 123 of the Representation of
People Act.
(iii)
The allegations set out in the election
petition do not in any manner materially
affect the outcome of the election results.
(iv)
The petitioner had already applied for
cancellation/deletion of her name from the
electoral roll of 51-Saitu (ST) Assembly
Constituency
before
the
election
in
question and the fact remains that her
name was still including in the electoral
roll
of
51-Saitu
(ST)
Assembly
Constituency which is the total dereliction
of duty by the concerned authority and not
the petitioner.
24.
Highlighting the above plea, the learned counsel for
the petitioner contended that the election petition at the hands of
the first respondent was bereft of material facts and particulars
and was also defective for want of requisite affidavit in support of
allegations of corrupt practice. Since the election petition did not
disclose any cause of action, the same deserves to be dismissed
at the threshold.
25.
The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that the
election petition is liable to be dismissed in limine at the initial
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 13
stage, as it does not disclose any cause of action. He would
submit that the cause of action in questioning the validity of the
election must relate to the grounds specified in Section 100 of
the Representation of People Act.
In fact, the allegations
contained in the election petition do not set out grounds of
challenge as contemplated by Section 100 and since the
allegations do not conform to the requirement of Section 83 of
the Act, the election petition is liable to be rejected under Order
7, Rule 11 CPC, as the pleadings are vague and general.
26.
Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act,
1951 reads thus:
“83. Contents of Petition: (1) An election petition –
(a) shall contain a concise statement of material
facts on which the petitioner relies,
(b) shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt
practice that the petitioner alleges, including as
full a statement as possible of the names of the
parties alleged to have committed such corrupt
practice and the date and place of the commission
of each such practice; and
(c) shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in
the manner laid down in the Code of Civil
Procedure 1908 (5 of 1908) for the verification of
the pleadings.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 14
Provided that where the petitioner alleges any
corrupt practice, the petition shall also be
accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed
form in support of the allegation of such corrupt
practice and the particulars thereof.
(2) Any schedule of annexure to the petition shall
also be signed by the petitioner and verified in the
same manner as the petition. Without specific
pleading consent, cause of action in an election
petition, based on allegations of corrupt practice
is incomplete and the petition liable to be
dismissed.”
27.
By relying upon the decisions in the cases of (i)
Ram Sukh, (2) Mangani Lal Mandal and (3) Jaipal Singh, supra,
the learned counsel for the petitioner argued that if the allegation
contained in the election petition, even assuming to be true and
correct, do not make out any case of corrupt practice or any
ground under Section 100 of the Representation of People Act,
the pleading would be unnecessary, frivolous and vexatious. It
is always open to strike out the same.
If after striking out
defective pleadings the Courts find that no cause of action
remains to be tried it would be duly bound to reject the petition
under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC. If a preliminary objection is raised
before the commencement of the trial, the Court is duty bound to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 15
consider the same, it need not postpone the consideration for
subsequent stage of the trial.
28.
In Ram Sukh, supra, the Apex Court held:
“9. In this backdrop, we may now turn to
the procedural provisions in the Act insofar as
they are relevant for our purpose:
“81. Presentation of petitions.— (1) An
election petition calling in question any election
may be presented on one or more of the
grounds specified in sub-section (1) of Section
100 and Section 101 to the High Court by any
candidate at such election or any elector within
forty-five days from, but not earlier than the date
of election of the returned candidate or if there
are more than one returned candidates at the
election and the dates of their election are
different, the later of those two dates.
Explanation.—In this sub-section, ‘elector’
means a person who was entitled to vote at the
election to which the election petition relates,
whether he has voted at such election or not.
......
(3)
Every
election
petition
shall
be
accompanied by as many copies thereof as
there are respondents mentioned in the petition,
and every such copy shall be attested by the
petitioner under his own signature to be a true
copy of the petition.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 16
.....
83. Contents of petition.—(1) An election
petition—
(a) shall contain a concise statement of the
material facts on which the petitioner relies;
(b) shall set forth full particulars of any
corrupt practice that the petitioner alleges,
including as full a statement as possible of the
names of the parties alleged to have committed
such corrupt practice and the date and place of
the commission of each such practice; and
(c) shall be signed by the petitioner and
verified in the manner laid down in the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the
verification of pleadings:
Provided that where the petitioner alleges
any corrupt practice, the petition shall also be
accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed
form in support of the allegation of such corrupt
practice and the particulars thereof.
(2) Any schedule or annexure to the petition
shall also be signed by the petitioner and
verified in the same manner as the petition.
.....
86. Trial of election petitions.—(1) The High
Court shall dismiss an election petition which
does not comply with the provisions of Section
81 or Section 82 or Section 117.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 17
Explanation.—An order of the High Court
dismissing an election petition under this subsection shall be deemed to be an order made
under clause (a) of Section 98.
(2) As soon as may be after an election
petition has been presented to the High Court,
it shall be referred to the Judge or one of the
Judges who has or have been assigned by the
Chief Justice for the trial of election petitions
under sub-section (2) of Section 80-A.
(3) Where more election petitions than one
are presented to the High Court in respect of the
same election, all of them shall be referred for
trial to the same Judge who may, in his
discretion, try them separately or in one or more
groups.
(4) Any candidate not already a respondent
shall, upon application made by him to the High
Court within fourteen days from the date of
commencement of the trial and subject to any
order as to security for costs which may be
made by the High Court, be entitled to be joined
as a respondent.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this subsection and of Section 97, the trial of a petition
shall be deemed to commence on the date fixed
for the respondents to appear before the High
Court and answer the claim or claims made in
the petition.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 18
(5) The High Court may, upon such terms as
to costs and otherwise as it may deem fit, allow
the particulars of any corrupt practice alleged in
the petition to be amended or amplified in such
manner as may in its opinion be necessary for
ensuring a fair and effective trial of the petition,
but shall not allow any amendment of the
petition which will have the effect of introducing
particulars of a corrupt practice not previously
alleged in the petition.
(6) The trial of an election petition shall, so
far as is practicable consistently with the
interests of justice in respect of the trial, be
continued from day to day until its conclusion,
unless the High Court finds the adjournment of
the trial beyond the following day to be
necessary for reasons to be recorded.
(7) Every election petition shall be tried as
expeditiously as possible and endeavour shall
be made to conclude the trial within six months
from the date on which the election petition is
presented to the High Court for trial.
87. Procedure before the High Court.—(1)
Subject to the provisions of this Act and of any
rules made thereunder, every election petition
shall be tried by the High Court, as nearly as
may be, in accordance with the procedure
applicable under the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (5 of 1908) to the trial of suits:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 19
Provided that the High Court shall have the
discretion to refuse, for reasons to be recorded
in writing, to examine any witness or witnesses
if it is of the opinion that the evidence of such
witness or witnesses is not material for the
decision of the petition or that the party
tendering such witness or witnesses is doing so
on frivolous grounds or with a view to delay the
proceedings.
(2) The provisions of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), shall, subject to the
provisions of this Act, be deemed to apply in all
respects to the trial of an election petition.”
From the aforequoted provisions, it would
appear that Section 81 enables a petitioner to
call in question any election on one or more of
the grounds specified in sub-section (1) of
Section 100 of the Act.
10. Section 83, the pivotal provision for the
present case, requires that: (a) the election
petition must contain a concise statement of
“material facts” on which the petitioner relies
and (b) he should also set forth “full particulars”
of any corrupt practices which the petitioner
alleges. Proviso to clause (c) of sub-section (1)
of Section 83 also provides that where the
petitioner alleges any corrupt practice, the
election petition shall also be accompanied by
an affidavit in the prescribed form in support of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 20
the allegation of such corrupt practice and the
particulars
thereof.
It
is
plain
that
the
requirement of disclosure of “material facts” and
“full particulars” as stipulated in the section is
mandatory.
11. Section 86 mandates that where the
election petition does not comply with the
provisions of Section 81 or Section 82 or
Section 117 of the Act, the High Court should
dismiss the election petition. Section 87 which
lays down the procedure required to be followed
by the High Court while trying an election
petition, requires that every election petition
shall be tried, as nearly as may be, in
accordance with the procedure applicable
under the Code to the trial of the suits, subject
of course to the provisions of the Act and of any
requirement made thereunder.
12. It is evident that the controversy in this
appeal lies in a narrow compass. It revolves
around the ambit of Section 83 of the Act. The
point for consideration is whether the election
petition lacked “material facts” required to be
stated in the election petition in terms of Section
83(1) of the Act and if so, could it be dismissed
summarily without trial? As already noted, it is
mandatory that all “material facts” are set out in
an election petition and it is also trite that if
material facts are not stated in the petition, the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 21
same is liable to be dismissed on that ground
alone. Therefore, the question is as to whether
the election petitioner had set out “material
facts” in his petition?"
29.
In Mangani Lal Mandal, supra, the Apex Court held:
“12. Although the impugned judgment runs
into 30 pages, but unfortunately it does not
reflect any consideration on the most vital
aspect as to whether the non-disclosure of
the information concerning the appellant's
first wife and the dependent children born
from that wedlock and their assets and
liabilities has materially affected the result
of the election insofar as it concerned the
returned candidate. As a matter of fact, in
the entire election petition there is no
pleading at all that the suppression of the
information by the returned candidate in
the affidavit filed along with the nomination
papers with regard to his first wife and
dependent children from her and nondisclosure of their assets and liabilities has
materially affected
the result of the
election. There is no issue framed in this
regard nor is there any evidence let in by
the election petitioner. The High Court has
also not formed any opinion on this
aspect.”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 22
30.
In Jaipal Singh, supra, the Apex Court held:
“7. Section 83 deals with contents of petition.
It states that an election petition shall contain a
concise statement of material facts, on which
the petitioner relies and shall state full
particulars of any corrupt practices which the
petitioner alleges and which shall be signed by
him and verified in the manner laid down in the
Code of Civil Procedure. In the case of Sopan
Sukhdeo
Sable v. Asstt.
Charity
Commr. [(2004) 3 SCC 137 : (2004) 2 Scale 82]
it has been held that Order 6 Rule 2(1) CPC
deals with basic rule of pleadings and declares
that the pleading has to state material facts and
not the evidence; that there is a distinction
between “material facts” and “particulars” and
the words “material facts” show that the facts
necessary to formulate a complete cause of
action must be stated. Omission of single
material fact leads to an incomplete cause of
action and consequently, the plaint becomes
bad. The distinction between “material facts”
and “particulars” was brought by Scott, L.J.
in Bruce v. Odhams Press Ltd. [(1936) 1 KB
697 : (1936) 1 All ER 287 (CA)] in the following
passage: (All ER p. 294)
“The cardinal provision in Rule 4 is that the
statement of claim must state the material facts.
The word ‘material’ means necessary for the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 23
purpose of formulating a complete cause of
action; and if any one ‘material’ statement is
omitted, the statement of claim is bad; it is
‘demurrable’ in the old phraseology and in the
new is liable to be ‘struck out’ under RSC Order
25 Rule 4 (see Philipps v. Philipps [(1878) 4
QBD 127 : 48 LJQB 135 : 39 LT 556 (CA)] ); or
‘a further and better statement of claim’ may be
ordered under Rule 7.
The function of ‘particulars’ under Rule 6 is
quite different. They are not to be used in order
to fill material gaps in a demurrable statement
of claim — gaps which ought to have been filled
by appropriate statements of the various
material facts which together constitute the
plaintiff's cause of action. The use of particulars
is intended to meet a further and quite separate
requirement of pleading, imposed in fairness
and justice to the defendant. Their function is to
fill in the picture of the plaintiff's cause of action
with information sufficiently detailed to put the
defendant on his guard as to the case he had to
meet and to enable him to prepare for trial.”
31.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the first
respondent/election petitioner submitted that each and every
averment made in the election petition constitute the material
facts and material particulars and these are the cause of action
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 24
for granting the reliefs sought by the election petitioner.
All
averments should be read as a whole so as to examine whether
such averments constitute the cause of action of the election
petition.
32.
The learned counsel for the first respondent then
submitted that all the averments of the election petition are
presumed to be true and the burden of establishing the truth of
all averments is on the election petitioner and that the allegations
of the petitioner raised in the present miscellaneous case are to
be decided only after the hearing of the election petition. In
support, the learned counsel placed reliance upon the decisions
of the Apex Court in the cases of D.Ramachandran and Ashraf
Kokkur, supra.
33.
It is also the argument of the learned counsel for the
first respondent/election petitioner that while exercising the
power of rejection of the election petition, the conditions
enumerated under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC have to be adhered to.
34.
In D.Ramachandran, supra, the Apex Court held:
“8. We do not consider it necessary to refer
in detail to any part of the reasoning in the
judgment; instead, we proceed to consider
the arguments advanced before us on the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 25
basis of the pleadings contained in the
election petition. It is well settled that in all
cases of preliminary objection, the test is to
see whether any of the reliefs prayed for
could be granted to the appellant if the
averments made in the petition are proved
to be true. For the purpose of considering
a preliminary objection, the averments in
the petition should be assumed to be true
and the court has to find out whether those
averments disclose a cause of action or a
triable issue as such. The court cannot
probe into the facts on the basis of the
controversy raised in the counter.
......
10. On the other hand, Rule 11 of Order 7
enjoins the court to reject the plaint where it
does not disclose a cause of action. There is no
question of striking out any portion of the
pleading under this Rule. The application filed
by the first respondent in OA No. 36 of 1997 is
on the footing that the averments in the election
petition did not contain the material facts giving
rise to a triable issue or disclosing a cause of
action. Laying stress upon the provisions of
Order 7 Rule 11(a), learned Senior Counsel for
the first respondent took us through the entire
election
petition
and
submitted
that
the
averments therein do not disclose a cause of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 26
action. On a reading of the petition, we do not
find it possible to agree with him. The election
petition as such does disclose a cause of action
which if unrebutted could void the election and
the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11(a) CPC
cannot therefore be invoked in this case. There
is no merit in the contention that some of the
allegations are bereft of material facts and as
such do not disclose a cause of action. It is
elementary that under Order 7 Rule 11(a) CPC,
the court cannot dissect the pleading into
several parts and consider whether each one of
them discloses a cause of action. Under the
Rule, there cannot be a partial rejection of the
plaint
or
petition.
See Roop
Lal
Sathi v. Nachhattar Singh Gill [(1982) 3 SCC
487] . We are satisfied that the election petition
in this case could not have been rejected in
limine without a trial.
....
15. As regards OA No. 186 of 1997, the
approach of the learned Judge is totally
erroneous as he has not kept in mind the
distinction between “material facts” and “full
particulars”. Nor has he correctly appreciated
the decisions of this Court referred to by him.
We do not want to express any opinion at this
stage on the additional documents produced by
the appellant. The trial court may decide the
application in the light of the relevant judgments
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 27
of this Court, in particular, those laying down the
difference between “material facts” and “full
particulars”. Hence the order in OA No. 186 of
1997 is set aside and the application is
remanded for fresh disposal in accordance with
law.
35.
In Ashraf Kokkur, supra, the Apex Court held:
"21. The pleadings, if taken as a whole, would
clearly show that they constitute the material
facts so as to pose a triable issue as to whether
the first respondent is disqualified to contest
election
to
the
Kerala
State
Legislative
Assembly while holding an office of profit under
the State Government as Chairperson of the
Kerala State Wakf Board. The question is not
whether the Chairperson of the Kerala State
Wakf Board is an office of profit or not. That is
the issue to be tried. The question is whether
the petitioner has raised such a question in the
election petition. The disqualification under the
Constitution of India being, holding an office of
profit under the State Government. The
petitioner
has
furnished
all
the
material
particulars in that regard. Therefore, the petition
discloses a cause of action.
22. After all, the inquiry under Order 7 Rule
11(a) CPC is only as to whether the facts as
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 28
pleaded disclose a cause of action and not
complete cause of action. The limited inquiry is
only to see whether the petition should be
thrown out at the threshold. In an election
petition, the requirement under Section 83 of
the RP Act is to provide a precise and concise
statement of material facts. The expression
“material facts” plainly means facts pertaining to
the subject-matter and which are relied on by
the election petitioner. If the party does not
prove those facts, he fails at the trial
[See Philipps v. Philipps [(1878) LR 4 QBD 127
(CA)]
(QBD
p.
133); Mohan
Rawale v. Damodar Tatyaba [(1994) 2 SCC
392] (SCC p. 399, para 16)].
36.
In order to deal with the present miscellaneous
case, there is a duty cast on this Court to determine whether the
election petition discloses a cause of action by scrutinizing the
averments made in the election petition.
37.
The law governing an application under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC, reads thus:
“11. Rejection of plaint.—The plaint shall be
rejected in the following cases—
(a) where it does not disclose a cause of
action;
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 29
(b)
where
the
relief
claimed
is
undervalued, and the plaintiff, on being
required by the court to correct the
valuation within a time to be fixed by the
court, fails to do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly
valued but the plaint is written upon paper
insufficiently stamped, and the plaintiff, on
being required by the court to supply the
requisite stamp paper within a time to be
fixed by the court, fails to do so;
(d) where the suit appears from the
statement in the plaint to be barred by any
law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with
the provisions of Rule 9:
Provided that the time fixed by the court for
the correction of the valuation or supplying
of the requisite stamp-papers shall not be
extended unless the court, for reasons to
be recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff
was prevented by any cause of an
exceptional nature from correcting the
valuation or supplying the requisite stamppapers, as the case may be, within the
time fixed by the court and that refusal to
extend such time would cause grave
injustice to the plaintiff.”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 30
38.
“Cause of action” means every fact which would be
necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to
support his right to judgment. It consists of a bundle of material
facts, which are necessary for the plaintiff to prove in order to
entitle him to the reliefs claimed in the suit.
39.
In A.B.C. Laminart Private Limited and another v.
A.P. Agencies, Salem, (1989) 2 SCC 163, the meaning of cause
of action was explained by the Apex Court as under:
"12. A cause of action means every fact, which
if traversed, it would be necessary for the
plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to
a judgment of the court. In other words, it is a
bundle of facts which taken with the law
applicable to them gives the plaintiff a right to
relief against the defendant. It must include
some act done by the defendant since in the
absence of such an act no cause of action can
possibly accrue. It is not limited to the actual
infringement of the right sued on but includes all
the material facts on which it is founded. It does
not comprise evidence necessary to prove such
facts, but every fact necessary for the plaintiff to
prove to enable him to obtain a decree.
Everything which if not proved would give the
defendant a right to immediate judgment must
be part of the cause of action. But it has no
relation whatever to the defence which may be
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 31
set up by the defendant nor does it depend
upon the character of the relief prayed for by the
plaintiff.
40.
"Cause of action” is a term of art and has been
described by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as also by this Court as
a concise statement of material facts as also full particulars
(where corrupt practice at an election is alleged) on which the
election petitioner relies for making out corrupt practice as a
ground for setting aside an election. A cause of action
challenging an election on the ground of corrupt practice requires
as full a statement as possible of the names of the parties alleged
to have committed the corrupt practice and the details, date and
place of the commission of such corrupt practice.
41.
The expression “cause of action” has acquired a
judicially settled meaning.
In the restricted sense, cause of
action means the circumstances forming the infraction of the right
or the immediate occasion for the action. In the wider sense, it
means the necessary conditions for the maintenance of the suit,
including not only infraction of the right, but the infraction coupled
with the right itself. Compendiously the expression means every
fact which would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if
traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment of the
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 32
Court.
Every fact which is necessary to be proved, as
distinguished from every piece of evidence which is necessary to
prove each fact, comprises in “cause of action”.
42.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
first
respondent/election petitioner argued that the cause of action is
a bundle of facts which taken with the law applicable to them
gives the plaintiff the right to relief against the defendant. Every
fact which is necessary for the plaintiff to prove to enable him to
get a decree. It is worthwhile to find out the meaning of the words
“cause of action”. A cause of action must include some act done
by the defendant since in the absence of such an act no cause
of action can possibly accrue.
43.
For the purpose of determining whether the election
petition discloses cause of action, the Court must take into
consideration the election petition as a whole. It is only if even
after the election petition is read as a whole, no cause of action
is found discernible that the Court can exercise its powers under
Order VII, Rule 11 CPC.
44.
Coming to the instant case, on an overall
consideration of the allegations in the election petition, it is clear
that the allegation of corrupt practices – concealment of facts of
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 33
the ongoing construction of building inside the agricultural land;
false total income stated in the relevant column in Form 26
affidavit for the financial year 2021-2022 and possession of two
voter cards – have been set out in the election petition. On a
close reading of the election petition, it is also clear that all the
ingredients to maintain election petition and the grounds referred
in Section 100(1)(b) of the Representation of People Act have
been stated in the election petition.
45.
As stated supra, it is the case of the first respondent
that the petitioner has failed to disclose the asset and investment
of about Rs.2 crore for land development made in the land and
construction inside the agricultural land mentioned in her Form
26 affidavit. She had also concealed her total income for the
financial year 2021-2022 even though she was serving as
Committee Officer at the Secretariat of Manipur Legislative
Assembly till 31.12.2021. The nomination paper of the petitioner
has been improperly accepted since the name of the person
namely Kimneo Haokip alleged to be herself listed in the electoral
roll of 46-Saikul (ST) Assembly Constituency was also listed in
another electoral toll of 51-Saitu (ST) Assembly Constituency at
Serial No.643.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 34
46.
According to the first respondent/election petitioner,
the petitioner has intentionally omitted vital information which
may have shown the wealth and properties she may have
accumulated in Form 26 affidavit which are required to be
disclosed as per the mandate of the Election Commission of
India. If the aforesaid aspects are proved, it would amount to
corrupt practice under Section 123 of the Representation of
People Act allegedly committed by the petitioner. On the face of
it, the aforesaid contention urged by the learned counsel for the
first respondent cannot be brushed aside.
47.
The learned counsel for the first respondent argued
that it cannot be said that the charge of corrupt practice lacks
material facts and particulars. Even if this Court thinks that there
is deficiency of material particulars, instead of dismissing the
election petition, it would be just and proper to direct the election
petitioner to produce more particulars in support of his allegation.
48.
In Swamy
Atmananda v. Sri
Ramakrishna
Tapovanam (2005) 10 SCC 51, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held :
“24. A cause of action, thus, means every fact,
which, if traversed, it would be necessary for the
plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 35
a judgment of the court. In other words, it is a
bundle of facts, which taken with the law
applicable to them gives the plaintiff a right to
relief against the defendant. It must include
some act done by the defendant since in the
absence of such an act, no cause of action can
possibly accrue. It is not limited to the actual
infringement of the right sued on but includes all
the material facts on which it is founded.”
49.
In T.Arivandandam v. T.V.Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC
467, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that while considering an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC what is required to be
decided is whether the plaint discloses a real cause of action, or
something purely illusory, in the following words:
“5. ….. The learned Munsif must remember
that if on a meaningful—not formal—reading of
the plaint it is manifestly vexatious, and
meritless, in the sense of not disclosing a clear
right to sue, he should exercise his power under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC taking care to see that the
ground mentioned therein is fulfilled. And, if
clever drafting has created the illusion of a
cause of action, nip it in the bud at the first
hearing.…”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 36
50.
In ITC Ltd. v. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal,
(1998) 2 SCC 70, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that law
cannot permit clever drafting which creates illusions of a cause
of action. What is required is that a clear right must be made out
in the plaint. If, however, by clever drafting of the plaint, it has
created the illusion of a cause of action, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy v. Syed Jalal,
(2017) 13 SCC 174 held that it should be nipped in the bud, so
that bogus litigation will end at the earliest stage. The Court must
be vigilant against any camouflage or suppression, and
determine whether the litigation is utterly vexatious and an abuse
of the process of the Court.
51.
The election petition will have to be read as a whole
and cannot be dissected sentence-wise or paragraph-wise to
rule that the same does not disclose a cause of action. As stated
supra, cause of action embodies a bundle of facts which may be
necessary for the election petitioner to prove in order to get a
relief from the Court.
52.
Order 7, Rule 11 CPC enjoins the Court to reject the
plaint where it does not disclose a cause of action. The present
miscellaneous case filed by the petitioner is on the footing that
the averments in the election petition did not contain the material
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 37
facts giving rise to a triable issue or disclosing a cause of action.
Laying stress upon the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11(a), learned
counsel for the first respondent took us through the entire
election petition and submitted that the averments therein
disclose a cause of action.
53.
In
Church
of
Christ
Charitable
Trust
and
Educational Charitable Society v. Ponniamman Educational
Trust, (2012) 8 SCC 706, the Apex Court held that a cause of
action must include some act done by the defendant since in the
absence of such act, no cause of action can possibly accrue.
54.
By applying the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in
the decisions referred to supra, all the averments set out in the
election petition were considered as a bundle of facts and while
doing so, the specific averments with regard to the alleged
corrupt practice committed by the returned candidate (petitioner)
which constitute a ground for declaring an election to be void
under Section 100 of the Representation of People Act have
been spelt out in the election petition, more particularly in
paragraphs 15 and 18.
55.
On a reading of the petition, we do not find it
possible to agree with the submission made by the petitioner.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 38
The election petition, as such, discloses a cause of action which
if unrebutted could void the election and the provisions of Order
7 Rule 11(a) CPC cannot therefore be invoked in this case. There
is no merit in the contention made by the petitioner that some of
the allegations are bereft of material facts and, as such, do not
disclose a cause of action. As stated supra, it is elementary that
under Order 7 Rule 11(a) CPC, the Court cannot dissect the
pleading into several parts and consider whether each one of
them discloses a cause of action. There cannot be a partial
rejection of the plaint or petition. All the allegations contained in
the election petition, when this Court take as a bundle of facts,
would give the first respondent/election petitioner a right to the
relief and, thus, would constitute a valid cause of action for
maintaining the election petition.
56.
With regard to the ground raised by the petitioner
that the election petitioner failed to mention material facts which
would constitute the cause of action for filing the election petition,
it would be appropriate to refer the decision of the Apex Court in
the case of Madiraju Venkata Ramana Raju v. Peddireddigari
Ramachandra Reddy and others, (2018) 14 SCC 1. In the said
decision, the Apex Court held thus:
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 39
“40. In Harkirat
Singh [Harkirat
Singh v. Amrinder Singh, (2005) 13 SCC 511] ,
this Court once again reiterated thus : (SCC p.
526-28, paras 46-48)
“46. From the above provisions, it is clear
that an election petition must contain a concise
statement of “material facts” on which the
petitioner relies. It should also contain “full
particulars” of any corrupt practice that the
petitioner alleges including a full statement of
names of the parties alleged to have committed
such corrupt practice and the date and place of
commission of such practice. Such election
petition shall be signed by the petitioner and
verified in the manner laid down in the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
“the Code”) for the verification of pleadings. It
should be accompanied by an affidavit in the
prescribed form in support of allegation of such
practice and particulars thereof.
47.
All
material
facts,
therefore,
in
accordance with the provisions of the Act, have
to be set out in the election petition. If the
material facts are not stated in a petition, it is
liable to be dismissed on that ground as the
case would be covered by clause (a) of subsection (1) of Section 83 of the Act read with
clause (a) of Rule 11 of Order 7 of the Code.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 40
48. The expression “material facts” has
neither been defined in the Act nor in the Code.
According to the dictionary meaning, “material”
means “fundamental”, “vital”, “basic”, “cardinal”,
“central”,
“crucial”,
“decisive”,
“pivotal”,
“indispensable”,
“essential”,
“elementary”
or
“primary”. Burton's Legal Thesaurus (3rd Edn.),
p. 349.] The phrase “material facts”, therefore,
may be said to be those facts upon which a
party relies for its claim or defence. In other
words, “material facts” are facts upon which the
plaintiff's cause of action or the defendant's
defence depends. What particulars could be
said to be “material facts” would depend upon
the facts of each case and no rule of universal
application can be laid down. It is, however,
absolutely essential that all basic and primary
facts which must be proved at the trial by the
party to establish the existence of a cause of
action or defence are material facts and must
be stated in the pleading by the party.”
(emphasis supplied)
Again in paras 51 and 52, this Court observed
thus : (SCC pp. 527-28)
“51. A distinction between “material facts”
and “particulars”, however, must not be
overlooked. “Material facts” are primary or basic
facts which must be pleaded by the plaintiff or
by the defendant in support of the case set up
by him either to prove his cause of action or
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 41
defence. “Particulars”, on the other hand, are
details in support of material facts pleaded by
the party. They amplify, refine and embellish
material facts by giving distinctive touch to the
basic contours of a picture already drawn so as
to make it full, more clear and more informative.
“Particulars” thus ensure conduct of fair trial and
would not take the opposite party by surprise.
52. All “material facts” must be pleaded by
the party in support of the case set up by him.
Since the object and purpose is to enable the
opposite party to know the case he has to meet
with, in the absence of pleading, a party cannot
be allowed to lead evidence. Failure to state
even a single material fact, hence, will entail
dismissal of the suit or petition. Particulars, on
the other hand, are the details of the case which
is in the nature of evidence a party would be
leading at the time of trial.”
(emphasis supplied)
And again in para 72, the Court noted thus :
(SCC p. 535)
“72.
The
distinction
Court,
however,
drew
the
between
“material
facts”
and
“particulars”. According to the Court, “material
facts” are facts, if established would give the
petitioner the relief prayed for. The test is
whether the Court could have given a direct
verdict in favour of the election petitioner in case
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 42
the returned candidate had not appeared to
oppose the election petition on the basis of the
facts pleaded in the petition.”
(emphasis supplied)
41. In Ashraf Kokkur [Ashraf Kokkur v. K.V.
Abdul Khader, (2015) 1 SCC 129] , this Court
adverted
to
the
Kamalam v. V.A.
exposition
Syed
in M.
Mohammed [M.
Kamalam v. V.A. Syed Mohammed, (1978) 2
SCC
659]
, G.M.
Siddeshwar v. Prasanna
Kumar [G.M. Siddeshwar v. Prasanna Kumar,
(2013) 4 SCC 776 : (2013) 2 SCC (Civ) 715]
and in Para 21 noted that the pleadings must be
taken as a whole to ascertain whether the same
constitute the material facts involving triable
issues. In para 22, the Court observed as
follows : (SCC p. 139)
“22. After all, the inquiry under Order 7 Rule
11(a) CPC is only as to whether the facts as
pleaded disclose a cause of action and not
complete cause of action. The limited inquiry is
only to see whether the petition should be
thrown out at the threshold. In an election
petition, the requirement under Section 83 of
the RP Act is to provide a precise and concise
statement of material facts. The expression
“material facts” plainly means facts pertaining to
the subject-matter and which are relied on by
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 43
the election petitioner. If the party does not
prove those facts, he fails at the trial.”
(emphasis supplied)
57.
In Udhav Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia, (1977) 1
SCC 511, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“42. All the primary facts which must be proved
at the trial by a party to establish the existence
of a cause of action or his defence, are “material
facts”. In the context of a charge of corrupt
practice, “material facts” would mean all the
basic facts constituting the ingredients of the
particular corrupt practice alleged, which the
petitioner is bound to substantiate before he
can succeed on that charge. Whether in an
election petition, a particular fact is material or
not, and as such required to be pleaded is a
question which depends on the nature of the
charge levelled, the ground relied upon and the
special circumstances of the case. In short, all
those facts which are essential to clothe the
petitioner with a complete cause of action, are
“material facts” which must be pleaded, and
failure to plead even a single material fact
amounts to disobedience of the mandate of
Section 83(1)(a).”
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 44
58.
The Apex Court in the case of Azhar Hussain v.
Rajiv Gandhi, 1986 Supp SCC 315 has held:
“11. …. Whether in an election petition a
particular fact is material or not and as such
required to be pleaded is dependent on the
nature
of
the
charge
levelled
and
the
circumstances of the case.”
59.
According to the first respondent/election petitioner,
the petitioner admitted at para 9(a) of her Form 26 affidavit that
her profession or occupation is “Self-Ex-Committee Officer,
Assembly Secretariat, Manipur”, which means that she has
income. As such, her income could not be Rs.0/- and even if she
belongs to a member of the Scheduled Tribe community, she
may fill up as “Not Applicable” but she opted to fill the income
then she should have to fill up her actual income which is also
admitted in para 9(a) of the affidavit in Form 26. Learned counsel
submitted that this issue about her income for the year 20212022 can be decided after hearing and also after taking evidence.
This Court finds some force in the said submissions made by the
learned counsel for the first respondent/election petitioner.
60.
Since this Court finds that the basic facts and
allegations set out in the election petition, particularly paragraphs
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 45
16 and 18 would constitute a valid cause of action to maintain the
relief sought for in the election petition and applying the decisions
of the Apex Court, such basic facts pleaded by the election
petitioner in support of the case set up by him could be termed
as material facts.
61.
In V.S.Achuthanandan v. P.J.Francis and another,
(2001) 3 SCC 81, the Apex Court held that the election petition
was not liable to be dismissed in limine, merely because full
particulars of corrupt practice alleged are not set out. As held in
V.S.Achuthanandan, supra, material facts would be such primary
facts which must be proved at the trial by the party to establish
existence of such cause of action.
62.
In Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. V. Vessel M.V. Fortune
Express, (2006) 3 SCC 100, the Apex court held:
"12. ...... The court has to read the entire plaint
as a whole to find out whether it discloses a
cause of action and if it does, then the plaint
cannot be rejected by the court exercising the
powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code.
Essentially, whether the plaint discloses a
cause of action, is a question of fact which has
to be gathered on the basis of the averments
made in the plaint in its entirety taking those
averments to be correct. A cause of action is a
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 46
bundle of facts which are required to be proved
for obtaining relief and for the said purpose, the
material facts are required to be stated but not
the evidence except in certain cases where the
pleadings
relied
on
are
in
regard
to
misrepresentation, fraud, wilful default, undue
influence or of the same nature. So long as the
plaint discloses some cause of action which
requires determination by the court, the mere
fact that in the opinion of the Judge the plaintiff
may not succeed cannot be a ground for
rejection of the plaint. In the present case, the
averments made in the plaint, as has been
noticed by us, do disclose the cause of action
and, therefore, the High Court has rightly said
that the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the
Code cannot be exercised for rejection of the
suit filed by the plaintiff-appellants.
63.
When the averments in the election petition were
considered as a bundle of facts, the allegations made therein
would constitute a valid cause of action which could be termed
as material facts, which allegations are neither in violation of any
statutory provisions but are in conformity with the grounds for
which the election petitioner may seek for declaring the election
as void under the provisions of the Representation of People Act.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 47
64.
In a catena of decisions, the Apex Court held that
since the power conferred on the Court to terminate civil action
at the threshold is drastic, the conditions enumerated under
Order 7, Rule 11 CPC to the exercise of power of rejection of the
plaint have to be strictly adhered to.
65.
As stated supra, the pleadings, if taken as a whole,
would clearly show that they constitute the material facts so as to
post a triable issue and the first respondent has furnished all the
material particulars in that regard. Therefore, the election petition
discloses a cause of action. As held in Ashraf Kokkur, supra,
after all, the inquiry under Order 7, Rule 11(a) CPC is only as to
whether the facts as pleaded disclose a cause of action and not
complete cause of action. The limited inquiry is only to see
whether the election petition should be thrown out at the
threshold. In an election petition, the requirement under Section
83 of the Representation of People Act is to provide a precise
and concise statement of material facts, which in the instant case
have been clearly spelt out. The expression “material facts”
plainly means facts pertaining to the subject matter and which
are relied on by the election petitioner. If the election petitioner
does not prove those facts, he fails at the trial.
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
P a g e | 48
66.
Rules of pleadings are intended as aids for a fair
trial and for reaching a just decision. An action at law should not
be equated to a game of chess. Provisions of law are not mere
formulae to be observed as rituals. Beneath the words of a
provision of law, generally speaking, there lies a juristic principle.
It is the duty of the Court to ascertain that principle and implement
it. [Raj Narain v. Indira Nehru Gandhi, (1972) 3 SCC 850].
67.
Guided by the settled principles of law referred to
above, this Court is of the view that the election petition filed by
the first respondent herein having disclosed a cause of action,
the same should not be thrown out at the threshold as pleaded
by the petitioner.
68.
For all the reasons stated above, MC (Elec. Pet)
No.66 of 2022 in Election Petition No.34 of 2022 is dismissed.
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
MC(El.Pet.) No. 66 of 2022 (Ref:- El.Pet. No. 34 of 2022)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review