The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. Taking into account the settled principles of law laid down in the said judgment, it is the opinion of this Court that on the basis of the facts which have already been narrated above and the analysis so made, nothing has been placed before this Court which would shock the judicial conscience of this Court upon the punishment imposed. The findings of fact in the Enquiry Report clearly show that the Petitioner not only was inefficient which led to loss of revenue but the Petitioner also violated the Operational Guidelines which the Petitioner being the Programme Officer was required that the Petitioner had knowledge of the same. In matters where public money is spent, the Officer concerned cannot be allowed to take a stand that he did not know. The Operational Guidelines Page No.# 12/12 were clear and in spite of that pleading, ignorance only shows complete lack of efficiency on the part of the Petitioner. Negligence which results in loss to the public exchequer for want of knowledge of the required norms is a sheer case of inefficiency requiring such Officer to be shorn off from service as dead wood. Apart from that, even prior to imposition of punishment, a request was made seeking the Petitioner’s transfer for poor performance. Under such circumstances, this is not a fit case for interference with the punishment imposed upon the Petitioner.
22. Considering the above, it is the opinion of this Court that the instant writ petition lacks merit for which the instant writ petition stands dismissed. No costs. Bijoy Saha by Bijoy Saha 10:51:44 +05'30' Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010281822023
2026:GAU-AS:1828
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7302/2023
KHABIR UDDIN AHMED
SON OF LATE SADAR ALI,
VILLAGE AND P.O.- NAGAON,
P.S.- BARPETA SADAR,
DISTRICT- BARPETA, ASSAM,
PIN- 781311.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT (B) DEPARTMENT,
ASSAM, DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 781006.
2:THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT (B) DEPARTMENT
ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
3:THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT (B) DEPARTMENT
ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
DHUBRI
DISTRICT- DHUBRI
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/12
PIN- 783301.
5:THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
DHUBRI ZILLA PARISHAD
DHUBRI
DISTRICT- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783301
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. J. Abedin, Advocate
: Mr. A. M. Ahmed, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K. Konwar, Addl. AG, Assam
: Mr. A. Kalita, Advocate
: Mr. M. Kalita, Government Advocate
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: N/A
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 07.02.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
·
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: No
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. J. Abedin, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner and Mr. K. Konwar, the learned Additional Advocate General as
well as the Standing counsel of the P&RD Department appearing on behalf
of all the Respondents.
2.
The present writ petition has been filed by the Petitioner assailing the
order dated 16.09.2023 by which the major penalty of compulsory
Page No.# 3/12
retirement under Rule 7(v) of the Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal)
Rules, 1964 (for short ‘the Rules of 1964) was imposed upon the Petitioner
and the notification dated 26.09.2023 whereby the order dated 16.09.2023
imposing the major penalty was duly notified and given effect to.
3.
The question involved in the instant writ petition is as to whether
imposition of the penalty of compulsory retirement vide the order dated
16.09.2023 was in accordance with law.
4.
At the outset, it is very pertinent to take note of that though the
Petitioner had an alternative and efficacious remedy of preferring an appeal
in terms with Rule 15 of the Rules of 1964, the Petitioner did not avail the
said remedy but approached this Court. It is also very pertinent to take note
of that the Petitioner has also not challenged the findings of the enquiry
dated 21.06.2023.
5.
Be that as it may, for the purpose of deciding the instant writ petition,
this Court finds it pertinent to take note of the brief facts which led to the
filing of the instant writ petition.
FACTUAL PERSPECTIVE QUA THE PLEADINGS:
6.
The materials on record would show that an FIR was lodged by the
Chief Executive Officer of the Zilla Parishad, Dhubri before the Officer Incharge of Dhubri Police Station dated 08.07.2021 alleging misappropriation
of money against Shri Saddam Hussain, Shri Abdullah Al Masud Mollah and
Shri Jahidul Hoque. The said FIR was registered as Dhubri P.S. Case
No.1097/2021 under Sections 120(B)/406/409/465/468/471/420/511 of the
Page No.# 4/12
IPC.
7.
It appears that the Petitioner herein in pursuance to the said FIR was
arrested on 05.09.2021. On the basis of the arrest, the Petitioner was
suspended in terms with Rule 6(2) of the Rules of 1964. The Petitioner
thereupon filed an application for bail before this Court which was registered
and numbered as Bail Application No.3144/2021 and the learned Coordinate
Bench of this Court released the Petitioner on bail vide an order dated
26.11.2021.
8.
Thereupon, on 04.01.2022, the Petitioner was issued a Show Cause
Notice in terms with Rule 9(2) of the Rules of 1964 thereby charging the
Petitioner with gross negligence of duty and breach of conduct in performing
duties and violation of Rule 3 of the Assam Civil Service (Conduct) Rules,
1965. The Petitioner submitted his statement of defence. Pursuant thereto,
an Enquiry Officer was appointed for the purpose of carrying out the
necessary enquiry.
9.
It is pertinent to mention that during this period, the Petitioner was
also reinstated to his service vide a notification dated 10.03.2022. The
Enquiry Report was submitted on 21.06.2023. In respect to both the
charges, it was opined by the Enquiry Officer that the said charges levelled
against the Petitioner were proved beyond doubt.
10.
At this stage, it is very relevant to take note of another aspect prior to
the submission of the Enquiry Report dated 21.06.2023. The Deputy
Commissioner, Dhubri, submitted a letter dated 08.06.2022 reporting that
the Petitioner herein was unable to monitor daily activities/progress of
Page No.# 5/12
important schemes and requested his transfer due to poor performance.
When the request for such transfer was placed before the Chief Minister of
Assam, an order dated 07.10.2022 was issued directing the Department to
consider the Petitioner for compulsory retirement in larger public interest.
11.
Be that as it may, the enquiry so initiated against the Petitioner
continued and on 21.06.2023 as aforestated, the Petitioner was found guilty
as charged. Thereupon, the Enquiry Report being placed before the
Departmental Review Committee, it was decided that the Petitioner should
be given an opportunity to submit his objections/views to the fact finding
Enquiry Report dated 21.06.2023 and accordingly, a second Show Cause
Notice was issued to the Petitioner. The Petitioner replied to the second
Show Cause Notice. The reply to the said second Show Cause Notice
however did not find favour and accordingly, the Petitioner was imposed the
major penalty of compulsory retirement vide the impugned order dated
16.09.2023. The said order dated 16.09.2023 was subsequently given effect
to vide a notification dated 26.09.2023 which is also impugned in the instant
proceedings. The Petitioner thereupon filed the instant writ petition on
11.12.2023 and this Court vide an order dated 18.12.2023 issued notice.
12.
Pursuant thereto, an affidavit-in-opposition was filed by the
Respondent No.2 justifying that the imposition of penalty of compulsory
retirement was proportionate to the charges levelled against the Petitioner
and further the Petitioner cannot raise any issues as regards the findings of
the enquiry. In addition to that, a preliminary objection was taken that this
Court ought not to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution taking into account that there is an alternative and efficacious
Page No.# 6/12
remedy. The Petitioner thereupon submitted a reply by reiterating his stand
in the writ petition and denying to the various factual assertions made in the
affidavit-in-opposition.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE PARTIES:
13.
Mr. J. Abedin, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner
submitted that the allegations so made against the Petitioner are in respect
to a period when the COVID pandemic was going on. On account of the
floods, it was of urgent necessity that works were to be carried out and in
view of the COVID pandemic, there were no person who was willing to
perform such works. It is under such circumstances, the Petitioner was
compelled to request various empanelled contractors more particularly Shri
Jahidul Hoque who is the proprietor of Jahidul Enterprise to carry out the
work. The learned counsel further submitted that it was not the
responsibility of the Petitioner as a Programme Officer to look into the details
which were overseen only by the concerned engineers. The learned counsel
for the Petitioner further submitted that at best what can be alleged against
the Petitioner is a case of negligence but not a case of abdication of duty or
misappropriation as charged. The learned counsel for the Petitioner further
submitted that the imposition of penalty of compulsory retirement vide the
impugned order dated 16.09.2023 did not take into consideration the
previous years of dedicated service rendered by the Petitioner and as such,
the learned counsel submitted that without the said consideration, the
penalty of compulsory retirement could not have been imposed upon the
Petitioner. He further submitted that penalty of compulsory retirement is
disproportionate to the charges levelled against the Petitioner.
Page No.# 7/12
14.
Mr. K. Konwar, the learned Additional Advocate General submitted that
both the charges levelled against the Petitioner were held to be proved. The
Petitioner has not challenged the Enquiry Report and therefore the only
question which can be decided in the instant proceedings is as to whether
the penalty so imposed upon the Petitioner was disproportionate to the
charges levelled. The learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the
scope of judicial review for interfering with the proportionality of the
punishment is very limited and it is only in a case of gross disproportionality,
the powers of judicial review can be exercised. In that regard, he referred to
the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Chief Executive Officer,
Krishna District Cooperative Central Bank Limited and Another Vs. K.
Hanumantha Rao and Another reported in (2017) 2 SCC 528.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
15.
This Court has duly heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of
the parties and perused the materials on record.
16.
Though there is no challenge to the Enquiry Report dated 21.06.2023,
but this Court finds it pertinent taking into account the submissions so made
to look into as to whether the power of judicial review can be exercised as
regards the findings in the Enquiry Report more so, when such findings have
a direct nexus with the punishment imposed.
17.
This Court has perused the Enquiry Report and from a perusal of the
Enquiry Report, the charges which have been levelled against the Petitioner
and the findings thereupon arrived at on the basis of the evidence do not
appear to be perverse or there is any violation to the provisions of law. The
fact that the Petitioner violated the MGNREGA Operational Guidelines have
Page No.# 8/12
been proved against the Petitioner. The fact that the Petitioner choose to
grant the contracts to M/s Jahidul Enterprise in violation of the MGNREGA
Operational Guidelines were apparent not only for the findings of the Enquiry
Officer but also from the self admission of the Petitioner as is apparent from
the writ petition itself. Nothing has been placed by the Petitioner which
would enable this Court to come to a finding that certain vital evidence
which would have changed the findings of fact were not considered.
18.
Considering the above, this Court therefore does not find any ground
to interfere with the findings of fact so arrived at by the Enquiry Officer in its
report dated 21.06.2023.
19.
This Court has also taken note of that in pursuance to the Enquiry
Report dated 21.06.2023, the Petitioner was issued a Show Cause Notice
giving opportunity to place views/objections for/against the Enquiry Report.
The Petitioner though submitted his views on 01.08.2023 but upon
consideration of the reply, the impugned order dated 16.09.2023 was passed
providing due reasons why the Petitioner was imposed the major
punishment of “Compulsory Retirement”.
20.
This Court has also taken note of that earlier a request was made by
the Deputy Commissioner seeking transfer of the Petitioner on account of his
poor performance. The Disciplinary Authority after considering all the
aspects, were of the opinion that as the Petitioner was found to be
inefficient, the punishment of compulsory retirement was imposed upon the
Petitioner. This Court finds it pertinent to take note of the judgment of the
Supreme Court in the case of Chief Executive Officer, Krishna District
Cooperative Central Bank Limited (supra) which was relied upon by Mr. K.
Page No.# 9/12
Konwar, the learned Additional Advocate General as regards the scope of
judicial review in respect to imposition of punishment in Disciplinary
Proceedings. Paragraph Nos. 7.3 of the said judgment being relevant is
reproduced herein under:
“7.3. The impugned order is also faulted for the reason that it is not the
function of the High Court to impose a particular punishment even in those
cases where it was found that penalty awarded by the employer is shockingly
disproportionate. In such a case, the matter could, at the best, be remanded
to the disciplinary authority for imposition of lesser punishment leaving it to
such authority to consider as to which lesser penalty needs to be inflicted upon
the delinquent employee. No doubt, the administrative authority has to
exercise its powers reasonably. However, the doctrine that powers must be
exercised reasonably has to be reconciled with the doctrine that the Court
must not usurp the discretion of the public authority. The Court must strive to
apply an objective standard which leaves to the deciding authority the full
range of choice. In Lucknow Kshetriya Gramin Bank v. Rajendra Singh, this
principle is formulated in the following manner : (SCC pp. 380-81, paras 1314)
“13.
Indubitably, the well-ingrained principle of law is that it is the
disciplinary authority, or the appellate authority in appeal, which is to
decide the nature of punishment to be given to a delinquent employee
keeping in view the seriousness of the misconduct committed by such an
employee. Courts cannot assume and usurp the function of the
disciplinary authority. In Apparel Export Promotion Council v. A.K. Chopra
this principle was explained in the following manner : (SCC p. 773, para
22)
‘22. … The High Court in our opinion fell in error in interfering with
the punishment, which could be lawfully imposed by the
Page No.# 10/12
departmental authorities on the respondent for his proven
misconduct. … The High Court should not have substituted its own
discretion for that of the authority. What punishment was required
to be imposed, in the facts and circumstances of the case, was a
matter which fell exclusively within the jurisdiction of the competent
authority and did not warrant any interference by the High Court.
The entire approach of the High Court has been faulty. The
impugned order of the High Court cannot be sustained on this
ground alone.’
14.
Yet again, in State of Meghalaya v. Mecken Singh N. Marak, this
Court reiterated the law by stating : (SCC pp. 584-85, paras 14 and 17)
‘14. In the matter of imposition of sentence, the scope of
interference is very limited and restricted to exceptional cases. The
jurisdiction of the High Court, to interfere with the quantum of
punishment is limited and cannot be exercised without sufficient
reasons. The High Court, although has jurisdiction in appropriate
case, to consider the question in regard to the quantum of
punishment, but it has a limited role to play. It is now well settled
that the High Courts, in exercise of powers under Article 226, do
not interfere with the quantum of punishment unless there exist
sufficient reasons therefor. The punishment imposed by the
disciplinary authority or the appellate authority unless shocking to
the conscience of the court, cannot be subjected to judicial review.
In the impugned order of the High Court no reasons whatsoever
have been indicated as to why the punishment was considered
disproportionate. Failure to give reasons amounts to denial of
justice. The mere statement that it is disproportionate would not
suffice.
17.
Even in cases where the punishment imposed by the
Page No.# 11/12
disciplinary authority is found to be shocking to the conscience of
the court, normally the disciplinary authority or the appellate
authority should be directed to reconsider the question of
imposition of penalty. The High Court in this case, has not only
interfered with the punishment imposed by the disciplinary
authority in a routine manner but overstepped its jurisdiction by
directing the appellate authority to impose any other punishment
short of removal. By fettering the discretion of the appellate
authority
to
impose
appropriate
punishment
for
serious
misconducts committed by the respondent, the High Court totally
misdirected itself while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226.
Judged in this background, the conclusion of the Division Bench of
the High Court cannot be regarded as proper at all. The High Court
has interfered with the punishment imposed by the competent
authority in a casual manner and, therefore, the appeal will have to
be accepted.”
21.
Taking into account the settled principles of law laid down in the said
judgment, it is the opinion of this Court that on the basis of the facts which
have already been narrated above and the analysis so made, nothing has
been placed before this Court which would shock the judicial conscience of
this Court upon the punishment imposed. The findings of fact in the Enquiry
Report clearly show that the Petitioner not only was inefficient which led to
loss of revenue but the Petitioner also violated the Operational Guidelines
which the Petitioner being the Programme Officer was required that the
Petitioner had knowledge of the same.
In matters where public money is spent, the Officer concerned cannot be
allowed to take a stand that he did not know. The Operational Guidelines
Page No.# 12/12
were clear and in spite of that pleading, ignorance only shows complete lack
of efficiency on the part of the Petitioner. Negligence which results in loss to
the public exchequer for want of knowledge of the required norms is a sheer
case of inefficiency requiring such Officer to be shorn off from service as
dead wood.
Apart from that, even prior to imposition of punishment, a request was
made seeking the Petitioner’s transfer for poor performance.
Under such circumstances, this is not a fit case for interference with
the punishment imposed upon the Petitioner.
22.
Considering the above, it is the opinion of this Court that the instant
writ petition lacks merit for which the instant writ petition stands dismissed.
No costs.
Bijoy
Saha
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.02.11
10:51:44 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review