Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010243352024
2026:GAU-AS:12076
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
CRP(IO)/490/2024
1. Kimi Sarda
W/O Sri Gopal Sarda,
Permanent Resident of Janiganj Bazar,
PO and PS Silchar,
District Cachar, Assam
Presently Residing At P 78, CIT Road,
Esteeem 6m, 2nd Floor, Near Fulbagan, PS
PO Kolkata 7000054, West Bengal,
Represented by her duly constituted by
her duly constituted Attorney Sri Rajendra
Kumar Sarda,
Aged About 73 Years, Son of Late Ram
Charan Sarda, of Janiganj Bazar, PO And
PS Silchar, District-Cachar Assam
-Versus1.
2.
3.
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
…..Appellant
Krishna Sharma
S.O Late Ananda Sharma,
Resident Of Bhandar Galli, Tarapur, Silchar,
PO Silchar, Dist Cachar, Assam 788003
Smti Geeta Das
W/O Late Sankar Das
Resident of Arjya Patty PO and PS Silchar
District Cachar Assam 788001
Smti Uma Das
W/O Late Santanu Das
Page 1
4.
5.
Resident of Arjya Patty PO and PS Silchar
District Cachar Assam 788001
Smti Supriya Das
W/O Late Atanu Das
Resident of Arjya Patty PO and PS Silchar
District Cachar Assam 788001
Nilanjana Das
D/O Late Atanu Das
Resident of Arjya Patty PO and PS Silchar
Distrcit Cachar Assam 788001
……Respondents
For Appellant
:
Mr. S. Choudhury, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. G. N. Sahewalla, Sr. Advocate
Ms. S. Todi, Advocate
Date of Hearing
:
21.08.2026
Date of Judgment
:
24.08.2026
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Heard Mr. S. Choudhury, the learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. G. N. Sahewala, the learned senior counsel assisted by
Ms. S. Todi, the learned counsel for the respondent No. 1.
2.
This application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been filed by the petitioner, namely, Smt. Kimi Sarda, impugning the
order dated 10.09.2023 passed by the Court of learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division) No. 4, Cachar, Silchar in Misc. Case No. 102/2023,
whereby the prayer for impleading the respondent No. 1 as a
defendant in the Title Suit No. 138/2021 was allowed.
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 2
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant CRP (I/O), in
brief, are that the present petitioner had filed a title suit before the
Court of learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) No. 4, Cachar, Silchar
against present respondent Nos. 2 to 5 and one more defendant,
namely, Smt. Supriya Das who was arrayed as defendant No. 2 in
the said suit. However, she has not been made a party in this
Revision Petition. The present petitioner has sought the relief of
declaration of her right, title and interest over the suit property as
well as for eviction of the said defendants from the suit property
and for permanent injunction against the defendants. The said suit
was registered as Title Suit No. 91/2013.
4.
During the pendency of the aforesaid suit, respondent No. 1, Shri
Krishna Sharma, filed an application under Order I Rule 10 read
with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking his
impleadment as a defendant in the suit. It was contended in the
said application that the present respondent No. 1 has taken a room
situated over the schedule property on monthly rental basis from
the respondent No.2 who was the defendant No. 1 in the suit filed
by the present petitioner. It was further contended that a tenancy
agreement was also executed between them and the respondent
No.1 is running a retail electric goods shop by the name and style
M/s Anandamoyee in the said premises.
5.
Though, the present petitioner objected to the said prayer before
the Trial Court by filing written objection, however, by order dated
10.09.2023, passed in the Misc. Case No. 102/2023, arising out of
Title Suit No. 138/2021, the Trial Court allowed the aforesaid
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 3
application filed by the present respondent No. 1 and directed him
to be impleaded as a defendant in the said suit. The present
petitioner was also directed to accordingly amend the plaint. Being
aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the instant Revision Petition has
been filed.
6.
Mr. S. Choudhury, the learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the Trial Court had erred in allowing the
impleadment application filed by the present respondent without
taking into consideration that the present respondent No. 1 is not a
necessary party in the suit. He further submits that the trial court
also failed to take into consideration that the plaintiff, being the
dominus litis in a suit, has the option to choose as to who may be
impleaded as defendant in the suit filed by him.
7.
He further submits that since there is no tenant-landlord
relationship between the present petitioner and the present
respondent No. 1, he cannot be compelled to implead such a person
when the suit is already pending before the court, wherein the other
defendants are made parties. He further submits that if the
petitioner is able to obtain decree in the suit against the persons
from whom the present respondent has derived his right as a
licensee, there may not be any requirement of seeking a separate
decree against such an unauthorized licensee.
8.
He further submits that in the event if a decree is issued in favor of
the present petitioner by the Trial Court without impleading the
respondent No. 1, and if he remains aggrieved by such a decree, he
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 4
always has recourse to approach before the Executing Court by
filing an appropriate application under Order 21 Rule 99 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908.
9.
As such, he submits that the trial court was wrong in directing the
impleadment of the present respondent as a defendant in the suit
filed by the present petitioner, ignoring the fact that the present
petitioner, being the dominus litis in the suit, has the discretion to
choose as to whom he may add as defendants. In support of his
submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner has cited the
following rulings:
i.
Vidur Impex and Traders Private Limited and Others Vs. Tosh
Apartments Private Limited and Others, reported in (2012) 8
SCC 384.
ii.
NAK
Engineering
Company
Private
Limited
Vs.
Tarun
Keshrichand Shah, reported in 2026 INSC 8.
10.
On the other hand, Mr. G. N. Sahewala, the learned senior counsel
for the respondents submits that the Trial Court has rightly passed
the order of impleading the respondent No. 1 as a defendant in the
suit after considering the fact that it is the present respondent, who
is in possession over the suit property since the year 2000 and has
been
running
his
business
therein
after
taking
electricity
connections and depositing rent in the Court after the present
respondent No. 2 refused to accept the said rent from him.
11.
He submits that this application under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is not maintainable as the jurisdiction under
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 5
Article 227 of the Constitution of India has to be sparingly exercised
and with circumspection.
12.
He submits that Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 gives judicial discretion to the Court to add a party at any
stage of the proceeding if the party sought to be added is either a
necessary party or a proper party.
13.
The learned senior counsel for the respondents submits that in the
instant case, since the present petitioner is admittedly in possession
of the suit property, he is a necessary party to the suit and without
impleading him, no effective decree may be passed in the Suit. He
further submits that impleadment of the present respondent No. 1
is also required to avoid multiplicity of litigation as admittedly the
present respondent No. 1 is in possession of the suit property. He
submits that though, the principle that it is the plaintiff who, being
dominus litis, may choose a person against whom he wishes to
litigate is a well-accepted principle, however, the same is not an
absolute rule under all circumstances and the provisions contained
in Order 1 Rule 10(2) gives discretion to the Court, in an
appropriate case, to implead a proper or necessary party.
14.
He submits that in the instant case, since there is a dispute
regarding acceptance of rent between the present respondent No. 1
and respondent No. 2, the suit filed by the present petitioner is a
collusive suit, wherein the petitioner has deliberately suppressed the
fact that a shop room over the suit schedule property is presently in
possession of the present respondent No. 1. In support of his
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 6
submission, he has cited the ruling of the Apex Court in the case of
Mumbai International Airport Private Limited Vs. Regency Convention
Centre and Hotels Private Limited and Others, reported in (2010) 7
SCC 417.
15.
I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for
both sides and have gone through the materials available on record.
I have also gone through the rulings cited by the learned counsel
for both sides in support of their respective submissions.
16.
The question to be decided in this Revision Petition is as to whether
the discretion of the Court to implead a party under Order 1 Rule 10
(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 would override the right of
the plaintiff, as a dominus litis, to choose as to who may be made
defendant in the suit filed by him. In this regard, the Apex Court
has observed in the case of Mumbai International Airport Private
Limited vs. Regency Convention Centre and Hotels Private Limited
and Others (supra) as follows:
“13. The general rule in regard to impleadment of
parties is that the plaintiff in a suit, being dominus
litis, may choose the persons against whom he
wishes to sue and cannot be compelled to sue a
person against whom he does not seek any relief.
Consequently, a person who is not a party has no
right to be impleaded against the wishes of the
plaintiff. But this general rule is subject to the
provisions of Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Code of
Civil Procedure ('the Code', for short), which
provides for impleadment of proper or necessary
parties. The said sub-rule is extracted below:
'10. (2) Court may strike out or add
parties.—The court may at any stage of the
proceedings, either upon or without the
application of either party, and on such
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 7
terms as may appear to the court to be
just, order that the name of any party
improperly joined, whether as plaintiff or
defendant, be struck out, and that the
name of any person who ought to have
been joined, whether as plaintiff or
defendant, or whose presence before the
court may be necessary in order to enable
the court effectually and completely to
adjudicate upon and settle all the questions
involved in the suit, be added.'"
14. The said provision makes it clear that a court
may, at any stage of the proceedings (including in
an appeal) either upon or even without any
application, and on such terms as may appear to
it to be just, direct:
(a) that any party improperly joined as a
plaintiff or defendant, be struck out;
(b) that any person who ought to have
been joined (that is, who is a necessary
party) or whose presence before the court
may be necessary in order to enable the
court effectually and completely to
adjudicate upon and settle all the questions
involved in the suit (that is, who is a proper
party), be added as a party."
15. A 'necessary party' is a person who ought to
have been joined as a party and in whose
absence no effective decree can be passed at all
by the court. If a 'necessary party' is not
impleaded, the suit itself is liable to be dismissed.
A 'proper party' is a party who, though not a
necessary party, is a person whose presence
would enable the court to completely, effectively
and adequately adjudicate upon all matters in
dispute in the suit, though he need not be a
person in favour of or against whom the decree is
to be made. If a 'proper party' is not accorded an
opportunity to participate in the proceedings, the
decision may not bind him, nor should the decree
be passed in his absence if it affects his rights,
but the suit will not be dismissed for non-joinder."
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 8
17.
From the observations made by the Apex Court in the above
judgment, there remains no doubt that the general rule with regard
to impleadment of parties, that the plaintiff being dominus litis may
choose the person against whom he wishes to litigate, gives way to
the discretion of the court under Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 to implead either necessary or proper parties,
as the case may be.
18.
In the instant case, there is no dispute that Respondent No. 1 is in
possession of a room in the suit premises over which he is running
his shop. As such, there is no doubt that his presence in the suit as
a defendant would enable the Trial Court to completely, effectively,
and adequately adjudicate upon all matters in dispute in the suit. As
such, not to speak of whether he is a necessary party or not, there
is no dispute that Respondent No. 1 is certainly a proper party in
the suit. As such, the exercise of discretion by the court under
Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in
impleading the present Respondent No. 1 in the above-mentioned
suit does not appear to be an arbitrary exercise of the said
discretion in any view of the matter.
19.
It is a well-settled proposition of law that the supervisory power of
this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has to be
exercised sparingly and with circumspection. Such an exercise of
power may be justified if the Court below has exercised its
discretion with arbitrariness, capriciously and without following the
principles of natural justice.
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Page 9
20.
However, it is not the case in the present case, and it appears that
the Trial Court has given valid reasons for exercise of its discretion
under Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for
impleading the present respondent as defendant in the abovementioned suit. As such, this Court does not find it a case where
extraordinary powers of this Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India may be invoked to interfere with the impugned
order.
21.
In view of the discussions made and reasons stated in the foregoing
paragraph, this Court does not find any merit in this case to invoke
its extraordinary powers under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India to interfere with the impugned order.
22.
Accordingly, this CRP (I/O) is hereby dismissed.
23.
The interim order of stay of the suit granted in this CRP (I/O) is
accordingly, vacated.
24.
Let a copy of this order be forwarded to the Trial Court.
25.
The parties are left to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
CRO (I/O) No. 490/2024
Amita Sharma
2026.08.24 15:43:44
+05'30'
Page 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review