Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
APPEAL SUIT No.157 OF 2022
AND
I.A.No.1 OF 2026
IN/AND
APPEAL SUIT No.281 OF 2022
DATE:
09.10.2026
Reserved on: 23.07.2026
Pronounced on :
Uploaded on
:
09.10.2026
09.10.2026
Between:
APPEAL SUIT No.157 of 2022
(CNR No.HBHC010218152022)
Kattar Jithender Rao and another
….Appellants
And
Kattar Upender Rao and others
….Respondents
APPEAL SUIT No.281 of 2022
(CNR No.HBHC010557212022)
Kattar Upender Rao
….Appellant
And
Kattar Jithender Rao
….Respondent
COMMON JUDGMENT
Since these two appeals arise out of the common
judgment and decree dated 28.10.2021 passed by the learned VI
Additional District Judge, Mahabubabad, Warangal (for short
‘trial Court’) in O.S.No.123 of 2012 and O.S.Nos.84, 85, 86 of
2013, they are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2.
Heard Sri K.V.Bhanu Prasad, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for Sri Kothapalli Sai Sri Harsha, learned counsel for
the appellants in A.S.No.157 of 2022 and for the respondent in
A.S.No.281 of 2022; Sri A.Prabhakar Rao, learned counsel for
the respondents in A.S.No.157 of 2022 and for the appellant in
A.S.No.281 of 2022 and perused the record.
3.
In A.S.No.157 of 2022, the appellants are the plaintiffs
and the respondents are defendants in O.S.No.123 of 2012. In
A.S.No.281 of 2022, the appellant is defendant No.1 and the
respondent is plaintiff No.1 in the said Suit O.S.No.123 of 2012.
4.
For the sake of convenience and clarity, the parties are
hereinafter referred to in the capacity as they were arrayed
before the trial Court.
Factual Matrix
5.
Plaintiff No.1, Sri Kattar Jithender Rao, and defendant
No.1, Sri Kattar Upender Rao, are natural brothers. Plaintiff
No.2, Smt. Kattar Sarala Devi, is the wife of plaintiff No.1. The
dispute between the parties relates to agricultural lands
situated at Ramavaram Village, Kodakandla Revenue Mandal,
Mahabubabad District, formerly within Warangal District.
6.
Plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 instituted O.S.No.123 of 2012
seeking a declaration that plaintiff No.1 is the owner and
possessor of the plaint A-Schedule property and that plaintiff
No.2 is the owner and possessor of the plaint B-Schedule
property, together with a consequential relief of perpetual
injunction.
7.
The case of the plaintiffs, in substance, was that an oral
family partition had taken place in the year 1968–69, pursuant
to which plaintiff No.1 was allotted an extent of Ac.30.26½ Gts.
According to the plaintiffs, out of the said extent, an extent of
Ac.1.00 was sold to one Sarada, while an extent of Ac.9.26 Gts
was subsequently gifted by plaintiff No.1 to plaintiff No.2 under
a registered Gift Deed dated 19.07.2012.
8.
The plaintiffs further alleged that defendant No.1 had
taken advantage of certain blank papers signed by plaintiff No.1
during his stay in the United States and had created fictitious
documents in respect of the suit properties. It was also alleged
that defendant No.1 had instituted O.S.No.70 of 2009 for
specific
performance
and
O.S.No.1
of
seeking
an
injunction in respect of the disputed properties. The plaintiffs
alleged interference by defendant No.1 with their possession and
enjoyment of the suit properties and consequently sought the
relief of perpetual injunction.
9.
Defendant No.1 contested the suit and denied the
plaintiffs' claim. His specific case was that he had purchased
the suit B-Schedule property under an unregistered Sale Deed
dated 25.05.1996 for a total consideration of Rs.3,10,000/-.
According to defendant No.1, a sum of Rs.2,20,000/- had been
paid towards the sale consideration and the balance amount of
Rs.90,000/- was payable at the time of registration of the sale
deed.
10.
It was further pleaded that the transaction was scribed by
the parties' brother, K. Narender Rao, and attested by their
sister, Smt. N. Vimala Devi. Defendant No.1 claimed that
possession of the property had been delivered to him pursuant
to the said transaction and that he had been in continuous
possession and enjoyment thereof. Defendant No.1 also relied
upon revenue entries for the period from 2000–01 to 2007–08 in
support of his possession.
11.
Defendant No.1 further contended that the Gift Deed
dated 19.07.2012 relied upon by plaintiff No.2 was hit by the
Doctrine of lis pendens under Section 52 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, as it had allegedly been executed during the
pendency of O.S.No.40 of 2009. He asserted his readiness and
willingness to pay the balance consideration of Rs.90,000/- and
to complete the transaction by obtaining a registered sale deed.
12.
Plaintiff No.1 also instituted a suit vide O.S.No.84 of 2013
seeking the relief of perpetual injunction in respect of the
disputed
property.
The
defence
of
defendant
No.1
was
substantially founded on the same unregistered Sale Deed dated
25.05.1996 and his claim of possession pursuant thereto.
13.
Defendant No.1 instituted O.S.No.85 of 2013 seeking
specific
performance
of
the
agreement
contained
in
the
unregistered Sale Deed dated 25.05.1996, along with the relief
of perpetual injunction.
14.
The
plaint
schedule
described
the
suit
lands
as
comprising Sy.Nos.337, 338/A, 340, 341 and 344, stated to be
an aggregate extent of Ac.9.02 Gts. The plaintiff's case was that
the total sale consideration was Rs.3,10,000/-, out of which
Rs.2,20,000/- had already been paid and the balance amount of
Rs.90,000/- remained payable at the time of registration. It was
further pleaded that possession had been delivered to him
pursuant to the transaction and that he had continued in
possession and enjoyment of the property.
15.
The plaintiff relied upon a legal notice dated 30.06.2009
issued through his General Power of Attorney (GPA) and the
reply dated 22.07.2009 disputing the alleged contract. He
asserted that he had always been ready and willing to perform
his part of the contract by paying the balance consideration of
Rs.90,000/- and sought specific performance of the agreement
together with an injunction.
16.
The record further shows that the suit was originally
instituted as O.S.No.71 of 2009 before the Senior Civil Judge,
Mahabubabad,
and
was
subsequently
transferred
and
renumbered as O.S.No.85 of 2013.
17.
Defendant No.1 also instituted a suit vide O.S.No.86 of
2013 seeking damages of Rs.80,000/- and a consequential
injunction, alleging that the defendants had caused damage to
his standing paddy crop in or about November 2010. The claim
was contested and the alleged damage was denied.
18.
Before the trial Court, the plaintiffs examined PW-1 and
PW-2 and got marked Exs.A1 to A43. However, on the other
hand the defendants neither examined anyone nor marked any
exhibits.
19.
Upon appreciation of the pleadings, oral and documentary
evidence, the trial Court heard all four suits together and
delivered a common judgment dated 28.10.2021.
20.
Insofar as O.S.No.85 of 2013 and O.S.No.86 of 2013 are
concerned, the trial Court observed that the plaintiff in both
suits was one and the same person. However, the plaintiff did
not appear before the Court to adduce evidence in support of
the plaint averments. The defendants specifically denied the
material allegations made in the respective plaints. The trial
Court noted that the material facts pleaded in the said suits,
including the alleged agreement of sale and the plaintiff's claim
of possession over the immovable property, were matters
required to be established through documentary and other
admissible evidence. The relevant documents were required to
be exhibited before the Court in accordance with the rules of
evidence. Since the plaintiff in the said Suits O.S.Nos.85 and 86
of 2013 failed to appear and no evidence was adduced or
documents exhibited on his behalf, the plaint averments
remained unsupported by evidence. The trial Court, therefore,
held that the plaintiff had failed to prove the material facts
pleaded in O.S.No.85 of 2013 and O.S.No.86 of 2013 and
accordingly dismissed both suits.
21.
Insofar as O.S.No.123 of 2012 and O.S.No.84 of 2012 are
concerned, the trial Court examined the title and possession
claimed by plaintiff No.1. It considered Ex.A.1, the original title
deed, as well as the revenue records produced by the plaintiffs.
The Court observed that, according to the plaintiffs' own case
and the material on record, plaintiff No.1 had acquired the suit
schedule properties through a joint family partition. However,
the Court further noted that plaintiff No.1 admittedly had a son
and, applying the prevailing rules of Hindu law held that the
son and daughters were also coparceners. Consequently, the
Court held that plaintiff No.1 could not, by himself, claim an
absolute right of ownership and possession over the entire suit
schedule properties. On that reasoning, the claim of plaintiff
No.2 to absolute ownership over the B-Schedule property on the
basis of the Gift Deed executed by plaintiff No.1 was also held to
be unsustainable.
22.
The trial Court also examined the revenue records
produced by the parties and noticed inconsistencies therein. It
observed that there were no pahani records showing the
plaintiffs in possession of certain lands covered by the relevant
survey numbers. While the name of plaintiff No.1 was shown as
pattadar in some survey numbers, the name of defendant No.1
appeared as possessor in respect of certain extents. The Court
held that the revenue entries in favour of defendant No.1 could
not simply be brushed aside, particularly in the absence of
satisfactory material explaining the presence of his name in the
revenue records or demonstrating that such entries were
unlawfully made. The Court further observed that a revenue
entry made by a public authority carries evidentiary significance
unless displaced by tangible material. It also reiterated the
principle that a person in peaceful possession may maintain an
injunction even against a true owner, leaving the alleged true
owner to seek recovery of possession on the basis of title. On
these grounds, the trial Court declined to grant the plaintiffs
protection of possession over the suit schedule properties.
23.
Accordingly, the trial Court answered the issues against
the respective plaintiffs and dismissed all four suits by a
common judgment dated 28.10.2021.
24.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree dated
28.10.2021, plaintiffs preferred A.S.No.157 of 2022, while
defendant No.1 preferred A.S.No.281 of 2022.
Submissions on behalf of the appellants in A.S.No.157 of
25.
The learned counsel for the appellants, assailing the
impugned
judgment
and
decree,
advanced
the
following
submissions:
i.
That the judgment and decree of the trial Court
dismissing the suit for declaration in respect of the A
and B schedule properties is contrary to the pleadings,
evidence and material on record and is therefore liable
to be set aside.
ii.
That the respondent No.1/defendant No.1 himself, in
his written statement, admitted that the suit schedule
properties
originally
belonged
to
the
appellant
No.1/plaintiff No.1 and did not dispute his title. In the
face of such admission, the trial Court ought not to
have denied the declaration sought by the appellants
by introducing, on its own, a question regarding the
nature of the property and the alleged rights of the son
of appellant No.1. No such claim was raised by any of
the parties, the son was not a party to the proceedings,
and no issue was framed in that regard. The finding of
the trial Court on that basis is, therefore, contrary to
the pleadings and the controversy between the parties.
iii. That the finding that the appellant No.1, having a son,
could not claim absolute rights over the properties and
consequently could not validly execute the Gift Deed in
favour of the appellant No.2, is contrary to the
pleadings and evidence on record.
iv. The trial Court also failed to properly appreciate the
registered Gift Deed in favour of the appellant No.2, the
title documents and the revenue records produced
before it. The findings relating to possession and the
interpretation placed upon the revenue entries are
contrary to the material on record and do not
satisfactorily dislodge the appellants’ claim of title and
possession.
v.
That though respondent No.1 had sought specific
performance against the appellant No.1 and damages
against the appellants in the connected proceedings,
he did not choose to adduce evidence in O.S.No.85 of
2013 and O.S.No.86 of 2013. The dismissal of those
suits for want of evidence could not, by itself, furnish a
basis for rejecting the appellants’ claim for declaration
and injunction in the present suit.
vi. It was further submitted that the trial Court travelled
beyond the pleadings and introduced the theory of
coparcenary, holding that plaintiff No.1 could not claim
absolute ownership merely because he had a living
son. No such plea was raised by any of the parties, the
son was not a party to the proceedings, and no issue
was framed in that regard. The finding that plaintiff
No.1 consequently lacked absolute rights over the
property and could not execute the Gift Deed in favour
of plaintiff No.2 was, therefore, contended to be
unsustainable.
vii. That the Gift Deed executed by appellant No.1/plaintiff
No.1 in favour of appellant No.2/plaintiff No.2 was a
registered document and that the trial Court failed to
appreciate the same in the proper perspective. It was
also contended that the trial Court failed to properly
appreciate Ex.A.1 and the revenue records while
recording its findings on possession. The appellants
submitted that the finding regarding their possession
was contrary to the material on record and that the
trial Court itself recognised the principle that a person
in peaceful possession is entitled to seek protection of
such possession even against a person claiming to be
the true owner.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant in A.S.No.281 of
26.
The learned counsel for the appellant, assailing the
impugned
judgment
and
decree,
advanced
the
following
submissions:
i.
That the trial Court committed an error in dismissing
O.S.No.85 of 2013, which was filed for specific
performance of the agreement of sale dated 25.05.1996
and for perpetual injunction, without affording the
appellant an effective opportunity to lead evidence. It
was submitted that the dismissal was principally on
the ground that the appellant did not appear to adduce
evidence and that his counsel reported no instructions,
though the circumstances preventing the appellant
from appearing were bona fide and beyond his control.
ii.
That the appellant was residing in the United States,
was about 79–80 years of age and was suffering from
serious
ailments,
including
chronic
lymphocytic
leukemia, prostate cancer and heart ailment, besides
having a pacemaker. During the COVID period and
thereafter, he was advised by his doctors not to travel.
Consequently, he could not come to India to give
evidence.
iii. That when the appellant visited India, he was informed
by his counsel that his personal presence was not
necessary.
The
appellant
came
to
know
of
the
dismissal only when he came to India on 12.02.2022.
His subsequent efforts to resolve the family disputes
through elders, including in the context of the
undertaking dated 17.04.2022, were also bona fide.
The delay in pursuing the appellate remedy was,
therefore, neither wilful nor deliberate.
iv. That the appellant had a specific case based on the
agreement of sale dated 25.05.1996, under which the
respondent agreed to execute a registered sale deed in
respect of the plaint schedule properties for a total
consideration of Rs.3,10,000/-, of which Rs.2,20,000/was paid, leaving a balance of Rs.90,000/-. The
agreement was reduced to writing on Rs.100/- nonjudicial stamp paper, scribed by Kattar Narender Rao
and attested by Smt. N. Vimala Devi. It was further
submitted
that
possession
of
the
suit
schedule
properties was delivered to the appellant pursuant to
the agreement and that, despite repeated requests, the
respondent postponed execution of the registered sale
deed on one pretext or another.
v.
That the appellant had documentary material in
support of his case, including the agreement dated
25.05.1996, proof relating to payment of Rs.2,20,000/material concerning delivery of possession, revenue
entries relied upon by him, the legal notice dated
30.06.2009 and the reply dated 22.07.2009. The
appellant had also taken steps for enforcement of his
rights after the respondent instituted O.S.No.40 of
2009, resulting in the filing of the suit which was
subsequently
transferred
O.S.No.85 of 2013.
and
renumbered
as
vi. That the dismissal of O.S.No.85 of 2013 without
permitting the appellant to place his evidence on
record has resulted in the appellant being deprived of
an adjudication of his claim on merits. In view of the
nature of the relief sought and the valuable property
rights involved, the appellant ought to be granted one
effective opportunity to adduce oral and documentary
evidence and establish his case in accordance with
law.
vii. That the evidence in O.S.No.85 of 2013 has a direct
bearing on the connected suit, particularly O.S.No.123
of 2012, as the
proceedings concern the
same
properties and arise out of the same transaction.
Therefore,
learned
counsel
submitted
that
the
judgment and decree in the connected suits may also
require reconsideration after the appellant is afforded
an opportunity to lead evidence in O.S.No.85 of 2013.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents in A.S.No.157 of
27.
The learned counsel for the respondents supporting the
impugned
judgment
submissions:
and
decree,
advanced
the
following
i.
That appellant/plaintiff No.1 could not claim absolute
title over the suit schedule properties, as the properties
formed part of the joint family property and his son
had a coparcenary interest therein. On that basis, it
was submitted that plaintiff No.1 could not validly gift
the B-schedule property in favour of plaintiff No.2.
ii.
That the Gift Deed was executed during the pendency
of O.S.No.40 of 2009 and was therefore hit by Section
52 of the Transfer of Property Act. The respondents
also relied upon the revenue records to contend that
defendant No.1 was shown to be in possession of
certain extents and submitted that the plaintiffs failed
to establish their lawful possession over the suit
schedule properties.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents in A.S.No.281 of
i.
With regard to O.S.No.85 of 2013, learned counsel
submitted that the suit was rightly dismissed as the
appellant failed to enter the witness box and adduce
evidence in support of his claim. It was contended that
the appellant had not satisfactorily explained his
absence
and
that
the
alleged
unregistered
sale
deed/agreement dated 25.05.1996 could not be relied
upon in the absence of proof. The respondents
disputed the genuineness and legal validity of the
document and contended that it was unregistered,
insufficiently stamped and did not contain specific
boundaries. It was also their case that the alleged
agreement was brought into existence by using blank
papers and that the appellant failed to establish
payment of consideration, possession, and readiness
and willingness to perform his part of the contract. The
respondents further contended that the suit for
specific performance was barred by limitation.
ii.
That no interference with the judgment and decree of
the trial Court was warranted. It was contended that
the scope of such remand, if any, ought to be confined
to the said suit and the findings already recorded in
O.S.No.123 of 2012 ought not to be disturbed and that
reopening the entire matter would cause serious
prejudice to the respondents.
28.
I have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
the material placed on record.
Consideration by this Court
29.
In the present case, the trial Court dismissed O.S.No.85 of
and
O.S.No.86
of
on
the
ground
that
the
appellant/plaintiff failed to appear and adduce evidence in
support of the plaint averments. The trial Court observed that,
in the absence of oral and documentary evidence, the material
allegations made in the plaint remained unsubstantiated.
30.
It is well settled that procedural default should not
ordinarily defeat substantive rights, unless the default is
deliberate or the party is guilty of contumacious conduct.
31.
It is pertinent to note that the appellant/plaintiff in
O.S.No.85 of 2013 was aged about 79–80 years, was residing in
the United States and was suffering from serious ailments. He
had engaged counsel to represent him before the trial Court,
which recorded that the counsel reported no instructions. The
appellant/plaintiff has stated that his counsel did not inform
him about the disposal of the case and that he came to know of
the dismissal only on 12.02.2022. He thereafter took steps to
pursue his remedies and also attempted to resolve the family
disputes amicably. These circumstances constitute sufficient
cause for his non-appearance.
32.
of
Further, the suit for specific performance of an agreement
sale
relates
to
valuable
agricultural
land.
In
the
circumstances of the present case, the interests of justice
warrant consideration of the appellant/plaintiff being afforded
one effective opportunity to adduce evidence, subject to
appropriate terms and to the respondents being given full
opportunity to cross-examine the appellant/plaintiff and adduce
rebuttal evidence. The trial Court can thereafter adjudicate the
respective
claims
on
merits.
Therefore,
the
dismissal
of
O.S.No.85 of 2013 and O.S.No.86 of 2013, insofar as the suits
were
dismissed
without
the
appellant/plaintiff
adducing
evidence in support of his claims, calls for interference.
33.
Further, O.S.No.123 of 2012 was filed seeking declaration
and injunction. O.S.No.85 of 2013 was filed seeking specific
performance of the unregistered sale deed/agreement dated
25.05.1996 and injunction. Both suits relate to the same
properties. The defence in O.S.No.123 of 2012 is that appellant
in A.S.No.281 of 2022 (Kattar Upender Rao) acquired the
properties under the unregistered sale deed/agreement dated
25.05.1996 and was put in possession thereof. The plaint in
O.S.No.85 of 2013 proceeds on the same transaction. Therefore,
the evidence to be adduced in O.S.No.85 of 2013 is directly
relevant to the adjudication of the issues arising in O.S.No.123
of 2012.
34.
While deciding O.S.No.123 of 2012, the trial Court
considered
the
revenue
records
and
recorded
that
appellant/defendant No.1 was shown as possessor of certain
extents. However, in O.S.No.85 of 2013, the appellant/plaintiff
was not afforded an opportunity to establish, by oral and
documentary
evidence,
the
agreement
dated
25.05.1996,
payment of Rs.2,20,000/-, delivery of possession, readiness and
willingness, and the revenue entries relied upon by him. The
trial
Court
also
recorded
findings
touching
upon
title,
coparcenary rights, the validity and effect of the Gift Deed and
the plea of lis pendens. Those findings were recorded without
the benefit of the evidence which the appellant/plaintiff in
O.S.No.85 of 2013 seeks to adduce in support of the transaction
forming the foundation of his claim.
35.
Without expressing any final opinion on the merits of the
respective claims, including the validity and legal effect of the
unregistered sale deed/agreement dated 25.05.1996, the plea of
readiness and willingness, the plea of limitation, the effect of the
Gift Deed, the plea of lis pendens under Section 52 and 53-A of
the Transfer of Property Act, or the questions relating to title
and possession and leaving all such questions open for
consideration by the trial Court on the basis of the complete
evidence that may be brought on record, the suits O.S.No.123 of
2012 and O.S.No.85 of 2013 are remanded to the trial Court.
36.
Since, O.S.No.84 of 2013 and O.S.No.86 of 2013 are also
connected suits arising out of the same common judgment, as
the immediate direction is to reconsider O.S.No.123 of 2012 and
O.S.No.85 of 2013, the trial Court may, if considered necessary
and convenient, restore the connected suits to its file and
dispose of all the connected suits together, so as to avoid any
possibility of conflicting findings. The parties shall be at liberty
to adduce such oral and documentary evidence in the respective
suits as may be permissible in accordance with law.
37.
I.A.No.1 of 2026 is filed by the appellant in A.S.No.281 of
2022 to receive the medical record dated 07.02.2026 issued by
the doctor.
Failure on the part of the appellant to adduce
evidence before the trial Court stated to be on account of the
fact that he was advised by the doctors not to undertake travel
during COVID.
Hence, this Court deems it appropriate to
receive the medical record submitted by the appellant for a fair
and proper adjudication of the appeal.
38.
Accordingly, I.A.No.1 of 2026 is allowed. The trial Court
shall take into consideration the aforesaid medical record
produced by the appellant.
Conclusion
39.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of considered view
that the appellant in A.S.No.281 of 2022 ought to be afforded an
effective opportunity to adduce oral and documentary evidence
in support of his claim in O.S.No.85 of 2013. And as such
evidence may have a direct bearing on the issues arising in
O.S.No.123 of 2012, which is the subject matter of A.S.No.157
of 2022 inasmuch as the connected suits were disposed of by a
common judgment and the findings therein are interrelated, the
said matters require reconsideration on the basis of the
complete evidence to be brought on record.
40.
Accordingly, A.S.No.157 of 2022 and A.S.No.281 of 2022
are disposed of. The common judgment and decree dated
28.10.2021 passed in O.S.No.123 of 2012 and O.S.Nos.84, 85
and 86 of 2013 is set aside. O.S.No.123 of 2012 and O.S.No.85
of 2013 are restored to the file of the learned VI Additional
District Judge, Mahabubabad, Warangal, for fresh disposal,
uninfluenced by the
findings recorded
in the
impugned
judgment. The trial Court shall afford the plaintiff in O.S.No.85
of 2013 a reasonable opportunity to adduce evidence, subject to
payment of costs of Rs.50,000/- to the defendant in the said
suit and shall afford the defendant an opportunity to crossexamine and adduce rebuttal evidence and mark documents in
accordance with law. The status quo directed by this Court vide
order dated 28.11.2022, as existing today in respect of the suit
schedule properties, shall continue until fresh disposal of the
suits by the trial Court.
In view of the advanced age of the
plaintiff, the trial Court is requested to proceed with the trial
expeditiously and endeavour to dispose of the suit as early as
possible.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending if any in
the appeal, shall stand closed. No costs.
_____________________
G.M.MOHIUDDIN, J
Date: 09.10.2026
ssp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review