Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 13941/2026
CNR: RJHC020855852026 | URN: CRLMB / 25790U / 2026
Kewal Singh S/o Roopsingh, Aged About 52 Years, R/o Bajigar
Basti Near Barnala Fatak, Ward No. 11, Dhuri, Police Station
Dhuri, District Sangrur (Kota) (At Present Accused Confined In
Central Jail, Kota)
----Petitioner
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through Pp
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Nirmal Kumar Sharma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Jitendra Singh Rathore, PP
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE FARJAND ALI
Order
14/09/2026
1.
The jurisdiction of this Court has been invoked by way of
filing an application under Section 483 BNSS at the instance
of accused-petitioner. The requisite details of the matter are
tabulated herein below:
S.No.
Particulars of the Case
1.
FIR Number
140/2022
2.
Concerned Police Station
Suket
3.
District
Kota Rural
4.
Offences alleged in the FIR
Under Sections 8/15 and
8/18 of the NDPS
Act.
5.
Offences added, if any
-
6.
Date of passing of impugned 01.07.2026
order
(2 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
2.
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
It is contended on behalf of the accused-petitioner that no
case for the alleged offences is made out against him and his
incarceration is not warranted. There are no factors at play in
the case at hand that may work against grant of bail to the
accused-petitioner and he has been made an accused based
on conjectures and surmises.
3.
Contrary to the submissions of learned counsel for the
petitioner,
learned
Public
Prosecutor
opposes
the
bail
application and submits that the present case is not fit for
enlargement of accused on bail.
4.
I have considered the submissions made by both the parties
and have perused the material available on record.
5.
In the present case, the accused-petitioner has remained in
custody since the year 2022 and has thus undergone
incarceration for nearly four years. The alleged recovery is of
about 97.970 kilograms of doda chura and about 2 kg of
opium. Out of the total 29 prosecution witnesses, only 5
witnesses have so far been examined, which clearly indicates
that the trial is still at an initial stage and is likely to take
considerable time to reach its logical conclusion. Having
regard to the prolonged incarceration and the pace of the
trial, the rigour of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, though
statutorily prescribed, cannot be permitted to operate in
isolation or at the cost of the fundamental right guaranteed
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The statutory
embargo must necessarily yield where the right to a speedy
(3 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
trial stands substantially impaired by prolonged incarceration
and the trial is not progressing at a reasonable pace.
6.
Dealing with the identical issue where the trial had been
protracted
for
an
unreasonable
period,
an
elaborate
discussion has been made by this Court while deciding the
S.B.
Criminal
Misc.
Bail
Application
No.5916/2023
in
Lichhman Ram @ Laxman Ram Vs. State of Rajasthan
the relevant part that would be apt to reproduce here which
reads as under:7.
This Court feels that the nature and gravity of
offence and availability of material in support thereof are
not the only factors to be taken into account while
considering a bail application. The fact that trial is to be
concluded within a reasonable period of time is
imperative while considering grant of bail to an accused.
It is settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that there
is presumption of innocence at the pre-conviction stage
and the objective for keeping a person in jail is to
ensure his presence to face the trial and to receive the
sentence that may be passed. This detention is not
supposed to be punitive or preventive in nature. An
accused is considered to be innocent until he or she or
they are proven guilty in the court of law.
8.
As per the fundamental rights granted to every
citizen/person by the Constitution of India, the accused
cannot be expected to languish in custody for an
indefinite period if the trial is taking unreasonably long
time to reach the stage of conclusion. An under trial
prisoner, who is waiting for the trial to complete and
reach a conclusion about his guilt for the alleged crime,
is not only deprived of his right to a speedy trial but his
other fundamental rights like right to liberty, freedom of
movement, freedom of practising a profession or
carrying on any occupation, business or trade and
freedom to dignity are also hampered.
9.
Life without liberty is like a body without soul.
Freedom is the open window through which pours the
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(4 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
sunlight of the human spirit and human dignity. Personal
liberty of the accused is sacrosanct and quintessential to
the very spirit and structure of a civilisation. Jeremy
Bentham, the great English jurist, postulated that the
greatest happiness of the greatest number is the end of
law. The concept of civil liberty is embedded in
individualism. This simply means that the purpose of the
state is to help every individual in reaching their highest
development and evolving into the best personality,
thereby reaching a point where law and state are not
required by the society. Thus, when personal liberty of
an individual is threatened, his development is in peril
which is a matter of great concern. Sir Wiiliam
Blackstone has deftly observed on page 134 of the first
volume of his book, ‘Commentaries on the Laws of
England’ that,
"Personal liberty consists in the power of locomotion,
of changing situation or moving one's person to
whatsoever place one's own inclination may direct,
without imprisonment or restraint unless by due
process of law".
Justice cannot be presumed to have been
administered merely on passing of a judgment of
conviction and order of sentence or a judgment of
acquittal; rather administration of justice shall be deemed
to have been completed when the trial is concluded within
a reasonable period of time and the accused as well as
the complainant/victim are not made to wait for years on
end to know the result of the trial.
10. One of the founding fathers and the Third President
of the United States of America, Thomas Jefferson, has
rightly said that, “Rightful liberty is unobstructed action,
according to our will, within limits drawn around us by the
equal rights of others." Though the victim/complainant
party has the right to seek justice against an accused
person but that does not mean that the right of the
accused to a fair trial can get hampered. A fair trial is one
which is concluded within a reasonable period of time.
11. It is not just a fundamental right but also a human
right of every accused as incarceration for an indefinite
period pending trial is in contravention of the universal
rights that are imperative for us all sans any kind of
discrimination. Justice P.N. Bhagwati has embodied the
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(5 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
spirit of the afore-mentioned observation in Maneka
Gandhi Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Ors. reported in
AIR 1978 SC 597 in the following words:
“The expression ‘personal liberty’ in Article 21 is of
the widest amplitude and it covers a variety of rights
which go to constitute the personal liberty of man
and some of them have raised to the status of
distinct fundamental rights and given additional
protection under Article 19.”
12. No one is unaware of the fact that justice delayed is
justice denied. On one hand, if a victim has to wait for
years to see the perpetrator get his due and on the other
hand, if the accused is innocent and it is so decided that
he was not guilty for the crime as alleged by the
prosecution, then there is no justifiable answer that can
put out the fire that has been burning in the minds of the
parties since the very inception of the criminal
proceedings.
13. A petition for issuance of a writ of habeas corpus
was filed in Hussainara Khatoon & Ors. Vs. Home
Secretary, State of Bihar, Govt. of Bihar, Patna
reported in 1979 SCR (3) 169, praying for the release of a
large number of men, women and children that were
languishing in jails in Bihar for offences which if found
guilty, were punishable by a sentence of not more than
few months. Following the creative deliverance passed in
the case of Maneka Gandhi (supra) which expanded the
scope of interpretation under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India, the right to a speedy trial was interpreted as
being implied in the broad gamut of rights that are borne
out of right to life and personal liberty enshrined under
Article 21. Justice Bhagwati further expressed his anguish
over the fact that the bail system of India works on the
rusty assumption that monetary loss will deter an accused
from fleeing from justice and thus, it operates harshly
against the poor and indigent persons of the society. The
burden of the period of detention falls on the innocent
people who are the members of the family of the accused.
A set of guidelines were issued by the Apex Court in
this case to ensure that the courts subordinate to
each of the High Courts take lesser time to reach a
legitimate conclusion in a trial and that there should
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(6 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
be greater access to bail along with humane living
standards for the under-trials.
14. Subsequent to Hussainara Khatoon (supra),
Hon’ble the Supreme Court held that the right to speedy
trial is available at all the stages, be it the stage of
investigation or inquiry, trial, appeal, revision and even
retrial, in Abdul Rehman Antulay & Ors. Vs. R.S.
Nayak & Ors., reported in AIR 1992 SC 1701. In addition
to the above, it was also held that a time limit cannot be
set for the conclusion of trial as there are many factors
that impact the right to speedy trial and the facts and
circumstances of each case need to be considered
separately. An order for conclusion of trial within a fixed
time is possible in specific cases where the circumstances
and nature of offence demand it but a fixed time limit for
all the trials cannot be imposed.
15. In the case of Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, reported in
AIR 2012 SC 830, Hon'ble the Supreme Court had
observed that as the investigation is complete and charge
sheet has already been filed by the investigating agency,
there remains no necessity to keep the accused in custody
for further investigation. Being cognizant of the fact that
the alleged offences were such that if proved, they could
cause peril to the Indian economy, still Hon'ble the
Supreme Court upheld the right of an under-trial prisoner
to be released on bail. In S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous IV
Bail Application No.14677/2021 titled as Banwari Meena
v. State of Rajasthan, this Court has passed an
elaborate order in similar context holding that it is a wellestablished canon of criminal law that there is
presumption of innocence at the pre-conviction stage and
the objective for keeping a person in jail is to ensure his
presence to face trial and to receive the sentence that
may be passed. This detention is not supposed to be
punitive or preventive in nature. In another case titled
Savanta v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Criminal
Miscellaneous VII Bail Application No. 3701/2022), this
Court has held that over-incarceration of under-trial
prisoners, beyond reasonable period of time, is violative of
their fundamental right to a fair and speedy trial. Any trial
that is deemed fair should conclude in a reasonable period
of time.
16. While keeping an accused detained, the opportunity
to the prosecutor to lead evidence can only be given for a
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(7 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
reasonable period. The wider connotation of the phrase
‘reasonable period’ be understood to be one year because
the case is classified as a sessions case which would mean
that the like cases should commence and conclude within
a session, that is, one year. Even if an elastic
interpetration of the expression ‘reasonable period’ is
taken
on
the
pretext
of
certain
unavoidable
circumstances, then it can only be doubled and even in
that situation, trial has to be completed within two years
while keeping an accused in custody. Suffice it would to
say that for the purpose of determination as to whether
the accused is guilty or not, only a reasonable period can
be awarded to the prosecutor if the accused is behind the
bars. The cases which are classified as session case are
purposefully directed to be heard by senior officer of
District Judge Cadre looking to his experience and
rank/grade/post. In criminal jurisprudence prevalent in
India, there is a presumption of innocence working in
favour of the accused until he is proven guilty in the trial.
The trial is conducted for the purpose of affording an
opportunity to the prosecutor to prove the charge and
only for the purpose of proving guilt or adducing evidence
on record, an unreasonable period of time cannot be
granted as the same infringes the fundamental rights of
an accused which are otherwise guaranteed by the
Constitution of India. While entertaining a bail plea, the
court of law is required to take into account the abovementioned aspect of the matter as well besides the gravity
of offence and quantum of sentence. After pondering over
the legal provisions made in the code of Criminal
Procedure, the law enunciated by Hon’ble the Supreme
Court through plethora of judicial pronouncements and
upon deliberation of bail jurisprudence, it is understood
that the only thing which a court of law is to ascertain
while entertaining a bail plea is whether the accused
should be allowed to come to the court to attend the
judicial proceeding from his home and he may be allowed
to remain with his family and within the society on the
specific condition that on the stipulated date of the
hearing of the case, he will willfully attend the court
proceeding or he is such a person that even in the
pending trial, he should be detained, should not be
allowed to visit his family and should be lodged at a
specified place of detention so that on the day of hearing,
he may be brought to the court from the jail. In other
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(8 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
words, it is to be decided whether he may be allowed to
eat, sleep and live with his family like a man ordinarily
does or he may be allowed to eat, sleep and live in the
jail. It all boils down to this that whether the Court wishes
to allow the accused to come to the court to attend the
proceedings from his home upon furnishing his bonds and
surety of independent person(s)s or the court thinks that
he cannot be allowed to roam free and therefore, he
should be detained so that he may be brought before the
court on the day fixed for the hearing. This Court is of the
considered view that this is the only thing which is to be
thought over and to be ascertained while entertaining a
bail plea. The main object of keeping a person behind the
bars pending trial is nothing more but to ensure a smooth,
unhindered, fair and speedy trial and that he may be
present to receive the sentence as may be passed.
17. Courts should not lose sight of the fact that preconviction detention has some punitive implications and
the purpose of detention before conviction is to secure
their presence at the trial and ensure their personal
attendance in cases where necessity dictates their arrest
and jail is the exception not the rule.
18. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has recently passed a
judgment in Criminal Appeal No(s). 1525 of 2021 titled as
Ashim @ Asim Kumar Haranath Bhattacharya @
Asim Harinath Bhattacharya @ Aseem Kumar
Bhattacharya v. National Investigation Agency vide
order dated 01.12.2021 wherein looking to the aspect that
the fundamental right of the undertrial prisoner to have a
timely trial was getting violated due to long and indefinite
period of incarceration, the trial court was directed to
grant the benefit of post-arrest bail in favour of the
appellant.
19. In Union of India (UOI) Vs. K.A. Najeeb,
reported in AIR 2021 SC 712, Hon’ble the Supreme Court
upheld the order of the High Court of Kerala granting bail
to an accused and observed that had it been a case at the
threshold, the Hon’ble Court would not have paid heed to
the respondent’s prayer but looking to the length of time
that the accused has already spent in jail and the
likelihood of the trial taking still more time to conclude,
they agreed that the High Court was not left with any
other option but to release the accused on bail. The
relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced as below:
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(9 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
“An attempt has been made to strike a balance
between the Appellant's right to lead evidence of its
choice and establish the charges beyond any doubt
and
simultaneously
the
Respondent's
rights
guaranteed under Part III of our Constitution have
been well protected.”
20. In another recent case of Satender Kumar Antil
Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation & Ors., reported
in AIR 2022 SC 3386, Hon’ble the Supreme Court took
cognizance of the fact that the jails of the country are
over-flowing with prisoners and that arrest, being a
draconian measure that curtails the liberty of the arrested
individual, should be used sparingly. It was also observed
that accused can be considered for enlargement on bail
on the basis of unreasonable delay being one of the
grounds. The Apex Court classified offences into four
broad categories and prescribed guidelines with respect
to following statutory law as well as precedents laid down
by the Apex Court with regard to Sections 41 & 41A, 87 &
88, 167, 170, 309(1) among others, with the expectation
that it would help in unclogging the prisons and result in
reduction of pendency of bail applications.
21. The inmates who have spent years on end to see
what has been decided in their case have probably
resigned to their ill fate and become used to the confines
of the four walls of the prison. It reminds this Court of the
reference made to Dr. Manette’s predicament in the
Charles Dickens’ novel ‘A Tale of Two Cities’ by Hon’ble
the Supreme Court in State of Kerala Vs. Raneef,
reported in AIR 2011 SC 340 while dismissing the appeal
filed against grant of bail to the accused who was a
doctor and had already spent 66 days in custody. In the
book, Dr. Manette had spent such a long time of eighteen
years as an inmate that he forgot his name, profession
and other details about his life that existed prior to him
becoming a prisoner at La Bastille. This Court is anxious
over the fact that jails debilitate the under-trial prisoners
and if after the long wait, the accused is ultimately
acquitted, then how would the long years spent by the
under-trial in custody be restored to him/her/them. The
fact that the imprisonment of a family member affects the
whole family cannot be overlooked and if long
incarceration pending trial is considered to be harsh on
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(10 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
the accused, then it should also be considered to be
equally harsh on the family members of the accused. The
rule is that pre-conviction detention is not warranted by
law.
22. There have been repetitive pronouncements by this
Court as well wherein considering the fact of long
incarceration inter alia other aspects, bail has been
granted to accused persons. Indisputably, the petitioner
has been in custody since long and the protracted trial
will violate his fundamental right to a timely trial.
23. In Writ Petition (Criminal) No 279 of 2022, titled
Mohammed Zubair Vs. State of NCT of Delhi & Ors,
while granting bail to the accused vide order dated
20.07.2022, the Apex Court observed that the accused
was trapped in a vicious cycle of the criminal process
where the process had itself become the punishment.
24. Similarly, in cases where under-trial prisoners are
made to wait and the trial is prolonged, the procedure of
criminal proceedings itself becomes a punishment for
such detainees. If the provisions laid down in the Code of
Criminal Procedure are followed to the letter and not just
in spirit, there will be lesser room for grievance related to
speedy trial. Having noted the significance and
development of the right to speedy trial, it is also
important to consider the following factors while
adjudicating a bail application against the backdrop of the
right to a speedy trial:
i) The delay should not have been a defence tactic. Who
has caused the delay is also to be seen. Every delay does
not necessarily prejudice the accused.
ii) The aim is not to interpret the right to speedy trial in a
manner so as to disregard the nature of offence, gravity
of punishment, number of accused and witnesses,
prevailing local conditions and other systemic delays.
iii) If there is a strong reason to believe that the accused
will surely flee from justice if released on bail and it will
be a hard task for the investigating agency to reapprehend him, then the benefit of bail should not be
extended in his favour.
iv) If it is shown by placing compelling material on record
that the release of the accused may create a ruckus in
the society or that he will create such a situation wherein
the prosecution witnesses will not come forward to
depose against him or that he may otherwise hamper the
evidence of prosecution in any other manner, then utmost
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(11 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
caution needs to be exercised in such cases before
granting bail to the accused.
The (iii) and (iv) points are to be considered only
when strong and cogent evidence is placed on record or a
compelling reason in support has come to light but surely
not just on the basis of a simple, blanket submission
made by the counsel appearing on behalf of the
prosecution/complainant/victim.
25. While hearing a bail plea, if there appears the
slightest possibility of acquittal of the accused based on
any of the submissions made by counsel for the parties,
then there is no harm in inclining towards extending the
benefit of bail in favour of the accused so far as it is
limited to the justifiable disposal of the bail. It is a settled
principle of law that the defence is not required to prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt and it can rely on the
principle of preponderance of probability. In juxtaposition,
the burden to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt
always lies upon the prosecution except in exceptions
prescribed by law. Thus, whenever a doubt is raised
against the story of the prosecution, it needs to be
considered objectively but needless to say, it is to be
considered only for the limited purpose of deciding the
bail application and should not influence the trial court so
as to adversely affect the interests of either of the parties
in any manner.
26. While adjudicating a bail plea, the Court should
never assume that the case put forth by the prosecution
is sacrosanct and true and the accused is guilty; however,
the same does not mean that the case of the prosecution
should be approached with an initial presumption of
doubt. Suffice it to say that if a substantial plea is raised
at the time of praying for bail, it can be considered
tentatively for the purpose of granting bail at that stage,
without deeply speculating the result of the trial as a
dead end. In addition, if material is placed on record, it
needs to be considered.
27. Coming back to the point of protracted trial and
consequent expansion of period of incarceration, this
Court is of the firm view that the accused should be
released on bail if he has been incarcerated pending trial
for more than a reasonable period of time unless
extraordinary and overwhelming circumstances prevent
the Court from doing so.
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(12 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
28. The procedure of law is that the exact date of
imprisonment would commence from the judgment of
conviction and the date of order of sentence. The further
provision of law is that the period already undergone
would be set off against the period of sentence. The
purpose of keeping the accused behind bars is to ensure
that the accused would not flee from justice and to avoid
the apprehension that he may hamper the witnesses or
tamper with the prosecution evidence. True it is that the
gravity of offences and severity of punishment attached
with the crime form vital parts of consideration while
adjudicating a bail plea but the period of incarceration
pending trial must be a reasonable period. It is the duty
of the prosecutor as wells as of the Court to ensure that
the prosecution evidence is produced within a reasonable
period which must not be an unfair and unjust. In order
to justify period of incarceration pending trial, the aid of
provision for setting off period of incarceration suffered
pending trial with the term of imprisonment decided by
the convicting Court in the order of sentence cannot be
taken in cases where the trial went on for a long period of
time and ultimately resulted into acquittal.
29. The right to be freed from detention and get a fast
culmination of trial are liberties that every accused should
be able to enjoy and in cases where the delay is not
caused at the hands of the accused, he bears the brunt of
the follies of the criminal justice system.
30. The right to speedy trial has developed to become an
inalienable fundamental right guaranteed under Article 21
of the Constitution of India by way of a slew of judgments
passed by Hon’ble the Supreme Court, however, it has
been prevalent since times immemorial and finds mention
even in the Magna Carta Libertatum commonly called
Magna Carta, the royal charter of rights agreed to by King
John of England in around 1215 A.D. Among other
conventions and precedents, the text of Magna Carta was
one of the major inspirations that laid the basis for
English Common Law and the pre-eminent English
luminaries like Lord Macaulay and Sir James Stephen
drafted our criminal legislation and statutes. Clause 40 of
the Magna Carta which reads as "To no one will We sell,
to no one will We deny or delay, right or justice", paved
the way for right to habeas corpus as well as the idea of
adjudication by the jury or the equals of the accused. The
idea that no accused person can be detained indefinitely
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(13 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
during the pendency of trial also sprang up from this
clause.
31. The matter needs to be looked at from a
humanitarian lens also. The accused is spending his time
as an under-trial in prison where the living conditions are
depressing and pitiable. The bellies of prisons all across
the country are bloated due to the humongous influx of
prisoners in India. The prisons are over-crowded to an
unimaginable extent. Nelson Mandela was the torchbearer of the movement against apartheid in South Africa
and he had the following words to say about his fabled
incarceration at the Robben Island Prison from 1964 to
1982:
“No one truly knows a nation until one has been
inside its jail. A nation should not be judged by how
it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.”
Any prison that was built with the infrastructure to
hold a certain number of prisoners would be
overpopulated and congested if it would be required to
house a percentage of prisoners which is way beyond its
capacity. Prisoners in India sleep in turns as there is no
space for all of them to sleep at the same time. They are
packed like sardines in the cells and are deprived of basic
needs like balanced diet, sanitation, sewage, hygiene etc.
From food and ration to commodities like soap, detergent,
toothpaste etc., everything is provided by the state in
measured quantities for the number of prisoners that the
prison is designated to hold and not for the number of
prisoners that it actually holds in reality. In such cases,
an under-trial prisoner cannot be subjected to such harsh
and inhuman conditions for eons.
32. The Amnesty International India’s Report titled
Justice Undertrial: A Study of Pre-trial Detention in
India reveals that as of 2019, 69% of the prisoners in
Indian prisons are under-trials which means that the
under-trial prisoners are more than twice in number than
the convicted prisoners. As per the report, the average
occupancy rate of Indian jails is 114%. There are very
few prisons that are equipped and able to decide which
under-trial prisoners are eligible for release under Section
436A of the CrPC. As per the Prison Statistics India 2020
published by the National Crime Records Bureau (Ministry
of Home Affairs), Government of India, 76.12% of the
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
(14 of 15)
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
total prisoners across the country are under-trial
prisoners. Nothing can be assumed about the life
expectancy of an accused, rather if an accused is made to
stay in prisons in such miserable conditions, it would lead
to more health problems and impair the health of the
accused person.
While sharing his thoughts about his experience in
jail, Mahatma Gandhi had once said, “Men in prison are
‘civilly dead’ and have no claim to any say in policy.” Ours
is not a despotic nation rather it is a democratic nation
which proudly upholds the liberties of its citizens. Despite
Supreme Court guidelines, legal and executive reforms,
there is no significant improvement in the state of the
under-trials.
33. Law and society go hand in hand. A lawless society is
no better than a jungle. Right to life is not a bare right; it
means right to a dignified life and personal liberty and
includes in its ambit all aspects that help a person lead a
life of dignity. Any law which does not accommodate or
adapt to the evolution of the society seizes to serve its
purpose. When a person is detached from the society and
put in jail, he goes through a big change of social
environment. The present petitioner has spent seven long
years in prison while he awaits the verdict of his ongoing
trial. Though he has not yet been proved to be guilty but
he has spent all the seasons of last seven years in the jail
precinct; he has not been a part of any social gathering,
major family events, festivals and like occasions for seven
years and if he is finally acquitted after culmination of
trial then no court can give him back the time and
reputation that he has lost. There is no way to
recompense the accused who has spent a prolonged
period pending trial in case there is an acquittal waiting
for him at the end of a seemingly endless journey. No
concept of solatium to an under trial prisoner in case of
acquittal exists in the statutes of our country. Moreover, it
is pertinent to note that if under trial prisoners are
released looking to the facts and circumstances of the
case, then there can be more space for the inmates and
better living standards in the jails. For instance, if a jail is
built to house 100 inmates only but it is overcrowded to
the extent of housing 200 inmates, then release of under
trial prisoners post consideration of relevant factors would
result in improved living conditions for all prison mates.
(15 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:36946]
7.
[CRLMB-13941/2026]
In view of the judgment referred to hereinabove, and having
regard to the fact that the trial is likely to take considerable
time to reach its logical conclusion, this Court is of the
considered
opinion
that
the
petitioner
deserves
to
be
enlarged on bail. In the facts and circumstances of the case,
this Court deems it just and proper to extend the benefit of
bail to the petitioner.
8.
Accordingly, the instant bail application under Section 483
BNSS is allowed and it is ordered that the accused-petitioner
as named in the cause title shall be enlarged on bail provided
he furnishes a personal bond in the sum of Rs.50,000/- with
two sureties of Rs.25,000/- each to the satisfaction of the
learned trial Judge for his appearance before the court
concerned on all the dates of hearing as and when called
upon to do so.
(FARJAND ALI),J
146/YOGESH KUMAR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review