Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:1097
Serial No.131
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 353 of 2024
Date of Decision: 17.11.2025
1.
Shri. Kharka Bahadur Thapa.
2.
Smti. Miraculous Paslein.
3.
Smti (L) Radha Joshi, represented by her husband
Shri. Dil Ram Joshi.
4.
Smti. Kalpana Chettri.
5.
Smti. Rina Kor.
6.
Late Ek Bahadur Chettri, represented by his wife
Smti. Obel Sohshang.
7.
Shri. Ranjit Singh.
8.
Shri. Ranko Khyriam.
9.
Shri. Ganesh Prashad Sapkota.
10.
Shri. Borshon Singh Rodborn.
11.
Shri. Radhe Shyam Thakur.
12.
Smti. Phrida Marbaniang.
13.
Smti. Hermot Frankling Suchiang.
14.
Smti. Kashmiri Kaur.
15.
Shri. Amulya Das.
16.
Shri. Sandrika Yadav.
2025:MLHC:1097
17.
Shri. Mahiuddin Ansari.
18.
Shri. Heavenson Nonghuloo.
19.
Shri. Yusuf Nongrum.
20.
Shri. Kamlesh Prasad Shukla.
21.
Shri. Niren Singh.
22.
Shri. Montu Kr. Singh.
23.
Shri. B.G.Thangkhiew.
24.
Shri. Tellianching Ryntathiang.
…Petitioners
-Versus-
1.
The State of Meghalaya, represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary,
Transport Department, Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
2.
The Managing Director, Meghalaya
Transport Corporation (M.T.C.) Shillong.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. S.K.hassan, Adv.
Mr. E.Ahmed, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mrs. T.Yangi B, AAG with
Mr. E.R.Chyne, GA for R 1.
Mr. S.Sen, Adv. for R 2.
:
2025:MLHC:1097
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The writ petitioners who are stated to be retired employees of the
Meghalaya Transport Corporation (MTC), an undertaking of the
Government of Meghalaya are before this Court impugning two Resolutions
dated 24-10-2018 and 29-10-2020, passed by the Board of Directors of the
MTC, whereby the Meghalaya Fifth Pay Commission has been adopted
w.e.f. 01-01-2019. The grievance basically centers around the fact that, as
far as the State government is concerned the recommendations of the
Meghalaya Fifth Pay Commission has been implemented since 01-01-2017.
3.
Mr. S.K.Hassan, learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that
there is no rational basis to create the artificial date, inasmuch as, on earlier
occasions, the date adopted for implementation of the Pay Commission
Reports has been as per the dates which have been adopted by the state
government. Learned counsel has also submitted that the fixation of the
implementation date by the MTC is arbitrary and has infringed Article 14 of
2025:MLHC:1097
the Constitution as far as the employees are concerned. He therefore, prays
that a mandamus be issued to direct the respondents to implement the
Meghalaya Fifth Pay Commission w.e.f. 01-01-2017, and the writ
petitioners accordingly be given their due arrears as permissible.
4.
Mrs. T.Yangi B, learned AAG assisted by Mr. E.R.Chyne, learned GA
appearing for the State respondent No. 1, has submitted that the employees
of the MTC are not government employees and cannot claim parity with
regular government employees, and that the implementation of the
Meghalaya Fifth Pay Commission is also a decision that has been arrived at
by the Board of Directors taking into consideration the relevant factors, such
as, financial constraints and so on. She further submits that though the matter
has been brought to the notice of the government, however, as the decision
rests with the Board of Directors, no further directions were given by the
state respondents.
5.
Mr. S.Sen, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No. 2, i.e. the
Managing Director, has at the outset raised an objection that the relevant
necessary party i.e. the Meghalaya Transport Corporation has not been
arrayed as a party in the instant writ petition, and only the Managing Director
of the said Corporation has been made party. On this ground alone, he
submits that the writ petition deserves no consideration and should be
2025:MLHC:1097
dismissed in limine. Learned counsel has however, further submitted that
even on merits, the writ petitioners have not made out any case, inasmuch
as, the decision to implement the Meghalaya Fifth Pay Commission
recommendation has been taken by a competent authority i.e. the Board of
Directors of the MTC. In this context, learned counsel has drawn the
attention of this Court to the Minutes of the 151 st meeting of the Board of
Directors held on 24-10-2018, wherein the pay scale of the MTC employees
in accordance with the recommendations of the Meghalaya Fifth Pay
Commission, 2017, was discussed and also the Minutes of the 154th meeting
held on 29-10-2020, wherein the financial conditions of the Corporation was
also again discussed. He submits that based on these meetings, after a
considered decision, the date for implementation of the Meghalaya Fifth Pay
Commission was fixed as 01-01-2019. He further submits that the same
being an executive decision, there is no cause for interference, and in support
of his arguments has placed reliance in the case of State of Punjab & Ors.
vrs. Amar Nath Goyal & Ors. (2005) 6 SCC 754, wherein he submits the
Supreme Court has held that the recommendations of the Pay Commission
are not ipso facto binding on the Government, as the same has to be accepted
and implemented. In the instant case, he submits, the Board of Directors
having taken a decision based on the financial conditions as to the viability
2025:MLHC:1097
of the date of implementation, no interference is called for nor can a
mandamus issue in this regard.
6.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and also on perusal
of the materials as placed, the issue in question is only whether a mandamus
can issue to direct the respondents to implement the Meghalaya Fifth Pay
Commission
recommendations
from
01-01-2017,
the
date
of
implementation by the State Government in the circumstances pertaining to
the instant case. Though the writ petitioners have not arrayed the Meghalaya
Transport Corporation as a party, which indeed is a disabling feature which
would normally entail dismissal of the writ petition at the threshold itself,
however, this Court has also examined the other attendant facts and
circumstances of the case. As submitted by the learned counsels for the
respondents No. 1 and 2, it is an undisputed fact that the MTC, though a
government undertaking, is a Corporation with a duly constituted Board of
Directors, who manage the company independently, and as such, cannot be
considered to be a department of the Government of Meghalaya or its
employees taken to be government employees.
7.
The decision with regard to the implementation of the Meghalaya
Fifth Pay Commission from 01-01-2019, it is noticed by this Court, is based
on the Minutes of the two meetings of the Board of Directors of the
2025:MLHC:1097
Meghalaya Transport Corporation which were held on 24-10-2018 and 2910-2020. For the sake of convenience, from the Minutes of the 151st meeting
dated 24-10-2018, 151.10: Agenda No. 9, and from the Minutes of the 154th
meeting dated 29-10-2020, 154.05: Agenda No. 4 and 154.09: Extra
Agenda, which are relevant are reproduced hereinbelow:
“151.10: Agenda No. 9: Pay Scale of MTC in
accordance with the recommendation of 5th Meghalaya
Pay Commission 2017.
The Board perused the agenda item. It was
informed that if the pay structure in the revised scale is
to be adopted there will be an additional monthly
financial implication of an approximate amount of Rs.
17.55 lakhs over the existing salary requirement of Rs.
75.00 lakhs (approx.). Thus for clearing of arrear for
24(twenty four) months from 1.1.2017 to 31.12.2018 the
financial implication comes to Rs. 5.00 crores (approx.).
After due deliberation the Board of Directors
approved to adopt the Fifth Meghalaya Pay Commission
since the Corporation is following the pay structure of
the Govt. Therefore it allowed implementation of the
Revised Pay Scale of the Government of Meghalaya to
the employees of the Meghalaya Transport Corporation
with effect from January 2019 with a condition that its
implementation is subject to availability of fund.
The Board advised the M.D to come up with a
proposal to submit to the Government for providing
additional fund.
154.05: Agenda No. 4: Revenue Budget for the year
2020-2021.
The Budget Estimate for the year 2007-2008 of the
Corporation has been prepared and is placed before the
Board for consideration and approval.
2025:MLHC:1097
Revenue Account – The Budget Estimate has projected
a Revenue Receipt of Rs. 1399.79 lakhs and a Revenue
Expenditure of Rs. 2057.20 lakhs (which includes a
depreciation of Rs. 121.53 lakhs). Thus the Budget has
projected a deficit of Rs. 778.94 (excluding Capital
Contribution of Rs. 500.00 lakhs) for the year 20202021.
The Managing Director informed the Board of that the
Corporation is still having huge outstanding liabilities,
such as Provident Fund, Leave encashment and
Gratuity, etc. With the serious efforts having been made
by the management of the Corporation to clear the
outstanding Provident Fund dues in the last two years,
the outstanding Provident Fund now stands at Rs.
159.42 lakhs. This amount is proposed to be cleared
during the current year 2020-2021.
After discussion and deliberation the Board approved
the Revenue budget for 2020-2021 as presented before
the Board.
154.09: Extra Agenda: Corrigendum of the Proceeding
of the 151st and 152nd Board Meeting.
The Board deliberated on the matter at length and it was
pointed out by the Member from the Planning that as per
the decision taken in the 151st meeting R.O.P. is to be
implemented with effect from 1st January 2019 then
payment of arrear revised pay also should be made from
01.01.2019. Thereafter it was resolved by the Board that
they should stick with implementation of the 5th
Meghalaya Pay Commission to the employees of the
Corporation be with effect from 1st January 2019 as
approved earlier.”
8.
A perusal of the above would clearly go to show that while arriving
at the decision to implement the Fifth Pay Commission recommendations
2025:MLHC:1097
from 01-01-2019, the Corporation had taken a considered decision keeping
in mind the financial constraints that the Corporation was under. Further, it
being settled law that the Corporation is the sole authority with the manner
and date of implementation, and the same being an executive decision of the
Corporation itself, in the considered opinion of this Court, no interference is
called for.
9.
For the reasons aforementioned, and on the facts and circumstances
of the case, the writ petition is devoid of any merit and is accordingly
dismissed.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2025.11.17 05:38:57 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review