Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010683032025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3327]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE 21st DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3655/2025
Between:
1. KATAMENNI VENKATESWARA RAO, S/O.SESHAGIRI RAO,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
R/O. RAYANAPADU VILLAGE,
VIJAYAWADA RURAL MANDAL, KRISHNA DISTRICT
...PETITIONER
AND
1. KATAMNENI SESHAGIRI RAO, (DIED)
2. KATAMNENI SIVA RAO, S/O. SESHAGIRI RAO, AGED ABOUT
63 YEARS,
R/O.D.NO.7-96/1, FLAT NO.SF-4,
SRI
VEERANJANEYA HEMALTHA TOWERS,
GRANDHALAYAM
STREET, GOLLAPUDI VILLAGE,
VIJAYAWADA RURAL
MANDAL.
3. SMT GARIKAPATI SIVA LAKSHMI, W/O.LATE MALLEWARA
RAO, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS, R/O. NEAR PANCHAYAT
WATER TANK, VELGAPUDI VILLAGE, THULLUR MANDAL,
GUNTUR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying
that in the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the
High Court may be pleased to set aside the order dated 27.10.2025
passed in I.A.No.309/2024 in O.S.No.1104/2020 on the file of III
Additional Civil Judge (Junior Division) At Vijayawada by allowing
the C.R.P. and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings in the
suit O.S.No.1104/2020 on the file of the III Additional Civil Judge
(Junior Division) at Vijayawada and pass
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. P PRABHAKAR RAO
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
2. SUNKARA RAJENDRA PRASAD
The Court made the following:
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
ORDER
Civil Revision Petition No.3655 of 2025 came to be
filed challenging the Order dated 27.10.2025 passed in I.A.No.309
of 2024 in O.S.No.1104 of 2020 by the learned III Additional Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Vijayawada (for brevity „the trial Court‟),
whereunder and whereby, application filed under Order VI Rule 17
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity „CPC‟) by the
petitioner herein/plaintiff to amend the plaint, was dismissed.
2.
Petitioner herein is the plaintiff and the respondents
herein are the defendants, in O.S.No.1104 of 2020, pending on the
file of the trial Court. Parties hereinafter are referred to, as they
were arrayed in the suit proceedings.
3.
It is the case of the plaintiff that the plaintiff and the
defendant Nos.2 and 3 are sons of deceased 1st defendant, who
died on 18.07.2022 during the pendency of suit proceedings; that
under a Partition List dated 30.11.1989, the family properties, which
include schedule property admeasuring to an extent of Ac.0.93
cents in R.S.No.58/3 of Rayanapadu Village, were allotted to
deceased 1st defendant, subject to a condition that the property
shall devolve upon the plaintiff and 2nd defendant in equal shares
after the demise of their parents; that the plaintiff filed the suit
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
seeking a Declaration that the Registered Gift Deed dated
17.10.2020, executed by his father in favour of 2nd defendant, as
null and void and not binding on him, with consequential relief of
Permanent Injunction restraining 2nd defendant from alienating the
schedule property.
4.
While the suit was at the stage of framing issues, 1st
defendant died, and to claim that the schedule property is liable to
be divided equally between the plaintiff and 2nd defendant, in terms
of Partition List, dated 30.11.1989, the plaintiff filed the subject
application vide I.A.No.309 of 2024 under Order VI Rule 17 and
Section 151 of CPC seeking to amend the plaint to incorporate the
subsequent event and the relief of Partition, including allotment of
his share by metes and bounds. Defendants filed counter in the
subject application contending that the proposed amendments are
not permissible and the relief of Partition of schedule property into
two equal shares and to allot one such share to the plaintiff, is also
not maintainable. It was further contended that the deceased 1st
defendant himself executed a Gift Deed and gifted the property,
and as on the date of death of 1st defendant, there is no estate to
be partitioned among the plaintiff and 2nd defendant, and as the
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
deceased 1st defendant himself is not having any estate, question
of partition does not arise.
5.
The trial Court vide impugned Order dated 27.10.2025
dismissed the subject application observing as under:
“8. This Court perused the contents of the petition as
well as counter and also the docket order, this suit is coming
for framing of issues, at this stage, this petition is filed by the
petitioner/plaintiff to add the relief of partition of plaint
schedule property between the petitioner/plaintiff and 2nd
respondent/2nd defendant into two equal shares. As rightly
contended by the respondent/defendant, the plaintiff filed this
suit for declaration declaring that the registered gift deed said
to have been executed by 1st respondent/1st defendant in
favour of 2nd respondent/2nd defendant on 17.10.2020 vide
document No.5939/2020 of Sub Registrar Office, Gunadala is
null and void and for consequential permanent injunction
restraining the 2nd respondent/2nd defendant not to alienate the
property in any manner to the third parties and during the
pending of the suit, his father died intestate and as per the
recitals of the partition list Dt: 30.11.1989 the plaint schedule
property shall be partitioned to him and 2nd respondent/2nd
defendant into two equal shares, but as per the contention of
the 2nd respondent/2nd defendant, the 1st respondent/1st
defendant/his father executed gift deed in his favour on
17.10.2020 vide document No.5939/2020 of Joint Sub
Registrar, Gunadala, as such, 1st defendant himself executed
the
gift
deed
and
as
rightly
contended
by
the
respondent/defendant that if this petition is allowed, the entire
case and nature of the suit will be changed and the 2nd
respondent/2nd defendant strongly denied the contention of the
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
plaintiff. As such, if this petition is allowed, the entire case and
nature of the suit is changed.”
Aggrieved by the impugned Order, the petitioner herein/
plaintiff preferred the present Revision Petition.
6.
Sri P.Prabhakara Rao, learned counsel for the
petitioner herein/plaintiff submits that the trial Court failed to
appreciate the nature and purpose of the proposed amendment.
The
petitioner
herein/plaintiff
originally
instituted
the
suit
challenging the Gift Deed executed by his father i.e. 1st defendant,
in favour of 2nd defendant, but during the pendency of the suit, his
father
died,
making
the
petitioner
herein/plaintiff
to
seek
consequential relief of Partition in terms of Partition List dated
30.11.1989. Learned counsel further contends that the proposed
amendment is intended to bring subsequent event on record and to
avoid multiplicity of proceedings. He further contends that the
proposed relief of Partition is connected with the existing relief of
Declaration and it is necessary for complete adjudication of the
dispute between the parties. He submits that the rival claims
regarding the effect of the gift deed and the rights of the parties can
be decided after the parties are given an opportunity to lead
evidence.
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
7.
Per contra, Sri Sunkara Rajendra Prasad, learned
counsel for the respondents herein/defendants would contend that
the suit was instituted seeking to declare the Registered Gift Deed
as null and void and for consequential relief of Permanent
Injunction,
but
the
proposed
amendment
seeking
Partition
introduces a new and inconsistent claim and changes the entire
nature of the suit. Learned counsel further contends that the
deceased 1st defendant executed a Registered Gift Deed in favour
of 2nd defendant and, therefore, no property remained available for
Partition upon his death. He further contends that the relief of
Partition is not maintainable and that the petitioner herein/plaintiff
failed to establish sufficient grounds for amending the plaint.
Hence, it is prayed to dismiss the Civil Revision Petition.
8.
Now the point that arise for consideration is, whether
the Order dated 27.10.2025 passed in I.A.No.309 of 2024 in
O.S.No.1104 of 2020 by the learned III Additional Civil Judge
(Junior Division), Vijayawada, dismissing the application for
amendment of the plaint, suffers from any error warranting
interference by this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India?
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
9.
It is to be borne in mind that the main purpose of
permitting an amendment of pleadings is to enable the Court to
decide the real dispute between the parties and, as far as possible,
avoid unnecessary separate proceedings. At the same time, an
amendment should not be permitted if it introduces entirely a new
cause of action and inconsistent case or causes injustice to the
opposite party. In the present case, there is no dispute with regard
to the relationship between the parties. A perusal of the contents of
plaint goes to show that the suit is filed challenging the validity of
the Registered Gift Deed dated 17.10.2020 alleged to have been
executed by the deceased 1st defendant i.e. father of both parties,
in favour of 2nd defendant. The petitioner herein/plaintiff solely
relied upon the Partition List dated 30.11.1989 and contends that
the schedule property was allotted to his father subject to condition
that it shall devolve upon the petitioner herein/plaintiff and 2nd
defendant equally after the lifetime of their parents.
10.
A perusal of the material on record coupled with the
recitals in the subject application goes to show that the proposed
amendment is based on subsequent death of the deceased 1st
defendant i.e. father of petitioner herein/plaintiff and 2nd defendant,
during pendency of suit proceedings, and by seeking the relief of
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
Partition, the petitioner herein/plaintiff intends to claim his right over
the very same property determined in the pending proceedings.
Therefore, the proposed amendment cannot, at this stage, be
treated as introducing wholly a new cause of action. The original
relief and the proposed relief relate to the same property and arise
from the parties‟ competing claims regarding their respective right
over that property.
11.
A perusal of the impugned Order goes to show that the
trial Court dismissed the subject application on the ground that the
proposed amendment would change the nature of the suit, relying
upon the decision in P. Mukunda Rao v. Eluru Town Automobile
Mechanical Association1. However, in the aforesaid proposition it
was held that the principle that an amendment should not alter the
basic structure of a suit has to be applied having regard to the facts
and circumstances of each case, and it does not mean that every
additional relief arising out of the same property and the
subsequent events during the pendency of the suit must be
refused. But, in the case on hand, the petitioner herein/plaintiff
seeks to bring on record a subsequent event and an additional
relief relating to the very same schedule property, and such
2022 (4) ALT 554 (AP).
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
proposed amendment would enable the trial Court to examine the
claims of the parties in one proceeding.
12.
The objection of the respondents/defendants that the
Gift Deed was validly executed and that no property remains
available for Partition, is a matter of defence that has to be
adjudicated by adducing proper evidence during trial. Whether the
Gift Deed is valid, whether the petitioner herein/plaintiff is entitled to
a share in terms of the Partition List, and whether the property is
available for Partition, are the matters that have to be decided
basing on the evidence led by both parties, and those questions
cannot be conclusively decided while considering the application
for amendment alone.
13.
Under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC, the Court may at any
stage of the proceedings, allow either party to alter or amend his
pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may be just, and
all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary for the
purpose of determining the real questions in controversies between
the parties. Proviso to the said Rule stipulates that no application
for amendment shall be allowed after trial has commenced, unless
the Court comes to conclusion that in spite of due diligence, the
party could not have raised the matter before the commencement
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
of trial. In the case on hand, trial has not commenced in the suit,
and it is at the stage of, framing of issues, and the proposed
application was filed at that stage. As held supra, the proposed
amendment is necessary for the purpose of determining the real
questions in controversy between the parties in respect of the
subject property, and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. In these
circumstances, permitting the proposed amendment would enable
the trial Court to frame necessary issues and adjudicate the real
controversy between the parties. Furthermore, the respondents
herein/defendants can as well file additional written statement, if
necessary, and contest the amended pleadings. In view of the
aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion that
the trial Court adopted a restrictive approach in dismissing the
application, and the proposed amendment is necessary for
effective and complete adjudication of the dispute regard the
schedule property. The impugned Order warrants interference of
this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
14.
Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed. The
Order dated 27.10.2025 passed in I.A.No.309 of 2024 in
O.S.No.1104 of 2020 by the learned III Additional Civil Judge
SRK, J
CRP No.3655 of 2025
(Junior
Division),
Vijayawada,
is
set-aside.
Consequently,
I.A.No.309 of 2024 stands allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs of the Revision
Petition.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if
any, shall also stand closed.
JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
21st September, 2026.
DNB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review