Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/32
GAHC010168362025
2026:GAU-AS:13166
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4294/2025
KHATANGPANI TEA ESTATE AND ANR
BURIDIHING, KHATANGPANI,
P.O AND P.S- PENGAREE, DIST- TINSUKIA, SUB-DIVISION- MARGHERITA ,
PIN-786176, ASSAM, REP. BY ONE OF ITS CO-OWNERS MRS. PRIYANKA
BHATTACHARJEE,
2: PRIYANKA BHATTACHARJEE
D/O- UDAYJYOTI SARMA
R/O- 301 TOWER 6 UNIWORLD CITY
HORIZONS
NEW TOWN
NORTH 24 PARGANAS
WEST BENGAL
PIN-70015
VERSUS
OIL INDIA LIMITED AND ORS
A PUBLIC SECTOR UNDERTAKING,
HAVING ITS REGD. OFFICE AT P.O.- DULIAJAN, DIST.-DIBRUGARH,
ASSAM, PIN-786602.
REPRSENTED BY THE RESIDENT CHIEF EXECUTIVE
2:THE GENERAL MANAGER -LAND (HOD)
OIL INDIA LIMITED
P.O.- DULIAJAN
DIST.-DIBRUGARH
Page No.# 2/32
ASSAM
PIN-786602.
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
LAND REQUISITION AND ACQUISITION BRANCH
TINSUKIA BRANCH
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
PIN-786125
4:NATWA BHUSAN SONOWAL
S/O- DHRUBA SONOWAL
R/O- PENGAREE CHARIALI
P.O AND P.S- PENGAREE
DIST- TINSUKIA
SUB-DIVISION- MARGHERITA
PIN-786125
ASSAM
5:DILIP KUMAR BORA
S/O- PRIJARAM BORA
R/O- PENGAREE CHARIALI
P.O AND P.S- PENGAREE
DIST- TINSUKIA
SUB-DIVISION- MARGHERITA
PIN-786125
ASSAM
6:VIKRAM SARMA
S/O- LATE BALINDRA NATH SARMA
R/O- 39B
PURNA DAS ROAD
P.O- SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.S- GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
7:BULI SARMA
W/O LT. DHIRENDRA NATH SARMA
Page No.# 3/32
R/O K.K
BARUA ROAD
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
8:SUNITA SARMA ALIAS SUNITA SARMA BARUA
W/O SRI BIDYUT BARUA
D/O LT. DHIRNDRA NATH SARMA
R/O 25D POCKET B
SIDDHARTH EXTENSION
NEW DELHI-14
9:SHEKHAR SARMA
S/O LT. DHIRENDRA NATH SARMA
R/O K.K. BARUAH ROAD
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
10:DIPTI SARMA
W/O LT. HIRENDRA NATH SARMA
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. AND P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
11:MANVI SARMA
D/O LT. HIRENDRA NATH SARMA
R/O B-45
AKASHGANGA APARTMENT
PLOT NO.17
SECTOR-6
DWARKA
DELHI-110075
12:REETESH SARMA
S/O LT. HIRENDRA NATH SARMA
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. P.S. GARIAHAT
Page No.# 4/32
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
13:MUNIN SARMA
S/O LT. JATINDRA NATH SARMA
R/O CAMELLIA HOUSE
H/NO 3
BYELANE NO.2
PARAG DAS PATH
ANANDA NAGAR
BAMUNIMAIDAN
GUWAHATI-21
KAMRUP METRO
14:PABINDRA NATH SARMA
S/O LT. JATINDRA NATH SARMA
R/O G.H. ROAD
KHELMATI CLUB ROAD
CINNAMARA MAJGAON
P.O.
P.S. CINNAMARA
DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
PIN-785008
15:AROOP SARMA
S/O LT JAGAT CHANDRA SARMA
R/O CHOLADHARA CHARIALI
P.O.
P.S AND DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
16:ANJANA SINGH
D/O LT. JAGAT CHANDRA SARMA
W/O SUVEER SINGH
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT A 202
SCOND FLOOR
STELLAR JEEVAN
GREATER NOIDA WEST
NEW DELHI
17:JUTHIKA GOSWAMI
D/O LT. JATINDRA NATH SARMA
Page No.# 5/32
W/O LT. PRATAP CHANDRA GOSWAMI
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
18:NISHA BORTHAKUR
D/O SRI VIJAY RANJAN BORTHAKUR
R/O H/NO.7
SAMPRITI PATH
GEETANAGAR
ABS KITCHEN
ZOO ROAD
GUWAHATI-24
ASSAM
19:ASHA BORTHAKUR
D/O SRI VIJAY RANJAN BOTHAKUR
R/O H/NO.2 GMCH ROAD
BHANGAGARH SRIMANTAPUR
DISPUR
KAMRUP METRO
ASSAM
PIN-781005
20:POLASH BORTHAKUR
S/O SRI VIJAY RANJAN BORTHAKUR
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT FLAT NO.102
BISHIRAI AYAN
OPP. NEST HERITAGE
SECTOR 30
RABALE GOTHIVALI
MUMBARI-400701
21:RAHUL KATAKEY
S/O LT RABIN PRASAD KATAKEY
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
Page No.# 6/32
22:RAKTIM KATAKEY
S/O LT. RABIN PRASAD KATAKEY
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. AND P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
23:RAJEEV KATAKEY
S/O LT. ROBIN KATAKEY
RESIDENT OF BISHNU RAM PATH
WARD NO.8
SIVASAGAR
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN-785640
24:PURABI PHUKAN
D/O LT. JATINDRA NATH SARMA
W/O DR. DWIJENDRA NATH PHUKAN
RESIDENT OF USHA PRIYA REGENCY
CHAKRABARTY PATH
JORHAT EAST
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
PIN-785001
25:RUMA SARMA
W/O LT. SANJAY SARMA
R/O FLAT-4 F
BAIKUNTHA 114 N.S.C. BOSE ROAD
P.O. REGENT PARK
KOLKATA
WEST BENGAL
PIN-700040
26:ROHAN SARMA
S/O LT. SANJAY SARMA
C/O MAHUA SARKAR SEN
UNIWORLD CITY
GARDEN 10
FLAT NO.0601
NEW TOWN ACTION AREA 3
KOLKATA
Page No.# 7/32
NORTH 24 PARGANAS
WEST BENGAL
PIN-700156
27:MANDIRA AGNIHOTRI
W/O SRI VARUN AGNIHOTRI
R/O 20764 E
FUERO DRIVE
WALLNUT
CA91789
UNITED STATE OF AMERICA
28:NANDINI DUTTA
W/O SRI VIKRAM DUTT
R/O 26 B EAST ROAD
JADAVPUR
KOLKATA
WEST
BENGAL
PIN-700032
29:MADHU MALTI SARMA
W/O LT. ANUP SHARMA
R/O 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O.
P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
30:INDRANI BEZBORA
W/O MR. MADHUR BEZBORA
R/O COSMOS APARTMENTS
12/14 BOAT CLUB ROAD
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
PIN-411001
31:LEENA EZEKIAL
W/O JAWAHAR PHEROZE EZEKIAL
R/O 6225 NE SKIDMORE STREET
PORTLAND
OR 97218
USA.
32:RANA RANJIT SARMA
S/O LT. HARENDRA NATH SARMA
Page No.# 8/32
R/O 39 B
PURNA DAS ROAD
SARAT BOSE ROAD
P.O. AND P.S. GARIAHAT
KOLKATA
PIN-700029
33:NEENA SARMA
W/O MR. JAY SHANKAR SHARMA
R/O 20995 CANYON VIEW DRIVE
SARATOGA
CA95070
CALIFORNIA
USA
34:MINA GOSWAMI
W/O LT. BEDABRATA GOSWAMI
R/O H.NO.86
K.K. ROAD
CHENIKUTHI HILL SIDE
SILPUKHURI
KAMRUP METRO
ASSAM
PIN 781003
35:SUNANDA SARMA
W/O LT. PRAN PRADIP SARMA
R/O 49/90A
PRINCE GOLAM
MD SHAH ROAD
TOLLYGUNGE H.O. TOLLYGUNGE
KOLKATA
WEST BENGAL
PIN-700033
36:ANIRBAN SARMA
S/O LT. PRAN PRADIP SARMA
R/O 49/90A
PRINCE GOLAM
MD SHAH ROAD
TOLLYGUNGE H.O.
TOLLYGUNGE
KOLKATA
WEST BENGAL
PIN-700033
37:ARADHANA SARMA
D/O LT. AMAR JYOTI SARMA
Page No.# 9/32
R/O CHENIJAN TEA ESTATE
P.O. AND P.S. LADOIGARH
DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
38:AASHISH SARMA
S/O LT. AMAR JYOTI SARMA
R/O CHENIJAN TEA ESTATE
P.O. AND P.S. LADOIGARH
DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
39:RUBY SARMA
W/O LT. UDAY JYOTI SARMA
R/O H/NO.6
BORNALI PATH
JAPORIGOG
GUWAHATI
DIST- KAMRUP METRO
ASSAM
40:ANINDITA BARUAH
W/O SRI RANVIR KAUSHIK BARUAH
R/O FLAT NO.I/306
AKRUTI ORCHID PARK
ANDHERI KURLA ROAD
NEAR MAHARAJA RESTAURANT
SAKINAKA
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA-400072
41:PRIYAM SARMA @ PRIYAM SARMA BARUAH
W/O SRI SUBIR KAUSHIK BARUAH
R/O D-501
KALPATARU SPELDOR
NEAR DATTA MANDIR
WAKAD
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA-411057
42:RANJANA RAJKHOWA
W/O SRI ARUP KUMAR RAJKHOWA
R/O H.NO.6
GOVERNMENT PRESS ROAD
BAMUNIMAIDAN
P.S. CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI
Page No.# 10/32
KAMRUP METRO
ASSAM
PIN-781021
ALL THE APPLICANTS ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR ATTORNEY SRI
BABUL SONOWAL
S/O SRI DHRUBA SONOWAL
R/O PENGAREE CHARIALI
P.O. AND P.S. PENGAREE
DIST- TINSUKIA
ASSA
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
Advocate for the Petitioners
:::::::-
Mr. H. K. Das, Sr. Advocate
Ms. D. Mahanta, Advocate
Mr. D. Saikia, Sr. Advocate
Mr. A. Sarma, Advocate
Mr. A. K. Gupta, Advocate
Mr. P. J. Saikia, Sr. Advocate
Ms. M. Nirola, Advocate
Date of hearing
:-
09.09.2026.
Date of which judgment is reserved
:-
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:-
09.09.2026.
Whether the pronouncement if of the
:-
Yes
:-
No
Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3
Advocate for the Respondent No. 4
Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 7 - 42
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. H. K. Das, the learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
D. Mahanta, the learned counsel for the Petitioners. Also heard Mr.
Page No.# 11/32
D. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. A. Sarma, learned
counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2. Mr. D. Saikia, the learned
Senior Counsel also informed this Court that he had been instructed
to appear for the Respondent No.3. Mr. A. K. Gupta, learned counsel
appears for the Respondent No. 4 and Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned
Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. M. Nirola, learned counsel appears
for the Respondent Nos. 7 to 42.
2.
The present writ petition was filed by the Petitioners seeking
directions upon the Respondent authorities, more particularly
Respondent No. 2 to declare compensation, which would be paid
against the land acquired by the Respondent No. 1 for laying down
oil pipelines. The Petitioners have also sought for directions upon
the Respondent authorities, more particularly to the Respondent
No. 2 to declare compensation, which had been already paid and to
whom, with regard to the land acquired by the Respondent No. 1
for laying down oil pipelines. The Petitioners have also sought for
directions upon the Respondent authorities to complete the
payment of the entire compensation to the rightful owners of the
Petitioner No. 1 tea estate over the land acquired by the
Respondent No. 1 for laying down oil pipelines. Further, the
Petitioners have sought for a direction upon the Respondent
authorities to stop utilizing the oil pipeline laid down in the
Petitioner No. 1’s land.
Page No.# 12/32
3.
At the outset, it is pertinent to take note that though the
Petitioner No. 2 has filed the instant writ petition on behalf of the
Petitioner No. 1, but the Petitioner No. 1 is not the juristic person.
Further to that, the Petitioner No. 2 apparently is only a co-owner
of the land where the Petitioner No.1 Tea Estate is established.
Nothing has been placed before this Court to show that the
Petitioner No.2 can represent Khatangpani Tea Estate. This aspect
of the matter was also recorded by this Court in the order dated
23.06.2026.
4. The materials on record show that admittedly the Petitioner
No.2 along with private Respondent Nos. 6 – 42 are the co-owners
of the land upon which the Khatangpani Tea Estate is set up. The
said tea estate which admeasures 2387 Bighas 0 Katha 3 Lechas is
situated over a plot of land covered by various Dags and included in
Tea Periodic Patta No. 1 of village Khatangpani Tea Estate 121 Bhu
(WLA), under Mouza Buridihing, Margherita Revenue Circle, District
– Tinsukia, Assam.
5. The materials on record further show that Khatangpani Tea
Estate is managed by a Hindu Undivided Family, namely, M/S J. N.
Sarma and Others. The Karta of said Hindu Undivided Family in the
year 2017 by a communication dated 23.03.2017 entrusted the
Respondent Nos. 9 & 12 to look after the tea estate and manage
the operations, finance accounts, liabilities, services and interaction
Page No.# 13/32
with the Government Bodies amongst others.
6. Subsequent thereto, the said Respondent Nos. 9 & 12 on the
basis of the said authorization given in the communication dated
23.03.2017 entered into an agreement with three persons, namely,
Bhanu Sarma, Kuldip Sarma and Natwa Bhushan Sonowal
(Respondent No. 4) on 05.02.2019. In terms with the said
agreement, dated 05.02.2019, the operation and management of
the tea estate along with the tea factory was handed over to the
said Bhanu Sarma, Kuldip Sarma and Natwa Bhushan Sonowal (the
Respondent No.4) on profit sharing basis. At this stage, it is
relevant to observe that the communication dated 23.03.2017 did
not confer any power to the Respondent Nos.9 and 12 to deal with
the co-ownership rights of the co-owners of the land over which the
Khatangpani Tea Estate was established.
7. A perusal of the agreement dated 05.02.2019 would also show
that no authority was conferred upon Shri Bhanu Sarma, Shri Kuldip
Sarma as well as the Respondent No.4 to transfer, alienate and
encumber any part of the tea estate.
8. The records show that while the aforesaid three persons were
running the management and operating the Khatangpani Tea
Estate, the Director of a Company in the name and style of “N.B.
Sonowal Tea Private Limited”, who is the Respondent No.4 in the
Page No.# 14/32
present proceedings informed the HUF, i.e. M/S J.N. Sarma and
Others, by a communication dated 22.03.2021, that the Oil India
Limited (for short, ‘OIL’) was proposing to acquire some portion of
the land for pipelines, and as such, a portion of the garden would
get damaged. It was also informed that the officials of OIL insisted
on acquisition of the land by paying compensation for the land and
crops separately and in such events, the compensation would be
deposited in the bank account of the HUF of M/S J.N. Sarma and
Others. The Respondent No.4 also stated that as the Respondent
No.4 was managing all expenditures of the garden and therefore,
requested that the said amount which OIL proposes to disburse be
disbursed in the bank account of M/S N.B. Sonowal Tea Private
Limited wherein the Respondent No.4 was the Director.
9.
Subsequent thereto, the record further reveals that on
10.03.2022, the Respondent No. 4 handed over the possession of
41 Bighas 1 Katha 14 Lechas of land and OIL paid a compensation
of Rs. 94,70,670/- towards crops value. The Respondent No.4
issued a Declaration stating inter alia that he would not claim any
further compensation in future. In addition to that, the Respondent
No.4 also declared that he had no objection to the execution of a
Sale Deed by the co-owners conveying the land to OIL before the
Sub-Registrar after obtaining permission for sale from the Deputy
Commissioner, Tinsukia.
Page No.# 15/32
10. It is relevant to take note of that subsequent to receiving the
amount of Rs. 94,70,670/-, the Respondent No.4 informed vide a
communication dated 06.04.2022 to M/S J.N. Sarma & Others that
an amount of Rs. 94,70,670/- was received in the bank account of
N.B. Sonowal Tea Private Limited on behalf of Khatangpani Tea
Estate.
11. The Respondent No. 6 on coming to learn about the aforesaid
facts, filed an FIR on 21.04.2022, alleging breach of trust. The said
FIR was registered and numbered as Pengree PS Case No. 17/2022.
12. The Respondent OIL on coming to learn about the lodging of
the FIR inquired vide a communication dated 04.05.2022 with the
Respondent No.4 and sought a reply from the Respondent No. 4.
13. It is further seen from another communication dated
14.07.2022, issued by some authorized signatory of Khatangpani
Tea Estate to the Land Department of OIL wherein it is mentioned
that there are 44 co-owners of the land in respect to Khatangpani
Tea Estate and further a civil suit is pending before the learned 10 th
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Alipur Court, Kolkata, being Title-R831/2019 and it was further mentioned that the tea estate owes
various Government Dues and as such, the compensation which is
to be payable be first released to the concerned statutory
authorities.
Page No.# 16/32
14. The records further reveals that while the Respondent OIL
continued to correspond with the Respondent No. 4, the co-owners
of the land upon whose lands Khatangpani Tea Estate is situated
including the Petitioner No.2 have executed various Irrevocable
Power of Attorney in favour of one Shri Babul Sonowal. It may not
be out of place to mention that though Shri Babul Sonowal is not a
party to the present proceeding, but the Respondent No. 7 – 42 are
being represented in the present proceedings by Shri Babul
Sonowal. The said aspect would be apparent from the vakalatnama
so filed in the instant proceedings as well as the application filed by
Shri Babul Sonowal seeking impleadment of the Respondent Nos.7
to 42 through him.
15. This Court had also perused the Irrevocable General Power of
Attorney dated 08.12.2023 executed by the Petitioner No.2
appointing Shri Babul Sonowal as her Attorney whereby the power
was conferred upon Shri Babul Sonowal to sale, lease, transfer all
her interest over the land wherein the Khatangpani Tea Estate is
established.
16. The record further reveals that based upon the various Power
of Attorneys which were executed by the co-owners, the
Respondent OIL entered into an Agreement to Sale on 10.04.2024
with the co-owners through their Attorney Shri Babul Sonowal for
purchase of an area of 39 Bighas 4 Kathas 11 Leachas of land
Page No.# 17/32
contained in various Dags for a total consideration of Rs.
7,01,22,000/-.
17. Perusal of the said Agreement to Sale would show that the sale
consideration was fixed on the basis of zonal value rate fixed by the
Deputy Commissioner, Tinsukia, dated 25.07.2022. Out of the said
total consideration, 50% was paid to Shri Babul Sonowal for and on
behalf of the Petitioner No. 2 as well as the Respondent Nos. 6 – 42
and remaining amount of Rs. 3,50,61,000/- was to be paid at the
execution of the Deed of Sale.
18. Taking into account the relief so sought for by the Petitioner
No.2 at Sl. No. IV that directions should be issued to the
Respondent authorities to stop from utilizing the pipeline laid down
within Khatangpani Tea Estate, it would be apposite herein to take
note of Clause 10 of the Agreement to Sale and the same being
relevant is reproduced herein below:“10.
That the FIRST PARTIES / SELLERS hereby agrees to allow the
PURCHASER
unhindered access to the said lands and further covenants
not to hinder or obstruct the PURCHASER, its workers, men, contractor, etc.
to enter upon, take possession and use the said lands for its various works
and operations.”
19. A perusal of the above quoted clause would show that handing
over of the possession by the Respondent No. 4 though
unauthorizedly on 10.03.2022 was ratified by the co-owners
Page No.# 18/32
including the Petitioner No.2 through the Registered Agreement to
Sale dated 10.04.2024.
20. From the affidavit so filed by the Respondent OIL, it also
appears that apart from Rs. 94,70,670/-, the Respondent No. 4 was
disbursed a further amount of Rs. 7,02,84,000/- as a rehabilitation
grant for an area of land admeasuring 40 Bighas. This payment of
the amount was made prior to the Agreement to Sale so entered
into as well as the Power of Attorneys so executed by the Petitioner
No.2 in favour of the Shri Babul Sonowal.
21. In the backdrop of the above facts, it is relevant to take note
that when the writ petition was listed before this Court on
23.06.2026, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent
No. 4 had submitted that the Petitioner No.2 was paid an amount of
Rs. 34,16,668/- on 27.03.2023 through Bank Transfer to the
Petitioner’s bank account.
22. This Court vide order dated 23.06.2026, directed the Petitioner
No.2 to file an affidavit as to whether the account mentioned, being
account No. 3199301044303 belonged to the Petitioner No.2 and if
so, whether the Petitioner No.2 after receipt of the said amount,
which was transferred by the Respondent No. 4, had taken steps for
returning the said amount.
23. In terms with the aforesaid directions, an affidavit was filed by
Page No.# 19/32
the Petitioner No.2 admitting that the account bearing No.
3199301044303 belonged to the Petitioner No.2 and it was also a
fact that the amount of Rs. 34,16,668/- was transferred to the said
Petitioner No.2’s bank account. However, it was mentioned that the
Petitioner No.2 was under an impression that the said amount was
paid by the Respondent No. 4 as part of the profits earned from
Khatangpani Tea Estate. The said explanation appeared to this
Court to be fictitious inasmuch as there was no history of such a
huge amount of transfer to the Petitioner No.2 at any point of time.
It also appeared to this Court taking into account the facts of the
instant case that the Petitioner No.2 had some knowledge of the
acquisition to be made by the Respondent OIL and as such, the act
on the part of the Petitioner No.2 not to enquire after receiving the
amount from the Respondent No.4 prima facie appeared to be an
abuse of the process of the Court for want of diligence.
24. This Court, in view of the above, vide order dated 31.07.2026,
directed the Petitioner No.2 to deposit the amount of Rs.
34,16,668/- along with interest @9% per annum w.e.f. 27.03.2023
to 03.08.2026 before the Registry of this Court so that the
Petitioner can be heard on merits. In pursuance thereto, the
Petitioner duly deposited an amount of Rs. 44,48,689/- before the
Registrar General of this Court and the records of the present
proceedings shows the acknowledgement by the Registry.
Page No.# 20/32
25. This Court vide order dated 05.08.2026, made a query upon Mr.
A. Sarma, learned counsel appearing for the Respondent No. 1 & 2
as to what necessitated the payment of rehabilitation grant as well
as surface compensation, when the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 was
otherwise purchasing the same land from the Petitioner No.2 as
well as the other co-owners of the land wherein Khatangpani Tea
Estate was established.
26. When the writ petition was listed on 18.08.2026, Mr. A. Sarma
submitted that such steps were taken to pay the surface
compensation and rehabilitation on the basis of Office Memorandum
dated 05.07.2021. On the same date of hearing, it was informed to
this Court that amount was released to the Respondent No. 4 on
the basis of a communication issued by Shri Babul Sonowal. At the
cost repetition, this Court finds it apposite to observe that Shri
Babul Sonowal was appointed by the Petitioner as attorney much
after the transfer of Rs. 94,70,670/- as well as Rs. 7,02,84,000/- to
the Respondent No. 4.
27. Mr. A. Sarma, the learned counsel for the Respondent OIL also
submitted that such steps were taken on the basis of a
communication received from the authorized signatory of the
Khatangpani Tea Estate. Be that as it may, it was the categorical
submission of the learned counsel for the Respondent No. 4 that
the payment was made to the Respondent No. 4 by the Respondent
Page No.# 21/32
OIL on the basis of a communication issued by Shri Babul Sonowal
to the Respondent No. 2.
28. Taking into account the conflicting stands, this Court directed
the presence of the Chief General Manager Land Department (OIL)
through the video conferencing link and also to file an affidavit in
that regard. In pursuance to the said directions, an additional
affidavit was filed by the Chief General Manager of Land
Department (OIL) enclosing various documents.
29. This Court had heard the submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties as well as Mr. Madhurjya Prasad Chaliha,
Chief General Manager Land Department, OIL, who is present
before this Court.
30. Mr. H. K. Das, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
Petitioner No.2 submitted that insofar as the Agreement to Sale is
concerned entered into by her attorney with Respondent OIL that is
not a subject matter of the present proceedings. However, the
Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 ought not to have entered into any form of
negotiation with the Respondent No. 4 inasmuch as the Respondent
No. 4 was never given any authority to deal on behalf of the
Petitioner No.2. Mr. H. K. Das, the learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the acquisition ought to have been done under the
Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of user in
Page No.# 22/32
land) Act, 1962 (for short, ‘the Act of 1962’) and the compensation
ought to have been determined on the basis of the said Act of
1962.
31. Mr. H. K. Das, the learned Senior Counsel also submitted that in
the meanwhile the Power of Attorney which was made by the
Petitioner No.2 in favour of Babul Sonowal was recently revoked.
32. Per contra Mr. D. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 submitted that purchase of land by
way of a sale deed is different from payment of rehabilitation grant.
Mr. D. Saikia, the learned Senior Counsel referring to the OM dated
05.07.2021 submitted that in the instant case instead of carrying
out an acquisition, the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 had proposed to
purchase the land, for which a Registered Agreement to Sale had
already been entered into. In addition to payment of the sale
amount agreed upon, the Respondent OIL was required to pay
rehabilitation grant and surface compensation in terms with Clause
(ii) of the OM dated 05.07.2021.
33. Mr. D. Saikia, the learned Senior Counsel further submitted that
as to whether the Respondent No. 4 was authorized to receive on
behalf of the Petitioner No.2 is a question between the Petitioner
No.2 and the Respondent No. 4. However, insofar as the
Respondent OIL is concerned, the payment of the 50% as advance
Page No.# 23/32
had been duly paid to the Power of Attorney of the Petitioner No.2
and the surface compensation of Rs. 94,70,670/- and rehabilitation
grant of Rs. 7,02,85,000/- have been duly paid to the Respondent
No. 4.
34. Mr. D. Saikia, the learned Senior Counsel also submitted that it
is not the case of the Petitioner No.2 herein that the Petitioner No.2
is entitled to additional compensation or something more than what
she received. Rather, it is the case of the Petitioner No.2 that she
has no information as to what amount has been paid by the
Respondent OIL. Mr. D. Saikia, the learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the Petitioner No.2 cannot question on laying down
of pipelines which is a national pipeline project, more so after
having ratified the handing over the possession by the Respondent
No. 4 to the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 in the Registered Agreement to
Sale.
35. I have also heard Mr. A. K. Gupta, learned counsel appearing
for the Respondent No. 4, more particularly on the issue in respect
to the submission made before this Court on 18.08.2026, wherein
the learned counsel submitted that there exists a Memorandum of
Understanding between the Respondent No. 4 and Shri Babul
Sonowal to purchase the Tea Estate. He therefore submitted that
the amount of Rs.34,16,668/- was the amount paid to the Petitioner
Page No.# 24/32
No.2 as regards her 1/60th share towards purchase of the land and
her entitlement towards surface compensation and rehabilitation
grant.
36. Mr. A. K. Gupta, the learned counsel produced a Memorandum
of Understanding dated 14.06.2023, executed by Shri Babul
Sonowal on behalf of the co-owners including the petitioner No.2
for selling the entire Tea Estate to M/S N.B. Sonowal Tea Pvt. Ltd.
This Court inquired as to on what basis Shri Babul Sonowal
executed the Memorandum of Understanding inasmuch as the said
Memorandum of Understanding was executed much prior to the
irrevocable Power of Attorney dated 08.12.2023 which was a part of
the record. Mr. A. K. Gupta, the learned counsel submitted that the
said power can be related to the Power of Attorney executed by the
Petitioner No.2 on 29.03.2023. This Court duly perused the said
Power of Attorney dated 29.03.2023 so produced which prima facie
do not appear to confer a specific power to sale. The said
observation is however limited to the present proceedings and
would not impact any other proceedings.
37. Be that as it may, the Respondent No. 4 received the surface
compensation on 02.03.2022 and the rehabilitation grant on
09.03.2023,
that
is
much
prior
to
the
Memorandum
of
Understanding dated 14.06.2023 as well as the Power of Attorney
Page No.# 25/32
dated
29.03.2023
and
the
amount
of
Rs.34,16,668/-
was
transferred on 27.03.2023 to the Petitioner No.2.
38. Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel for the private
Respondent Nos. 6 - 42 submitted that the said Respondents agree
with the contentions of the Respondent No. 4 and that the
Petitioner No.2 had initiated the instant proceedings by completely
abusing the process of Court. Mr. P. J. Saikia, the learned Senior
Counsel also submitted that the private Respondents have received
their share of surface compensation as well as the rehabilitation
grant from the Respondent No.4.
39. In the backdrop of the above, let this Court analyze the
materials on record on the basis of the contentions placed before
this Court with specific reference to the reliefs sought for in the
present proceedings.
40.
The relief No. (I) sought for by the Petitioner No.2 is for
declaration of compensation which is still pending to be paid against
the land acquired by the Respondent OIL for laying down the oil
pipelines. In the foregoing paragraphs of the instant judgment, this
Court duly took note of the Registered Agreement to Sale dated
10.04.2024 wherein the total purchase price agreed upon was Rs.
7,02,85,000/- and out of which 50% of the same had already been
paid to Shri Babul Sonowal, who was the attorney of the Petitioner
Page No.# 26/32
No.2 as well as the other co-owners. The Petitioner No.2 is aware of
the said Registered Agreement to Sale. In other words, the
Petitioner No.2 is aware that the Respondent OIL is purchasing the
land along with what is standing thereon by directly purchasing
from the Petitioner No.2 and other co-owners. Therefore, the
question of any further acquisition of the land by any other mode
does not arise. Be that as it may, the Respondent OIL in addition to
the purchase of the land was further making payment of surface
compensation of Rs.94,70,670/- and rehabilitation grant to the tune
of Rs.7,02,85,000/-. The above therefore answers the Relief No.(I)
to the writ petition.
41. The Relief No.(II) pertains to directions upon the Respondent
OIL to declare about the amount of compensation which have been
paid and to whom. The answer to the same is already dealt with
while considering the Relief No.(I). Apart from that, payment of the
surface compensation and rehabilitation grant were paid to the
Respondent No.4 as would be apparent from the materials on
record.
42. The Relief No.(III) which was sought for by the Petitioner No.2
is that the Respondent authorities should be directed to make
payment of the entire compensation amount to the rightful owners
of the Khatangpani Tea Estate for the land acquired by the
Respondent OIL for laying down oil pipelines.
Page No.# 27/32
43. It is relevant to take note of that insofar as the advance
payment towards the purchase amount is concerned, an amount of
Rs. 3.5 crores has already been paid to the attorney of the
Petitioner No.2 and other co-owners, i.e. Shri Babul Sonowal. In so
far as the remaining amount of the sale consideration, the same
would be paid only at the time of execution of the Deed of Sale. It
is observed that in the circumstances the Power of Attorney dated
08.12.2023 executed by the Petitioner appointing Shri Babul
Sonowal as her attorney had been revoked (as no Revocation Deed
placed on record but only submission made by the learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioner), the Petitioner is at liberty to inform the
Respondent OIL about the same.
44. The Respondent Nos. 6 – 42 who are the other co-owners have
no grievance against the Respondent No. 4 for not making payment
of their dues from the amount received by the Respondent No. 4
towards the surface compensation as well as the rehabilitation grant
and it is only the Petitioner No.2 in the instant case who is
aggrieved.
45. From the materials on record it is apparent that the Petitioner
No.2’s share in the land of the Khatangpani Tea Estate is 1.665%,
i.e. 1/60th and the Respondent No. 4 had already paid an amount of
Rs. 34,16,668/- to the Petitioner No.2 on 27.03.2023 and the
Page No.# 28/32
Petitioner No.2 pursuant to the order of this Court dated 31.07.2026
have already deposited the said amount along with interest of @
9% per annum, total amount of Rs. 44,48,689/-.
46. It is opinion of this Court that the amount paid to the Petitioner
No.2 was as per the Respondent No.4’s estimation, the Petitioner
No.2’s entitlement qua her share of 1.665%. Accordingly, this Court
grant liberty to the Petitioner No.2 to submit an application before
the Registry of this Court and on such application being filed by the
Petitioner No.2, the Registry would permit the Petitioner to
withdraw the said amount so deposited. If it is the case of the
Petitioner No.2 that Rs. 34,16,668/- is less than what she should
have received from the Respondent No.4, the Petitioner No.2 is
granted the liberty to approach the Competent Court of civil
jurisdiction as it would be a dispute purely between the Petitioner
No.2 and the Respondent No. 4.
47. This Court categorically observes that the said amount which
have been paid by the Respondent No. 4 to the Petitioner No.2, i.e.
Rs. 34,16,668/-, shall be construed only as an estimation of the
Respondent No.4 to the entitlement of the Petitioner No.2 qua her
share in respect to her rights in Khatangpani Tea Estate.
48. Before proceeding to the next relief, this Court feels it relevant
to take note of the submission of the learned Senior Counsel for the
Page No.# 29/32
Petitioner No.2 that the land ought to have been acquired under the
Act of 1962 and compensation should have been paid in terms with
the Act of 1962 read with the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act, 2013. The submission cannot be accepted for two reasons.
Firstly, the said submission is outside the scope of the instant
proceedings taking into account the pleadings in the present
proceedings and the reliefs sought for. Secondly, after having
agreed to sale the land, the Petitioner No.2 cannot be allowed to
raise this issue.
49. Let this Court take up the Relief No.(IV) as sought for, i.e.
issuing directions to the Respondent authorities to stop utilizing the
oil pipelines in the Khatangpani Tea Estate.
50. This Court in the foregoing paragraphs of the instant judgment
had duly taken note of the date on which the Respondent No. 4 had
handed over the possession of the land to the Respondent OIL,
though the Respondent No. 4 had no authority to do so. However
by virtue of Registered Agreement to Sale executed by the
Petitioner No.2 as well as the other co-owners they ratified the
action of the Respondent No.4 of handing over the possession. In
addition to that, Clause 10 of the Registered Agreement to Sale
specifically empowers the Respondent OIL to use the land.
Page No.# 30/32
51. Under such circumstances, the question of stopping the
utilization of the oil pipelines as laid down in the Khatangpani Tea
Estate cannot be directed.
52. Considering the above, the instant writ petition stands disposed
of with the following observations and directions:(A) The amount received by the Respondent No. 4 from
the Respondent OIL on account of surface compensation
as well as rehabilitation grant is the amount received on
behalf of the co-owners of Khatangpani Tea Estate
including the Petitioner No.2. Every co-owner including
the Petitioner No.2 has a claim over the said amount to
the extent of their co-ownership rights over the land
proposed to be transferred to the Respondent OIL.
(B)
The acquisition of the rights over the land by the
Respondent OIL is not on the basis of acquisition being
carried out under the relevant acquisition laws. The
acquisition of the rights over the land in the instant case
by the Respondent OIL is through direct purchase, i.e. by
sale. An Agreement to Sale had already been entered into
for which 50% of the payment had already been paid by
the Respondent OIL and the remaining would be paid at
the time of Execution of the Sale Deed.
Page No.# 31/32
(C) The Respondent OIL had apart from agreeing to pay
the amount agreed to in the Registered Agreement to
Sale
have
already
paid
Rs.94,70,670/-
as
surface
compensation and Rs.7,02,85,000/- as rehabilitation grant
to the Respondent No. 4.
(D)
The Respondent No. 4 had already disbursed the
amounts to the Respondent Nos.7 to 42 and the said
Respondents have no objection. The Respondent No.4
had also disbursed an amount of Rs.34,16,668/- to the
Petitioner No.2 which is as per the estimation of the
Respondent No.4 that the same constitutes the Petitioner
No2's share of her entitlement qua her rights.
(E) The Petitioner No. 2 is granted liberty to file an
application before the Registry for release of the amount
of Rs. 44,48,689/- and upon such application submitted,
the Registry shall after verification release the said
amount to the Petitioner No. 2.
(F) If the Petitioner No. 2 is aggrieved that the amount
received
from
the
Respondent
No.4
does
not
commensurate to her co-ownership share of her rights,
the Petitioner No.2 is granted liberty to approach the
Competent Court of civil jurisdiction.
Page No.# 32/32
(G) The relief No. (IV) sought to direct the Respondents
not to utilize the pipeline stands rejected.
(H) No costs.
53. The appearance of Mr. Madhurjya Prasad Chaliha, Chief General
Manager, Land Department stands dispensed with.
JUDGE
Pradip Kumar Kalita
Comparing Assistant
Date: 2026.09.15 16:32:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review