Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:727
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 100 of 2021
Date of Decision: 13.08.2024
1. Shri. Kennedy Ch. Marak
S/o (L) Jogen T. Sangma,
R/o. Gondenggiri A.king
P.O Rongram
P.S. Jengjal West Garo Hills
Meghalaya
2. Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak
W/o Jimberth T. Sangma
R/o. Gondenggiri A.king
P.O Rongram
P.S. Jengjal West Garo Hills
Meghalaya
3. Shri. Jimberth T. Sangma
S/o Shri. Morison Ch. Marak
R/o. Gondenggiri A.khing
P.O Rongram
P.S. Jengjal West Garo Hills
Meghalaya
…… Petitioner
-Versus1. The Garo Hills Autonomous District Council, represented by its
Secretary, Executive Committee, West Garo Hills, Tura
3. Shri. Mechail Ch. Marak
R/o. Gondenggiri A.khing
P.O Rongram, P.S. Jengjal
West Garo Hills Meghalaya.
4. The Chief Executive Member,
2024:MLHC:727
Garo Hills Autonomous District Council, Tura
5. The Executive Member,
In-Charge Land & Revenue,
Garo Hills Autonomous District Council, Tura
…….Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Dey, SC, GHADC (For R 1, 4 & 5)
Mr. S. Deb, Adv. (For R 3)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
This is an application filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the petitioners being aggrieved with the judgment and order
dated 05.02.2019 passed by the Executive Member, I/C Land &
Revenue, Garo Hills Autonomous District Council (GHADC), Tura in
GHADC-REF/19 A.C. of 2015 and the order dated 16.10.2020 passed by
the Chief Executive Member, GHADC, Tura in GDC Rev Appeal No. 2
A/C of 2019, have now approached this Court praying for a direction by
this Court to set aside and quash the abovementioned impugned orders.
2.
Heard Mr. P.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the petitioners who
has submitted that the petitioners are from the lineage of the last
2024:MLHC:727
recorded Nokma of Jamadar Amathe Akhing III-33 under Gondenggiri
Akhing, the parents of the petitioner No. 2 (L) Jongen Sangma and his
wife (L) Jingme Ch. Marak being such registered Nokma by virtue of the
appointment order dated 08.08.1979 issued by P. Momin, Executive
Member, Incharge Revenue, Garo Hills District Council, Tura.
3.
The learned counsel has further submitted that after the demise of
Jongen Sangma, his wife Jingme Ch. Marak had filed a petition for
registration of her daughter Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak along with her
husband Shri. Jimberth T. Sangma as the Nokma of the said Jamadar
Amathe Akhing III-33 under Gondenggiri Akhing which fact was also
admitted by the respondents.
4.
The learned counsel has again submitted that the controversy
between the parties arose only as regard the area of jurisdiction, the
petitioners maintaining that the said Jamadar Amathe Akhing III-33
consisted of 77 bitots (hillocks) whereas the respondents have contended
that the area consists of only 59 bitots.
5.
This controversy apparently refers to a litigation by the parties
before the Waribokgre Village Court in V/C Case No. 4 of 1969 wherein
the Village Court after hearing the parties had vide order dated
04.12.1969 decided the matter in favour of Jingme Ch. Marak the
predecessor of the present petitioners herein. The order of the Village
Court was challenged by the respondent therein, Smti. Genjak Mechik
before the Subordinate District Council Court whereby vide order dated
23.03.1971 the order of the Village Court was set aside. The petitioner
then preferred an appeal before the District Council Court against the said
2024:MLHC:727
order dated 23.03.1971 and again vide order dated 14.12.1972 the District
Council Court had set aside the order dated 23.03.1971 passed by the
Subordinate District Council Court. Against this order dated 14.12.1972
the respondent Smti. Genjak Mechik as petitioner had filed a Civil
Revision Petition No. 5(H) of 1976 before the Gauhati High Court and
the Hon’ble High Court vide judgment dated 08.12.1977 had dismissed
the said petition and in effect had upheld the order dated 14.12.1972
passed by the District Council Court.
6.
On the strength of the High Court’s order dated 08.12.1977, the
predecessor of the petitioners filed an application before the District
Council for execution of such order, accordingly, the said order dated
08.03.1979 was passed in GDC-REV No. 1 A/C of 1979-1980 whereby
the predecessors of the petitioner No. 1, Jogen Sangma and his wife
Jigme Mechik were declared as inheritors of the Jamadar Akhing within
the Akhing land of Gongenggiri.
7.
The learned counsel went on to submit that the respondent has
again approached the High Court with a writ petition being Civil Rule
No. 38 (SH) of 1989 challenging the order dated 08.03.1979. The High
Court upon hearing the parties, have, vide order dated 28.08.1989
remanded the matter to the Executive Member, In-charge, Revenue to
decide the matter afresh, however, it was also made clear that no
submission be entertained in the matter already decided in Civil Revision
No 5(H) of 1976.
8.
As to the order dated 28.08.1989, the respondent has failed to
approach the District Council Court and as such the dispute between the
2024:MLHC:727
parties was put to rest. The petitioner thereafter has approached the
Executive Member I/C Land & Revenue vide GHADC REF/19 A.C. of
2005 with an application for registration of the name of Shri Jimberth T.
Sangma and his wife Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak as the Nokma of Jamadar
Amathe- III-33, the reason being that since the petitioner has inherited the
said Akhing in the year 1979, the first Nokma being Smti Jingme Ch.
Marak and her husband Jogen T. Sangma, therefore the said applicants,
Shri Jimberth T. Sangma and his wife Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak are
entitled to be appointed as the Nokma of the said Jamadar Amathe- III-33
within the Gondenggiri Akhing land.
9.
On the objection of the respondent No. 3 herein, claiming that the
Akhing land belongs to the Chambugong clan, the Executive Member
then passed the impugned order dated 05.02.2019 holding that the
appointment of Smt. Repolish Ch. Marak and her husband Shri Jimberth
T. Sangma was as Jamadal Nokma for 59 bitots within Gondenggiri
Akhing.
10.
The learned counsel has submitted that the petitioners being
aggrieved by the order dated 05.02.2019 passed by the Executive
Member I/C Land & Revenue, an appeal was preferred before the Chief
Executive Member being GDC Rev Appeal No 2 A/C of 2019. However,
the Chief Executive Member, vide order dated 16.10.2020 had dismissed
the appeal as devoid of merits. Hence this petition.
11.
The learned counsel has maintained that the Executive Member in
passing the impugned order dated 05.02.2019 has exceeded his
jurisdiction inasmuch as the matter in favour of the petitioner through his
2024:MLHC:727
predecessor has been settled on the strength of the order dated 08.12.1977
passed in Civil Revision No 5(H) of 1976 as well as the order dated
28.08.1989 passed in Civil Rule No. 38(SH) of 1989 wherein the control
of the petitioners over 77 bitots of land of Jamadar Amathe Akhing III-33
has been confirmed and as such the impugned order is hit by the principle
of res judicata.
12.
The final submission of the learned counsel is that the principle of
natural justice has been violated since the petitioner was not given any
notice when the impugned appellate order dated 16.10.2020 was passed
by the Chief Executive Member.
13.
In reply, Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the respondent No. 3
while refuting the contention and the submission made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner has submitted that at the first instance this
petition is not maintainable as it suffers from non-joinder of necessary
parties, that is the present Nokma of the Godenggiri Akhing, Shri. Ronjith
T. Sangma and Smti. Benje Ch. Marak which Akhing encompasses the
land in question known as Jamadar Amathe Akhing have not been arrayed
as respondents in this case, instead, Shri. Mechail Ch. Marak who is only
a Chra (elder male member) of the Chubogong Clan was impleaded as
respondent No. 3.
14.
The learned counsel went on to submit that the petitioners cannot
be said to be ignorant of this aspect of the matter since the said Nokma
that is Shri. Ronjith T. Sangma and Smti. Benje Ch. Marak were very
much party to the proceedings before the Executive Member who had
passed the impugned order dated 05.02.2019 as well as before the Chief
2024:MLHC:727
Executive Member who had passed the impugned appellate order dated
16.10.2020.
15.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the respondent No. 3
has filed his affidavit-in-opposition in this case and has made several
factual and legal averments thereto. However, the petitioners have not
filed any rejoinder to the said affidavit-in-opposition and as such, without
any rebuttal to the contentions made in the said affidavit-in-opposition,
the same remain uncontroverted. In this regard, the order dated
26.09.2014 passed in WA. No. 43/2011 in the case of Shri. Chellish
Sangma & Anr. v. Smti. Labina Sangma & Ors., para 9 and 10 is cited in
support of this contention.
16.
Reverting to the facts of the case between the parties, the learned
counsel has submitted that there is no dispute that Gondenggiri III-33
Akhing belongs to the Chambugong clan, the same having been
established in the relevant records since the British regime with the
genealogical tree, map-wareng and Ma’ambi being maintained in the
GHADC. Since the year 2013 till date, the registered Nokma(s) of the
said Akhing are Shri Ronjith T. Sangma and his wife Smti. Benje Ch.
Marak who are the descendants of the original Nokma late Chagran
Sangma and Smti Khanje Marak.
17.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the father of the
petitioner No. 1, (L) Jogen T. Sangma had approached the then Nokma of
the said Akhing (Gondenggiri) as well as the office of the Executive
Member, GHADC claiming to be the Jamadal Nokma of the Gondenggiri
Akhing, however, upon scrutiny of the records, the GHADC vide order
2024:MLHC:727
dated 14.10.2009 had rejected the said claim. The claim of the petitioners
as Jamadal Nokma of the said Akhing is therefore hit by the principle of
res judicata, further submits the learned counsel.
18.
The learned counsel has further contended that the petitioners
have not come before this Court with clean hands, inasmuch as they have
failed to mention that vide the said order dated 14.10.2009, the claim of
the petitioners’ predecessors as Nokmas of Gongenggiri Akhing III-33(9)
have been rejected by the GHADC as baseless. There is no appeal filed
against this order, the same has therefore attained finality.
19.
In such a situation, the petitioners by filing the petition before the
Executive Member I/C Land and Revenue, GHADC seeking to recognize
Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak and Shri. Jingberth T. Sangma, the petitioners
No. 2 & 3 respectively as the Jamadal Nokmas of Gondenggiri Akhing
and the rejection of the prayer made therein vide the impugned order
dated 05.02.2019 in GHADC- Rev/19 AC of 2015 is justified as the
learned Executive Member has heard the parties after considering the
petition, the written statement, the issues framed and the arguments of the
parties.
20.
Again, the learned counsel has submitted that on appeal by the
petitioners, the learned Chief Executive Member, GHADC has duly
considered the written submission filed by the parties as well as the oral
argument advanced before him and on consideration of such argument,
the impugned appellate order dated 16.10.2020 was passed. The
challenge of the petitioners that they have not been heard by the CEM is
without basis and is to be discarded, further submits the learned counsel.
2024:MLHC:727
21.
Mr. S. Dey, learned Standing Counsel of the respondent GHADC
in response to the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioners has
submitted that the dispute between the parties in this case is the claim of
the petitioners to be appointed as the Jamadal Nokmas of Amathe Akhing
within the Gondenggriri Akhing. This claim cannot be sustained as there
cannot be an Akhing within an Akhing.
22.
The learned SC has further submitted that there are no records to
prove that the said Jamadar Akhing has been recognized as such since
there is no map or demarcation of such unrecognized Akhing. This has
been clarified by the Executive Member I/C Land & Revenue in his order
dated 08.03.1979.
23.
The claim of the petitioners is only with regard to the ownership
of 77 bitots of land within the said Gondenggiri, which however upon
adjudication, it was clarified that the total land entitled to them is only 77
plot of land or 59 bitots.
24.
The learned SC has also submitted that the proceedings before the
Executive Member as well as the Chief Executive Member was carried
out in accordance with due procedure as was mandated in the case of
Smti Dore Sangma v. The Chief Executive Member, Garo Hills District
Council, Tura & Ors. reported in (1988) 2 GLR 120, with the respective
parties having been given ample opportunities to present their respective
case by filing written statement and upon framing of relevant issues, the
argument of the parties have been heard followed by the passing of the
said impugned order. Therefore, there is no violation of the said
procedure or the principle of natural justice.
2024:MLHC:727
25.
The learned SC has also endorsed the contention of the learned
counsel for the respondent No. 3 that this petition is bad for non-joinder
of proper and necessary parties in the form of the present Nokmas of
Gondenggiri Akhing and on this ground alone, this petition ought to be
dismissed.
26.
On an overall observation of the case between the parties, this
Court is made to understand that the dispute between the principal parties
is with regard to control of an area known to the petitioner as Jamadar
Amathe (A.mate) Aking III-33 which is contained within the Gondenggiri
Akhing land as admitted by the parties.
27.
It is the case of the petitioners that the said Jamadar Amathe falls
within the boundaries of 77 bitots (hillocks) carved out of the said larger
portion of Akhing land called Gondenggiri. It is for this particular plot of
land that an application was made by the predecessor of the petitioner to
be appointed as Nokma of the said Jamadar Amathe Akhing III-33.
28.
As is evident from the submission and contention of the parties
noted herein above, the history of the dispute dates back to the case filed
by the predecessors of the petitioners before the Waribokgre Village
Court in Case No. 4 of 1969, the subject matter being the claim of
ownership over 77 plots of Akhing land which was decreed by the Village
Court in favour of the predecessors of the petitioners herein. On appeal
before the Subordinate District Council Court the order of the Village
Court was vacated. Being aggrieved by the order of the Subordinate
District Council Court, the predecessors of the petitioners preferred an
appeal before the District Council Court and the District Council Court
2024:MLHC:727
vide order dated 14.12.1972 set aside the order of the Subordinate District
Council Court and in effect has upheld the order of the Waribokgre
Village Court.
29.
The opposite parties therein had then approached the High Court
(Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court as this Court then was) with a
Civil Revision Petition No. 5(H) of 1976 assailing the said order dated
14.12.1972. The Hon’ble High Court vide order dated 08.12.1977 had
dismissed the petition finding no merits on the substance in the said
revision petition.
30.
On the strength of the said order dated 08.12.1977 the petitioners
had approached the Executive Member, In-charge, Revenue, Garo Hills
District Council and vide order dated 08.08.1979 in GDC-REV.No. 5 A/C
of 1979-80, Shri. (L) Jogen Sangma and his wife Smti. Jingme Marak
Michik were appointed as Nokma of Jamadar Akhing existed in the
Gondenggiri Akhing land. A certificate to this effect was issued by the
Secretary, Executive Committee Garo Hills District Council on
03.02.2004 certifying that Shri. Jogen Sangma is appointed Akhing
Nokma of Gondenggiri Akhing III-33 (9) w.e.f. 08.08.1979.
31.
Against the order dated 08.08.1979, Gonjak Marak Nokma and
another approached the Gauhati High Court (Shillong Bench) with a writ
application registered as Civil Rule No. 38(SH) of 1989 and the Hon’ble
High Court in the Division Bench vide judgment and order dated
28.08.1989 has held that the impugned order cannot be sustained, that is
the order dated 08.08.1979 and has remanded the case to the Executive
Member, In charge Revenue to decide the matter afresh. It is also the
2024:MLHC:727
direction of the Court that the matter already decided in the Civil Suit and
ultimately in Civil Revision No. 5(H)/76 cannot be agitated afresh. What
could be understood of the body of the order dated 28.08.1989 is that the
issue of the 77 plots of land as “Amathe” of the predecessors of the
petitioners herein has been settled. What remains is the issue of
declaration of the said predecessors of the petitioners as Jamadar Nokma.
32.
It is this issue of recognition of Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak and her
husband Shri. Jimberth T. Sangma, the petitioners No. 2 and 3 herein
respectively as the Nokma of Jamadar Amathe III-33 (within Gondenggiri
Akhing) which was taken up by the Executive Member In-Charge Land
& Revenue GHADC in GHADC-REF/19 A.C of 2015 and upon hearing
the parties and on consideration of the issues framed therein, the
impugned order dated 05.02.2019 was passed rejecting the claim of the
petitioners as Nokma of Jamadar Akhing since the same was not borne
from the records of the office of the District Council as was indicated in
the order dated 14.10.2009 passed in response to a petition dated
07.09.2009 filed by Smti. Gengak Marak, Nokma of Gondenggiri Akhing
land. However, the Executive Member has come to a finding that the
petitioners, that is Smti. Repolish Ch. Marak and her husband Shri.
Jimberth T. Sangma are appointed as Jamadar Nokma for 59 bitots of
land within Gondenggiri Akhing. It is further directed that the 59 bitots be
demarcated and a map to be prepared.
33.
The petitioners being aggrieved by the said order dated
05.02.2019 had approached the Chief Executive Member in GDC Rev
Appeal No. 2 A/C of 2019, who after hearing the parties and on
2024:MLHC:727
consideration of their respective written submissions as is seen in the
order dated 27.02.2020 had passed the said impugned order dated
16.10.2020.
34.
At this juncture, it may not be out of place to note that the
contention of the petitioners that they have not been heard before the
Chief Executive Member is factually incorrect. The argument advanced in
this regard is rejected.
35.
On the issue of non-joinder of proper and necessary parties, it is
the contention of the respondent/GHADC that the respondent No. 3
herein was not a party to the proceedings before the Executive Member or
the Chief Executive Member since he is not the Nokma of the
Gondenggiri Akhing whereas Shri. Ronjith T. Sangma and his wife Smti.
Benje Ch. Marak are the recognised Nokma of the Gondenggiri Akhing,
having not been impleaded as respondents in these proceedings, this writ
petition is not maintainable on such ground. This Court on perusal of the
impugned order has however noted that the name of Mechail Ch. Marak
has been recorded as the respondent along with others. Nothing from the
records brought before this Court is indicated that the said Nokma of the
Gondenggiri Akhing was arrayed as party respondents before the
Executive Member as well as the Chief Executive Member. The fact that
the said Mechail Ch. Marak has not raised any objection on the issue of
non-joinder of proper and necessary parties in the proceedings before the
Executive Member as well as the Chief Executive Member to raise this
issue at this point of time may not be proper.
36.
It is well settled that proceedings before the Executive Member or
2024:MLHC:727
the Chief Executive Member of the District Council which are quasijudicial in nature, the High Court would insist that such proceedings have
to be conducted keeping in mind the principles laid down in the case of
Smti Dore Sangma (supra). At para 20 of the same is found the following:
“20. For all these reasons, we would hold that the Revenue
Member alone has jurisdiction to decide the types of disputes at
hand. But then while doing so, the Revenue Member has to follow
the fundamental principles of judicial procedure; these being: (1)
framing of issues which has been regarded as necessary for courts
to get the grip of the case. (See Vindeo vs. Ziakruool, (1983) 1
GLR (NOC) 34). (2) Opportunity to lead evidence on the issues
framed–the evidence given could be recorded in full or summary
of the same could be noted; and (3) hearing of the parties
themselves or through their lawyers if engaged. This apart, some
other accepted principles of sound judicial procedure like not
allowing a document to be used in a case without the other side
having been given opportunity to rebut the same should also be
followed when the case is taken up by the Revenue Member in the
first instance or by the Chief Executive Member on appeal.”
37.
It is also fundamental that the power of judicial review of a
constitutional court exercising writ jurisdiction is mainly not to dwell on
the merits of the decision taken but to evaluate the decision-making
process so as to ensure that there is fairness in the proceedings, more
particularly that the principle of natural justice is adhered to. The High
Court exercising writ jurisdiction, more often than not cannot substitute
its own findings on the merits of the case under consideration which it
can do so in its appellate or revisional jurisdiction.
38.
On careful examination of the procedure adopted by the Executive
Member and the Chief Executive Member, it is seen that due procedure
has been followed as has been mandated in the case of Dore Sangma
2024:MLHC:727
(supra) and as such, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the
findings rendered by the said Executive Member and Chief Executive
Member respectively.
39.
However, in keeping with judicial propriety, this Court would
reiterate the decision of a Division Bench of this Court (as it then was) in
the judgment and order dated 28.08.1989 passed in Civil Rule No.
38(SH) of 1989 wherein it was held “…We however, make it clear that
the Executive Member shall not entertain any submission in regards to
the matter already decided in the Civil Suit and ultimately in Civil
Revision No. 5(H)/76.…” which in essence has maintained the decision of
the Waribokgre Village Court as regard the 77 plots as ‘Amathe’ of the
predecessors of the petitioners herein.
40.
There being no procedural defects in the proceedings leading to
the passing of the impugned orders, this petition is accordingly found to
be devoid of merits and the same is liable to be dismissed and is hereby
done so.
41.
Records of the Department produced before this Court to be
handed over to the Standing Counsel, GHADC.
42.
In view of the dismissal of this instant petition, any status quo
order or such similar orders involving the parties herein in the facts and
circumstances of this case stands vacated.
43.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2024.08.13 18:21:43
PDT
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review