Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/28
GAHC040012562025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/341/2025
Kayin Ering and 4 Ors
Unit 5th IRBn (APP) BHQ Pasighat, present address C/o SP cum CSLO HCM
Security Office Establishment, Itanagar.
2: Tadar Nachung
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Tako Hinda Tadar
Village Yuba
PO and PS Nyapin
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh and present address O/o Commandant 4th IRBN BHQ Jully
3: Bedum Borang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Oki Borang
Kiyit Village
PO and PS Mebo
East Siang District
present address O/o HCM Security Cell Itanagar
Unit 5th IRBN BHQ Pasighat
4: Bojer Yordung
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Tanya Yordung
Tato Village
PO and PS Tato
Shi Yomi District
place of posting 3rd IRBN
BHQ Seijosa.
5: Oyon Tayeng
Page No.# 2/28
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Sore Tayeng
Mebo Village
PO and PS Mebo
East Siang District
place of posting 1st IRBN BHQ Namsangmu
VERSUS
The State of AP and 15 Ors
through the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Civil Secretariat, Itanagar.
2:The Principal Secretary (Home)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Home
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar.
3:The Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Home Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar.
4:The Director General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Police Headquarters
Itanagar 791113
5:Deepak Langkam
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Maggul Langkam
presently posted at PHQ
Itanagar
PO and PS
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
6:Phassang Simi
Page No.# 3/28
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Phassang Tanang presently posted as Officer in Charge Doimukh Police
Station Papum Pare District Arunachal Pradesh
7:Mipak Riba
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Momi Riba
presently posted at Anti Corruption Branch Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
8:Tashi Yangi
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Tanong Yangki
presently posted at PHQ Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
9:Minli Geyi
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Kimin Geyi
presently posted at Seppa Police Station
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10:Rajen Yekar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tabik Yekar
presently posted at PHQ Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
11:Inya Ete
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Roi Ete
presently posted at ACB
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Page No.# 4/28
Arunachal Pradesh.
12:Khiksi Yangfo
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Taro Yangfo
presently posted at PS Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
13:Jumli Kamduk
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Tojum Kamduk
presently posted at PHQ Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
14:Tapun Messar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tanyok Messar
presently posted at PHQ Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
15:Torun Mai
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Late Mai Tara
presently posted at PS Nirjuli
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
16:Techi Nega
Age: 0
Occupation :
Son of Techi Rukh
presently posted at ACB
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Prades
Page No.# 5/28
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tony Pertin, T Mize,H K Jamoh
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Dicky Panging, Sr. Adv,Doge Lona,Marge Doji,Daina
Tamuk
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 25.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 21.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Kardak Ete, J)
Heard Mr. T. Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. N. Ratan,
learned Additional Advocate General for State respondent Nos. 1 to 4, and Mr.
D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. D. Tamuk, learned counsel
for respondent Nos. 5 to 16.
2.
By filing this writ petition, the petitioners have put to challenge the
Page No.# 6/28
constitutionality/vires of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment)
Rules, 2025, particularly, Rule 5(1)(b),whereby it provides that the promotion to
the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) shall be filled up from
amongst the eligible Inspector of Police (APP Civil), (IRBn) and (AAPBn) in the
ratio of 79.39% (Civil Police), 15.35% (IRBn) and 5.26% (AAPBn), based on the
existing sanctioned strength of the posts of Inspector in the respective
cadres/units.
3.
The case of the petitioners, in brief, is that they are working as Inspectors
of Police in the IRBn, whose promotions were effected on 25.07.2012 and
31.01.2017, and are eligible to be considered for promotion to the post of
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade). The posts in the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) are filled up in the ratio of 50:50 by direct
recruitment and by promotion from the cadre of Inspectors and are governed by
the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service Rules, 1989, which has been amended
from time to time, the latest being the impugned Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025 (hereinafter referred to as the "Amendment
Rules, 2025"), notified on 07.04.2025. The total sanctioned strength of the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) is 105 posts under the Civil
Police, IRBn and AAPBn. According to the petitioners, out of the total sanctioned
strength of 105 posts in the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade), 60
posts are sanctioned for the Civil Police, accounting for 56.66%, 33 posts for the
IRBn, accounting for 31.43%, and 12 posts for the AAPBn, accounting for
11.43%. Out of the sanctioned strength of 33 posts earmarked for the IRBn,
50%, i.e. 17 posts, are required to be filled up by promotion from amongst the
eligible Inspectors of IRBn, while the remaining 50%, i.e. 16 posts, are to be
Page No.# 7/28
filled up through direct recruitment.
4.
It is the contention of the petitioners that by virtue of the Amendment
Rules, 2025, a percentage-based distribution of the 50% promotional quota
amongst the three feeder cadres, namely, Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn, has
been introduced. However, such distribution is not based on the sanctioned
promotional posts allocated to each wing under the Rules, rather on the existing
numerical strength of Inspectors in the respective cadres. The sanctioned
strength of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) earmarked for
the IRBn is 33 posts, which constitutes 32% of the total cadre strength, out of
which 17 posts are required to be filled up by promotion in terms of the
prescribed 50:50 ratio between direct recruitment and promotion. However, by
virtue of the impugned amendment, only 15.35% of the promotional quota has
been allocated to the IRBn, thereby reducing the promotional posts available to
the IRBn from 17 to 9. According to the petitioners, such computation has been
made solely on the basis of the existing numerical strength of Inspectors in the
IRBn by completely disregarding the cadre-wise promotional quota already
envisaged under the Rules. As a result, this methodology has resulted in an
arbitrary reduction of the promotional share of the IRBn, thereby causing
serious prejudice to the eligible Inspectors of the IRBn. Such computation of the
promotional quota on the basis of the existing strength of the feeder cadre,
instead of the sanctioned cadre-wise promotional posts, defeats the very
scheme of cadre-based promotional reservation and undermines the structural
design of cadre-wise promotional opportunities envisaged under the Rules.
5.
Mr. T. Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that Rule 5(1)(b)
of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025, regulating
Page No.# 8/28
the distribution of the promotional quota amongst the Civil Police, AAPBn and
IRBn, is ex facie arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India. The impugned Rule unjustifiably dilutes the
promotional avenues available to the Inspectors of the IRBn by introducing an
artificial and unreasonable classification, which has no rational nexus with the
object sought to be achieved, namely, ensuring a fair and equitable promotional
avenue for each of the feeder cadres. He submits that the fixation of the
promotional quota cannot be altered to the detriment of a particular cadre
merely on the basis of the fluctuating numerical strength of the feeder cadre
officers, especially when the number of sanctioned promotional posts remains
unchanged.
6.
He submits that the promotional quota ought to be determined with
reference to the number of sanctioned promotional posts and not on the basis
of the existing strength of the feeder cadres, which is neither static nor a
rational criterion for determining promotional entitlement. The percentagebased allocation introduced by the impugned Rule results in an unequal and
artificial restriction on the promotional opportunities of the IRBn officers vis-àvis the other feeder cadres and is contrary to Schedule-I of the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025. He submits that a promotion
policy must rest on objective and rational criteria and should not defeat the
legitimate expectations of similarly situated officers by disproportionately
curtailing their promotional prospects despite the availability of sanctioned
promotional posts.
7.
Mr. Pertin, learned counsel, submits that the records produced by the
respondents themselves reveal that the amendment process was initially
undertaken only to rectify a drafting omission in the earlier Rules relating to
Page No.# 9/28
promotion from the respective feeder cadres and there was no proposal
whatsoever regarding cadre imbalance, distribution of promotional quota, intercadre percentage allocation or determination of promotional entitlement on the
basis of the strength of the feeder cadres. He submits that, under the guise of
rectifying a drafting omission, Rule 5(1)(b) introduces an altogether new
methodology for distribution of promotional opportunities based on the
numerical strength of the Inspectors in the feeder cadres, which has no nexus
with the defect sought to be rectified. He further submits that the proposal for
such percentage-based allocation did not originate from the Home Department
but was introduced for the first time by the Department of Administrative
Reforms without any cadre review, empirical study, manpower assessment or
recommendation of the parent department. He submits that even the Principal
Secretary (Home), while considering the representation submitted by the
petitioners, had recorded that the proposal appeared to be "undoable" when
posts had been created for specific units and the respondents have failed to
explain as to how a proposal initially considered unworkable subsequently
formed the basis of the impugned amendment.
8.
He submits that the amendment process is also vitiated on account of
non-compliance with the Office Memorandum dated 21.06.2024 issued by the
Department of Administrative Reforms & Training, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, which prescribes the procedure for framing or amendment of Service
Rules. The said Office Memorandum mandates consultation with the Arunachal
Pradesh Public Service Commission (APPSC) before finalisation of any
amendment to the Service Rules. While the draft amendment culminating in the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2023, had been
forwarded to the APPSC for its views/comments, no such consultation was
Page No.# 10/28
undertaken before notifying the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment)
Rules, 2025. The records produced by the respondents also do not disclose any
such consultation. Apart from the absence of consultation with the APPSC, the
procedure contemplated under the Office Memorandum was not adhered to
inasmuch as the proposal did not originate from the concerned administrative
department but was based solely on the views of the Department of
Administrative
Reforms,
thereby
rendering
the
impugned
amendment
procedurally defective.
9.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Pertin, learned counsel for the
petitioners, has placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in A. Satyanarayana & Ors. Vs. S. Purushotham& Ors., reported in
(2008) 5 SCC 416.
10. On the other hand,Mr. N. Ratan, learned Additional Advocate General for
the State respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3, submits that the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025 were notified after due deliberations involving
all the stakeholders and on the basis of the recommendation made by the
Department of Administrative Reforms. He submits that the amended Rules
prescribe promotion to the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) on
the basis of merit-cum-seniority and not on the basis of any common or
combined seniority. Rule 5(1)(b) introduces a unified cadre structure by
providing for distribution of the promotional quota in the ratio of 79.39% for
Civil Police, 15.35% for IRBn and 5.26% for AAPBn, thereby ensuring fair,
balanced and proportionate promotional opportunities amongst the three units
while preserving the identity of each cadre. He submits that the Amendment
Rules, 2025 provide a legally sound, administratively workable and cadre
integrity-preserving framework for regulating promotions to the Arunachal
Page No.# 11/28
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade).
11.
He submits that although the sanctioned strength of the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) is 105 posts, as reflected in Schedule-I to
the Amendment Rules, 2025, the petitioners are under a misconception in
contending that 17 promotional posts are earmarked exclusively for the IRBn.
The posts of Assistant Commandant/APPS (Entry Grade) are filled up by
promotion from amongst the eligible Inspectors of Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn
in accordance with the applicable Rules and the promoted officers are
transferable amongst all the three units. Therefore, there is no unit-wise
earmarked promotional vacancy under the existing Rules.
12.
He submits that Rule 5(1)(b) was introduced to remove the legal and
structural deficiencies noticed in the earlier Rules by restoring the omitted
provisions, removing the restriction relating to the respective feeder cadres and
providing for a sanctioned-strength-based distribution of the promotional quota.
The rationale behind the distribution of the promotional quota, as reflected in
the recommendations of the Department of Administrative Reforms, is to ensure
equitable promotional opportunities amongst the three feeder cadres, having
regard to the considerable variations in their respective promotional prospects
from the rank of Sub-Inspector to Inspector. The amended Rules also provide
for periodic review of the promotional quota after every three years with effect
from 01.01.2028.
13. Learned Addl. Advocate General submits that mere existence of sanctioned
posts does not confer any vested or enforceable right to promotion, as
promotions are governed strictly by the statutory Recruitment Rules. Rule 5(1)
(b) is founded on intelligible and objective criteria, duly recommended by the
Department of Administrative Reforms and approved by the competent authority
Page No.# 12/28
and has a rational nexus with the object of balanced cadre management and
administrative efficiency.
14. In support of his submissions, Mr. N. Ratan, learned Additional Advocate
General, has placed reliance on the following judgments:
(i)
A.P. Cooperative Oil Seeds Growers Federation Limited,
Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh Vs. D. Achyuta RAo& Ors.,
reported in (2007) 13 SCC 320.
(ii)
Union of India Vs. Pushpa Rani & Ors., reported in (2008) 9
SCC 242.
15. Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent Nos.
5 to 16, while endorsing the submissions advanced by the learned Additional
Advocate General, submits that the amendment to the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service Rules, 1989 was necessitated to remove the anomalies that had arisen
under the earlier Rules relating to promotion to the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade). Although the Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn constitute
separate cadres up to the rank of Inspector, the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade) has always been conceived as a common cadre, whose
members are transferable amongst all the three wings of the Police Department.
Therefore, there is no cadre-wise earmarking of promotional posts in the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade), as sought to be contended by
the petitioners.
16.
He submits that prior to the amendment, promotions to the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) on the basis of seniority amongst the
Inspectors of the three wings resulted in serious imbalance inasmuch as the
Inspectors of the IRBn and AAPBn, having comparatively better promotional
Page No.# 13/28
prospects from the rank of Sub-Inspector to Inspector, were promoted to the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) much earlier than their
counterparts in the Civil Police, despite the latter having entered service much
earlier. Such a situation resulted in juniors in service holding higher posts than
their seniors in the Civil Police, thereby causing stagnation and dissatisfaction
amongst the Civil Police officers. He submits that Rule 5(1)(b) has been
introduced to remedy the said anomaly by providing a proportionate distribution
of the promotional quota based on the sanctioned strength of Inspectors in the
three wings, thereby ensuring a level playing field for all the feeder cadres.
17. Learned Senior Counsel submits that the disparity in promotional prospects
is evident from the cadre strength and promotional avenues available in the
three wings. The sanctioned cadre strength of Sub-Inspectors in the Civil Police
is 400 posts, out of which 200 posts are earmarked for promotion to the rank of
Inspector, whereas the corresponding cadre strength in the IRBn is 115 posts
with 58 promotional posts, and in the AAPBn, 36 posts with 18 promotional
posts. On the other hand, the sanctioned strength of the cadre of Inspectors
comprises 181 posts in the Civil Police, 35 posts in the IRBn and 12 posts in the
AAPBn. Owing to the substantially larger strength of Sub-Inspectors in the Civil
Police, promotions to the rank of Inspector are comparatively slower, resulting in
stagnation amongst Civil Police officers, whereas officers in the Armed Police
wings secure promotion to the rank of Inspector much earlier.
18.
By way of illustration, he contends that respondent No. 5, Shri Deepak
Langkam, though appointed as Sub-Inspector on 17.02.1989, was promoted to
the rank of Inspector only on 14.08.2013, whereas petitioner Nos. 1 and 2, who
were appointed as Sub-Inspectors on 12.01.2006, were promoted as Inspectors
on 25.07.2012. Likewise, petitioner No. 3, appointed on 17.03.2006, and
Page No.# 14/28
petitioner Nos. 4 and 5, appointed on 27.09.2010, were promoted to the rank of
Inspector on 30.01.2017. He submits that, as a consequence, officers belonging
to the Armed Police wings, despite entering service much later as SubInspectors, become eligible for promotion to the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade) much earlier than their counterparts in the Civil Police.
Since the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) constitutes a common
transferable cadre, such a situation results in juniors occupying higher posts
than their seniors in the Civil Police. He, therefore, submits that the impugned
amendment seeks to rectify the said anomaly and bring about a fair and
balanced promotional framework amongst the three feeder cadres.
19. Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel for the private respondent Nos. 5
to 16, in support of his submissions, has placed reliance on the following
judgments:
(i)
P.U. Joshi & Ors. Vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad &
Ors., reported in (2003) 2 SCC 632.
(ii)
Gulf Goans Hotels Company Limited &Anr. Vs. Union of
India & Ors., reported in (2014) 10 SCC 673.
20. Due consideration has been extended to the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials available on
record.
21. The petitioners, who are the Inspectors of Police in the IRBn,are aggrieved
by the amended rule 5(1)(b) of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service
(Amendment) Rules, 2025. Primarily, the grievance of the petitioners is that
while the sanctioned strength of the posts in the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Page No.# 15/28
Service (Entry Grade) remains unchanged, the impugned Rule allocates the
promotional quota amongst the three feeder cadres, namely, Civil Police, IRBn
and AAPBn, on the basis of the existing sanctioned strength of Inspectors in the
respective cadres instead of the sanctioned promotional posts available to each
cadre. According to the petitioners, such methodology has resulted in
substantial reduction of the promotional opportunities available to the
Inspectors of IRBn and is arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. The respondents, conversely, have justified the amendment by
contending that the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) constitutes
a common cadre and that Rule 5(1)(b) has been introduced to remove the
anomaly prevailing under the earlier Rules and to ensure equitable promotional
opportunities amongst the three feeder cadres.
22. It is settled position of law that the State by appropriate rules is entitled to
amalgamate departments or bifurcate departments into more and constitute
different categories of posts or cadres by undertaking further classification,
bifurcation or amalgamation as well as reconstitute and restructure the pattern
and cadres/categories of service, as may be required from time to time by
abolishing existing cadres/posts and creating new cadres/posts. No Government
employee has a vested right to claim that rules governing conditions of service
or promotional avenues existing at the time of his entry into service should be
forever the same and the employee has no right to challenge the authority of
the State to frame, amend, alter and bring it to force any rule relating to and
amend even existing service rule. An enactment or rules and its amendment
unless shown to be arbitrary, unreasonable or irrational cannot be struck down
and there is always a presumption in favour of constitutionality of the
Page No.# 16/28
enactment/Rule and the burden of proof is upon the person who attacks it.
23.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid rival contentions of parties and position
of law, the issue that engaged our attention is whether Rule 5(1)(b) of the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025 suffers from any
arbitrariness or unconstitutionality requiring interference by this Court.
24.
In order to appreciate, it would be apposite to refer and consider the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service Rules, 1989, and its amended rules including
the impugned Amended Rules 2025. The Arunachal Pradesh Police Service
Rules, 1989 has been amended from time to time.
25.
Rule 5 of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service Rules, 1989, originally
reads as under:
“5. Method of recruitment:- (1) Same as provided in rule 14, appointment to
the service shall be made by the following methods, namely:-
(a)
50% of the substantive vacancies which occur from time to time in
the authorized permanent strength of the service shall be filled by direct
recruitment in the manner specified in the Part-IV of these rules; and
(b)
The remaining such substantive vacancies shall be filled by merit-cumseniority basis with due regard to seniority in the manner specified in
Part-V of these rules from amongst officers who are substantively borne
on the cadre of Inspector of Police employed in the State of Arunachal
Pradesh;
(c)
Post of SPs/Commandant/Deputy Commandant (Non-IPS) will be filled
up by selection from the cadre of Deputy Superintendent of Police (State
Government) in the manner specified in Part-IX of these rules.
(2) Officers who may be considered for appointment to the service at its initial
condition though not actually appointed there to under Rule 15 and who at the
commencement of these rules, held substantively and continue to held:-
Page No.# 17/28
(a) Any of the posts specified in the Schedule at the commencement of these
rules, or
(b) any of the posts under the Government of Arunachal Pradesh carrying the
same designation as any of the post specified in Schedule:
Provided that nothing in this rule shall preclude the Governor from holding a
vacancy in abeyance of filling it on an officiating basis in accordance with the
provisions in Part-VIII of these rules.”
26.
By the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (2nd Amendment) Rules, 2023,
rule 5(1), was amended which reads as under:
“4. Amendment of Rule 5(1) in Clause(c) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 5, for the existing
entries, the following shall be substituted.
(i)
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Special Grade)/ post of Commandant
(AAPBn)/Commandant (IRBN) etc. shall be filled by promotion from the feeder
cadre/post grade as a specified under clause (a) and (b) (ii) of sub-rule (1) of
Rule 12 and Rule 26.
(ii)
Arunachal Pradesh Police service (Junior Administrative Grade)/post of
Superintendent of Police District Security/Vice-Principal (PTC)/Deputy
Commandant (AAPBn)/Deputy Commandant (IRBN) etc. shall be filled by
promotion from amongst the eligible officers .... to the respective feeder
grade/cadre/post as specified under clause (a) and (b)(ii) & (iii) of sub-rule (1)
of Rule 12 and Rule 26.
(iii)
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Grade-I0 post of Additional Superintendent
of Police/Addl. District Commissioner to the Governor shall be filled by
promotion from the feeder grade/cadre/post of Sub-Divisional police
Officer/Deputy Superintendent of Police as specified under clause (a) and (b)
(ii) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 12 and Rule 26.
(iv)
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade)/post of Sub-Divisional Police
Officer/Deputy Superintendent of Police/Assistant Commandant (AAPBn)
Assistant Commandant (IRBn) shall be filled by promotion from amongst the
eligible officers belonging to the respective feeder grade/cadre/post of
Inspector of Police (Civil)/(AAPBn)/(IRBN) as specified under Clause (b) of subrule (1) of Rule 5, clause (a) and (b)(i) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 12 and Rule 26.”
27. Subsequently, the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service Rules have been again
amended by the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025.
Page No.# 18/28
Impugned rule 5(1)(b), as introduced by the said Amendment Rules, is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“6. Amendment of Rule 5
6.1. Amendment of Rule 5(1)(b):In clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the APPS Amendment Rules, 2023, for
the existing entries, the following entries shall be substituted, namely:The remaining substantive vacancies shall be filled by promotion on the basis of meritcum-seniority from amongst the officers who are substantively borne on the cadre of
Inspectors of Police (APP Civil), Inspectors of Police (AAPBn) and Inspectors of Police
(IRBn) employed in the State of Arunachal Pradesh in the manner specified in Part V
of the Rules. The posts of Dy. SP/SDPO/Asstt. Commandant IRBn/ AAPBn falling under
promotional quota of APPS (EG) shall be filled from amongst the eligible Inspector of
Police (APP Civil), Inspector of Police (AAPBn) and Inspector of Police (IRBn) in
accordance with the following ratio based on present sanctioned strength of post of
Inspectors in each unit:i. 79.39% (Civil Police)
ii. 15.35% (IRBn)
iii. 05.26% (AAPBn)
The above ratio is based upon the present total strength of the three feeders as
228 posts of Inspectors comprising 181 posts in Civil Police, 35 posts in IRBn and 12
posts in AAPBn. However, the ratio shall be reviewed after every 3(three) years based
upon the sanctioned strength on 1st January of that year and first such review shall be
on 01.01.2028 and so on.
28.
Reading of the above rules shows that 50% of the post of Arunachal
Page No.# 19/28
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade)shall be filled up on basis of merit-cumseniority with due regard to seniority from amongst officers who are
substantively borne on the cadre of Inspector of Police. Thereafter, by
amendment, it was provided that the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry
Grade), post of Sub-Divisional Police Officer/Deputy Superintendent of
Police/Assistant Commandant (AAPBn) Assistant Commandant (IRBn) shall be
filled by promotion from amongst the eligible officers belonging to the
respective cadres of Inspector of Police. By the impugned rule 5, the APPS (EG)
are to be filled up by promotion on the basis of merit-cum-seniority from
amongst the officers who are substantively borne on the cadre of Inspectors of
Police (APP Civil), (AAPBn) and (IRBn)and the posts of Dy.SP/SDPO/Asstt.
Commandant IRBn/AAPBn falling under promotional quota of APPS (EG) shall be
filled from amongst the eligible Inspector of Police (APP Civil), Inspector of
Police (AAPBn) and Inspector of Police (IRBn) based on present sanctioned
strength of post of Inspectors in each unit in the ratio of 79.39% (Civil Police),
15.35% (IRBn) and 05.26% (AAPBn). The above ratio is based upon the
present total sanctioned strength of 228 posts of Inspectors, comprising 181
posts in Civil Police, 35 posts in IRBn and 12 posts in AAPBn. It shows that said
ratio shall be reviewed after every 3(three) years based upon the sanctioned
strength of the feeder cadres as on 1st January of that year.
29.
Upon careful consideration, it transpires that the impugned Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025 was mooted on the basis of
the views rendered by the Department of Administrative Reforms. The amended
rule prescribes promotion to the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade)
on the basis of merit-cum-seniority from the Inspector of Civil Police, IRBn and
AAPBn. Rule 5(1)(b) introduces a unified cadre structure by providing for
Page No.# 20/28
distribution of the promotional quota in the ratio of 79.39% for Civil Police,
15.35% for IRBn and 5.26% for AAPBn, based on the sanctioned strength of
the posts of Inspectors in the respective cadres. Thus, while the Civil Police,
IRBn and AAPBn continue to remain separate feeder cadres up to the rank of
Inspector, the amendment prescribes an objective criterion for distribution of
the promotional quota to the common cadre of the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade).
30. As per Schedule-I to the Amendment Rules, 2025, the sanctioned strength
of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) is 105 posts, inter alia,
showing 17 posts of Assistant Commandant for the IRBn. However, the posts of
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) are filled up by promotion from
amongst the eligible Inspectors of Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn and the
promoted officers are transferable amongst all the three units. It transpires that
impugned Rule 5(1)(b) was introduced to remove the anomaly noticed under
the earlier Rulesremoving the restriction relating to the respective feeder cadres
and providing for a sanctioned-strength-based distribution of the promotional
quota and to ensure equitable promotional opportunities amongst the three
feeder cadres. Thus, it cannot be construed that promotional vacancies are
earmarked for each unit in view of the fact that the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (EG) is a common cadre.
31.
The amendment to the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service Rules, 1989
appears to have been necessitated to remove the anomalies that had arisen
under the earlier Rules relating to promotion to the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade). While the Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn constitute
separate cadres up to the rank of Inspector, the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade) has always remained a common cadre, whose members
Page No.# 21/28
are transferable amongst all the three wings of the Police Department. In other
words, once an Inspector belonging to any of the three feeder cadres is
promoted to the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade), he ceases to
serve exclusively within his original feeder cadre and becomes a member of the
common Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade), whose members are
liable to be posted and transferred amongst the Civil Police, IRBn and AAPBn in
accordance with administrative requirements. Thus, it would not be correct to
construe that there is a cadre-wise earmarking of promotional posts in the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) and as such the contention of
the learned counsel for the petitioners falls flat as Rule 5(1)(b) is seen to have
been made providing a proportionate distribution of the promotional quota
based on the sanctioned strength of Inspectors in the Civil Police, IRBn and
AAPBn, the post of APPS (EG) being common cadre.
32.
Needless to observe that mere existence of sanctioned posts does not
confer any vested or enforceable right to promotion, as promotion is governed
by relevant Rules. Therefore, rule 5(1)(b) appears to be founded on intelligible
and objective criteria and has a rational nexus with the object of promotion and
balanced cadre management.
33.
This Court, in the case of Er. K. Wati & Ors. Vs. The State of
Nagaland & Ors., WP(C) No. 261/2021, while dealing with the
constitutional validity of the Service Rules, had an occasion to consider the
scope of judicial review in relation to subordinate legislation and amendment of
service rules as considered and settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Gainfully
we refer Paragraphs 72, 73 and 75 of the said judgment which are reproduced
hereinbelow:
Page No.# 22/28
“72. We are not oblivious of settled position of law that law/rules may be struck down
on two counts i.e., lack of legislative competence and violation of fundamental rights
or constitutional rights for which we would refer to the case of State of A.P. and Ors
Vs. Mcdowell& Co and Ors reported in (1996) 3 SCC 709. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Shayara Bano Vs. Union of India and Ors reported in (2017) 9 SCC 1 has
enlarged the scope (manifest arbitrariness) and observed which is reproduced herein
below:
“101. It will be noticed that a Constitution Bench of this Court in Indian
Express Newspapers v. Union of India, (1985) 1 SCC 641, stated that it was
settled law that subordinate legislation can be challenged on any of the grounds
available for challenge against plenary legislation. This being the case, there is
no rational distinction between the two types of legislation when it comes to
this ground of challenge under Article 14 . The test of manifest arbitrariness,
therefore, as laid down in the aforesaid judgments would apply to invalidate
legislation as well as subordinate legislation under Article 14 . Manifest
arbitrariness, therefore, must be something done by the legislature capriciously,
irrationally and/or without adequate determining principle. Also, when
something is done which is excessive and disproportionate, such legislation
would be manifestly arbitrary. We are, therefore, of the view that arbitrariness
in the sense of manifest arbitrariness as pointed out by us above would apply to
negate legislation as well under Article 14.”
73. We would also refer to the case of Nagaland Senior Government Employees
Welfare Association and Ors Vs. State of Nagaland and Ors reported in (2010) 7 SCC
643, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that enactment or rules and its
amendment unless shown to be arbitrary, unreasonable or irrational cannot be struck
down and there is always a presumption in favour of constitutionality of the
enactment/Rule and the burden of proof is upon the person who attacks it. In the
present case, the petitioners have not been able to demonstrate that the impugned
Schedules attached to the Service Rules, 1998 are violative of the fundamental rights
or constitutional rights and/or there is legislative incompetence or manifest
arbitrariness.
75. It is trite that the State by appropriate rules is entitled to amalgamate departments
or bifurcate departments into more and constitute different categories of posts or
cadres by undertaking further classification, bifurcation or amalgamation as well as
reconstitute and restructure the pattern and cadres/categories of service, as may be
required from time to time by abolishing existing cadres/posts and creating new
cadres/posts. There is no right in any employee of the State to claim that rules
governing conditions of his service should be forever the same and it should provide
Page No.# 23/28
promotional avenues and the employee has no right to challenge the authority of the
State to frame, amend, alter and bring it to force any rule relating to and amend even
existing service rule.”
34. Coming to the case of A. Satyanarayana (supra), the authority, relied on
by the learned counsel for the petitioners, which this Court has carefully
perused, we find that the issue before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in that case
was whether, after fixing the quota under the statutory Rules, it was open to the
Government to impose a ceiling restricting the number of persons who could be
promoted from certain posts. While holding that such a cap was ultra vires, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that, while exercising the power of judicial
review, the Superior Courts must examine the validity of subordinate legislation
having regard to its effect and whether there exists a rational nexus between
the impugned legislation and the object sought to be achieved. It has been
further held that promotions are intended to avoid stagnation and frustration
amongst employees; that though an employee has no fundamental right to
promotion, he has a right to be considered for promotion in accordance with the
applicable Rules; and that a statutory rule must be in consonance with the
constitutional scheme and cannot be arbitrary or unreasonable. A policy that
completely extinguishes the promotional avenues of a class of employees would
offend Article 16 of the Constitution.
35.
The aforesaid principles, however, do not advance the case of the
petitioners as in the present case, Rule 5(1)(b) neither takes away nor
extinguishes the promotional avenues of the Inspectors belonging to the IRBn.
The petitioners continue to remain eligible for consideration for promotion to the
Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) in accordance with the statutory
Rules. The impugned amendment merely restructures the distribution of the
Page No.# 24/28
promotional quota amongst the three feeder cadres on the basis of the
sanctioned strength of Inspectors in each cadre. Such restructuring cannot be
equated with denial of promotional opportunity altogether. On the contrary, the
materials placed before this Court disclose that the amendment was introduced
to remedy the imbalance that had arisen under the earlier Rules, whereby
officers belonging to the Armed Police wings, despite entering service much
later as Sub-Inspectors, were reaching the common cadre of the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade) ahead of their counterparts in the Civil
Police on account of comparatively faster promotion to the rank of Inspector.
The methodology adopted under Rule 5(1)(b), therefore, bears a rational nexus
with the object sought to be achieved and cannot be said to be arbitrary or
unreasonable.
36.
Equally apposite is the principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in A.P. Cooperative Oil Seeds Growers Federation Limited(supra),
wherein it has been held that even if a service rule causes hardship or
inconvenience to a section of employees, the same cannot be struck down so
long as the Rule is fair, just and reasonable and does not offend Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution. The constitutionality of a service rule cannot be tested on
the touchstone of the fortunes of an individual or a particular class of
employees. In the present case, the grievance of the petitioners essentially
proceeds on the footing that the promotional prospects of the Inspectors
belonging to the IRBn have been comparatively reduced. Even assuming that
the impugned amendment results in lesser promotional opportunities for one
feeder cadre than what existed earlier, such consequence, by itself, cannot
render the Rule unconstitutional, particularly when the Rule has been framed
with the object of balancing promotional opportunities amongst all the feeder
Page No.# 25/28
cadres constituting the source of recruitment to a common cadre.
37.
The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pushpa Rani (supra) also
lends support to the stand of the respondents. It has been categorically held
therein that matters relating to creation and abolition of posts, structuring or
restructuring of cadres, prescribing the source and mode of recruitment, laying
down eligibility criteria and determining promotional avenues fall within the
exclusive domain of the employer. Judicial review in such matters is confined
only to examining whether the action is contrary to any constitutional or
statutory provision, is patently arbitrary or is vitiated by mala fides. The Court
cannot substitute its own views for that of the rule-making authority as to how
the cadre should be structured or promotional avenues regulated. In the present
case, the petitioners have not been able to demonstrate either any
constitutional infirmity or manifest arbitrariness in Rule 5(1)(b). Their challenge
is essentially directed against the wisdom of the policy adopted by the State in
regulating promotions to the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Entry Grade),
which is clearly beyond the permissible limits of judicial review.
38.
Similar is the principle enunciated in P.U. Joshi (supra), wherein the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that questions relating to the constitution of
cadres, restructuring of services, prescription of eligibility criteria and avenues of
promotion are matters of policy within the exclusive competence of the State
and no Government servant has a vested right to insist that the Rules governing
his service should forever remain unchanged. The State is competent to amend
the service rules and alter the conditions of service, including promotional
avenues, in accordance with administrative exigencies, subject only to
constitutional limitations.
39. Applying the aforesaid principle, we are unable to accept the contention of
Page No.# 26/28
the petitioners that the promotional quota ought necessarily to have continued
in the same manner as under the earlier Rules. The amendment merely alters
the criteria governing distribution of promotional vacancies and does not take
away any accrued or vested right of the petitioners.
40.
The petitioners have also laid considerable emphasis on the internal/file
notings contained in the Government files as well as the Office Memorandum
dated 21.06.2024 to contend that the proposal for the impugned amendment
did not originate from the Home Department and consultation with the
Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission had not been undertaken, which
this Court finds unacceptable. The records reveal that various departments,
including the Department of Administrative Reforms, examined the proposal and
tendered their respective views and the competent authority ultimately
approved and notified the Amendment Rules, 2025. Merely because certain
officers expressed reservations or differing opinions during the decision-making
process cannot invalidate the statutory Rules finally notified by the competent
authority. It is well settled that departmental/file notings merely reflect the
opinion of the concerned officers at different stages of processing and do not
constitute the decision of the Government. In this regard, the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gulf Goans Hotels Company Limited(supra)
assumes significance. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has categorically held that
notings in Government files are merely expressions of opinion by the concerned
officers and cannot, by themselves, be treated as decision of the Government. It
is only the final order expressed and authenticated in accordance with law that
constitutes the decision of the Government. Consequently, neither the
observations made by any departmental authority during the process of
consideration nor the alleged opinion recorded by the Principal Secretary
Page No.# 27/28
(Home) can furnish a valid ground for invalidating the statutory Rules ultimately
framed and notified by the competent authority.
41. In a similar way, the Office Memorandum dated 21.06.2024 relied upon by
the petitioners merely prescribes an administrative procedure to be followed
while processing proposals for framing or amendment of service rules. The said
Office Memorandum does not have the force of a statutory rule nor have the
petitioners been able to point out any statutory provision making compliance
thereof mandatory so as to render the Rules void in the event of any deviation.
Executive instructions cannot override statutory rules nor can they curtail the
rule-making power of the competent authority. Even assuming that there has
been any procedural deviation in the
internal processing of the proposal, the same would not, by itself, invalidate the
statutory Rules once duly approved and notified by the competent authority.
The petitioners have also failed to demonstrate that any prejudice has been
caused to them on account of the alleged procedural deviation.
42. In the light of the foregoing discussions, we are of the considered opinion
that the petitioners have failed to establish that Rule 5(1)(b) of the Arunachal
Pradesh Police Service (Amendment) Rules, 2025 is manifestly arbitrary,
unreasonable or violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. We find that
the impugned Rule has been framed/amended with the object of rationalizing
promotional opportunities amongst the three feeder cadres constituting the
source of recruitment to the common cadre of the Arunachal Pradesh Police
Service (Entry Grade). The classification adopted under the Rule is founded on
an intelligible differentia, namely, the sanctioned strength of Inspectors in the
respective feeder cadres, which bears a rational nexus with the object sought to
be achieved, namely, balanced cadre management and equitable distribution of
Page No.# 28/28
promotional opportunities. Merely because the petitioners perceive that the
earlier system was more beneficial to them would not be a ground for this Court
to hold a decision embodied in a statutory rule ultra vires.
43.
Consequently, we do not find any legal or constitutional infirmity in the
impugned Rule 5(1)(b) of the Arunachal Pradesh Police Service (Amendment)
Rules, 2025 and therefore, no interference is called for.
44.
In the result, writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed. No order as to
cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review