The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. 06.2023 on the ground that he was compelled to seek voluntary retirement on the same day his permission to maintain a beard was revoked with immediate effect. The vindictiveness of Respondent No. 5 is manifest from the fact that the petitioner's voluntary retirement application was accepted on the very day of its submission. Furthermore, when the petitioner submitted an application to withdraw his retirement request the following day (17.06.2023), but it was rejected. The petitioner asserts that the respondents passed the impugned order in outright violation of statutory rules, rendering it legally unsustainable. 5) The respondents have filed their response stating therein that the impugned order dated 16th June, 2023, was passed by the Commandant 50 BN BSF, Praharinagar, Tura (Meghalaya) whereby the voluntary retirement of the petitioner was accepted by the respondents on the explicit consent of the petitioner. Therefore, the cause of action, if any, has accrued to the petitioner beyond the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. It is stated that the petitioner was enrolled in the BSF as a Constable on 16.03.1998 and was placed under low medical category on 26th June, 2018, which became permanent on 4th March, 2022. It is stated that the petitioner has 13 bad entries to his credit under various sections of the BSF Act including AWL, OSL, Intoxication, falsifying official reco…
17. In the light of the aforesaid propositions of law when the instant case is examined, it becomes evident that the facts pleaded in the writ petition do not indicate or demonstrate that the cause of action or part thereof or even a fraction of cause of action which is integral or material to the lis between the parties has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The allegations which are being enquired into by the respondents pertain to the period when the petitioner was posted as Commandant 11th Bn under Sector HQ Gangtok of Eastern Frontier. The acts or omissions alleged against the petitioners have been committed outside the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The Court of Inquiry, Record of Evidence and the order convening the General Force Court etc., have been passed by the authorities not located anywhere in Jammu and Kashmir. Simply because the petitioner is posted in Jammu and Kashmir and has been informed of the action envisaged against him in the UT of Jammu and Kashmir is not sufficient to vest the jurisdiction in this Court to entertain the petition. The communications issued to the petitioners informing him about the action initiated against him sent to his address in Jammu and Kashmir do not, by any stretch of reasoning, constitute integral part of cause of action sufficient enough to clothe this Court with the territorial jurisdiction to ente…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 26.09.2026
Pronounced on: 30.09.2026
Uploaded on: 30.09.2026
Whether the operative part
or
full
judgment
is
pronounced:
Full
WP(C) No.2936/2024
KHURSHEED AHMAD KHAN
...PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Ateeb Kanth, Advocate.
Vs.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI, with
Mr. Faizan Ali, CGC.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner has filed this petition for quashing the
order dated 16.06.2023 passed by respondent No.5, whereby
voluntary retirement of the petitioner from service has been
accepted and the petitioner has been struck of the strength
of the Unit with effect from 16th June, 2023 (AN).
2)
The petitioner, a devout religious person, was initially
permitted to maintain a neatly trimmed beard in terms of
order dated 6th January, 2018. However, this permission was
revoked with immediate effect by an order dated June 16,
WP(C) 2936/2024
2023. According to the petitioner, this sudden revocation
prompted
him
to
apply
for
voluntary
retirement.
Remarkably, his application was accepted on June 16, 2023,
the very day it was submitted.
3)
The petitioner thereafter submitted a representation to
respondents, whereby he sought to withdraw his request for
voluntary retirement and in terms of order dated, 5th July,
2023, the said application for withdrawal of the voluntary
retirement was rejected and he was directed to take pension
and not to resume duties. The petitioner further submits
that he again approached the respondents with a request
that the permission granted to the petitioner for keeping the
beard was cancelled due to vindictiveness, and the petitioner
was compelled to seek voluntary retirement, but that
application was yet again rejected. Thereafter the petitioner
made a formal representation with the Director General of
BSF on 19.07.2024 but the said representation was not
considered by the respondents and his pension was fixed
forcibly without his consent.
4)
The petitioner assails the impugned order dated
16.06.2023 on the ground that he was compelled to seek
voluntary retirement on the same day his permission to
maintain a beard was revoked with immediate effect. The
WP(C) 2936/2024
vindictiveness of Respondent No. 5 is manifest from the fact
that the petitioner's voluntary retirement application was
accepted on the very day of its submission. Furthermore,
when the petitioner submitted an application to withdraw
his retirement request the following day (17.06.2023), but it
was rejected. The petitioner asserts that the respondents
passed the impugned order in outright violation of statutory
rules, rendering it legally unsustainable.
5)
The respondents have filed their response stating
therein that the impugned order dated 16th June, 2023, was
passed by the Commandant 50 BN BSF, Praharinagar, Tura
(Meghalaya) whereby the voluntary retirement of the
petitioner was accepted by the respondents on the explicit
consent of the petitioner. Therefore, the cause of action, if
any, has accrued to the petitioner beyond the territorial
jurisdiction of this Court. It is stated that the petitioner was
enrolled in the BSF as a Constable on 16.03.1998 and was
placed under low medical category on 26th June, 2018,
which became permanent on 4th March, 2022. It is stated
that the petitioner has 13 bad entries to his credit under
various sections of the BSF Act including AWL, OSL,
Intoxication, falsifying official records, neglecting to obey
general/local orders, failing to appear at a time and place
WP(C) 2936/2024
fixed for parade. It is further stated that pursuant to the
request made by him, the petitioner was allowed to keep
beard but duly trimmed, neat and tidy in terms of order
dated 6th January, 2018. It is stated that after the Zero
Parade, the petitioner conveyed his desire to proceed on
voluntary
retirement
immediately
and
submitted
an
application to that effect. The petitioner was subsequently
heard by the Commandant, as his appointing authority in
presence
of the Adjt, the SM and in the hearing of
the
Battalion Subordinate Officer, the petitioner was pointedly
asked if his decision was made under some duress or any
other compulsion, which he expressly denied. The whole
proceedings have been
duly recorded in the concerned
register. The petitioner had clearly cited his mother’s illness
and his own inability to endure difficult service conditions
given his medical status and weak body, to be the reasons
behind preferring
retirement and while considering his
physical and mental state, past service record and the recent
conduct as also his insistence on accepting his request, the
competent authority being satisfied that the curtailment of
the period of notice of three months will not cause any
administrative inconvenience, relaxed the requirement of
notice of three months and accepted the voluntary
retirement of the petitioner with immediate effect. It is also
WP(C) 2936/2024
stated that on 16th June, 2023, the petitioner was found to
be utterly shabbily dressed with long free-flowing beard
which was not only violative of the order dated 6th January,
2018, but also not in consonance with the directions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case titled “Md. Zubair vs.
Union of India” and in order to maintain discipline and
decorum of the Force, the permission to keep beard was
revoked in terms of order dated 16.06.2023. The petitioner
had even refused to trim his beard. It is the stand of the
respondents that all rules and regulations were followed
before accepting the voluntary retirement of the petitioner.
6)
Heard and perused the record.
7)
The respondents have raised a preliminary objection
with regard to lack of territorial jurisdiction of this Court to
entertain the instant writ petition. It is evident from the
record that the application was submitted by the petitioner
to the respondents for voluntary retirement at a place which
is situated beyond the territorial jurisdiction of this Court
and the order impugned in this petition was also passed at
Tura Meghalaya which is also beyond the territorial
jurisdiction of this Court, as such, this Court is of the
considered view that no cause of action has accrued with in
the territorial jurisdiction of this court and this court does
WP(C) 2936/2024
not have the territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present
petition and adjudicate the same.
8)
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that since
the Inspector General, BSF, Kashmir, has been arrayed as a
party, this Court possesses territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the writ petition. However, a perusal of the record
reveals that the Inspector General, BSF, Kashmir, has no
nexus with the controversy at hand. Indeed, the material
respondent arrayed in the present petition is the Inspector
General, BSF, Shillong.
9)
The petitioner’s contention that the Director General,
BSF, New Delhi, is subject to the jurisdiction of any High
Court across India is equally unmeritorious. Under Article
226 of the Constitution, territorial jurisdiction is contingent
upon the cause of action, wholly or in part, arising within
the local limits of the concerned High Court.
10)
As already mentioned above, no cause of action has
accrued to the petitioner within the territorial jurisdiction of
this Court, and this Court lacks the territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the present writ petition.
11)
In Rajesh Kumar Tomar Versus Union of India &
Ors., JKJ ONLINE 6983616, the co-ordinate Bench has held
as under:
WP(C) 2936/2024
“16.From the aforesaid judgments of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, the following
prepositions can be culled out on the issue of
territorial jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution:
(i) That there is two fold limitations on the power
of the High Court to issue writs under Article 226
of the Constitution;
(a) The power is to be exercised throughout the
territories in relation to which the High Court
exercises jurisdiction i.e. the writs issued by the
Courts cannot run beyond the territories subject
to its jurisdiction
(b) A person or authority to whom the High Court
is empowered to issue such writs must be
within those territories which clearly implies
that they must be amenable to its jurisdiction
either by residence or location within those
territories.
(This was the position of law till the
Constitutional (Fifteenth Amendment) Act,
1963 whereby the concept of cause of action
was introduced by adding clause (2) to Article
226 of the Constitution).
(ii) that the High Court was also conferred the
jurisdiction in relation to the territories within
which;
(a) cause of action, wholly or in part arises; and
(b) even a fraction of cause of action is a part of
cause of action and is sufficient enough to vest
the jurisdiction in the High Court, provided it
arises within the territories in relation to which
the High Court exercises its jurisdiction;
(iii) cause of action or part thereof or fraction of
cause of action must be one which is material,
integral or essential part of the lis.
17. In the light of the aforesaid propositions of
law when the instant case is examined, it
becomes evident that the facts pleaded in the
writ petition do not indicate or demonstrate that
the cause of action or part thereof or even a
fraction of cause of action which is integral or
material to the lis between the parties has
arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this
Court. The allegations which are being enquired
WP(C) 2936/2024
into by the respondents pertain to the period
when the petitioner was posted as
Commandant 11th Bn under Sector HQ Gangtok
of Eastern Frontier. The acts or omissions
alleged against the petitioners have been
committed outside the territorial jurisdiction of
this Court. The Court of Inquiry, Record of
Evidence and the order convening the General
Force Court etc., have been passed by the
authorities not located anywhere in Jammu and
Kashmir. Simply because the petitioner is
posted in Jammu and Kashmir and has been
informed of the action envisaged against him in
the UT of Jammu and Kashmir is not sufficient to
vest the jurisdiction in this Court to entertain the
petition. The communications issued to the
petitioners informing him about the action
initiated against him sent to his address in
Jammu and Kashmir do not, by any stretch of
reasoning, constitute integral part of cause of
action sufficient enough to clothe this Court
with the territorial jurisdiction to entertain this
petition.”
12)
In “Zahoor Ahmad Baba v. Union of India & Ors. 2012
(3) JKJ 119[HC], it has been held that only the Court
having territorial jurisdiction over the place where the
dismissal order was made can entertain the writ petition
challenging such dismissal order. It was further held that
the mere fact that the petitioner had received copy of the
impugned order at Ganderbal within the jurisdiction of this
Court does not confer jurisdiction upon this Court to
entertain and deal with the petition.
13)
A similar view has been taken by the Coordinate Bench
of this Court in Shahnawaz Ahmad v. Union of India &
Ors., JKJ ONLINE 84560.
WP(C) 2936/2024
14)
Further a Division Bench of this Court in the of Tirath
Ram vs. Union of India and Ors., JKJ Online 89042, has,
in para 7, observed that the cause of action or part thereof
or even a fraction thereof must be relatable to the lis and
must form material, integral or essential part thereof and
once the cause of action or part thereof has not accrued
within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court, the Court
lacks jurisdiction to adjudicate the petition.
15)
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered view
that this Court lacks territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the
petition at hand and, accordingly, the same is dismissed,
leaving the petitioner free to approach the jurisdictional
Court for redressal of his grievances.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Srinagar,
30.09.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable:
WP(C) 2936/2024
YES
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review