Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010513182025
2026:CGHC:34392-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 13626 of 2025
Order reserved on 22/07/2026
Order delivered on 06/08/2026
Mohan Lal Ratre S/o Kaliram Ratre Aged About 37 Years Working As Forest
Guard, R/o Bhaneshar Mission, Post - Jairamnagar, Tahsil - Masturi, District
- Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Petitioner
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Forest,
Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Principal Conservator Of Forest Aranya Bhawan, Medical College
Road, Raipur, District - Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The Chief Conservator Of Forest Bilaspur Circle, District - Bilaspur
(C.G.)
4 - The Divisional Forest Officer Bilaspur, District - Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 34 of 2026
1 - Khem Singh Rajput S/o Hazari Rajput, Aged About 33 Years R/o Village
And Post Sardha, Tahsil Lormi, District- Mungeli (C.G.)
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.08.06
18:56:47 +0530
2 - Ramawtar Tiwari S/o Keshav Prasad Tiwari Aged About 53 Years R/o
Lig - 122 Deendayal Colony, Parsada (Bharni) P.O. Bharni District- Bilaspur
(C.G.)
3 - Tukesh Kumar Sahu S/o Devcharan Sahu Aged About 36 Years R/o
Village Saber Post Sel, Tahsil Kasdol, District- Balodabazar- Bhatapara
(C.G.)
4 - Bhagat Singh Markam S/o Kejuram Markam Aged About 33 Years R/o
Village Dawanpur, Tahsil Kota, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
5 - Ravindra Kumar Mahilange S/o Shivkumar Mahilange Aged About 33
Years R/o A-12 Nature City, Uslapur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
---Petitioners
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Forest,
Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya Naya Raipur District- Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Principal Conservator Of Forest Aranya Bhawan, Medical College
Road, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The Chief Conservator Of Forest Bilaspur Circle, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
4 - The Deputy Director Achanakmar Tiger Reserve Mungeli DistrictMungeli (C.G.)
5 - The Divisional Forest Officer Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
6 - The Divisional Forest Officer Forest Division Katghora, District- Korba
(C.G.)
7 - The Divisional Forest Officer Research And Extension Forest Division
Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 1105 of 2026
Vinod Kumar Raj S/o Budhwar Singh Aged About 34 Years Resident Of
Village- Nawapara, Police Station- Katghora, District- Korba (C.G.)
---Petitioner
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Forest,
Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Principal Conservator Of Forest Aranya Bhawan, Medical College
Road, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The Chief Conservator Of Forest Bilaspur Circle, District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
4 - The Divisional Forest Officer Katghora, District- Korba (C.G.)
... Respondents
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioners
: Mr. Goutam Khetrapal, Advocate
For Respondents/State
: Mr. Prasun Bhaduri, Deputy A.G.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
C.A.V. Order
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
1.
In WPS No. 13626 of 2025, the petitioner has sought the following
reliefs:
“a) This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
Quash
and
set
aside
the
circular
dated
31.07.2014 issued by the Respondent, as being
arbitrary, unconstitutional, and ultra vires to the
provisions of Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule
IV of the Chhattisgarh Forest Service Recruitment
Rules, 2012.
b) Quash the impugned order dated 25.09.2025
passed by the Chief Conservator of Forests,
Bilaspur
Circle,
rejecting
the
representation dated 18.09.2025.
Petitioner's
c) Direct the respondents to prepare fresh
gradation list of Forest Guard placing the
petitioner at appropriate place on the basis of his
merit, in accordance with the statutory governing
Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule IV of the
Chhattisgarh Forest Service Recruitment Rules,
2012.
d) pass any other order(s) that may be deemed fit
and just in the facts and circumstances of the
case including awarding of the costs to the
petitioner.”
2.
In this WPS No. 13626 of 2025, the petitioner was appointed as a
Forest Guard on 05.01.2013 through a regular recruitment process
conducted
under
the
Chhattisgarh
Class
III
Forest
Service
Recruitment Rules, 2012 (in short Recruitment Rules 2012), and was
initially posted in Udanti Forest Division, Gariaband. Subsequently,
on administrative grounds, he was transferred on 23.08.2019 to
Bilaspur circle and joined his duties on 05.12.2019.
3.
In WPS No. 34 of 2026, the petitioners have sought the following
reliefs:
“a) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to quash and set aside the circular dated
31.07.2014 issued by the Respondent, as being
arbitrary, unconstitutional, and ultra vires to the
provisions of Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule
IV of the Chhattisgarh Forest Service Recruitment
Rules, 2012.
b) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to quash the impugned order dated 25.09.2025
passed by the Chief Conservator of Forests,
Bilaspur
Circle,
rejecting
the
Petitioners'
representation.
c) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to direct the respondents to prepare fresh
gradation list of Forest Guard placing the
petitioners at appropriate place on the basis of
their merit, in accordance with the statutory
governing Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule IV
of the Chhattisgarh Forest Service Recruitment
Rules, 2012.
d) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to pass any other order(s) that may be deemed fit
and just in the facts and circumstances of the
case including awarding of the costs to the
petitioners.”
4.
In this WPS No. 34 of 2026, all the petitioners were initially appointed
on 05.01.2013 and were posted at Udanti Forest Division, Gariaband.
Subsequently, on administrative grounds, the petitioners No. 1 to 4
were transferred on 14.08.2017 and their place of transfer are as
follows:******* The petitioner No.1 Khem Singh Rajput was transferred from
Bhoramdeo Range, Wildlife Sanctuary Forest Division, Kawardha to
Lormi Buffer Range, Achanakmar Tiger Reserve, Lormi.
******* The petitioner No.2 Ramawtar Tiwari was transferred from
Baloda Bazar Range, Forest Division, Baloda Bazar to Kanan
Pendari, Mini Zoo, Bilaspur.
******* The petitioner No.3 Tukesh Kumar Sahu was transferred from
Bhanwartonk Beat, Bhoramdeo Range, Forest Division, Kawardha to
Forest Research and Development Division, Bilaspur, Akaltara Unit.
******* The petitioner No.4 Bharat Singh Markam was transferred
from Bhoramdeo Range, Wildlife Sanctuary, Forest Division,
Kawardha to
Lormi Buffer Range, Achanakmar Tiger Reserve,
Lormi.
******* The petitioner No.5 Ravindra Kumar Mahilange was
transferred on 08.11.2019 from Devtidand Beat, Devgarh Range,
Forest Division, Koriya to Bilaspur Forest Division.
5.
In WPS No. 1105 of 2026, the petitioner has sought the following
reliefs:
“a) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to quash and set aside the circular dated
31.07.2014 issued by the Respondent, as being
arbitrary, unconstitutional, and ultra vires to the
provisions of Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule
IV of the Chhattisgarh Forest Service Recruitment
Rules, 2012.
b) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to quash the impugned order dated 25.09.2025
passed by the Chief Conservator of Forests,
Bilaspur Circle, rejecting the Petitioner's request
for assigning proper seniority.
c) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to direct the respondents to prepare fresh
gradation list of Forest Guard placing the petitioner
at appropriate place on the basis of his merit, in
accordance with the statutory governing Rules 14
and 15 read with Schedule IV of the Chhattisgarh
Forest Service Recruitment Rules, 2012.
d) That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to pass any other order(s) that may be deemed fit
and just in the facts and circumstances of the case
including awarding of the costs to the petitioner.”
6.
In this WPS No. 1105 of 2026, the petitioner was appointed as a
Forest Guard on 05.01.2013 through a regular recruitment process
conducted
under
the
Chhattisgarh
Class
III
Forest
Service
Recruitment Rules, 2012 (in short Recruitment Rules 2012), and was
initially posted in Udanti Forest Division, Gariaband. Subsequently,
on administrative grounds, he was transferred on 30.07.2016 to
Katghora Forest circle.
7.
According to the petitioners, under Rules 14 and 15 of the
Recruitment Rules, 2012, seniority and eligibility for promotion are
required to be determined on the basis of merit, suitability and the
statutory criteria prescribed therein, and not on account of an
administrative transfer. It is the petitioners case that although the
Principal Chief Conservator of Forests had directed preparation of a
consolidated merit list of newly appointed Forest Guards on the basis
of marks obtained in the recruitment examination, their marks were
not reflected in the gradation lists published from the year 2021
onwards, resulting in an incorrect fixation of their seniority. Upon
verification initiated by the Bilaspur Division, the Gariaband Division
eventually forwarded the petitioners respective recruitment marks.
Despite the availability of the said records, the gradation list
published as on 01.09.2025 continued to place the petitioners at a
lower position with the remark that they had been transferred from
another circle, allegedly ignoring their original merit position.
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners submitted detailed representation
seeking correction of their seniority in accordance with the
Recruitment Rules, 2012. However, the said representations came to
be rejected on 25.09.2025 by placing reliance upon the Government
circular dated 31.07.2014, which provides that an employee
transferred from one circle to another shall be placed at the bottom of
the seniority list in the transferee circle. The petitioners stand is that
the said executive circular cannot override the statutory provisions of
the Recruitment Rules, 2012, and that the impugned orders rejecting
their claim for correction of seniority is arbitrary, illegal and liable to
be quashed.
9.
In rejoinder, the petitioners denied the stand taken by the
respondents and reiterated that the impugned action is founded
solely on an executive circular dated 31.07.2014, which cannot
override the statutory provisions of the Recruitment Rules, 2012. It
has been averred that the petitioners, being direct recruits transferred
only on administrative grounds, cannot be treated as transferee
recruits so as to be placed at the bottom of the seniority list. The
petitioners have further averred that their recruitment merit has
already been verified by the competent authority and that the
alteration of their seniority solely on account of transfer is arbitrary,
violative of the statutory scheme governing seniority and promotion,
and prejudicial to their promotional prospects. It has, therefore, been
prayed that the impugned circular dated 31.07.2014 and the
consequential order dated 25.09.2025 rejecting their representations
be quashed.
10.
The respondents/state have opposed the writ petitions with the
averments that the petitioners representations were rightly rejected in
terms of Clause 5 of the Government Circular dated 31.07.2014,
which governs inter-circle transfers of Forest Department employees.
It has been averred in the return that the said circular, issued in
continuation of the earlier circular dated 10.09.1986, provides that an
employee transferred from one forest circle to another, whether on
administrative, mutual or voluntary grounds, shall have his seniority
determined in accordance with Rule 12(2)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil
Services (General Conditions of Service) Rules, 1961, and shall
consequently be placed below all direct recruits and promotees
selected on the same occasion in the transferee circle. According to
the respondents/state, the petitioners, having been transferred from
Gariaband Circle to Bilaspur Circle on administrative grounds in the
year 2019, have rightly been assigned seniority in accordance with
the aforesaid circular and the applicable service rules.
11.
The respondents have further pleaded that the petitioners have
misconstrued the scope of the Recruitment Rules, 2012. According to
the respondents, the 2012 Rules deal exclusively with recruitment
and do not regulate inter-circle transfers or fixation of seniority upon
transfer. It has been submitted that Rules 14 and 15 of the 2012
Rules pertain to preparation of the promotion/selection list for the
post of Forester and cannot be relied upon to determine the seniority
of a transferred Forest Guard. Placing reliance upon Rule 3 of the
2012 Rules, it has been argued that the said Rules operate subject to
the provisions of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (General Conditions
of Service) Rules, 1961, and therefore the impugned circular dated
31.07.2014 is consistent with the statutory framework. On the
aforesaid grounds, the respondents have prayed for dismissal of the
writ petitions.
12.
Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that the petitioners
were appointed as a Forest Guards on 05.01.2013 through a regular
process of direct recruitment under the Recruitment Rules, 2012 and
were initially posted in Udanti Forest Division, Gariaband. Thereafter,
on administrative grounds,they were transferred to Bilaspur Circle by
order dated 23.08.2019 without any fault attributable to them. It is
argued that the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, by circular
dated 29.05.2013, had directed preparation of a consolidated merit
list of all newly appointed Forest Guards at the Circle level on the
basis of marks secured in the recruitment process. Although the
petitioners recruitment marks were subsequently verified by the
competent authority and communicated by the Divisional Forest
Officer, Gariaband, vide letter dated 08.09.2025 showing their
respective recruitment marks, the respondents failed to accord them
seniority in accordance with their merit. Instead, while publishing the
gradation list as on 01.09.2025, the respondents placed the
petitioners at Serial No. 321 with the remark " अन्य वृत्त से स्थानांतरण",
solely because they had been transferred from another Circle. The
petitioners representation dated 18.09.2025 seeking correction of
their seniority was rejected on 25.09.2025 by placing exclusive
reliance on Clause 5 of the Government circular dated 31.07.2014,
without considering the statutory Recruitment Rules, the verified
recruitment marks of the petitioners or the earlier circular dated
29.05.2013.
13.
Learned counsel would further argued that Clause 5 of the circular
dated 31.07.2014, which mandates that an employee transferred
from one Circle to another, even on administrative grounds, shall be
placed below all direct recruits and promotees of the relevant year in
the transferee Circle, is contrary to the statutory scheme contained in
Rules 14 and 15 read with Schedule IV of the Chhattisgarh Class III
Forest Service Recruitment Rules, 2012. It is argued that the
Recruitment Rules, having been framed under the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution, have statutory force and cannot be
overridden by an executive circular. Once the merit position of a
directly recruited Forest Guards has been determined in the selection
process and a consolidated merit list has been directed to be
maintained by the circular dated 29.05.2013, such merit cannot be
nullified merely because of an administrative transfer, which is an
incident of service. It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned
circular dated 31.07.2014, to the extent it places transferred
employees at the bottom of the seniority list, is arbitrary and violative
of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, and consequently
the order dated 25.09.2025 rejecting the petitioner's representation is
unsustainable in law and deserves to be quashed with a
consequential direction to re-fix the petitioner's seniority on the basis
of their recruitment merit.
14.
Per contra, learned State counsel would support the impugned orders
and submit that the petitioners representation has been rightly
rejected in terms of Clause 5 of the Government circular dated
31.07.2014, which uniformly governs the fixation of seniority of
employees transferred from one Forest Circle to another, whether on
administrative, mutual or voluntary grounds. It is argued that the
petitioners, though initially appointed in Gariaband Circle on
05.01.2013, were transferred to Bilaspur Circle on administrative
grounds by order dated 23.08.2019 and, therefore, their seniority in
the transferee Circle is required to be determined in accordance with
Rule 12(2)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (General Conditions
of Service) Rules, 1961, as specifically incorporated by the aforesaid
circular. Learned State counsel would further submit that the
Recruitment Rules, 2012 regulate only the process of recruitment and
do not govern fixation of seniority upon inter-circle transfer. Rules 14
and 15 of the 2012 Rules pertain to preparation of the selection list
for promotion to the post of Forester and have no application to the
petitioners claim. It is, therefore, argued that the petitioners have
misread the statutory provisions; the circular dated 31.07.2014 is
consistent with the applicable service rules and has been uniformly
implemented
to
maintain
administrative
consistency,
and
consequently the writ petitions, being devoid of merit, deserve to be
dismissed.
15.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material annexed with the petition and gone through their pleadings.
16.
Having considered the rival submissions and upon perusal of the
record, the main question which falls for consideration is whether
employees who have been appointed by way of direct recruitment
and whose inter se merit has been determined in accordance with the
statutory Recruitment Rules can be relegated to the bottom of the
seniority list in the transferee Circle merely because they have been
transferred on administrative grounds by invoking Clause 5 of the
Government Circular dated 31.07.2014. The petitioners were
admittedly appointed as Forest Guards through a regular recruitment
process under the Chhattisgarh Class III Forest Service Recruitment
Rules, 2012. It is equally undisputed that their transfer from
Gariaband Circle to Bilaspur Circle was not on account of any
misconduct or at their own volition, but on administrative grounds. It
is also not in dispute that their respective recruitment marks were
subsequently verified by the competent authority and communicated
to the Bilaspur Division. Despite the said verification, their placement
in the gradation list has been determined solely on the basis of the
impugned circular, treating them as transferred employees and not
on the basis of their merit determined at the time of recruitment.
17.
The method of recruitment is provided in Rule 6 of the Rules of 2012,
which is necessary to be reproduced here:“6. Method of Recruitment.(1)
Recruitment
to
the
Service,
after
the
commencement of these rules, shall be made by
the following methods, namely:-
(a) By direct recruitment on the basis of
competitive examination or by selection on
the basis of merit and interview;
(b) By promotion of the members of the
Service as specified in column (3) of
Schedule IV;
(c) By transfer/Deputation of persons, who
hold in substantive/substitutive capacity,
such posts in such services as may be
specified in this behalf.”
18.
Rule 14 provides the conditions of eligibility for promotion and Rule
15 provides preparation of list of suitable candidates, which reads as
under:“14. Conditions of Eligibility for Promotion.The committee shall consider the cases of all
persons who on the 1ˢᵗ day of January of that
year had completed such number of years of the
service (Whether officiating or substantive) in the
posts from which promotion is to be made or any
other post or posts declared equivalent thereto by
the Government, as specified in column (5) of
Schedule-IV
and
are
within
the
zone
of
consideration in accordance with the provisions of
sub-rule (2).
Explanation(1) Manner of computation for eligibility for
promotion - The calculation of period of qualifying
service on 1st January of the relevant year in
which
Departmental
Promotion
Committee/
Screening Committee is convened shall be
counted from the Calendar year in which the
public servant has joined the feeding cadre/part of
the service/pay scale of the post and not from the
date of joining of the cadre/part of the service/pay
scale of post.
(2) The reservation in promotion shall be made in
accordance with the provision of Chhattisgarh Lok
Seva (Padonnati) Niyam, 2003.
(3) Promotion shall be made as per Reservation
Roster prescribed by the Government.
(4)
The
Foresters
who
have
successfully
completed prescribed training for Forester from
training school of the state will be eligible for the
promotion on the post of Deputy Ranger.
15. Preparation of list of suitable candidate.(1) The Departmental Promotion Committee shall
prepare a list of such persons who satisfy the
conditions prescribed in rule 14 above and as are
held by the Committee to be suitable for
promotion to the service, the list shall be sufficient
to cover the anticipated vacancies on account of
retirement and promotion during the course of
one year from the date of preparation of the
Select list.
(2) The selection for inclusion in such list shall be
based on merit and suitability (seniority subject to
fitness) in all respects.
(3) The names of employees included in the list
shall be arranged in order of seniority in the
service or posts as specified in column (3) of
Schedule-IV at the time of preparation of select
list as per Chhattisgarh Civil Services (General
Conditions of Service) Rules, 1961.
Explanation- The person whose name is included
in a select list but who is not promoted during the
validity of the list, shall have no claim to seniority
over those persons considered in a subsequent
selection merely by the fact of his earlier
selection.”
19.
It is also necessary to take notice of the circular dated 31.07.2014,
which provided the method of placement of the names of the
employees after their transfer at the transferee place, which is as
under:छत्तीसगढ़ शासन
वन विभाग
"मंत्रालय"
महानदी भवन, रायपुर-492002
क्रमांक/एफ 11-01/2013/10-1/वन,
नया रायपुर, दिनांक 31/07/2014
प्रति,
******* प्रधान मुख्य वन संरक्षक,
******* छत्तीसगढ़ रायपुर।
विषय :- कर्मचारियों का एक क्षेत्र से दूसरे क्षेत्र (मैदानी से मैदानी एवं मैदानी से
मुख्यालय संवर्ग) में स्थानांतरण किए जाने पर उसकी वरिष्ठता के निर्धारण के
संबंध में दिशा-निर्देश।
संदर्भ :- इस विभाग का पत्र क्रमांक 6961/10-1/86 दिनांक 10/09/1986
---00---
******* वन विभाग के अंतर्गत वन मुख्यालय एवं मैदानी कार्यालय
(वनवृत्तों/वनमंडलों के लिये) के लिए पृथक सेटअप स्वीकृ त हैं। अलिपिक
संवर्ग में वनपाल तक की वरीयता एवं लिपिक वर्गीय संवर्ग में लेखापाल/सहायक
ग्रेड-2 तक की वरीयता पृथक रूप से मुख्यालय/वृत्त स्तर पर संधारित की
जाती है। मैदानी सेटअप में एक वृत्त से दूसरे वृत्त में स्थानांतरण किये जाने पर
उनकी वरीयता निर्धारण के संबंध में वन विभाग के ज्ञापन क्रमांक 6961/101/86 दिनांक 10.09.1986 द्वारा जारी दिशा-निर्देश के अनुवृत्ति में निम्नानुसार
दिशा-निर्देश दिये जाते हैं :-
(1) यदि दो कर्मचारी अपना पारस्परिक स्थानांतर एक स्थान से दूसरे स्थान
पर करवाता है तो, इसे स्वेच्छा से स्थानांतर माना जाकर ऐसे कर्मचारी से
वरिष्ठता छोड़ने के संबंध में स्वीकृ ति या तो आवेदन पत्र के साथ ही ले ली जाय
या उसे कार्यमुक्त करने से पूर्व उसकी सहमति ली जाय कि ऐसे कर्मचारी अपने
नए स्थान पर उस संवर्ग में कनिष्ठतम स्थान पर रखे जाएंगे।
(2) यदि यह पारस्परिक स्थानांतर का प्रकरण नहीं है तथा किसी अन्य किसी
कारण से उक्त कर्मचारी को एक स्थान से दूसरे स्थान पर स्थानांतर किया
जाता है तथा उसका संवर्ग भिन्न हो जाता है तो ऐसी परिस्थिति में स्थानांतरण
आदेश जारी करने से पूर्व अपनी वरिष्ठता त्यागने के संबंध में कर्मचारी की
सहमति ली जाय एवं तत्पश्चात् ही उसे उसका स्थानांतर आदेश जारी किया
जाय तथा ऐसे कर्मचारी को नए संवर्ग में कनिष्ठतम स्थान दिया जाय।
(3) ऐसे प्रकरणों में जहां कानून एवं व्यवस्था अथवा साम्प्रदायिक तनाव की
स्थिति उत्पन्न होने की परिस्थिति में किसी कर्मचारी को एक स्थान से दूसरे
स्थान पर स्थानांतर करने का निर्णय प्रशासकीय कारणों से लिया जाता तो
ऐसी स्थिति में वरिष्ठता के संबंध में शासन स्तर से आदेश दिये जाये तथा
शासन स्तर से स्पष्ट आदेश होने पर ही उस कर्मचारी को नये स्थान की संवर्ग में
उपयुक्त वरिष्ठता दी जा सके गी।
(4) पूर्व में यदि कु छ स्थानान्तर हो गए हो तथा वरिष्ठता के संबंध में विवाद हो
तो उपर्युक्त निर्देशों का पालन करते हुए संबंधित कर्मचारी की वरीयता छोड़ने
की सहमति ली जाये एवं उसकी वरिष्ठता का निर्धारण किया जाये अथवा
कर्मचारी द्वारा सहमति न देने की दशा में जिस स्थान से उसका स्थानांतर
किया गया है, उसे उसी स्थान पर वापस पदस्थ करने की कार्यवाही की जाये,
जिससे वरिष्ठता संबंधी विवादों का अंतिम रूप से निराकरण हो सके ।
(5) यदि किसी कर्मचारी का स्थानांतरण (चाहे प्रशासनिक/आपसी/स्वैच्छिक
दृष्टि से हो) मैदानी संवर्ग के अंतर्गत एक वृत्त से दूसरे वृत्त में किया जाता है, तो
उसकी वरीयता छ.ग. सिविल सेवा (सेवा की सामान्य शर्तें) नियम-1961 के
उप नियम-12(2) (ख) के अनुसार निर्धारित होगी, अर्थात् एक ही अवसर (वर्ष)
पर चयनित सभी सीधी भर्ती/पदोन्नत कर्मचारियों से नीचे की श्रेणी में रखा
जावेगा।
(6) प्रशासकीय हित में यह निर्णय लिया गया है कि, सामान्यतः 05 वर्ष की सेवा
अवधि पूर्व करने के पश्चात् ही किसी कर्मचारी को भिन्न संवर्ग वाले कार्य क्षेत्र में
स्थानांतरित किया जावेगा, इससे पूर्व नहीं।
Sd/(आर.पी. मण्डल)
प्रमुख सचिव,
छत्तीसगढ़ शासन, वन विभाग”
20.
Rule 12(2)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (General Conditions
of Service) Rules, 1961 provides that:“12. Seniority.
The seniority of the members of a service or a
distinct branch or group of posts of that service
shall be determined in accordance with the
following principles, viz.,(1) xxxxx
(2) Seniority of Transferees. (a) xxxxx
(b) Where a person is appointed by
transfer
in
accordance
with
the
provisions in the Recruitment Rules,
providing for such transfer in the
event of non availability of suitable
candidates by direct recruitment or
promotion, such transferee shall be
grouped
with
direct
recruits
or
promotees, as the case may be, and
he shall be ranked below all direct
recruits or promotees, as the case
may be, selected on the same
occasion.”
21.
Seniority is an important service right having a direct bearing upon
promotional avenues and other service benefits. Though no
employee can claim an indefeasible right to serve at a particular
place, transfer is undoubtedly an incidence of service and, by itself,
cannot ordinarily visit an employee with adverse civil consequences
unless such consequence is specifically sanctioned by a valid
statutory provision. A transfer made in public interest or on
administrative exigency is an act of the employer and not of the
employee. Therefore, if the employees are compelled to forfeit their
accrued seniority solely because they have obeyed orders of transfer
passed by the employer, such consequence would, in substance,
operate as a penalty without there being any misconduct or
disciplinary proceedings against them. Such a consequence, in the
considered opinion of this Court, would be manifestly arbitrary and
offend the guarantee of fairness embodied in Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India.
22.
The stand of the respondents is founded upon Rule 12(2)(b) of the
Chhattisgarh Civil Services (General Conditions of Service) Rules,
1961 read with Clause 5 of the circular dated 31.07.2014. However, a
plain reading of Rule 12(2)(b) would indicate that it deals with cases
where appointment is made by transfer as a mode of recruitment in
accordance with the Recruitment Rules. The petitioners are
admittedly not persons appointed by transfer as a source of
recruitment. They entered service by direct recruitment and were
subsequently transferred during the course of their service on
administrative grounds. Prima facie, therefore, the applicability of
Rule 12(2)(b) to such a situation appears to be misplaced. Even
otherwise, an executive circular cannot travel beyond the statutory
rules or create consequences which are otherwise not contemplated
by the governing service rules.
23.
This Court is also unable to persuade itself to accept the proposition
that merely because the service is organized Circle-wise, the
employer can, by way of an executive instruction, reduce regularly
recruited employees to the lowest position in the gradation list
whenever they are transferred from one Circle to another.
Acceptance of such a proposition would vest an uncanalised and
arbitrary power in the administration. An authority, by directing
transfer of employees from one Circle to another, would effectively be
in a position to deprive them of their accrued seniority and
consequently postpone or even frustrate their chances of promotion.
Such an interpretation would expose employees to arbitrary exercise
of power and would be susceptible to misuse, particularly where
transfers are effected on administrative grounds over which the
employees have no control. Service jurisprudence does not
countenance a situation where an incidence of service is converted
into a source of civil disability.
24.
At the same time, this Court is conscious of the fact that the gradation
list presently operating in the Bilaspur Circle may have remained in
force for a considerable period and several employees who are not
parties to the present proceedings may have arranged their affairs on
the basis thereof. The petitioners have challenged the rejection of
their respective representations and the consequential application of
Clause 5 of the circular to their cases. Therefore, while this Court
finds merit in the grievance raised by the petitioners, it is neither
necessary nor appropriate, in the facts of the present case, to
unsettle the entire gradation list or disturb the seniority of other
employees who have not been impleaded before this Court.
25.
On a conjoint reading of the Chhattisgarh Class III Forest Service
Recruitment Rules, 2012, particularly Rules 6, 14 and 15 read with
Schedule IV, and Rule 12(2)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services
(General Conditions of Service) Rules, 1961, this Court is of the
considered opinion that Clause 5 of the circular dated 31.07.2014,
insofar as it mandates that Forest Guards, who have been appointed
by direct recruitment and are subsequently transferred from one
Circle to another on administrative, mutual or voluntary grounds, shall
invariably be placed below all direct recruits and promotees of the
corresponding year in the transferee Circle, is manifestly arbitrary
and dehors the statutory scheme governing the service. The said
executive instruction has the effect of depriving such employees of
the benefit of the merit determined at the time of recruitment and
inflicts adverse civil consequences upon them without any statutory
sanction or misconduct on their part. It also travels beyond the scope
of Rule 12(2)(b) of the Rules, 1961, which deals with appointment by
transfer as a mode of recruitment and has no application to cases
where direct recruits are merely transferred during service. An
executive circular cannot supplement, amend or override statutory
rules framed under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution.
26.
Consequently, Clause 5 of the circular dated 31.07.2014, to the
aforesaid extent, being violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India and inconsistent with the statutory Rules of 2012
and the Rules of 1961, is declared ultra vires and is hereby struck
down to that limited extent.
27.
As a fall out, the impugned orders dated 25.09.2025 rejecting the
petitioners representations cannot be sustained and are hereby
quashed. The respondents are directed to reconsider the petitioners’
claims for fixation of their seniority by ignoring the stipulation
contained in Clause 5 of the circular dated 31.07.2014 insofar as it
has been applied to the petitioners, and to determine their placement
on the basis of their original merit in the recruitment process and the
applicable statutory rules. Such exercise shall be completed within a
period of ninety (90) days from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
28.
It is, however, made clear that this declaration shall operate
prospectively and shall not automatically unsettle the seniority
already assigned to other employees who are not parties to the
present proceedings, leaving it open to the competent authority to
take consequential action in accordance with law after complying with
the principles of natural justice wherever the rights of third parties are
likely to be affected.
29.
It is clarified that this order shall operate only qua the petitioners and
shall not, by itself, result in disturbance of the existing seniority of
other employees. If, upon reconsideration, any consequential
modification affecting the rights of any other employee becomes
necessary, the competent authority shall proceed strictly in
accordance with law after affording due opportunity of hearing to the
persons likely to be affected.
30.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the present writ
petitions are allowed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
HEAD NOTE
******* An employee cannot be deprived of accrued
seniority merely because of an administrative
transfer, in the absence of any statutory provision
authorising such consequence.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review