Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA Digitally
Date: 2024.06.14 12:35:31 +05'30'
Page |1
THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Khwairakpam Romio Singh, aged about 54 years,
S/o (L) Kh. Budhi Singh, a resident of Nambol Awang
Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Nambol, Bishnupur District,
Manipur – 795132 (now in Manipur Central Jail,
Sajiwa)
…Appellant
-VersusThe
State
of
Manipur
Commissioner/Addl.
Chief
represented
Secretary
by
the
(Home),
Government of Manipur, having its office at Manipur
Secretariat South Block, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West, Manipur, Pin Code : 795001.
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
For the Appellant
::
Mr. M. Gunedhor, Adv.
For the Respondent
.
Date of Hearing and
Reserving Judgment
& Order
::
Mr. RK Umakanta, PP
::
23.02.2024
Date of Judgment & Order ::
14.06.2024
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
1.
Khwairakpam Romio Singh, the appellant (hereafter
the appellant) assails the impugned judgment and order dated 8 th
of February, 2023 passed by the learned Special Judge (ND&PS),
Bishnupur, Manipur in Special Trial (ND & PS) Case No. 4 of 2015
whereby the appellant was convicted under Section 21(c) of
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
(ND&PS Act in short) as well as the order of sentence dated 13th
February, 2023 sentencing him for 15 years R.I. with a fine of Rs.
1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh) only failing payment of which he was
sentenced to undergo further rigorous imprisonment of 6 (six)
months; whilst granting him the benefit of the provisions of Section
428 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1908 (hereinafter Cr.P.C. in
short).
2.
The case of the Prosecution is that the complainant
namely, S.I. Th. Ibotombi Singh, O.C., Special Intelligent Unit
(S.I.U.) received a special report that one person was selling
Number 4 (Heroin Powder) near Lainingthou Khoriba Hill at I.V.
Road, Nambol. The complainant along with the police party rushed
to the said location after completing formalities from the S.P. Imphal
East and found one person lurking there in a suspicious manner
and holding one polythene bag.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |3
3.
With the help of the police party, the complainant
stopped the appellant and asked him about his identity and about
the polythene bag he was holding in his right hand.
4.
The appellant identified himself as aforementioned
and stated that the polythene bag belongs to him.
5.
The complainant informed the appellant that the latter
was suspected for possessing Number 4 (Heroin Powder) and also
informed him whether he would like the search of his body and
belongings to be conducted before the Magistrate or a Gazetted
Officer or any independent witnesses as he had the right in law so
to opt and require.
6.
The appellant thereupon stated that he may be
searched before any independent witness at the very spot i.e.
Lainingthou Khoriba Hill at I.V. Road, Nambol.
7.
Accordingly, the complainant called upon two persons,
namely, 1) Shri Nongmaithem Robindro Singh, 28 years, S/o N.
Ibotombi Singh of Top Moirang Kampu Makha Leikai and 2) Kamei
Aching, 56 years, S/o late K. Paoling of Langol Laimanai who were
at the spot and residing in the nearby area and thereafter conducted
the body search of the appellant as well as his belongings in
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |4
presence of the said witness; whilst simultaneously preparing
option for search under Section 50 of the ND&PS Act.
8.
The search of the polythene bag having mixed colour
(black, white, green, red and yellow), led to the discovery of one
transparent plastic packet containing Number 4 (Heroin Powder)
with a marking as “Sunflower with a symbol (picture) and with a
marking of one Kg and 90%” which was covered with a piece of old
newspaper. On weighing the same by using the police weighing
scale, it was found weighing “1,050 gms.” (one thousand and fifty
grams) including the weight of the receptacle container and the
same was marked as “A”. Out of the said marked ‘A’, two 5 gms
(five grams) each of Number 4 (heroin powder) i.e. one for original
and other for duplicate samples were extracted. The said two
samples were marked as “A-1” and ‘A-2’ respectively. The two
samples of Number 4 (heroin powder) and the remaining powder
i.e. marked as ‘A’ weighing 1,040 gms were put in three separate
envelopes. weighing 1040 gms which were put in three separate
envelopes, packed and sealed in the presence of the aforesaid
witnesses.
9.
The appellant was thereafter arrested and appended
his signatures on the three separate envelopes aforementioned in
the presence of the said witnesses and the latter also put their
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |5
signatures on the said three envelopes. The appellant along with
the seized articles i.e. original and duplicate samples of Number 4
heroin powder were brought to Nambol Police Station and handed
over to OC/Nambol PS for taking further necessary legal action
accordingly.
10.
Further, the seized Number 4 heroin powder was re-
seized on the complainant’s production by the I.O. of the case.
11.
Upon completion of the investigation, a Charge Sheet
No. 2/2008 dated 17th June, 2015 was submitted against the
appellant for the alleged commission of the offences punishable
under Section 21(c) ND&PS Act.
12.
The Charge Sheet, inter alia, relevantly stated as
follows :“During the course of investigation visited the spot and a
rough sketch map of the P.O. is drawn with index. Examined
the Complainant and the seizure witnesses. The statement
of the Complainant is fully corroborated with the O.E. Some
portion of the seized heroin powder was examined by the
expert of FSL Pangei and gave the result as positive test of
the heroin. The investigation reveals that there is a prima
facie evidence to charge against the accused person u/s
21(c) ND & PS Act. So, the accused person is sent up to the
Court of law to stand his trial under the aforesaid section of
law.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |6
Hon’ble Judge is therefore prayed to kindly fixed a date of
hearing at an early date against the accused person u/s 21
(c) ND & PS Act.”
13.
Vide order dated 13th February, 2017, a Charge Sheet
under Section 21(c) of the ND& PS Act was framed against the
appellant in the following terms :“After due consideration of the facts and records of the
prosecution case, I am satisfied that there is prima facie
material for presuming that the Accused Person has
committed that the alleged crime. Hence, this court has
ascertained that there exists ground for framing charge
against the said accused person under Section 21(c) of ND
& PS Act”
14.
The Prosecution, in order to prove its case, produced
the following 6 (six) witnesses :(i) P.W. No. 1 – Irom Bikram Singh
(ii) P.W. No. 2 – Thokchom Ibotombi Singh
(iii) P.W. No. 3 – Oinam Iboton Singh
(iv) P.W. No. 4 – Nongmaithem Robindro
(v) P.W. No. 5 – Soraisam Joychandra Singh.
(vi) P.W. No. 6 – Ashem Chaoba Singh
15.
The Prosecution further exhibited the following
documents/articles :-
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |7
(i) Ext. P/1
- Re-seizure memo dated 01-10-2004.
(ii) Ext. P/2
- O.E. of the case.
(iii) Ext. P/3
- Weighing and seizure memo dated 01-102004.
(iv) Ext. P/4
- Duty of searching officer for conducting the
suspected person dated 01-10-2004.
(v) Ext. P/5
- FIR.
(vi) Ext. P/6
- Source report.
(vii) Ext. P/7
- Go-down receipt dated 01-10-2004.
(viii) Ext. P/8 - Rough sketch map.
(ix) Ext. P/9
- Index of the rough sketch map.
(x) Ext. P/10
- Option for searching dated 01-10-2004.
(xi) Ext. P/11 - Forwarding letter dated 31-10-2005.
(xiii) Ext. P/12 - Examination report being no. 86-CH/2004
FSL (ND & PS)
(a) Ext. M.O.-1 – Paper envelope marked as ‘A’
containing 1040 grams of Heroin
powder.
(b) Ext. M.O.-2 – Envelope marked as ‘A2’ containing
remnant returned from the Director,
FSL, Pangei.
(c) Ext. M.O. -3 – Envelope marked as ‘A1’ containing
5 gm of Heroin powder (original)
(d) Ext. M.O.-4 – A piece of old newspaper.
(e) Ext. M.O.-5 – A bag having mixed colour (black,
white, green, red and yellow)
16.
On conclusion of the examination of the Prosecution’s
witnesses, the appellant’s statement was recorded under Section
313 Cr.P.C.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |8
17.
During the said examination before the trial court, the
appellant answered all the questions put to him, either in the
negative or by stating that he “does not know” except for the
following :“Q7. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 2 namely
Thokchom Ibotombi Singh (complainant) that Ext. P/4 is
the option for search of your (accused) body and
belongings and Ext. P/4(2) is your (accused) signature.
What do you have to say?
Ans: I deny. I put my signature on a blank paper at the police
station situated at Imphal East district.
Q13. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 2 namely
Thokchom Ibotombi Singh (complainant) that you
(accused) were thereafter arrested. What do you have to
say?
Ans: It is true that I was arrested on that day but I do not know
those persons who have arrested me.
Q14. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 2 namely
Thokchom Ibotombi Singh (complainant) that you
(accused) and the said two local witnesses appended
your respective signatures on the said three envelopes.
What do you have to say?
Ans: I put my signature in blank papers. I do not know others.
Q16. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 2 namely
Thokchom Ibotombi Singh (complainant) that Ext. P/3 is
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
Page |9
the seizure list prepared by him and Ext. P/3(1) is your
(accused person’s) signature. What do you have to say?
Ans: I put my signature whatever they have said but in blank
papers.
Q17. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 2 namely
Thokchom Ibotombi Singh (complainant) that you
(accused) along with the seized articles were taken and
handed over to the O.C, Nambol P.S. for further
necessary action. What do you have to say?
Ans: It is true that I was handed over to the O.C, NBL. PS. but
I do not have any idea about the alleged seized articles.
Q34. It is also in the evidence of the P.W. No. 3 namely Oinam
Iboton Singh (1st I.O. of the case) that on 02-10-2004,
you (accused) were produced before the Special Judge
(ND&PS), Imphal with a prayer for 6 days police remand
and the prayer was allowed. What do you have to say?
Ans: It is true.
Q68. Do you have anything more to say in c/w the present
Trial case?
Ans: About 18 years back, when I was passing the IV Road
near Nambol Khoriphaba foothill, I was kidnapped by
about 5 persons and thereafter, I do not know what had
happened.
Q69. Do you like to produce any defence witness ?
Ans: I will give defence witnesses.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 10
The accused produced two defence witnesses inclusive of
himself as follows :
(i)
D.W. No. 1
-
Khwairakpam Romio Singh
(the accused himself).
(ii)
D.W. No. 2
-
Ningthoujam Gobin Singh.
18.
Having heard the learned Special PP for the State as
well as Mr. P. Premchand Singh, learned counsel for the appellant
and considered the oral as well as the documentary evidence and
material placed before the Court, the Special Judge, ND & PS
concluded that the Prosecution had been able to prove beyond
reasonable doubt that the appellant was guilty of having committed
the offence punishable under Section 21 (c) ND&PS Act and
resultantly convicted him vide order dated 13.02.2023 for the
unauthorized possession of 1050 gms of Number 4 (heroin
powder).
19.
Vide the order of sentence dated 13th February, 2023
the appellant was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
a period of 15 (fifteen) years with a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees
one Lakh) only relying on the Supreme Court case reported in
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1457 OF 2021 : Mohd. Zahid Vs State
through NCB supra within a period of 5 years from the date of order
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 11
of sentence, failing which he had to undergo further rigorous
imprisonment of 6 months.
20.
Mr. Gunedhor, learned counsel, appearing on behalf
of the appellant would vehemently urge that the appellant’s right to
be searched before the Magistrate or a Gazetted officer was not
communicated to him by the complainant before conducting the
search of the former’s person thereby violating the provision of
Section 50 of the ND & PS Act and that therefore, the appellant’s
conviction was manifestly erroneous. In other words, it is contended
that, S.I. Thokchom Ibotombi Singh i.e. the complainant, never
informed the appellant of his right to be body searched in the
presence of a Magistrate or a Gazetted officer and consequently
the latter never gave his consent to the former to search his body
and belongings at the spot in the presence of local witnesses in
place of being searched in the presence of a Magistrate or a
Gazetted officer.
21.
The solitary contention urged on behalf of the
appellant does not come to his aid, inasmuch as, the clear and
unrebutted deposition of PW No. 2 clearly brings out as follows :“On 01-10-2004 at about 1:30 pm, I received a special
report that one person was trying to sell out Number 4
(Heroin powder) near Lainingthou Khoriphaba Hill on I.V.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 12
road, Nambol while I along with my party were staying at
my office. I along with my police party rushed towards the
said location after taking formalities from S.P., Imphal East
and found one person standing in a suspicious manner by
holding one polythene bag near the hillside of Lainingthou
Khoriphaba Hill on I.V. road. I then stopped him and asked
about his identity and also enquired about the polythene
bag which he was holding in his right hand. The accused
identified himself as Khwairakpam Romio Singh, aged
about 40 years, S/o (L) Budhi Singh of Nambol Awang
Leikai and also said that the polythene bag belongs to him.
I then informed the accused that he was suspected for
possessing Number 4 (Heroin powder) and also asked him
whether he would like to conduct his body search along
with search of his belongings before a Magistrate or a
Gazetted Officer or any independent witnesses. To which
the accused replied that he may be searched before any
independent witnesses at that very spot i.e. near
Lainingthou Khoriphaba Hill on I.V. road, Nambol.
Accordingly, I conducted body search of the accused along
with his belongings by calling upon two persons from the
nearby area to be witnesses of the body search and the
belongings of the accused by preparing option for search
u/s 50 ND & PS Act.”
22.
The unrebutted testimony of PW No. 2 is further
corroborated by the testimony of PW No. 4 who deposed as
follows :-
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 13
“Nongmaithem Robindro, aged about 45 years, S/o
N. Ibotomba, a resident of Top Moirang Kampu Makha
Leikai and A/P Thangmeiband Hijam Leikai, District
Imphal West.
My particulars are stated above. I am a goldsmith
by profession.
I know the accused person who is now in the dock.
On 01-10-2004, at about 3:00 pm, while I was along
the IV road of Nambol near the western side of Lainingthou
Khoiriphaba foothill, one police personal who identified
himself as SI Ph. Ibotombi Singh, the then O.C., Special
Investigation Unit (SIU) and his police party stopped one
person who was holding one bag in his right hand. The
person identified himself as Khwairakpam Romio Singh,
S/o Kh. Budhi Singh of Nambol Awang Leikai. The said SI
Ibotombi Singh asked for Romio that he was suspected for
possession of Heroin powder and further asked him
whether he would like conduct his body search and
belongings before a Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer or
any independent witness(es). Then, he (Romio) replied that
his body and his belongings might be searched before any
independent witness at the very spot.
Thereafter, the said SI Ibotombi Singh conducted
check/search of the bag belonging to the said Romio (the
said bag was a mixed colour of black, white, green, red and
yellow) in presence of I myself and one Kamei Aching, S/o
(L) K. Paoling of Langol Laimanai. On opening the said
bag, found one transparent plastic packet containing
Heroin No. 4 powder. The said plastic packet was marked
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 14
as “Sunflower” with one symbol. The said plastic packet
was covered by a piece of newspaper. On weighing, it was
found of 1050 gram including the weight of the container
and it was marked as ‘A’. From the said 1050 gm, the said
SI took out 5 gm each of Heroin powder for original and
duplicate sample respectively. After taking out the 5 gm
each from the said 1050 gm, 1040 gm was remaining. The
said and 1040 gm and 5 gm each was put in separate
envelopes and packed and sealed and marked as ‘A’, ‘A1’
& ‘A2’ respectively. I myself and the said Kamei Aching put
our signatures on the envelopes. Then the SI Ibotombi
Singh prepared a weighing and seizure list dated 01-102004 at 2:30 pm at near Lainingthou Khoiriphaba Ching
on I.V. Road for the seizure of : (i) On transparent plastic
packet marking as SUNFLOWER with SUNFLOWER
symbol containing No. 4 powder, (ii) A piece of old
newspaper, (iii) One polythene bag having mixed colour
(black, white, green, red and yellow) in presence of two
witnesses. I and Kamei Aching put our signatures on the
said weighing and seizure list and Kh. Romio Singh also
put his signature on the said weighing and seizure list.
The said S.I. Ibotombi Singh also prepared a duty
of searching officer for conducting of suspected person
under Section 50 ND&PS Act dated 01-10-2004 place –
near Lainingthou Khoiriphaba Ching on I.V. Road. I and
Kamei Aching also put our signatures on the said duty of
searching officer for conducting of suspected person under
Section 50 ND&PS Act and the accused Kh. Romio Singh
also put his signature on the same.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 15
An option for searching dated 01-10-2004 place –
near Lainingthou Khoiriphaba Ching on I.V. Road was
also prepared by the S.I. Ibotombi in our presence. I and
Kamei Aching also put our signatures on the said option
for searching and the accused Kh. Romio Singh also put his
signature on the same.”
23.
It was also urged, albeit without conviction, on behalf
of the appellant that the weighing scale on which the heroin number
4 powder was purportedly weighed was not produced before the
trial court.
24.
Having heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the appellant as well as upon consideration of the evidence
produced on behalf of the Prosecution, the following are selfevident :i)
that the appellant was found standing in a suspicious
manner whilst holding one polythene bag near the hill
side of Lainingthou Khoiriphaba Ching on I.V. Road,
Nambol on the 1st October, 2004;
ii)
that the complainant upon receipt of a special report,
rushed to the spot and asked the appellant about his
identity as well as about the polythene bag, the latter
was holding in his right hand;
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 16
iii)
that the appellant identified himself as Khwairakpam
Romio Singh and also stated that the polythene bag
belongs to him;
iv)
that the complainant then informed the appellant that
the latter was suspected for possessing Number 4
heroin powder and also informed him whether he
would like to his body search as well as the search of
his belongings to be conducted before the Magistrate
or a Gazetted Officer or any independent witnesses;
v)
that the appellant replied that he may be searched at
the very spot before any independent witnesses;
vi)
that the complainant conducted the body search as
well as the search of the polythene bag belonging to
the appellant in the presence of two witnesses from
the nearby area;
vii)
that the said polythene bag having mixed (black,
white, green, red and yellow) led to the discovery of
one transparent plastic packet containing Number 4
(Heroin Powder) with a marking as “Sunflower with a
symbol (picture) and with a marking of “one Kg and
90%” which was covered with a piece of old
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 17
newspaper. On weighing the same by using the police
weighing scale, it was found weighing “1,050 gms.”
(one thousand and fifty grams) including the weight of
the container and the same was marked as “A”. Out
of the said marked ‘A’, two 5 gms (five grams) each of
Number 4 (heroin powder) i.e. one for original and
other for duplicate samples were extracted. The said
two samples were marked as “A-1” and ‘A-2’
respectively. The two samples of Number 4 (heroin
powder) and the remaining powder i.e. marked as ‘A’
weighing 1,040 gms were put in three separate
envelopes. weighing 1040 gms which were put in
three separate envelopes, packed and sealed in the
presence of the aforesaid witnesses.
viii)
that the appellant was thereafter arrested and
appended his signatures on the three separate
envelopes in the presence of the said witnesses who
also put their signatures on the said three envelopes.
The appellant along with the seized articles i.e. original
and duplicate samples of Number 4 heroin powder
were brought to Nambol Police Station and handed
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 18
over to OC/Nambol PS for taking further necessary
legal action accordingly;
ix)
that
the seized Number 4 heroin powder was re-
seized on the complainant’s production by the I.O. of
the case;
x)
that, upon completion of the investigation, a Charge
Sheet No. 2/2008 dated 17th June, 2015 was
submitted against the appellant for the alleged
commission of the offences punishable under Section
21(c) ND&PS Act;
xi)
that the testimony of PW No. 2 has been fully
corroborated by the testimony of PW No. 4
establishing that 1050 gms of Number 4 heroin
powder was seized from the possession of the
appellant in the presence of two witnesses of which
PW No. 4 was one;
xii)
that PW No. 4 also identified the signatures of the
other seizure witness namely Kamei Aching;
xiii)
that the report of the Forensic Science Laboratory
(FSL),
Pangei
Manipur
proved
by
Soraisam
Joychandra Singh, Director of Forensic Laboratory,
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 19
Manipur PW No. 5 established that the substance
seized from the appellant “gave positive rest for
heroin”;
xiv)
that the appellant did not dispute the expert opinion
rendered by PW No. 5 nor report of the FSL being Ext.
P/12 No. 86-CH/2004 FSL (NDPS) dated 31st October,
2005;
xv)
that the appellant who entered the dock as DW No. 1
himself deposed that he had put his signature on Ext.
P-3, Ext. P-4 and Ext. P-10 and Ext. P-14 and further
deposed that he was arrested by the police personnel
from Lainingthou Khoriba Hill at I.V. Road, Nambol on
1st October, 2004; the appellant also testified that Ext.
M.O.-5 is the polythene bag seized from him by the
police personnel at the time of his arrest upon seizure
of number 4 heroin powder from his possession;
xvi)
that DW No. 2 namely, Ningthoujam Gobin Singh also
deposed during his cross-examination that the
appellant was arrested by the police from near
Lainingthou Khoriba Hill on the 1st October, 2004.
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
P a g e | 20
25.
In view of the foregoing discussion, I find myself in
complete agreement with the finding arrived at by the learned
Special Court that, the Prosecution has been able to prove beyond
reasonable doubt that the appellant committed the offence
punishable under Section 21(c) of the ND&PS Act.
26.
Therefore, I am of the view that the impugned
judgment and order dated 08.02.2023 and order and sentence
dated 13.02.2023 respectively suffer from no infirmity so as to
warrant any interference in appeal by this Court.
27.
The appeal being devoid of merit is accordingly
dismissed and the orders dated 08.02.2023 and 13.02.2023
respectively are hereby upheld.
28.
Copy be sent to the accused; Superintendent, Central
Jail, Sajiwa for information and compliance.
29.
Announced in the open court on 14.06.2024.
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
Crl. A. No. 4 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review