Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:512
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 498 of 2019
1. Shri. Kewingson Momin
S/o:(L) Joga Marak,
President, Dambo-Rongjeng
Land Owners Associations,
R/o: Rongjeng,
P.O & P.S: Rongjeng,
District: East Garo Hills,
Meghalaya.
2. Shri. Keneth Momin,
S/o (L) Renjang Sangma
Secretary, Dambo-Rongjeng
Land Owners Association,
R/o: Rongjeng,
P.O & P.S: Rongjeng,
District: East Garo Hills,
Meghalaya.
::::Petitioners
Date of Decision: 07.06.2024
Vs.
1. State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Chief Secretary
to the Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
2. The Principal Secretary, to the
Govt. of Meghalaya, Revenue and
Disaster Management Department,
Shillong.
3. The Deputy Commissioner
(Revenue)/District Collector,
East Garo Hills District,
Williamnagar.
4. The Chief Engineer PWD (Roads)
Meghalaya, Shillong.
5. The Executive Engineer PWD
(Roads), Williamnagar, In-Charge,
of Dambo-Rongjeng to MangsangAdokgre Road, under, NLCPR,
Ministry of Doner, Government of
India, East Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
6. The Assistant Executive Engineer
(PWD Road), Rongjeng SubDivision, Rongjeng, East Garo Hills
District, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:512
7. Shri. Ojin Momin,
Nokma Amata/Watecha A’king Land,
R/o:- Watecha Village
P.O:- Mangsang, P.S:- Rongjeng
District: East Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
::::Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A. H. Hazarika, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N. D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. A. H. Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA.(R:1-6)
None for (R: - 7)
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
By this writ petition, the petitioners claim for compensation for
anticipated damages to their properties due to the proposed widening of the
Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road and also for setting aside and quashing of
the impugned order dated 08-03-2019 issued by the respondent No.3 by which
the petitioners and others are found to have encroached the PWD roadside land
situated along the said road.
2024:MLHC:512
1.
The petitioner No.1 and the petitioner No.2 claim themselves to be the
President and Secretary respectively of Dambo-Rongjeng Land Owners
Association. The case of the petitioners is that the Government with the
intention of widening the Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road issued a public
notice (vide Annexure -1 to the writ petition) without formulating any scheme
for compensating the settlers who would be affected by the said widening of
the road.
The existing Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road is a narrow and
small road and on both side of the road there are many residential houses,
shops, plantations and cultivations etc. on which the petitioners and many
others are dependent for maintaining their livelihood. The proposed
construction of widening of the road would damage and destroy the properties
of the petitioners and others thereby affecting their survival and, hence the
Government is duty bound to pay compensation to the petitioners and other
affected persons for their properties to be damaged by such construction. The
petitioners being aggrieved by such action of the Government, had preferred a
representation dated 24-11-2017, raising their grievances and claiming
compensation, however, the said representation went unheard.
Having no
other option, the petitioners approached this Court on an earlier occasion by
way of WP(C) No. 24 of 2018 which was disposed of at the stage of motion by
order dated 23-05-2018 with a direction to the respondent No.3 to accord
consideration to the representation of the petitioner and for taking all necessary
action required to ensure that the object of the representation is achieved.
Consequent to the direction, an enquiry into the matter was held after taking
into consideration all relevant aspects and reports and on the basis of the
enquiry report, the respondent No.3 passed the impugned order dated 08-032019 holding the petitioners and others as encroachers to the PWD land and
also held that their claim for compensation has no merit.
2024:MLHC:512
2.
Mr. A. H. Hazarika, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
that the petitioners and many others are residing by the side of Rongjeng
Mangsang A’dokgre Road for many years and have undertaken several
activities in the area for supporting their livelihood by setting up residential
houses, shops and other structures and also have many plantations and
cultivations in the area. He submits that although the Rongjeng Mangsang
A’dokgre Road is in existence since the year 1970 and was constructed on the
land donated by the land owners at that point of time, the petitioners continued
to occupy the land lying by the side of the said road for sustaining their
livelihood. He submits that the petitioners being aware of the fact that the land
in question had been donated to the Government, are not making any claim for
payment of compensation in respect of the stretches of land held by them and
are only praying for payment of compensation for the damage to the structures
erected on the land and other properties to be caused by the widening of the
road. He admits that the land on which petitioners have taken up all their
activities belong to the Government and they have no claim over the land. He
further submits that the petitioners are mostly illiterate and poor persons and it
becomes the duty of the Government to ensure that their livelihood is not
affected by any action on the part of the authorities. He submits that the survey
report on Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road prepared by the PWD
department of the State (page 49 of the writ petition) makes it evident that
many properties including houses, shops, plantation and cultivation would be
destroyed in the event of widening of the road and prays for issuance of
necessary directions to the respondents for consideration of payment of
compensation to the petitioner and others.
3.
Countering the submission made on behalf of the petitioner, Mr. N. D.
Chullai, learned AAG appearing on behalf of the State-respondents, questions
the maintainability of the writ petition on the ground that the Dambo-Rongjeng
2024:MLHC:512
Land Owners Association is not a registered association and there is no
document on record showing the authorization of the petitioners being the
President and the Secretary respectively of the said Association to file the
present writ petition. He submits that there is also no compliance of the
provisions of Order 1 Rule 8 CPC, which mandates taking of permission of the
court for filing a case in representative capacity, by the writ petitioners. The
learned AAG contends that the proposed construction of Rongjeng Mangsang
A’dokgre Road is very much within the Government land as the construction
would be confined to 35 feet from the centre of the existing road designated as
Right of Way (ROW).
He submits that the Government cannot be asked to
pay compensation for making construction of road on its own land. Referring
to the survey report (page 43 of the writ petition), the report dated 20-06-2018
of the Executive Engineer, PWD, Williamnagar and the Enquiry Report dated
21-12-2018 of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Williamnagar, he submits
that the petitioners and many others have been found to be encroachers on the
stretches of the land located along the sides of the Rongjeng Mangsang
A’dokgre Road and the encroachers cannot have any legal right to claim
compensation. He contends that the Government cannot be asked to initiate
acquisition proceedings to acquire its own land in order to make out a case for
the petitioners. The Learned AAG further contends that the construction of the
existing road is proposed on the basis of the fund provided by the Central
Government and the scheme does not make any provision for payment of
compensation. There is no intention on the part of the Government to acquire
additional land and the petitioners are demanding compensation for the very
act of encroachment and unauthorized activity on the PWD roadside land
which is not permissible in law. He submits that there is no legality in the claim
made in the writ petition and the same be dismissed forthwith.
4.
None appeared for the respondent No.7.
2024:MLHC:512
5.
From the submissions made by the rival parties and on perusal of the
materials on record, it is clear that the Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road,
which is a Government PWD Road, is in existence from the year 1970. The
notification issued vide Annexure - 1 to the writ petition speaks of construction
of intermediate lane on the aforesaid road for a total length of 38 kilometers
covering from Rongjeng to A’dokgre under a project funded by the
Government of India. There is no mention of requirement of any additional
land for the purpose of the said construction in the notice. The notice appears
to be issued for general public information and not under any specific law or
under the provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Re-settlement Act, 2013. The petitioners
also have not taken any plea in the writ petition that the aforesaid proposed
construction would require additional land other than the land which forms part
and parcel of the existing road. Hence, it is clear that the Government does not
intend to take any additional piece of land from any anyone for the proposed
construction of the Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road.
6.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner in his argument before this Court
conceded that the properties, for which claim of compensation is made in the
writ petition, are not located on the individual private land of the petitioners.
The survey report (page – 49 of the writ petition) relied on by the learned
Counsel for the petitioner contains a list of occupiers who have encroached the
area located by the side of the Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road belonging
to the PWD department of the State. The survey report also contains the
description of the unauthorized properties in the encroached portion of the road
against the name of each and every individual who are held to be in illegal
occupation of the land. The petitioners have not brought anything into the
record to establish that all the properties mentioned in the list were set up after
obtaining due permission from the Government. There is also nothing on
2024:MLHC:512
record to indicate that there was a kind of implied approval of the Government
in setting up of such properties on the encroached PWD land. There is nothing
in law to show that encroachers are entitled to claim compensation for damages
of properties set up without any authority. The survey report, as such, does not
add any legality to the claim of compensation made by the petitioner in the writ
petition.
7.
Perusal of the order-sheets of the present case reveals that at the stage of
motion of the writ petition, this Court was informed by the learned Counsel for
the petitioners that the present writ petition has been filed for the benefits of
180 individuals. By order dated 15-11-2019, this Court directed the petitioners
to place on record the list of all such persons along with pattas said to have
been issued in their favour. Pursuant to the said direction, the petitioners vide
an additional affidavit dated 02-12-2019 brought into records a list of 84
persons and the land documents/pattas issued by the Garo Hills Autonomous
District Council (in short GHADC) concerning the said 84 persons. However,
it is interesting to notice that the list of 84 persons does not include the names
of any of the petitioners. The writ petition also does not contain any details as
to how many members are there in the petitioners’ association and what their
names and other details are. Therefore, there exists a serious doubt about the
claim raised by the petitioners in the writ petition. This is in view of the fact
that admittedly petitioners’ association is not a registered association and there
is no compliance of Order 1 Rule 8 CPC by the petitioners before instituting
this writ petition.
8.
During the argument of the matter, the learned Counsel for the petitioner
conceded that the land document pertains to the portions of land falling outside
the land covered by the Rongjeng Mangsang A’dokgre Road. He also further
conceded that the structures, plantations and cultivations which are likely to be
destroyed or damaged by the proposed construction are situated by the side of
2024:MLHC:512
the said road forming part and parcel of the road. Hence, there remains no iota
of doubt that the compensation claimed in the writ petition pertains to the
unauthorized properties set up on the encroached lands of the said PWD road.
There is no law which entitles an encroacher to claim compensation for
unauthorized occupation of encroached land and for damages/destruction made
to the properties set up illegally on the encroached land.
9.
In addition to the above observation, it appears from the land
documents/Periodic Lease Patta brought into records by the petitioners that
there is a stipulation contained therein which states that in the event the State
Government or the Local Authority desire to make road through patta land, the
pattadar shall have to leave at least 35 feet of land for making road. The
provisions of Rule 23 of the rules under the Assam Land and Revenue
Regulation 1886 as adopted by the GHADC lays down as under: “23. Roadside land.
(1) Nothing in these rules shall
entitle any person to obtain a lease in respect of land within
35 feet from the foot of the slope of a public road. Any
person occupying or encroaching on such land shall be
liable to ejectment under R.18 of these rules.
Explanation
The expression “public road” includes
any road maintained by the State Government or by a local
board, and any other road declared by the Deputy
Commissioner to be a public road for the purpose of this
rule.
(2) Except under the general or special orders of the
State Government, no new periodic lease shall be issued in
respect of land within one chain (66 feet) of the 35 feet
reservation alongside roads maintained by the State
Government.
Note.
This rule applies to existing and not to
projected roads. It is, however, open to the Public Works
Department to apply to the Deputy Commissioner to utilize
his powers under R. 2 so as to reserve from settlement
otherwise than on annual lease land lying within 126 feet
from the centre line of a projected road.”
2024:MLHC:512
From the above, it emerges that no one can maintain a legal claim of
ownership or possessory right over the land and properties set up thereon
falling within the 35 feet from the foot of the slope of a public road. Thus, the
question of payment of compensation for any alleged damage or destruction of
properties situated within such 35 feet does not arise.
10.
In view of what has been discussed, there is no merit in this writ petition
and the same stands dismissed.
11.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
07.06.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
BISWARUP
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.06.07 17:03:30 +05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review