The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In view of the above pleadings it is necessary that the following issue be framed in Title Suit No. 02 of 2020:- W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021 Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors. With W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021 Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors. Whether the defendant no.1 fraudulently and surreptitiously transferred and mutated plot no.242 measuring an area of 0.2700 hectares, portions of land measuring of 0.0560, 0.0360 and 0.0660 from plot no.243 and a portion of land measuring 0.0980 hectare from plot no.250 in his name from the name of the plaintiff’s grandfather with the help of defendant no.4. (onus on the plaintiff).
14. The applications under Article 227 of the Constitution of India are allowed. The impugned Orders both dated
17. 11.2021 are modified to the above extent. The learned Trial Court shall frame the necessary issue as directed above and proceed with the trial. ( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan ) Judge Approved for reporting Internet to/ : Yes : Yes
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2021
Shri Kharka Singh Chettri,
Son of Purna Bahadur Chettri,
Resident of Bermiok, Martam Gayabring,
P.O. Bermiok and P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim-737113.
….. Petitioner
Versus
1.
Shri Mangal Chandra Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
2.
Shri Manoj Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
3.
Shri Suraj Lall Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
4.
Miss Usha Rai,
Daughter of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang, Hee
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim-737121.
5.
The Secretary,
Land Revenue and Disaster Management
Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Bhawan, Gangtok
East Sikkim-737101.
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
6.
The District Collector, West District,
District Administrative Centre,
Rabdentse, Gyalshing,
West Sikkim-737111.
7.
The Sub-Divisional Magistrate
Soreng Sub-Division
Soreng, West Sikkim-737121
…..Respondents
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
(Impugned order dated 17.11.2021 passed by the Court of the learned Civil
Judge, West Sikkim at Soreng, in the Title Suit No. 03 of 2020 rejecting a prayer of
the Petitioner made vide application under Order XIV Rule 5 read with Section 151
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908).
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tara Devi Chettri
Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Nirmal Kumar Berdewa,
Respondent Nos. 1 to 4.
Advocate
for
the
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General and
Mr. Shakil Raj Karki, Assistant Government Advocate
for the State-respondent Nos.5 to 7.
-----------------------------------------------------------------With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Shri Man Bahadur Chettri,
Son of Kharka Singh Chettri,
Resident of Bermiok, Martam Gayabring,
P.O. Bermiok and P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim-737113.
….. Petitioner
Versus
1. Shri Mangal Chandra Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
2.
Shri Manoj Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
3.
Shri Suraj Lall Rai,
Son of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim – 737121.
4.
Miss Usha Rai,
Daughter of Late Kumar Singh Rai,
Resident of Chuchen, Takuthang, Hee
P.O. and P.S. Nayabazar,
West Sikkim-737121.
5.
The Secretary,
Land Revenue and Disaster Management
Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Bhawan, Gangtok
East Sikkim-737101.
6.
The District Collector, West District,
District Administrative Centre,
Rabdentse, Gyalshing,
West Sikkim-737111.
7.
The Sub-Divisional Magistrate
Soreng Sub-Division
Soreng, West Sikkim-737121
…..Respondents
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
(Impugned order dated 17.11.2021 passed by the Court of the learned Civil
Judge, West Sikkim at Soreng, in the Title Suit No. 02 of 2020 rejecting a prayer of
the Petitioner made vide application under Order XIV Rule 5 read with Section 151
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908).
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tara Devi Chettri
Advocate for the Petitioner.
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
Mr. Nirmal Kumar Berdewa,
Respondent Nos. 1 to 4.
Advocate
for
the
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General and
Mr. Shakil Raj Karki, Assistant Government Advocate
for the State-respondent Nos.5 to 7.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Date of hearing
:
02.09.2022
ORDER
(O R A L)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
These
applications
under
Section
of
the
Constitution of India invoking the supervisory jurisdiction
of this court assails two Orders both dated 17.11.2021
deciding two applications under Order XIV Rule 5 read with
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) to
amend the issues framed by the learned Trial Court on
22.09.2021 in two suits i.e. Title Suit No. 03 of 2020
(Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors. Vs. Kharka Chettri & Ors) and
Title Suit No.02 of 2020 (Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors. Vs. Man
Bahadur Chettri & Ors.) pending before the learned Civil
Judge, West Sikkim at Soreng.
2.
By Orders dated 22.09.2021 the learned Trial Court
had framed issues in both the suits.
3.
The petitioners who were defendant no.1 in both the
suits filed applications under order XIV Rule 5 read with
Section 151 CPC for rectifications including the striking out
of issue no.5 and issue no.7 in the respective suits. Issue
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
no. 5 (in Title Suit No. 03 of 2020) and issue no.7 (in Title
Suit No.02 of 2020) which were identically worded read as
under:
“Whether the suit property was sold to meet legal
necessity of the joint family of the plaintiffs. (onus on the
defendants).”
4.
Although the learned Trial Court rectified the other
errors pointed out in the applications it was of the view that
issue no.5 (in Title Suit No. 03 of 2020) and issue no.7 (in
Title Suit No. 02 of 2020) need not be struck off as in its
opinion if the suit property was found to be ancestral
property then it may be necessary for the defendants to
show that it was sold out of legal necessity. This view of the
learned Trial Court was in spite of noting that there were
no pleadings that the property was sold out of legal
necessity.
5.
The learned Trial Court thus seems to have framed
issue no.5 and 7 as above without necessary pleadings. The
approach of the learned Trial Court in holding that if the
suit property are found to be ancestral property then it may
be necessary for the defendants to show that it was sold
out of legal necessity is incorrect. It is fundamental that
issues are framed when material preposition of fact or law
is affirmed by one party and denied by the other. Issues
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
are required to be framed with regard to only those
pleadings which are asserted by one party and denied by
other. The learned Trial Court has categorically held that
there is no pleading or denial of legal necessity. If that be
so then the issue of legal necessity was not necessary.
6.
In Ponnayal alias Lakshmi vs. Karuppannan1
the
Supreme Court held that “Civil Suits are decided on the
basis of pleadings and the issues framed and the parties to
the suit cannot be permitted to travel beyond the pleadings.”
7.
Thus, the impugned Orders dated 17.11.2021 relating
to issue no. 5 and issue no.7 have incorrectly decided the
applications for amending/striking out the issues and
accordingly set aside to the above extent.
8.
During the arguments the relevant pleadings in the
two suits were pointed out by the learned counsel for the
parties. In paragraph 11 of the plaint (in Title Suit No.03 of
2020) it was asserted by the plaintiff that:“11. That through above report it further came to light
that the Defendant No.1 fraudulently and surreptitiously
transferred and mutated (i) portion of land measuring an
area of 0.03500 Hectare from the Plot No.243 and (ii) a
portion of land measuring an area of 0.1160 Hectare from
Plot No.250 in his name from the name of their Late
grandfather with the aid of Defendant No.4.”
1 (2019) 11 SCC 800
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
9.
Paragraph 21 of the written statement contested the
plea of the plaintiff in the following manner in Title Suit
No.03 of 2020:
“21. That the contents of paragraphs 10 and 11 of the
plaint are denied. It is denied that only on the perusal of
the documents marked Annexures IV to VII in the plaint
the plaintiffs came to know the actual status of the landed
properties of their late grand-father under Khatiyan No.72
bearing Plot Nos. 242, 243 and 250 situated under
Chuchen Block, Mangalbaria Revenue Circle, West Sikkim.
It is reiterated that the plaintiffs were fully aware of the
sale of the suit lands made by their father identifying as
Late Bishnu Bahadur Rai and the mutations of the suit
lands in favour of the answering defendant. It is further
denied that the answering defendant fraudulently and
surreptitiously transferred and mutated a portion of land
measuring an area of 0.3500 Hectare from Plot Nos. 243
and a portion of land measuring an area of 0.1160
Hectare from Plot No.250 in his name from the name of
Late Bishnu Bahadur Rai. The original sale deed validly
executed and registered, computerized parcha indicating
the answering defendant’s ownership over the suit land
along with other relevant documents submitted with the
written statements clearly establish that there was lawful
and valid transfer of the suit lands in favour of the
answering defendant. It is admitted that after the valid
and lawful mutation of the suit lands in favour of the
answering defendant the new plot numbers were
generated by the Office of the Defendant No.4.”
10. In view of the pleadings at paragraph 11 of the plaint
and paragraph 21 of the written statement it would be
necessary to frame the following issue in Title Suit No.03 of
2020:Whether the defendant no.1 had fraudulently
and surreptitiously transferred and mutated (i)
portion of land measuring an area of 0.3500
Hectares from plot no.243 and (ii) a portion of
land measuring an area of 0.1160 Hectares from
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
plot no.250 in his name from the name of their
late grand-father with the aid of defendant no.4?
(onus on the plaintiff).
11. In paragraph 10 of the plaint (in Title Suit No. 02 of
2020) the plaintiff had averred:“10. That through above report it further came to light that
the Defendant No.1. fraudulently and surreptitiously
transferred and mutated Plot No.242 measuring an area of
0.2700 Hectare, (ii) portion of land measuring an area of
0.0560, 0.0360, and 0.0660 from total measuring of land
0.8580 Hectare from the Plot No.243 and (iii) a portion of
land measuring an area of 0.0980 Hectare from Plot
No.250 in his name from the name of their Late grandfather with the aid of Defendant No.4.”
12. In the written statement paragraph 10 of the plaint
was responded to in the following manner:
“23. That the contents of paragraphs 9 and 10 of the
plaint are denied. It is denied that only on the perusal of
the documents marked Annexures IV to VII in the plaint
the plaintiffs came to know the actual status of the landed
properties of their late grand-father under Khatiyan No.72
bearing Plot Nos. 242, 243 and 250 situated under
Chuchen Block, Mangalbaria Revenue Circle, West Sikkim.
It is reiterated that the plaintiffs were fully aware of the
sale of the suit lands made by their father identifying
himself as Late Bishnu Bahadur Rai and the mutation of
the suit lands in favour of the answering defendant. It is
further denied that the answering defendant fraudulently
and surreptitiously transferred and mutated Plot Nos. 242,
portions of land from 243 and portion of land from Plot No.
250 in his name from the name of Late Bishnu Bahadur
Rai. The averments made in paragraphs 17, 18 and 19 of
the Written Statements (supra) clearly establish the lawful
and valid transfer of the suit lands in favour of the
answering defendant. It is admitted that after the valid
and lawful mutation of the suit lands in favour of the
answering defendant the new plot numbers were
generated and new Parcha Khatiyan was issued to the
answering defendant by the Office of the Defendant No.4.”
13. In view of the above pleadings it is necessary that the
following issue be framed in Title Suit No. 02 of 2020:-
W.P. (C) No.48 of 2021
Kharka Singh Chettri vs. Mangal Chandra Rai & Ors.
With
W.P. (C) No. 49 of 2021
Man Bahadur Chettri vs. Mangal Chand Rai & Ors.
Whether the defendant no.1 fraudulently and
surreptitiously transferred and mutated plot
no.242 measuring an area of 0.2700 hectares,
portions of land measuring of 0.0560, 0.0360
and 0.0660 from plot no.243 and a portion of
land measuring 0.0980 hectare from plot no.250
in his name from the name of the plaintiff’s
grandfather with the help of defendant no.4.
(onus on the plaintiff).
14. The applications under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India are allowed. The impugned Orders both dated
17.11.2021 are modified to the above extent. The learned
Trial Court shall frame the necessary issue as directed
above and proceed with the trial.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review